Diagnostic errors after inferior petrosal sinus sampling

Although inferior petrosal sinus sampling (IPSS) is useful in the evaluation of Cushing's syndrome, false negative cases have been described, and many patients presumed to have ectopic tumors based upon negative IPSS remain without a final diagnosis. These patients are often managed as if they have as yet undiscovered ectopic tumors. To test this assumption, we conducted a retrospective review of our results to determine the ultimate diagnoses after IPSS. Between 1986 and 2002, 179 patients underwent 185 IPSS procedures as part of their evaluation for Cushing's syndrome. Confirmed diagnoses were available for 149 patients (83%): 139 patients had pituitary adenomas (94%), eight had bronchial carcinoids (5%), and two had adrenal tumors (1%). Threshold criteria for a pituitary source were defined as an inferior petrosal sinus to peripheral (IPS:P) basal ratio of 2:1 or greater without CRH or an IPS:P ratio of 3:1 or greater after CRH stimulation. There were nine patients in whom the IPS:P ratio failed to meet threshold criteria after successful sampling, but were nonetheless found to have pituitary tumors after transsphenoidal exploration (false negatives). Eight of these had received CRH and had a significant rise (>35%) in peripheral ACTH levels after CRH treatment, even though the IPS:P ratio did not reach the threshold. There were two patients in whom the IPS:P ratio reached threshold criteria, and ectopic tumors were demonstrated as the source of ACTH overproduction (false positives). The sensitivity after CRH stimulation was 90% (95% confidence interval, 80.8-95.5%) with a specificity of 67% (95% confidence interval, 11.4-94.5%). The positive and negative predictive values were 99 and 20%, respectively. Our data show that patients with an IPS:P ratio suggestive of a nonpituitary source of ACTH overproduction may still have Cushing's disease. Analyzing the CRH-stimulated peripheral ACTH levels in addition to the standard IPS:P ratios may provide improved diagnostic accuracy. Transsphenoidal exploration should be considered in all cases of unsuccessful sampling and in those cases for which no ectopic source can be identified after further body imaging, even if the IPSS is negative, and especially if peripheral ACTH levels rise significantly with CRH stimulation.

Jugular venous sampling: an alternative to petrosal sinus sampling for the diagnostic evaluation of adrenocorticotropic hormone-dependent Cushing's syndrome

Bilateral sampling of the inferior petrosal sinuses (IPSS) to distinguish Cushing's disease from the ectopic ACTH syndrome is accurate but risky and technically difficult. Bilateral sampling of the internal jugular vein (JVS) is simpler and presumably safer. To compare jugular and petrosal sinus venous sampling for distinguishing Cushing's disease from ectopic ACTH syndrome, we studied 74 patients with surgically proven Cushing's disease, 11 with surgically confirmed, and three with occult ectopic ACTH secretion. Patients underwent JVS and IPSS with administration of CRH on separate days. Ratios of central-to-peripheral ACTH in venous samples were calculated. At 100% specificity, IPSS correctly identified 61 of 65 patients with Cushing's disease [sensitivity, 94%; confidence interval (CI), 84-98%]. When patients with abnormal venous drainage were excluded, sensitivity was 98% (CI, 90-100%). JVS had a sensitivity of 83% (CI, 71-91%) at 100% specificity. Receiver operated characteristics plot areas under the curve were similar (0.968 +/- 0.020 and 0.974 +/- 0.016, area under the curve +/- se, JVS vs. IPSS). Although petrosal sampling had better diagnostic accuracy, CIs overlapped (95% CI, 90-100% vs. 86% CI, 78-94%). Centers with limited sampling experience may choose to use the simpler JVS and refer patients for IPSS when the results are negative.

Retrograde flow in the left inferior petrosal sinus and blood steal of the cavernous sinus associated with central vein stenosis: MR angiographic findings

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

We attempted to identify the cause of abnormal venous flow seen during arterial MR angiography in the inferior petrosal sinus by use of in three female patients (aged 51, 48, and 70 years, respectively).

METHODS

Arterial 3D time-of-flight MR angiography was performed with a tilted optimized nonsaturating excitation pulse sequence (TR/TE, 31/7; flip angle, 20 degrees; section thickness, 65 mm; effective thickness, 1 mm; number of sections, 1 to 2); no magnetization transfer pulse sequence was used. Contrast-enhanced 3D MR angiography of the neck was performed with a 3D fast low-angle shot pulse sequence (TR/TE, 4.6/1.8; flip angle, 40 to 45 degrees; section thickness, 80 mm; intersection gap, 1.5 mm; acquisition matrix, 180 x 256; acquisition time, 27 s) on a system with a whole-body coil.

RESULTS

In all three patients, 3D time-of-flight MR angiography revealed abnormal vascular signal originating from the left cavernous sinus, continuing through the inferior petrosal sinus, and ending in the proximal internal jugular vein at the jugular bulb level. Abnormal vascular signal at the jugular bulb, sluggish flow and flow-related enhancement in the left internal jugular vein, and signal void in the contralateral jugular vein were noted. Contrast-enhanced delayed-phase MR angiography showed stenosis in the left brachiocephalic vein in all patients.

CONCLUSION

High signal intensity noted at the inferior petrosal sinus resulted from retrograde flow. Retrograde flow was due to blood stealing from the internal jugular vein toward the cavernous sinus because of venous stenosis in the brachiocephalic vein.

Petrosal sinus sampling in the diagnosis of Cushing's syndrome: preliminary experience in University of Malaya Medical Centre

Differentiating between Cushing's disease of pituitary origin and ectopic ACTH syndrome of extra-pituitary origin remains a major challenge to the clinician because of limitations in the diagnostic accuracy of the high-dose dexamethasone suppression test. Routine use of inferior petrosal sinus sampling (IPSS) is therefore advocated by some authors for these patients. We present our preliminary experience of IPSS in 7 consecutive patients with Cushing's disease and discuss how the results impacted on the patients' management.

Usefulness of multiple-site venous sampling in the treatment of adrenocorticotropic hormone-producing pituitary adenomas

BACKGROUND

While venous sampling for adrenocorticotropic hormone (ACTH) may be the most accurate way to establish a diagnosis of Cushing's disease, its usefulness for lateralization of adenomas is limited even in combination with simultaneous bilateral sampling methods. Therefore, to increase accuracy in predicting the lateralization of adenomas, we performed a trial in which we carried out simultaneous venous sampling from multiple sites of the cavernous sinus (CS) and inferior petrosal sinus (IPS). Here we report on the usefulness of our method in the correct tumor lateralization in patients with Cushing's disease.

METHODS

Eighteen patients with Cushing's disease underwent simultaneous bilateral ACTH sampling. The samples were obtained from the anterior, middle, and posterior CS and the IPS. CS sampling after stimulation with corticotropin-releasing hormone (CRH) was also performed. The central-to-peripheral ACTH ratio (c/p ratio) was calculated using sampling data from each site; the lateralizing gradients (right versus left) were calculated using the c/p ratio. Instead of the conventional method where the lateralization gradient is based on sampling data from a single site, we used the distribution of the c/p ratio determined from multiple-site data.

RESULTS

There was no significant difference in the mean lateralization gradient obtained from each set of sampling data (p > 0.05). With the conventional method, correct tumor lateralization was obtained in 50% of tumors in the IPS; 72.2 to 77.8% of tumors in the CS; and 77.8% of tumors in the middle CS after CRH. Our method using ACTH contour analysis based on multiple sites produced correct results in all 18 of the patients examined. The difference in correct calls between the conventional method and our method was significant (p < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Multiple-site sampling of ACTH is valuable for lateralizing the adenoma in patients with Cushing's disease; it produces more correct results than does single venous sampling.

Selective venous sampling in diagnosing ACTH-dependent hypercortisolism

PURPOSE

To evaluate the sensitivity of selective sampling from the inferior petrosal sinuses in the differential diagnosis of ACTH-dependent hypercortisolism with non-diagnostic pituitary imaging.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Between 1987 and 2001, 17 patients (14 women and 3 men, aged 18-63 years) with ACTH-dependent hypercortisolism and negative X-ray of the sellar region, underwent simultaneous bilateral sampling from the inferior petrosal sinuses with ACTH measurement, at baseline and after stimulation with CRH (100 micro i.v.). Baseline samplings were also carried out at the level of the infrarenal and suprarenal inferior vena cava, of the adrenal and suprahepatic veins, of the superior vena cava, of the jugular veins, and of a peripheral vein. A central/peripheral gradient >2 at baseline and/or one >3 after stimulation with CRH was considered indicative of the pituitary origin of ACTH. Bilateral femoral venous catheterization was performed in an angiographic room using 5-French introducers after local anaesthesia. Selective catheterization of the inferior petrosal sinuses was achieved with 100 cm-long, steam-bent (45 degrees) 5-French catheters, without lateral holes.

RESULTS

Twelve patients exhibited ACTH central/ peripheral gradients indicating the pituitary origin of the hormonal hyperincretion; this was confirmed by surgical exploration of the hypophysis in 10 patients, whereas 2 refused surgery and were therefore "lost". Of the five patients without ACTH central/peripheral gradients, one had an adrenal metastasis from ACTH-secreting lung neoplasia (with ACTH gradient in the blood flowing back from the adrenal gland), one had a hepatic CRHoma (with high levels of CRH in the suprahepatic veins), whereas the origin of the hyperincretion remained indeterminate in three.

CONCLUSIONS

Bilateral simultaneous selective sampling from the inferior petrosal sinuses for ACTH measurements proved to be highly sensitive and free of complications in the differential diagnosis of ACTH-dependent forms of hypercortisolism.

Characterisation of ACTH related peptides in ectopic Cushing's syndrome

Adrenocorticotrophin (ACTH) is derived by cleavage from the precursor, pro-opiomelanocortin (POMC), and depending on the degree of processing by the tissue or tumor, there is the potential for a number of ACTH-related peptides to be secreted from POMC expressing cells. Previous chromatographic approaches have indicated the presence of high molecular weight forms of ACTH in the human peripheral circulation. However a quantitative assessment of the degree of processing requires two-site immunoradiometric assays which distinguish ACTH precursors and ACTH. Using this approach, we have previously identified the precursors of ACTH (POMC and proACTH) in the circulation of normal subjects in the range 5-40 pmol/l, which suggests that processing in the normal pituitary cell is incomplete. This study aimed to examine the extent of POMC processing by tumors that give rise to Cushing's Syndrome as a means of evaluating its usefulness as a diagnostic marker. In a retrospective analysis of 86 patients with Cushing's Syndrome, 34/35 patients with pituitary tumors had low levels of ACTH precursors (below 100 pmol/l) and the mean ratio of ACTH precursors:ACTH was 5:1 which indicates that these tumors do process POMC to ACTH relatively efficiently. In ectopic Cushing's Syndrome, it is unlikely that the extra-pituitary tumor cells, process POMC as efficiently. Therefore increased prevalence of ACTH precursors in the circulation would be expected and this was substantiated by the large excess of ACTH precursors (139-18,000 pmol/l) in the circulation of the 51 patients with the ectopic ACTH Syndrome. The diagnostic accuracy of the measurement of ACTH precursors was then prospectively compared with a group of 62 patients undergoing the current "gold standard" test of inferior petrosal sinus sampling (IPSS). All those patients with ACTH precursors below a diagnostic cut-off of 100 pmol/l were subsequently shown to have pituitary tumors, whereas levels of >100 pmol/l were seen in the four patients with ectopic tumors. In comparison the IPSS had a specificity of 100% but a sensitivity of 93% and for these false negative results the ACTH precursors proved diagnostically useful. Therefore measurement of ACTH precursors offers a simple non-invasive diagnostic test for the differential diagnosis of Cushing's Syndrome which compares favourably with IPSS.

Dynamic tests in the diagnosis and differential diagnosis of Cushing's syndrome

Cushing's syndrome is an uncommon disorder, but one that often presents diagnostic challenges to the managing physician. Since the 1960's, dynamic tests have been a mainstay of the investigation of this disorder, both to make the diagnosis and then to identify the cause. It is in this latter role that these tests provide the greatest results, particularly in cases of ACTH-dependent disease, where defining the source accurately allows targeted surgery to the pituitary or ectopic lesions. It can, however, be a confusing area, as multiple protocols, and therefore cut-off criteria, often exist for each test, and some tests are now largely redundant. Therefore, in this article we discuss the physiological basis behind each dynamic test, review the different protocols and criteria that have been utilized, and assess how they perform. It will become clear that no single dynamic test used in this condition is 100% reliable for either the diagnosis or differential diagnosis, but the combination of test results, together with the knowledge of an endocrinologist experienced in such cases, provides the best means of correctly assessing patients with Cushing's syndrome.

Accuracy of bilateral inferior petrosal or cavernous sinuses sampling in predicting the lateralization of Cushing's disease pituitary microadenoma: influence of catheter position and anatomy of venous drainage

Bilateral inferior petrosal sinus sampling (BIPSS) is the most reliable procedure for distinguishing Cushing's disease from ectopic ACTH secretion. However, it is less reliable at predicting the lateralization of the pituitary corticotroph microadenoma. We sought to determine whether this could be improved by taking into account the pattern of venous drainage and the precise location of the catheters. We retrospectively studied data from 86 patients who underwent BIPSS. Cushing's disease was predicted in 74 patients, of whom 69 underwent transsphenoidal surgery. Surgical cure was obtained in 65 patients, with identification of a corticotroph microadenoma in 58 cases. In 49 patients the location of the microadenoma predicted by the intersinus ACTH gradient could be compared with the pathologist's data. BIPSS accurately predicted the lateralization of the microadenoma in only 57% of these patients. Prediction was improved to 71% when both venograms and catheters were symmetric (35 patients). In this subgroup accuracy was 86% in patients with both catheters in the inferior petrosal sinuses compared with 50% in patients with both catheters in the cavernous sinuses (CS). Two transient sixth nerve palsies occurred during CS catheterization. Our data suggest that BIPSS results are much improved when venous drainage is symmetric. Catheterization of CS did not improve the results and was less safe.

Central ghrelin production does not substantially contribute to systemic ghrelin concentrations: a study in two subjects with active acromegaly

INTRODUCTION

In an animal model of acromegaly (PEPCK-hGH transgenic mice), low systemic levels of ghrelin have been observed compared with normal mice. We hypothesized that systemic circulating ghrelin levels are also decreased in humans with active acromegaly and that the contribution of central ghrelin production to systemic ghrelin levels is minimal.

OBJECTIVES

The aim of the present study was to investigate, in two subjects with active acromegaly, whether there are differences between systemic ghrelin levels and ghrelin concentrations in the petrosal sinus.

DESIGN

We measured systemic and central ghrelin levels in these two acromegalic patients by bilateral simultaneous inferior petrosal sinus sampling. Central and systemic blood samples were drawn before and 1, 5, 10, 15 and 20 min after stimulation with GH-releasing hormone (GHRH). Ghrelin was measured with a commercially available radioimmunoassay.

RESULTS

In one acromegalic subject, the baseline systemic and central ghrelin levels were within the same range as in two non-acromegalic obese subjects. No gradient could be observed between central and systemic ghrelin concentrations. Stimulation with GHRH did not change the ghrelin concentrations in this patient. In the other acromegalic subject, the systemic ghrelin levels were also in the same range as in two non-acromegalic obese subjects. However, in this subject, baseline ghrelin concentrations in the right inferior petrosal vein were considerably lower than the systemic ghrelin concentrations, indicating a peripheral over central gradient. Administration of GHRH induced a significant rise in central ghrelin concentrations in the right inferior petrosal vein. Ghrelin levels in the left inferior petrosal vein and systemic ghrelin levels were in the normal range and GHRH stimulation did not change these concentrations.

CONCLUSIONS

The absence of a central over peripheral ghrelin gradient in these two acromegalics indicated that circulating ghrelin is mainly produced peripherally. Circulating systemic ghrelin levels were not decreased in these two subjects with active acromegaly.

Biochemical and imaging evaluation of Cushing's syndrome

The diagnosis and differential diagnosis of Cushing's syndrome remains a considerable challenge in clinical endocrinology. Investigation is a two-step process, involving first diagnosis followed by differential diagnosis. Traditionally diagnosis has relied upon urinary free cortisol (UFC) collection, low-dose dexamethasone-testing, and assessment of midnight cortisol. More recently, differentiation between mild disease and pseudo-Cushing's states has been achieved using dexamethasone-suppressed corticotropin releasing hormone (CRH) and desmopressin tests. Refinements of tests used for differential diagnosis have been made including optimized response criteria for ovine and human sequence CRH tests, desmopressin tests, GHBP-testing and testing with combinations of peptides. Despite improvements in these non-invasive tests use of inferior petrosal or cavernous sinus sampling is frequently required. Imaging is guided by biochemical assessment. MRI is the investigation of choice for Cushing's disease, but is often negative. Scintigraphic investigation using radionucleotide-labeled agonists for receptors commonly expressed by neuroendocrine tumors the investigation of occult ACTH-dependent disease remains disappointing. In this review we critically analyze the tests used for this most challenging of clinical conditions.

[Differential diagnosis and medical treatment in Cushing's disease]

Cushing's disease remains a difficult diagnosis in spite of new technical procedures such as pituitary MRI, selective bilateral petrosal or cavernous sampling, (111)In pentreotide scan and 18 Flurodeoxyglucose pituitary PET scan. In this article, we review biological diagnostic procedures of Cushing's disease and corticotroph adenomas. According to our experience and the literature, we summarize the approach in medical treatment of Cushing's disease.

[Technical aspects and surgical strategy for removal of corticotroph pituitary adenoma]

The development of transsphenoidal microsurgery and the refinement of endocrinological and radiological diagnostic procedures have afforded therapeutic options appropriate for each individual case in patients with pituitary-dependent hypercortisolism. Compared with other secreting pituitary tumors, the corticotroph adenoma seems to be the most biologically active tumor. Clinical evidence of hypercortisolism mainly occurs at an early stage of tumor growth when the tumor is very small, below the detection threshold of modern imaging techniques. While the treatment of large tumors remains difficult due to the non-discrete boundary lines of the tumor and extension or invasion, surgical removal of very tiny tumors requires reliable preoperative or peroperative identification in order to achieve total tumor resection for clinical remission and pituitary preservation to prevent hypopituitarism. We reviewed all the current surgical techniques or clever surgical procedures used to achieve both goals with the lowest complication rate. We report here the state-of-the-art of surgical management of corticotroph pituitary adenoma focusing on preoperative radiological and biological data required for performing guided intrasellar surgical exploration and reliable tumor identification. Different technical aspects of the nasosphenoidal approaches are reported as well as the modified transdiaphragmatic or transtubercular transcisternal approaches to tumors in a suprasellar localization or lying along the pituitary stalk. The advantages of minimally invasive surgical techniques such as intrasellar endoscopic surgery are discussed. Adapted surgical techniques for second transnasal surgery indicated for recurrent tumors are described. Guidelines are given for peroperative tumor identification with macroscopic assessment or histological control with frozen section biopsies. Different techniques for tumor removal are discussed from selective microadenomectomy to enlarged pituitary resection and total hypophysectomy. Methods for preoperative guidance of total tumor removal are proposed including histological or biological assessment of normal adjacent pituitary tissue. the strategy of surgical intrasellar exploration and tumor resection is outlined using a set of algorithms. The first is devoted to positive preoperative documentation of the tumor. The second is proposed for the surgical scenario where there is no preoperative MRI evidence of the tumor. Special strategies are discussed for ectopic adenoma or multiple tumors. Revision surgical management after surgical failure or tumor recurrence is described. Special guidelines for surgical treatment of large clinically silent corticotroph macroadenomas are given with emphasis on the high risk of recurrence in comparison with other silent pituitary tumors such as gonadotroph or immunonegative adenomas.

[Role of perioperative biological tests during the performance and follow-up of corticotroph adenoma exeresis]

ACTH assay in cavernous sinus samples during resection of pituitary adrenocorticotroph adenomas is a simple and safe technique providing an intraoperative assessment of adrenocorticotroph hormone gradients. Bilateral puncture of the cavernous sinus can be achieved vial the standard transsphenoidal approach to the sella turcica. ACTH is determined with IRMA at 37;C with an incubation time of less than one hour. Among 71 cases in our experience, the ACTH gradient accurately predicted the position of the adenoma in 93% of the cases. This rate is higher than the 61% accuracy reported for inferior petrosal sinus sampling. The technique reported is more precise than MRI which correctly identifies adenomas in only 50% of the cases. The remaining cases are either false positives or false negatives. We report an 82% cure rate either via direct resection of the microadenoma or via partial hypophysectomy guided by the ACTH gradient. In our series, 20 cases of Cushing's disease had a normal MRI and no surgically identifiable adenoma. In 10 of these cases however, cure was achieved by performing ACTH gradient guided partial hypophysectomy. This method produces no morbidity and is most helpful for the neurosurgeon allowing confirmation of the position of an MRI-visible adenoma or an adenoma identified intraoperatively. It does not however replace neurosurgical experience which remains the most important predictive factor for outcome in surgical treatment of Cushing's disease.

[Indications for total hypophysectomy in Cushing's disease]

OBJECTIVE

Transsphenoidal selective adenomectomy is the treatment of choice for Cushing's disease. In some patients, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) fails to detect small pituitary ACTH-secreting adenomas. Total hypophysectomy can be performed when MRI appears normal. The aim of this paper is to study results and complications after total hypophysectomy for Cushing's disease.

METHODS

Between July 1988 and May 1999, 49 patients underwent transsphenoidal surgery for Cushing's disease at our institution. The criteria for inclusion in this study were clinical and biochemical studies strongly suggestive of Cushing's disease with normal MRI. Total hypophysectomy was performed in 7 patients who fulfilled these criteria. Their results were analyzed retrospectively.

RESULTS

The average age of the patients was 43 years; there were 7 women. Five adrenocorticotrophic hormone-secreting adenomas were proven histologically. Complications occurred in 6 patients (cerebrospinal fluid fistulas in 6 patients, loss of vision in 1 patient, meningitis in 5 patients, anterior pituitary insufficiency in 5 patients, diabetes insipidus in 5 patients). Six patients had sustained remission 36 months after surgery.

CONCLUSION

Total hypophysectomy can be perform ed for Cushing's disease with normal MRI. Complications occurs frequently, especially cerebrospinal fluid fistulas. Inferior petrosal sinus sampling can be helpful in localizing the adenoma allowing hemihypophysectomy and thus reduced morbidity.

Aberrant inferior petrosal sinus: unusual transvenous approach to the cavernous sinus

Two patients with vascular lesions of the cavernous sinus (CS) undergoing endovascular management are reported. During transvenous embolization an unusually low termination of the inferior petrosal sinus (IPS) was observed. In both patients, we were able to catheterize the CS using this aberrant venous route. Knowledge of this variant can be crucial for a successful transvenous approach and treatment of vascular lesions involving the cavernous sinus.

[Multihormonal bilateral petrosal sinus sampling in Cushing's disease: radiological, surgical and pathological correlations]

Multihormonal bilateral petrosal sinus sampling (BPSS) has been proposed to improve corticotroph microadenomas prediction of lateralisation. Few series have simultaneously compared data of pituitary MRI, surgical findings and multihormonal BPSS. Seven patients (6F/1M) with Cushing's disease, mean age at diagnosis of 35 years (range 24-55) were prospectively studied to compare radiological and multihormonal BPSS data with surgical and pathological findings. In untreated patients, simultaneous measures of ACTH, TSH and prolactine (PRL) were done at time 0, 7, 15, 22 minutes after CRH (500 microgram) and TRH (200 microgram) stimulation. An intersinus gradient of 1.4 was considered as a lateralisation. All microadenomas were identified during surgery, diameters ranged from 2 to 7 mm. All patients were in long-term surgical remission. Pathological studies confirmed a tumoral tissue with ACTH immunostaining in 6/7 cases and PRL in 3/7 cases. Pituitary MRI correctly identified tumors in 4 cases, the remaining tumors were not seen. Basal and stimulated intersinus gradients of ACTH, TSH and PRL were homolateral in 6/7 cases and were coincident with surgical findings in 4/7 cases. The other three cases were contralateral to MRI and surgical data. In conclusion, simultaneous gradient of ACTH, PRL and TSH did not improve lateralisation prediction in this series. Hormonal hypersecretion was homolateral in six cases whereas pathological studies demonstrated a mixed secretion in only three cases. A preferential pituitary draining could explain these discordances. Data from our series and from others (done with CRH stimulation and ACTH-PRL measures) strongly suggest a paracrine interaction between tumoral and normal pituitary tissue.

Undetectable postoperative cortisol does not always predict long-term remission in Cushing's disease: a single centre audit

OBJECTIVE

An undetectable postoperative serum cortisol has been regarded as a definition of cure in Cushing's disease. However, we noted disease recurrence amongst patients with Cushing's disease despite undetectable postoperative cortisol levels, and this led us to audit our data. We have also previously assessed surgical outcome for acromegaly and microprolactinoma for a single surgeon. The aims of this study were two-fold: (i) to investigate the treatment and surgical outcome of patients with Cushing's disease. In particular, we wished to compare the data with outcome for other pituitary tumours in our centre; and (ii) to determine whether undetectable cortisol following surgery is predictive of long-term cure for Cushing's disease.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

We performed a retrospective audit of 97 patients; mean age 39.1 (range: 14-82) years, 78/97 (80.4%) female, mean follow-up 92 months (range: 6 months to 29 years), with Cushing's disease seen in our unit between 1969 and 1998. We documented diagnostic investigation, immediate surgical outcome and disease recurrence in these patients.

RESULTS

All patients had elevated urinary free cortisol (mean 1270.6 nmol/l, range: 327-3245 nmol/l). In total, 95.5% of patients did not suppress with low-dose dexamethasone suppression testing. Hypokalaemia (K < 3.2 mmol/l) was present in 15.6% of patients; 17.5% of patients did not show cortisol suppression with high-dose dexamethasone and 15.8% of patients did not show an ACTH rise of > 50% following corticotrophic releasing hormone (CRH) administration. There was no significant (> 3) gradient in ACTH or cortisol following CRH during inferior petrosal sinus sampling in 27.3% of patients who had the test. A pituitary tumour was demonstrated on imaging in 55.8% of patients; 10.3% were macroadenomas. Mortality rate following trans-sphenoidal surgery was 1%. Following surgery, the immediate postoperative remission rate (undetectable postoperative cortisol) was 68.5%. However, 11.5% of these patients developed disease recurrence during a mean follow-up period of 36.3 months. Considering microadenomas, Cushing's disease patients had an immediate postoperative remission rate of 63.2% which is significantly lower (P < 0.05) compared to a remission rate of 91.1% in acromegaly. Additionally, new postoperative gonadotrophin deficiency (13.9%) and TSH deficiency (25.8%) was higher in patients with Cushing's disease compared to patients with acromegaly or microprolactinoma. Immediate postoperative remission rates improved from 50% in the first decade of a surgeon's career to consistently above 60% in the second and third decades, demonstrating a trend which may be attributed to surgical experience.

CONCLUSIONS

(i) Despite strict criteria for immediate postoperative remission and recurrence, undetectable postoperative cortisol is not always predictive of long-term remission. (ii) Despite an aggressive surgical approach, immediate postoperative remission rates for Cushing's disease are lower compared to other microadenomas. The development of new pituitary hormonal deficiency following surgery is also commoner than that seen amongst other microadenomas. These data have important implications for the follow-up of patients with Cushing's disease.

Relative contributions of inferior petrosal sinus sampling and pituitary imaging in the investigation of children and adolescents with ACTH-dependent Cushing's syndrome

Selective transsphenoidal microadenomectomy is the first line treatment of childhood Cushing's disease, with accurate preoperative localization of the corticotroph adenoma an important step in its investigation. Inferior petrosal sinus sampling (IPSS) for ACTH after CRH stimulation is a recognized investigation in adults, but there are few data in the pediatric age range. We report the relative contributions of IPSS and pituitary imaging in 11 patients, aged 10.7-18.8 yr, presenting with Cushing's disease. All underwent transsphenoidal surgery (TSS). IPSS was performed without complication. Sampling was from the inferior petrosal sinuses in 7 patients and the high jugular veins in 4 (patients 2, 4, 5, and 10). The central to peripheral ACTH (IPS/P) ratios were more than 2 (2.5-157.2) in 10 of 11 patients, confirming central ACTH secretion. In 3 patients with high jugular sampling, IPS/P ratio ranged from 2.5-21.1. In the fourth patient with high jugular sampling (IPS/P ratio, 0.95), a central adenoma was identified surgically, and the patient was cured after TSS. The interpetrosal sinus ACTH gradient (IPSG) was more than 1.4 (2.1-20.8) in 10 patients, indicating lateralization of ACTH secretion to the right side in 6 patients and to the left in 4. IPSG ratios were 2.1-8.5 in 3 patients with high jugular sampling. Pituitary imaging (computed tomography and or magnetic resonance imaging) was reported to identify an adenoma in 5 of 11 patients. At operation a tumor was visualized by the same surgeon in all 11 cases. In 9 patients with lateralization on IPSS, the correct side of the tumor was confirmed at surgery. In a 10th patient with a negative IPSG, a central tumor was present. Thus, IPSS gave a 91% prediction of correct tumor localization. In only 1 of 5 patients with an adenoma reported on pituitary imaging was this localization confirmed at surgery, a prediction rate of only 9%. After TSS, 8 patients were cured, 1 was in remission, and 2 required pituitary irradiation. In 73% of patients undergoing IPSS, localization of the adenoma was followed by surgical cure or remission. Pituitary scanning was therefore relatively unhelpful in localizing the adenoma. In experienced hands, however, IPSS was feasible in this age group, safe, and strongly predictive of the site of the adenoma, leading to a high rate of successful surgical outcome.

[Importance of the CRH (corticotropin releasing hormone) test in the differential diagnosis of Cushing's syndrome]

In the group of 13 patients with Cushing's syndrome (CS) CRH test was performed by sampling the blood from peripheral vein and in eight patients also after inferior petrosal sinus catheterization (IPSC) to resolve the disease etiology. In the group of patients with Cushing's disease (CD, n = 11), which was proven by surgery and adenoma immunohistochemistry, 10/11 had in CRH test the significant increase of cortisol and ACTH in the peripheral blood. Among two patients with ectopic ACTH syndrome one had the significant increase of both hormones in CRH test. After IPSC the ratio of ACTH in the petrosal sinus and in the peripheral vein was significant in 4/8 patients before, and in 6/8 after CRH administration. The intersinus gradient was significant in 3/8 patients before, and in 4/8 after CRH test. According to our results we can conclude that the determination of ACTH in the blood from peripheral veins after CRH administration is a very sensitive method for differential diagnosis of CS, while the results after IPSC were less sensitive in our conditions than those described in the literature.

Involvement of the cholinergic pathway in the pathogenesis of pituitary Cushing's syndrome

Transsphenoidal adenomectomy is currently the first choice for treatment of patients with pituitary ACTH-dependent Cushing's syndrome. However, pharmacotherapy is prescribed for some patients, e.g., unsuccessful surgery. We treated a woman in whom pituitary Cushing's syndrome was improved while she was on antimuscarinic cholinergic agents, atropine sulphate and pirenzepine hydrochloride. The diminished effect of anticholinergics on ACTH and cortisol was incidentally identified in an inferior petrosal sinus sampling procedure. A single intramuscular injection of atropine significantly decreased both ACTH (43.9 pg/ml to less than 12.0; normal, 12.0-40.0 pg/ml) and cortisol (29.9 microg/dl to 13.6; normal, 7.6-23.6 microg/dl). An M1-muscarinic receptor specific antagonist, pirenzepine hydrochloride, also had a diminishing effect on these hormones and this inhibiting effect was partially blocked by the simultaneous administration of an anticholinesterase agent, pyridostigmine bromide. Chronic oral ingestion of these agents led to improvement in clinical symptoms, and urinary 17-hydroxycorticosteroid and 17-ketosteroid levels were at normal to upper-normal levels. This is the first documentation of involvement of the cholinergic system in the pathogenesis of pituitary Cushing's syndrome.

Inferior petrosal sinus sampling in the differential diagnosis of Cushing's syndrome: results of an Italian multicenter study

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of inferior petrosal sinus sampling (IPSS) in the differential diagnosis of ACTH-dependent Cushing's syndrome as compared with pituitary imaging techniques.

DESIGN AND METHODS

We retrospectively studied the diagnostic accuracy of basal and post corticotropin-releasing hormone (CRH) IPSS, magnetic resonance imaging and computed tomography in distinguishing pituitary from ectopic ACTH secretion in 97 Cushing's syndrome patients: 74 with Cushing's disease (CD) and 10 with ectopic ACTH secretion (EAS). Thirteen patients were excluded because of unconfirmed diagnosis. The difference between IPSS and pituitary imaging techniques in the correctly localized pituitary adenoma in the patients with CD was also investigated.

RESULTS

The basal ACTH inferior petrosal sinus:periphery (IPS:P) ratio was > or = 2 in 63/74 patients with CD (85%), and in 1/10 EAS patients (10%); after stimulation with CRH, the ratio was > or = 3 in 60/68 patients with CD (88%) and < 3 in all patients with EAS. The basal and post-CRH ACTH IPS:P ratios had a diagnostic accuracy of 86% and 90% respectively. The diagnostic accuracy of IPSS with both ratios was significantly higher than magnetic resonance imaging (50%) and computed tomography (40%). The IPS:P ratio suggested by receiver-operator characteristic (ROC) analysis that better distinguished CD from EAS was 2.10 for the basal and 2.15 for the post-CRH ratios. Using these cut-offs, the specificity of basal ratio and the sensitivity of the post-CRH test rose to 100% and 93% respectively. Diagnostic accuracy remained substantially unchanged for the basal ratio (87% vs 86%), while it rose from 90% to 94% for the post-CRH ratio. The sensitivity of IPSS was significantly higher than that of magnetic resonance and computerized tomography. IPSS was less reliable in identifying the adenoma site found at surgery than magnetic resonance imaging or computed tomography (65% vs 75% and 79% respectively).

CONCLUSION

In conclusion, IPSS improved the diagnostic performance of imaging techniques. It can help in excluding transsphenoidal surgery in EAS patients. More striking results were obtained when a > or = 2.1:1 basal ratio or a > or = 2.15:1 post-CRH ratio were considered as criteria to distinguish between patients with CD and EAS. To establish correctly the location of the pituitary adenoma, IPSS is less reliable than imaging techniques.

Elevated inferior petrosal sinus levels of PTHrP in a patient with Cushing's disease

PTHrP has been found in various tissues, including prolactinomas and growth hormone producing adenomas. The function and clinical importance of PTHrP are poorly understood. We report the case of a 25-year-old female patient with hirsutism. Autonomous ACTH-dependent hypercortisolism was documented by endocrine testing. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) revealed a 3-mm intrasellar hypointense lesion in the left side of the pituitary gland. The inferior petrosal sinus sampling disclosed a gradient of ACTH left central/peripheral of 30.5 and right central/peripheral of 2.0 and suggested the diagnosis of a left-sided pituitary ACTH secreting microadenoma. Interestingly, we found elevated PTHrP levels in the left inferior petrosal sinus with a gradient of 4.7 compared to peripheral venous blood and of 3.6 compared to the right sinus. Our results fit very well to the concept of a para-/autocrine secretion of PTHrP which has been proposed recently and suggest a role in the regulation of cell growth of pituitary adenomas.

The differential diagnosis of Cushing's syndrome

The diagnosis of Cushing's syndrome remains one of the most challenging tasks in clinical neuroendocrinology. The diagnostic procedure can be divided into two distinct steps: diagnosis of the neuroendocrine disorder and differential diagnosis of the precise aetiology. The goal of the first laboratory tests is to obtain biochemical proof of Cushing's syndrome. Patients with Cushing's syndrome are relatively insensitive to glucocorticoid feedback and exhibit an oversecretion of cortisol devoid of a circadian cycle. In our experience, a low-dose dexamethasone suppression test provides the most reliable confirmation of steroid resistance, a cortisol level of<50 nmol/l at 9 a.m. having 98% sensitivity. A cortisol level below 50 nmol/l at midnight rules out active Cushing's syndrome with, in our experience, 100% sensitivity and a specificity depending on numerous other variables. A very high level of free urinary corticol can be a useful sign. After having established the diagnosis of Cushing's syndrome, a persistently low level of ACTH (<10 pg/ml), or preferentially an undetectable level unresponsive to CRH (100 microgram iv), is suggestive of an ACTH-independent disorder, and consequently of primary adrenal disease. The precise location of the lesion can identified with CT or MRI imaging, generally prior to surgical cure. If the ACTH level is detectable, patients with pituitary Cushing's syndrome, or Cushing's disease, should be differentiated from those with ectopic ACTH secretion. The secreting tumour may be difficult to localise and diagnosis is never 100% sure with dynamic tests. Catheterisation of the petrosal sinus with CRH stimulation provides the best sensitivity for differentiating the two aetiologies. We consider a central to peripheral gradient of>3 to confirm the pituitary origin of the disorder with a 98% sensitivity. Chest or abdominal CT can be helpful to identify an ectopic tumour but very small tumours may go undetected. MRI can detect 60 or 70% of all pituitary adenomas but is virtually non-contributive to the diagnosis of Cushing's disease in children.