Promoting healthy exercise among older people in general practice: issues in designing and evaluating therapeutic interventions

The potential health benefits derived from sustained physical activity in older people are numerous; however, whether exercise promotion should take place in general practice is unsubstantiated. Exercise promotion should use existing research evidence of the advantages of exercise for various conditions, and target those inactive individuals who currently have no intention of changing their level of physical activity. Research has also raised methodological issues and questions about the feasibility of exercise interventions which still need to be tested in exercise trials conducted in general practice.

The modernisation of general practice in the UK: 1980 to 1995 and beyond. Part I

The UK is unusual in providing universal free healthcare in which access to specialists is largely controlled by general practitioners with 24-hour responsibility, throughout the year, for a defined list of patients of all ages. It is generally considered that this gatekeeper function has contributed to the relatively low cost of the National Health Service, but major changes in the organisation and clinical role of general practitioners have occurred, culminating in a new contract that aims to re-orientate general practice towards health promotion, disease prevention and the management of chronic disease. The implications of these changes are discussed.

A prototype computer decision support system for the management of asthma

Asthma is a chronic disease estimated to affect 6-7% of the total UK population. In addition, a number of studies have shown that asthma has become commoner since the 1970s, especially in children. The diagnosis of asthma can be difficult and its management requires the involvement of patients in a long-term treatment plan, something which general practitioners may be unable to achieve easily in the average 10-min consultation. As a consequence, asthma is underdiagnosed and undertreated. Deaths from the disease are often avoidable with timely and sufficient use of the available medication. In order to support this, the British Thoracic Society (BTS) has published guidelines for asthma management based upon a stepwise approach, in which a patient is categorized as being on one of five steps according to the severity of his or her asthma. The guidelines give "rules of thumb" for deciding when the patient should move up or down the steps. The most recent version of the guidelines also included special rules for children. Within a recent European Community project on Advanced Informatics in Medicine (AIM), we developed a prototype decision support system for asthma management targeted at the primary care setting and based on the British Thoracic Society guidelines. This paper reports this development, and describes the further work needed on the prototype. Plans for evaluation of the knowledge bases and for future full application production are also described.

Home nebuliser-compressors

Home nebuliser therapy requires sensible supervision to ensure that the nebuliser and the compressor are well matched and that both are in good condition. It can then be acceptable and helpful to appropriately selected patients.

From guidelines to decision support in the management of asthma

Asthma is a common chronic disease of the lungs caused by inflammation of the airways affecting 6-7% of the population. Asthma is becoming commoner and there is evidence of under-diagnosis and poor management. Guidelines have been developed aimed at improving quality of care and in reducing social costs of asthma. The paper discusses an approach to implementing guidelines through decision-support system in primary care, based on methods developed in the AIM GAMES-II project. We also describe a prototype system that has been developed and a programme of clinical evaluation.

Evaluation of the use of brief screening instruments for dementia, depression and problem drinking among elderly people in general practice

BACKGROUND

Use of brief screening instruments for detection of psychological morbidity among elderly people is being promoted, although the appropriateness and effectiveness of available instruments have not been evaluated in general practice.

AIM

This study set out to determine the outcome of opportunistic use of brief screening instruments for dementia, depression and problem drinking in randomized trials in two group practices in north west London.

METHOD

Screening instruments were inserted into a random sample of medical records for people aged 75 years and over in each practice. Medical records of those seen by their general practitioners over a six month period were reviewed for new diagnoses of dementia (or confusion), depression or problem drinking, and the scores obtained on screening instruments noted. The records of all those identified as possibly demented, depressed or drinking heavily were reviewed one year after screening and all relevant referrals and new treatments were noted.

RESULTS

In one practice use of screening instruments resulted in a significant increase in the detection of possible dementia, but not of depression. In the second practice screening instruments yielded significantly higher numbers with possible dementia or depression. Heavy drinking was uncommon in either population. There was no difference in the proportions of cases identified by screening instrument or by clinical judgement alone who received treatment or referral.

CONCLUSION

These results suggest that in the absence of agreed guidelines and resources, information derived from screening instruments may not alter clinical practice.

Beyond ‘Clinical’?: Four-Dimensional Medical Education

Medical education is in crisis. Undergraduates experience an excessive burden of information, develop attitudes to learning that are based on passive acquisition of knowledge than on curiosity and exploration, and suffer from progressive disenchantment with medicine. There is also a serious problem of providing adequate clinical experience for medical students at existing teaching sites, largely because of reduction in bed numbers, increased patient throughput and clinical specialization. This problem was identified over a decade ago in London but has not been solved by the merger of medical schools. A recent survey in one London teaching hospital showed underemployment of students and limited patient contact. A review of clinical clerkships in an Australian medical school revealed that one-third of teachers were perceived as unconcerned, discouraging, derogatory or hostile, and only one-half were rated as effective educators. One consequence has been the development of a wide-ranging debate on changing medical education. Traditionalists have diminishing room for manoeuvre in defence of existing educational practices, as cautious bodies like the General Medical Council (GMC) opt for fundamental reform.

Assessment of elderly people in general practice. 4. Depression, functional ability and contact with services

The aim of this study was to look at the interrelationship between depression, physical disability and contact with services. In a random sample of 239 people aged 75 years and over from nine general practices in north London, depression (as measured by a shortened version of the comprehensive assessment and referral evaluation schedule) was found to be significantly associated with being a woman, and inability to perform a number of activities of daily living. Consumption of three or more prescribed medicines, a home visit by the general practitioner in the previous three months and contact with health visitors and home helps were all significantly more likely among depressed patients. There were also significant associations between loss of functional abilities, measured using items from an activities of daily living scale, and use of certain services: general practitioner home visits and reduced mobility indoors and both home help and district nurse visits to those with difficulty in bathing. Multiple logistic regression analysis suggested that contact with services was principally associated with loss of mobility, although contact with home helps was independently associated with depression, when adjustment was made for functional impairment.