Evolution of a molecular switch: universal bacterial GTPases regulate ribosome function

The GTPases comprise a protein superfamily of highly conserved molecular switches adapted to many diverse functions. These proteins are found in all domains of life and often perform essential roles in fundamental cellular processes. Analysis of data from genome sequencing projects demonstrates that bacteria possess a core of 11 universally conserved GTPases (elongation factor G and Tu, initiation factor 2, LepA, Era, Obg, ThdF/TrmE, Ffh, FtsY, EngA and YchF). Investigations aimed at understanding the function of GTPases indicate that a second conserved feature of these proteins is that they elicit their function through interaction with RNA and/or ribosomes. An emerging concept suggests that the 11 universal GTPases are either necessary for ribosome function or transmitting information from the ribosome to downstream targets for the purpose of generating specific cellular responses. Furthermore, it is suggested that progenitor GTPases were early regulators of RNA function and may have existed in precursors of cellular systems driven by catalytic RNA. If this is the case, then a corollary of this hypothesis is that GTPases that do not bind RNA arose at a later time from an RNA-binding progenitor that lost the capability to bind RNA.

Synthesis of the translational apparatus is regulated at the translational level

The synthesis of many mammalian proteins associated with the translational apparatus is selectively regulated by mitogenic and nutritional stimuli, at the translational level. The apparent advantages of the regulation of gene expression at the translational level are the speed and the readily reversible nature of the response to altering physiological conditions. These two features enable cells to rapidly repress the biosynthesis of the translational machinery upon shortage of amino acids or growth arrest, thus rapidly blocking unnecessary energy wastage. Likewise, when amino acids are replenished or mitogenic stimulation is applied, then cells can rapidly respond in resuming the costly biosynthesis of the translational apparatus. A structural hallmark, common to mRNAs encoding many components of the translational machinery, is the presence of a 5' terminal oligopyrimidine tract (5'TOP), referred to as TOP mRNAs. This structural motif comprises the core of the translational cis-regulatory element of these mRNAs. The present review focuses on the mechanism underlying the translational control of TOP mRNAs upon growth and nutritional stimuli. A special emphasis is put on the pivotal role played by ribosomal protein S6 kinase (S6K) in this mode of regulation, and the upstream regulatory pathways, which might be engaged in transducing external signals into activation of S6K. Finally, the possible involvement of pyrimidine-binding proteins in the translational control of TOP mRNAs is discussed.

Recombination and clonal groupings within Helicobacter pylori from different geographical regions

A collection of 20 strains of Helicobacter pylori from several regions of the world was studied to better understand the population genetic structure and diversity of this species. Sequences of fragments from seven housekeeping genes (atpA, efp, mutY, ppa, trpC, ureI, yphC ) and two virulence-associated genes (cagA, vacA) showed high levels of synonymous sequence variation (mean percentage Ks of 10-27%) and lower levels of non-synonymous variation (mean percentage Ka of 0.2-5.6%). Cluster analysis of pairwise differences between alleles revealed the existence of two weakly clonal groupings, which included half of the strains investigated. All six strains isolated from Japanese and coastal Chinese were assigned to the 'Asian' clonal grouping, probably reflecting descent from a distinct common ancestor. The clonal groupings were not totally uniform; recombination, as measured by the homoplasy test and compatibility matrices, was extremely common within all genes tested, except cagA. The fact that clonal descent could still be discerned despite such frequent recombination possibly reflects founder effects and geographical separation and/or selection for particular alleles of these genes.

Evolutionary relationship between translation initiation factor eIF-2gamma and selenocysteine-specific elongation factor SELB: change of function in translation factors

Eubacterial and eukaryotic translation initiation systems have very little in common, and therefore the evolutionary events that gave rise to these two disparate systems are difficult to ascertain. One common feature is the presence of initiation, elongation, and release factors belonging to a large GTPase superfamily. One of these initiation factors, the gamma subunit of initiation factor 2 (eIF-2gamma), is found only in eukaryotes and archaebacteria. We have sequenced eIF-2gamma gene fragments from representative diplomonads, parabasalia, and microsporidia and used these new sequences together with new archaebacterial homologues to examine the phylogenetic position of eIF-2gamma within the GTPase superfamily. The archaebacterial and eukaryotic eIF-2gamma proteins are found to be very closely related, and are in turn related to SELB, the selenocysteine-specific elongation factor from eubacteria. The overall topology of the GTPase tree further suggests that the eIF-2gamma/SELB group may represent an ancient subfamily of GTPases that diverged prior to the last common ancestor of extant life.

Increased functional activity of elongation factor G with G16V mutation in the GTP-binding domain

Oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis was used to obtain elongation factor G from Thermus thermophilus with the G16V mutation in its GTP-binding domain. Functional studies of the mutated protein and elongation factor G from E. coli were carried out. The data revealed that the G16V mutant retains high thermostability, has an increased ribosome-dependent GTPase activity, and its translation activity in cell-free translation system is equal to that of the factor G from E. coli. The mutated protein with an uncleavable GTP analog also has an increased affinity to the ribosomes.

A role for a protease in morphogenic responses during yeast cell fusion

Cell fusion during yeast mating provides a model for signaling-controlled changes at the cell surface. We identified the AXL1 gene in a screen for genes required for cell fusion in both mating types during mating. AXL1 is a pheromone-inducible gene required for axial bud site selection in haploid yeast and for proteolytic maturation of a-factor. Two other bud site selection genes, RSR1, encoding a small GTPase, and BUD3, were also required for efficient cell fusion. Based on double mutant analysis, AXL1 in a MATalpha strain acted genetically in the same pathway with FUS2, a fusion-dedicated gene. Electron microscopy of axl1, rsr1, and fus2 prezygotes revealed similar defects in nuclear migration, vesicle accumulation, cell wall degradation, and membrane fusion during cell fusion. The axl1 and rsr1 mutants exhibited defects in pheromone-induced morphogenesis. AXL1 protease function was required in MATalpha strains for fusion during mating. The ability of the Rsr1p GTPase to cycle was required for efficient cell fusion, as it is for bud site selection. During conjugation, vegetative functions may be redeployed under the control of pheromone signaling for mating purposes. Since Rsr1p has been reported to physically associate with Cdc24p and Bem1p components of the pheromone response pathway, we suggest that the bud site selection genes Rsr1p and Axl1p may act to mediate pheromone control of Fus2p-based fusion events during mating.

Bayesian adaptive alignment and inference

Sequence alignment without the specification of gap penalties or a scoring matrix is attained by using Bayesian inference and a recursive algorithm. This procedure's recursive algorithm sums over all possible alignments on the forward step to obtain normalizing constants essential to Bayesian inferences, and samples from the exact posterior distribution on the backward step. Since both terminal and intervening unrelated subsequences will often be excluded from an alignment, the resulting alignments may be seen as extensions of local alignments. An alignment's significance is assessed using the Bayesian evidence. A shuffling simulation shows that Bayesian evidence against the null hypothesis tends to be a conservative measure of significance compared to classical p-values. An application to proteins from the GTPase superfamily shows that the posterior distribution of the number of gaps is often flat and that the posterior distribution of the evolutionary distance is often flat and sometimes bimodal. An alignment of 1GIA with 1ETU shows good correspondence with a structural alignment.

Site-directed mutagenesis of Thermus thermophilus EF-Tu: the substitution of threonine-62 by serine or alanine

The invariant threonine-62, which occurs in the effector region of all GTP/GDP-binding regulatory proteins, was substituted via site-directed mutagenesis by alanine and serine in the elongation factor Tu from Thermus thermophilus. The altered proteins were overproduced in Escherichia coli, purified and characterized. The EF-Tu T62S variant had similar properties with respect to thermostability, aminoacyl-tRNA binding, GTPase activity and in vitro translation as the wild-type EF-Tu. In contrast, EF-Tu T62A is severely impaired in its ability to sustain polypeptide synthesis and has only very low intrinsic and ribosome-induced GTPase activity. The affinity of aminoacyl-tRNA to the EF-Tu T62A.GTP complex is almost 40 times lower as compared to the native EF-Tu.GTP. These observations are in agreement with the tertiary structure of EF-Tu.GTP, in which threonine-62 is interacting with the Mg2+ ion, gamma-phosphate of GTP and a water molecule, which is presumably involved in the GTP hydrolysis.

Structure-based sequence alignment of elongation factors Tu and G with related GTPases involved in translation

The G domain and domain II in the crystal structure of Thermus thermophilus elongation factor G (EF-G) were compared with the homologous domains in Thermus aquaticus elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu). Sequence alignment derived from the structural superposition was used to define conserved sequence elements in domain II. These elements and previously known conserved sequence elements in the G domain were used to guide the alignment of the sequences of Sulfolobus acidocaldarius elongation factor 2, human elongation factor 2, and Escherichia coli initiation factor 2 and release factor 3 to the aligned sequences of EF-G and EF-Tu. This alignment, which deviates from previously published alignments, has evolutionary implications and leads to alternative interpretations of biochemical data concerning the interaction of elongation factors with the alpha-sarcin/ricin region of the ribosome. A single conserved sequence motif in domain II was identified and used to further characterize the GTPase subfamily of translation factors and related proteins. It was shown that the motif is found in most if not all the members of the family. Apparently, the common characteristic of these GTPases is an extensive consensus structural unit that possibly accounts for a similar interaction with the ribosome and is composed of two domains homologous to the G domain and domain II in EF-Tu and EF-G.

Elongation factor Tu, a GTPase triggered by codon recognition on the ribosome: mechanism and GTP consumption

The mechanism of elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu) catalyzed aminoacyl-tRNA (aa-tRNA) binding to the A site of the ribosome was studied. Two types of complexes of EF-Tu with GTP and aa-tRNA, EF-Tu.GTP-aa-tRNA (ternary) and (EF-Tu.GTP)2.aa-tRNA (quinternary), can be formed in vitro depending on the conditions. On interaction with the ribosomal A site, generally only one molecule of GTP is hydrolysed per aa-tRNA bound and peptide bond formed. The second GTP molecule from the quinternary complex is hydrolyzed only during translation of an oligo(U) tract in the presence of EF-G. The first step in the interaction between the ribosome and the ternary complex is the codon-independent formation of an initial complex. In the absence of codon recognition, the aa-tRNA-EF-Tu complex does not enter further steps of A site binding and remains in the initial binding state. Despite the rapid formation of the initial complex, the rate constant of GTP hydrolysis in the noncognate complex is four orders of magnitude lower compared with the cognate complex. This, together with the results of time-resolved fluorescence measurements, suggests that codon recognition by the ternary complex on the ribosome initiates a series of structural rearrangements that result in a conformational change of EF-Tu, presumably involving the effector region, which, in turn, triggers GTP hydrolysis and the subsequent steps of A site binding.

Translation elongation factor-3 (EF-3): an evolving eukaryotic ribosomal protein?

Fungi appear to be unique in their requirement for a third soluble translation elongation factor. This factor, designated elongation factor 3 (EF-3), exhibits ribosome-dependent ATPase and GTPase activities that are not intrinsic to the fungal ribosome but are nevertheless essential for translation elongation in vivo. The EF-3 polypeptide has been identified in a wide range of fungal species and the gene encoding EF-3 (YEF3) has been isolated from four fungal species (Saccharomyces cerevisiae, Candida albicans, Candida guillermondii, and Pneumocystis carinii). Computer-assisted analysis of the predicted S. cerevisiae EF-3 amino acid sequence was used to identify several potential functional domains; two ATP binding/catalytic domains conserved with equivalent domains in members of the ATP-Binding Cassette (ABC) family of proteins, an amino-terminal region showing significant similarity to the E. coli S5 ribosomal protein, and regions of predicted interaction with rRNA, tRNA, and mRNA. Furthermore, EF-3 was also found to display amino acid similarity to myosin proteins whose cellular function is to provide the motive force of muscle. The identification of these regions provides clues to both the evolution and function of EF-3. The predicted functional regions are conserved among all known fungal EF-3 proteins and a recently described homologue encoded by the Chlorella virus CVK2. We propose that EF-3 may play a role in the ribosomal optimization of the accuracy of fungal protein synthesis by altering the conformation and activity of a ribosomal "accuracy center," which is equivalent to the S4-S5-S12 ribosomal protein accuracy center domain of the E. coli ribosome. Furthermore, we suggest that EF-3 represents an evolving ribosomal protein with properties analogous to the intrinsic ATPase activities of higher eukaryotic ribosomes, which has wider implications for the evolutionary divergence of fungi from other eukaryotes.

Small clusters of divergent amino acids surrounding the effector domain mediate the varied phenotypes of EF-G and LepA expression

Elongation factors G, Tu, and related proteins (including LepA) form a distinct subgroup within the GTPase superfamily. This observation is based primarily upon amino acid comparisons of the effector region (G2) of the GTP-binding domain. To examine the functional importance of the highly conserved elongation factor G2 domain a series of chimeric proteins were constructed between Escherichia coli EF-G and Micrococcus luteus EF-G, and between E. coli EF-G and LepA (a protein of unknown function). The M. luteus EF-G/E. coli EF-G hybrid, M. luteus EF-G, and E. coli EF-G efficiently complemented EF-G function in an E. coli strain (PEM101) harbouring a temperature-sensitive mutation in fusA (the gene encoding EF-G). A comparison of the amino acid sequences of the M. luteus EF-G and E. coli EF-G indicated that groups of divergent amino acid residues (amino acids 1-9 and 72-80) were not important for function. LepA and LepA/EF-G chimeric proteins were tested for the ability to complement EF-G function in vivo, for cross-linking to 8-azido-[gamma-32P]-GTP in vitro and for fusidic acid-dependent co-sedimentation with 70S ribosomes. With one exception, all chimeras could be readily cross-linked to azido-GTP in an EF-G-like manner, indicating that hybrid protein construction did not generally result in improperly folded GTP-binding domains. However, the inability of such chimeras to complement EF-G function in vivo indicates that the effector domains are not functionally interchangeable. All LepA/EF-G chimeric proteins were severely defective in fusidic acid-dependent complex formation with 70S ribosomes. A comparison of the amino acid sequences of all three proteins suggests that residues 30-33, 43-48, and 63-66 of E. coli EF-G are important for EF-G specific ribosome-associated function.

Carboxyl-terminal amino acid residues in elongation factor G essential for ribosome association and translocation

The translocation of ribosomes on mRNA is carried out by cellular machinery that has been extremely well conserved across the entire spectrum of living species. This process requires elongation factor G (EF-G, or EF-2 in archaebacteria and eukaryotes), which is a member of the GTPase superfamily. Using genetic techniques, we have identified a series of mutated alleles of fusA (the Escherichia coli gene that encodes EF-G) that were unable to support protein synthesis in vivo. These alleles encode proteins with point mutations at codons 495 (a variant with a Q-to-P change at codon 495 [Q495P]), 502 (G502D), and 563 (G563D) and a nonsense mutation at codon 608. Biochemical analyses demonstrated that EF-G Q495P, G502D, and delta 608-703 were not disrupted in guanine nucleotide binding but were deficient in ribosome-dependent GTP hydrolysis and guanine nucleotide-dependent ribosome association. We propose that all of these mutations are present in a domain that is essential for ribosome association and that GTP hydrolysis was deficient as a secondary consequence of impaired binding to 70S ribosomes.

Substitution of aspartic acid-80, a residue involved in coordination of magnesium, weakens the GTP binding and strongly enhances the GTPase of the G domain of elongation factor Tu

The functional role of Asp80, a residue involved in the coordination of the Mg(2+).guanine nucleotide complex in elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu), has been investigated by its substitution with Asn in the isolated N-terminal domain (G domain). The G domain D80N is characterized by a strong decrease in binding affinity for GTP and magnesium, whereas the affinity for GDP is unchanged. This effect can be mimicked in wild-type G domain by the addition of EDTA. In contrast to this, EDTA does not essentially influence the selective effects of the mutation on the GTP and GDP binding of G domain D80N, indicating that the action of Asp80 is mainly mediated by the GTP-coordinated magnesium ion. The GTPase activity of the G domain D80N is very unstable, but can be markedly stabilized by the addition of glycerol without essentially modifying the specific effects of the mutation. In the absence of glycerol G domain D80N can express a short-lived GTPase activity. The presence of glycerol transforms this evanescent activity into a linear multiple-round activity that under optimal conditions can be almost 2 orders of magnitude higher than the GTPase of wild-type G domain. This enhanced catalytic activity represents the most striking consequence of the mutation and stresses the key role of Asp80 in the GTPase of EF-Tu.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Membrane-associated GTPases in bacteria

Members of the GTPase superfamily are extremely important in regulating membrane signalling pathways in all cells. This review focuses on membrane-associated GTPases that have been described in prokaryotes. In bacteria, LepA and NodQ are very similar to protein synthesis elongation factors but apparently have membrane-related functions. The amino acid sequences of FtsY and Ffh are clearly related to eukaryotic factors involved in protein secretion. Obg and Era are not closely related to any GTPase subgroup according to amino acid sequence comparisons, but they are essential for viability. In spite of similarities to well-studied eukaryotic proteins the signalling pathways of these cellular regulators, with the exception of NodQ, have not yet been elucidated.

GTPase domains of ras p21 oncogene protein and elongation factor Tu: analysis of three-dimensional structures, sequence families, and functional sites

GTPase domains are functional and structural units employed as molecular switches in a variety of important cellular functions, such as growth control, protein biosynthesis, and membrane traffic. Amino acid sequences of more than 100 members of different subfamilies are known, but crystal structures of only mammalian ras p21 and bacterial elongation factor Tu have been determined. After optimal superposition of these remarkably similar structures, careful multiple sequence alignment, and calculation of residue-residue interactions, we analyzed the two subfamilies in terms of structural conservation, sequence conservation, and residue contact strength. There are three main results. (i) A structure-based alignment of p21 and elongation factor Tu. (ii) The definition of a common conserved structural core that may be useful as the basis of model building by homology of the three-dimensional structure of any GTPase domain. (iii) Identification of sequence regions, other than the effector loop and the nucleotide binding site, that may be involved in the functional cycle: they are loop L4, known to change conformation after GTP hydrolysis; helix alpha 2, especially Arg-73 and Met-67 in ras p21; loops L8 and L10, including ras p21 Arg-123, Lys-147, and Leu-120; and residues located spatially near the N and C termini. These regions are candidate sites for interaction either with the GTP/GDP exchange factor, with a GTPase-affected function, or with a molecule delivered to a destination site with the aid of the GTPase domain.