The structure of elongation factor G in complex with GDP: conformational flexibility and nucleotide exchange

BACKGROUND

Elongation factor G (EF-G) catalyzes the translocation step of translation. During translocation EF-G passes through four main conformational states: the GDP complex, the nucleotide-free state, the GTP complex, and the GTPase conformation. The first two of these conformations have been previously investigated by crystallographic methods.

RESULTS

The structure of EF-G-GDP has been refined at 2.4 A resolution. Comparison with the nucleotide-free structure reveals that, upon GDP release, the phosphate-binding loop (P-loop) adopts a closed conformation. This affects the position of helix CG, the switch II loop and domains II, IV and V. Asp83 has a conformation similar to the conformation of the corresponding residue in the EF-Tu/EF-Ts complex. The magnesium ion is absent in EF-G-GDP.

CONCLUSIONS

The results illustrate that conformational changes in the P-loop can be transmitted to other parts of the structure. A comparison of the structures of EF-G and EF-Tu suggests that EF-G, like EF-Tu, undergoes a transition with domain rearrangements. The conformation of EF-G-GDP around the nucleotide-binding site may be related to the mechanism of nucleotide exchange.

The dynamic structure of EF-G studied by fusidic acid resistance and internal revertants

We have previously identified 20 different fusidic acid-resistant alleles of fusA, encoding mutant forms of the ribosomal translocase EF-G. One of these, P413L, is used here as the starting point in selections for internal revertants, identifying 20 different pseudo-wild-type forms of EF-G. We have also identified two alleles of fusA previously isolated as suppressors of 4.5 S RNA deficiency. All of these mutants are analysed in terms of their effects on the structural dynamics of EF-G. Most mutation conferring fusidic acid-resistance interfere with conformational changes of EF-G, but some may be located at a possible fusidic acid binding site. Revertants of the P413L mutations restore the function of EF-G with or without affecting the level of resistance to fusidic acid. The revertant mutations probably restore the balance between the GDP and GTP conformations of EF-G off the ribosome, and most of them are located close to the interface between the G domain and domain II. The procedure for the isolation of pseudo-wild-type forms of EF-G can be used to direct evolution progressively away from the wild-type while still maintaining the essential functions of EF-G.

Truncated elongation factor G lacking the G domain promotes translocation of the 3' end but not of the anticodon domain of peptidyl-tRNA

The mechanism by which elongation factor G (EF-G) catalyzes the translocation of tRNAs and mRNA on the ribosome is not known. The reaction requires GTP, which is hydrolyzed to GDP. Here we show that EF-G from Escherichia coli lacking the G domain still catalyzed partial translocation in that it promoted the transfer of the 3' end of peptidyl-tRNA to the P site on the 50S ribosomal subunit into a puromycin-reactive state in a slow-turnover reaction. In contrast, it did not bring about translocation on the 30S subunit, since (i) deacylated tRNA was not released from the P site and (ii) the A site remained blocked for aminoacyl-tRNA binding during and after partial translocation. The reaction probably represents the first EF-G-dependent step of translocation that follows the spontaneous formation of the A/P state that is not puromycin-reactive [Moazed, D. & Noller, H. F. (1989) Nature (London) 342, 142-148]. In the complete system--i.e., with intact EF-G and GTP--the 50S phase of translocation is rapidly followed by the 30S phase during which the tRNAs together with the mRNA are shifted on the small ribosomal subunit, and GTP is hydrolyzed. As to the mechanism of EF-G function, the results show that the G domain has an important role, presumably exerted through interactions with other domains of EF-G, in the promotion of translocation on the small ribosomal subunit. The G domain's intramolecular interactions are likely to be modulated by GTP binding and hydrolysis.

Rate of translation of natural mRNAs in an optimized in vitro system

We report results on in vitro translation of an mRNA coding for elongation factor TuB which was in vitro transcribed from the tufB gene from Escherichia coli. Translation occurs at a rate of about 10 codons per second, which is close to the in vivo rate. Protein elongation obeys Michaelis-Menten kinetics with respect to the concentrations of the elongation factors EF-Tu and EF-G in the translation system. The measured K(m) values for EF-Tu and EF-G are 10 and 0.25 microM, respectively. The obtained k(cat) and K(m) values were used to estimate the average k(cat)/K(m) of about 24 x 10(6) s-1 M-1 for the interaction of individual EF-Tu*GTP*aa-tRNA complexes with ribosomes. The estimated k(cat)/K(m) value for EF-G is 36 x 10(6) s-1 M-1. We have also studied translation with a "hyperaccurate" ribosome variant that is pseudodependent on streptomycin (SmP). We have found that SmP ribosomes translate the TuB mRNA significantly slower than wild-type ribosomes do. This is mainly due to a threefold lower k(cat)/K(m) for the interaction of EF-Tu*GTP*aa-tRNA complexes with SmP ribosomes.

Imprinting through molecular mimicry. Protein synthesis

Part of the structure of translational elongation factor G, in a complex with GDP, resembles the tRNA bound in a ternary complex with elongation factor Tu and GTP; this 'molecular mimicry' extends to charge distribution as well as shape.

Tetracyclines induce changes in accessibility of ribosomal proteins to proteases

Limited proteolysis was used to test the interaction of tetracyclines and some of their derivatives with ribosomes. Proteolysis of the free ribosomes was compared with that of the ligand-bound ribosomes. The interaction of different tetracyclines with ribosomes depends on their chemical structure and produces both a protective effect and an increased susceptibility to proteases of some ribosomal proteins in the 30S and 50S subparticles. Most of the proteins affected by tetracycline action are located on the head of the 30S and interface side of the 50S subunits. On the grounds of the obtained data one of the antibiotic-binding regions can be located near the ribosomal peptidyl transferase center. The effect of possible conformational changes induced by tetracyclines on the translation process is discussed.

Bovine mitochondrial initiation and elongation factors

The procedures summarized above provide nearly homogeneous preparations of IF-2mt, EF-Tu. Tsmt, and EF-Gmt. The scheme developed for IF-2mr leads to a 24,000-fold purification of this factor with a 26% recovery of activity. Analysis by SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and gel filtration chromatography indicates that this factor functions as a monomer with a molecular weight of about 85,000. The scheme developed EF-Tu.Tsmt provides a 10,000-fold purification with an overall yield of about 10%. The EF-Tumt component in this complex has a molecular weight of about 46,000, whereas EF-Tsmt has a molecular weight of about 32,000 on SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. The EF-Tu. Tsmt complex is tightly associated and appears to have a native molecular weight of about 70,000. The five-step purification procedure outlined above for EF-Gmt results in a 14,000-fold purification of EF-Gmt with a 2-5% recovery of activity. Analysis by SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and gel filtration chromatography indicates that EF-Gmt functions as a monomeric protein with an apparent molecular weight of about 80,000.

Messenger RNA translation in prokaryotes: GTPase centers associated with translational factors

During the decoding of messenger RNA, each step of the translational cycle requires the intervention of protein factors and the hydrolysis of one or more GTP molecule(s). Of the prokaryotic translational factors, IF2, EF-Tu, SELB, EF-G and RF3 are GTP-binding proteins. In this review we summarize the latest findings on the structures and the roles of these GTPases in the translational process.

Dual functions of ribosome recycling factor in protein biosynthesis: disassembling the termination complex and preventing translational errors

We summarize in this communication the data supporting the two functions of ribosome recycling factor (RRF, originally called ribosome releasing factor). The first described role involves the disassembly of the termination complex which consists of mRNA, tRNA and the ribosome bound to the mRNA at the termination codon. This process is catalyzed by two factors, elongation factor G (EF-G) and RRF. RRF stimulated protein synthesis as much as eight-fold in the in vitro lysozyme synthesis system, when ribosomes were limiting. In the absence of RRF, ribosomes remain mRNA-bound at the termination codon and translate downstream codons. In the in vitro system, the site of reinitiation is the triplet codon 3' to the termination codon. RRF is an essential protein for bacterial life. Temperature sensitive (ts) RRF mutants were isolated and in vivo translational reinitiation due to inactivation of ts RRF was demonstrated using the beta-galactosidase reporter gene placed downstream from the termination codon. A second function of RRF involves preventing errors in translation. In polyphenylalanine synthesis programmed by polyuridylic acid, misincorporation of isoleucine, leucine or a mixture of amino acids was stimulated upto 17-fold when RRF was omitted from the in vitro system. RRF did not influence the large error (10-fold increase) induced by streptomycin. This means that RRF participates not only in the disassembly of the termination complex but also in peptide elongation. Extending this concept and its conventional role for releasing ribosomes from mRNA, involvement of RRF in the reinitiation in the 3A' system (a construct using S aureus protein A, a collaborative work with Dr Isaksson), in programmed frame shifting, in trans-translation with 10Sa RNA (collaborative work with Dr Muto), and in the reinitiation downstream from the ORF A of the IS 3 (insertion sequence of a transposon, collaborative work with Dr Sekine) are discussed on the basis of preliminary data to be published elsewhere. Finally, we review the known RRF sequences from various organisms including eukaryotes and discuss the possible mechanism for disassembly of the eukaryotic termination complex.

Crystal structure of the ternary complex of Phe-tRNAPhe, EF-Tu, and a GTP analog

The structure of the ternary complex consisting of yeast phenylalanyl-transfer RNA (Phe-tRNAPhe), Thermus aquaticus elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu), and the guanosine triphosphate (GTP) analog GDPNP was determined by x-ray crystallography at 2.7 angstrom resolution. The ternary complex participates in placing the amino acids in their correct order when messenger RNA is translated into a protein sequence on the ribosome. The EF-Tu-GDPNP component binds to one side of the acceptor helix of Phe-tRNAPhe involving all three domains of EF-Tu. Binding sites for the phenylalanylated CCA end and the phosphorylated 5' end are located at domain interfaces, whereas the T stem interacts with the surface of the beta-barrel domain 3. The binding involves many conserved residues in EF-Tu. The overall shape of the ternary complex is similar to that of the translocation factor, EF-G-GDP, and this suggests a novel mechanism involving "molecular mimicry" in the translational apparatus.

Ribosomal proteins and elongation factors

Structural work on the translation machinery has recently undergone rapid progress. It is now known that six out of nine ribosomal proteins have an RNA-binding fold, and two domains of elongation factors Tu and G have very similar folds. In addition, the complex of EF-Tu with a GTP analogue and Phe-tRNA(Phe) has a structure that overlaps exceedingly well with that of EF-G-GDP. These findings obviously have functional implications.

Structure-based sequence alignment of elongation factors Tu and G with related GTPases involved in translation

The G domain and domain II in the crystal structure of Thermus thermophilus elongation factor G (EF-G) were compared with the homologous domains in Thermus aquaticus elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu). Sequence alignment derived from the structural superposition was used to define conserved sequence elements in domain II. These elements and previously known conserved sequence elements in the G domain were used to guide the alignment of the sequences of Sulfolobus acidocaldarius elongation factor 2, human elongation factor 2, and Escherichia coli initiation factor 2 and release factor 3 to the aligned sequences of EF-G and EF-Tu. This alignment, which deviates from previously published alignments, has evolutionary implications and leads to alternative interpretations of biochemical data concerning the interaction of elongation factors with the alpha-sarcin/ricin region of the ribosome. A single conserved sequence motif in domain II was identified and used to further characterize the GTPase subfamily of translation factors and related proteins. It was shown that the motif is found in most if not all the members of the family. Apparently, the common characteristic of these GTPases is an extensive consensus structural unit that possibly accounts for a similar interaction with the ribosome and is composed of two domains homologous to the G domain and domain II in EF-Tu and EF-G.

Arrangement and nucleotide sequence of the gene (fus) encoding elongation factor G (EF-G) from the hyperthermophilic bacterium Aquifex pyrophilus: phylogenetic depth of hyperthermophilic bacteria inferred from analysis of the EF-G/fus sequences

The gene fus (for EF-G) of the hyperthermophilic bacterium Aquifex pyrophilus was cloned and sequenced. Unlike the other bacteria, which display the streptomycin-operon arrangement of EF genes (5'-rps12-rps7-fus-tuf-3'), the Aquifex fus gene (700 codons) is not preceded by the two small ribosomal subunit genes although it is still followed by a tuf gene (for EF-Tu). The opposite strand upstream from the EF-G coding locus revealed an open reading frame (ORF) encoding a polypeptide having 52.5% identity with an E. coli protein (the pdxJ gene product) involved in pyridoxine condensation. The Aquifex EF-G was aligned with available homologs representative of Deinococci, high G+C Gram positives, Proteobacteria, cyanobacteria, and several Archaea. Outgroup-rooted phylogenies were constructed from both the amino acid and the DNA sequences using first and second codon positions in the alignments except sites containing synonymous changes. Both datasets and alternative tree-making methods gave a consistent topology, with Aquifex and Thermotoga maritima (a hyperthermophile) as the first and the second deepest offshoots, respectively. However, the robustness of the inferred phylogenies is not impressive. The branching of Aquifex more deeply than Thermotoga and the branching of Thermotoga more deeply than the other taxa examined are given at bootstrap values between 65 and 70% in the fus-based phylogenies, while the EF-G(2)-based phylogenies do not provide a statistically significant level of support (< or = 50% bootstrap confirmation) for the emergence of Thermotoga between Aquifex and the successive offshoot (Thermus genus). At present, therefore, the placement of Aquifex at the root of the bacterial tree, albeit reproducible, can be asserted only with reservation, while the emergence of Thermotoga between the Aquificales and the Deinococci remains (statistically) indeterminate.

A new factor from Escherichia coli affects translocation of mRNA

Reconstitution of protein synthesis from purified translation factors on ribosomes from Escherichia coli has revealed the requirement for a protein, W, that affects chain elongation and is essential to reconstitute the process (Ganoza, M. C., Cunningham, C., and Green, R. M. (1985) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 82, 1648-1652). We report that W has no effect on initiation complex formation by 30 or 70 S ribosomes or on the association of ribosomal subunits, peptide bond synthesis, or binding Ala-tRNA, which is the second amino acid of the coat protein of the MS2 RNA virion. W has a pronounced effect on tripeptide synthesis, and is obligatory for the synthesis of the coat protein or of the hexapeptide encoded by f2am3 RNA. Extracts from a temperature-sensitive mutant of the translocase, EF-G, were purified free of the W protein and were used to score for translocation defects. W is required for binding Ser-tRNA, the third N-terminal amino acid of the MS2 or f2 RNA coat protein to ribosomes bearing fMet-Ala-tRNA, as well as for the ejection of deacyl-tRNA from ribosomes, which occurred concomitant with the binding of the Ser-tRNA. We propose that W functions by ejecting tRNAs from ribosomes in a step that precedes the movement of mRNA during translocation.

Crystallographic studies of elongation factor G

The elongation factors G (EF-G) and Tu (EF-Tu) go through a number of conformation states in their functional cycles. Since they both are GTPases, have similar G domains and domains II, and have similar interactions with the nucleotides, then GTP hydrolysis must occur in similar ways. The crystal structures of two conformational states are known for EF-G and three are known for EF-Tu. The conformations of EF-G.GDP and EF-Tu.GTP are closely related. EF-Tu goes through a large conformational change upon GTP cleavage. This conformational change is to a large extent due to an altered interaction between the G domain and domains II and III. A number of kirromycin-resistant mutations are situated at the interface between domains I and III. The interface between the G domain and domain V in EF-G corresponds with this dynamic interface in EF-Tu. The contact area in EF-G is small and dominated by interactions between charged amino acids, which are part of a system that is observed to undergo conformational changes. Furthermore, a number of fusidic acid resistant mutants have been identified in this area. All of this evidence makes it likely that EF-G undergoes a large conformational change in its functional cycle. If the structures and conformational states of the elongation factors are related to a scheme in which the ribosome oscillates between two conformations, the pretranslocational and posttranslocational states, a model is arrived at in which EF-Tu drives the reaction in one direction and EF-G in the opposite. This may lead to the consequence that the GTP state of one factor is similar to the GDP state of the other. At the GTP hydrolysis state, the structures of the factors will be close to superimposable.

Overexpression and purification of Thermus thermophilus elongation factors G, Tu, and Ts from Escherichia coli

The translation elongation factors G (EF-G), Tu (EF-Tu), and Ts (EF-Ts) from the extreme thermophilic bacterium Thermus thermophilus were overproduced in Escherichia coli. The fus gene coding for EF-G and the tufA gene coding for EF-Tu were expressed under the control of a tac promoter, whereas EF-Ts was overproduced with the T7 RNA polymerase system. A detailed description for the purification of the three elongation factors from E. coli is presented. EF-G and EF-Tu are isolated by Q-Sepharose FF chromatography, heat treatment at 65 or 60 degrees C, respectively, and Sephacryl S200 gel permeation chromatography. For the purification of EF-Ts, a heat denaturation step is followed by DEAE-cellulose chromatography and a cation exchange EMD-SO-3 650 column. The overproduced factors show the same properties as those purified from T. thermophilus. As the crystal structures of T. thermophilus EF-Tu and EF-G have been solved recently, many questions concerning the function of particular residues or domains arise, which may be best addressed by studying the in vitro behavior and structure of altered recombinant constructs. The methods presented here should facilitate such studies.

Small clusters of divergent amino acids surrounding the effector domain mediate the varied phenotypes of EF-G and LepA expression

Elongation factors G, Tu, and related proteins (including LepA) form a distinct subgroup within the GTPase superfamily. This observation is based primarily upon amino acid comparisons of the effector region (G2) of the GTP-binding domain. To examine the functional importance of the highly conserved elongation factor G2 domain a series of chimeric proteins were constructed between Escherichia coli EF-G and Micrococcus luteus EF-G, and between E. coli EF-G and LepA (a protein of unknown function). The M. luteus EF-G/E. coli EF-G hybrid, M. luteus EF-G, and E. coli EF-G efficiently complemented EF-G function in an E. coli strain (PEM101) harbouring a temperature-sensitive mutation in fusA (the gene encoding EF-G). A comparison of the amino acid sequences of the M. luteus EF-G and E. coli EF-G indicated that groups of divergent amino acid residues (amino acids 1-9 and 72-80) were not important for function. LepA and LepA/EF-G chimeric proteins were tested for the ability to complement EF-G function in vivo, for cross-linking to 8-azido-[gamma-32P]-GTP in vitro and for fusidic acid-dependent co-sedimentation with 70S ribosomes. With one exception, all chimeras could be readily cross-linked to azido-GTP in an EF-G-like manner, indicating that hybrid protein construction did not generally result in improperly folded GTP-binding domains. However, the inability of such chimeras to complement EF-G function in vivo indicates that the effector domains are not functionally interchangeable. All LepA/EF-G chimeric proteins were severely defective in fusidic acid-dependent complex formation with 70S ribosomes. A comparison of the amino acid sequences of all three proteins suggests that residues 30-33, 43-48, and 63-66 of E. coli EF-G are important for EF-G specific ribosome-associated function.

The hinge region of Escherichia coli ribosomal protein L7/L12 is required for factor binding and GTP hydrolysis

A variant form of Escherichia coli ribosomal protein L7/L12 that lacked residues 42 to 52 (L7/L12: delta 42-52) in the hinge region was shown previously to be completely inactive in supporting polyphenylalanine synthesis although it bound to L7/L12 deficient core particles with the normal stoichiometry of four copies per particle (Oleinikov AV, Perroud B, Wang B, Traut RR (1993) J Biol Chem, 268, 917-922). The result suggested that the hinge confers flexibility that is required for activity because the resulting bent conformation allows the distal C-terminal domain to occupy a location on the body of the large ribosomal subunit proximal to the base of the L7/L12 stalk where elongation factors bind. Factor binding to the hinge-truncated variant was tested. As an alternative strategy to deleting residues from the hinge, seven amino acid residues within the putative hinge region were replaced by seven consecutive proline residues in an attempt to confer increased rigidity that might reduce or eliminate the bending of the molecule inferred to be functionally important. This variant, L7/L12:(Pro)7, remained fully active in protein synthesis. Whereas the binding of both factors in ribosomes containing L7/L12:delta 42-52 was decreased by about 50%, there was no loss of factor binding in ribosomes containing L7/L12:(Pro)7, as predicted from the retention of protein synthesis activity. The factor:ribosome complexes that contained L7/L12:delta 42-52 had the same low level of GTP hydrolysis as the core particles completely lacking L7/L12 and EF-G did not support translocation measured by the reaction of phe-tRNA bound in the A site with puromycin. It is concluded that the hinge region is required for the functionally productive binding of elongation factors, and the defect in protein synthesis reported previously is due to this defect. The variant produced by the introduction of the putative rigid Pro7 sequence retains sufficient flexibility for full activity.

A ribosomal protein module in EF-G and DNA gyrase

A novel common fold observed in the structures of elongation factor G, DNA gyrase B, and ribosomal protein S5 displays a rare topological feature suggesting the high probability of an evolutionary relationship.

Dissociation rate of cognate peptidyl-tRNA from the A-site of hyper-accurate and error-prone ribosomes

The binding stability of the aminoacyl-tRNA site (A-site), estimated from the dissociation rate constant kd, of AcPhe-Phe-tRNA(Phe) has been studied for wild-type (wt), for hyperaccurate ribosomes altered in S12 [streptomycin-dependent (SmD) and streptomycin-pseudodependent (SmP) phenotypes], for error-prone ribosomes altered in S4 (Ram phenotype), and for ribosomes in complex with the error-inducing aminoglycosides streptomycin and neomycin. The AcPhe2-tRNA stability is slightly and identically reduced for SmD and SmP phenotypes in relation to wt ribosomes. The stability is increased (kd is reduced) for Ram ribosomes to about the same extent as the proof-reading accuracy is decreased for this phenotype. kd is also reduced by the action of streptomycin and neomycin, but much less than the reduction in proof-reading accuracy induced by streptomycin. Similar kd values for SmD and SmP ribosomes indicate that the cause of streptomycin dependence is not excessive drop-off of peptidyl-tRNAs from the A-site.

Carboxyl-terminal amino acid residues in elongation factor G essential for ribosome association and translocation

The translocation of ribosomes on mRNA is carried out by cellular machinery that has been extremely well conserved across the entire spectrum of living species. This process requires elongation factor G (EF-G, or EF-2 in archaebacteria and eukaryotes), which is a member of the GTPase superfamily. Using genetic techniques, we have identified a series of mutated alleles of fusA (the Escherichia coli gene that encodes EF-G) that were unable to support protein synthesis in vivo. These alleles encode proteins with point mutations at codons 495 (a variant with a Q-to-P change at codon 495 [Q495P]), 502 (G502D), and 563 (G563D) and a nonsense mutation at codon 608. Biochemical analyses demonstrated that EF-G Q495P, G502D, and delta 608-703 were not disrupted in guanine nucleotide binding but were deficient in ribosome-dependent GTP hydrolysis and guanine nucleotide-dependent ribosome association. We propose that all of these mutations are present in a domain that is essential for ribosome association and that GTP hydrolysis was deficient as a secondary consequence of impaired binding to 70S ribosomes.

Synergism between the GTPase activities of EF-Tu.GTP and EF-G.GTP on empty ribosomes. Elongation factors as stimulators of the ribosomal oscillation between two conformations

A remarkable positive cooperativity between the GTPase activities of EF-Tu and EF-G on empty ribosomes from Escherichia coli has been discovered. This cooperativity implies a decrease of the corresponding apparent KM values of the empty ribosome for either elongation factor: from more than 10 microM to 0.5 microM for EF-Tu.GTP by the addition of 0.25 microM EF-G and from 0.7 microM to 0.5 microM for EF-G.GTP by the addition of 3 microM EF-Tu. In a further analysis of this phenomenon, the effects of various specific antibiotics were studied: thiostrepton, fusidic acid, tetracycline, pulvomycin and kirromycin appeared to inhibit the synergistic effect, whereas streptomycin was found to stimulate it. Even in the present minimal system the ribosomes respond to the above-mentioned antibiotics in a way surprisingly similar to that in the coupled system with mRNA and tRNAs. The cooperativity seems not to be due to a simultaneous binding of the two elongation factors to the ribosome as revealed by studying the effects of fusidic acid and kirromycin, and by band-shift experiments by means of gel electrophoresis under non-denaturing conditions. Our experimental data and the kinetic analysis of alternative models provide evidence that EF-Tu.GTP and EF-G.GTP interact sequentially with empty ribosomes that oscillate between two different conformations, one for each elongation factor. Apparently, ribosomes have an intrinsic property for oscillation as normally observed during protein synthesis with a frequency paced by the events of tRNA binding and translocation.