Expanding the scope of RNA catalysis

The basic notions of transition state theory have been exploited in the past to generate highly selective catalysts from the vast library of antibody molecules in the immune system. These same ideas were used to isolate an RNA molecule, from a large library of RNAs, that catalyzes the isomerization of a bridged biphenyl. The RNA-catalyzed reaction displays Michaelis-Menten kinetics with a catalytic rate constant (kcat) of 2.8 x 10(-5) per minute and a Michaelis constant (Km) of 542 microM; the reaction is competitively inhibited by the planar transition state analog with an inhibition constant (Ki) value of approximately 7 microM. This approach may provide a general strategy for expanding the scope of RNA catalysis beyond those reactions in which the substrates are nucleic acids or nucleic acid derivatives.

Antibody catalysis of peptide bond formation

An antibody generated against a neutral phosphonate diester transition-state (TS not equal to) analog catalyzes the formation of an amide bond between a phenylalanyl amino group and an acyl azide derived from L-alanine. The antibody is selective for L- vs. D-alanine and does not catalyze the hydrolysis of the acyl azide to an appreciable degree. A rate acceleration of 10,000-fold relative to the uncatalyzed reaction is observed. The antibody may achieve its catalytic efficiency both by acting as an entropy trap and by stabilizing the deprotonated form of the amine nucleophile. These experiments constitute a first step toward a general strategy for the generation of sequence-specific peptide ligases.

A permutational approach toward protein-DNA recognition

The cI repressor of bacteriophage 434, known as 434 repressor, binds to 14-bp operator sequences by means of a helix-turn-helix motif. To probe the requirements for selective DNA recognition by this class of DNA binding proteins, as well as to generate new proteins with altered specificities, a library of approximately 3 x 10(6) mutants was generated that contains all permutations of five residues in the recognition helix (helix 3) of the repressor. These mutants were then selected in vivo for their ability to bind both wild-type (WT) and mutant operator sequences. The results of the selection demonstrate that four of these residues--Gln28, Gln29, Ser30, and Gln33--play a critical role in recognition of the WT operator. A number of repressors with mutations at Thr27 showed altered DNA binding affinities and specificities. The approach described here may also prove useful in studies of DNA recognition by other classes of DNA binding proteins.

Site-specific incorporation of biophysical probes into proteins

Biophysical probes which can detect structural changes in proteins and the interaction of proteins with other macromolecules are important tools in studying protein function. Many difficulties remain, however, in introducing probes into proteins site-specifically. Here we report the successful site-specific incorporation of a spin-labeled, a fluorescent, and a photoactivatible amino acid into a variety of surface and internal sites in bacteriophage T4 lysozyme by using unnatural amino acid mutagenesis. In addition, we report the purification and spectral characterization of T4 lysozyme mutants containing the spin-labeled amino acid and the fluorescent amino acid. The ability to incorporate these probes site-specifically allows for novel studies of protein structure and dynamics. Moreover, this work demonstrates that the Escherichia coli protein biosynthetic machinery can tolerate unnatural amino acids with little resemblance to the natural amino acids.

Isoabzymes: structurally and mechanistically similar catalytic antibodies from the same immunization

Mechanistic and structural comparisons of five catalytic monoclonal antibodies generated from the same hybridoma fusion indicated that all five hydrolyze phenyl acetate by subtle variations of the same mechanism. All of the antibodies showed a pre-steady-state multi-turnover burst in which kcat and Km declined but kcat/Km did not change. The burst of one of the antibodies, 20G9, has previously been found to result from inhibition by the product, phenol. Although all of the antibodies showed the burst, their individual values for kcat, Km, and hapten Ki differed substantially. Three of the antibodies that were investigated for the effect of pH on kcat showed an acid limb pK of 9.5-9.6. Substrate inhibition was seen in four of the five antibodies. Variable region nucleotide sequencing of the heavy and light chains confirmed that all five antibodies were structurally similar and also revealed several potentially critical tyrosines. Despite their structural similarities, analysis of their sequences suggested that the antibodies are products of distinct, independent rearrangements of immunoglobulin gene segments that took place in different progenitor B cells. A plot of Ki for hapten inhibition vs Km/kcat for substrate hydrolysis for the mechanistically related antibodies ("isoabzymes") gave a linear relationship suggesting a catalytic role for transition-state complementarity. Taken together with previous work [Martin et al. (1991) Biochemistry 30, 9757-9761], the data conform to a mechanism in which the antibodies exploit both transition-state complementarity and an acyl-tyrosyl intermediate during phenyl acetate hydrolysis.

Probing the role of loop 2 in Ras function with unnatural amino acids

The YDPT sequence motif (residues 32-35) in loop 2 (residues 32-40) of Ha-Ras p21 protein is conserved in the Ras protein family. X-ray crystal structures have revealed significant conformational differences in this region between the GTP- and GDP-bound forms. Moreover, mutations in this region block neoplastic transformation and prevent interaction with GTPase-activating protein (GAP), suggesting that this region may contribute to the effector function of Ras. To better understand the structural features required for GAP interaction and GTPase activity, the expanded repertoire of unnatural amino acid mutagenesis has been used to investigate the roles of the key residues, Pro-34, Thr-35, and Ile-36. A Pro-34-->methanoproline mutant, in which residue 34 is locked in the trans conformation, was found to retain high levels of intrinsic and GAP-activated GTPase activity, making unlikely conformational isomerization at this position. Deletion of a single methyl group from Ile (Ile-36-->norvaline) abolished GAP activation of Ras, revealing a remarkable specificity in this protein-protein interaction. Finally, replacement of Thr-35 with diastereomeric allo-threonine led to inactivation of Ras, demonstrating the importance of the orientation of this critical residue in Ras function.

Probing the mechanism of staphylococcal nuclease with unnatural amino acids: kinetic and structural studies

Staphylococcal nuclease is an enzyme with enormous catalytic power, accelerating phosphodiester bond hydrolysis by a factor of 10(16) over the spontaneous rate. The mechanistic basis for this rate acceleration was investigated by substitution of the active site residues Glu43, Arg35, and Arg87 with unnatural amino acid analogs. Two Glu43 mutants, one containing the nitro analog of glutamate and the other containing homoglutamate, retained high catalytic activity at pH 9.9, but were less active than the wild-type enzyme at lower pH values. The x-ray crystal structure of the homoglutamate mutant revealed that the carboxylate side chain of this residue occupies a position and orientation similar to that of Glu43 in the wild-type enzyme. The increase in steric bulk is accommodated by a backbone shift and altered torsion angles. The nitro and the homoglutamate mutants display similar pH versus rate profiles, which differ from that of the wild-type enzyme. Taken together, these studies suggest that Glu43 may not act as a general base, as previously thought, but may play a more complex structural role during catalysis.

An unnatural biopolymer

A highly efficient method has been developed for the solid-phase synthesis of an "unnatural biopolymer" consisting of chiral aminocarbonate monomers linked via a carbamate backbone. Oligocarbamates were synthesized from N-protected p-nitrophenyl carbonate monomers, substituted with a variety of side chains, with greater than 99 percent overall coupling efficiencies per step. A spatially defined library of oligocarbamates was generated by using photochemical methods and screened for binding affinity to a monoclonal antibody. A number of high-affinity ligands were then synthesized and analyzed in solution with respect to their inhibition concentration values, water/octanol partitioning coefficients, and proteolytic stability. These and other unnatural polymers may provide new frameworks for drug development and for testing theories of protein and peptide folding and structure.

Controlling chemical reactivity with antibodies

The remarkable specificity of an antibody molecule has been used to accomplish highly selective functional group transformations not attainable by current chemical methods. An antibody raised against an amine-oxide hapten catalyzes the reduction of a diketone to a hydroxyketone with greater than 75:1 regioselectivity for one of two nearly equivalent ketone moieties. The antibody-catalyzed reaction is highly stereoselective, affording the hydroxyketone in high enantiomeric excess. Similarly, the reduction of ketones containing branched and aryl substituents, including the highly symmetrical 1-nitrophenyl-3-phenyl-2-propanone, was enantioselective. The simple strategy presented herein may find general applicability to the regio- and stereoselective reduction of a broad range of compounds.

A genetic approach to the generation of antibodies with enhanced catalytic activities

A hydrolytic catalytic antibody, generated against a nitrophenyl phosphonate transition state analogue, has been cloned and expressed in Escherichia coli for use as a model system to demonstrate the feasibility of using genetic selections to enhance catalytic activity. Conditions were found that permit the secretion of active recombinant antibody into the periplasm of a strain of E. coli deficient in the biotin biosynthetic genes (delta bio-gal). A number of substrates were synthesized that, upon hydrolysis by the antibody, yield free biotin, which is required for cell growth. The substrates and selections can be used to identify mutants of the antibody with altered activities. This approach should be generalizable to a wide number of hydrolytic reactions including the selective cleavage of peptide, polysaccharide, phosphodiester, and ester bonds.

Probing the structure and mechanism of Ras protein with an expanded genetic code

Mutations in Ras protein at positions Gly12 and Gly13 (phosphate-binding loop L1) and at positions Ala59, Gly60, and Gln61 (loop L4) are commonly associated with oncogenic activation. The structural and catalytic roles of these residues were probed with a series of unnatural amino acids that have unusual main chain conformations, hydrogen bonding abilities, and steric features. The properties of wild-type and transforming Ras proteins previously thought to be uniquely associated with the structure of a single amino acid at these positions were retained by mutants that contained a variety of unnatural amino acids. This expanded set of functional mutants provides new insight into the role of loop L4 residues in switch function and suggests that loop L1 may participate in the activation of Ras protein by effector molecules.

Probing protein stability with unnatural amino acids

Unnatural amino acid mutagenesis, in combination with molecular modeling and simulation techniques, was used to probe the effect of side chain structure on protein stability. Specific replacements at position 133 in T4 lysozyme included (i) leucine (wt), norvaline, ethylglycine, and alanine to measure the cost of stepwise removal of methyl groups from the hydrophobic core, (ii) norvaline and O-methyl serine to evaluate the effects of side chain solvation, and (iii) leucine, S,S-2-amino-4-methylhexanoic acid, and S-2-amino-3-cyclopentylpropanoic acid to measure the influence of packing density and side chain conformational entropy on protein stability. All of these factors (hydrophobicity, packing, conformational entropy, and cavity formation) significantly influence protein stability and must be considered when analyzing any structural change to proteins.

Peptide ligands for a sugar-binding protein isolated from a random peptide library

Peptide ligands for the carbohydrate-binding protein concanavalin A (Con A) have been identified by screening a large, diverse peptide library expressed on the surface of filamentous phage. A dodecapeptide containing the consensus sequence Tyr-Pro-Tyr was found to bind Con A with an affinity (dissociation constant, Kd) of 46 microM, comparable to that of a known carbohydrate ligand, methyl alpha-D-mannopyranoside (Kd of 89 microM). In addition the peptide inhibited precipitation of the alpha-glucan dextran 1355 by Con A. Given the complexity of oligosaccharide synthesis, the prospect of finding peptides that competitively inhibit carbohydrate-specific receptors may simplify the development of new therapeutic agents.

An efficient antibody-catalyzed aminoacylation reaction

An antibody generated against a neutral phosphonate diester transition-state analog was found to catalyze the aminoacylation of the 3'-hydroxyl group of thymidine with an alanyl ester. A comparison of the apparent second-order rate constant of the antibody-catalyzed reaction [5.4 x 10(4) molar-1 minute-1 (M-1 min-1)] with that of the uncatalyzed reaction (2.6 x 10(-4) M-1 min-1) revealed this to be a remarkably efficient catalyst. Moreover, although the concentration of water (55 M) greatly exceeds that of the secondary alcohol, the antibody selectively catalyzes acyl transfer to thymidine. The antibody exhibits sequential binding, with Michaelis constants of 770 microM and 260 microM for acyl acceptor and donor, respectively, and a dissociation constant of 240 pM for hapten. This antibody-catalyzed reaction provides increased insight into the requirements for efficient aminoacylation catalysts and may represent a first step toward the generation of "aminoacyl transfer RNA synthetases" with novel specificities.

Site-specific incorporation of novel backbone structures into proteins

A number of unnatural amino acids and amino acid analogs with modified backbone structures were substituted for alanine-82 in T4 lysozyme. Replacements included alpha,alpha-disubstituted amino acids, N-alkyl amino acids, and lactic acid, an isoelectronic analog of alanine. The effects of these electronic and structural perturbations on the stability of T4 lysozyme were determined. The relatively broad substrate specificity of the Escherichia coli protein biosynthetic machinery suggests that a wide range of backbone and side-chain substitutions can be introduced, allowing a more precise definition of the factors affecting protein stability.

Mechanistic studies of a tyrosine-dependent catalytic antibody

A pre-steady-state multiple-turnover kinetic burst is observed during hydrolysis of phenyl acetate by the catalytic antibody, 20G9. The burst is caused by partial product inhibition by phenol (Ki,app = 2.5 microM), which lowers both kcat and KM by almost an order of magnitude without affecting kcat/KM. The acid limb of the steady-state kcat pH profile of native 20G9 has a pKa of 9.6, suggesting a catalytic role for tyrosine. Additional evidence for an essential tyrosyl residue is that mild treatment of 20G9 with tetranitromethane nitrates a single tyrosine per equivalent of antigen binding sites and the mononitrated derivative has less than 5% of the native activity. Near-UV absorbance spectroscopy suggests that the alternative substrates N-carbobenzoxyglycine O-phenyl ester (ZG-OPh) and N-acetylglycine O-phenyl ester (AcG-OPh) acylate multiple tyrosines on the antibody. Neither ZG-OPh nor AcG-OPh are measurably catalyzed once appreciable acylation has taken place. Antibody acylated by ZG-OPh is inactive toward phenyl acetate hydrolysis, but can be reactivated by hydroxylamine. The data and derived kinetic rate equations are consistent with an acyl mechanism for phenyl acetate hydrolysis in which phenol inhibits by binding to a covalent O-acetyltyrosyl intermediate, slowing deacylation. Although the data are consistent with such a mechanism, they do not rule out other plausible, yet less unifying mechanisms of phenol inhibition; the observed burst could conceivably result from partial mixed phenol inhibition or from phenol-induced nonproductive substrate binding. Because antibodies often use tyrosines in antigen binding, tyrosyl catalytic antibodies may be commonly encountered in the future.

A combinatorial approach toward DNA recognition

A combinatorial approach has been used to identify individual RNA molecules from a large population of sequences that bind a 16-base pair homopurine-homopyrimidine DNA sequence through triple-helix formation. Fourteen of the seventeen clones selected contained stretches of pyrimidines highly homologous to the target DNA sequence (T.AT and C+.GC). In addition, these RNA molecules contained hairpin loops, interior loops, and nonstandard base triplets [C+(or C).AT, U.GC, G.GC, and A.AT] at various positions. Affinity cleavage experiments confirmed the ability of selected sequences to bind specifically to the target DNA. Systematic variation in both the target DNA sequence and buffer components should provide increased insight into the molecular interactions required for triple-helix-mediated recognition of natural DNA.

Recent advances in catalytic antibodies

Recently the biological machinery of the immune system has been exploited with the aid of mechanistic chemistry to produce catalytic antibodies. Because antibodies can be generated that selectively bind almost any molecule of interest, this new technology offers the potential to tailor-make highly selective catalysts for applications in biology, chemistry and medicine. In addition, catalytic antibodies provide fundamental insight into important aspects of biological catalysis, including the importance of transition-state stabilization, proximity effects, general acid and base catalysts, electrophilic and nucleophilic catalysis, and strain.