Vitrification of mouse oocytes results in aneuploid zygotes and malformed fetuses

Potential use of embryo coculture with human in vitro fertilization procedures

PURPOSE

This review was designed to outline potential uses of an embryo co-culture system in human assisted reproduction programs to improve embryo quality and pregnancy rates.

RESULTS

The various cell types used in embryo co-culture were reviewed in addition to the use of co-culture for both animal and human embryos. Co-culture provides a method to enhance embryo development in an inadequate in vitro environment without compromising embryo quality. Human IVF laboratories have used various types of "helper cells" to improve rate of development, reduce cell fragmentation rate and in some instances increases pregnancy and implantation rates.

CONCLUSION

In conjunction with several assisted reproduction procedures such as IVF, microsurgical fertilization, cryopreservation and genetic evaluation, co-culture may increase the number of viable embryos for replacement and improve pregnancy rates.

The effect of temperature fluctuations on the cytoskeletal organisation and chromosomal constitution of the human oocyte

The effect of temperature fluctuation on spindle integrity and chromosomal organisation in the human oocyte, and the consequences of such effects on the chromosomal constitution of resulting parthenotes, were investigated. A total of 340 oocytes were stained immunocytochemically with an antibody to alpha-tubulin, and 502 were activated parthenogenetically. Exposure of oocytes to room temperature for 2, 10 or 30 min caused disruption of the spindle in 77% (n = 26), 72% (n = 18) and 89% (n = 19) of cases respectively, with evidence of chromosomal dispersal in 50%, 56% and 52.6% respectively. These effects were reversed when oocytes were returned to 37 degrees C after exposure to room temperature for 2 min, but not after 10 min or 30 min. Temperature reduction affected rates of parthenogenetic activation of oocytes (2 min: 67%, n = 27; 10 min: 68%, n = 28; 30 min: 54%, n = 35) and cleavage of resulting parthenotes, but only if oocytes were exposed to room temperature for 30 min (30 min: 53%, n = 19). There is a direct association between temperature-induced spindle damage in the oocyte (70%, 50 of 63) and chromosomal abnormalities in parthenotes developed from oocytes exposed to room temperature (56%, 23 of 41; p < 0.01).

Analysis of the chromosome complement of frozen-thawed mouse oocytes after parthenogenetic activation

Frozen-thawed mouse oocytes were artificially activated with Sr2+ and analyzed cytogenetically at the first cleavage division to examine the behavior of the maternal chromosomes independently of the paternal complement. There was no significant difference in the rate of activation between frozen-thawed and freshly collected oocytes and the majority of oocytes (> 90%) had a normal haploid chromosome constitution. The incidence of second polar body retention in frozen-thawed oocytes was low and did not differ significantly from that observed in fresh oocytes and oocytes exposed to dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO) at 0 degree C or 37 degrees C for extended periods beyond those required for protection. The frequency of aneuploidy was similar for frozen-thawed and fresh oocytes but oocytes held at 0 degree C without DMSO or held at 37 degrees C with DMSO for 1 hr showed a 2.5 and 12-fold increase in the frequency of aneuploidy compared with oocytes subjected to a conventional oocyte/embryo freezing regime. It is concluded that the procedures used in successful oocyte cryopreservation do not increase the incidence of chromosomal abnormalities of maternal origin in the resulting embryos.

Evaluation of the meiotic spindle apparatus in oocytes undergoing intracytoplasmic sperm injection

OBJECTIVE

To determine whether intracytoplasmic sperm injection has an adverse effect on the meiotic spindle of oocytes after injection of a sperm into the ooplasm.

DESIGN

Hamster oocytes were injected with human sperm (Test group) and evaluated for meiotic spindle and chromosome morphology using immunofluorescent staining. Results were compared with control uninjected oocytes exposed to the microscope environment (CS group) and untreated oocytes remaining in the incubator (CI group).

SETTING

Basic research center at a medical school.

RESULTS

No significant differences were noted in spindle appearance and chromosome alignment between Test (13 abnormal/68 normal) and both control groups (CS 9/73 and CI 12/71; P = 0.602).

CONCLUSION

Our results demonstrate that injection of human sperm into the cytoplasm of hamster oocytes may not result in a significant increase in damage to the meiotic spindle provided care is taken to orient the polar body away from the site of injection.

In vitro viability and ultrastructural changes in bovine oocytes treated with a vitrification solution

Abattoir-derived oocytes were exposed to a concentrated cryoprotectant solution (DAP213: 2 M DMSO, 1 M acetamide, 3 M propanediol, and 10% FCS in TCM199) for 1.5 or 5 min at the germinal vesicle (GV) stage or after maturation in vitro (IVM). Their viability was assessed by in vitro fertilization (IVF) and culture (IVC) to blastocysts. To investigate the effect of DAP213 on the ultrastructure, GV and IVM oocytes were processed for transmission electron microscopy (TEM) before (control) or after exposure to the cryoprotectant. DAP213 induced profound ultrastructural modifications to the microvilli and mitochondria, resulted in large vesicle formation, and, most significantly, caused the premature release of the cortical granules (CG). In IVM oocytes exposed to the cryoprotectant for 5 min, exocytosis of CG into the perivitelline space was common and the IVF rate was reduced (P < .05). After exposure for 5 min, GV oocytes displayed clusters of CG comparable to controls, but after IVM-IVF, polyspermy rate was increased (P < .05). Furthermore, treated GV oocytes showed a reduced rate of cleavage and blastocyst formation and an increased percentage of oocytes exhibiting alterations in organelles, whereas the viability and ultrastructure of IVM oocytes treated for 1.5 min was not different from controls. These observations demonstrate that 1) cortical granule kinetics is one of the key elements controlling fertilizability of bovine oocytes treated with cryoprotectant, and 2) GV oocytes are more sensitive to the cryoprotectant than those that have already been matured in vitro.

Effects of cooling and equilibration in DMSO, and cryopreservation of mouse oocytes, on the rates of in vitro fertilization, development, and chromosomal abnormalities

In a previous study, we have shown that the cryopreservation of mouse oocytes caused increases in the rates of degeneration and of digynic polyploid embryos, while the fertility of frozen-thawed oocytes was decreased. In this study, we have attempted to determine the different stages in the complete freezing-thawing process which are deleterious for the oocytes and the subsequent zygotes. IVF assays showed that DMSO decreased the fertility of oocytes, whereas cooling to 0 degrees C had no effect. DMSO, used at 0 degrees C, was less deleterious for oocytes. Thus, the prefreezing manipulations seem to be important for the quality and fertility of oocytes. However, neither DMSO nor cooling increased the incidence of chromosomal abnormalities in embryos obtained from inseminated exposed oocytes. Therefore, the increased frequency of polyploidy observed in embryos after the cryopreservation of mouse oocytes must correspond to disruption occurring during the freezing-thawing process.

Cytogenetic, cellular, and developmental consequences of cryopreservation of immature and mature mouse and human oocytes

This study examined the effects of cryopreservation on cellular organization, chromosomal complement, and developmental potential of immature and mature mouse and human oocytes. Chromosomal analyses were performed by DNA fluorescence microscopy and karyotyping on the same metaphase II-stage oocytes before and after freezing. Cellular analyses involved electron microscopy, time-lapse video recording, and fluorescent-probe microscopy of cortical granules. The findings demonstrate that while profound cytoplasmic, nuclear, and nucleolar alterations occur in the immature oocyte during cryopreservation, an apparently normal nucleus and cytoplasm is re-established progressively after thawing and culture. The resulting oocytes mature at high frequency and for the mouse, are fertilizable and capable of normal preimplantation of embryogenesis. Cryopreservation of mature mouse and human oocytes is not accompanied by a significant increase in the frequency of aneuploidy. However, cryopreserved human oocytes, while fertilizable, arrest development during the early cleavage stages and display aberrant patterns of cytokinesis. The possible etiologies of developmental failure in the human embryo that may be related to oocyte cryopreservation, as well as the potential benefits of cryopreservation of the immature oocyte, are discussed with respect to clinical and commercial applications.

Effect of cryoprotectant concentration, equilibration time and thawing procedure on survival and development of rapid frozen-thawed mature mouse oocytes

Experiments were conducted to develop a simple rapid-freezing protocol for mature mouse oocytes that would yield a high proportion of oocytes with developmental potential. The effects of concentration (3.5, 4.5 and 6.0 M dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) all with 0.5 M sucrose) and the duration of exposure (2.5 min vs 45 sec) of oocytes to the cryoprotectant and its extraction after thawing in 2, 3 or 4 steps of descending sucrose concentration were studied. The most effective of the rapid-freezing and thawing protocols (4.5 M DMSO; 45 sec exposure and 3-step thawing) was compared to slow freezing protocols using 1.5 M DMSO and 1.0 M 1,2 propanediol as cryoprotectants. The DMSO concentrations had an effect on survival, fertilization and embryo development using short (45 sec) but not long (2.5 min) exposure. The rate of morphological oocyte survival was significantly higher using 4.5 M DMSO than 3.5 or 6.0 M (92% vs 82 and 73%, respectively). The development of fertilized embryos to blastocysts was also significantly higher at 4.5 M than at 3.5 or 6.0 M (68% vs 42 and 53%, respectively). The extraction of cryoprotectant in 3 or 4 steps of descending sucrose concentration resulted in higher survival (P < 0.01) and fertilization than in 2 steps. The best survival, fertilization and development was achieved with the 3-step procedure. Optimal combinations of conditions were 4.5 M DMSO at 45 sec prefreeze exposure and 3-step extraction of the cryoprotectant. Oocytes frozen by conventional methods had a survival, fertilization and development to blastocyst rate significantly lower than those frozen under the optimal rapid conditions. Thus rapid freezing of mature mouse oocytes with 4.5 M DMSO + 0.5 M sucrose and short prefreeze exposure is effective and has the additional advantage of being less time-consuming than slow freezing methods.

New challenges in human in vitro fertilization

This review assesses some scientific and ethical problems with human in vitro fertilization. Improved selection of viable embryos, better culture conditions, and greater understanding of the uterine environment will increase success and prevent multiple pregnancy. Further advances will also improve oocyte cryopreservation, in vitro maturation of oocytes, knowledge of sperm function, and sperm microinjection. Preimplantation diagnosis will help avoid genetic diseases and increase understanding of embryonic defects and the viability of zygotes. The greatest ethical problem with all these developments seems to be delivery of these complex treatments when health-care resources are increasingly limited.

A freezing and thawing method of hamster oocytes designed for both the penetration test and chromosome assay of human spermatozoa

Superovulated hamster oocytes were cryopreserved and thawed according to our carefully designed procedures. More than 90% (92 +/- 4%) of oocytes survived freezing and thawing. They were proven to be well conserved, showing excellent performance comparable to freshly ovulated oocytes in the human sperm penetration test (proportion of penetrated ova: 94.7% vs. 93.6%) and human sperm chromosome analysis (proportion of metaphasic ova: 81.8% vs. 83.6%). There was no statistically significant difference in the incidences of sperm chromosome aberrations between assays using fresh and frozen-thawed oocytes. In addition, there was no statistically significant increase of aberrations in female pronuclear (hamster) chromosomes. This freezing-thawing method was found to be reliable, yielding viable hamster oocytes of high quality.

Numerical chromosome anomalies after fertilization of freeze-thawed mouse oocytes

The chromosome complement of first cleavage stage mouse embryos was analyzed to investigate the effect of slow freezing-fast thawing cryopreservation on chromosome numbers by comparing these numbers with those found fresh after fertilization of control oocytes. Fewer frozen-thawed (34.1%) than control oocytes (75.0%) cleaved to the 2-cell stage after in vitro fertilization. The incidence of hyperploidy was significantly increased by freezing (4.5% vs. 0% in controls). Polyploidy was not significantly affected (17.0% for freeze-thaw embryos vs. 26.2% for controls).

In vitro fertilization and development of frozen-thawed bovine oocytes

Bovine oocytes were vitrified (V-oocytes) or frozen slowly (S-oocytes) at the germinal vesicle (GV) stage or after maturation in vitro (IVM) and their survival assessed morphologically and also by in vitro fertilization (IVF) and culture. The morphological survival of S-oocytes was 30.7% after freezing at the GV stage and 53.3% after IVM. The corresponding survival rates of V-oocytes were significantly lower, viz. 14.6 and 14.0%, respectively. The fertilization rate of S-oocytes frozen after IVM (51.0%) was lower than that of unfrozen controls (75.8%), but higher than after other treatments. Development continued in 16.0% of the fertilized S-oocytes, compared to 39.4% of control IVF zygotes and 1.6% developed into morulae or blastocysts (4.5% in controls). Only 0.8% of frozen-thawed GV stage oocytes and 4.6% of post-IVM V-oocytes cleaved after IVF and none formed morulae or blastocysts. Transfer of four embryos (two morulae and two blastocysts) derived from post-IVM S-oocytes into a recipient heifer resulted in pregnancy and the birth of twin calves.

Survival of human oocytes cryopreserved with or without the cumulus in 1,2-propanediol

BACKGROUND

Although cryopreservation of human preembryos has been carried out with success, the cryostorage of oocytes, which pose fewer controversial moral, ethical, and legal problems has been much less successful. Various attempts to cryopreserve human oocytes have been mostly unsuccessful and the search for an optimal protocol for oocyte cryopreservation remains elusive. We therefore undertook this study to determine the effect of oocyte cryostorage in 1,2-propanediol.

METHOD

Mature human oocytes with or without their cumuli were cryopreserved in precooled 1,2-propanediol, then thawed and inseminated with sperms for in vitro fertilization. The outcome of insemination and subsequent embryonic development were also recorded and compared.

RESULTS

Postthaw cryosurvival rate was significantly better when cryostorage was carried out with the oocyte cumulus intact as compared to those oocytes denuded of their cumuli (54 versus 27%, respectively; P < 0.05). Eight (44%) of 18 surviving postthaw oocytes with intact cumuli were fertilized normally, with cleavage in six, as compared to two (25%) and one, respectively, of those denuded of their cumulus prior to cryostorage. Development to the blastocyst stage was achieved in three embryos derived from oocytes with an intact cumulus at cryostorage.

CONCLUSION

We conclude that 1,2-propanediol can be used with success in oocyte cryopreservation, although the issue of parthenogenecity is still to be resolved. Oocyte's with intact cumulus survive cryostorage better than those without it.

The effects of cooling mouse oocytes

The effects of cooling and warming on meiotic spindles of mouse oocytes have been assessed by transmission electron microscopy. Intact cumulus-oocyte complexes were immediately cooled from 37 to 15, 4, 0, and -7 degrees C (seeding temperature) for 15 min in a programmed biological freezer and fixed at these temperatures. Other complexes, cooled to these temperatures, were rapidly warmed to 37 degrees C and incubated for 2 hr before fixation at 37 degrees C. Of 334 oocytes assessed at various temperatures, at least 100 were examined for metaphase II spindles. Spindle microtubules completely disappear at 0 and -7 degrees C, while complete or partial depolymerization of microtubules was observed at 4 degrees C. Cooling to 15 degrees C did not cause major disruptions of spindle structure in most oocytes. Chromosomes tended to rotate or clump at lower temperatures but chromosome scatter outside the spindle zone was rarely observed. Centrosomal material was fragmented at 4 degrees C and occasionally at 15 degrees C and was not evident at the spindle poles at 0 and -7 degrees C. Kinetochores were seen at all temperatures. Spindle structure was evidently restored in the majority of oocytes on rewarming at 37 degrees C. Changes in the ooplasm induced by cooling were elongation and disruption of vesicular smooth endoplasmic reticulum, especially between lipid globules and disappearance of fibrillar inclusions. Cortical granule exocytosis was not observed on cooling, while microfilaments were intact. Swelling of membranous organelles was also observed in cumulus cells. Most of the cytoplasmic changes were also reversed on rewarming. The response of mouse oocytes to cooling is compared to that of human oocytes, reported previously.

Vitrification of mouse oocytes: improved rates of survival, fertilization, and development to blastocysts

Rall and Fahy's (1985) vitrification procedure for the cryopreservation of 8-cell embryos was applied to unfertilized mouse oocytes. Unchanged, this method resulted in a mean of 24.1% of vitrified oocytes fertilizing and developing to blastocysts in vitro. Exposure of oocytes to the cryoprotectant media, but without the vitrification, resulted in 30.8% developing to blastocysts. Modifications to the durations of and media used in the dilution and equilibration steps of the procedure produced a final protocol giving a mean of 55.4% of vitrified oocytes and 72.4% of nonvitrified VS1-exposed oocytes developing to blastocysts; 85.7% of control oocytes develop to blastocysts. Osmotically induced damage was found to be the most important cause of loss of viability in these methods. Cooling of oocytes to 5-8 degrees C during the procedure had no significant effect on their viability. No parthenogenetic activation of oocytes occurred as a result of exposure to the procedure.

Transient cooling to room temperature can cause irreversible disruption of the meiotic spindle in the human oocyte

The effect on the microtubule system of human oocytes of cooling to room temperature for either 10 or 30 minutes has been investigated. Changes in spindle organization were found in all oocytes cooled for 30 minutes compared with control oocytes kept at 37 degrees C throughout. These changes included reduction in spindle size, disorganization of microtubules within the spindle itself, and sometimes a complete lack of microtubules. In some oocytes, chromosome dispersal from the metaphase plate was associated with these changes. Cooling the oocyte to room temperature for only 10 minutes produced a similar pattern of disruption to spindle structure in many cases. The spindles in oocytes that were cooled for either 10 or 30 minutes and then allowed to recover at 37 degrees C for either 1 or 4 hours were found to resemble those in noncooled control oocytes in less than one half of the cases examined, although in only a few cases did the chromosomes remain dispersed. The significance of these findings for the handling of oocytes during gamete intrafallopian transfer and in vitro fertilization procedures is discussed in relation to the levels of aneuploidy detected in early human embryos.

Problems in the cryopreservation of unfertilized eggs by slow cooling in dimethyl sulfoxide

The survival, fertilization, development, and viability in vitro and in vivo of unfertilized mouse eggs frozen by slow cooling to -36 degrees C or -80 degrees C in 1.5 M dimethyl sulphoxide (DMSO) was examined in a series of experiments which explored some of the problems in freezing the egg. DMSO was added to the eggs at either room temperature or at 0 degrees C. Maximum success rate (42% of frozen eggs developing to two cells) was obtained when DMSO was added at 0 degrees C and the eggs slow cooled to -80 degrees C. Removal of cumulus failed to improve freezing success rates. Addition of DMSO at temperatures above 0 degrees C significantly reduced the fertilizing capacity of eggs. Excessive exposure of eggs to temperatures around 15 degrees C also caused a significant reduction in fertilization rates. The effects of DMSO and cooling on fertilization are likely to be due to zona hardening by cortical granule release and to disorganization of the egg cytoskeleton and plasma membrane. These problems will be difficult to overcome if cryopreservation of the unfertilized human egg is preferred to the fertilized egg or early cleavage stage embryo in clinical in vitro fertilization.

Screening of conditions for rapid freezing of human oocytes: preliminary study toward their cryopreservation

One hundred and twenty-one freshly-collected human oocytes and 839 unfertilized human oocytes after insemination were cryopreserved by vitrification. The cryoprotectants used were dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO) and sucrose. Vital staining and morphological criteria were used to assess injuries to cells. Variation of the time exposure to DMSO and sucrose, and cryoprotectants concentrations, followed by extraction-dilution in sucrose without freezing made it possible to study chemical toxicities. Variation of cryoprotectant concentrations followed by immersion in liquid nitrogen, thawing, extraction, and dilution made it possible to choose optimal conditions for vitrification. The sucrose concentration upon extraction after freezing and thawing which was lower than that during soaking enhanced the oocyte survival rate as did the choice of duration and temperature of soaking. No parthenogenetical activation of these unfertilized ovum was observed. This study indicates that with a certain combination of DMSO and sucrose concentrations up to 80% of morphologically intact human oocytes can be recovered after rapid freezing and thawing.

Parthenogenetic activation of unfertilized mouse oocytes by exposure to 1,2-propanediol is influenced by temperature, oocyte age, and cumulus removal

Cumulus-intact and -denuded unfertilized oocytes from two mouse strains were exposed to 1.5 M ethanol (EtOH) or two cryoprotectant solutions, 1.5 M propanediol (PROH) or 1.5 M dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO), for 4.5 min at 27 degrees C, and the proportion of activating or degenerating oocytes studied. Exposure to DMSO did not significantly increase activation above that of oocytes not exposed to DMSO. Treatment of oocytes in PROH resulted in the activation of up to 87% of viable oocytes. This was significantly higher (P less than .01) than in control oocytes and comparable to the rate of activation after treatment with EtOH (59-96% activation). In solutions at 1 degree C, 47% of control oocytes were activated, which was not significantly different from the rate of activation in EtOH (36%) or PROH (50%) at 1 degree C. Following treatment with PROH, up to 87% of oocytes degenerated within a period of 6 h in vitro. The age of the oocytes (h post hCG) and the time of cumulus removal with the enzyme hyaluronidase, relative to the time of exposure to the chemicals, influenced the level of degeneration in most groups. Significantly fewer oocytes degenerated when cumulus cells were removed before treatment (0-31%) than when the cumulus was left intact throughout the treatment and 6 h culture period (10-87%). Exposure to PROH at 1 degree C reduced oocyte degeneration to 5%. We conclude that PROH causes significantly greater losses of oocytes as a result of parthenogenetic activation and degeneration than of exposure to DMSO.