Human T cell receptor-gamma delta-expressing T-cell lines recognize MHC-controlled elements on autologous EBV-LCL that are not HLA-A, -B, -C, -DR, -DQ, or -DP

HLA-loss variants of an EBV-transformed B lymphoblastoid cell line (EBV-LCL) 721 were used to investigate whether human MHC molecules other than known class I or class II were involved in autologous T cell responses. Bulk lymphocyte cultures of purified T cells primed to an autologous variant EBV-LCL that fails to express HLA-class II and has reduced cell surface HLA-class I expression, and oligoclonal TCR-gamma delta-bearing lines derived from them, could lyse both this EBV-LCL and an independently derived, class II expressing autologous variant EBV-LCL that bears no HLA-A, -B, or -C, suggesting the presence of additional HLA-like restriction elements. Cold target inhibition of cytolysis mediated by these lines indicated that a shared or cross-reactive MHC controlled restriction element other than the known MHC determinants was retained by the EBV-LCL variants. Single-cell derived clones from these T cell lines which expressed only the TCR-gamma delta showed this same target cell specificity pattern, proving recognition of MHC-controlled determinants by autologous gamma delta T cells. Anti-gamma delta antibody could inhibit cytolysis by the gamma delta-expressing lines, suggesting that the TCR-gamma delta was involved in recognition of the EBV-LCL targets. Flow cytometric analysis with separate HLA-reactive antibodies indicated that the restriction element for these cytolytic responses is a molecule serologically cross-reactive with HLA-B and -C Ag, yet is a determinant that cannot be HLA-A, -B, -C, -DR, -DQ or -DP.

Human T cell receptor-gamma delta-expressing T-cell lines recognize MHC-controlled elements on autologous EBV-LCL that are not HLA-A, -B, -C, -DR, -DQ, or -DP

HLA-loss variants of an EBV-transformed B lymphoblastoid cell line (EBV-LCL) 721 were used to investigate whether human MHC molecules other than known class I or class II were involved in autologous T cell responses. Bulk lymphocyte cultures of purified T cells primed to an autologous variant EBV-LCL that fails to express HLA-class II and has reduced cell surface HLA-class I expression, and oligoclonal TCR-gamma delta-bearing lines derived from them, could lyse both this EBV-LCL and an independently derived, class II expressing autologous variant EBV-LCL that bears no HLA-A, -B, or -C, suggesting the presence of additional HLA-like restriction elements. Cold target inhibition of cytolysis mediated by these lines indicated that a shared or cross-reactive MHC controlled restriction element other than the known MHC determinants was retained by the EBV-LCL variants. Single-cell derived clones from these T cell lines which expressed only the TCR-gamma delta showed this same target cell specificity pattern, proving recognition of MHC-controlled determinants by autologous gamma delta T cells. Anti-gamma delta antibody could inhibit cytolysis by the gamma delta-expressing lines, suggesting that the TCR-gamma delta was involved in recognition of the EBV-LCL targets. Flow cytometric analysis with separate HLA-reactive antibodies indicated that the restriction element for these cytolytic responses is a molecule serologically cross-reactive with HLA-B and -C Ag, yet is a determinant that cannot be HLA-A, -B, -C, -DR, -DQ or -DP.

Specific recognition of human leukemic cells by allogeneic T cells: II. Evidence for HLA-D restricted determinants on leukemic cells that are crossreactive with determinants present on unrelated nonleukemic cells

Transplantation of immunocompetent cells present within allogeneic bone marrow has been associated with the elimination of residual host leukemia, both in animal tumor models and in patients receiving marrow transplants for leukemia. This observation has been called the "graft-versus-leukemia effect." We have attempted to study this phenomenon in vitro by characterizing the cytolytic response of T cells from normal donors after in vitro activation with allogeneic leukemic cells. As expected, most T cells that react against an allogeneic patient's leukemic cells recognize their foreign HLA antigens and lyse the patient's nonleukemic remission lymphoid cells. In addition, we have shown that a small fraction of the T cells recognize and lyse foreign leukemic targets without lysis of nonmalignant remission targets from the same leukemic patient. These T cells have been isolated and characterized as CD3+, CD4+ cells expressing the alpha/beta T cell receptor (TCR). Their lysis appears to reflect specific antigen recognition mediated via the CD3-TCR complex and interactions involving the CD4 receptor. Some of these "leukemic specific" T cell lines, which are restricted by HLA class II molecules, can also lyse occasional nonleukemic cells from certain unrelated donors. This recognition appears to involve crossreactive determinants shared by the leukemic cells and the unrelated allogeneic nonleukemic cells. These specific interactions may represent an in vitro model of the graft-versus-leukemia effect.

Gamma/delta T cell clones and natural killer cell clones mediate distinct patterns of non-major histocompatibility complex-restricted cytolysis

Non-MHC-restricted killer cells are cytotoxic lymphocytes that can mediate cytolysis of most tumor targets without apparent selectivity and restriction by the MHC, particularly when activated with IL-2. These effector cells include predominantly NK cells and T cells expressing the TCR-gamma/delta. We found that TCR-gamma/delta-1+, delta TSC1-, BB3+, Ti gamma A+ T cell clones mediate a characteristic cytolytic pattern of non-MHC-restricted cytolysis that is markedly different from NK clones and alpha/beta T cell clones derived from the peripheral blood of the same normal individuals. The characteristic finding is that all BB3/Ti gamma A+ gamma/delta clones mediate strong cytolysis of Daudi cells but they do not lyse Raji cells. In contrast, NK clones from the same donors mediate strong cytolysis of both Daudi and Raji targets. Cytotoxicity by the gamma/delta clones on certain target cells such as Daudi and Molt 4 can be specifically inhibited by mAbs reactive against the TCR-gamma/delta. Therefore, the TCR-gamma/delta on these clones either directly recognizes target epitopes on some tumor targets or it is involved in the regulation of their cytotoxic function. The expression of TCR-gamma/delta products reacting with the BB3 and Ti gamma A mAbs reflects the usage of identical TCR-gamma/delta V region genes that appear to be associated with the characteristic pattern of non-MHC-restricted cytotoxicity displayed by this major subset of human peripheral blood gamma/delta cells.

Natural killer cells activated by interleukin 2 treatment in vivo respond to interleukin 2 primarily through the p75 receptor and maintain the p55 (TAC) negative phenotype

Interleukin 2 (IL-2) induced activation of unstimulated resting natural killer (NK) cells or resting T-cells initially occurs following binding of IL-2 through the p75 receptor that is expressed primarily by these cells. However, this IL-2/p75 interaction induces TAC chain synthesis and formation of high affinity IL-2 receptor required for the proliferation of resting peripheral blood lymphocytes. In this study, we present data indicating that NK cells activated by in vivo IL-2 treatment, in contrast to resting NK cells, respond and proliferate to further IL-2 in vitro using primarily the p75 receptor with only a minor component of cells responding through the high affinity receptor. These in vivo activated NK cells minimally expressed the TAC chain and maintained this TAC negative phenotype while proliferating in response to IL-2. The primary involvement of the p75 receptor in the proliferative response of these cells to IL-2 was demonstrated by the need for concentrations of IL-2 higher than 44 pM to obtain a significant response and by the dramatic inhibition of this response by anti-p75 monoclonal antibody. Anti-TAC monoclonal antibody inhibited only the poor proliferation obtained at low doses of IL-2 suggesting a minor role for TAC and high affinity IL-2 receptors. This was in contrast to the partial inhibition of proliferation by anti-p75 or anti-TAC observed in unstimulated pretherapy peripheral blood lymphocytes suggesting that these cells respond to IL-2 through both high affinity receptors and intermediate affinity p75 receptors. The T-cells isolated from in vivo activated peripheral blood lymphocytes, despite expressing TAC, were not responsive to IL-2, suggesting that these cells express predominantly nonfunctional low affinity TAC receptors. NK cells activated by IL-2 in vivo represent a unique model system of IL-2 dependent cells that respond and proliferate to IL-2 essentially through the p75 IL-2 receptor.

T helper-cell leukemia/lymphoma: presentation as an acute immune-mediated illness

A 36-year-old man presented with an acute immune-mediated illness characterized by leukocytoclastic vasculitis and polyarthritis. Evaluation of the synovial fluid, bone marrow, and peripheral blood revealed large numbers of abnormal lymphoid cells labeling a 4B4-positive, CD4-positive, IL-2 receptor-negative, helper T cells. Hypergammaglobulinemia, immune complexes, high levels of serum IL-2 receptors, serum antibodies against foreign alloantigens, and specific cytolysis of the patient's leukemic cells by his normal CD8+ T lymphocytes suggest an interaction of the malignant cells and his normal immune cells. Thus, some of the rheumatologic symptoms leading to the diagnosis of leukemia appear to reflect an immunoregulatory imbalance manifested by B-cell hyperactivity, likely induced by the malignant helper T cells, and attempted regulation of his malignant T cells by normal lymphocytes.

Specific recognition of human leukemic cells by allogeneic T cell lines

Clinical and experimental data suggest a role for the immune response in preventing leukemic relapses following allogeneic bone marrow transplantation the graft-versus-leukemia (GVL) effect. In the context of an allogeneic BMT, a number of different immune mechanisms mediated by donor cells may be responsible for the GVL effect. We have approached this question by using limiting dilution cultures of alloactivated human lymphocytes to analyze the in vitro allogeneic cytolytic response against fresh allogeneic leukemia. Initial results in the limiting dilution assays with split culture analyses demonstrated frequent alloreactive cytolytic T lymphocyte precursors that destroyed remission peripheral blood lymphocytes and leukemic cells from the allogeneic leukemic patient. These assays also demonstrated frequent lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cell precursors that lysed both the LAK sensitive Daudi line and the allogeneic leukemia. In these experiments, isolated cultures also showed cytolytic activity directed against the allogeneic leukemic blasts without activity against remission PBL, or the LAK-sensitive Daudi cell line. Two T cell lines (ABL1 and ABL2) isolated from an LDA, demonstrated this form of specificity, mediating destruction specifically against the allogeneic acute lymphoblastic leukemic cells. Both cell lines ABL1 and ABL2 were CD3+, TCR alpha beta +, and CD4+. These 2 cell lines mediated little or no cytotoxicity against a large panel of other targets tested (natural killer sensitive and resistant cell lines, allogeneic PBL, and allogeneic fresh leukemic blasts). Antibody-blocking experiments revealed a role for the CD3-TCR receptor of both cell lines in lysis of leukemic cells; the CD4 and MHC class II molecules were clearly involved in the lysis by the ABL1 cell line. Specificity of recognition for the allogeneic leukemic blasts was further confirmed by unlabeled target competitive inhibition studies. The mechanism of the preferential lysis of leukemia by the alloactivated T cell lines described in this paper remains uncertain. Nevertheless, these leukemic-specific populations provide a means by which the human GVL effect may be further studied in vitro.

Lymphokine-activated killer activity induced by in vivo interleukin 2 therapy: predominant role for lymphocytes with increased expression of CD2 and leu19 antigens but negative expression of CD16 antigens

The phenotype and function of lymphocytes from cancer patients treated with repetitive weekly cycles of continuous i.v. infusions of recombinant interleukin 2 (IL-2) were examined. Peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) obtained after IL-2 therapy showed an increased percentage of cells bearing the CD16 and leu19 markers which are associated with natural killer cells. These PBL mediated significantly increased levels of IL-2-dependent lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) activity against the Daudi cell line. Depletion of CD16+ cells from PBL obtained after in vivo IL-2 caused only slight inhibition of their LAK activity or their proliferative response to IL-2 in vitro. This indicates that CD16+ cells are involved but play only a minor role in these responses. In contrast, depletion of leu19+ cells, from PBL activated in vivo with IL-2, virtually abrogated their LAK activity and their proliferative response to IL-2. Two-color flow cytometry studies showed that a leu19+/CD16- population was expanded by in vivo IL-2 therapy and was responsible for the majority of LAK activity by in vivo-activated PBL. Moreover, this CD16- population showed an increased density of leu19 and CD2 (E rosette receptor) antigens when compared to the resting PBL obtained prior to IL-2 treatment. These data show that the predominant population mediating in vitro LAK activity, induced by in vivo IL-2 therapy, consists of activated natural killer cells with a high density of leu19 and CD2 antigens but negative for the CD16 antigen.

Antigen-specific recognition of autologous leukemia cells and allogeneic class-I MHC antigens by IL-2-activated cytotoxic T cells from a patient with acute T-cell leukemia

Culturing of leukemic blood lymphocytes from a patient with acute T-cell lymphoblastic leukemia (T-ALL) with interleukin-2 (IL-2) yielded T-cell line AK-1 with a remarkable cytotoxic specificity. This line mediated strong lysis of tumor target lines expressing major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I antigens, such as Raji, CEM, and Molt-4 cells, but no killing of K562 and Daudi cells, which are deficient in MHC class I. In contrast, lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells from normal donors destroyed all these tumor targets, without MHC restriction. Line AK-1, originating from residual normal T cells present in the leukemic blood, lysed autologous leukemic blasts and peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) from many but not all allogeneic individuals but failed to kill autologous remission lymphocytes. Destruction of the autologous leukemic targets by AK-1 could be inhibited by unlabeled competitor target cells that were lysed by AK-1, but not by target cells that were not lysed. This suggests that AK-1 specifically recognized an alien determinant on the autologous ALL cells, crossreactive with allogeneic MHC class I antigens. This reactivity with some degree of tumor specificity may be a leukemic equivalent to responses reported for populations of tumor infiltrating lymphocytes (TIL) seen in some solid tumors.

Unexplained infertility: evaluation of treatment with clomiphene citrate and human chorionic gonadotropin

A double-blind, randomized, prospective therapeutic trial was conducted in 148 couples with unexplained infertility. Treatment consisted of 4 consecutive months of placebo or clomiphene citrate (CC) (100 mg) by mouth on cycle days 5 to 9, and placebo or human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) (5,000 IU) intramuscularly on cycle days 19, 22, 25, and 28. There were 14 pregnancies during the trial and 39 pregnancies during observation before and after the trial. Placebo treatment resulted in no pregnancies over 4 months. Clomiphene citrate was significantly better than placebo (P less than 0.04), with a pregnancy rate of 19% over the course of 4 months. The pregnancy rate with hCG either alone (11%) or in combination with CC (7.6%), was not significantly better than placebo. Treatment-independent pregnancies, defined as those before treatment (but after enrollment), or more than 1 month after therapy, occurred in 16% of the couples, with a mean time to conception of 8.8 months. As part of their follow-up, 39 of the study couples subsequently underwent in vitro fertilization (IVF), and 43% were found to have a previously unrecognized male factor or fertilization defect. A pregnancy rate of 16% was achieved after a mean of 1.1 cycles in these 39 couples. The authors conclude that CC is useful in treating unexplained infertility and is a reasonable initial therapy. For couples who fail to conceive, IVF may be diagnostic as well as therapeutic.

Serum levels of the low-affinity interleukin-2 receptor molecule (TAC) during IL-2 therapy reflect systemic lymphoid mass activation

Expression of the low-affinity interleukin-2 (IL-2) receptor molecule (TAC) has been associated with lymphocyte activation, in vitro and in vivo [Greene WC (1987) Clin Res 35:439]. We have used an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) to quantify the role of released and cell-bound IL-2 receptor following in vitro or in vivo activation of human lymphocytes with IL-2. In vitro experiments, culturing fresh peripheral blood lymphocytes in 30 U/ml IL-2 (corresponding to the steady-state IL-2 concentration achieved in patients receiving IL-2 in our clinical trials), showed that the levels of IL-2 receptor released into the culture media exceeded the levels of cell-associated receptor, with both rising in parallel to the cytotoxic activity of the peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) against cultured tumor cells. In 12 patients receiving high-dose IL-2 for the treatment of various malignant neoplasms, the levels of IL-2 receptor released into the serum rose dramatically during the IL-2 infusion, and then fell following cessation of the IL-2 infusion. This heightened release of IL-2 receptor into the serum occurred during the episodes of profound lymphopenia that developed within hours after patients began an IL-2 infusion. Following each 4-day infusion of IL-2, a rebound lymphocytosis was observed, as has been previously reported. Serum IL-2 receptor levels do not rebound in parallel; rather, they reach a plateau near the end of the 4-day infusion and then decrease upon cessation of IL-2. These changes in serum IL-2 receptor levels accompany changes in lytic activity of circulating PBL on Daudi target cells. These results suggest that lymphocyte populations exposed to IL-2 in vivo are activated to become cytotoxic, release TAC, and relocate in non-peripheral blood compartments. Following cessation of the IL-2 infusion these activated lymphocytes return to the peripheral circulation and do not secrete TAC as vigorously as while influenced directly by the IL-2 infusion.

The cellular immunotherapy of cancer: current and potential uses of interleukin-2

The potential for immune-mediated destruction of neoplasms was suggested nearly one century ago. Despite this, no "magic bullet" has yet been identified. Nevertheless, the physiology of cell-mediated immune reactions has been well characterized in molecular, cellular, and clinical studies of allograft and microbial immunity. Extensive studies performed in laboratory animal models have documented the in vitro and in vivo destruction of various neoplastic tissues by immune cells. This destruction can be directed against autologous, syngeneic, or allogeneic tumors in several systems with varying degrees of "tumor specificity". Two approaches exist towards utilizing these immune reaction in vivo. The first involves providing the tumor bearer with immunostimulatory agents, either specific or nonspecific, designed to activate and amplify the destructive potential of the individual's endogenous immune cells able to recognize and destroy autologous tumor. The second approach provides immune cells with antitumor capacity to a tumor-bearing individual, these cells having been activated exogenously. A number of successful regimens involving these two approaches, and combinations of them, have been delineated in animal tumor models. These experimental studies lay a strong foundation for initiating clinical trials of these concepts for patients with cancer. This review summarizes the diverse experimental studies in animals leading to clinical trials, presents recent data from ongoing clinical trials directly testing the potential for cellular immunotherapy, and then presents some of the major challenges facing further development and application of this potential therapeutic approach.