Cellular and molecular mechanisms of stress-induced premature senescence (SIPS) of human diploid fibroblasts and melanocytes

Does p53 affect organismal aging?

The p53 protein plays a critical role in the prevention of cancer. It responds to a variety of cellular stresses to induce either apoptosis, a transient cell cycle arrest, or a terminal cell cycle arrest called senescence. Senescence in cultured cells is associated with augmented p53 activity and abrogation of p53 activity may delay in vitro senescence. Increasing evidence suggests that p53 may also influence aspects of organismal aging. Several mutant mouse models that display alterations in longevity and aging-related phenotypes have defects in genes that alter p53 signaling. Recently, my laboratory has developed and characterized a p53 mutant mouse line that appears to have an enhanced p53 response. These p53 mutants exhibit increased cancer resistance, yet have a shortened longevity and display a number of early aging-associated phenotypes, suggesting a role for p53 in the aging process. The nature of the aging phenotypes observed in this p53 mutant line is consistent with a model in which aging is driven in part by a gradual depletion of stem cell functional capacity.

Aging is a deprivation syndrome driven by a germ-soma conflict

Evolution through natural selection can be described as driven by a perpetual conflict of individuals competing for limited resources. Recently, I postulated that the shortage of resources godfathered the evolutionary achievements of the differentiation-apoptosis programming [Rev. Neurosci. 12 (2001) 217]. Unicellular deprivation-induced differentiation into germ cell-like spores can be regarded as the archaic reproduction events which were fueled by the remains of the fratricided cells of the apoptotic fruiting body. Evidence has been accumulated suggesting that conserved through the ages as the evolutionary legacy of the germ-soma conflict, the somatic loss of immortality during the ontogenetic segregation of primordial germ cells recapitulates the archaic fate of the fruiting body. In this heritage, somatic death is a germ cell-triggered event and has been established as evolutionary-fixed default state following asymmetric reproduction in a world of finite resources. Aging, on the other hand, is the stress resistance-dependent phenotype of the somatic resilience that counteracts the germ cell-inflicted death pathway. Thus, aging is a survival response and, in contrast to current beliefs, is antagonistically linked to death that is not imposed by group selection but enforced upon the soma by the selfish genes of the "enemy within". Environmental conditions shape the trade-off solutions as compromise between the conflicting germ-soma interests. Mechanistically, the neuroendocrine system, particularly those components that control energy balance, reproduction and stress responses, orchestrate these events. The reproductive phase is a self-limited process that moulds onset and progress of senescence with germ cell-dependent factors, e.g. gonadal hormones. These degenerate the regulatory pacemakers of the pineal-hypothalamic-pituitary network and its peripheral, e.g. thymic, gonadal and adrenal targets thereby eroding the trophic milieu. The ensuing cellular metabolic stress engenders adaptive adjustments of the glucose-fatty acid cycle, responses that are adequate and thus fitness-boosting under fuel shortage (e.g. during caloric restriction) but become detrimental under fuel abundance. In a Janus-faced capacity, the cellular stress response apparatus expresses both tolerogenic and mutagenic features of the social and asocial deprivation responses [Rev. Neurosci. 12 (2001) 217]. Mediated by the derangement of the energy-Ca(2+)-redox homeostatic triangle, a mosaic of dedifferentiation/apoptosis and mutagenic responses actuates the gradual exhaustion of functional reserves and eventually results in a multitude of aging-related diseases. This scenario reconciles programmed and stochastic features of aging and resolves the major inconsistencies of current theories by linking ultimate and proximate causes of aging. Reproduction, differentiation, apoptosis, stress response and metabolism are merged into a coherent regulatory network that stages aging as a naturally selected, germ cell-triggered and reproductive phase-modulated deprivation response.

Lack of antibody production following immunization in old age: association with CD8(+)CD28(-) T cell clonal expansions and an imbalance in the production of Th1 and Th2 cytokines

Although it is generally recognized that the function of the immune system declines with age, the nature of the underlying defects is still poorly understood. We now demonstrate the predominance of CD8(+)CD28(-) T cell clonal expansions in elderly persons who fail to produce specific Abs following influenza vaccination. These clones express effector cell markers and are mostly CD45RA(+). When isolated and put into culture, they are unable to proliferate, but produce IFN-gamma (but no IL-5) upon stimulation with anti-CD3 or autoantigen. These autoreactive CD8(+) type 1 effector cells seem to trigger a Th1 polarization, as CD4(+) T cells from elderly persons without in vivo Ab production produce Th1, but only low amounts of Th2 cytokines upon in vitro stimulation with PHA. Therefore, the increased occurrence of CD8(+)CD28(-) clonal expansions may be decisive for the development of immune deficiency in the elderly.

Approach of evolutionary theories of ageing, stress, senescence-like phenotypes, calorie restriction and hormesis from the view point of far-from-equilibrium thermodynamics

B. L. Strehler wrote that "Any system that is not in thermodynamic equilibrium will approach that state at a rate that is a function of absolute temperature and the energy barriers to the rearrangements of components". Far-from-equilibrium thermodynamics allows a global systemic description of the cellular behaviour. This approach transcends the genetic and stochastic considerations on ageing as well as some evolutionary questions about ageing. The fundamental difference between the processes of development and ageing could reflect the intrinsic differences existing between biological systems where an increase in specific entropy production (SEP) is, respectively, still possible or not. The increase of the potential of SEP which probably occurred with evolution might explain in part why life span could increase. However, this SEP-driven increase in life span was possible only in those species which did not take advantage of their increased potential of SEP to ameliorate their reproductive capacity at the expense of possible increases in repair capacity. The criteria of stability of far-from-equilibrium open systems and the theory of attractors also help to sort the possible types of cellular stress responses: normal ageing, hormesis, stress-induced premature senescence, apoptosis or necrosis.

Identification of a candidate tumor-suppressor gene specifically activated during Ras-induced senescence

Normal cells display protective responses against oncogenes. Notably, oncogenic Ras triggers an irreversible proliferation arrest that is reminiscent of replicative senescence and that is considered a relevant tumor-suppressor mechanism. Here, we have used microarrayed filters to identify genes specifically upregulated in Ras-senescent human fibroblasts. Among the initial set of genes selected from the microarrays, we found the cell-cycle inhibitor p21(Cip1/Waf1), thus validating the potency of the screening to identify markers and mediators of Ras-senescence. A group of six genes, formed by those more highly upregulated during Ras-senescence, was analyzed in further detail to evaluate their specificity. In particular, we examined their expression in cells overexpressing Ras but rendered resistant to Ras-senescence by the viral oncoprotein E1a; also, we have studied their expression during replicative senescence, organismal aging, H(2)O(2)-induced senescence, and DNA damage. In this manner, we have identified a novel gene, RIS1 (for Ras-induced senescence 1), which is not upregulated in association to any of the above-mentioned processes, but exclusively during Ras-senescence. Furthermore, RIS1 is also upregulated by the transcriptional factor Ets2, which is a known mediator of Ras-induced senescence. Interestingly, RIS1 is located at chromosomal position 3p21.3 and, more specifically, it is included in a short segment of just 1 Mb previously defined by other investigators for its tumor-suppressor activity. In summary, we report the identification of a novel gene, RIS1, as a highly specific marker of Ras-induced senescence and a candidate tumor-suppressor gene.

Effects of telomerase and viral oncogene expression on the in vitro growth of human chondrocytes

Senescent chondrocytes accumulate with aging in articular cartilage, a process that interferes with cartilage homeostasis and increases the risk of cartilage degeneration. We showed previously that chondrocyte telomere length declines with donor age, which suggests that the aging process is telomere dependent. From these results we hypothesized that telomerase should delay the onset of senescence in cultured chondrocytes. Population doubling limits (PDL) were determined for chondrocytes expressing telomerase. We found that telomerase alone did not extend PDL beyond controls that senesced after 25 population doublings. The human papillomavirus 16 oncogenes E6 and E7 were transduced into the same cell population to investigate this telomere-independent form of senescence further. Chondrocytes expressing E6 and E7 grew longer than the telomerase cDNA (hTERT) cells but still senesced at 55 population doublings. In contrast, chondrocytes expressing telomerase with E6 and E7 grew vigorously past 100 population doublings. We conclude that although telomerase is necessary for the indefinite extension of chondrocyte life span, telomere-independent senescence limits PDL in vitro and may play a role in the age-related accumulation of senescent chondrocytes in vivo.

Senescence: does it all happen at the ends?

Over 60 years ago Barbara McClintock described the telomere and suggested that it protected the chromosome from illegitimate or end-to-end fusion, thus functioning to protect the genome. Since that time we have discovered that the telomere is a complex structure composed of both DNA and a growing list of associated proteins that together serve to regulate the length of the telomere and, as predicted by McClintock, protect genomic integrity. In addition to its protective role, the telomere has also been hypothesized to serve as a molecular clock that tallies the number of cell divisions and limits further divisions at a predetermined point. However, the precise role of telomeres in predicting and limiting cellular lifespan remains a matter of much debate. In this review, we highlight some of the salient points of basic telomere biology and relate them to the current controversies surrounding the role of telomeres and telomerase in cellular senescence.

Overexpression of apolipoprotein J in human fibroblasts protects against cytotoxicity and premature senescence induced by ethanol and tert-butylhydroperoxide

Human diploid fibroblasts (HDFs) exposed to subcytotoxic stresses under H2O2, tert-butylhydroperoxide (t-BHP), and ethanol (EtOH) undergo stress-induced premature senescence (SIPS) characterized by many biomarkers of HDFs replicative senescence. Among these biomarkers are a growth arrest, an increase in the senescence-associated beta-galactosidase activity, a senescent morphology, an overexpression of p21waf-1 and the subsequent inability to phosphorylate pRb, the presence of the common 4977-bp mitochondrial deletion, and an increase in the steady-state level of several senescence-associated genes such as apolipoprotein J (apo J). Apo J has been described as a survival gene against cytotoxic stress. In order to study whether apo J would be protective against cytotoxicity SIPS and replicative senescence in human fibroblasts, a full-length complementary deoxyribonucleic acid of apo J was transfected into WI-38 HDFs and SV40-transformed WI-38 HDFs. The overexpression of apo J resulted in an increased cell survival after t-BHP and EtOH stresses at cytotoxic concentrations. In addition, when WI-38 HDFs were exposed to 5 subcytotoxic stresses with EtOH or t-BHP, in conditions that were previously shown to induce SIPS, a lower induction of 2 biomarkers of SIPS was observed in HDFs overexpressing apo J. No effect of apo J overexpression was observed on the proliferative life span of HDFs, even if apo J overexpression triggered osteonectin (SPARC) overexpression, which was shown to decrease the mitogenic potential of platelet-derived growth factor but not of other common growth-inducing conditions. Apo J senescence-related overexpression is proposed to have antiapoptotic rather than antiproliferative effects.

Putting the stress on senescence

Cultivation of primary cells over many generations eventually results in a reproducible loss of proliferative potential that has been termed 'replicative senescence'. Recent work has revealed the heterogeneity of senescence. Importantly, the analysis of the various aspects and types of senescence has turned out to be very informative about numerous in vivo processes, and particularly about carcinogenesis.

BJ fibroblasts display high antioxidant capacity and slow telomere shortening independent of hTERT transfection

Human foreskin BJ fibroblasts are well protected against oxidative stress as shown by their low intracellular peroxide content, low levels of protein carbonyls, and low steady-state lipofuscin content as compared to other primary human fibroblasts. This correlates with a long replicative life span of the parental cells of about 90 population doublings and a telomere-shortening rate of only 15-20 bp/PD. This value might define the upper limit of a telomere-shortening rate that can still be explained by the end replication problem alone. In BJ clones immortalized by transfection with hTERT, the catalytic subunit of telomerase, the same telomere-shortening rate as in parental cells is observed over a long time despite strong telomerase activity. Hyperoxia, which induces oxidative stress and accelerates telomere shortening in a variety of human fibroblast strains, does not do so in BJ cells. It is possible that the high antioxidative capacity of BJ cells, by minimizing the accumulation of genomic damage, is instrumental in the successful immortalization of these cells by telomerase.

Telomeres and replicative senescence: Is it only length that counts?

Telomeres are well established as a major 'replicometer', counting the population doublings in primary human cell cultures and ultimately triggering replicative senescence. However, neither is the pace of this biological clock inert, nor is there a fixed threshold telomere length acting as the universal trigger of replicative senescence. The available data suggest that opening of the telomeric loop and unscheduled exposure of the single-stranded G-rich telomeric overhang might act like a semaphore to signal senescent cell cycle arrest. Short telomere length, telomeric single-strand breaks, low levels of loop-stabilizing proteins, or other factors may trigger this opening of the loop. Thus, both telomere shortening and the ultimate signalling into senescence are able to integrate different environmental and genetic factors, especially oxidative stress-mediated damage, which might otherwise become a thread to genomic stability.

Stress, DNA damage and ageing -- an integrative approach

Ageing is highly complex, involving multiple mechanisms at different levels. Nevertheless, recent evidence suggests that several of the most important mechanisms are linked via endogenous stress-induced DNA damage caused by reactive oxygen species (ROS). Understanding how such damage contributes to age-related changes requires that we explain how these different mechanisms relate to each other and potentially interact. In this article, we review the contributions of stress-induced damage to cellular DNA through (i) the role of damage to nuclear DNA and its repair mediated via the actions of poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase-1, (ii) the role of damage to telomeric DNA and its contribution to telomere-driven cell senescence, and (iii) the role of damage to and the accumulation of mutations in mitochondrial DNA. We describe how an integrative approach to studying these mechanisms, coupled with computational modelling, may be of considerable importance in resolving some of the complexity of cellular ageing.

Subcytotoxic H2O2 stress triggers a release of transforming growth factor-beta 1, which induces biomarkers of cellular senescence of human diploid fibroblasts

Stress-induced premature senescence (SIPS) is induced 3 days after exposure of human diploid fibroblasts to subcytotoxic oxidative stress with H(2)O(2), with appearance of several biomarkers of replicative senescence. In this work, we show that transforming growth factor-beta1 (TGF-beta1) regulates the induction of several of these biomarkers in SIPS: cellular morphology, senescence-associated beta-galactosidase activity, increase in the steady-state level of fibronectin, apolipoprotein J, osteonectin, and SM22 mRNA. Indeed, the neutralization of TGF-beta1 or its receptor (TGF-beta RII) using specific antibodies decreases sharply the percentage of cells positive for the senescent-associated beta-galactosidase activity and displaying a senescent morphology. In the presence of each of these antibodies, the steady-state level of fibronectin, osteonectin, apolipoprotein J, and SM22 mRNA is no more increased at 72 h after stress. Results obtained on fibroblasts retrovirally transfected with the human papillomavirus E7 cDNA suggest that retinoblastoma protein (Rb) regulates the expression of TGF-beta1 in stressful conditions, leading to SIPS and overexpression of these four genes.