Transcription of mutS- and mutL-homologous genes during meiosis in Saccharomyces cerevisiae and identification of a regulatory cis-element for meiotic induction of MSH2

We have analysed the levels of mRNA transcripts of the mutS- and mutL-homologous genes of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae during the course of meiosis, by quantitative RT-PCR. We found that all mutS homologues (MSH1-6) were induced during meiosis, whereas no evidence for regulation of the mutL homologues (PMS1, MLH1-3) was obtained. Temporal expression patterns indicative of co-regulation were observed for the gene pairs MSH4/MSH5 and MSH2/ SPO11. Sequence comparisons of the 5' flanking regions revealed similar sequence stretches in the respective gene pairs, which may constitute regulatory elements. Similar sequences were also found in the 5' flanking regions of the pairs MSH1/MSH3 and MSH1/MSH6. Upstream of MSH2 three closely spaced sequences similar to UASH elements were found, which - surprisingly are located within the coding region of SPO21. Deletion of these elements resulted in loss of meiotic induction of MSH2. Genetic analysis of homozygous deletion mutants did not reveal any differences from wild type with respect to genetic distance estimates, aberrant segregation, or suppression of homoeologus recombination in an interspecies cross with Saccharomyces paradoxus.

Interaction of Escherichia coli MutS and MutL at a DNA Mismatch

MutS and MutL are both required to activate downstream events in DNA mismatch repair. We examined the rate of dissociation of MutS from a mismatch using linear heteroduplex DNAs or heteroduplexes blocked at one or both ends by four-way DNA junctions in the presence and absence of MutL. In the presence of ATP, dissociation of MutS from linear heteroduplexes or heteroduplexes blocked at only one end occurs within 15 s. When both duplex ends are blocked, MutS remains associated with the DNA in complexes with half-lives of 30 min. DNase I footprinting of MutS complexes is consistent with migration of MutS throughout the DNA duplex region. When MutL is present, it associates with MutS and prevents ATP-dependent migration away from the mismatch in a manner that is dependent on the length of the heteroduplex. The rate and extent of mismatch-provoked cleavage at hemimethylated GATC sites by MutH in the presence of MutS, MutL, and ATP are the same whether the mismatch and GATC sites are in cis or in trans. These results suggest that a MutS-MutL complex in the vicinity of a mismatch is involved in activating MutH.

Direct observation of three conformations of MutS protein regulated by adenine nucleotides

Mismatched base-pairs, which are caused by either DNA replication errors, DNA damage or genetic recombination, are repaired by the mismatch-repair system. The MutS protein, a component of the mismatch-repair system, recognizes mismatched base-pairs in DNA, and its DNA-binding activity is affected by ATP and ADP. Here, we show that the MutS protein from Thermus thermophilus HB8 can have three different conformations in solution, based on direct observations made by small-angle X-ray scattering. The conformation of MutS in solution is drastically influenced by the presence of ADP and ATP; the ATP-bound form has the most compact conformation, the ADP-bound form the most stretched, and the nucleotide-free form has a conformation intermediate between the two. Based on these findings, we conclude that the DNA-binding activity of MutS may depend on conformational changes triggered by both the binding and hydrolysis of ATP.

Characterization of functional interactions among the Escherichia coli mismatch repair proteins using a bacterial two-hybrid assay

Vsr mediates very short patch repair in Escherichia coli, correcting T/G mismatches caused by deamination of 5-methylcytosine to thymine. MutS and MutL, part of the post-replication mismatch repair system, stimulate VSP repair. In this study, we use a bacterial two-hybrid assay to show that MutL interacts with Vsr. We also show that interaction between Vsr and MutL inhibits the ability of MutL to dimerize, to interact with MutS and MutH and to mediate a previously unknown interaction between MutS and MutH. This inhibition may explain why high levels of Vsr are mutagenic in vivo. In addition, we show that the Mut fusion proteins are repair proficient in the bacterial two-hybrid assay, making it possible to study their interactions in various genetic backgrounds, or in the presence of DNA damaging agents.

Directionality of DNA replication fork movement strongly affects the generation of spontaneous mutations in Escherichia coli

Using a pair of plasmids carrying the rpsL target sequence in different orientations to the replication origin, we analyzed a large number of forward mutations generated in wild-type and mismatch-repair deficient (MMR(-)) Escherichia coli cells to assess the effects of directionality of replication-fork movement on spontaneous mutagenesis and the generation of replication error. All classes of the mutations found in wild-type cells but not MMR(-) cells were strongly affected by the directionality of replication fork movement. It also appeared that the directionality of replication-fork movement governs the directionality of sequence substitution mutagenesis, which occurred in wild-type cells at a frequency comparable to base substitutions and single-base frameshift mutations. A very strong orientation-dependent hot-spot site for single-base frameshift mutations was discovered and demonstrated to be caused by the same process involved in sequence substitution mutagenesis. It is surprising that dnaE173, a potent mutator mutation specific for sequence substitution as well as single-base frameshift, did not enhance the frequency of the hot-spot frameshift mutation. Furthermore, the frequency of the hot-spot frameshift mutation was unchanged in the MMR(-) strain, whereas the mutHLS-dependent mismatch repair system efficiently suppressed the generation of single-base frameshift mutations. These results suggested that the hot-spot frameshift mutagenesis might be initiated at a particular location containing a DNA lesion, and thereby produce a premutagenic replication intermediate resistant to MMR. Significant numbers of spontaneous single-base frameshift mutations are probably caused by similar mechanisms.

Costs and benefits of high mutation rates: adaptive evolution of bacteria in the mouse gut

We have shown that bacterial mutation rates change during the experimental colonization of the mouse gut. A high mutation rate was initially beneficial because it allowed faster adaptation, but this benefit disappeared once adaptation was achieved. Mutator bacteria accumulated mutations that, although neutral in the mouse gut, are often deleterious in secondary environments. Consistently, the competitiveness of mutator bacteria is reduced during transmission to and re-colonization of similar hosts. The short-term advantages and long-term disadvantages of mutator bacteria could account for their frequency in nature.

Escherichia coli MutS,L modulate RuvAB-dependent branch migration between diverged DNA

This study examines the interaction between Escherichia coli MutS,L and E. coli RuvAB during E. coli RecA-promoted strand exchange. RuvAB is a branch migration complex that stimulates heterologous strand exchange. Previous studies indicate that RuvAB increases the rate at which heteroduplex products are formed by RecA, that RuvA and RuvB are required for this stimulation, and that RuvAB does not stimulate homologous strand exchange. This study indicates that MutS,L inhibit the formation of full-length heteroduplex DNA between M13-fd DNA in the presence of RuvAB, such that less than 2% of the linear substrate is converted to product. Inhibition depends on the time at which MutS,L are added to the reaction and is strongest when MutS,L are added during initiation. The kinetics of the strand exchange reaction suggest that MutS,L directly inhibit RuvAB-dependent branch migration in the absence of RecA. The inhibition requires the formation of base-base mismatches and ATP utilization; no effect on RuvAB-promoted strand exchange is seen if an ATP-deficient mutant of MutS (MutS501) is included in the reaction instead of wild-type MutS. These results are consistent with a role for MutS,L in maintaining genomic stability and replication fidelity.

Affinity of mismatch-binding protein MutS for heteroduplexes containing different mismatches

We have used bandshift analysis to measure the interaction between the Escherichia coli mismatch-binding protein MutS and synthetic DNA fragments containing all possible DNA mismatches as well as an unpaired T (DeltaT). The order of affinity is found to be DeltaT>GT>GG>AA approximately TT approximately TC>CA>GA>CC>GC. We find that the affinity for GT mismatches is affected by the flanking sequence and decreases in the order G(n)C(n)>(GC)(n)>A(n)T(n)>(AT)(n). Studies with base analogues show good binding to phiT (where phi represents 1',2'-dideoxyribose), but much weaker binding to Gphi.

PCR candidate region mismatch scanning: adaptation to quantitative, high-throughput genotyping

Linkage and association analyses were performed to identify loci affecting disease susceptibility by scoring previously characterized sequence variations such as microsatellites and single nucleotide polymorphisms. Lack of markers in regions of interest, as well as difficulty in adapting various methods to high-throughput settings, often limits the effectiveness of the analyses. We have adapted the Escherichia coli mismatch detection system, employing the factors MutS, MutL and MutH, for use in PCR-based, automated, high-throughput genotyping and mutation detection of genomic DNA. Optimal sensitivity and signal-to-noise ratios were obtained in a straightforward fashion because the detection reaction proved to be principally dependent upon monovalent cation concentration and MutL concentration. Quantitative relationships of the optimal values of these parameters with length of the DNA test fragment were demonstrated, in support of the translocation model for the mechanism of action of these enzymes, rather than the molecular switch model. Thus, rapid, sequence-independent optimization was possible for each new genomic target region. Other factors potentially limiting the flexibility of mismatch scanning, such as positioning of dam recognition sites within the target fragment, have also been investigated. We developed several strategies, which can be easily adapted to automation, for limiting the analysis to intersample heteroduplexes. Thus, the principal barriers to the use of this methodology, which we have designated PCR candidate region mismatch scanning, in cost-effective, high-throughput settings have been removed.

The miaA mutator phenotype of Escherichia coli K-12 requires recombination functions

miaA mutants, which contain A-37 instead of the ms(2)i(6)A-37 hypermodification in their tRNA, show a moderate mutator phenotype leading to increased GC-->TA transversion. We show that the miaA mutator phenotype is dependent on recombination functions similar to, but not exactly the same as, those required for translation stress-induced mutagenesis.

Phylogenetic evidence for horizontal transfer of mutS alleles among naturally occurring Escherichia coli strains

mutS mutators accelerate the bacterial mutation rate 100- to 1,000-fold and relax the barriers that normally restrict homeologous recombination. These mutators thus afford the opportunity for horizontal exchange of DNA between disparate strains. While much is known regarding the mutS phenotype, the evolutionary structure of the mutS(+) gene in Escherichia coli remains unclear. The physical proximity of mutS to an adjacent polymorphic region of the chromosome suggests that this gene itself may be subject to horizontal transfer and recombination events. To test this notion, a phylogenetic approach was employed that compared gene phylogeny to strain phylogeny, making it possible to identify E. coli strains in which mutS alleles have recombined. Comparison of mutS phylogeny against predicted E. coli "whole-chromosome" phylogenies (derived from multilocus enzyme electrophoresis and mdh sequences) revealed striking levels of phylogenetic discordance among mutS alleles and their respective strains. We interpret these incongruences as signatures of horizontal exchange among mutS alleles. Examination of additional sites surrounding mutS also revealed incongruous distributions compared to E. coli strain phylogeny. This suggests that other regional sequences are equally subject to horizontal transfer, supporting the hypothesis that the 61.5-min mutS-rpoS region is a recombinational hot spot within the E. coli chromosome. Furthermore, these data are consistent with a mechanism for stabilizing adaptive changes promoted by mutS mutators through rescue of defective mutS alleles with wild-type sequences.

Fidelity of replication of repetitive DNA in mutS and repair proficient Escherichia coli

Replication fidelity is not constant among strains within a species or at all genetic loci within a genome. Altered fidelity of replication may affect patterns of pathogenesis and the evolution of these strains. We have been studying replication fidelity in Escherichia coli, both in laboratory attenuated strains and in food-borne pathogens. To understand the altered patterns of mutagenesis at the molecular level, we used a shuttle vector plasmid with a tRNA mutational marker gene which had been altered to include homopolymeric runs of five, seven and nine [G:C] pairs, as well as non-repetitive DNA. Replication of the plasmid in mutS strains resulted in a 20-fold increase in mutant progeny plasmids. The mutations were almost all (>90%) frameshift mutations, while base substitution mutations were rare. Most mutations were insertions or deletions of one or two [G:C] pairs in the longest homopolymeric runs. Larger deletions (5 to >70bp), also targeted to the repetitive sequence, were likewise common. Mutations increased exponentially with the length of the homopolymeric run. These patterns of mutation, including unexpectedly high levels in repair proficient strains, led to an examination of the E. coli K-12 genome for homopolymeric DNA. This sequence motif was found to be rare, particularly in genes and open reading frames. Amino acid homotrimers were found to avoid usage of homopolymeric codons, even when they are preferred among synonymous codons in E. coli. There appears to be active selection against tandem direct nucleotide repeats in the E. coli genome, correlated with the inability of the organism to accurately replicate such sequence.

DNA mismatch repair: MutS structures bound to mismatches

When DNA mismatch repair fails, the result is a mutator phenotype, which can lead to cancer in humans. Functional repair is dependent on the recognition of mismatches by a dimeric MutS protein, a homodimer in bacteria but a heterodimer in humans. Recent crystal structures of Thermus aquaticus and Escherichia coli MutS have revealed the structural heterodimeric nature of the bacterial proteins and provide new insights into their complicated ATP-dependent repair mechanism.

Functional analysis of the Bacillus subtilis y shD gene, a mutS paralogue

In the course of the Bacillus subtilis genome sequencing project, an ORF called yshD was identified, and its product was classified as a mismatch repair protein. Further analysis of the YshD primary sequence showed that the protein belongs to the MutS2 protein family, sharing a high degree of identity with the Thermootoga Inaritima protein TM1278 (34%) and with the so-called MutS2 protein sl11772 of Synechocystis (32%). The COG1193 family of MutS-like proteins is made up of polypeptides that have been predicted from genomic sequencing data from various prokaryotes, but their biological role has not yet been analysed. The functional study of yshD revealed that the gene is constitutively transcribed during the life cycle of B. subtilis, and in minimal medium expression remains at appreciable levels until very late in stationary phase. Fluctuation tests with yshD knock-out mutants did not indicate any role for the protein in preventing the accumulation of spontaneous forward mutations to RifR, nor was any functional interaction with MutS or MutL suggested in fluctuation experiments with mutants lacking combinations of the three genes. Nevertheless, the mutation spectrum observed in the rpoB gene in the deltayshD strain has some characteristic features. The gene does not seem to be involved in the prevention of interspecific recombination in transformation-competent cells.

Disruption of the helix-u-turn-helix motif of MutS protein: loss of subunit dimerization, mismatch binding and ATP hydrolysis

The DNA mismatch repair protein, MutS, is a dimeric protein that recognizes mismatched bases and has an intrinsic ATPase activity. Here, a series of Taq MutS proteins having C-terminal truncations in the vicinity of a highly conserved helix-u-turn-helix (HuH) motif are assessed for subunit oligomerization, ATPase activity and DNA mismatch binding. Those proteins containing an intact HuH region are dimers; those without the HuH region are predominantly monomers in solution. Steady-state kinetics of truncated but dimeric MutS proteins reveals only modest decreases in their ATPase activity compared to full-length protein. In contrast, disruption of the HuH region results in a greatly attenuated ATPase activity. In addition, only dimeric MutS proteins are proficient for mismatch binding. Finally, an analysis of the mismatch repair competency of truncated Escherichia coli MutS proteins in a rifampicin mutator assay confirms that the HuH region is critical for in vivo function. These findings indicate that dimerization is critical for both the ATPase and DNA mismatch binding activities of MutS, and corroborate several key features of the MutS structure recently deduced from X-ray crystallographic studies.

Composite active site of an ABC ATPase: MutS uses ATP to verify mismatch recognition and authorize DNA repair

The MutS protein initiates DNA mismatch repair by recognizing mispaired and unpaired bases embedded in duplex DNA and activating endo- and exonucleases to remove the mismatch. Members of the MutS family also possess a conserved ATPase activity that belongs to the ATP binding cassette (ABC) superfamily. Here we report the crystal structure of a ternary complex of MutS-DNA-ADP and assays of initiation of mismatch repair in conjunction with perturbation of the composite ATPase active site by mutagenesis. These studies indicate that MutS has to bind both ATP and the mismatch DNA simultaneously in order to activate the other mismatch repair proteins. We propose that the MutS ATPase activity plays a proofreading role in DNA mismatch repair, verification of mismatch recognition, and authorization of repair.

DNA binding and protein-protein interaction sites in MutS, a mismatched DNA recognition protein from Thermus thermophilus HB8

The mismatch repair system repairs mismatched base pairs, which are caused by either DNA replication errors, DNA damage, or genetic recombination. Mismatch repair begins with the recognition of mismatched base pairs in DNA by MutS. Protein denaturation and limited proteolysis experiments suggest that Thermus thermophilus MutS can be divided into three structural domains as follows: A (N-terminal domain), B (central domain), and C (C-terminal domain) (Tachiki, H., Kato, R., Masui, R., Hasegawa, K., Itakura, H., Fukuyama, K., and Kuramitsu, S. (1998) Nucleic Acids Res. 26, 4153-4159). To investigate the functions of each domain in detail, truncated genes corresponding to the domains were designed. The gene products were overproduced in Escherichia coli, purified, and assayed for various activities. The MutS-MutS protein interaction site was determined by size-exclusion chromatography to be located in the B domain. The B domain was also found to possess nonspecific double-stranded DNA-binding ability. The C domain, which contains a Walker's A-type nucleotide-binding motif, demonstrated ATPase activity and specific DNA recognition of mismatched base pairs. These ATPase and specific DNA binding activities were found to be dependent upon C domain dimerization.

DNA mismatch repair: the hands of a genome guardian

DNA mismatch repair (MMR) is initiated when the MutS protein recognizes damaged DNA. Crystal structures of MutS bound to mispaired and unpaired DNA show how MutS distinguishes damaged from undamaged DNA and explain how a broad variety of DNA mismatch lesions can be detected. The structures suggest mechanisms for the ATP-induced structural regulation of multistep DNA repair processes.

Experimental analysis of molecular events during mutational periodic selections in bacterial evolution

A fundamental feature of bacterial evolution is a succession of adaptive mutational sweeps when fitter mutants take over a population. To understand the processes involved in mutational successions, Escherichia coli continuous cultures were analyzed for changes at two loci where mutations provide strong transport advantages to fitness under steady-state glucose limitation. Three separate sweeps, observed as classic periodic selection events causing a change in the frequency of neutral mutations (in fhuA causing phage T5 resistance), were identified with changes at particular loci. Two of the sweeps were associated with a reduction in the frequency of neutral mutations and the concurrent appearance of at least 13 alleles at the mgl or mlc loci, respectively. These mgl and mlc polymorphisms were of many mutational types, so were not the result of a mutator or directed mutation event. The third sweep observed was altogether distinct and involved hitchhiking between T5 resistance and advantageous mgl mutations. Moreover, the hitchhiking event coincided with an increase in mutation rates, due to the transient appearance of a strong mutator in the population. The spectrum of mgl mutations among mutator isolates was distinct and due to mutS. The mutator-associated periodic selection also resulted in mgl and fhuA polymorphism in the sweeping population. These examples of periodic selections maintained significant genotypic diversity even in a rapidly evolving culture, with no individual "winner clone" or genotype purging the population.

Role of the dinB gene product in spontaneous mutation in Escherichia coli with an impaired replicative polymerase

We isolated several new mutator mutations of the Escherichia coli replicative polymerase dnaE subunit alpha and used them and a previously reported dnaE mutation to study spontaneous frameshift and base substitution mutations. Two of these dnaE strains produce many more mutants when grown on rich (Luria-Bertani) than on minimal medium. A differential effect of the medium was not observed when these dnaE mutations were combined with a mismatch repair mutation. The selection scheme for the dnaE mutations required that they be able to complement a temperature-sensitive strain. However, the ability to complement is not related to the mutator effect for at least one of the mutants. Comparison of the mutation rates for frameshift and base substitution mutations in mutS and dnaE mutS strains suggests that the mismatch repair proteins respond differently to the two types of change. Deletion of dinB from both chromosome and plasmid resulted in a four- to fivefold decrease in the rate of frameshift and base substitution mutations in a dnaE mutS double mutant background. This reduction indicates that most mistakes in replication occur as a result of the action of the auxiliary rather than the replicative polymerase in this dnaE mutant. Deletion of dinB from strains carrying a wild-type dnaE had a measurable effect, suggesting that a fraction of spontaneous mutations occur as a result of dinB polymerase action even in cells with a normal replicative polymerase.

Evolutionary implications of the frequent horizontal transfer of mismatch repair genes

Mutation and subsequent recombination events create genetic diversity, which is subjected to natural selection. Bacterial mismatch repair (MMR) deficient mutants, exhibiting high mutation and homologous recombination rates, are frequently found in natural populations. Therefore, we have explored the possibility that MMR deficiency emerging in nature has left some "imprint" in the sequence of bacterial genomes. Comparative molecular phylogeny of MMR genes from natural Escherichia coli isolates shows that, compared to housekeeping genes, individual functional MMR genes exhibit high sequence mosaicism derived from diverse phylogenetic lineages. This apparent horizontal gene transfer correlates with hyperrecombination phenotype of MMR-deficient mutators. The sequence mosaicism of MMR genes may be a hallmark of a mechanism of adaptive evolution that involves modulation of mutation and recombination rates by recurrent losses and reacquisitions of MMR gene functions.