Specificity, duration and mechanism of idiotype suppression induced by neonatal injection of monoclonal anti-idiotope antibodies into mice

Monoclonal antibodies detecting idiotopes on the germ line-encoded anti-(4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl)acetyl (NP) antibody B1-8 were injected at various doses into newborn mice and the expression of B1-8 idiotopes was measured in anti-NP responses in later life. Suppression was long lasting, and a 100-fold increase in the dose of anti-idiotope delayed recovery from suppression by 5-6 weeks. Upon injection of a single anti-idiotope, suppression was observed for all B1-8 idiotopes to various degrees. Certain idiotopically defined antibody phenotypes were much more efficiently suppressed, and later recovered from suppression, than others. This specificity pattern was observed at the level of both B and T cells from the manipulated animals, as demonstrated in cell transfer experiments in which such cells were mixed with normal T and B cells. In these experiments, there was evidence for suppression mediated by regulatory T (and possibly also B) cells. Whereas the B cells from the manipulated animals were idiotypically unresponsive in a T cell-dependent adoptive primary response, the frequency of lipopolysaccharide-reactive B cells expressing the target idiotype was only slightly reduced in these animals as compared to control mice. Together with data on the elimination of anti-idiotope antibody from the neonatally injected animals these results are interpreted in the following way: idiotype suppression is induced through the reaction of anti-idiotope with idiotopes expressed on the surface of newly generated B cells, at microgram concentrations of anti-idiotope. When the concentration of anti-idiotope fall below that level, recovery from suppression sets in. Two types of suppression are induced. The first, namely, direct blockade of B cell maturation, is short-lived. The second involves the induction of regulatory cells, perhaps through idiotope-bearing antibody V regions complexed by anti-idiotope. This type of suppression is long-lived and its specificity depends upon the distribution of the target idiotope in the antibody repertoire and/or peculiarities of the T cell receptor repertoire. It impinges on the selection of the B cell repertoire in the animal as expressed in T cell-dependent (and possibly other) responses and is thus hardly seen at the level of lipopolysaccharide-reactive (immature) cells. Idiotype suppression by regulatory cells may be perpetuated by antigen interacting with idiotypic antibodies on the B cell surface and may therefore play a role in establishing tolerance not only for the expressed antibody repertoire, but for self antigens in general.

Mechanism of neonatally induced idiotype suppression and its relevance for the acquisition of self-tolerance

We present an analysis of the elimination of a monoclonal anti-idiotope antibody injected into C57BL/6 mice on the day of birth. During the first 4 weeks of life the antibody is eliminated from the circulation with a slow half-life, ranging from 15-18 days. This finding makes sense biologically as the animals depend at that time on maternally transmitted antibodies. After 4 weeks elimination speeds up considerably. The rate of elimination appears to be the same for a 1 microgram and a 100 microgram dose. The elimination data and previous results on the specificity, duration and cellular basis of idiotype suppression induced by the monoclonal anti-idiotope fit into the following model of idiotype suppression, which is in good accord with other experimental evidence on idiotype and allotype suppression in the literature: suppression depends strictly on the concentration of anti-idiotope in the cellular environment. As long as it is in the microgram range, the generation of idiotope-bearing B cells from pre-B cells is prevented. The system recovers quickly from this type of suppression, as soon as the concentration of anti-idiotope falls below that range. A second type of suppression is also induced in the anti-idiotope-treated animals. It is long-lived (8-10 weeks longer that the first type), has a peculiar specificity in that it affects, in our particular case, only a certain subset of the antibodies bearing the target idiotope, and involves regulatory T (and possibly B) cells which prevent the functional maturation of B cells expressing those antibodies in the animal. Suppression of this type also depends strictly on anti-idiotope concentration and is induced either at the time when the generation of idiotope-bearing B cells from pre-B cells is still inhibited or just thereafter, when such cells begin to appear in the system and the anti-idiotope concentration is still at a few hundred nanograms per ml. Experimental evidence indicates that in the induction of suppression, the primary target of the anti-idiotope are idiotope-bearing antibodies variable regions. We assume that those variable regions, complexed by anti-idiotope are the inducers of regulatory (suppressive) T cells. Idiotype suppression may also be induced upon interaction of antibody variable regions (and possibly other receptors) with ligands other than anti-idiotypic antibodies. We, therefore, think that idiotype suppression not only establishes self-tolerance within the antibody system, but is a mechanism of self-tolerance in general.

The immune response against anti-idiotope antibodies II. The induction of antibodies bearing the target idiotope (Ab3 beta) depends on the frequency of the corresponding B cells

In the present study we use two monoclonal anti-idiotope antibodies (Ac38 and Ac146; Ab1) against the germ line-encoded, lambda 1 chain-bearing and (4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl)acetyl (NP)-binding antibody B1-8 (Ab1) for the induction of complementary antibodies (Ab3) and ask the question to what extent antibodies bearing B1-8-like idiotopes (Ab3 beta) are represented in the Ab3 population. In this experimental system, Ab3 beta is distinguished from the remaining Ab3 population (Ab3 alpha) by three properties which Ab3 beta may share with B1-8: (a) the binding of NP, (b) the binding to Ac146 (if induced by Ac38) or the binding to Ac38 (if induced by 146) and (c) that they carry lambda 1 chains. Antibodies with all three properties are induced in low amounts by both anti-idiotopes. Also, Ac146 induces only Ab3 alpha (bearing kappa chains and not binding NP and Ac38). In contrast, Ac38 triggers almost exclusively a lambda 1 chain-bearing response, i.e. Ab3 beta. The response has an unusually large size, reaches its maximum after a week and is long-lasting. An analysis at the level of lipopolysaccharide-reactive precursor B cells demonstrates that, in this case, cells expressing Ab3 beta occur at exceedingly high frequency (approximately equal to 10(-3] and are at least 10 times more frequent than cells expressing Ab3 alpha. The high frequency of Ab3 beta-expressing cells correlates with the contribution of several VH, D and J genes to the expression of this particular idiotope. In the case of the Ac146 anti-idiotope antibody, the response is dominated by Ab3 alpha. Ab3 beta represents less than 10% of the total response, reaches maximal levels 2 weeks after immunization and declines rapidly. This correlates with a low frequency of precursor B cells expressing Ab3 beta (approximately equal to 10(-5] and a restriction of the corresponding idiotope to rare VH-D combinations, caused presumably by a stringent contribution of the H chain to this idiotope which covers the NP-binding site. Our data suggest that anti-idiotypic antibodies (Ab2) against Ab1 will preferentially induce antibodies idiotypically related to Ab1 if the corresponding idiotopes are expressed in high frequency in the B cell compartment. This is expected in cases where Ab2 recognizes an idiotope that can be formed by many germ line-encoded VH-D-VL-combinations.

The expression of a set of antibody variable regions in lipopolysaccharide-reactive B cells at various stages of ontogeny and its control by anti-idiotypic antibody

An analysis is presented in which we measure the expression of a subset of antibody variable (V) regions in lipopolysaccharide (LPS)-reactive precursor B cells at various stages of ontogeny. The V regions were characterized by hapten (4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl)acetyl (NP)-binding specifity and/or expression of idiotypic determinants whose genetic basis had been explored in previous studies. Only V regions containing the V lambda 1 domain were considered: this allowed an unequivocal determination of idiotopes and reduced heterogeneity in the system essentially to the multiplicity of VH and D genes. It was found that approximately every fourth lambda 1-bearing LPS-reactive splenic B cell produces an NP-binding antibody. Approximately 1 in 40 lambda 1-bearing cells expressed an idiotope (Ac38) which is encoded by V lambda 1 and a set of related VH genes in combination with D and J elements. Of these cells, only a minority produce an NP-binding antibody and a few percent of the latter express a second idiotope (Ac146) which is known to be restricted to a subset of Ac38-positive, NP-binding humoral antibodies. All these frequencies are in good accord with previous analyses of anti-idiotope-induced antibodies in the serum. They can be easily accommodated into a simple model of random selection of VH genes in LPS-reactive B lymphocytes. The frequencies of the V regions under study were essentially the same in LPS-reactive B cells from spleens of adult and newborn animals and in LPS-reactive B cells generated from bone marrow pre-B cells in vitro. In the case of the latter cells the frequencies were independent of the absence or presence of T cells in the culture system. While we could thus detect, in naive mice, neither positive nor negative selection of the cells from the time of their generation in the bone marrow until their arrival in the periphery, negative selection is in principle possible: the presence of microgram amounts of anti-idiotope antibodies during maturation from pre-B to B cells specifically blocks the appearance of idiotope-bearing LPS-reactive cells in vitro. The potential physiological role of the latter effect in the sense of self-stabilization of the expressed antibody repertoire in ongoing immune responses and the possibility that frequency determinations in LPS-reactive B cells may be not representative for the repertoire expressed in the population of mature B cells is discussed.

The immune response against anti-idiotope antibodies. I. Induction of idiotope-bearing antibodies and analysis of the idiotope repertoire

In the present analysis we dissect the idiotype repertoire, independently of hapten-binding specificity, by immunizing different strains of mice with cross-linked monoclonal anti-idiotope antibodies against antibody B1-8. B1-8 is a monoclonal antibody with specificity for the hapten (4-hydroxy-3-nitro-phenyl)acetyl (NP) and carries a germ line gene-encoded variable region. The results demonstrate that the expression of B1-8 idiotopes and their association with each other and with NP-binding specificity are strain-specific. Certain idiotopes are expressed on antibodies differing in antigen-binding specificity, whereas one of the idiotopes appears strictly associated with NP-binding antibodies. The genetic analysis provides strong evidence that the strain specificity of the idiotope repertoire is a result of V region polymorphism in the mouse.

Two distinct types of helper T cells involved in the secondary antibody response: independent and synergistic effects of Ia- and Ia+ helper T cells

We have described here two distinct types of carrier-specific helper T cells which act independently and synergistically to augment the B-cell response to a hapten. They are separable by passage through a nylon wool column. The first type of helper T cell, which we designate as Th1, is nylon nonadherent, and can help the response of hapten-primed B cells only if the haptenic and carrier determinants are present on a single molecule (cognate interaction). The second type of helper T cell, Th2, adheres to the nylon wool column, and can help the B-cell response to a hapten coupled to a heterologous carrier upon stimulation with unconjugated relevant carrier (polyclonal interaction). The addition of a small number of Th2 to the mixture of Th1 and B cells significantly augmented the net response to the hapten carrier conjugate. Both Th1 and Th2 cells belong to the Lyt-1+,2-,3- subclass. Th1 has no detectable Ia antigen, whereas Th2 is killed by certain anti-Ia antisera and complement. The Ia antigen detected on Th2 was found to be controlled by a locus in the I-J subregion. The results clearly established the fact that there are two distinct pathways in the T- and B-cell collaboration, which involves two different subsets of carrier-specific helper T cells.

Specific enrichment of the suppressor T cell bearing I-J determinants: parallel functional and serological characterizations

A simple procedure to enrich the antigen (keyhole limpet hemocyanin, KLH)-specific suppressor T cell was described. The suppressor T cell from KLH)-immunized mice specifically bound to the KLH-coated Sephadex G-200 column at 37 degrees C, and was eluted from the column by cold (0-4 degrees C) medium. The helper T cell did not bind to the column under the identical condition. The suppressor T cell thus obtained had 100 times as potent suppressor activity as the original spleen cells in in vivo and in vitro secondary antibody responses against a hapten coupled to KLH. This procedure also enriched the cells bearing I-J determinants and Lyt-2,3 alloantigens, allowing us to study the phenotypic expressions on the suppressor T cell by direct serological procedures as well as by the use of the fluorescence activated cell sorter. Parallel functional and serological analyses indicated that the antigen-specific suppressor T cell belongs to a population of I-J+, Lyt-2+,3+ and Fc R- T cells.

The role of receptors for T cell products in antibody formation

Immunocompetent cell interactions are achieved via direct contact between functionally different cell types or via interactions between soluble factors elaborated by regulatory T cells and specific receptors on responding cells for the T cell factors. In either case, there exist certain restrictions with respect to the effective interactions, which depend on the state of differentiation and genetic background of the responding cell type. Such restrictions are considered to be mainly determined by the development and nature of the receptor site on responding cell types for different T cell factors, which is now refered to the "acceptor" for the T cell factors. The presence of such acceptor sites on different populations of both T and B cells has been demonstrated in various experimental systems, and they are now considered to be the site by which responding cells receive appropriate signal for destination of their further differentiation. We have tried to review the nature and possible role of acceptor sites on both B and T cells for different T cell factors with respect to the induction and regulation of immune responses. A special emphasis was put on the genetic nature of the acceptor site. The observed genetic restrictions in the acceptance of T cell factors by responding cells suggest that such restrictions are needed for meaningful and unmistakable communications between funcionally different immunocometent cells. Furthermore, the presence or absence of acceptor sites for certain T cell factors is supposed to be a very important factor for determination of the immune responsiveness of animals against certain antigens, and thus in some cases the Ir gene effect may predominantly affect the expression of acceptor site. Possible implications of acceptor site in the regulation of antibody response and in the network of immunocompetent cell interactions are discussed.

Properties of antigen-specific suppressive T-cell factor in the regulation of antibody response of the mouse. I. In vivo activity and immunochemical characterization

An antigen-specific suppressive T-cell factor was extracted from physically disrupted thymocytes and spleen cells of mice that had been immunized with soluble protein antigens. The factor, when inoculated into syngeneic normal mice, could induce a significant suppression of IgG antibody response against a hapten coupled to the carrier protein by which the donor of the suppressor factor was immunized. The suppressor factor was found only effective in suppressing the antibody response of syngeneic or H-2 histocompatible recipients. The suppressive T-cell factor was removed by absorption with immunoadsorbent composed of the relevant antigen, but not with any of those of anti-immunoglobulin antibodies. The factor was successfully removed by alloantibodies with specificity for the K end (H-2K, I-A and I-B) of the H-2 complex of the donor strain, but not by those for the D end (I-C, SsSlp, and H-2D). The activity was removed by absorption with a heterologous antithymocyte serum. The mol wt of the suppression T-cell factor was between 35,000 and 60,000 as determined by Sephadex G-200 gel filtration. The suppressive T-cell factor was found to be a heat-liable protein.

Selective roles of thymus-derived lymphocytes in the antibody response. I. Differential suppressive effect of carrier-primed T cells on hapten-specific IgM and IgG antibody responses

Passively transferred thymocytes and spleen cells from donors primed with keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) exerted differential suppressive effect on IgM and IgG antibody responses of syngeneic recipients immunized with DNP-KLH depending primarily on the time when KLH-primed cells were transferred. This was demonstrated by the decrease in the numbers of DNP-specific direct and indirect PFC in the spleen of the recipients given KLH-primed cells at different times during primary and secondary immunization. Whereas the cell transfer simultaneously with or 2 days after the primary immunization produced only slight suppression of the peak IgM antibody response, it caused profound suppression of late IgM and IgG antibody responses. By contrast, the cell transfer 3 days after the immunization produced immediate suppression of the ongoing IgM antibody response resulting in its earlier termination, while being unable to prevent the induction of IgG antibody response. KLH-primed cells could moderately suppress the secondary anti-DNP antibody response, in which IgG antibody response was found to be slightly more sensitive than IgM antibody response to the suppressive influence of KLH-primed cells. The suppressive effect of the KLH-primed spleen cells was completely eliminated by the in vitro treatment of the cells with anti-theta and C before cell transfer, indicating that cells responsible for the suppression are, in fact, T cells. The suppression of DNP-specific antibody response by KLH-primed T cells was achieved only if the recipients were immunized with DNP-KLH but not with DNP-heterologous carrier, suggesting that direct interaction between T and B cells is necessary for the suppression of the antibody response. It is concluded that susceptibility of B cells to the specific suppressive influence of T cells is inherently different depending on the differentiation stage of B cells and on the immunoglobulin class they are destined to produce.

Selective roles of thymus-derived lymphocytes in the antibody response. II. Preferential suppression of high-affinity antibody-forming cells by carrier-primed suppressor T cells

Passive transfer of thymocytes and spleen cells from donors primed with keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) caused significant decrease in the average avidity of anti-DNP antibodies produced by direct and indirect PFC in the recipients in both primary and adoptive secondary antibody responses against DNP-KLH. The analysis of the avidity distribution of antibodies produced by plaque-forming cells (PFC) indicated that the observed decrease in the average avidity is primarily due to the selective loss of high avidity subpopulation of PFC leaving low avidity subpopulation relatively unaffected. The degree of suppression in antibody avidity did not correlate with the reduction in the number of PFC, and thus causing the "shift" of avidity distribution of PFC to the low avidity end. These results indicate that the "maturation" of antibody in the T-cell-dependent antibody response is influenced by the carrier-specific suppressor T cells with respect to the emergence and selection of B cells having high affinity receptors for hapten. It is suggested that B cells binding antigen with high affinity receptors would be more easily affected than those with low affinity receptors by specific suppressor T cells which are capable of reacting the carrier portion of the same antigen.