Contributions of the TATA box sequence to rate-limiting steps in transcription initiation by RNA polymerase II

Probability in transcriptional regulation and its implications for leukocyte differentiation and inducible gene expression

The phenotype of individual hematopoietic cells, like all other differentiated mammalian cells, is determined by selective transcription of a subset of the genes encoded within the genome. This overview summarizes the recent evidence that transcriptional regulation at the level of individual cells is best described in terms of the regulation of the probability of transcription rather than the rate. In this model, heterogeneous gene expression among populations of cells arises by chance, and the degree of heterogeneity is a function of the stability of the mRNA and protein products of individual genes. The probabilistic nature of transcriptional regulation provides one explanation for stochastic phenomena, such as stem cell lineage commitment, and monoallelic expression of inducible genes, such as lymphokines and cytokines.

Probability in transcriptional regulation and its implications for leukocyte differentiation and inducible gene expression

The phenotype of individual hematopoietic cells, like all other differentiated mammalian cells, is determined by selective transcription of a subset of the genes encoded within the genome. This overview summarizes the recent evidence that transcriptional regulation at the level of individual cells is best described in terms of the regulation of the probability of transcription rather than the rate. In this model, heterogeneous gene expression among populations of cells arises by chance, and the degree of heterogeneity is a function of the stability of the mRNA and protein products of individual genes. The probabilistic nature of transcriptional regulation provides one explanation for stochastic phenomena, such as stem cell lineage commitment, and monoallelic expression of inducible genes, such as lymphokines and cytokines.

The exchange of cognate TATA boxes results in a corresponding change in the strength of two HSV-1 early promoters

Previous analysis of two Herpes Simplex Virus Type-1 (HSV-1) promoters controlling expression of mRNA encoding early genes (U(L)37 and U(L)50) showed that the U(L)50 (dUTPase) promoter is at least 6-fold stronger both in its normal genomic location and in the non-essential gC locus. In the present report we demonstrate that the TATA element of either promoter is the major determinant of promoter strength. When the U(L)37 TATA element (CGTATAAC) was mutated with two base changes to the U(L)50 TATA sequence (CATAAAAC) in recombinant viruses, the activity of the U(L)37 promoter was increased to that of the U(L)50 promoter. Conversely, when the U(L)50 TATA element was changed to that of the U(L)37 promoter, U(L)50 promoter activity was reduced to the level of the U(L)37 promoter. In addition, we investigated the spacing of the TATA box with respect to upstream promoter elements. We found that re-positioning the U(L)37 TATA box to a location equivalent to that of the U(L)50 promoter relative to the transcript start site; i.e. three bases upstream of its cognate location, significantly diminished activity. Substitution of the U(L)50 TATA box at the new position could only partially restore promoter activity. Thus, we also conclude that the spacing of TATA elements vis-à-vis upstream promoter elements is also a critical determinant of promoter strength.

Roles for non-TATA core promoter sequences in transcription and factor binding

Sequence blocks within the core region were swapped among RNA polymerase II promoters to explore effects on transcription in vitro. The pair of blocks flanking TATA strongly influenced general transcription, with an additional effect on promoter activation. These flanking elements induced a change in the ratio of activated to basal transcription, whereas swapping TATA and initiator sequences only altered general transcription levels. Swapping the flanking blocks influenced binding by general transcription factors TBP and TFIIB. The results suggest that the architecture of the extended core sequence is important in determining promoter-specific effects on both general transcription levels and the tightness of regulation.

Adeno-associated virus major Rep78 protein disrupts binding of TATA-binding protein to the p97 promoter of human papillomavirus type 16

Adeno-associated virus type 2 (AAV) is known to inhibit the promoter activities of several oncogenes and viral genes, including the human papillomavirus type 16 (HPV-16) E6 and E7 transforming genes. However, the target elements of AAV on the long control region (LCR) upstream of E6 and E7 oncogenes are elusive. A chloramphenicol acetyltransferase assay was performed to study the effect of AAV on the transcription activity of the HPV-16 LCR in SiHa (HPV-positive) and C-33A (HPV-negative) cells. The results reveal that (i) AAV inhibited HPV-16 LCR activity in a dose-dependent manner, (ii) AAV-mediated inhibition did not require the HPV gene products, and (iii) the AAV replication gene product Rep78 was involved in the inhibition. Deletion mutation analyses of the HPV-16 LCR showed that regulatory elements outside the core promoter region of the LCR may not be direct targets of AAV-mediated inhibition. Further study with the electrophoretic mobility shift assay demonstrated that Rep78 interfered with the binding of TATA-binding protein (TBP) to the TATA box of the p97 core promoter more significantly than it disrupted the preformed TBP-TATA complex. These data thus suggest that Rep78 may inhibit transcription initiation of the HPV-16 LCR by disrupting the interaction between TBP and the TATA box of the p97 core promoter.

Gene structure of a new cardiac peptide hormone: a model for heart-specific gene expression

Volume excess and mechanical load lead to the induction of the endocrine activity of the heart. The increased production and secretion of A- and B-type natriuretic peptides (ANP and BNP), in turn, unload the heart due to their physiological effects. To find out the mechanisms of cardiac-specific expression and sensitivity to mechanical stimuli of the natriuretic peptide genes, we have used salmon (Salmo salar) as our model organism, because osmoregulating fish have a particularly well developed defense mechanism against volume excess. We have previously cloned a complementary DNA from salmon heart encoding a novel vasorelaxant cardiac hormone, salmon cardiac peptide (sCP). Its production is restricted to the heart, and its release is very sensitive to mechanical load. We have now cloned the gene encoding sCP. The structure of the gene suggests that sCP may represent an ancestral form of the mammalian natriuretic peptides. Remarkably, despite the large phylogenetic distance, the sCP promoter is as effective as mammalian ANP promoters in cultured neonatal rat atrial cardiomyocytes. Therefore, structural and functional comparisons of the promoters of sCP and ANP provide an excellent means of identifying the elements and transcription factors required for atrial-specific gene expression and the regulation of the endocrine function of the heart. Isolation of the protein product of sCP gene from salmon atrium demonstrated that the storage form of sCP is the prohormone of 126 amino acids. The final processing of the prohormone appears to take place during exocytosis of the secretory granules, as the released and circulating form is the biologically active 29-amino acid sCP.

Comparative genomics of chalcone synthase and Myb genes in the grass family

Most plant genes occur as members of multigene families where new copies arise through duplication. Duplicate genes that do not confer an adaptive advantage to the plant are expected to rapidly erode into pseudogenes owing to the accumulation of transpositions, insertion/deletion mutations and nucleotide changes. Nonfunctional copies will drift to fixation within a few million years and ultimately erode beyond recognition. Duplicate genes that are retained over longer periods of evolutionary time must be positively selected based on some adaptive advantage conferred on the plant species. We explore the dynamics of the recruitment of new duplicate genes for chalcone synthase, the enzyme that catalyzes the first committed step of flavonoid biosynthesis, and for the myb family of transcriptional activators. Our analyses show that new chs genes are recruited into the genome of grasses at a rate of one new copy every 15 to 25 million years. In contrast, the myb gene family is much older and many duplicate copies appear to predate the separation of the angiosperm lineage from other seed plants. The general pattern suggests a rapid adaptive proliferation of new chs genes but a more ancient elaboration of regulatory gene functions. Our analyses also reveal accelerated rates of protein evolution following gene duplication and evidence is presented for interlocus exchange among duplicate gene loci.

TATA box DNA deformation with and without the TATA box-binding protein

DNA ring closure methods have been applied to TATA box DNA and its complex with the TATA box-binding protein (TBP). The J factors for cyclization (effective concentrations of one DNA end about the other) have been measured using cyclization kinetics, with and without bound TBP, for 18 DNA constructs containing the adenovirus major late promoter TATA box (TATAAAAG) separated by a variable helical phasing adapter from sequence-induced A-tract DNA bends. Six phasing lengths were used at three overall DNA lengths each. Cyclization kinetics were also measured in the absence of protein for the same set of molecules bearing a mutant TATA box (TACAAAAG). The results suggest that the TATA box DNA itself is strongly bent and anisotropically flexible, in a direction opposite to the bend induced by TBP, and that the mutant TACA box is much less bent/flexible. The bending and flexibility of the free DNA may govern the energetics of recognition of different DNA sequences by TBP, and the intrinsic bend may act to repress transcription complex assembly in the absence of TBP. The cyclization kinetics of TBP-DNA complexes in solution predict a geometry generally consistent with crystal structures, which show dramatic bending and unwinding. The novel observation of TBP-induced topoisomers suggests that this minicircle approach is able to distinguish TBP-induced unwinding from writhe (these cancel out in larger DNA), and this in turn suggests that changes in supercoiling in small topological domains can control TBP binding.

SNAP(c): a core promoter factor with a built-in DNA-binding damper that is deactivated by the Oct-1 POU domain

snRNA gene transcription is activated in part by recruitment of SNAP(c) to the core promoter through protein-protein contacts with the POU domain of the enhancer-binding factor Oct-1. We show that a mini-SNAP(c) consisting of a subset of SNAP(c) subunits is capable of directing both RNA polymerase II (Pol II) and Pol III snRNA gene transcription. Mini-SNAP(c) cannot be recruited by Oct-1, but binds as efficiently to the promoter as SNAP(c) together with Oct-1 and directs activated RNA Pol III transcription. Thus, SNAP(c) represses its own binding to DNA, and repression is relieved by interactions with the Oct-1 POU domain that promote cooperative binding. We have shown previously that TBP also represses its own binding, and in that case repression is relieved by cooperative interactions with SNAP(c). This may represent a general mechanism to ensure that core promoter-binding factors, which have strikingly slow off-rates, are recruited specifically to promoter sequences rather than to cryptic-binding sites in the genome.

Spatial organization of the core region of yeast TFIIIB-DNA complexes

The interaction of yeast TFIIIB with the region upstream of the SUP4 tRNATyr gene was extensively probed by use of photoreactive phosphodiesters, deoxyuridines, and deoxycytidines that are site specifically incorporated into DNA. The TATA binding protein (TBP) was found to be in close proximity to the minor groove of a TATA-like DNA sequence that starts 30 nucleotides upstream of the start site of transcription. TBP was cross-linked to the phosphate backbone of DNA from bp -30 to -20 in the nontranscribed strand and from bp -28 to -24 in the transcribed strand (+1 denotes the start site of transcription). Most of the major groove of DNA in this region was shown not to be in close proximity to TBP, thus resembling the binding of TBP to the TATA box, with one notable exception. TBP was shown to interact with the major groove of DNA primarily at bp -23 and to a lesser degree at bp -25 in the transcribed strand. The stable interaction of TBP with the major groove at bp -23 was shown to require the B" subunit of TFIIIB. The S4 helix and flanking region of TBP were shown to be proximal to the major groove of DNA by peptide mapping of the region of TBP cross-linked at bp -23. Thus, TBP in the TFIIIB-SUP4 gene promoter region is bound in the same direction as TBP bound to the TATA box with respect to the transcription start site. The B" and TFIIB-related factor (BRF) subunits of TFIIIB are positioned on opposite sides of the TBP-DNA core of the TFIIIB complex, as indicated by correlation of cross-linking data to the crystal structure of the TBP-TATA box complex. Evidence is given for BRF binding near the C-terminal stirrup of TBP, similar to that of TFIIB near the TBP-TATA box complex. The protein clamp formed around the TBP-DNA complex by BRF and B" would help explain the long half-life of the TFIIIB-DNA complex and its resistance to polyanions and high salt. The path of DNA traversing the surface of TBP at the 3' end of the TATA-like element in the SUP4 tRNA gene is not the same as that of TBP bound to a TATA box element, as shown by the cross-linking of TBP at bp -23.

Intermediate species possessing bent DNA are present along the pathway to formation of a final TBP-TATA complex

Binding of the TATA-binding protein (TBP) to the "TATA" sequences present in the promoters of eukaryotic class II genes is the first step in the sequential assembly of transcription pre-initiation complexes. Myriad structural changes, including severe bending of the DNA, accompany TBP-TATA complex formation. A detailed kinetic study has been conducted to elucidate the mechanistic details of TBP binding and DNA bending. The binding of Saccharomyces cerevisiae TBP to the adenovirus major late promoter (AdMLP) was followed in real-time through a range of temperatures and TBP concentrations using fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) and stopped-flow mixing. The results of association and relaxation kinetics and equilibrium binding experiments were analyzed globally to obtain the complete kinetic and energetic profile of the reaction. This analysis reveals a complex mechanism with two intermediate species, with the DNA in the intermediates apparently bent similarly to the DNA in the final complex. TBP binding and DNA bending occur simultaneously through the multiple steps of the reaction. The first and third steps in this sequential process show nearly identical large increases in both enthalpy and entropy, whereas the middle step is highly exothermic and proceeds with a large decrease in entropy. The first intermediate is significantly populated at equilibrium and resembles the final complex both structurally and energetically. It is postulated that both this intermediate and the final complex bind transcription factor IIB in the second step of pol II pre-initiation complex assembly. A consequence of such a reactive intermediate is that the rate of assembly of transcriptionally competent pre-initiation complexes from bi-directionally bound TBP is greatly increased.

PU.1 and USF are required for macrophage-specific mannose receptor promoter activity

In the current study we report the isolation of 854 base pairs of the rat mannose receptor promoter. Analysis of the sequence revealed one Sp1 site, three PU.1 sites, and a potential TATA box (TTTAAA) 33 base pairs 5' of the transcriptional start site. The tissue specificity of the promoter was determined using transient transfections. The promoter was most active in the mature macrophage cell line NR8383 although the promoter also showed activity in the monocytic cell line RAW. No activity was observed in pre-monocytic cell lines or epithelial cell lines. Mutation of the TTTAAA sequence to TTGGAA resulted in a 50% decrease in activity in transient transfection assays suggesting that the promoter contains a functional TATA box. Using electrophoretic mobility shift assays and mutagenesis we established that the transcription factors Sp1, PU.1, and USF bound to the mannose receptor promoter, but only PU.1 and USF contributed to activation. Transient transfections using a dominant negative construct of USF resulted in a 50% decrease in mannose receptor promoter activity, further establishing the role of USF in activating the rat mannose receptor promoter. Comparison of the rat, mouse, and human sequence demonstrated that some binding sites are not conserved. Gel shifts were performed to investigate differences in protein binding between species. USF bound to the rat and human promoter but not to the mouse promoter, suggesting that different mechanisms are involved in regulation of mannose receptor expression in these species. From these results we conclude that, similar to other myeloid promoters, transcription of the rat mannose receptor is regulated by binding of PU.1 and a ubiquitous factor at an adjacent site. However, unlike other myeloid promoters, we have identified USF as the ubiquitous factor, and demonstrated that the promoter contains a functional TATA box.

Transcription reinitiation rate: a potential role for TATA box stabilization of the TFIID:TFIIA:DNA complex

Potential pathways that could account for observed rapid rates of transcription reinitiation were explored. A nuclear extract system was established in which reinitiation rates were observed to be kinetically facilitated and in which the rate was sensitive to TATA box mutation. Kinetic facilitation of functional complex formation could be mimicked by pre-assembling activator and certain general transcription factors on the promoter and then adding nuclear extract. The minimal activated complex with this characteristic contained general factors TFIID and TFIIA. The ability of the TFIID:TFIIA complex to complete assembly rapidly was reduced by the same TATA box mutation that reduced reinitiation rate. Band shift experiments also showed that this same mutation lowered the stability of the TBP:TFIIA complex on the DNA. The results suggest that TATA-dependent variations in retention of the TFIID:TFIIA complex after release of the polymerase could be a primary determinant of reinitiation rate, allowing diversity in promoter strength to be related to diversity in TATA element sequences.

Intermediates in formation and activity of the RNA polymerase II preinitiation complex: holoenzyme recruitment and a postrecruitment role for the TATA box and TFIIB

Assembly and activity of yeast RNA polymerase II (Pol II) preinitiation complexes (PIC) was investigated with an immobilized promoter assay and extracts made from wild-type cells and from cells containing conditional mutations in components of the Pol II machinery. We describe the following findings: (1) In one step, TFIID and TFIIA assemble at the promoter independently of holoenzyme. In another step, holoenzyme is recruited to the promoter. Mutations in the CTD of Pol II, Srb2, Srb4, and Srb5, and two mutations in TFIIB disrupt recruitment of all holoenzyme components tested without affecting TFIID and TFIIA recruitment. These results indicate that the stepwise assembly pathway is blocked after TFIID/TFIIA binding. (2) Both the Gal4-AH and Gal4-VP16 activators stimulate formation of active PICs by increasing the extent of PIC formation. The Gal4-AH activator stimulated PIC formation by enhancing the binding of TFIID and TFIIA, whereas Gal4-VP16 could enhance the recruitment of TFIID, TFIIA, and holoenzyme. (3) Extracts deficient in TFIIA activity showed reduced assembly of all PIC components. These and other results suggest that TFIIA acts at an early step by enhancing the stable recruitment of TFIID. (4) An extract containing the TFIIB mutant E62G, had no defect in PIC formation, but had a severe defect in transcription. Similarly, mutation of the TATA box reduced PIC formation only two- to fourfold, but severely compromised transcription. These results demonstate an involvement of TFIIB and the TATA box in one or more steps after recruitment of factors to the promoter.

Affinity, stability and polarity of binding of the TATA binding protein governed by flexure at the TATA Box

The TATA binding protein (TBP), which plays a central role in gene regulation as an essential component of all three nuclear transcription systems, sharply kinks the TATA box at two sites and severely contorts the intervening DNA segment. DNA constructs with precisely localized flexure have been used to investigate the special repertoire of mechanisms and properties that arise from TBP interacting with the TATA box. DNA flexure precisely localized to the sites of TBP-mediated DNA kinking increases the affinity of TBP more than 100-fold; unexpectedly, this increase in affinity is achieved almost exclusively by increasing the stability of the TBP-DNA complex rather than the rate of its formation. In vitro transcription with RNA polymerase III provides a first demonstration that the orientation of TBP on the TATA box is governed by DNA deformability, its C-proximal repeat contacting the more flexible end of the TATA box. Exceptionally stable TBP-DNA complexes reach their orientational equilibrium very slowly; in these circumstances, assembly of stable ("committed") transcription initiation complexes can freeze far-from-equilibrium orientations of TBP on the TATA box, causing transcription polarity to be determined by a kinetic trapping mechanism.