Creatine for treating muscle disorders

BACKGROUND

Progressive muscle weakness is a main symptom of most hereditary muscle diseases. Creatine is a popular nutritional supplement among athletes. It improves muscle performance in healthy individuals and might be helpful for treating myopathies.

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the efficacy of oral creatine supplementation in muscle diseases.

SEARCH STRATEGY

We searched the Cochrane Neuromuscular Disease Group Register in May 2004 for randomised trials using the search term 'creatine'. We also searched the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (The Cochrane Library, Issue 2, 2005) using the same search term. We adapted this strategy to search MEDLINE (PubMed, from January 1966 to September 2005) and EMBASE (from January 1980 to May 2004). We reviewed the bibliographies of the randomised trials identified, contacted the authors and known experts in the field and approached pharmaceutical companies to identify additional published or unpublished data.

SELECTION CRITERIA

Types of studies: randomised or quasi-randomised controlled trials.

TYPES OF PARTICIPANTS

people of all ages with hereditary muscle disease. Types of intervention: any creatine supplementation of at least 0.03 g/kg body weight/day.

PRIMARY OUTCOME MEASURE

change in muscle strength measured by quantitative muscle testing.

SECONDARY OUTCOME MEASURES

change in muscle strength measured by manual muscle testing, change in energy parameters assessed by 31 phosphorous spectroscopy, change in muscle mass or a surrogate for muscle mass, adverse events.

DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS

Two authors independently applied the selection criteria, assessed trial quality and extracted data. Some missing data were obtained from investigators.

MAIN RESULTS

Twelve trials, including 266 participants, met the selection criteria. One trial compared creatine and glutamine treatment with placebo. In trials with 138 participants with muscular dystrophies treated with creatine, there was a significant increase in maximum voluntary contraction in the creatine group compared to placebo, with a weighted mean difference of 8.47% (95% confidence intervals 3.55 to 13.38). There was also an increase in lean body mass during creatine treatment compared to placebo (weighted mean difference 0.63 kg, 95% confidence intervals 0.02 to 1.25). No trial reported any clinically relevant adverse event. In trials with 33 participants with metabolic myopathies treated with creatine, there was no significant difference in maximum voluntary contraction between the creatine and placebo group (weighted mean difference -2.26%, confidence intervals -6.29 to 1.78). One trial reported a significant increase in muscle pain during high-dose creatine treatment (150 mg/kg body weight) in glycogen storage disease type V.

AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS

Evidence from randomised controlled trials shows that short- and medium-term creatine treatment improves muscle strength in people with muscular dystrophies, and is well-tolerated. Evidence from randomised controlled trials does not show significant improvement in muscle strength in metabolic myopathies. High-dose creatine in glycogenosis type V increased muscle pain.

Regular insulin secretory oscillations despite impaired ATP synthesis in Friedreich Ataxia patients

Friedreich Ataxia is an inherited disorder caused by decreased expression of a mitochondrial protein called frataxin. Deficiency of this protein causes reduced biogenesis of iron-sulfur clusters, and subsequently impaired synthesis and replenishment of ATP IN VIVO. Basal secretion of insulin occurs in an oscillating manner presumably triggered by ATP-dependent feedback inhibition of glycolytic flux. Hence, individuals with reduced ATP synthesis rates should possibly exhibit impaired insulin secretory oscillations if these were solely dependent on ATP. In the present study Friedreich Ataxia patients with a presumptive impairment of ATP synthesis in pancreatic beta-cells were evaluated for regularity of basal secretory oscillations of insulin. Healthy siblings were employed as controls. In conflict with the initial hypothesis, no differences in regards to oscillation patterns were observed between patients and controls. Supported by EX VIVO evidence, these findings tentatively suggest that pulsatile insulin secretion might not be exclusively dependent on ATP feedback inhibition in humans.

Facing the genetic heterogeneity in neuromuscular disorders: Linkage analysis as an economic diagnostic approach towards the molecular diagnosis

The identification of an ever increasing number of gene defects in patients with neuromuscular disorders has disclosed both marked phenotype and genotype variability and considerable disease overlap. In order to offer an economic strategy to characterise the molecular defect in patients with unclassified neuromuscular disorders, we designed DNA marker sets for linkage analysis of 62 distinct neuromuscular disorders gene loci, including all known muscular dystrophies, congenital myopathies, congenital myasthenic syndromes and myotonias. Genotyping of marker loci of 140 clinically well-characterised families with unclassified neuromuscular disorders reduced the number of candidates to one or two genes in 49 % of the families. Subsequent mutation analysis and genome-wide scans enabled the determination of the genetic defect in 31 % of the families including the identification of a new gene and a new mutation in an unexpected candidate gene. This highlights the effective application of this approach both for diagnostic strategies as well as for the identification of new loci and genes.

Creatine has no beneficial effect on skeletal muscle energy metabolism in patients with single mitochondrial DNA deletions: a placebo-controlled, double-blind 31P-MRS crossover study

The purpose of our randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled crossover study in 15 patients with chronic progressive external ophthalmoplegia (CPEO) or Kearns-Sayre syndrome (KSS) because of single large-scale mitochondrial (mt) DNA deletions was to determine whether oral creatine (Cr) monohydrate can improve skeletal muscle energy metabolism in vivo. Each treatment phase with Cr in a dosage of 150 mg/kg body weight/day or placebo lasted 6 weeks. The effect of Cr was estimated by phosphorus-31 magnetic resonance spectroscopy ((31)P-MRS), clinical and laboratory tests. (31)P-MRS analysis prior to treatment showed clear evidence of severe mitochondrial dysfunction. However, there were no relevant changes in (31)P-MRS parameters under Cr. In particular, phosphocreatine (PCr)/ATP at rest did not increase, and there was no facilitation of post-exercise PCr recovery. Clinical scores and laboratory tests did not alter significantly under Cr, which was tolerated without major side-effects in all patients. Cr supplementation did not improve skeletal muscle oxidative phosphorylation in our series of patients. However, one explanation for our negative findings may be the short study duration or the limited number of patients included.

Immune-mediated rippling muscle disease

The authors report a 44-year-old man with rippling muscle disease (RMD) who does not have a mutation in the caveolin-3 gene. Immunohistochemistry of the muscle biopsy revealed a marked reduction of caveolin-3 and a mosaic pattern of dysferlin immunostaining. Ultrastructural studies showed a loss of caveolae and alterations of the triad. Autoantibodies were directed against the sarcolemma, triad, and several unknown muscle proteins.

L-carnitine and creatine in Friedreich's ataxia. A randomized, placebo-controlled crossover trial

Impaired oxidative phosphorylation is a crucial factor in the pathogenesis of Friedreich's ataxia (FA). L-carnitine and creatine are natural compounds that can enhance cellular energy transduction. We performed a placebo-controlled triple-phase crossover trial of L-carnitine (3 g/d) and creatine (6.75 g/d) in 16 patients with genetically confirmed FA. Primary outcome measures were mitochondrial ATP production measured as phosphocreatine recovery by 31Phosphorus magnetic resonance spectroscopy, neurological deficits assessed by the international co-operative ataxia rating scale and cardiac hypertrophy in echocardiography. After 4 months on L-carnitine phosphocreatine recovery was improved compared to baseline (p<0.03, t-test) but comparison to placebo and creatine effects did not reach significance (p=0.06, F-test). Ataxia rating scale and echocardiographic parameters remained unchanged. Creatine had no effect in FA patients. L-carnitine is a promising substance for the treatment of FA patients, and larger trials are warranted.

Adult polyglucosan body disease: a postmortem correlation study

Autopsy of a 50-year-old woman with adult polyglucosan body disease and missense mutations (Arg515His, Arg524Gln) in the glycogen branching enzyme gene (GBE) revealed accumulation of polyglucosan bodies in the heart, brain, and nerve. GBE activity was decreased in the morphologically affected tissues but was normal in unaffected tissues. GBE mRNA transcripts were similar in all tissues and in controls, which confirms the lack of tissue-specific GBE isoforms.

[Fatal cardiomyopathy in adult in polyglucosan body disease]

Adult polyglucosan body disease (APBD) is a rare genetic disorder, inherited in an autosomal recessive mode. The disease is caused by mutations of the gene coding for the glycogen-branching enzyme, which is essential for branching of polyglucose chains in the normal glycogen molecule. The age of clinical manifestation of the disease mostly is between 40 and 60 years and its course is slowly progressive. Characteristic globular deposits (polyglucosan bodies, PGB) can be detected in biopsies of skin and skeletal muscle as well as in the peripheral and central nervous system. Biochemically, PGBs consist of poorly branched glycogen molecules with abnormally long polysaccharide chains. We report the case of a 50-year-old female patient with APBD who suffered from neurological symptoms such as spastic tetraparesis, urinary incontinence, hypesthesia and dementia. She died unexpectedly of cardiac failure. At autopsy a severe cardiomyopathy with abundant PGBs in the heart muscle fibres could be proven as the cause of death. This observation shows that in addition to the known deposition of PGBs in nervous system and skeletal muscle, an involvement of the heart has to be considered in APBD as well.

A sporadic case of rippling muscle disease caused by a de novo caveolin-3 mutation

OBJECTIVE

To determine the cause of sporadic rippling muscle disease (RMD) in a 24-year-old patient.

BACKGROUND

RMD is a rare myopathy characterized by percussion-induced rapid muscle contractions (PIRC), muscle mounding, and rippling waves. We have recently found that autosomal dominant RMD is caused by mutations in the caveolin-3 gene (CAV3) on chromosome 3p25. Possibly, increased activity of neuronal nitric oxide synthase (nNOS) contributes to the clinical characteristics of increased mechanical muscle hyperexcitability.

METHODS

Clinical examination, mutational analysis, and immunohistochemistry of muscle tissue were performed in a patient with sporadic RMD.

RESULTS

The authors observed a de novo CAV3 missense mutation Arg26Gln. Immunohistochemistry showed reduced caveolin-3 surface expression in a muscle biopsy. In addition, the authors found normal sarcolemmal nNOS expression and a reduced expression of alpha-dystroglycan in muscle fibers.

CONCLUSIONS

These data confirm that RMD is caused by CAV3 mutations. Moreover, there is evidence that CAV3 mutations may also be found in patients without a positive family history of RMD.

Mutations in CAV3 cause mechanical hyperirritability of skeletal muscle in rippling muscle disease

Hereditary rippling muscle disease (RMD) is an autosomal dominant human disorder characterized by mechanically triggered contractions of skeletal muscle. Genome-wide linkage analysis has identified an RMD locus on chromosome 3p25. We found missense mutations in positional candidate CAV3 (encoding caveolin 3; ref. 5) in all five families analyzed. Mutations in CAV3 have also been described in limb-girdle muscular dystrophy type 1C (LGMD1C; refs. 6,7), demonstrating the allelism of dystrophic and non-dystrophic muscle diseases.

Idebenone in patients with Friedreich ataxia

Friedreich ataxia (FA), the most common form of degenerative ataxia, is thought to be caused by respiratory deficiency due to mitochondrial iron accumulation and oxidative stress. Idebenone, a free-radical scavenger, protects mitochondrial function in in vitro models of FA. In a placebo-controlled crossover trial we studied the effect of idebenone on respiratory function in nine ambulant FA patients. (31)P magnetic resonance spectroscopy demonstrated mitochondrial impairment in vivo in skeletal muscle of all FA patients, but no recovery with idebenone. No effects were seen in clinical scores. Echocardiography did not confirm a preliminary study reporting improvement of FA-associated cardiomyopathy with idebenone.