A new American Joint Committee on Cancer staging system for cutaneous melanoma

The Melanoma Staging Committee of the AJCC has proposed major revisions of the melanoma TNM and stage grouping criteria. The committee members represent most of the major cooperative groups and cancer centers worldwide with a special interest in melanoma; the committee also collectively has had clinical experience with over 40,000 patients. The new staging system better reflects independent prognostic factors that are used in clinical trials and in reporting the outcomes of various melanoma treatment modalities. Major revisions include 1) melanoma thickness and ulceration, but not level of invasion, to be used in the T classification; 2) the number of metastatic lymph nodes, rather than their gross dimensions, the delineation of microscopic versus macroscopic lymph node metastases, and presence of ulceration of the primary melanoma to be used in the N classification; 3) the site of distant metastases and the presence of elevated serum LDH, to be used in the M classification; 4) an upstaging of all patients with Stage I,II, and III disease when a primary melanoma is ulcerated; 5) a merging of satellite metastases around a primary melanoma and in-transit metastases into a single staging entity that is grouped into Stage III disease; and 6) a new convention for defining clinical and pathologic staging so as to take into account the new staging information gained from intraoperative lymphatic mapping and sentinel lymph node biopsy. The AJC Melanoma Staging Committee invites comments and suggestions regarding this proposed staging system before a final recommendation is made.

Long-term results of a multi-institutional randomized trial comparing prognostic factors and surgical results for intermediate thickness melanomas (1.0 to 4.0 mm). Intergroup Melanoma Surgical Trial

BACKGROUND

Ten- to 15-year survival results were analyzed from a prospective multi-institutional randomized surgical trial that involved 740 stages I and II melanoma patients with intermediate thickness melanomas (1.0 to 4.0 mm) and compared elective (immediate) lymph node dissection (ELND) with clinical observation of the lymph nodes as well as prognostic factors that independently predict outcomes.

METHODS

Eligible patients were stratified according to tumor thickness, anatomical site, and ulceration, and then prerandomized to either ELND or nodal observation. By using Cox stepwise multivariate regression analysis, the independent predictors of outcome were tumor thickness (P < .001), the presence of tumor ulceration (P < .001), trunk site (P = .003), and patient age more than 60 years (P = .01).

RESULTS

Overall 10-year survival was not significantly different for patients who received ELND or nodal observation (77% vs. 73%; P = .12). Among the prospectively stratified subgroups of patients, 10-year survival rates favored those patients with ELND, with a 30% reduction in mortality rate for the 543 patients with nonulcerated melanomas (84% vs. 77%; P = .03), a 30% reduction in mortality rate for the 446 patients with tumor thickness of 1.0 to 2.0 mm (86% vs. 80%; P = .03), and a 27% reduction in mortality rate for 385 patients with limb melanomas (84% vs. 78%; P = .05). Of these subgroups, the presence or absence of ulceration should be the key factor for making treatment recommendations with regard to ELND for patients with intermediate thickness melanomas.

CONCLUSIONS

These long-term survival rates from patients treated at 77 institutions demonstrate that ulceration and tumor thickness are dominant predictive factors that should be used in the staging of stages I and II melanomas, and confer a survival advantage for these subgroups of prospectively defined melanoma patients.

Soft tissue masses of the chest wall and axilla: has metastatic melanoma been considered?

Isolated axillary and chest wall soft tissue masses are an uncommon presentation of metastatic cancer. The authors present three patients in whom malignant melanomas metastatic to these sites had been misdiagnosed, leading to inappropriate oncologic treatment planning in all three cases. The presumed diagnoses, even after fine-needle aspiration or trucut biopsies, were soft-tissue sarcoma (n = 2) and undifferentiated breast cancer (n = 1). The combination of taking a thorough history and performing proper immunohistochemical analysis of the biopsy material would have suggested the presence of malignant melanoma in all cases. As the disease appeared locoregionally limited in all patients, radical surgical resection with extended lymphadenectomy was performed without significant dysfunction of the upper extremity. One patient agreed to postoperative immunotherapy with interferon-alpha. Two patients are currently alive 17 and 14 months after operation. One patient was found to have systemic recurrence at 5 months, one experienced two isolated local recurrences in a prior operative site that were amenable to reresection and presently has no evidence of disease 12 months after resection, and one patient remains free of disease at 14 months. Clinical presentation, suggested diagnostic workup, and therapeutic implications are discussed to avoid misdiagnoses in this setting of possible clinical presentations of metastatic melanoma.

Multi-institutional melanoma lymphatic mapping experience: the prognostic value of sentinel lymph node status in 612 stage I or II melanoma patients

PURPOSE

To compare the effect of pathologic sentinel lymph node (SLN) status with that of other known prognostic factors on recurrence and survival in patients with stage I or II cutaneous melanoma.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

We reviewed the records of 612 patients with primary cutaneous melanoma who underwent lymphatic mapping and SLN biopsy between January 1991 and May 1995 to determine the effects of tumor thickness, ulceration, Clark level, location, sex, and SLN pathologic status on disease-free and disease-specific survival.

RESULTS

In the 580 patients in whom lymphatic mapping and SLN biopsy were successful, the SLN was positive by conventional histology in 85 patients (15%) but negative in 495 patients (85%). SLN status was the most significant prognostic factor with respect to disease-free and disease-specific survival by univariate and multiple covariate analyses. Although tumor thickness and ulceration influenced survival in SLN-negative patients, they provided no additional prognostic information in SLN-positive patients.

CONCLUSION

Lymphatic mapping and SLN biopsy is highly accurate in staging nodal basins at risk for regional metastases in primary melanoma patients and identifies those who may benefit from earlier lymphadenectomy. Furthermore, pathologic status of the SLN in these patients with clinically negative nodes is the most important prognostic factor for recurrence. The information from SLN biopsy is particularly helpful in establishing stratification criteria for future adjuvant trials.

Clinical outcomes of localized melanoma of the foot: a case-control study

The controversy over whether melanoma of the foot has a poorer prognosis than melanoma of the leg remains unresolved. This investigation used a case-control design to address this issue. This design consisted of a survival analysis of 119 cases with localized melanoma of the foot and 238 controls with localized melanoma of the leg that were matched on prognostic factors including tumor thickness, ulceration, surgical treatment, gender, year of diagnosis, and age. There was a statistically significant difference between the survival rates of cases and controls. The 5-year survival rate for cases was 74.3% compared to 85.2% for controls. At 10 years, the survival rate was 63.6% for cases and 77.2% for controls. Cases experienced a higher percentage of distant recurrences than controls. These results imply that patients with melanoma of the foot have a poorer survival than patients with melanoma of the leg after controlling for prognostic factors.

Is the capacity for lymph node-mediated distant dissemination the same for all nodal groups in malignant melanoma?

This study addresses two hypotheses: (1) that the inherent potential of melanoma metastatic to regional nodal groups for lymph-mediated distant dissemination may not be the same for all nodal groups; and (2) that the risk of distant metastases in patients with clinically involved nodal metastases is higher than in patients with clinically occult nodal metastases. It involved a retrospective chart review of patients with histologically involved axillary or inguinal nodes treated at Roswell Park Cancer Institute (RPCI) (244 patients) or at the participating institutes from the Intergroup Surgical Trial (IST) (108 patients). The distant recurrence rates of 623 melanomas with axillary or inguinal drainage from the IST data were also reviewed. In the RPCI data there was a significant difference in the overall and disease-free survival (P=0.0001) between patients with microscopic versus palpable involvement of the regional nodes in the axilla, while no such difference was observed for patients with groin metastases (P=0.30 and 0.36, respectively). The same trend was noted in the IST data. In the latter data the distant recurrence rate for melanomas drained via the axilla was significantly higher (P=0.026) than for those drained by the groin. In conclusion, lymph-mediated distant dissemination may be more aggressive from the axilla than from the groin in melanoma.

Prospective, randomized, double-blind study of prophylactic antibiotics in axillary lymph node dissection

BACKGROUND

Antibiotic prophylaxis is controversial in patients undergoing axillary lymph node dissection (ALND). We determined whether preoperative antibiotics decreased incidence or treatment cost of infectious complications following ALND.

METHODS

Two hundred patients entered this prospective, randomized, double-blind trial. Patients received either placebo or cefonicid preoperatively. Loco-regional signs of infection were monitored for 4 weeks postoperatively.

RESULTS

There was a trend toward fewer infections in the prophylactic group (placebo 13% versus cefonicid 6%; P = 0.080). Cefonicid significantly decreased severe infections requiring hospitalization (placebo 8% versus cefonicid 1%; P = 0.033). Cefonicid also decreased the treatment cost of infection per patient ($49.80 versus $364.87).

CONCLUSIONS

We demonstrated a trend toward fewer overall infections and significantly fewer severe infections in patients given prophylactic antibiotics, which translated into a decrease in the cost of treatment for infectious complications. These findings support antibiotic prophylaxis for patients undergoing ALND.

Surgical adjuvant active specific immunotherapy for patients with stage III melanoma: the final analysis of data from a phase III, randomized, double-blind, multicenter vaccinia melanoma oncolysate trial

BACKGROUND

A phase III, randomized, double-blind, multicenter trial of active specific immunotherapy (ASI) using vaccinia melanoma oncolysate (VMO) was performed in patients with stage III (American Joint Commission on Cancer) melanoma to determine the efficacy of VMO to increase the disease-free interval (DFI) or overall survival (OS) in these patients. Two interim analyses of data from this trial were performed in May 1994 and June 1995. Although the results from these analyses showed no statistically significant improvement in DFI or OS in all patients using VMO, two subsets-men aged 44-57 years with one to five positive nodes and all patients with clinical stage I and pathologic stage II disease-showed an overall survival advantage with VMO therapy. A final analysis of data from this trial was performed in May 1996 and is reported here. The design of future melanoma vaccine trials is discussed based on information learned from this first randomized, multicenter trial of ASI therapy.

STUDY DESIGN

A polyvalent VMO was prepared using melanoma cells derived from four melanoma cell lines and vaccinia vaccine virus (V). Patients were accrued from 11 United States institutions and were randomized by the Statistical Center at the University of Alabama, Birmingham. Two hundred fifty patients were randomized to treatment with either VMO (1 U containing 2 mg of total protein derived from 5 x 10(6) melanoma cells and 10(5.6) 50% tissue culture infectious dose of vaccinia virus) or control V (1 U containing 10(5.4) 50% tissue culture infectious dose of vaccinia virus) once a week for 13 weeks and then once every 2 weeks for a total of 12 months, or until recurrence. Patient data were collected by the Statistical Center and analyzed as of May 1996 for DFI and OS using Wilcoxon test and log-rank analysis.

RESULTS

Two hundred seventeen patients were found to be eligible according to the inclusion criteria. Data from these patients were analyzed for DFI and OS after a median followup of 46.3 months (50.2 months for VMO and 41.3 months for V). This final analysis showed no statistically significant increase in either DFI (p = 0.61) or OS (p = 0.79) of patients treated with VMO (n = 104) compared with V (n = 113). At 2-, 3-, and 5-year intervals, 47.8%, 43.8%, and 41.7% of patients treated with VMO were disease-free, respectively, compared with 51.2%, 44.8%, and 40.4% of patients treated with V. At the same intervals, 70.0%, 60.0%, and 48.6% of patients treated with VMO survived, compared with 65.4%, 55.6%, and 48.2% of patients treated with V. In a retrospective subset analysis, male patients aged 44-57 years (n = 20) with one to five positive nodes showed 18.9%, 26.82%, and 21.3% improvement in survival at 2-, 3-, and 5-year intervals, respectively, after treatment with VMO when compared with V (n = 18) (p = 0.046).

CONCLUSIONS

This study was a randomized, multicenter, placebo-controlled evaluation of an active specific immunotherapeutic agent to increase the DFI or OS of patients with stage III melanoma in a surgical adjuvant setting. In this trial, ASI with VMO when compared with V showed no difference in either DFI or OS. In a retrospective subset analysis, however, a subset of men with one to five positive nodes, between the ages of 44 and 57 years, showed a survival advantage with VMO. This result suggests that one must include a detailed subset analysis in the design of future trials of ASI for patients with American Joint Commission on Cancer stage III melanoma. An appropriate control arm also must be included in ASI trials.

Patterns of recurrence following a negative sentinel lymph node biopsy in 243 patients with stage I or II melanoma

PURPOSE

To determine the patterns of recurrence and causes of regional nodal basin failure in stage I or II melanoma patients who had a histologically negative sentinel lymph node (SLN) and whose regional nodal basins were not dissected following lymphatic mapping and SLN biopsy.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

The records of 344 patients with primary cutaneous melanoma who underwent lymphatic mapping and SLN biopsy between 1991 and 1995 at The University of Texas M.D. Anderson Cancer Center were reviewed. Of 322 patients who underwent successful lymphatic mapping procedures, 270 had histologically negative SLNs; mapped nodal basins were observed without further surgical intervention in 243 of these 270 patients. Recurrence patterns were analyzed from this cohort and a histologic reevaluation of all previously identified SLNs on which a biopsy had been taken was performed in patients who developed recurrent disease.

RESULTS

Of 243 patients with a histologically negative SLN, 27 (11%) developed local, in-transit, regional nodal, and/or distant metastases after a median follow-up time of 35 months. Ten patients (4.1%) developed a nodal recurrence in the previously mapped basin, either solely or as a component of the first site of recurrence. Detailed analysis of the SLNs in these 10 patients demonstrated evidence of occult metastases in 80% by serial sectioning or immunohistochemical staining.

CONCLUSION

Regional nodal failures in melanoma patients following a negative SLN biopsy are infrequent and to date have most commonly occurred because conventional histologic evaluation was unable to identify occult metastatic disease. These data provide further evidence that lymphatic mapping and SLN biopsy accurately reflect the status of the regional nodal basin. Specialized pathologic techniques are necessary to reduce further the already low false-negative rates and to improve disease staging.

Factors affecting survival following local, regional, or distant recurrence from localized melanoma

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Approximately one third of all melanoma patients will experience disease recurrence. Factors that affect patient survival following local, regional, or distant first recurrences of localized melanoma are the subject of this investigation.

METHODS

Survival times for a total of 1,085 first recurrences from 4,568 localized melanoma patients were examined in relationship to patient and disease factors by Cox regression. Nearly half (48.8%) of all first recurrences were regional, 21.8% were local, and 29.4% were distant recurrences.

RESULTS

Survival following recurrence differed significantly by site of recurrence (local, regional, or distant; P < 0.0001). Within each site, the median survival time did not differ by time of recurrence following diagnosis. Significant tumor factors for survival following local recurrence included tumor thickness (P = 0.0263) and lesion location (P < 0.0001). For regional recurrences, survival was significantly related to ulceration (P = 0.0105) and whether the recurrence was combined with a local recurrence (P = 0.0429). Survival following distant metastasis was related to number of distant sites (P < 0.0001) and whether a visceral site was involved (P < 0.0001).

CONCLUSIONS

Patient and tumor characteristics predict survival following recurrence. Regardless of disease-free interval, long-term follow-up of melanoma patients is necessary. Patients experiencing distant metastasis have the shortest median survival time compared to patients experiencing local or regional recurrences.

Factors affecting survival following local, regional, or distant recurrence from localized melanoma

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Approximately one third of all melanoma patients will experience disease recurrence. Factors that affect patient survival following local, regional, or distant first recurrences of localized melanoma are the subject of this investigation.

METHODS

Survival times for a total of 1,085 first recurrences from 4,568 localized melanoma patients were examined in relationship to patient and disease factors by Cox regression. Nearly half (48.8%) of all first recurrences were regional, 21.8% were local, and 29.4% were distant recurrences.

RESULTS

Survival following recurrence differed significantly by site of recurrence (local, regional, or distant; P < 0.0001). Within each site, the median survival time did not differ by time of recurrence following diagnosis. Significant tumor factors for survival following local recurrence included tumor thickness (P = 0.0263) and lesion location (P < 0.0001). For regional recurrences, survival was significantly related to ulceration (P = 0.0105) and whether the recurrence was combined with a local recurrence (P = 0.0429). Survival following distant metastasis was related to number of distant sites (P < 0.0001) and whether a visceral site was involved (P < 0.0001).

CONCLUSIONS

Patient and tumor characteristics predict survival following recurrence. Regardless of disease-free interval, long-term follow-up of melanoma patients is necessary. Patients experiencing distant metastasis have the shortest median survival time compared to patients experiencing local or regional recurrences.

Prognostic factors for survival of patients treated systemically for disseminated melanoma

PURPOSE

The current American Joint Commission on Cancer (AJCC) staging system distinguishes between soft tissue and visceral metastases in advanced (stage IV) melanoma. We sought to verify these staging criteria and to identify prognostic variables that could be used to evaluate the impact of systemic therapy on long-term survival during the prior decade.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

We conducted a retrospective study of patients with advanced cutaneous melanoma enrolled in clinical trials between 1979 and 1989 at The University of Texas M.D. Anderson Cancer Center. Pretreatment age, sex, number of organs with metastases, serum levels of lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) and albumin, and period of enrollment were analyzed using a Cox proportional hazards model of survival.

RESULTS

In univariate and multivariate analyses that involved 318 stage IV patients, normal serum levels of LDH and albumin, soft tissue and/or single visceral organ metastases (especially lung), female sex, and enrollment late in the decade were independent positive predictors for survival. In multivariate analyses, the current AJCC criteria did not significantly predict outcome. Systemic treatment response did not bias these results, and only 4% of patients had a complete response. Patients who lived more than 2 years (11%) had a mix of favorable prognostic characteristics and a high frequency of systemic or surgically induced complete response.

CONCLUSION

This study supports the use of stratification parameters that reflect the favorable prognostic impact of soft tissue or single visceral organ metastases and normal serum levels of LDH and albumin at time of enrollment in advanced melanoma trials. Improved survival over the prior decade probably reflects advances in diagnostic and palliative interventions.

Active immunotherapy with ultraviolet B-irradiated autologous whole melanoma cells plus DETOX in patients with metastatic melanoma

Our objective was to determine the clinical activity, toxicity, and immunological effects of active immunotherapy using UVB-irradiated (UVR) autologous tumor (AT) cells plus adjuvant DETOX in metastatic melanoma patients. Eligibility included nonanergic patients fully recovered after resection of 5 or more grams of metastatic melanoma. Treatment consisted of intradermal injections of 10(7) UVR-AT plus 0.25 ml of DETOX every 2 weeks x 6, then monthly. Peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) were harvested for cytotoxicity assays, and skin testing was performed for delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) determinations before the first, fourth, seventh, and subsequent treatments. Forty-two patients were treated, 18 in the adjuvant setting and 24 with measurable disease. Among the latter group, there were two durable responses in soft-tissue sites and in a bone metastasis. Treatment was well tolerated. Thirty-five patients were assessable for immunological parameters; 10 of these patients, including the 2 responders, demonstrated early induction of PBMC cytotoxicity against AT cells that persisted up to 10 months on treatment before falling to background levels. In five of seven patients, the fall-off heralded progressive disease. Late induction of a weak DTH reaction to AT cells was observed in eight patients. Active immunotherapy with UVR-AT + DETOX had modest but definite clinical activity in advanced melanoma. The induction of both PBMC cytotoxicity and DTH reactivity to AT cells supported a specific systemic immune effect of treatment, although the former more closely followed disease course in this study.

Increased survival of patients treated with a vaccinia melanoma oncolysate vaccine: second interim analysis of data from a phase III, multi-institutional trial

OBJECTIVE

The efficacy of vaccinia melanoma oncolysate (VMO) vaccine to increase overall survival and disease-free survival of patients with surgically resected International Union Against Cancer (UICC) stage II melanoma was studied in a phase III, randomized, multi-institutional trial.

SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA

Phase I and II trials with VMO showed minimal toxicity and clinical efficacy in patients with melanoma. In a recently completed phase III VMO trial, the first interim analysis performed in April 1994 showed an increasing trend in the survival of patients treated with VMO. The second interim analysis was performed in April 1995.

METHODS

Patients with surgically resected stage II (UICC) melanoma were treated with VMO (N = 104) or placebo vaccinia vaccine virus (V) (N = 113) once a week for 13 weeks and then once every 2 weeks for a total of 12 months. Patients' clinical data were collected as of May 1995 and analyzed for survival.

RESULTS

In this second interim analysis, the mean follow-up time is 42.28 months. No survival difference was observed between VMO and V treatments. However, in a retrospective subset analysis, a subset of males between the ages of 44 and 57 years and having one to five positive nodes (at 2-, 3-, and 5-year intervals, 13.6%, 15.9%, and 20.3% difference insurvival in favor of VMO [N = 20] when compared to V [N = 18] [p = 0.037]) and another subset of patients with clinical stage I (at 3- and 5-year intervals, 30% and 7% difference in survival in favor of VMO [N = 20] when compared to V [N = 23], [p = 0.05]) showed significant survival advantage with VMO.

CONCLUSIONS

Although VMO vaccine therapy in surgical adjuvant setting did not produce a significant survival benefit to all patients with melanoma, patients from the above two subsets had significant survival benefit.

Classification of localized melanoma by the exponential survival trees method

BACKGROUND

Over the past 2 decades, remarkable progress has been made in the identification of clinical and pathologic factors that affect the survival of patients with melanoma. Through the use of multivariate regression methods, key prognostic factors, such as tumor thickness, tumor ulceration, invasion level, and lesion location, have been identified. Clinical investigators are often interested in developing criteria to classify melanoma patients into different risk groups based on the key prognostic factors identified. However, classical multivariate regression models are generally less efficient in accomplishing this task than newly developed tree-based methods.

METHODS

In this study, the authors applied the exponential survival trees method to analyze a combined data set (n = 4568) from the University of Alabama at Birmingham and the Sydney Melanoma Unit in Camperdown, Australia. A survival tree was created according to prognostic factors that classified patients into homogeneous subgroups by survival. Six clinical and pathologic factors were included in the analysis. This tree-based method provided a superior means of prognostic classification and was shown to have greater ability to detect interactions among the variables than regression models.

RESULTS

Tumor thickness was found to be the most important prognostic factor, followed by tumor ulceration and primary lesion site. Some important interactions among these prognostic factors were identified. Five distinct risk groups, defined by tumor thickness, ulceration, and primary lesion site, were created. Patients who had tumor thickness less than or equal to 0.75 mm and lesions on their arms or legs had the best prognosis. Patients who had ulcerated tumors with thickness greater than 4.50 mm had the poorest prognosis.

CONCLUSIONS

The authors' analysis, based on exponential survival trees, provides a comprehensive, easy-to-use risk grouping system for classifying patients with localized melanoma. This grouping system would be useful in the clinical management of melanoma patients and in designing and analyzing clinical trials.

Critical analysis of the current American Joint Committee on Cancer staging system for cutaneous melanoma and proposal of a new staging system

PURPOSE

To critically review the accuracy of the current American Joint Committee on Cancer (AJCC) staging system for cutaneous melanoma and propose a more useful staging system.

METHODS

Retrospective evaluation of the published data as well as a reanalysis of the University of Alabama and Sydney Melanoma Unit (UAB/SMU) data bases (n = 4,568) for patients with primary melanoma was performed to examine specifically the impact of level of invasion and ulceration on the prognostic value of tumor thickness. In addition, an overlay graphic technique was used to compare the Kaplan-Meier survival curves of patients with local recurrences, satellites, in-transit metastases, and nodal metastases reported in the literature.

RESULTS

Tumor thickness and ulceration remained the most powerful prognostic indicators in patients with stage I and II disease. Level of invasion provided statistically significant prognostic information only in the subgroup of patients with tumor thickness < or = 1 mm, but the absolute 10-year survival differences were small and inconsistent (level II, 95%; level III, 85%; level IV, 89%). The best statistical fit for tumor thickness cutoffs was at 1 versus 2 versus 4 mm. The overlay graphic technique showed that patients who developed satellite lesions or local recurrence had prognoses similar to those of patients with stage III disease. The most important prognostic factor for patients with nodal metastases was number of involved nodes rather than size.

CONCLUSION

Our analysis showed that the current AJCC staging system has many inaccuracies that should be modified to conform to published data. On the basis of our analysis and review of the literature, we propose a new and more accurate staging system.