A financial analysis of maxillomandibular fixation versus rigid internal fixation for treatment of mandibular fractures

PURPOSE

The aim of this study was to compare the cost-effectiveness of mandibular fracture treatment by closed reduction with maxillomandibular fixation (CRF) with open reduction and rigid internal fixation (ORIF).

PATIENTS AND METHODS

This was a retrospective study of 85 patients admitted to the Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery Service at San Francisco General Hospital and treated for mandibular fractures from January 1 to December 31, 1993. The patients were divided into 2 groups: 1) those treated with CRF and 2) those treated with ORIF. The outcome variables were length of hospital stay, duration of anesthesia, and time in operating room. The charge for primary fracture treatment included the fees for the operation and hospitalization without any complications. Within the group of 85 patients treated for mandibular fractures in 1993, 10 patients treated with CRF and 10 patients treated with ORIF were randomly selected, and hospital billing statements were used to estimate the average charge of primary treatment. The average charge to manage a major postoperative infection also was estimated based on the billing statements of 10 randomly selected patients treated in 1992 (5 treated with CRF, 5 with ORIF) who required hospital admission for the management of a complication. The average total charge was computed by using the average charge for primary treatment plus the incidence of postoperative infection multiplied by the average charge for management of that complication.

RESULTS

Eighty-five patients were included in the study. The average charge for primary treatment was $10,100 for the CRF group and $28,362 for the ORIF group. The average charge for the inpatient management of a major postoperative infection was $26,671 for the CRF group and $39,213 for the ORIF group. The average total charge for management of a mandible fracture with CRF was $10,927; the total charge for the ORIF group was $34,636.

CONCLUSION

The results of this retrospective study suggest that the use of CRF in the management of mandibular fractures at our institution provides considerable savings over treatment by using ORIF. The use of ORIF should be reserved for patients and fracture types with specific indications.

The therapeutics of melatonin: a paediatric perspective

The production of melatonin by the pineal gland and its functions are considered, and then its possible uses in the treatment of children. Institutionalized children, and those with severe learning disorders, often have irregular sleep-wake patterns, and there is evidence that melatonin can result in improvement to the benefit of both the child and the carers. The affected children can become less irritable, calmer, happier, and content. Also they may socialize better and become more attentive, with an improvement in their cognitive abilities. Another group of children who are likely to suffer from disturbed sleep are those who are visually handicapped. Melatonin given in the evening can improve their sleep patterns, and often their performance. No important side-effects have been reported. It is generally accepted that if a child is liable to epileptic seizures sleep deprivation may well exacerbate them. There is some evidence from clinical trials that in that event melatonin can be helpful. There are many other problems in which it is claimed that treatment with melatonin is justifiable. These are mentioned, but further confirmatory studies are needed in most of them. There is no doubt that melatonin can effect the circadian system, and shift the sleep-wake cycle; and that there are situations in which this can be desirable.

Cognitive functions and epileptic activity

Epilepsy, and its treatment, can affect the development and use of language in a number of different ways. The seizures may be a symptom of a lesion in areas of the brain essential for language function, and the complications of both the seizures and of the drugs can interfere with learning. However, the purpose of this review is to consider the role of epileptic activity as demonstrated by electrical discharges in the electroencephalogram (EEG), whether these are accompanied by overt seizures or not, on cerebral function especially that of language. The Landau-Kleffner, the continuous spike-waves during sleep, and the benign epilepsy of childhood with Rolandic spikes syndromes are considered; as well as the evidence of epileptic discharges affecting language development. If there are doubts that a patient is suffering from epilepsy the diagnosis may be difficult; and anyone involved in the treatment of language disorders should keep this possibility in mind. Particularly during childhood an EEG, awake and asleep, should be an important part of the assessment of both developmental and acquired dysphasia. The control of overt fits may be relatively easy, but drugs are not so effective in controlling the epileptic activity in the EEG. The treatment of such discharges used to be discouraged, but the evidence is now strongly in favour of employing both medical and surgical treatment. The results in restoring language function are sometimes dramatic.

Carbohydrate-deficient glycoprotein syndromes

Four types of carbohydrate-deficient glycoprotein syndrome have been described, and the cause of two of them has been found. The symptoms and signs of these syndromes are described, with variations that occur at different ages. The commonest is type Ia with an autosomal recessive form of inheritance, and the gene responsible has been mapped to 16p. The typical pathology is atrophy of the cerebellum and brainstem, sometimes also involving the cortex, although both the pathology and the biochemical deficiencies vary between different types of syndrome. The diagnosis depends firstly on recognising the clinical features, including the presence of complications such as thyroid disorders. Then biochemical tests can be carried out, especially chromatographic carbohydrate-deficient transferrin assay and isoelectric focusing of serum transferrin. The prognosis depends on the complications, renal, hepatic, and cardiac, but affected children will be severely handicapped. Therefore treatment consists mainly of coping with the complications, and supporting the child and the family. Oral infusion of mannose can be effective in type Ib disease.

Muscular strength and physical function

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the potential association of muscular strength and endurance at baseline with the prevalence of functional limitations at follow-up.

METHODS

Study participants were 3,069 men and 589 women (30-82 yr) who received a clinical examination including a strength evaluation at the Cooper Clinic between 1980 and 1989 and responded to a 1990 mail-back survey. Participants also had to achieve at least 85% of their age-predicted maximal heart rate on a maximal exercise treadmill test and have no history of heart attack, stroke, diabetes, high blood pressure, cancer, or arthritis at their first visit. A strength index composite score (0-6) was calculated using age- and sex-specific tertiles from bench press, leg press, and sit-up tests. Those scoring 5 or 6 were categorized in the high strength group. Functional health status was assessed by responses to questions about the participant's ability to perform light, moderate, and strenuous recreational, household, daily living, and personal care tasks.

RESULTS

After an average follow-up of 5 yr, 7% of men and 12% of women reported at least one functional limitation. A logistic regression model including age, aerobic fitness, body mass index, and new health problems at follow-up found that, relative to those with lower levels of strength, the odds of reporting functional limitations at follow-up in men and women categorized as having higher levels of strength were 0.56 (95%CI = 0.34, 0.93) and 0.54 (95%CI = 0.21, 1.39), respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings, if replicated in other populations, suggest that maintenance of strength throughout the lifespan may reduce the prevalence of functional limitations.

The acquisition of a second language

It is claimed that if children can begin to acquire a second language at an early age they will find it easier to develop fluency, and will speak it without an accent. Age is a factor in acquiring one's mother tongue, and this also applies when learning a second language. One essential to developing such a skill is the ability to switch from one language to the other, as appropriate. Studies on the effects of age on this learning are reviewed. Techniques such as positron emission tomography can now be used to show which areas of the brain are involved in developing new skills, and much has been learnt in this way. Differences can be demonstrated between the cerebral function of the children who learn a second language at an early age and those who do this when they are older, and also between those who acquire a high degree of fluency and those who never do. If children speak a second language by hearing it in the environment in which they live, they are acquiring it as they do their mother tongue, but if they start at the age of 12 years they are learning it like any other subject they study. If the opportunity is present, surely it is better to acquire a second language than learn it.

The neurological complications of achondroplasia

The genetics of achondroplasia are discussed, and then the clinical features. The respiratory complications are only considered when related to the neurological ones which are the concern of this paper; and their effects on morbidity and mortality. Cervicomedullary compression can cause pain, ataxia, incontinence, apnea, and respiratory arrest. One of the signs can be progressive quadriparesis which can be a presenting symptom; and may be caused by a vascular lesion as well as by cord compression. Also nerve root compression in the neural foramina can cause symptoms and signs in the limbs. Enlargement of the head is a feature of achondroplasia. This may be due to subdural haematoma related to the wide subarachnoid spaces, and to trauma. Hydrocephalus is common, and may be non-communicating and due to aqueduct stenosis, but is much more often communicating and the result of raised intracranial venous pressure. Shunting may be necessary, but surgery directed towards relieving the venous pressure may be more logical. Otitis media often affects these children, and can cause deafness and subsequently delayed language development. Sleep disturbances can be the result of both neurological and respiratory complications. Apart from the treatment for hydrocephalus the most important decision is often the question of operating on the cervical medullary compression. Risk factors such as brisk reflexes, small foramen magnum, and central hypopnea, can be an indication for surgery; but timing can be difficult as the cord compression can resolve spontaneously. The intelligence levels of these children are usually normal, and studies have shown a surprisingly high level of satisfaction with the services provided.

Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder: possible causes and treatment

The possible causes of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder are considered, and the drugs that may be of benefit in treating it. Accurate diagnosis is essential for effective management. This includes the syndrome itself and associated conditions. Theories of causation are discussed. These involve the anatomical substrate but, equally importantly, the role of neurotransmitters; and the use of tests such as positron emission tomography will undoubtedly increase understanding. Genetic factors also play a part. Options for treatment are considered. Evidence supports the effectiveness of stimulant drugs, such as methylphenidate. Among the justifications for such treatment are the excessive strains placed on family relationships by the condition, and the disruption of the child's schooling. It must be carefully planned, and a constant watch kept for adverse effects. These can include difficulty in sleeping, poor appetite, loss of weight and tics. Drugs alone, however, are unlikely to help, and attention must first be given to the situation at home and at school, and how this can be improved. Treatment is often successful, and it can be a rewarding condition to treat.

New variant Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease

It is now recognised that new variant Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (CJD) can present during adolescence, so it may be within the experience of any paediatrician. Some observations on prion proteins are made, and some of the features of classical CJD are reviewed. Reports of patients with new variant CJD are given. The possible links between this condition and bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE) are considered, especially the finding that certain people who are homozygous for methionine at codon 129 of the prion protein may be particularly susceptible to this infection. The diagnosis of new variant CJD can be difficult. Early sensory and psychiatric symptoms can be suggestive, so can the initial signs of ataxia and involuntary movements. The EEG does not help in this variety. Although not specific some serum and CSF tests may give diagnostic support. It has been claimed that tonsillar biopsy may confirm the diagnosis, but this often necessitates brain biopsy; or the diagnosis may only be made at autopsy. Beliefs about the way infections spread will have to be modified, and more must be learnt about the nature of prions, how they enter the body, and how they spread in the brain.

The acute porphyrias

The various types of acute porphyria are discussed, as well as their mode of inheritance and the enzyme deficiencies responsible for the symptoms. The symptoms and signs of an acute attack are then described, especially those due to neuropathies and to disturbances of behaviour. Agents which can precipitate attacks are listed. These are most frequently drugs, and as they include those used for anti-epileptic treatment problems soon arise as seizures often occur in this condition. The main complications are hypertension and renal failure, and examples of hyponatraemia and folate deficiency are illustrated. The urgency to diagnose this disorder lies in the need to avoid precipitating factors. Screening tests are discussed, and those needed to confirm the diagnosis. The prognosis has improved over the years, due to increased awareness of the disorder, and better management. During an acute attack the treatment of pain and vomiting will be of particular importance, and then haematin or chelating agents can be tried. With better management most of those who have inherited acute porphyria should be able to lead a normal life.

The role of botulinus toxin type A in treatment--with special reference to children

Although botulinum toxin A was first introduced to treat strabismus and blepherospasm it is now used in an increasing number of conditions, many in the field of pediatrics. Its action results from a prevention of the release of acetylcholine from nerve terminals. A number of studies recording the effects of the toxin in the treatment of spastic cerebral palsy are reviewed, and although these can be criticized, there seems to be no doubt that it can be of benefit. It is few side effects, but it may reveal an underlying weakness. Other disadvantages are its cost and the need for repeated injections. It can be used for the relief of rigidity, although the effects in the extrapyramidal form of cerebral palsy are not so dramatic. Also it can be beneficial in some forms of dystonia, rarely if this is generalized, but certainly if it is focal, and especially if there is accompanying pain. There are several conditions seen in children, such as strabismus, blepherospasm and tremors, in which this form of treatment will rarely be indicated; but they will be mentioned. An exception may be spasmodic torticollis during adolescence if it does not respond to other therapy, as it is so disabling. Botulinum toxin can be used to block the discharges from cholinergic sympathetic and parasympathetic terminals. Focal hyperhidrosis can be very distressing among older children, and the use of the toxin should sometimes be considered in this and other autonomic disorders.

Retinoid signaling in immortalized and carcinoma-derived human uroepithelial cells

This paper investigates the presence and functionality of retinoid signaling pathways in human urinary bladder carcinoma and SV40-immortalized uroepithelial cell lines. Only two of eight cell lines were proliferation-inhibited by 10 microM of either all-trans or 13-cis-retinoic acid. Transactivation of the CAT gene under control of a retinoid-responsive element demonstrated functionality of the signaling pathway in both sensitive cell lines and four of six resistant cell lines. Relative RT-PCR analysis of a panel of retinoid-responsive and inducible genes demonstrated changes in expression levels of all the genes in response to-retinoic acid treatment together with numerous aberrations dysregulations. We conclude that retinoid signaling may be a target for inactivation during tumorigenesis by uncoupling gene expression, proliferation and differentiation. Therefore retinoids are more likely to be effective for chemoprevention than for treatment of bladder carcinomas.

Treating depression in staff-model versus network-model managed care organizations

OBJECTIVE

To compare primary care providers' depression-related knowledge, attitudes, and practices and to understand how these reports vary for providers in staff or group-model managed care organizations (MCOs) compared with network-model MCOs including independent practice associations and preferred provider organizations.

DESIGN

Survey of primary care providers' depression-related practices in 1996.

SETTING AND PARTICIPANTS

We surveyed 410 providers, from 80 outpatient clinics, in 11 MCOs participating in four studies designed to improve the quality of depression care in primary care.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

We measured knowledge based on depression guidelines, attitudes (beliefs about burden, skill, and barriers) related to depression, and reported behavior. Providers in both types of MCO are equally knowledgeable about treating depression (better knowledge of pharmacologic than psychotherapeutic treatments) and perceive equivalent skills in treating depression. However, compared with network-model providers, staff/group-model providers have stronger beliefs that treating depression is burdensome to their practice. While more staff/group-model providers reported time limitations as a barrier to optimal depression treatment, more network-model providers reported limited access to mental health specialty referral as a barrier. Accordingly, these staff/group-model providers are more likely to treat patients with major depression through referral (51% vs 38%) or to assess but not treat (17% vs 7%), and network-model providers are more likely to prescribe antidepressants (57% vs 6%) as first-line treatment.

CONCLUSIONS

Whereas the providers from staff/group-model MCOs had greater access to and relied more on referral, the providers from network-model organizations were more likely to treat depression themselves. Given varying attitudes and behaviors, improving primary care for the treatment of depression will require unique strategies beyond enhancing technical knowledge for the two types of MCOs.

A diagnostic in vitro urine assay for interstitial cystitis

OBJECTIVES

A low molecular weight urine factor that inhibits the proliferation of normal bladder epithelial cells in vitro was previously shown to be present significantly more often in the urine of patients with interstitial cystitis (IC) than in the urine of asymptomatic age-, race-, and sex-matched control subjects. We sought to determine the specificity of this finding for IC by determining whether the urine of patients with other urogenital inflammatory disorders also contains a factor that inhibits bladder epithelial cell proliferation.

METHODS

Urine was collected from women with IC, acute bacterial cystitis, or vulvovaginitis, as well as from asymptomatic control women. The proliferation of primary normal adult bladder epithelial cells was determined by measuring 3H-thymidine incorporation in vitro.

RESULTS

Osmolality- and pH-corrected urine specimens from 50 (86%) of 58 women with IC significantly inhibited human bladder epithelial cell proliferation compared with 3 (8%) of 36 asymptomatic control women, 7 (12%) of 58 women with bacterial cystitis, and 0 (0%) of 12 women with vulvovaginitis (P < 0.001 for the comparison of mean percent change in 3H-thymidine incorporation with IC urine versus urine from each of the control groups). Optimal sensitivity and specificity values of 91.4% and 90.6%, respectively, were achievable at a cutoff of 25% inhibition of 3H-thymidine incorporation, using all three control groups.

CONCLUSIONS

The measurement of urine antiproliferative activity may be a useful noninvasive means for diagnosing IC in women.

Arthrogryposis multiplex congenita

The common factor causing congenital arthrogryposis is lack of fetal movements. This can result from a large number of disorders. They may be neuropathic, affecting the brain, the spinal cord, or the peripheral nerves; they may be abnormalities of the muscles, such as myasthenia gravis, congenital muscular dystrophies or mitochondrial cytopathies; they may be diseases of the connective tissues; or they may be conditions which limit the space within the uterus; or they may result from defects of the uterine environment. These are discussed in turn. Typical clinical findings are given and it is emphasised that the arthrogryposis is often a manifestation of certain syndromes, some the result of abnormal chromosomes. Although it is not within the scope of this review article to describe these in detail, examples are given. In particular the subgroup of distal arthrogryposes and amyoplasia are considered. The importance of trying to define a cause is especially the need to give reliable genetic advice to the parents and also to establish a prognosis. The diagnosis will often be made by the associated symptoms and signs, and sometimes by tests such as electromyography and muscle biopsy. Although some of the diseases will be fatal early in life, there are many instances when the child will survive into adult life; if due attention is given to the treatment, particularly orthopedic procedures, and to social and educational management. This can only be done realistically if there is a good idea of the natural history of the condition underlying the arthrogryposis.

Thermographic imaging in the beating heart: a method for coronary flow estimation based on a heat transfer model

Intraoperative thermographic imaging in open-chest conditions can provide the surgeon with important qualitative information regarding coronary flow by utilizing heat transfer analysis following injection of cold saline into the aortic root. The heat transfer model is based on the assumption that the epicardial temperature changes are mainly due to convection of heat by the blood flow, which may, therefore, be estimated by measuring the temperature variations. Hearts of eight dogs were exposed and imaged by a thermographic camera. Flow in the left arterial descending (LAD) coronary branch was measured by a transit-time flowmeter. 20 ml of cold saline were injected into the aortic root (just after the aortic valve) and the epicardial temperature images were recorded at end-diastole, for 20-30 s. Different flow rates were achieved by 1 min occlusion of the LAD, which affected a reactive hyperemic response. The dynamics of the temperature in the arterial coronary tree was obtained by averaging the temperature over an edge-detected arterial segment for each frame. The heat transfer equation was curve-fitted, and the flow-dependent heat transfer index was correlated with the experimentally determined coronary flow (r = 0.69, p < 0.001). In summary: a method for quantitative estimation of coronary blood flow by thermography and heat transfer analysis was developed and tested in animal experiments. This method can provide important information regarding coronary blood flow during open-chest surgical procedures.

Estimation of coronary blood flow by ECG gated cardiac thermography in open-chest conditions

Thermography is suggested as a tool to estimate myocardial and coronary epicardial flow in open-chest heart surgery. To test the feasibility and compare various methods for coronary flow estimation in open-chest surgery, thermographic imaging was applied to eight open-chest dogs which were injected with cold saline into the aortic root. Blood flow in the left arterial descending (LAD) coronary vessel was measured by a transit-time flowmeter. ECG gated images were acquired for 20-30 s, while the cold saline (20 ml) was injected into the aortic root. Several flow levels were achieved during repeated hyperaemic response to transient occlusions of the LAD. A temperature response curve for each flow level was obtained by averaging over an edge-detected arterial segment for each image frame. Several indices were calculated from the temperature curve and correlated with the measured coronary flow. These include: an index based on a corrective heat transfer model (r = 0.69, p < 0.001), the slope of the descending part of the response curve (r = 0.76, p < 0.001), the peak temperature difference (r = 0.66, p < 0.001), and the area above the temperature response curve (r = 0.61, p < 0.01). As shown, coronary flow can be estimated quantitatively by intraoperative epicardial thermography, and may therefore provide important on-line information regarding blood flow during open-chest surgical procedures. Further studies are required for optimal application of this technique so as to increase its potential as a valid clinical tool.