Different behavior of two Trypanosoma cruzi major clones: transmission and circulation in young Bolivian patients

Specificity of two widespread Trypanosoma cruzi clonal genotypes or "clonets" (20 and 39) was first analyzed by hybridization with a large set of T. cruzi stocks characterized by multigenic study relying on both MLEE and RAPD. Then, these clonets were detected in the blood of Chagasic children from a Bolivian endemic area by a combination of polymerase chain reaction and clonet-specific DNA hybridization. The distribution of these clonets in patients was significantly different from that observed in the vectors of the same area (Triatoma infestans). In vectors, clonets 20 and 39 are found with comparable frequencies (0.69 and 0.67, respectively) in contrast with patients, in whom clonet 20 and mixed infections exhibit low frequencies. The Chagasic population can be divided into acute infections and latent infections above the accepted criterion of parasitemia (direct microscopic examination). The results suggest a limited selection in the transmission of the two clonets and a further drastic control of clonet 20 parasitemia by the immune system of children patients.

Compared vectorial transmissibility of pure and mixed clonal genotypes of Trypanosoma cruzi in Triatoma infestans

A total of 15 mixtures involving 9 different stocks attributed to the 19/20, 32 and 39 major clonal genotypes of Trypanosoma cruzi were used to infect third-instar nymphs of Triatoma infestans via an artificial feeding device. Three biological parameters were considered: (1) the percentage of infected insects (%II), (2) the number of flagellates per insect (NFI), and (3) the percentage of trypomastigotes per insect (%DIF). Genetic characterization by both multilocus enzyme electrophoresis (MLEE) and random amplification of polymorphic DNA (RAPD) indicated that in almost all cases (87%), mixtures remained present after completion of the whole cycle in the insect vector. Two lines of comparison were performed: (1) pure clonal genotypes versus corresponding mixed clonal genotypes and (2) the actual behavior of mixed clonal genotypes versus the expected behavior of the theoretical mixture (i.e. the arithmetic mean of the results observed for each of the two clonal genotypes taken separately). Statistical analyses of the variables were made difficult because of the presence of large standard deviations. Nevertheless, in several cases, mixtures differed significantly from pure clonal genotypes, and in one case the actual mixture differed significantly from the theoretical mixture. In some cases, interaction (either potentialization or reciprocal inhibition) could be suspected.

Predicted and observed alleles of Plasmodium falciparum merozoite surface protein-1 (MSP-1), a potential malaria vaccine antigen

The 19-kDa antigenic domain of Plasmodium falciparum merozoite surface protein (MSP)-1 is a potential malaria vaccine candidate. Based on the amino acid substitution, four known alleles, E-TSR (PNG-MAD20 type), E-KNG (Uganda-PA type), Q-KNG (Wellcome type), and Q-TSR (Indo type) of this domain have been identified. Using single or double crossover recombinational events, we predicted the existence of additional alleles of this antigen. The presence of the predicted alleles was determined in parasite isolates from western Kenya, by undertaking a cross-sectional and a longitudinal study. Of the ten predicted alleles, we have revealed the presence of three new alleles: E-KSG-L (Kenya-1 type); E-KSR-L (Kenya-2 type); and E-KNG-F (Kenya-3 type). The results of this study suggest that it may be possible to predict the complexity of the genetic makeup of natural parasite populations.

A phylogenetic analysis of the Trypanosoma cruzi genome project CL Brener reference strain by multilocus enzyme electrophoresis and multiprimer random amplified polymorphic DNA fingerprinting

We have assessed the phylogenetic status of the Trypanosoma cruzi Genome Project CL Brener reference strain by multilocus enzyme electrophoresis (MLEE) and multiprimer random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) including a set of cloned stocks representative of the whole genetic diversity of T. cruzi. MLEE and RAPD data gave congruent phylogenetic results. The CL Brener reference strain fell into the second major phylogenetic subdivision of T. cruzi, and was genetically very close to the Tulahuen reference strain. No reliable RAPD character and only one MLEE character permitted us to distinguish between the CL Brener and Tulahuen reference strains. In contrast, many RAPD and MLEE characters were able to distinguish between the CL Brener reference strain and the other T. cruzi genotypes analyzed here, in particular the formerly described principal zymodemes I, II and III. It is suspected that both CL Brener and Tulahuen are hybrid genotypes, a fact that should be taken into account when interpreting sequence data. Moreover, our study confirms that the species T. cruzi is genetically very heterogeneous. We recommend future comparison of sequencing data from the CL Brener reference strain with those of at least one radically distinct T. cruzi genotype, belonging to the other major phylogenetic subdivision of this species.

Trypanosoma cruzi: impact of clonal evolution of the parasite on its biological and medical properties

Trypanosoma cruzi populations are subdivided into natural clones that can exhibit considerable genetic differences. It has been proposed that T. cruzi clonal structure has a major impact on this parasite's biological properties. The present work aims at testing this hypothesis. Twenty-one stocks isolated from various ecological cycles, places, and hosts were characterized by multilocus enzyme electrophoresis (MLEE) with 22 genetic loci and random amplification of polymorphic DNA (RAPD) with 10 primers on the one hand and by 14 different biological parameters on the other hand. These parameters were related to: (i) growth kinetics of epimastigotes and amastigotes; (ii) infection of culture cells by amastigotes; (iii) viability of extracellular trypomastigotes; or (iv) sensitivity of epimastigotes, trypomastigotes, and amastigotes to Benznidazole and Nifurtimox. MLEE and RAPD results exhibited parity to each other, as previously noted (M. Tibayrenc, K. Neubauer, C. Barnabé, F. Guerrini, D. Skarecky, and F. J. Ayala, 1993, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA 90, 1335-1339), and showed that the 21 stocks were distributed into three main genetic groups, 19/20, 32, and 39, corresponding to the major clones 19, 20, 32, and 39 previously described on the basis of 15 isozyme loci. Most biological parameters showed a strong correlation to the genetic distances evaluated from either MLEE or RAPD, which favors the working hypothesis. The only exception came from drug sensitivity estimated on trypomastigote forms. The overall results made it possible to firmly reject the null hypothesis that there is no relationships between evolutionary distances and biological differences in T. cruzi natural clones.

La Spécificité Parasitaire et ses Incidences sur l'Etiologie et l'Epidémologie des Parasitoses Humaines d'Origine Zoonotique

by J. Euzeby, Fondation Mérieux, 1997. 250.00FFr (153 pages) ISBN 2 84039 053 1.

Genetic epidemiology of parasitic protozoa and other infectious agents: the need for an integrated approach

This paper emphasises the relevance of the concepts and methods of evolutionary genetics for studying the epidemiology of parasitic protozoa and other pathogenic agents. Population genetics and phylogenetic analysis both contribute to identifying the relevant evolutionary and epidemiologically discrete units of research (Discrete typing units = DTUs), that can be equated to distinct phylogenetic lines. It is necessary (i) to establish that a given species represents a reliable DTU; (ii) to see whether a given species is further structured into lower DTUs that correspond to either clonal lineages or to cryptic species, and could exhibit distinct biomedical properties (virulence, resistance to drugs, etc). DTUs at the species and subspecies level can be conveniently identified by specific genetic markers or sets of genetic markers ("tags") for epidemiological follow-up. For any kind of pathogen (protozoa, fungi, bacteria, viruses), DTUs represent the relevant units of research, not only for epidemiology, but also, for other applied researches (clinical study, pathogenicity, vaccine and drug design, immunology, etc). The development of an "integrated genetic epidemiology of infectious diseases", that would explore the respective role of, and the interactions between, the genetic diversity (and its biological consequences) of the pathogen, the host and the vector (in the case of vector-borne diseases) is called for.

Population structure of Andean Triatoma infestans: allozyme frequencies and their epidemiological relevance

Triatoma infestans (Hemiptera: Reduviidae) from 22 Andean localities in Bolivia (n = 968) and Peru (n = 37) were analysed by multi-locus enzyme electrophoresis. Among 12 gene-enzyme systems analysed, GPD, 6GPD and PGM were polymorphic, ACON, G6PD, GPI, 1DH, LAP, MDH, ME, PEP-A and PEP-B were monomorphic. Allozyme frequencies were analysed in relation to geographical and climatic factors, and the presence or absence of Trypanosoma cruzi infection. At one locality (Vallegrande, Bolivia), the frequency of 6Pgd-1 was significantly higher in infected (41% of 85) than in uninfected (17% of 83) adult T. infestans, although no such difference was found among nymphs (n = 347). From other localities, only insects infected with T. cruzi were subjected to isozyme analysis. Populations of T. infestans within villages showed panmixia, while genetic differentiation of T. infestans between villages was correlated with the distance between them. The genetic structure of T. infestans natural populations followed an 'isolation by distance' model, involving a series of founder effects followed by genetic drift, rather than adaptation in response to differential selection pressures. This conforms with circumstantial evidence that T. infestans spread, mainly in association with recent human migrations, from a source, probably in southern Bolivia. Isoenzyme characterization of populations of T. infestans could be used to infer sources of re-infestation during the surveillance phase of control programs.

Classification of plant trypanosomatids (Phytomonas spp.): parity between random-primer DNA typing and multilocus enzyme electrophoresis

The genetic polymorphism of 30 isolates of plant trypanosomatids colloquially referred to as plant trypanosomes was assayed by means of RAPD. The principle objectives of this study were to assess the discriminative power of RAPD analysis for studying plant trypanosomes and to determine whether the results obtained were comparable with those from a previous isoenzyme (MLEE) study. The principle groups of plant trypanosomes identified previously by isoenzyme analysis--intraphloemic trypanosomes, intralaticiferous trypanosomes and trypanosomes isolated from fruits--were also clearly separated by the RAPD technique. Moreover, the results showed a fair parity between MLEE and RAPD data (coefficient of correlation = 0.84) and the two techniques have comparable discriminative ability. Most of the separation revealed by the two techniques between the clusters was associated with major biological properties. However, the RAPD technique gave a more coherent separation than MLEE because the intraphloemic isolates, which were biologically similar in terms of their specific localization in the sieve tubes of the plant, were found to be in closer groups by the RAPD. For both techniques, the existence of the main clusters was correlated with the existence of synapomorphic characters, which could be used as powerful tools in taxonomy and epidemiology.

Parity among the randomly amplified polymorphic DNA method, multilocus enzyme electrophoresis, and Southern blot hybridization with the moderately repetitive DNA probe Ca3 for fingerprinting Candida albicans

Randomly amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) analysis, multilocus enzyme electrophoresis (MLEE), and Southern blot hybridization with moderately repetitive DNA probes have emerged as effective fingerprinting methods for the infectious fungus Candida albicans. The three methods have been compared for their capacities to identify identical or highly related isolates, to cluster weakly related isolates, to discriminate between unrelated isolates, and to assess microevolution within a strain. By computing similarity coefficients between 29 isolates from three cities within the continental United States, strong concordance of the results is demonstrated for RAPD analysis, MLEE, and Southern blot hybridization with the moderately repetitive probe Ca3, and weaker concordance of the results is demonstrated for these three fingerprinting methods and Southern blot hybridization with the moderately repetitive probe CARE2. All methods were also demonstrated to be able to resolve microevolution within a strain, with the Ca3 probe exhibiting the greatest resolving power. The strong correlations demonstrated between polymorphic markers assessed by the four independent fingerprinting methods and the nonrandom association between loci demonstrated by RAPD analysis and MLEE provide evidence for strong linkage disequilibrium and a clonal population structure for C. albicans. In addition, a synapomorphic allele, Pep-3A, was found to be present in all members of one of the three clusters discriminated by RAPD analysis, MLEE, and Ca3 fingerprinting, supporting the concordance of the clustering capacities of the three methods, the robustness of the clusters, and the clonal nature of the clusters.

Evidence for hybridization by multilocus enzyme electrophoresis and random amplified polymorphic DNA between Leishmania braziliensis and Leishmania panamensis/guyanensis in Ecuador

The taxonomic attribution of four Leishmania stocks isolated from humans in Ecuador has been explored by both multilocus enzyme electrophoresis and random amplified polymorphic DNA. For three loci, MLEE results showed patterns suggesting a heterozygous state for a diploid organism, while the corresponding homozygous states are characteristic of the Leishmania panamensis/guyanensis complex and Leishmania braziliensis, respectively. Other enzyme loci showed characters attributable to either the L. panamensis/ guyanensis complex or L. braziliensis. RAPD profiles exhibited for several primers a combination of the Leishmania panamensis/ guyanensis complex and L. braziliensis characters. These data hence suggest that the four stocks are the result of hybridization between L. panamensis/guyanensis and L. braziliensis. MLEE data show that the results cannot be attributed to either mixture of stocks, or an F1 in the framework of a simple Mendelian inheritance.

Metric differences between silvatic and domestic Triatoma infestans (Heteroptera: Reduviidae) in Bolivia

One hundred and fifty-seven specimens of Bolivian Triatoma infestans (Klug 1834), including 44 from the silvatic focus at Cochabamba (Bolivia), were compared using morphometric characters of the head capsule. From these specimens, 10 silvatic and 28 domestic adults were also compared using additional morphometric characters of the membranous part of the hemelytra. Nonparametric univariate comparisons between specimens from silvatic and domestic ecotopes indicated the importance of the postocular region as a possible diagnostic character for nymphs and adults from the different ecotopes, and they detected wing differences in males. Populations became more distinct entities when head or wing characters were considered jointly in canonical variate analysis. Regardless of whether size variation was considered, canonical variate analysis generally showed greater significance for wing than for head features. These morphological differences between silvatic and domestic bugs, particularly unrelated to size differences, are interpreted to indicate incipient separation between silvatic and domestic populations that had not been detected by previous isoenzyme analyses, and suggest a reinterpretation of the epidemiological significance of silvatic populations of T. infestans in Bolivia.

Leishmania infantum is clonal in AIDS patients too: epidemiological implications

OBJECTIVE

To test, in AIDS patients, a previously proposed hypothesis of clonal population structure in Leishmania infantum, the agent of visceral leishmaniasis.

DESIGN

Forty-three stocks of L. infantum isolated from AIDS patients in Spain were analysed by multilocus enzyme electrophoresis.

METHODS

The results were analysed in terms of population genetics according to previously described statistical methods. Departures from panmixia were examined by linkage disequilibrium analysis.

RESULTS

As previously shown in HIV-negative patients, classical manifestations of clonality were shown, namely strong linkage disequilibrium, over-representation of genotypes and overall lack of genotype diversity. The same dominant clonal genotype (MON1) was recorded in both HIV-positive and HIV-negative patients. Frequency of this dominant genotype was not statistically different in HIV-positive and HIV-negative patients.

CONCLUSIONS

The parasite population under survey appears to be clonal; parasite genotypes can therefore be equated to natural clones, stable in space and time, which can be used as multilocus epidemiological markers. Nevertheless, additional studies are required to better estimate the long-term stability of these clonal genotypes and the possible interference of gene exchange at an evolutionary scale.

Impact of clonal evolution on the biological diversity of Trypanosoma cruzi

Trypanosoma cruzi, the agent of Chagas' disease, exhibits considerable biological variability. Moreover, it has been postulated that populations of this protozoan are subdivided into natural clones, which can be separated from each other by considerable levels of evolutionary divergence. The authors have proposed that this long-term clonal evolution may have a profound impact on Trypanosoma cruzi biological diversity. In order to test this hypothesis, 16 T. cruzi stocks representing 3 major clonal genotypes of the parasite were analysed for 8 different in vitro biological parameters. The overall results show a strong statistical linkage between genetic and biological differences. This is in agreement with the working hypothesis, although a notable biological variability is observable among the stocks of each of the 3 major clonal genotypes. The authors propose that T cruzi genetic variability must be taken into account in any applied study dealing with this parasite.

Isoenzyme diversity in Pneumocystis carinii from rats, mice, and rabbits

Pneumocystis carinii is an opportunistic pathogen that causes pneumonia in immunocompromised patients. To investigate the genetic diversity of P. carinii populations, multilocus enzyme electrophoresis was used to analyze five enzyme systems (malate dehydrogenase, glucose phosphate isomerase, leucine aminopeptidase, malic enzyme, and 6-phosphogluconate dehydrogenase). Only five different multilocus associations (zymodemes) were recorded for the 70 isolates studied. While only one multilocus combination was found in mice and rabbits, three different multilocus associations were recorded in rats. Population genetic tests and phylogenetic analysis strongly suggest that P. carinii genotypes are host-specific, in agreement with molecular study results, and that no genetic exchange occurs between genotypes from different host species. This hypothesis could be verified only by the evolutionary genetic approach, which relies here on multilocus analysis.

Trypanosoma cruzi: evaluation of a RAPD synapomorphic fragment as a species-specific DNA probe

A methodological approach is proposed to select rapidly DNA sequences characterized by a well defined specificity and potentially interesting to be used as diagnostic probes or as taxonomic and phylogenetic markers. A fragment amplified from a diversified sample of Trypanosoma cruzi stocks by the RAPD (random amplified polymorphic DNA) method with the A8 primer, previously found to be monomorphic in all stocks, was separated in 2 fragments using polyacrylamide electrophoresis. RFLP (restriction fragment length polymorphism) analysis of the 750-bp fragment common to all stocks revealed some sequence heterogeneity within the T. cruzi species, whereas hybridization experiments showed a high homology between fragments amplified from different T. cruzi stocks. These results suggest that sequence analysis will allow the design of internal primers to be used as probes to target specific taxonomic levels (clone, family of related clones, or species) and for diagnosis.

Population structure of Trypanosoma brucei S. L. in Cote d'Ivoire assayed by multilocus enzyme electrophoresis: epidemiological and taxonomical considerations

Fifty-two Trypanosoma brucei stocks isolated in Côte d'Ivoire from sympatric locations were analyzed by cellulose acetate electrophoresis of isoenzymes. Of 13 genetic loci surveyed, 5 appeared as variable, which made it possible to delimit 12 different zymodemes. The most abundant zymodeme involved stocks isolated from both humans and pigs, which is consistent with the hypothesis that pig is a reservoir of human African trypanosomiasis in Côte d'Ivoire, as already proposed by other authors. Population genetic analysis of the isozyme data indicated a strong linkage disequilibrium, which suggests that genetic recombination is severely restricted in this sample and favors the hypothesis that the trypanosome populations surveyed are basically clonal. Nevertheless, additional studies are required to better estimate the long-term stability of these clones and the possible interference of gene exchange at an evolutionary scale. The results corroborate the hypothesis that a majority of human T. brucei stocks from West Africa correspond to a fairly homogeneous cluster of genotypes (T. brucei gambiense 'Group I', Gibson, 1986).

Towards a unified evolutionary genetics of microorganisms

I propose here that evolutionary genetics, apart from improving our basic knowledge of the taxonomy and evolution of microbes (either eukaryotes or prokaryotes), can also greatly contribute to applied research in microbiology. Evolutionary genetics provides convenient guidelines for better interpreting genetic and molecular data dealing with microorganisms. The three main potential applications of evolutionary genetics in microbiology are (a) epidemiological follow-up (with the necessity of evaluating the stability of microbial genotypes over space and time); (b) taxonomy in the broad sense (better definition and sharper delimitation of presently described taxa, research of hidden genetic subdivisions); and (c) evaluation of the impact of the genetic diversity of microbes on their relevant properties (pathogenicity, resistance to drugs, etc). At present, two main kinds of population structure can be distinguished in natural microbial populations: (a) species that are not subdivided into discrete phylogenetic lineages (panmictic species or basically sexual species with occasional bouts of short-term clonality fall into this category); (b) species that are strongly subdivided by either cryptic speciation or clonal evolution. Improvements in available statistical methods are required to refine these distinctions and to better quantify the actual impact of gene exchange in natural microbial populations. Moreover, a codified selection of markers with appropriate molecular clocks (in other words: adapted levels of resolution) is sorely needed to answer distinct questions that address different scales of time and space: experimental, epidemic, and evolutionary. The problems raised by natural genetic diversity are very similar for all microbial species, in terms of both basic and applied science. Despite this fact, a regrettable compartmentalization among specialists has hampered progress in this field. I propose a synthetic approach, relying on the statistical improvements and technical standardizations called for above, to settle a unified evolutionary genetics of microorganisms, valid whatever the species studied, whether eukaryotic (parasitic protozoa and fungi) or prokaryotic (bacteria). Apart from benefits for basic evolutionary research, the anticipated payoff from this synthetic approach is to render routine and common-place the use of microbial evolutionary genetics in the fields of epidemiology, medicine, and agronomy.