Patient satisfaction following laparoscopic and open antireflux surgery

Antireflux surgery. Indications, preoperative evaluation, and outcome

Gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) is an extremely common disorder. Many patients require lifelong medical therapy for symptom control. In patients being considered for antireflux surgery, thorough evaluation is required. Laparoscopic antireflux surgery is a safe and effective method of treating patients who have severe, refractory, or complicated GERD. Excellent long-term results are obtained with minimal morbidity, freeing the patient from the burden of chronic medical therapy.

Comparison of symptomatic and quality of life outcomes of laparoscopic versus open antireflux surgery

BACKGROUND

Even though laparoscopic antireflux procedures have become the surgical treatment of choice for gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD), little quantitative data exist comparing symptomatic and quality of life outcomes between laparoscopic and standard open procedures. This study was done to compare short-term outcomes.

METHODS

All patients referred for surgical treatment of GERD are prospectively followed with a disease-specific reflux symptom score (the GERD-HRQL, best score 0, worst score 50) and a generic quality of life questionnaire (the SF-36, best score 100, worst score 0). Patients are evaluated preoperatively and at least 6 weeks postoperatively. Patients were treated with either laparoscopic or open Nissen (360-degree wrap) or Toupet (270-degree wrap) fundoplications.

RESULTS

Sixty patients underwent laparoscopic surgery (LS) and 20 open surgery (OS). LS and OS had significant improvement in the median GERD-HRQL scores, 27 to 3 and 27 to 1, respectively, both P < .000001. LS had statistically significant improvements in the SF-36 domains of mental health (62 to 71.5, P = .05) and general health (57 to 67, P = .004). There was no worsening in any of the other 6 domains. OS produced a worsening score in the domain of physical functioning (75 to 67.5, P = .02). LS had better postoperative scores compared with OS in the domains of physical functioning (80 vs 67.5, P = .05) and trended to better scores in bodily pain (64 vs 51.5, P = .09).

CONCLUSIONS

LS produces equivalent improvement in reflux symptoms compared with OS, with improved general quality of life outcomes.

Partial fundoplications for gastroesophageal reflux disease: indications and current status

The Nissen fundoplication, and in particular the laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication, has received widespread acceptance as the most definitive therapy for gastroesophageal reflux disease. There remains, however, certain patients who do better with a less aggressive surgical augmentation of the lower esophageal sphincter. Partial fundoplications originated in the early 1960s as an alternative procedure to the Nissen, which was associated with moderately high rates of postoperative side effects. These "more physiologic" procedures have proved successful in the treatment of reflux disease in patients with poor or no esophageal motility. In particular, the use of partial fundoplications in association with Heller's myotomy for achalasia has been demonstrated to be well tolerated and to reduce the risk of late dysphasia resulting from uncontrolled gastroesophageal reflux (GER). The use of partial fundoplications in GER patients with normal motility, however, has been less successful. High recurrence rates are documented by many centers with the main cause appearing to be related to a less competent neo-lower esophageal sphincter and a higher rate of wrap herniation. This has led to the current practice of a "tailored approach" to reflux disease, in which all patients receive a thorough preoperative physiologic evaluation to determine the best antireflux procedure for the individual. This is generally a Nissen repair for those with normal motility and either an extrashort "floppy" Nissen or a partial wrap for those with impaired peristalsis.

Outcome of erosive reflux esophagitis after Nissen fundoplication

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to compare the utilization of health care resources and long term outcome of erosive esophagitis in patients treated with and without open Nissen fundoplication.

METHODS

A population of 35,725 patients with erosive esophagitis was extracted from the computerized database of the US Department of Veterans Affairs. Subjects were stratified by severity of disease into erosive esophagitis alone versus erosive esophagitis complicated by esophageal ulcers or peptic strictures. During a mean follow-up period of 4.2 yr (range 1-12 yr), the consumption of health care resources, except for medications, was compared between case and control subjects treated with and without fundoplication, respectively.

RESULTS

Among patients with complicated erosive esophagitis, 5,064 control subjects were treated without, and 542 case subjects were treated with, fundoplication. Cases incurred less recurrence of esophageal erosions (controls: 56% vs cases: 46%), esophageal ulcers (38% vs 33%), and peptic strictures (43% vs 32%) during follow-up. Among patients with erosive esophagitis but no complications, 29,514 control subjects were treated without, and 605 case subjects were treated with, fundoplication. Cases did not experience any change in the recurrence of esophageal erosions (controls: 25% vs cases: 24%). Irrespective of treatment type, none of the case or control subjects with erosive esophagitis alone developed esophageal ulcers or peptic strictures during follow-up. Compared with controls, however, after fundoplication in erosive esophagitis alone, cases incurred more dysphagia (2.6% vs 4.6%), postsurgical syndromes (0.8% vs 1.7%), as well as more outpatient visits (34 vs 40 visits/patient) and outpatient procedures (2.7 vs 4.3 procedures/patient).

CONCLUSIONS

Fundoplication improves the clinical outcome of erosive esophagitis in patients with concomitant esophageal ulcers and strictures, but not in patients without such complications. Fundoplication does not reduce the consumption of health care resources.

Laparoscopic surgery complications associated with trocar tip design: review of literature and own results

In the last 10 years, there has not been an abdominal surgical procedure that has not been performed by laparoscopic means. The enthusiasm of surgeons active in this field often neglects problems, especially with basic instruments which are important vehicles for the laparoscopic technique. The purpose of this study was to focus on trocar-related problems with special respect to the tip design. On the basis of a prospective study of laparoscopic transperitoneal hernia repair (TAPP) and laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication, we evaluated our data concerning trocar-related complications at the abdominal wall. We compared two groups of patients treated in a nonrandomized design with either sharp cutting single-use trocars or cone-shaped non-cutting reuseable trocars. The evaluation of our own data showed an incisional hernia in 1.83% of patients treated with a sharp trocar tip, a complication which could be significantly lowered, to 0.17%, with a conic tip design. Similar results could be seen with trocar-related bleeding events at the insertion site in the abdominal wall. In most publications, trocar design and related complications are unmentioned. Our data demonstrate a reasonable benefit for a conic tip design, which enables atraumatic insertion through the abdominal wall. The reuseable steel version furthermore holds a considerable cost-saving potential.

Comparison of costs between laparoscopic and open Nissen fundoplication: a prospective randomized study with a 3-month followup

BACKGROUND

Laparoscopic antireflux surgery has replaced conventional operation despite the fact that currently no randomized trials have been published regarding its cost effectiveness. The objective of the present study was to compare costs and some short-term outcomes of laparoscopic and open Nissen fundoplication.

STUDY DESIGN

Forty-two patients with documented gastroesophageal reflux disease were randomized between October 1995 and October 1996 to either laparoscopic (LNF) or open (ONF) Nissen fundoplication. Some short-term outcomes, Gastrointestinal Quality of Life Index (GIQLI) hospital costs, and costs to society were assessed. Followup was 3 months.

RESULTS

Medians of operation times in the LNF and ONF groups were 98 min and 74 min, respectively. Hospital stay was 2.5 days shorter after laparoscopic operation (LNF 3 days versus ONF 5.5 days). Both operations were equally safe and effective, but the LNF group experienced significantly less pain and fatigue during the first 3 postoperative weeks. Improvement in the GIQLI and overall patient satisfaction were comparable between the methods. Convalescence was faster in the LNF group: return to normal life being 14 versus 31 days and return to work being 21 versus 44 days in the LNF and ONF groups, respectively. Hospital costs were similar, $2,981 and $3,140 in the LNF and ONF groups, respectively, but total costs were lower ($7,506 versus $13,118) in the LNF group as a result of an earlier return to work.

CONCLUSIONS

LNF is superior in cost effectiveness, assuming that the longterm results between the methods are comparable.

Success of laparoscopic fundoplication for gastroesophageal reflux disease

BACKGROUND

We explored the efficacy of laparoscopic fundoplication (LF) in patients with uncomplicated, medically recalcitrant pathologic gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) for whom we previously would have recommended open surgical repair.

METHODS

From January 1994 to January 1998, we performed LF on 150 patients (80 men and 70 women) with GERD recalcitrant to maximal medical therapy. No patient suffered from esophageal stricture or epithelial dysplasia; however 16% (24 of 150) had benign Barrett's mucosa. Preoperative esophageal manometry and 24-hour pH testing were obtained in 93% (139 of 150) and 89% (134 of 150) of patients, respectively. Nissen LF (n = 123), Toupet LF (n = 26), or Dor LF (n = 1) were accomplished over a large (54 F) intraesophageal bougie. Preoperative (1 month) and postoperative (>6 month) symptom scoring were assessed on a 0 to 10 scale. Thirty-eight patients with a greater than 6-month postoperative period had manometry and pH studies performed.

RESULTS

The laparoscopic approach was successful in 99% (148 of 150) of patients, and there has been no mortality. Operative time was 160+/-59 minutes. Open conversion was required for 2 patients: because of difficulty with dissection owing to adhesions in 1 case and due to perforation in another. Reoperation was required for 5 patients (1 paraesophageal, 2 dysphagia, 2 recurrent reflux). Major postoperative complications involved stroke and pancreatitis in 1 patient each. Mean hospital stay was 2.6+/-1.2 days, full activity resumed by 7 days. Postoperative esophageal pH testing among 38 patients tested more than 6 months after operation demonstrated normal esophageal acid exposure in all but 2. GERD symptoms were relieved at 1 month, 6 months, and after 1 year in 95% (128 of 135), 94% (99 of 105), and 93% (65 of 70) of patients, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Intermediate-term results with LF suggest this to be a reasonable approach to surgical management of medically recalcitrant uncomplicated GERD. Thoracic surgeons interested in GERD should become familiar with minimally invasive surgical approaches.

Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease

Prior to the advent of proton pump inhibitors, internists recommended antireflux surgery primarily for patients whose gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) failed to respond to medical therapy. Although many physicians still cling to the notion that antireflux surgery is a procedure best reserved for "medical failures," today this position is inappropriate. Modern medical treatments for GERD are extraordinarily effective in healing reflux esophagitis. It is uncommon to encounter patients with heartburn or esophagitis due to GERD who do not respond to aggressive antisecretory therapy. Indeed, the very diagnosis of GERD must be questioned for patients whose esophageal signs and symptoms are unaffected by the administration of proton pump inhibitors in high dosages. In the large majority of these so-called refractory patients, protracted esophageal pH monitoring reveals good control of acid reflux by the proton pump inhibitors. This finding indicates that the persistent symptoms usually are not due to acid reflux, but to other problems such as functional bowel disorders. Medical treatment fails in such patients because the diagnosis is mistaken, not because the drugs fail to control acid reflux. Modern antireflux surgery also is highly effective for controlling acid reflux, but fundoplication will not be effective for relieving symptoms in patients whose symptoms are not reflux-induced. Therefore, many patients deemed failures of modern medical therapy would be surgical failures as well. Antireflux surgery is an excellent treatment option for patients with documented GERD who respond well to medical therapy, but who wish to avoid the expense, inconvenience, and theoretical risks associated with lifelong medical treatment. Ironically, surgical therapy for GERD today is best reserved for patients who are medical successes.

Antireflux surgery in the laparoscopic era

BACKGROUND

The recent development of laparoscopic techniques for fundoplication has created renewed interest in surgery for gastro-oesophageal reflux disease, leading to reports of large clinical series from many centres. However, controversy remains about technical aspects of laparoscopic antireflux surgery, with no consensus yet reached about a standard operative technique. It is important, therefore, to reassess critically the results of laparoscopic surgery for reflux disease, so that its current status can be determined.

METHODS

Published outcome studies for laparoscopic antireflux surgery, as well as selected studies from the era of open antireflux surgery, were reviewed to assess outcomes.

RESULTS

The results of case series for laparoscopic antireflux surgery with short- and medium-term follow-up, as well as the early results of randomized trials, confirm that this approach reduces the early overall morbidity of surgery for reflux disease. However, certain complications may be more common, for instance paraoesophageal hiatus herniation, pneumothorax and oesophageal perforation, requiring surgeons to use specific strategies which can help to avoid these problems. Published studies and trials do not support the routine or selective application of a posterior partial fundoplication technique or routine division of the short gastric vessels during Nissen fundoplication.

CONCLUSION

At present, a short loose Nissen fundoplication performed laparoscopically, with or without division of the short gastric vessels, is an appropriate surgical approach for gastro-oesophageal reflux disease. However, long-term outcomes following laparoscopic antireflux surgery will not be available for some years, and must be awaited before the final status of the various laparoscopic techniques can be confirmed.

Outcomes of atypical symptoms attributed to gastroesophageal reflux treated by laparoscopic fundoplication

BACKGROUND

The introduction of laparoscopic fundoplication (LF) has lowered the threshold for operation in patients with symptoms attributed to gastroesophageal reflux. We sought to determine whether the outcomes in patients referred for atypical symptoms (pulmonary, pharyngolaryngeal, and pain syndromes) were as good as those referred for correction of heartburn and regurgitation (typical symptoms).

METHODS

Thirty-five of 150 consecutive patients undergoing LF with a minimum of 12 months of follow-up were referred primarily for correction of atypical symptoms. A standard preoperative evaluation included endoscopy, manometry, upper gastrointestinal contrast radiography, and 24-hour pH probe testing (33 of 35 patients with atypical symptoms). Patients completed a symptom questionnaire administered by a study nurse before the operation and 3 and 12 months after the operation. Symptoms were scored from 0 to 10.

RESULTS

Heartburn was relieved by LF in 93% of patients, whereas only 56% of patients had relief of atypical symptoms. Furthermore, the degree of improvement in typical symptoms was greater than that seen for atypical symptoms as measured by the 0 to 10-symptom rating score (improvement in typical symptoms = 6.2 vs improvement in atypical symptoms = 4.4 [p = 0.01]). The response rate for laryngeal, pulmonary, and epigastric/chest pain symptoms was 78%, 58%, and 48%, respectively. Analysis of factors associated with relief of atypical symptoms revealed that response to a preoperative trial of omeprazole or H2-blockers was significantly associated with successful surgical outcome (p = 0.03). Six of seven patients with laryngeal symptoms who had acid reflux above the cricopharyngeal level shown by dual-probe pH testing had relief of the symptoms after LF. Manometric findings (amplitude of esophageal body contractions, propagation of contractions, and lower esophageal sphincter resting pressure) neither predicted nor correlated with relief of atypical symptoms after the operation.

CONCLUSIONS

Relief of atypical symptoms attributed to gastroesophageal reflux by LF is less satisfactory and more difficult to predict than relief of heartburn and regurgitation. The only useful preoperative predictors of relief of atypical symptoms in this study were the response to pharmacologic acid suppression and dual-probe pH testing (only in patients with laryngeal symptoms).

The treatment of gastroesophageal reflux disease with laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication: prospective evaluation of 100 patients with "typical" symptoms

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate prospectively the outcome of laparoscopic fundoplication in a large cohort of patients with typical symptoms of gastroesophageal reflux.

SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA

The development of laparoscopic fundoplication over the past several years has resulted in renewed interest in the surgical treatment of gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD).

METHODS

One hundred patients with typical symptoms of GERD were studied. The study was limited to patients with positive 24-hour pH studies and "typical" symptoms of GERD. Laparoscopic fundoplication was performed when clinical assessment suggested adequate esophageal motility and length. Outcome measures included assessment of the relief of the primary symptom responsible for surgery; the patient's and the physician's evaluation of outcome; quality of life evaluation; repeated upper endoscopy in 30 patients with presurgical esophagitis; and postsurgical physiologic studies in 28 unselected patients, consisting of 24-hour esophageal pH and lower esophageal sphincter manometry.

RESULTS

Relief of the primary symptom responsible for surgery was achieved in 96% of patients at a mean follow-up of 21 months. Seventy-one patients were asymptomatic, 24 had minor gastrointestinal symptoms not requiring medical therapy, 3 had gastrointestinal symptoms requiring medical therapy, and 2 were worsened by the procedure. Eighty-three patients considered themselves cured, 11 were improved, and 1 was worse. Occasional difficulty swallowing not present before surgery occurred in 7 patients at 3 months, and decreased to 2 patients by 12 months after surgery. There were no deaths. Clinically significant complications occurred in four patients. Median hospital stay was 3 days, decreasing from 6.3 in the first 10 patients to 2.3 in the last 10 patients. Endoscopic esophagitis healed in 28 of 30 patients who had presurgical esophagitis and returned for follow-up endoscopy. Twenty-four-hour esophageal acid exposure had returned to normal in 26 of 28 patients studied after surgery. Lower esophageal sphincter pressures had also returned to normal in all patients, increasing from a median of 5.1 mmHg to 14.9 mmHg.

CONCLUSIONS

Laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication provides an excellent symptomatic and physiologic outcome in patients with proven gastroesophageal reflux and "typical" symptoms. This can be achieved with a hospital stay of 48 hours and a low incidence of postsurgical complications.

Early experience and learning curve associated with laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication

BACKGROUND

Laparoscopic approach for hiatal hernia repair is relatively new. Information on the learning curve is limited.

METHODS

From January 1994 to September 1996, 280 patients underwent antireflux surgery at our institution. A laparoscopic repair was attempted in 60 patients (21.4%). There were 38 men and 22 women. Median age was 49 years (range 21 to 78 years). Indications for operation were gastroesophageal reflux in 59 patients and a large paraesophageal hernia in one. A Nissen fundoplication was performed in all patients; 53 (88.3%) had concomitant hiatal hernia repair.

RESULTS

In eight patients (13.3%) the operation was converted to an open procedure. Median operative time for the 52 patients who had laparoscopic repair was 215 minutes (range 104 to 320 minutes). There were no deaths. Complications occurred in five patients (9.6%). Median hospitalization was 2 days (range 1 to 5 days). Median operative time and median hospitalization were significantly longer in the first 26 patients than in the subsequent 25 patients (248 vs 203 minutes and 2 days vs 1 day, respectively; p = 0.03). Seven of the first 30 patients (23.3%) required laparotomy as compared with two of the second 30 (6.7%) (p = 0.07). Follow-up in the 51 patients who had laparoscopic fundoplication for reflux was complete in 50 (98.0%) and ranged from 7 to 38 months (median 13 months). Functional results were classified as excellent in 34 patients (68.0%), good in 6 (12.0%), fair in 7 (14.0%), and poor in 3 (6.0%). Three patients were reoperated on for recurrent reflux symptoms at 5, 5, and 11 months.

CONCLUSIONS

We conclude that laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication can be performed safely. The operative time, hospitalization, and conversion rate to laparotomy are higher during the early part of the experience, but all are reduced after the learning curve.

The surgical option for gastroesophageal reflux disease

Gastroesophageal reflux disease is a common condition. Most patients can be managed with medications, but patients with refractory disease, particularly those with an incompetent lower esophageal sphincter, should be referred for surgery. The open Nissen fundoplication cures >90% of patients of their symptoms. The laparoscopic approach was first applied for patients with gastroesophageal reflux disease in 1991, and since then numerous reports evaluating the early experience with this technique have been published with results similar to the open procedure. Over the last 5 years, 595 laparoscopic antireflux procedures have been performed by us. There was 1 mortality due to an unrecognized duodenal perforation. Splenic injury did not occur compared to an incidence of up to 8.5% for the open procedure. A total of 9 patients required conversion to the open procedure for perforation, bleeding, or dissection difficulties. However, in the last 350 cases no conversions have been necessary. Most patients are now being discharged from hospital on the day after surgery with some patients being discharged on the same day as surgery. The overall reoperation rate, both for early postoperative morbidity and for late poor outcome, was 3.9% with follow-up ranging from 2 months to 5 years. The laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication achieves the same short-term outcome as the open procedure with significantly less postoperative morbidity and a shorter hospital stay.

An objective assessment of laparoscopic antireflux surgery

BACKGROUND

Complicated gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) requires long-term medical therapy, which in some instances is incompletely effective or poorly tolerated. Additionally, there is concern about the consequences of prolonged acid suppression therapy. Surgical correction of GERD has been a therapeutic option for decades. With the advent of video-assisted laparoscopic surgery, antireflux surgery has had a resurgence in popularity.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Between October 1992 and June 1995, 20 patients who underwent laparoscopic antireflux surgery were completely studied preoperatively and 3 months postoperatively with 24-hour pH monitoring and esophageal manometry. Follow-up averaged 18 months. The indication for surgery was medically refractory disease in 75%, intolerance to medication in 10%, and concern regarding the consequences of long-term medical therapy in 15%. Two thirds of these patients had complicated GERD.

RESULTS

Operative time averaged 4 hours. There was no conversion to an open procedure. There was no mortality. Two patients had recurrent reflux, for a failure rate of 10%. Overall, postoperative reflux episodes and percent of time pH was less than 4 dropped significantly. Lower esophageal sphincter function showed a statistically significant increase in mean postoperative resting pressure and residual sphincter pressure during swallowing. There was no change in motility postoperatively.

CONCLUSIONS

Laparoscopic antireflux surgery is a safe, effective, therapeutic alternative in the management of gastroesophageal reflux disease.

The learning curve associated with laparoscopic antireflux surgery in infants and children

Laparoscopic fundoplication is an effective method for treating gastroesophageal reflux in infants and children. Some surgeons prefer the traditional open technique and have concerns regarding complications associated with laparoscopic surgery as well as the time length of operation. This report addresses these concerns in a retrospective review of the first 160 consecutive pediatric patients who underwent laparoscopic fundoplication. "Learning Curves" as a function of surgical experience are presented highlighting some of the lessons learned while developing the laparoscopic fundoplication technique.

Quality of life assessment after laparoscopic and open fundoplications. Results of a prospective, clinical study

BACKGROUND

In the evaluation of different treatment alternatives, assessment of the patients' own perceived situation can give important clinical information in addition to the conventional efficacy variables used.

METHODS

Fifty patients with chronic gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) were operated on with either an open fundoplication (n = 25; 17 men; mean age, 51.5 years) or with a fundoplication through the laparoscope (n = 25; 16 men; mean age, 49.8 years). In each case adequate control of the GERD was achieved with the operation, also when objectively assessed. Twelve months after surgery the quality of life was studied by using a battery of self-administered questionnaires (the Psychological General Well-being (PGWB) index and the Gastrointestinal Symptom Rating Scale (GSRS), and a visual analogue scale, depicting specific reflux-related symptoms (RVAS).

RESULTS

After antireflux surgery the overall PGWB scores were normalized with no obvious difference between the two procedures. In the GSRS scale, however, differences were shown between the two procedures, with more dyspeptic and indigestion symptoms in patients having a laparoscopic total fundic wrap.

CONCLUSION

These data emphasize the clinical efficacy of antireflux surgery, with normalization of the quality of life in terms of well-being after these procedures. It should be noted that these instruments are sensitive enough to pick up significant differences between different antireflux procedures and should therefore be frequently used in the attempt to refine and optimize long-term therapeutic alternatives in reflux disease.

Laparoscopic antireflux surgery

BACKGROUND

The purpose of this paper is to review the experience of a community surgeon performing laparoscopic antireflux procedures (LAP). The experience has been difficult and at times unsettling, and underscores the need for advanced laparoscopic expertise not normally obtained performing laparoscopic cholecystectomies.

METHODS

Sixty-one consecutive patients underwent attempted LAP. The preoperative evaluation is reviewed, and the length of operative times, conversion rates, complications, and patient satisfaction is discussed.

RESULTS

Four patients were converted to an open procedure, and two more patients required later reoperation for dysphagia. While the operative times are shorter now, the technical difficulty in performing the procedure does not seem to be appreciatively decreasing. No deaths or esophageal perforations occurred; however, there were a large number of patients with varying degrees of troubling dysphagia that did not require reoperation but frequently required endoscopic gastroduodenoscopy (EGD) dilatation. No recurrence of reflux has been documented in the short 2-year follow-up period.

CONCLUSIONS

LAP is still the most difficult procedure that I perform, and the learning curve is at least 60 cases. Patient satisfaction is quite good as only three have mild "heartburn." Dysphagia is a significant problem that has led to takedown of several short gastric vessels to obtain looser fundoplications around larger and larger bougies. Appropriate patient preoperative selection is paramount and the antireflux procedure should be tailored to the individual patient. Major complications have been reported elsewhere, but have not been seen in this review.