Comparative genomic hybridization (CGH) analysis of stage 4 neuroblastoma reveals high frequency of 11q deletion in tumors lacking MYCN amplification

High-resolution analysis of allelic imbalance in neuroblastoma cell lines by single nucleotide polymorphism arrays

Genomic copy number changes are detectable in many malignancies, including neuroblastoma, using techniques such as comparative genomic hybridization (CGH), microsatellite analysis, conventional karyotyping, and fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH). We report the use of 10K single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) microarrays to detect copy number changes and allelic imbalance in six neuroblastoma cell lines (IMR32, SHEP, NBL-S, SJNB-1, LS, and SKNBE2c). SNP data were generated using the GeneChip DNA Analysis and GeneChip chromosome copy number software (Affymetrix). SNP arrays confirmed the presence of all previously reported cytogenetic abnormalities in the cell lines, including chromosome 1p deletion, MYCN amplification, gain of 17q and 11q, and 14q deletions. In addition, the SNP arrays revealed several chromosome gains and losses not detected by CGH or karyotyping; these included gain of 8q21.1 approximately 24.3 and gain of chromosome 12 in IMR-32 cells; loss at 4p15.3 approximately 16.1 and loss at 16p12.3 approximately 13.2, 11q loss with loss of heterozygosity (LOH) at 11q14.3 approximately 23.3 in SJNB-1 cells; and loss at 8p21.2 approximately 23.3 and 9p21.3 approximately 22.1 with corresponding LOH in SHEP cells. The SNP arrays refined the mapping of the 2p amplicons in LS, BE2c, and IMR-32 cell lines, the 12q amplicon in LS cells, and also identified an 11q13 amplicon in LS cells. There was good concordance among SNP arrays, CGH, and karyotyping. SNP array analysis is a powerful tool for the detection of allelic imbalance in neuroblastoma and also allows identification of LOH without changes in copy number (uniparental disomy).

Genome wide measurement of DNA copy number changes in neuroblastoma: dissecting amplicons and mapping losses, gains and breakpoints

In the past few years high throughput methods for assessment of DNA copy number alterations have witnessed rapid progress. Both 'in house' developed BAC, cDNA, oligonucleotide and commercial arrays are now available and widely applied in the study of the human genome, particularly in the context of disease. Cancer cells are known to exhibit DNA losses, gains and amplifications affecting tumor suppressor genes and proto-oncogenes. Moreover, these patterns of genomic imbalances may be associated with particular tumor types or subtypes and may have prognostic value. Here we summarize recent array CGH findings in neuroblastoma, a pediatric tumor of the sympathetic nervous system. A total of 176 primary tumors and 53 cell lines have been analyzed on different platforms. Through these studies the genomic content and boundaries of deletions, gains and amplifications were characterized with unprecedented accuracy. Furthermore, in conjunction with cytogenetic findings, array CGH allows the mapping of breakpoints of unbalanced translocations at a very high resolution.

Single nucleotide polymorphism array analysis to predict clinical outcome in neuroblastoma patients

PURPOSE

Neuroblastoma (NB) is a heterogeneous tumor and demonstrates favorable or unfavorable outcomes. In Japan, a nationwide NB mass screening (MS) had been performed on 6-month-old infants for approximately 20 years, which might have detected almost all NB including regressing/maturing tumors. To clarify the heterogeneity of this tumor, we examined genetic alterations in the representative cases using genomewide microarrays.

METHODS

Genomic DNA was extracted from 198 NB tissue samples and paired blood samples including 76 MS-detected cases and analyzed by single nucleotide polymorphism arrays.

RESULTS

The single nucleotide polymorphism array classified the genetic aberrations into 4 types: whole gain/loss type, partial gain/loss type, MYCN-amplified type, and silent type. Most MS-detecting cases belonged to the whole gain/loss type, whereas unfavorable cases who died of disease showed partial gain/loss, MYCN-amplified, or silent types.

CONCLUSIONS

Genomewide genetic analysis is useful to predict the outcome of patients. Although the cases whose tumors showed whole gain/loss may respond well to contemporary therapy, sparing intensive surgery, current therapeutic strategy may be insufficient for the subgroups with partial gain/loss, MYCN-amplified, or silent type. Validation of these results would provide new tools to predict clinical outcome of children with NB.

Oligonucleotide array-based comparative genomic hybridization (aCGH) of 90 neuroblastomas reveals aberration patterns closely associated with relapse pattern and outcome

The study of genomic alterations in neuroblastoma is of particular importance since several cytogenetic markers proved to be closely associated with the clinical phenotype. To disclose patterns of gains and losses, we performed high-resolution oligonucleotide array-based comparative genomic hybridization (aCGH). A total cohort of 90 patients was classified into 6 subsets according to tumor stage and outcome: Stages 1-3+ (with event), Stage 1-3- (no event), Stage 4+/-, and Stage 4S+/-. The aberration patterns in Stages 1-3- and 4S- tumors differed from all other groups as they were predominantly characterized by losses (3, 4, 14, X) and gains (7, 17) of whole chromosomes. However, 59/65 (91%) tumors of Stages 1-3+ or Stage 4 revealed numerous structural copy number alterations (sCNA). While deletions in chromosomes 1, 3, and 11 discriminated outcome in Stage 4, there were no specific sCNA that distinguished tumor stage within the subgroup of unfavorable tumors. sCNA in 1p, 3p, 11q, 17q, or MYCN amplification (MNA) was seen among 22/24 patients who died, 10/12 with metastatic relapses, and 5/9 with local recurrences. Detailed breakpoint analyses on chromosomes 1, 3, 11, and 17 disclosed preferred breaking areas, although breakpoints were not identical. Amplifications were found in 18 patients and involved 2p24 (MYCN) and other segments of chromosome 2, as well as regions on chromosome arms 6q, 12q, and 17q. One single feature in 21q21.1 (BU678720, without known function yet) attracted particular attention since five patients showed a homozygous loss of this sequence.

Determination of genomic damage in neuroblastic tumors by arbitrarily primed PCR: MYCN amplification as a marker for genomic instability in neuroblastomas

The aim of this study is to establish an estimation of the global genomic alteration in neuroblastic tumors (ganglioneuromas, ganglioneuroblastomas and neuroblastomas) and correlate them with different clinical parameters (age, sex, diagnosis, Shimada index, proliferation index, tumor location, and 1p and v-myc avian myelocitomatosis viral-related (MYCN) status) in order to find new molecular and/or prognostic markers for neuroblastoma. To assess the genomic damage in neuroblastic tumors, we used an arbitrarily primed PCR approach, a technique based on the reproducibility of band profiles obtained by a PCR with a low annealing temperature in its first cycles. Genomic damage was assessed by comparing band profiles of tumors and normal paired samples. Gains and losses in the intensity of the bands were computerized and referred to the total number of bands analyzed. We found a higher genomic damage fraction (GDF) in the female's group (U-Mann-Whitney, P = 0.025), but we could not find any association between GDF and tumor location, proliferation index, diagnosis or age of the patient. There was no relationship between 1p status and GDF, but tumors with MYCN amplification had a slightly higher GDF. MYCN amplification might in some way contribute to genomic instability of neuroblastomas.

Multilocus loss of heterozygosity allelotypes identify a genetic pathway associated with progression from low to high stage disease in neuroblastoma

Neuroblastoma is a heterogeneous tumour with a variety of clinical phenotypes, ranging from a localised tumour with excellent outcome (stage 1) to a metastatic, usually fatal malignancy (stage 4). In order to investigate the genetic relationship between these tumour subtypes, a loss of heterozygosity (LOH) analysis was carried out. Composite LOH allelotypes incorporating data from 96 loci on 5 chromosomes (1p, 3p, 4p, 11q, 14q), were constructed for 62 neuroblastomas. Neuroblastomas with similar allelotypes were clustered into groups and allelotype patterns correlated with clinical features. Three distinct genetic subgroups of neuroblastoma were observed. The largest group (50% of tumours) was characterised by specific allelotype patterns indicative of a stepwise accumulation of genetic alterations (11q LOH-->1p, 4p, and/or 14q LOH-->3p LOH), associated with progression from low to high stage disease. These tumours are distinct from MYCN amplified neuroblastomas which have a more rapid and aggressive disease course, and also a proportion of low stage tumours, often ganglioneuromas or ganglioneuroblastomas, with restricted growth potential.

The von Hippel-Lindau tumor suppressor gene expression level has prognostic value in neuroblastoma

Deletions of the short arm of chromosome 3 are often observed in a specific subset of aggressive neuroblastomas (NBs) with loss of distal 11q and without MYCN amplification. The critical deleted region encompasses the locus of the von Hippel-Lindau gene (VHL, 3p25). Constitutional loss of function mutations in the VHL gene are responsible for the VHL syndrome, a dominantly inherited familial cancer syndrome predisposing to a variety of neoplasms, including pheochromocytoma. Pheochromocytomas are, like NB, derived from neural crest cells, but, unlike NB, consist of more mature chromaffin cells instead of immature neuroblasts. Further arguments for a putative role of VHL in NB are its function as oxygen sensitizer and the reported relation between hypoxia and dedifferentiation of NB cells, leading to a more aggressive phenotype. To test the possible involvement of VHL in NB, we did mRNA expression analysis and sought evidence for VHL gene inactivation. Although no evidence for a classic tumor suppressor role for VHL in NB could be obtained, a strong correlation was observed between reduced levels of VHL mRNA and low patient survival probability (p=0.013). Furthermore, VHL appears to have predictive power in NTRK1 (TRKA) positive tumor samples with presumed favorable prognosis, which makes it a potentially valuable marker for more accurate risk assessment in this subgroup of patients. The significance of the reduced VHL expression levels in relation to NB tumor biology remains unexplained, as functional analysis demonstrated no clear effect of the reduction in VHL mRNA expression on protein stability of its downstream target hypoxia-inducible factor alpha.

Risk estimation in localized unresectable single copy MYCN neuroblastoma by the status of chromosomes 1p and 11q

In localized neuroblastoma, the identification of patients requiring intensive treatment is still difficult. We retrospectively analyzed data of 280 single copy MYCN stage 2 and 3 neuroblastoma patients with gross residual tumor after initial surgery. The 3-year-event free survival of the total group was 83+/-2%, and 3-year-overall survival was 92+/-2%. Patients < or=1.5 years had a better outcome than older children. Deletions/imbalances of chromosome 1p were found in 9/90 patients and were associated with a higher event rate but not with a higher death rate. Aberrations of chromosome 11q in 14/91 patients were correlated with a higher event and death rate. Multivariate analysis identified 1p aberrations as important for event free survival and 11q aberrations for overall survival.

High-Resolution Analysis of Chromosomal Breakpoints and Genomic Instability Identifies PTPRD as a Candidate Tumor Suppressor Gene in Neuroblastoma

Although neuroblastoma is characterized by numerous recurrent, large-scale chromosomal imbalances, the genes targeted by such imbalances have remained elusive. We have applied whole-genome oligonucleotide array comparative genomic hybridization (median probe spacing 6 kb) to 56 neuroblastoma tumors and cell lines to identify genes involved with disease pathogenesis. This set of tumors was selected for having either 11q loss or MYCN amplification, abnormalities that define the two most common genetic subtypes of metastatic neuroblastoma. Our analyses have permitted us to map large-scale chromosomal imbalances and high-level amplifications at exon-level resolution and to identify novel microdeletions and duplications. Chromosomal breakpoints (n = 467) generating imbalances >2 Mb were mapped to intervals ranging between 6 and 50 kb in size, providing substantial information on each abnormality. For example, breakpoints leading to large-scale hemizygous loss of chromosome 11q were highly clustered and preferentially associated with segmental duplications. High-level amplifications of MYCN were extremely complex, often resulting in a series of discontinuous regions of amplification. Imbalances (n = 540) <2 Mb long were also detected. Although the majority (78%) of these imbalances mapped to segmentally duplicated regions and primarily reflect constitutional copy number polymorphisms, many subtle imbalances were detected that are likely somatically acquired alterations and include genes involved with tumorigenesis, apoptosis, or neural cell differentiation. The most frequent microdeletion involved the PTPRD locus, indicating a possible tumor suppressor function for this gene.

The role of age in neuroblastoma risk stratification: the German, Italian, and children's oncology group perspectives

Recent evidence suggests that the cut-off for age utilized in neuroblastoma risk groups should be increased from the 365-day cut-off currently in use. Separate cooperative group analyses were performed by German and Italian groups and two analyses by the Children's Oncology Group (North America, Australia, New Zealand, Switzerland, Netherlands). In general, the results are in agreement regarding the prognostic contribution of age. There is strong evidence to support an increase in the age cut-off to a value in the range of 15-18 months based on the results from the German analysis and two COG analyses. However, Italian results in INSS stage 4 patients show that outcome in patients 12-17 months is not better than that of older patients. Further analyses are warrented.

Analysis of chromosome breakpoints in neuroblastoma at sub-kilobase resolution using fine-tiling oligonucleotide array CGH

Understanding the genes and genetic pathways targeted by recurrent chromosomal imbalances in malignancy, along with the molecular mechanisms that generate the imbalances, are important problems in cancer biology. In this report, we demonstrate that oligonucleotide array CGH (oaCGH) analysis can routinely map chromosomal imbalance breakpoints at exon-level resolution, including imbalances that are single copy number genomic alterations. Different tiling-path array designs were used in this study: a whole-genome array with a 6-kb median probe spacing and fine-tiling arrays for selected genomic regions with either 50- or 140-bp median probe spacing. In both array formats, oligonucleotide probes were of isothermal design and were tiled through genic and inter-genic regions. Whole-genome oaCGH analysis of two neuroblastoma cell lines and three primary tumors led to the identification of 58 chromosomal breakpoints that generated 45 large-scale partial chromosomal imbalances (> 2 Mb). An unexpectedly high proportion (34%) of these breakpoint intervals mapped to regions containing segmental duplications. In addition, 88 smaller-sized regions (< 2 Mb) of imbalance were detected, the majority of which mapped to segmentally duplicated regions and may reflect constitutional copy number polymorphisms. The chromosomal breakpoints for 12 recurrent abnormalities exhibited in neuroblastoma tumors and cell lines, including MYCN amplicon boundaries, loss of 3p, loss of 11q, and gain of 17q, could be mapped to intervals ranging from 50 bp to 10 kb in size using high-density fine-tiling oligonucleotide microarrays. Fine-tiling oaCGH analysis provides an unprecedented level of resolution, allowing detailed mapping of recurrent unbalanced chromosomal abnormalities. Supplementary material for this article can be found on the Genes, Chromosomes, and Cancer website at http://www.interscience.wiley.com/jpages/1045-2257/suppmat/index.html.

Measurement and relevance of neuroblastoma DNA copy number changes in the post-genome era

The completion of the human genome sequence and the development of high throughput technology present exciting opportunities for the study of cancer cells. High-resolution analysis of chromosomal aberrations provides a global framework for understanding complex patterns in cancer cells, allowing us to ask hypothesis-driven questions. Genome-wide analysis of amplification and deletion of genomic regions is a critical step to resolving the mechanisms of neuroblastoma tumorigenesis. We used a high-resolution aCGH system that has over 4000 human BAC clones, resulting in an average coverage of 1Mb across the genome, to define whole genome copy number aberrations (CNAs) in a panel of human neuroblastoma-derived cell lines. By combining the aCGH data with meticulous regional validation studies, we showed that array CGH could reliably detect known aberrations including single copy gain or loss, that data correlate well with standard techniques used for the detection of these genetic changes, and that this technique can be used to identify novel regions of genomic imbalance.

High-resolution cDNA microarray-based comparative genomic hybridization analysis in neuroblastoma

Neuroblastoma (NB) is one of the most common pediatric solid tumors and displays a broad variety of genomic alterations. Array-based comparative genomic hybridization (A-CGH) is a novel technology enabling the high-resolution detection of DNA copy number aberrations. In this article, we outline features of this new technology and approaches of data analysis. We focus on stage specific DNA copy number variations in neuroblastoma detected by cDNA array-based comparative genomic hybridization (A-CGH). We also discuss hypothetic evolutionary models of neuroblastoma progression that can be derived from A-CGH data.

Inferring a tumor progression model for neuroblastoma from genomic data

PURPOSE

The knowledge of the key genomic events that are causal to cancer development and progression not only is invaluable for our understanding of cancer biology but also may have a direct clinical impact. The task of deciphering a model of tumor progression by requiring that it explains (or at least does not contradict) known clinical and molecular evidence can be very demanding, particularly for cancers with complex patterns of clinical and molecular evidence.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We formalize the process of model inference and show how a progression model for neuroblastoma (NB) can be inferred from genomic data. The core idea of our method is to translate the model of clonal cancer evolution to mathematical testable rules of inheritance. Seventy-eight NB samples in stages 1, 4S, and 4 were analyzed with array-based comparative genomic hybridization.

RESULTS

The pattern of recurrent genomic alterations in NB is strongly stage dependent and it is possible to identify traces of tumor progression in this type of data.

CONCLUSION

A tumor progression model for neuroblastoma is inferred, which is in agreement with clinical evidence, explains part of the heterogeneity of the clinical behavior observed for NB, and is compatible with existing empirical models of NB progression.

Region-specific detection of neuroblastoma loss of heterozygosity at multiple loci simultaneously using a SNP-based tag-array platform

Many cancers are characterized by chromosomal aberrations that may be predictive of disease outcome. Human neuroblastomas are characterized by somatically acquired copy number changes, including loss of heterozygosity (LOH) at multiple chromosomal loci, and these aberrations are strongly associated with clinical phenotype including patient outcome. We developed a method to assess region-specific LOH by genotyping multiple SNPs simultaneously in DNA from tumor tissues. We identified informative SNPs at an average 293-kb density across nine regions of recurrent LOH in human neuroblastomas. We also identified SNPs in two copy number neutral regions, as well as two regions of copy number gain. SNPs were PCR-amplified in 12-plex reactions and used in solution-phase single-nucleotide extension incorporating tagged dideoxynucleotides. Each extension primer had 5' complementarity to one of 2000 oligonucleotides on a commercially available tag-array platform allowing for solid-phase sorting and identification of individual SNPs. This approach allowed for simultaneous detection of multiple regions of LOH in six human neuroblastoma-derived cell lines, and, more importantly, 14 human neuroblastoma primary tumors. Concordance with conventional genotyping was nearly absolute. Detection of LOH in this assay may not require comparison to matched normal DNAs because of the redundancy of informative SNPs in each region. The customized tag-array system for LOH detection described here is rapid, results in parallel assessment of multiple genomic alterations, and may speed identification of and/or assaying prognostically relevant DNA copy number alterations in many human cancers.

Positional and functional mapping of a neuroblastoma differentiation gene on chromosome 11

Background

Loss of chromosome 11q defines a subset of high-stage aggressive neuroblastomas. Deletions are typically large and mapping efforts have thus far not lead to a well defined consensus region, which hampers the identification of positional candidate tumour suppressor genes. In a previous study, functional evidence for a neuroblastoma suppressor gene on chromosome 11 was obtained through microcell mediated chromosome transfer, indicated by differentiation of neuroblastoma cells with loss of distal 11q upon introduction of chromosome 11. Interestingly, some of these microcell hybrid clones were shown to harbour deletions in the transferred chromosome 11. We decided to further exploit this model system as a means to identify candidate tumour suppressor or differentiation genes located on chromosome 11.

Results

In a first step, we performed high-resolution arrayCGH DNA copy-number analysis in order to evaluate the chromosome 11 status in the hybrids. Several deletions in both parental and transferred chromosomes in the investigated microcell hybrids were observed. Subsequent correlation of these deletion events with the observed morphological changes lead to the delineation of three putative regions on chromosome 11: 11q25, 11p13->11p15.1 and 11p15.3, that may harbour the responsible differentiation gene.

Conclusion

Using an available model system, we were able to put forward some candidate regions that may be involved in neuroblastoma. Additional studies will be required to clarify the putative role of the genes located in these chromosomal segments in the observed differentiation phenotype specifically or in neuroblastoma pathogenesis in general.

Unequivocal delineation of clinicogenetic subgroups and development of a new model for improved outcome prediction in neuroblastoma

PURPOSE

Neuroblastoma is a genetically heterogeneous pediatric tumor with a remarkably variable clinical behavior ranging from widely disseminated disease to spontaneous regression. In this study, we aimed for comprehensive genetic subgroup discovery and assessment of independent prognostic markers based on genome-wide aberrations detected by comparative genomic hybridization (CGH).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Published CGH data from 231 primary untreated neuroblastomas were converted to a digitized format suitable for global data mining, subgroup discovery, and multivariate survival analyses.

RESULTS

In contrast to previous reports, which included only a few genetic parameters, we present here for the first time a strategy that allows unbiased evaluation of all genetic imbalances detected by CGH. The presented approach firmly established the existence of three different clinicogenetic subgroups and indicated that chromosome 17 status and tumor stage were the only independent significant predictors for patient outcome. Important new findings were: (1) a normal chromosome 17 status as a delineator of a subgroup of presumed favorable-stage tumors with highly increased risk; (2) the recognition of a survivor signature conferring 100% 5-year survival for stage 1, 2, and 4S tumors presenting with whole chromosome 17 gain; and (3) the identification of 3p deletion as a hallmark of older age at diagnosis.

CONCLUSION

We propose a new regression model for improved patient outcome prediction, incorporating tumor stage, chromosome 17, and amplification/deletion status. These findings may prove highly valuable with respect to more reliable risk assessment, evaluation of clinical results, and optimization of current treatment protocols.

The biologic basis for neuroblastoma heterogeneity and risk stratification

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Neuroblastoma serves as the paradigm for the clinical utility of tumor-specific biologic data for prognostication. This review will describe the genetic and biologic basis for the diverse clinical phenotypes observed in neuroblastoma patients. It will also discuss the current approach to risk classification and how this may change in the future.

RECENT FINDINGS

The biologic basis of neuroblastoma has come into clearer focus. PHOX2B is the first bona fide neuroblastoma predisposition gene identified, but is mutated in only a small subset of cases. Somatically acquired alterations at chromosome arms 3p and 11q are highly correlated with acquisition of metastases in the absence of MYCN amplification and may be useful as prognostic markers. The Children's Oncology Group risk classification system has been validated, with current emphasis on further refinement such as reevaluation of the age cutoff used to stratify therapy, and incorporation of additional molecular genetic markers is being studied prospectively. High-throughput genome scale analyses of neuroblastomas are further clarifying the genetic basis of this heterogeneous disease.

SUMMARY

Neuroblastoma remains a significant challenge as high-risk patients are treated with intensive multimodal therapies but cure rates remain suboptimal. There is remarkable heterogeneity observed in tumor phenotype, ranging from spontaneous regression to relentless progression. There are literally dozens of clinical and biologic markers that have been proposed as being predictive of disease outcome, but large clinical correlative studies are sharpening the focus of which markers can be used by the clinician to optimize therapy for an individual patient.

Evolution of unbalanced gain of distal chromosome 2p in neuroblastoma

Neuroblastoma, one of the most common tumors of childhood, presents at diagnosis with a vast number of recurrent chromosomal imbalances that include hyperdiploidy for whole chromosomes, partial loss of 1p, 3p, 4p, 11q, 14q, partial gain of 1q, 7q, 17q and amplification of MYCN. These abnormalities are nonrandomly distributed in neuroblastoma as loss of 3p and 11q rarely occur in MYCN amplified neuroblastomas. Here, we report on a patient who had a non-MYCN amplified 3p-/11q- neuroblastoma at diagnosis who subsequently developed a high level of MYCN amplification in bone marrow metastases 41 months after induction of complete remission. The tumor at diagnosis had low level unbalanced gain of distal 2p. In order to assess the frequency of low level gain of distal 2p in neuroblastoma, we examined the comparative genomic hybridization results from 60 neuroblastomas. Among non-MYCN amplified neuroblastomas, 8/45 (18%) had low level gain of distal 2p. Low level gain for a segment of 2p (i.e. a region larger than the 2p23-->p24 undergoing amplification) was also detected in five of the 15 tumors that had high level MYCN amplification. The possibility that low level gain of distal 2p is a risk factor for high level MYCN amplification is discussed.

MYCN-status in neuroblastoma: characteristics of tumours showing amplification, gain, and non-amplification

While the role of MYCN-amplification (MNA) for risk assessment in neuroblastoma is undisputed, the phenomenon of gene copy excess below the amplification threshold is rarely described. To discuss biological characteristics and the clinical impact of the so-called MYCN-gain versus amplified or non-amplified cases, we investigated the MYCN status of 659 patients uniformly analysed by fluorescence in situ hybridisation. The number of MYCN-amplified tumours in our cohort was 18% (116/659); an additional 38 tumours (6%) displayed MYCN-gain. Both alterations were associated with an advanced stage disease, an increased patient age and further chromosomal alterations. Most of the amplified neuroblastomas displayed 1p aberrations, whereas MYCN-gain tumours correlated with 11q alterations. In contrast to the amplified cases, tumours with gain displayed no increased MYCN RNA levels. MNA versus non-amplification discriminated between good and poor outcomes, independent of stage, age and the degree of amplification. However, patients with amplified tumours showed a significantly better outcome when this was combined with non-stage 4 disease and age <1 year versus stage 4 and age < 1 year. Although MYCN-gain was associated with poor event-free-survival (EFS) in stages 1-3, 4S (P=0.005), this might be related to associated genetic aberrations and not to the MYCN-gain itself. A survival difference between neuroblastomas with gain and single copy MYCN could not be delineated. In conclusion, MNA predicts a poor outcome for neuroblastoma patients of all stages and age. MYCN-gain is also a characteristic feature of advanced stage tumours and older patients, but is not associated with higher MYCN expression and appears not to be discriminative in predicting patient outcome.

Molecular cytogenetic analysis of recurrent unbalanced t(11;17) in neuroblastoma

Loss of 11q material occurs in approximately 30% of advanced stage neuroblastoma and defines a distinct genetic subtype of this disease. These tumors almost always possess unbalanced gain of the 17q, along with many additional recurrent chromosomal imbalances. Loss of 11q and gain of 17q is often the consequence of an unbalanced translocation between the long arms of both chromosomes, but because of the involvement of other chromosomal mechanisms, the actual frequency of t(11;17) is unknown. In addition, chromosomal breakpoint positions for the t(11;17) are variable in different tumors, with breakpoints on neither the 11q nor 17q being well defined. We have used interphase fluorescence in situ hybridization analysis to detect a der(11)t(11;17) in a series of neuroblastomas with 11q loss/17q gain using a statistical approach which could be applicable to the detection of translocations in other solid tumors. The frequency of der(11)t(11;17) was approximately 90% in our neuroblastoma series. A balanced t(11;17) was also detected in a MYCN amplified tumor, which is a distinctly different genetic subtype from the 11q- tumors. Breakpoint positions on 11q were determined to be variable, whereas all breakpoints on 17q appeared to cluster proximal to position 43.1 Mb on the DNA sequence map. The majority of tumors had large numbers of nuclei with 2 or more copies of der(11)t(11;17), which led to unbalanced gain of 11p, and further increases in 17q imbalance. The prevalence of t(11;17) in neuroblastoma warrants additional studies to further define the range in variation in breakpoint positions on both chromosomes and to elucidate the molecular mechanisms that lead to this important and interesting recurrent genetic abnormality.

[Prognosis of neuroblastoma in childhood. Methods of assessment and clinical use]

Neuroblastoma and its benign counterpart, ganglioneuroma, are pediatric neuroblastic tumors arising in the sympathetic nervous system from neural-crest cells. Neuroblastoma, the most common extra-cranial solid tumour during childhood, is unique for its broad spectrum of clinical virulence from spontaneous remission to rapid and fatal progression despite intensive multimodality therapy. To a large extent, outcome could be predicted by the stage of disease and the age at diagnosis. However, a number of molecular events in neuroblastoma tumors, accounting for the variability of outcome and response to therapy, have been identified over the past decades. Among these, MYCN amplification is the most relevant prognostic factor and was the first genetic marker, in paediatric oncology, to be included in clinical strategies as a guide for therapeutic decision. This has allowed the most suitable intensity of therapy to be delivered according to a risk-stratified strategy, from observation to megadose chemotherapy with stem cell transplantation. Recent advances in understanding the biology and genetics of neuroblastoma will ultimately allow to select poor-risk patients for appropriate future biologically based therapies.

cDNA array-CGH profiling identifies genomic alterations specific to stage and MYCN-amplification in neuroblastoma

Background

Recurrent non-random genomic alterations are the hallmarks of cancer and the characterization of these imbalances is critical to our understanding of tumorigenesis and cancer progression.

Results

We performed array-comparative genomic hybridization (A-CGH) on cDNA microarrays containing 42,000 elements in neuroblastoma (NB). We found that only two chromosomes (2p and 12q) had gene amplifications and all were in the MYCN amplified samples. There were 6 independent non-contiguous amplicons (10.4–69.4 Mb) on chromosome 2, and the largest contiguous region was 1.7 Mb bounded by NAG and an EST (clone: 757451); the smallest region was 27 Kb including an EST (clone: 241343), NCYM, and MYCN. Using a probabilistic approach to identify single copy number changes, we systemically investigated the genomic alterations occurring in Stage 1 and Stage 4 NBs with and without MYCN amplification (stage 1-, 4-, and 4+). We have not found genomic alterations universally present in all (100%) three subgroups of NBs. However we identified both common and unique patterns of genomic imbalance in NB including gain of 7q32, 17q21, 17q23-24 and loss of 3p21 were common to all three categories. Finally we confirm that the most frequent specific changes in Stage 4+ tumors were the loss of 1p36 with gain of 2p24-25 and they had fewer genomic alterations compared to either stage 1 or 4-, indicating that for this subgroup of poor risk NB requires a smaller number of genomic changes are required to develop the malignant phenotype.

Conclusions

cDNA A-CGH analysis is an efficient method for the detection and characterization of amplicons. Furthermore we were able to detect single copy number changes using our probabilistic approach and identified genomic alterations specific to stage and MYCN amplification.

No evidence for involvement of SDHD in neuroblastoma pathogenesis

BACKGROUND

Deletions in the long arm of chromosome 11 are observed in a subgroup of advanced stage neuroblastomas with poor outcome. The deleted region harbours the tumour suppressor gene SDHD that is frequently mutated in paraganglioma and pheochromocytoma, which are, like neuroblastoma, tumours originating from the neural crest. In this study, we sought for evidence for involvement of SDHD in neuroblastoma.

METHODS

SDHD was investigated on the genome, transcriptome and proteome level using mutation screening, methylation specific PCR, real-time quantitative PCR based homozygous deletion screening and mRNA expression profiling, immunoblotting, functional protein analysis and ultrastructural imaging of the mitochondria.

RESULTS

Analysis at the genomic level of 67 tumour samples and 37 cell lines revealed at least 2 bona-fide mutations in cell lines without allelic loss at 11q23: a 4bp-deletion causing skip of exon 3 resulting in a premature stop codon in cell line N206, and a Y93C mutation in cell line NMB located in a region affected by germline SDHD mutations causing hereditary paraganglioma. No evidence for hypermethylation of the SDHD promotor region was observed, nor could we detect homozygous deletions. Interestingly, SDHD mRNA expression was significantly reduced in SDHD mutated cell lines and cell lines with 11q allelic loss as compared to both cell lines without 11q allelic loss and normal foetal neuroblast cells. However, protein analyses and assessment of mitochondrial morphology presently do not provide clues as to the possible effect of reduced SDHD expression on the neuroblastoma tumour phenotype.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study provides no indications for 2-hit involvement of SDHD in the pathogenesis of neuroblastoma. Also, although a haplo-insufficient mechanism for SDHD involvement in advanced stage neuroblastoma could be considered, the present data do not provide consistent evidence for this hypothesis.

Abnormal constitutional karyotypes in patients with neuroblastoma: a report of four new cases and review of 47 others in the literature

Anomalies of constitutional karyotype, which have led to the discovery of oncogenes and tumor-suppressor genes in embryonal tumors such as retinoblastoma and Wilms tumor, have, until recently, rarely been reported until recently in neuroblastoma. We present four new cases of neuroblastoma associated with (a) a mosaicism for monosomy 22; (b) an 11q interstitial deletion; (c) a pericentric inversion of chromosome 9 at band 9p21; and (d) a Robertsonian translocation t(13;14). These anomalies and 47 others in the literature are worthy of interest, because some are recurrent, involving the same chromosome regions (1p36, 2p23, 3q, 11q23, and 15q), and some anomalies are situated on chromosome regions known to contain genes involved in neuroblastoma development (1p, 2p, 9p, 11q, 16q, and 17q). Chromosome regions 3q and 15q, observed several times, may also contain genes significant for neuroblastoma onset or development. Furthermore, the lack of neuroblastoma in patients with Down syndrome and Klinefelter or triple-X syndromes, together with a probable excess of neuroblastoma in patients with Turner syndrome, suggests that genes of importance for neuroblastoma may map to chromosomes X and 21. A search for genes implicated in neuroblastoma biology should use these data.

Neuroblastoma: biology and molecular and chromosomal pathology

Neuroblastoma is the most frequently occurring solid tumour in children, with an incidence of 1.3 cases per 100000 children aged 0-14 years. Despite many advances during the past three decades, neuroblastoma has remained an enigmatic challenge to clinical and basic scientists. 20 years ago, the MYCN gene was found to be amplified in neuroblastomas, and research since then has focused on the search for other genetic markers. It has emerged that neuroblastoma cells, like cells of many other tumour types, often suffer from extensive, non-random genetic damage at multiple genetic loci. Elucidation of the exact molecular make-up of neuroblastomas will enable researchers to analyse how much specific markers, alone or in combination, can help to stratify disease in prospective studies; at present, stratification is based on age, stage, MYCN, and Shimada pathology. Neuroblastoma may be one of the first examples of the use of genetic tumour markers as a tool for defining tumour behaviour and to aid clinical staging.

der(11)t(11;17): a distinct cytogenetic pathway of advanced stage neuroblastoma (NBL) - detected by spectral karyotyping (SKY)

Conventional cytogenetic, molecular cytogenic and genetic methods disclosed a broad spectrum of genetic abnormalities leading to gain and loss of chromosomal segments in advanced stage neuroblastoma (NBL). Specific correlation between the genetic findings could delineate distinct genetic pathways, of which the biology and prognostic significance is as yet undetermined. Using spectral karyotyping (SKY) and fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) on metaphases from 16 patients with advanced stage NBL, it was possible to explore the whole spectrum of rearrangement within complex karyotypes and to detect hidden recurrent translocations. All translocations were unbalanced. The most prevalent recurrent unbalanced translocations resulted in 17q gain in 12 patients (75%), 11q loss in nine patients (56%), and 1p deletion/imbalance in eight patients (50%). The most frequent recurrent translocation was der(11)t(11;17) in six patients. Three cytogenetic pathways could be delineated. The first, with six patients, was characterized by the unbalanced translocation der(11)t(11;17), detected only by SKY, resulting in the concomitant 17q gain and 11q loss. No MYCN amplification or 1p deletion (except one patient with 1p imbalance) were found, while 3p deletion, and complex karyotypes were common. The second subgroup, with four patients, had 17q gain and 1p deletion, and in two patients 11q loss, that was apparent only by FISH. 1p deletion occurred through der(1)t(1;17) or del(1p). The third subgroup of four patients was characterized by MYCN amplification with 17q gain and 1p deletion, very rarely with 11q loss (one patient) through a translocation with a non-17q partner. The SKY subclassifications were in accordance with the findings reported by molecular genetic techniques, and may indicate that distinct oncogenes and suppressor genes are involved in the der(11)t(11;17) pathway of advanced stage NBL.

FISH analyses for alterations in chromosomes 1, 2, 3, and 11 define high-risk groups in neuroblastoma

BACKGROUND

The prognostic chromosomal markers 1p loss and MYCN amplification (MNA) are only present in a subgroup of approximately 30% of neuroblastomas. To further characterize high and low risk subsets we investigated alterations in chromosome arms 3p and 11q, additional changes in 1p and MYCN as well as the somy-status of chromosome 1 in the same sample.

PROCEDURE

Fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) was used as an alternative technique to PCR/LOH- or comparative genomic hybridization (CGH) analyses. Alterations in chromosomes 3p and 11q were investigated in 182 unselected tumors, 1p loss and MNA in 174 and 179 of these, respectively. The somy-status of chromosome 1 was determined in 165 tumors as it highly correlates with the tumor ploidy.

RESULTS

Alterations in the four chromosomal regions were found in the following frequencies: 3p26: 19%, 11q23: 29%, 1p36: 29%, MNA: 19%. Fifty-two percent of all cases displayed structural aberrations in at least one chromosomal region, 83% in stage 4 and 30% in stages 1-3, 4s. All aberrations were thus correlated with stage 4 disease but were also present in a substantial subset of localized and 4s tumors. Trisomy of chromosome 1 was found in 38% of the tumors, disomy or tetrasomy in 62%. Patients with alterations in any of the four chromosomes and di/tetrasomy 1 showed a significantly increased age at diagnosis. Loss in 1p and MNA were closely associated with each other, as well as 3p and 11q aberrations but not the groups 1p/MNA versus 3p/11q. Only a small portion of trisomic tumors showed aberrations in at least one of the four chromosomal regions (14%) in contrast to the majority of the di/tetrasomic cases (74%). As already known the MYCN status discriminated between good and poor outcome in localized and metastatic stage 4 tumors. In addition alterations in 1p or 11q, deletion in 3p and di/tetrasomy 1 were associated with an unfavorable prognosis in MYCN single copy tumors of stages 1-3, 4s. Multivariate analysis revealed 11q alterations and MNA as the most important chromosomal prognostic factors in all stages.

CONCLUSION

FISH analyses for chromosomal alterations in 3p and 11q as well as in 1p and MYCN allows to define different groups with an increased risk for disease progression.

Neuroblastoma: biological insights into a clinical enigma

Neuroblastoma is a tumour derived from primitive cells of the sympathetic nervous system and is the most common solid tumour in childhood. Interestingly, most infants experience complete regression of their disease with minimal therapy, even with metastatic disease. However, older patients frequently have metastatic disease that grows relentlessly, despite even the most intensive multimodality therapy. Recent advances in understanding the biology and genetics of neuroblastomas have allowed classification into low-, intermediate- and high-risk groups. This allows the most appropriate intensity of therapy to be selected - from observation alone to aggressive, multimodality therapy. Future therapies will focus increasingly on the genes and biological pathways that contribute to malignant transformation or progression.

Combined 24-color karyotyping and comparative genomic hybridization analysis indicates predominant rearrangements of early replicating chromosome regions in neuroblastoma

Neuroblastoma is characterized by several distinct genetic alterations including MYCN amplification, chromosome 1p deletion and gain of chromosome 17. Although these alterations are thought to play a crucial role in oncogenesis, to date little is known about their underlying mechanisms. In order to more precisely document these genetic alterations, we have performed a combined study of 27 neuroblastoma cell lines using 24-color karyotyping (24-CK) and comparative genomic hybridization (CGH). 24-CK detected balanced translocations in 13 cases with recurrent involvement of chromosome 8. More importantly, 144 nonreciprocal translocations were observed in the 27 cell lines, with chromosome 1 as the most frequent recipient and chromosome 17 the most frequent donor. Each cell line exhibited at least one unbalanced translocation involving 17q, with 14 cell lines demonstrating more than one such translocation. Other recurrent alterations were amplification of the 2p24 chromosome region, which encodes the MYCN oncogene, losses of 1p, 3p and 11q, and gains of 1q and 7. In most cases, CGH profiles were directly linked to the presence of unbalanced translocations with gain of the donor fragment and loss of the replaced region on the recipient chromosome. Strikingly, over 60% of the chromosome breakpoints mapped to early replicating chromosome bands, which represent around 13% of the genome. Altogether these data suggest that neuroblastoma is characterized by rearrangements that predominantly involve chromosome fragments replicating early in the S-phase.

Are gains of chromosomal regions 7q and 11p important abnormalities in neuroblastoma?

Neuroblastoma exhibiting deletion of a segment of the long arm of chromosome 11 represents a genetic subtype of tumor that is distinct from those exhibiting MYCN amplification or 1p deletion. The 11q- genetic subtype is further characterized by gain of 17q and loss of distal 3p material. Gain of 11p material has also been reported in neuroblastoma with 11q loss, but at a considerably lower frequency than gain of 17q or loss of the distal 3p region. Our results, however, indicate that gain of 11p may occur more frequently in 11q- neuroblastoma than what was previously realized. Comparative genomic hybridization analyses of neuroblastoma tissue from eleven patients indicated that six of 11 tumors (55%) with loss of 11q also possessed gain of 11p. The shortest region of 11p gain was 11p11.2-->p14. G-banding and fluorescence in situ hybridization analysis performed on tumor cells from primary and metastatic sites from one patient allowed us to infer that gain of 11p arose secondarily to the abnormality that led to the loss of 11q material. Gain of an entire chromosome 7 was detected in 17 of 43 (40%) tumors, whereas gain of 7q was detected in 5 of 43 (12%) tumors. Unlike gain of 11p, gain of an entire chromosome 7 appears to be prevalent in all tumor stages and is not limited to the 11q- tumor subtype. Gain of 7q, however, is more prevalent in higher stage tumors. G-band cytogenetic analysis indicated that an unbalanced t(3;7) was responsible for the gain of 7q and loss of 3p material in one case. We discuss the possibility that gain of 7/7q, and 11p material may contribute to either tumorigenesis or progression.

Chromosomal localization of DNA amplifications in neuroblastoma tumors using cDNA microarray comparative genomic hybridization

Conventional comparative genomic hybridization (CGH) profiling of neuroblastomas has identified many genomic aberrations, although the limited resolution has precluded a precise localization of sequences of interest within amplicons. To map high copy number genomic gains in clinically matched stage IV neuroblastomas, CGH analysis using a 19,200-feature cDNA microarray was used. A dedicated (freely available) algorithm was developed for rapid in silico determination of chromosomal localizations of microarray cDNA targets, and for generation of an ideogram-type profile of copy number changes. Using these methodologies, novel gene amplifications undetectable by chromosome CGH were identified, and larger MYCN amplicon sizes (in one tumor up to 6 Mb) than those previously reported in neuroblastoma were identified. The genes HPCAL1, LPIN1/KIAA0188, NAG, and NSE1/LOC151354 were found to be coamplified with MYCN. To determine whether stage IV primary tumors could be further subclassified based on their genomic copy number profiles, hierarchical clustering was performed. Cluster analysis of microarray CGH data identified three groups: 1) no amplifications evident, 2) a small MYCN amplicon as the only detectable imbalance, and 3) a large MYCN amplicon with additional gene amplifications. Application of CGH to cDNA microarray targets will help to determine both the variation of amplicon size and help better define amplification-dependent and independent pathways of progression in neuroblastoma.

MYCN gene overrepresentation detected in primary neuroblastoma tumour cells without amplification

Neuroblastoma is the most frequent solid extracranial neoplasm of childhood, with a median age of presentation of under 2 years. This tumour is highly malignant in patients older than 12 months of age with metastatic disease. Clinical studies have confirmed that amplification of the MYCN proto-oncogene is one of the best prognostic indicators of poor outcome. Approximately 30% of neuroblastoma tumours present MYCN amplification at diagnosis. Far less is known about the incidence and consequences of overrepresentation of the gene due to duplication or rearrangement of the chromosome arm in which the gene is situated. This study has analysed 110 neuroblastomas by FISH and has detected a gain of 1-3 copies per cell of MYCN in 8% of MYCN-non-amplified tumours. In these primary tumours, cells gained small numbers of additional MYCN genes by two mechanisms: formation of an isochromosome 2p, or an unbalanced translocation involving the short arm of chromosome 2 (with MYCN) and various partner chromosomes. Quantitative RT-PCR showed three- to seven-fold elevated MYCN expression in three tumours. Although the follow-up time to date is still short, clinical outcome suggests that low-level overexpression of the MYCN gene does not enhance tumour aggressiveness and rapidity of disease progression, as is often seen in neuroblastoma with MYCN amplification. It is hypothesized that the small elevation in MYCN expression could alter the regulation of apoptosis, as has been shown in experimental models.

Genetic parameters of neuroblastomas

Neuroblastoma is a malignant childhood tumor of migrating neuroectodermal cells derived from the neural crest and destined for the adrenal medulla and the sympathetic nervous system. The biological behavior of neuroblastomas is extremely variable and in some respects unique. Neuroblastomas tend to regress spontaneously in a portion of infants or to differentiate into a benign ganglioneuroma in some older patients. Unfortunately, in the majority of patients neuroblastoma is metastatic at the time of diagnosis, and it usually undergoes rapid progression with a fatal outcome. The mechanisms leading to this diverse clinical behavior of neuroblastomas are largely unclear. From the analysis of tumors at the cytogenetic and molecular level non-random genetic changes have been identified, including ploidy changes, amplification of the oncogene MYCN, deletions of chromosome 1p, gains of chromosome arm 17q, and deletions of 11q as well as of other genomic regions that allow tumors to be classified into subsets with distinct biological features and clinical behavior. MYCN status is widely accepted for therapy stratification. Additional genetic parameters are currently under investigation to refine risk assessment, but so far the molecular monitoring tools for prediction of therapy response and disease outcome are still incomplete. This should lead to more risk-adapted therapies according to the clinical-genetic parameters by which individual tumors are characterized. This review aims at discussing the role of genomic changes in neuroblastomas of diverse biological and clinical types.

Distinct cytogenetic pathways of advanced-stage neuroblastoma tumors, detected by spectral karyotyping

Molecular studies of advanced-stage neuroblastoma (NBL) have revealed a marked genetic heterogeneity. In addition to MYCN amplification and chromosome 1 short-arm deletions/translocations detected by conventional cytogenetics, application of fluorescence in situ hybridization has disclosed a high prevalence of 17q gain, whereas allelotyping and comparative genomic hybridization techniques also have revealed loss of 11q and of other chromosomal material. Using the recently developed technique of spectral karyotyping (SKY), we sought to refine the cytogenetic information, identify hidden recurrent structural chromosomal abnormalities, and compare them to the molecular findings. Thirteen samples of metaphase spreads from 11 patients with advanced-stage NBL were analyzed by SKY. Most of them were found to have complex karyotypes (more than three changes per metaphase) and complex unbalanced rearrangements. Recurrent aberrations leading to 17q gain, deletion of 1p, MYCN amplification, and loss of 11q appeared in 7, 4, 4, and 5 patients, respectively, in simple and complex karyotypes. Chromosome 3 changes and gain of 1q and 7q appeared in 6, 5, and 4 patients, respectively, in complex karyotypes only, reflecting later changes. A strikingly high prevalence of the unbalanced translocation der(11)t(11;17), leading to concomitant 11q loss and 17q gain in 4 patients, delineated a distinct cytogenetic group, none having 1p deletion and/or MYCN amplification. der(11)t(11;17) was associated with complex karyotypes with changes in chromosomes 3 and 7q. The 17q translocations with partners other than 11q were associated with 1p deletion and/or MYCN amplification. The distinct cytogenetic subgroups identified by SKY confirm and extend the recent molecular observations, and suggest that different genes may interact in the der(11)t(11;17) pathway of NBL development and progression.

Compilation of published comparative genomic hybridization studies

The power of comparative genomic hybridization (CGH) has been clearly proven since the first paper appeared in 1992 as a tool to characterize chromosomal imbalances in neoplasias. This review summarizes the chromosomal imbalances detected by CGH in solid tumors and in hemopathies. In May of 2001, we took a census of 430 articles providing information on 11,984 cases of human solid tumors or hematologic malignancies. Comparative generic hybridization has detected a number of recurrent regions of amplification or deletion that allows for identification of new chromosomal loci (oncogenes, tumor suppressor genes, or other genes) involved in the development, progression, and clonal evolution of tumors. When CGH data from different studies are combined, a pattern of nonrandom genetic aberrations appears. As expected, some of these gains and losses are common to different types of pathologies, while others are more tumor-specific.

Suppression of human melanoma metastasis by the metastasis suppressor gene, BRMS1

We recently identified a novel metastasis suppressor gene, BRMS1, in breast cancer. Since the BRMS1 gene maps to chromosome 11q13.1-q13.2 and since chromosome 11q defects have been described in various stages of human melanoma progression, we hypothesized that BRMS1 may function as a tumor or metastasis suppressor in melanomas as well. Quantitative real-time RT-PCR revealed that BRMS1 mRNA expression was high in melanocytes, considerably reduced in early melanoma-derived cell lines, and barely detectable in advanced/metastatic cell lines. Stable transfectants of BRMS1 in the human melanoma cell lines MelJuSo and C8161.9 did not alter the tumorigenicity of either cell line, but significantly suppressed metastasis compared to vector-only transfectants. Orthotopic tumors continued to express BRMS1, but expression was lost in lung metastases. In vitro morphology, growth rate, and histology of BRMS1 transfectants were similar to controls. BRMS1 transfectants were less invasive in a collagen sandwich assay and had restored homotypic gap junctional intercellular communication (GJIC). Thus, BRMS1 functions as a metastasis suppressor in more than one tumor type (i.e., breast carcinoma and cutaneous melanoma) by modifying several metastasis-associated phenotypes.

Neuroblastoma tumour genetics: clinical and biological aspects

Neuroblastoma tumour cells show complex combinations of acquired genetic aberrations, including ploidy changes, deletions of chromosome arms 1p and 11q, amplification of the MYCN oncogene, and-most frequently-gains of chromosome arm 17q. Despite intensive investigation, the fundamental role of these features in neuroblastoma initiation and progression remains to be understood. Nonetheless, great progress has been made in relating tumour genetic abnormalities to tumour behaviour and to clinical outcome; indeed, neuroblastoma provides a paradigm for the clinical importance of tumour genetic abnormalities. Knowledge of MYCN status is increasingly being used in treatment decisions for individual children, and the clinical value of 1p and 17q data as adjuncts or refinements in risk stratification is under active investigation. Reliable detection of these molecular cytogenetic features should be regarded as mandatory for all new cases at presentation.

Combined M-FISH and CGH analysis allows comprehensive description of genetic alterations in neuroblastoma cell lines

Cancer cell lines are essential gene discovery tools and have often served as models in genetic and functional studies of particular tumor types. One of the future challenges is comparison and interpretation of gene expression data with the available knowledge on the genomic abnormalities in these cell lines. In this context, accurate description of these genomic abnormalities is required. Here, we show that a combination of M-FISH with banding analysis, standard FISH, and CGH allowed a detailed description of the genetic alterations in 16 neuroblastoma cell lines. In total, 14 cryptic chromosome rearrangements were detected, including a balanced t(2;4)(p24.3;q34.3) translocation in cell line NBL-S, with the 2p24 breakpoint located at about 40 kb from MYCN. The chromosomal origin of 22 marker chromosomes and 41 cytogenetically undefined translocated segments was determined. Chromosome arm 2 short arm translocations were observed in six cell lines (38%) with and five (31%) without MYCN amplification, leading to partial chromosome arm 2p gain in all but one cell line and loss of material in the various partner chromosomes, including 1p and 11q. These 2p gains were often masked in the GGH profiles due to MYCN amplification. The commonly overrepresented region was chromosome segment 2pter-2p22, which contains the MYCN gene, and five out of eleven 2p breakpoints clustered to the interface of chromosome bands 2p16 and 2p21. In neuroblastoma cell line SJNB-12, with double minutes (dmins) but no MYCN amplification, the dmins were shown to be derived from 16q22-q23 sequences. The ATBF1 gene, an AT-binding transcription factor involved in normal neurogenesis and located at 16q22.2, was shown to be present in the amplicon. This is the first report describing the possible implication of ATBF1 in neuroblastoma cells. We conclude that a combined approach of M-FISH, cytogenetics, and CGH allowed a more complete and accurate description of the genetic alterations occurring in the investigated cell lines.