Directed self-assembly of monodisperse phospholipid bilayer Nanodiscs with controlled size

Cooperativity in cytochrome P450 3A4: linkages in substrate binding, spin state, uncoupling, and product formation

Understanding the detailed metabolic mechanisms of membrane-associated cytochromes P450 is often hampered by heterogeneity, ill-defined oligomeric state of the enzyme, and variation in the stoichiometry of the functional P450.reductase complexes in various reconstituted systems. Here, we describe the detailed characterization of a functionally homogeneous 1:1 complex of cytochrome P450 3A4 (CYP3A4) and cytochrome P450 reductase solubilized via self-assembly in a nanoscale phospholipid bilayer. CYP3A4 in this complex showed a nearly complete conversion from the low- to high-spin state when saturated with testosterone (TS) and no noticeable modulation due to the presence of cytochrome P450 reductase. Global analysis of equilibrium substrate binding and steady-state NADPH consumption kinetics provided precise resolution of the fractional contributions to turnover of CYP3A4 intermediates with one, two, or three TS molecules bound. The first binding event accelerates NADPH consumption but does not result in significant product formation due to essentially complete uncoupling. Binding of the second substrate molecule is critically important for catalysis, as the product formation rate reaches a maximum value with two TS molecules bound, whereas the third binding event significantly improves the coupling efficiency of redox equivalent usage with no further increase in product formation rate. The resolution of the fractional contributions of binding intermediates of CYP3A4 into experimentally observed overall spin shift and the rates of steady-state NADPH oxidation and product formation provide new detailed insight into the mechanisms of cooperativity and allosteric regulation in this human cytochrome P450.

The local phospholipid environment modulates the activation of blood clotting

Examples abound of membrane-bound enzymes for which the local membrane environment plays an important role, including the ectoenzyme that triggers blood clotting, the plasma serine protease, factor VIIa, bound to the integral membrane protein, tissue factor. The activity of this enzyme complex is markedly influenced by lipid bilayer composition and further by tissue factor partitioning into membrane microdomains on some cell surfaces. Unfortunately, little is known about how membrane microdomain composition controls factor VIIa-tissue factor activity, as reactions catalyzed by membrane-tethered enzymes are typically studied under conditions in which the experimenter cannot control the composition of the membrane in the immediate vicinity of the enzyme. To overcome this problem, we used a nanoscale approach that afforded complete control over the membrane environment surrounding tissue factor by assembling the factor VIIa.tissue factor complex on stable bilayers containing 67 +/- 1 phospholipid molecules/leaflet (Nanodiscs). We investigated how local changes in phospholipid bilayer composition modulate the activity of the factor VIIa.tissue factor complex. We also addressed whether this enzyme requires a pool of membrane-bound protein substrate (factor X) for efficient catalysis, or alternatively if it could efficiently activate factor X, which binds directly to the membrane nanodomain adjacent to tissue factor. We have shown that full proteolytic activity of the factor VIIa.tissue factor complex requires extremely high local concentrations of anionic phospholipids and further that a large pool of membrane-bound factor X is not required to support sustained catalysis.

Using Nanodiscs to create water-soluble transmembrane chemoreceptors inserted in lipid bilayers

In this chapter we describe application of the emerging technology of Nanodiscs to chemoreceptors, a class of transmembrane proteins that presents many challenges to the investigator. Nanodiscs are soluble, nanoscale ( approximately 10nm diameter) particles of lipid bilayer surrounded by an annulus of amphipathic protein, the membrane scaffold protein. A transmembrane protein inserted in a Nanodisc is surrounded by a lipid bilayer much as it is prior to detergent solublization. Thus, the Nanodisc-inserted protein is in an environment that approximates its native state. Yet, that membrane protein is also water-soluble and segregated from other membrane proteins because the bilayer into which it is inserted is of very limited size and, with appropriate preparation, contains only a single protein. In a Nanodisc, the water-soluble, bilayer-inserted membrane protein can be purified by conventional techniques and analyzed for activities and interactions as a pure entity. Thus, Nanodisc technology has great promise for improving isolation, purification, and characterization of the many membrane proteins that are difficult to handle, become unstable, or lose native activity when surrounded by detergent instead of lipid bilayer. The technology has proven useful for the investigation of chemoreceptor activity as a function of oligomeric state.

Structural analysis of nanoscale self-assembled discoidal lipid bilayers by solid-state NMR spectroscopy

Nanodiscs are an example of discoidal nanoscale self-assembled lipid/protein particles similar to nascent high-density lipoproteins, which reduce the risk of coronary artery disease. The major protein component of high-density lipoproteins is human apolipoprotein A-I, and the corresponding protein component of Nanodiscs is membrane scaffold protein 1 (MSP1), a 200-residue lipid-binding domain of human apolipoprotein A-I. Here we present magic-angle spinning (MAS) solid-state NMR studies of uniformly (13)C,(15)N-labeled MSP1 in polyethylene glycol precipitated Nanodiscs. Two-dimensional MAS (13)C-(13)C correlation spectra show excellent microscopic order of MSP1 in precipitated Nanodiscs. Secondary isotropic chemical shifts throughout the protein are consistent with a predominantly helical structure. Moreover, the backbone conformations of prolines derived from their (13)C chemical shifts are consistent with the molecular belt model but not the picket fence model of lipid-bound MSP1. Overall comparison of experimental spectra and (13)C chemical shifts predicted from several structural models also favors the belt model. Our study thus supports the belt model of Nanodisc structure and demonstrates the utility of MAS NMR to study the structure of high molecular weight lipid-protein complexes.

Structure by design: from single proteins and their building blocks to nanostructures

Nanotechnology realizes the advantages of naturally occurring biological macromolecules and their building-block nature for design. Frequently, assembly starts with the choice of a "good" molecule that is synthetically optimized towards the desired shape. By contrast, we propose starting with a pre-specified nanostructure shape, selecting candidate protein building blocks from a library and mapping them onto the shape and, finally, testing the stability of the construct. Such a shape-based, part-assembly strategy is conceptually similar to protein design through the combinatorial assembly of building blocks. If the conformational preferences of the building blocks are retained and their interactions are favorable, the nanostructure will be stable. The richness of the conformations, shapes and chemistries of the protein building blocks suggests a broad range of potential applications; at the same time, it also highlights their complexity. In this Opinion article, we focus on the first step: validating such a strategy against experimental data.

Assembly of lipoprotein particles revealed by coarse-grained molecular dynamics simulations

High-density lipoproteins (HDL) function as cholesterol transporters, facilitating the removal of excess cholesterol from the body. Due to the heterogeneity of native HDL particles (both in size and shape), the details on how these protein-lipid particles form and the structure they assume in their lipid-associated states are not well characterized. We report here a study of the self-assembly of discoidal HDL particles using coarse-grained (CG) molecular dynamics. The microsecond simulations reveal the self-assembly of HDL particles from disordered protein-lipid complexes to form structures containing many of the features of the generally accepted double-belt model for discoidal HDL particles. HDL assembly is found to proceed in two broad steps, aggregation of proteins and lipids driven by the hydrophobic effect which occurs on a approximately 1 micros time scale, followed by the optimization of the protein structure driven by increasingly specific protein-protein interactions.

A model structure for the heterodimer apoA-IMilano-apoA-II supports its peculiar susceptibility to proteolysis

In this study, we propose a structure for the heterodimer between apolipoprotein A-I(Milano) and apolipoprotein A-II (apoA-I(M)-apoA-II) in a synthetic high-density lipoprotein (HDL) containing L-alpha-palmitoyloleoyl phosphatidylcholine. We applied bioinformatics/computational tools and procedures, such as molecular docking, molecular and essential dynamics, starting from published crystal structures for apolipoprotein A-I and apolipoprotein A-II. Structural and energetic analyses onto the simulated system showed that the molecular dynamics produced a stabilized synthetic HDL. The essential dynamic analysis showed a deviation from the starting belt structure. Our structural results were validated by limited proteolysis experiments on HDL from apoA-I(M) carriers in comparison with control HDL. The high sensitivity of apoA-I(M)-apoA-II to proteases was in agreement with the high root mean-square fluctuation values and the reduction in secondary structure content from molecular dynamics data. Circular dichroism on synthetic HDL containing apoA-I(M)-apoA-II was consistent with the alpha-helix content computed on the proposed model.

Nanodiscs separate chemoreceptor oligomeric states and reveal their signaling properties

Bacterial chemoreceptors are transmembrane homodimers that can form trimers, higher order arrays, and extended clusters as part of signaling complexes. Interactions of dimers in oligomers are thought to confer cooperativity and cross-receptor influences as well as a 35-fold gain between ligand binding and altered kinase activity. In addition, higher order interactions among dimers are necessary for the observed patterns of assistance in adaptational modification among different receptors. Elucidating mechanisms underlying these properties will require defining which receptor functions can be performed by dimers and which require specific higher order interactions. However, such an assignment has not been possible. Here, we used Nanodiscs, an emerging technology for manipulating membrane proteins, to prepare small particles of lipid bilayer containing one or only a few chemoreceptor dimers. We found that receptor dimers isolated in individual Nanodiscs were readily modified, bound ligand, and performed transmembrane signaling. However, they were hardly able to activate the chemotaxis histidine kinase. Instead, maximal activation and thus full-range control of kinase occurred preferentially in discs containing approximately three chemoreceptor dimers. The sharp dependence of kinase activation on this number of receptors per dimer implies that the core structural unit of kinase activation and control is a trimer of dimers. Thus, our observations demonstrate that chemoreceptor transmembrane signaling does not require oligomeric organization beyond homodimers and implicate a trimer of dimers as the unit of downstream signaling.

Current views on the fundamental mechanisms of cytochrome P450 allosterism

Clinically relevant cytochrome P450 (CYP)-dependent drug metabolism and drug-drug interactions remain difficult to predict on the basis of in vitro data. One contribution to this difficulty is the complex allosteric kinetics that CYPs exhibit in vitro. In principle, an understanding of this behaviour at the molecular level could improve in vitro-in vivo correlations and prediction of in vivo drug behaviour. Recent results suggest a multiplicity of allosteric mechanisms, including drug-dependent conformational changes and protein conformational heterogeneity, occupancy by separate drug molecules of discrete binding sites, potentially at remote locations, and drug concentration-dependent or effector concentration-dependent orientation within the active site of the drug being metabolised. Most importantly, the recent research provides optimism that we can understand these complex enzymes; the research has included the creative use of biophysical techniques previously thought to be inapplicable to CYPs.

The ferrous-dioxygen intermediate in human cytochrome P450 3A4. Substrate dependence of formation and decay kinetics

The oxy-ferrous complex is the first of three branching intermediates in the catalytic cycle of cytochrome P450, in which the total efficiency of substrate turnover is curtailed by the side reaction of autoxidation. For human membrane-bound cytochromes P450, the oxy complex is believed to be the primary source of cytotoxic superoxide and peroxide, although information on the properties and stability of this intermediate is lacking. Here we document stopped-flow spectroscopic studies of the formation and decay of the oxy-ferrous complex in the most abundant human cytochrome P450 (CYP3A4) as a function of temperature in the substrate-free and substrate-bound form. CYP3A4 solubilized in purified monomeric form in nanoscale POPC bilayers is functionally and kinetically homogeneous. In substrate-free CYP3A4, the oxy complex is extremely unstable with a half-life of approximately 30 ms at 5 degrees C. Saturation with testosterone or bromocriptine stabilizes the oxy-ferrous intermediate. Comparison of the autoxidation rates with the available data on CYP3A4 turnover kinetics suggests that the oxy complex may be an important route for uncoupling.

Assembly of single bacteriorhodopsin trimers in bilayer nanodiscs

Nanodiscs, phospholipid bilayer assemblies of controlled size, were used to self-assemble bacteriorhodopsin (bR) into single trimers. Self-assembly at optimal bR to Nanodisc and phospholipid stoichiometry yielded particles containing three bR molecules. Analysis of solution small angle X-ray scattering indicated that bacteriorhodopsin is embedded in a discoidal phospholipid bilayer structure. Formation of trimers, as evidenced by visible circular dichroism of the retinal absorbance bands, is facilitated in Nanodiscs at a specific size threshold, suggesting that a critical bilayer area or amount of lipid is necessary to maintain a native oligomeric state. The lipid to bR ratio in the assembly process was also found to be an important factor in determining oligomerization state. These nanoscale bilayers offer the opportunity to understand and control the assembly of oligomeric integral membrane proteins critical to macromolecular recognition and cellular signaling.

Functional reconstitution of β2-adrenergic receptors utilizing self-assembling Nanodisc technology

Integral membrane G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) compose the single most prolific class of drug targets, yet significant functional and structural questions remain unanswered for this superfamily. A primary reason for this gap in understanding arises from the difficulty of forming soluble, monodisperse receptor membrane preparations that maintain the trans-membrane signaling activity of the receptor and provide robust biophysical and biochemical assay systems. Here we report a technique for self-assembling functional 2-adrenergic receptor (β2AR) into a nanoscale phospholipid bilayer system (Nanodisc) that is highly soluble in aqueous solution. The approximately 10-nm nanobilayer particles contain β2AR in a native-like phospholipid bilayer domain of approximately 100 phospholipid molecules circumferentially bound by a membrane scaffold protein (MSP). The resulting construct allows for access to the physiologically intracellular and extracellular faces of the receptor and thus allows unrestricted access of antagonists, agonists, and G proteins. These Nanodisc-solubilized GPCRs can be directly purified by normal chromatographic procedures. We define the resultant Nanodisc-embedded monomeric β2AR by antagonist and agonist binding isotherms and demonstrate faithful G protein coupling.

Kinetics of dithionite-dependent reduction of cytochrome P450 3A4: heterogeneity of the enzyme caused by its oligomerization

To explore the basis of apparent conformational heterogeneity of cytochrome P450 3A4 (CYP3A4), the kinetics of dithionite-dependent reduction was studied in solution, in proteoliposomes, and in Nanodiscs. In CYP3A4 oligomers in solution the kinetics obeys a three-exponential equation with similar amplitudes of each of the phases. Addition of substrate (bromocriptine) displaces the phase distribution toward the slow phase at the expense of the fast one, while the middle phase remains unaffected. The fraction reduced in the fast phase, either with or without substrate, is represented by the low-spin heme protein only, while the slow-reducible fraction is enriched in the high-spin CYP3A4. Upon monomerization by 0.15% Emulgen-913, or by incorporation into Nanodiscs or into large proteoliposomes with a high lipid-to-protein (L/P) ratio (726:1 mol/mol), the kinetics observed in the absence of substrate becomes very rapid and virtually monoexponential. In Nanodiscs and in lipid-rich liposomes bromocriptine decreases the rate of reduction via appearance of the second (slow) phase, the amplitude of which reaches 100% at saturating bromocriptine. In contrast, in P450-rich liposomes (L/P = 112 mol/mol), where the surface molar density of the enzyme is comparable to that observed in liver microsomes, CYP3A4 behaves similarly to that observed in solution. These results suggest that in CYP3A4 oligomers in solution and in the membrane the enzyme is distributed between two persistent conformers with different accessibility of the heme for the reductant (SO*-(2) anion monomer). One of the apparent conformers exists in a substrate-dependent equilibrium between two states with different rate constants of reduction by dithionite, while the second conformer shows no response to substrate binding.

The role of molecular modeling in bionanotechnology

Molecular modeling is advocated here as a key methodology for research and development in bionanotechnology. Molecular modeling provides nanoscale images at atomic and even electronic resolution, predicts the nanoscale interaction of unfamiliar combinations of biological and inorganic materials, and evaluates strategies for redesigning biopolymers for nanotechnological uses. The methodology is illustrated in this paper through reviewing three case studies. The first one involves the use of single-walled carbon nanotubes as biomedical sensors where a computationally efficient, yet accurate, description of the influence of biomolecules on nanotube electronic properties through nanotube-biomolecule interactions was developed; this development furnishes the ability to test nanotube electronic properties in realistic biological environments. The second case study involves the use of nanopores manufactured into electronic nanodevices based on silicon compounds for single molecule electrical recording, in particular, for DNA sequencing. Here, modeling combining classical molecular dynamics, material science and device physics, described the interaction of biopolymers, e.g., DNA, with silicon nitrate and silicon oxide pores, furnished accurate dynamic images of pore translocation processes, and predicted signals. The third case study involves the development of nanoscale lipid bilayers for the study of embedded membrane proteins and cholesterol. Molecular modeling tested scaffold proteins, redesigned apolipoproteins found in mammalian plasma that hold the discoidal membranes in the proper shape, and predicted the assembly as well as final structure of the nanodiscs. In entirely new technological areas such as bionanotechnology, qualitative concepts, pictures and suggestions are sorely needed; these three case studies document that molecular modeling can serve a critical role in this respect, even though it may still fall short on quantitative precision.

Functional Liquid-Crystalline Assemblies: Self-Organized Soft Materials

In the 21st century, soft materials will become more important as functional materials because of their dynamic nature. Although soft materials are not as highly durable as hard materials, such as metals, ceramics, and engineering plastics, they can respond well to stimuli and the environment. The introduction of order into soft materials induces new dynamic functions. Liquid crystals are ordered soft materials consisting of self-organized molecules and can potentially be used as new functional materials for electron, ion, or molecular transporting, sensory, catalytic, optical, and bio-active materials. For this functionalization, unconventional materials design is required. Herein, we describe new approaches to the functionalization of liquid crystals and show how the design of liquid crystals formed by supramolecular assembly and nano-segregation leads to the formation of a variety of new self-organized functional materials.

Unusual protein behavior illustrated with silk fibroin

We investigated the interaction between phospholipid membranes and silk fibroin recovered from the posterior silk gland of the silkworm. Observations of the planar lipid bilayer membrane and electron microscopic observations of liposomes showed that newly constructed silk fibroin, existing in the form of filaments, quickly penetrates phospholipid membranes without bursting them.

Development and initial evaluation of PEG-stabilized bilayer disks as novel model membranes

We show in this study that stable dispersions dominated by flat bilayer disks may be prepared from a carefully optimized mixture of 1,2-distearoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DSPC), cholesterol, and 1,2-distearoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphoethanolamine-N-[methoxy(polyethyleneglycol)-5000] [PEG-DSPE(5000)]. By varying the content of the latter component, the average diameter of the disks can be changed in the interval from about 15 to 60 nm. The disks show excellent long-term stability, and their size and structure remain unaltered in the temperature range between 25 and 37 degrees C. The utility of the disks as artificial model membranes was confirmed and compared to uni- and multilamellar liposomes in a series of drug partition studies. Data obtained by isothermal titration calorimetry and drug partition chromatography (also referred to as immobilized liposome chromatography) indicate that the bilayer disks may serve as an attractive and sometimes superior alternative to liposomes in studies aiming at the investigation of drug-membrane interactions. The disks may, in addition, hold great potential for structure/function studies of membrane-bound proteins. Furthermore, we suggest that the sterically stabilized bilayer disks may prove interesting as carriers for in vivo delivery of protein/peptide, as well as conventional amphiphilic and/or hydrophobic, drugs.

Molecular dynamics simulations of discoidal bilayers assembled from truncated human lipoproteins

Human apolipoprotein A-1 (apo A-1) is the major protein component of high-density lipoproteins. The apo A-1 lipid-binding domain was used as a template for the synthesis of amphipathic helical proteins termed membrane scaffold proteins, employed to self-assemble soluble monodisperse discoidal particles called Nanodiscs. In these particles, membrane scaffold proteins surround a lipid bilayer in a belt-like fashion forming bilayer disks of discrete size and composition. Here we investigate the structure of Nanodiscs through molecular dynamics simulations in which Nanodiscs were built from scaffold proteins of various lengths. The simulations showed planar or deformed Nanodiscs depending on optimal length and alignment of the scaffold proteins. Based on mean surface area per lipid calculations, comparison of small-angle x-ray scattering curves, and the relatively planar shape of Nanodiscs made from truncated scaffold proteins, one can conclude that the first 17 to 18 residues of the 200-residue apo A-1 lipid-binding domain are not involved in formation of the protein "belts" surrounding the lipid bilayer. To determine whether the addition of an integral membrane protein has an effect on the overall structure of a Nanodisc, bacteriorhodopsin was embedded into a Nanodisc and simulated using molecular dynamics, revealing a planar disk with a slightly rectangular shape.

Homotropic cooperativity of monomeric cytochrome P450 3A4 in a nanoscale native bilayer environment

Mechanistic studies of mammalian cytochrome P450s are often obscured by the phase heterogeneity of solubilized preparations of membrane enzymes. The various protein-protein aggregation states of microsomes, detergent solubilized cytochrome or a family of aqueous multimeric complexes can effect measured substrate binding events as well as subsequent steps in the reaction cycle. In addition, these P450 monooxygenases are normally found in a membrane environment and the bilayer composition and dynamics can also effect these catalytic steps. Here, we describe the structural and functional characterization of a homogeneous monomeric population of cytochrome P450 3A4 (CYP 3A4) in a soluble nanoscale membrane bilayer, or Nanodisc [Nano Lett. 2 (2002) 853]. Cytochrome P450 3A4:Nanodisc assemblies were formed and purified to yield a 1:1 ratio of CYP 3A4 to Nanodisc. Solution small angle X-ray scattering was used to structurally characterize this monomeric CYP 3A4 in the membrane bilayer. The purified CYP 3A4:Nanodiscs showed a heretofore undescribed high level of homotropic cooperativity in the binding of testosterone. Soluble CYP 3A4:Nanodisc retains its known function and shows prototypic hydroxylation of testosterone when driven by hydrogen peroxide. This represents the first functional characterization of a true monomeric preparation of cytochrome P450 monooxygenase in a phospholipid bilayer and elucidates new properties of the monomeric form.