The biological effects of allogeneic effect factor (AEF) on T lymphocytes. III.--Interferon does not contribute to the biological activities displayed by AEF on both T and B lymphocytes

The studies reported here were designed to evaluate the potential contribution of interferon (IF) to the biological activities mediated by allogeneic effect factor (AEF), a soluble product of allogeneic cell interactions, on responses of T and B lymphocytes. AEF supernatants were found to contain varying levels of IF, predominantly of type II (immune). AEF preparations which were practically free of--or very low in--IF activity were obtained by bovine serum albumin-Sepharose chromatography of AEF, or by using strain combinations involving K-only or I-only differences within the H-2 complex for the production of AEF. Such preparations retained their biological activities in three in vitro assays characteristic of AEF: (a) induction of primary self-H-2-reactive cytotoxic T-lymphocyte responses, (b) mitogenicity for normal T cells, and (c) induction of plaque-forming cell antibody responses to a T-dependent antigen in T-cell-depleted spleen cultures. These results demonstrate that IF does not play any significant role in the biological activities medicated by AEF.

The biologic effects of allogeneic effect factor on T lymphocytes. I. The mitogenic activity and the autonomous induction of cytotoxic T lymphocytes by AEF

Studies presented herein illustrate the capacity of the soluble mediator, allogeneic effect factor (AEF), which is derived from histoincompatible cell interactions, to induce the in vitro differentiation of normal murine splenic lymphocytes into mature cytotoxic cells capable of exerting activity on H-2-identical target cells. This process requires the presence of T lymphocytes during the sensitization phase, and the lytic activity on tumor cells is mediated by cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL). The capacity of AEF to induce differentiation of such CTL does not require the presence of stimulating target cells in the sensitization phase. The induction of CTL requires the presence of AEF at the initiation of culture, although exposure to AEF as brief as 1 hr is sufficient to induce fresh spleen cells to differentiate into CTL during the subsequent 5 days in culture. In addition to its ability to induce CTL, AEF is highly mitogenic for T lymphocytes. However, the mitogenic and the CTL-inducing activities of AEF can be experimentally dissociated, indicating that different subpopulations of T lymphocytes may be involved in the response to AEF. In contrast to similar soluble helper factors derived from allogeneic cell interactions, AEF appears to be unique in its ability to autonomously induce a primary CTL response in vitro.

Promotion of hematopoietic stem cell differentiation in vitro by a soluble mediator, allogeneic effect factor

This study was designed to investigate the effects of allogenic effect factor (AEF), a soluble mediator derived from short-term mixed lymphocyte cultures (MLC) of in vitro alloantigen-primed T cells, on cultures of murine bone marrow cells. Cultures established under suboptimal conditions namely, in the absence of a pre-established adherent cell layer as required in conventional Dexter-type cultures--declined and lost their stem cell activity rapidly. In contrast, supplementation of these cultures, at initiation and thereafter, with AEF, but not with T cell growth factor (TCGF), induced cell growth and proliferation for several weeks. Such AEF-supplemented cultures exhibited cellular heterogeneity and stem cell activity for significantly longer periods than the control cultures. Even in conventional Dexter cultures, established under optimal conditions, AEF had a beneficial effect on cellular growth and proliferation and myeloid progenitor cell (CFU-C) activity. Furthermore, cell capable of synergizing with suboptimal numbers of mature T cells in con A-induced mitogenic responses, shown by others to be pre-T cells, were detected in the AEF-supplemented cultures for several weeks.

The biologic effects of allogeneic effect factor on T lymphocytes. I. The mitogenic activity and the autonomous induction of cytotoxic T lymphocytes by AEF

Studies presented herein illustrate the capacity of the soluble mediator, allogeneic effect factor (AEF), which is derived from histoincompatible cell interactions, to induce the in vitro differentiation of normal murine splenic lymphocytes into mature cytotoxic cells capable of exerting activity on H-2-identical target cells. This process requires the presence of T lymphocytes during the sensitization phase, and the lytic activity on tumor cells is mediated by cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL). The capacity of AEF to induce differentiation of such CTL does not require the presence of stimulating target cells in the sensitization phase. The induction of CTL requires the presence of AEF at the initiation of culture, although exposure to AEF as brief as 1 hr is sufficient to induce fresh spleen cells to differentiate into CTL during the subsequent 5 days in culture. In addition to its ability to induce CTL, AEF is highly mitogenic for T lymphocytes. However, the mitogenic and the CTL-inducing activities of AEF can be experimentally dissociated, indicating that different subpopulations of T lymphocytes may be involved in the response to AEF. In contrast to similar soluble helper factors derived from allogeneic cell interactions, AEF appears to be unique in its ability to autonomously induce a primary CTL response in vitro.

Immunologic tolerance to allergenic protein determinants: properties of tolerance induced in mice treated with conjugates of protein and a synthetic copolymer of D-glutamic acid and D-lysine (D-GL)

Conjugates of proteins and the synthetic copolymer of D-glutamic acid and D-lysine (protein-D-GL) reproducibly induce significant unresponsiveness to the protein antigens in experimental mice. Proteins studied include ovalbumin and antigen E of ragweed extract, the major allergen of ragweed pollen. The unresponsive state 1) can be induced in both unsensitized and previously sensitized experimental animals, 2) is selectively confined to responses of the IgE antibody class, 3) is long lasting, and 4) is highly antigen specific. IgE antibody responses can also be suppressed by administering comparable doses of unconjugated protein alone; however, the unresponsive state induced in this manner is only transient and rebound production of IgE antibody is often observed. Results from the studies of the cellular basis of the protein-D-GL induced unresponsiveness demonstrate that 1) protein-D-GL conjugates do not induce unresponsiveness at the level of protein-specific B cells, 2) tolerance is not induced by virtue of a detectable antigen-specific suppressor T cell mechanism, 3) tolerance is most probably induced in the antigen-specific helper T cell populations. The significant IgE-selective and antigen-specific tolerogenic activity of protein-D-GL conjugates make these compounds potential candidates for use as therapeutic agents in the treatment of IgE-mediated human allergic disorders induced by protein allergens.

New concepts concerning the clinical control of IgE synthesis

Prospects for new therapeutic approaches to IgE-mediated allergic diseases have arisen from (1) recent experimental observations that have suggested new concepts concerning the pathogenesis of the allergic phenotype, and (2) adaptation of previously described methods for induction of specific immunological tolerance to problems to allergy. The bases for these new approaches to allergic diseases are summarized herein.

Suppression of hapten-specific delayed-type hypersensitivity responses in mice by idiotype-specific suppressor T cells after administration of anti-idiotypic antibodies

Delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) responses specific for the phosphorylcholine (PC) hapten were induced in BALB/c mice by immunization with syngeneic peritoneal exudate cells (PEC) coupled with diazotized phenyl-phosphoryl-choline. PC-specific DTH responses were elicited in such immunized mice after footpad challenge with PC-derivatized syngeneic spleen cells. Moreover, PC-immune lymph node cells could passively transfer PC-specific DTH responses to naive BALB/c mice and it was possible to demonstrate that the cells responsible for such passively transferred responses were T lymphocytes. Because the T-15 idiotypic determinant displayed on the TEPC-15 PC-binding myeloma protein is known to be a dominant idiotype associated with anti-PC antibody responses in BALB/c mice, an analysis was made of the effects of anti-T-15 idiotypic antibodies on the induction and expression of murine PC-specific DTH responses. Repeated injections of anti-T-15 idiotypic antiserum, raised in A/J mice by immunization with TEPC-15 myeloma protein, into recipient BALB/c mice both immediately before and after sensitization with PC-PEC virtually abolished the development of PC-specific DTH responses. Although administration of anti-T-15 antiserum effectively inhibited the induction phase of PC-specific DTH responses, these anti-idiotypic antibodies had no suppressive activity at the effector phase of these responses. The inhibition observed with anti-T-15 antibodies was highly specific for the PC hapten, and for PC-specific DTH responses of BALB/c but not A/J mice. Studies were conducted to address the possibility that anti-Id treatment induced suppressor T lymphocytes capable of specifically inhibiting the activity of PC-specific T cells participating in DTH responses. The results demonstrate that idiotype-specific suppressor T cells are, indeed, induced by treatment with anti-Id; moreover, such suppressor T cells, once induced, are highly effective in abrogating both the induction and the effector phases of PC-specific T cell-mediated DTH responses in BALB/c mice.

Biological effects of allogeneic effect factor on T lymphocytes: in vitro induction of cytotoxic T lymphocytes manifesting preferential lytic activity against H-2-identical tumor cells

The studies reported herein were designed to determine the effects of allogeneic effect factor (AEF), a soluble mediator generated in the course of allogeneic cell interactions, on the differentiation of cytotoxic T lymphocytes in vitro. Normal, unprimed spleen cells from various strains of mice cultured with AEF for 5 days, in the absence of any stimulator cells, developed into cytotoxic lymphocytes capable of lysing target cells in a short-term 51Cr release assay. T lymphocyte-depleted spleen cells did not become cytotoxic when cultured with AEF, and the cytotoxic cells themselves were found to be T lymphocytes. AEF-induced cytotoxic T lymphocytes preferentially lysed H-2-identical target cells. Thus, AEF, as opposed to similar "helper" factors derived from mixed lymphocyte cultures, appears to be unique in its ability to trigger normal, unprimed T lymphocytes to differentiate into cytotoxic T lymphocytes in the absence of specific antigenic stimulation.

Adaptive differentiation of murine lymphocytes. IV (Responder x nonresponder) F1 T cells can be taught to preferentially help nonresponder, rather than responder, B cells

Responses to the synthetic terpolymer L-glutamic acid, L-lysine, L-tyrosine (GLT) in the mouse are controlled by H-2-1inked Ir-GLTgenes. (Responder x nonresponder) F(1) hybrid mice, themselves phenotypic responders, can be primed with GLT to develop specific helper cells capable of interacting with 2,4-dinitrophenyl hapten (DNP)-primed F(1) B cells in response to DNP-GLT. Unlike the indiscriminant ability of F(1) helper T cells for conventional antigens (i.e. not Ir gene-controlled), which can help B cells of either parental type (as well as F(1)) equally well, GLT-primed F(1) T cells can only provide help under normal circumstances for B lymphocytes of responder parent origin; they are unable to communicate effectively with nonresponder parental B cells (1, and the present studies). The present studies reveal, however, that the induction of a parental cell-induced allogeneic effect during priming of F(1) mice to GLT actually dictates the direction of cooperating preference that will be displayed by such F(1) helper cells for B cells of one parental type or the other. Thus, F(1) T cells, primed to GLT under the influence of an allogeneic effect induced by parental BALB/c cells, develop into effective helpers for nonresponder A/J B cells, but fail to develop effective helpers for responder BALB/c B cells, and vice-versa. In contrast, F(1) T cells, primed to GLT under the influence of an allogeneic effect induced by either parental type, display significantly enhanced levels of helper activity for B cells derived from F(1) donors. These results are interpreted to reflect the existence of two interdependent events provoked by the allogeneic effect: one event augments the differentiation of GLT-specific helper T cells belonging to the subset corresponding to the opposite parental type; this would explain the development of increased helper activity provided to partner B cells of opposite parental type (as well as of F(1) origin). The second event, we postulate, involves the production of responses against the receptors which normally self-recognize native cell interaction determinants; this form of anti-idiotype response is restricted against self- recognizing receptors of the same parental type used for induction of the allogeneic effect, hence explaining diminished helper activity of such F(1) cells for partner B lymphocytes of corresponding parental type.

Regulation of IgE antibody production by serum molecules. IV. Complete Freund's adjuvant induces both enhancing and suppressive activities detectable in the serum of low and high responder mice

Two biologically active serum molecules manifesting precisely opposite biologic effects, both of which are selective for IgE antibody synthesis, can be detected in the serum and ascites fluids of CFA-immune mice. One activity, described previously, is suppressive and hence termed suppressive factor of allergy (SFA); the other, reported for the first time herein, is enhancing and has been termed enhancing factor of allergy (EFA). The ability to detect one vs the other activity requires certain special manipulations such as different doses of low dose x-irradiation. Conclusive evidence for the existence of two distinct factors mediating these two opposing biologic effects was obtained in studies demonstrating that affinity chromatography on concanavalin A-Sepharose segregated the two molecular entities. Thus, SFA binds poorly or not at all to Con A-Sepharose, whereas EFA binds to Con A and can be recovered in the eluate eluted with the competitive sugar alpha-methyl-D-glucopyranoside.