A common ancestor for oxygenic and anoxygenic photosynthetic systems: a comparison based on the structural model of photosystem I

Evolution of the Inner Light-Harvesting Antenna Protein Family of Cyanobacteria, Algae, and Plants

Two hypotheses account for the evolution of the inner antenna light-harvesting proteins of oxygenic photosynthesis in cyanobacteria, algae, and plants: one in which the CP43 protein of photosytem II gave rise to the extrinsic CP43-like antennas of cyanobacteria (i.e. IsiA and Pcb proteins), as a late development, and the other in which CP43 and CP43-like proteins derive from an ancestral protein. In order to determine which of these hypotheses is most likely, we analyzed the family of antenna proteins by a variety of phylogenetic techniques, using alignments of the six common membrane-spanning helices, constructed using information on the antenna proteins' three-dimensional structure, and surveyed for evidence of factors that might confound inference of a correct phylogeny. The first hypothesis was strongly supported. As a consequence, we conclude that the ancestral photosynthetic apparatus, with 11 membrane-spanning helices, split at an early stage during evolution to form, on the one hand, the reaction center of photosystem II and, on the other hand, the ancestor of inner antenna proteins, CP43 (PsbC) and CP47 (PsbB). Only much later in evolution did the CP43 lineage give rise to the CP43' proteins (IsiA and Pcb) of cyanobacteria.

Photosystem II: an enzyme of global significance

Photosystem II (PSII) is a multisubunit enzyme embedded in the lipid environment of the thylakoid membranes of plants, algae and cyanobacteria. Powered by light, this enzyme catalyses the chemically and thermodynamically demanding reaction of water splitting. In so doing, it releases dioxygen into the atmosphere and provides the reducing equivalents required for the conversion of CO2 into the organic molecules of life. Recently, a fully refined structure of a 700 kDa cyanobacterial dimeric PSII complex was elucidated by X-ray crystallography which gave organizational and structural details of the 19 subunits (16 intrinsic and three extrinsic) which make up each monomer and provided information about the position and protein environments of 57 different cofactors. The water-splitting site was revealed as a cluster of four Mn ions and a Ca2+ ion surrounded by amino acid side chains, of which six or seven form direct ligands to the metals. The metal cluster was modelled as a cubane-like structure composed of three Mn ions and the Ca2+ linked by oxo-bonds with the fourth Mn attached to the cubane via one of its oxygens. The overall structure of the catalytic site is providing a framework to develop a mechanistic scheme for the water-splitting process, knowledge which could have significant implications for mimicking the reaction in an artificial chemical system.

Lipids in photosystem II: interactions with protein and cofactors

Photosystem II (PSII) is a homodimeric protein-cofactor complex embedded in the thylakoid membrane that catalyses light-driven charge separation accompanied by the oxidation of water during oxygenic photosynthesis. Biochemical analysis of the lipid content of PSII indicates a number of integral lipids, their composition being similar to the average lipid composition of the thylakoid membrane. The crystal structure of PSII at 3.0 A resolution allowed for the first time the assignment of 14 integral lipids within the protein scaffold, all of them being located at the interface of different protein subunits. The reaction centre subunits D1 and D2 are encircled by a belt of 11 lipids providing a flexible environment for the exchange of D1. Three lipids are located in the dimerization interface and mediate interactions between the PSII monomers. Several lipids are located close to the binding pocket of the mobile plastoquinone Q(B), forming part of a postulated diffusion pathway for plastoquinone. Furthermore two lipids were found, each ligating one antenna chlorophyll a. A detailed analysis of lipid-protein and lipid-cofactor interactions allows to derive some general principles of lipid binding pockets in PSII and to suggest possible functional properties of the various identified lipid molecules.

Lipids in photosynthetic reaction centres: structural roles and functional holes

Photosynthetic proteins power the biosphere. Reaction centres, light harvesting antenna proteins and cytochrome b(6)f (or bc(1)) complexes are expressed at high levels, have been subjected to an intensive spectroscopic, biochemical and mutagenic analysis, and several have been characterised to an informatively high resolution by X-ray crystallography. In addition to revealing the structural basis for the transduction of light energy, X-ray crystallography has brought molecular insights into the relationships between these multicomponent membrane proteins and their lipid environment. Lipids resolved in the X-ray crystal structures of photosynthetic proteins bind light harvesting cofactors, fill intra-protein cavities through which quinones can diffuse, form an important part of the monomer-monomer interface in multimeric structures and may facilitate structural flexibility in complexes that undergo partial disassembly and repair. It has been proposed that individual lipids influence the biophysical properties of reaction centre cofactors, and so affect the rate of electron transfer through the complex. Lipids have also been shown to be important for successful crystallisation of photosynthetic proteins. Comparison of the three types of reaction centre that have been structurally characterised reveals interesting similarities in the position of bound lipids that may point towards a generic requirement to reinforce the structure of the core electron transfer domain. The crystallographic data are also providing new opportunities to find molecular explanations for observed effects of different types of lipid on the structure, mechanism and organisation of reaction centres and other photosynthetic proteins.

Conservation of distantly related membrane proteins: photosynthetic reaction centers share a common structural core

Photosynthesis was established on Earth more than 3 billion years ago. All available evidences suggest that the earliest photosynthetic organisms were anoxygenic and that oxygen-evolving photosynthesis is a more recent development. The reaction center complexes that form the heart of the energy storage process are integral membrane pigment proteins that span the membrane in vectorial fashion to carry out electron transfer. The origin and extent of distribution of these proteins has been perplexing from a phylogenetic point of view mostly because of extreme sequence divergence. A series of integral membrane proteins of known structure and varying degrees of sequence identity have been compared using combinatorial extension-Monte Carlo methods. The proteins include photosynthetic reaction centers from proteobacteria and cyanobacterial photosystems I and II, as well as cytochrome oxidase, bacteriorhodopsin, and cytochrome b. The reaction center complexes show a remarkable conservation of the core structure of 5 transmembrane helices, strongly implying common ancestry, even though the residual sequence identity is less than 10%, whereas the other proteins have structures that are unrelated. A relationship of sequence with structure was derived from the reaction center structures; with characteristic decay length of 1.6 A. Phylogenetic trees derived from the structural alignments give insights into the earliest photosynthetic reaction center, strongly suggesting that it was a homodimeric complex that did not evolve oxygen.

CP43-like chlorophyll binding proteins: structural and evolutionary implications

CP43, encoded by the psbC gene, is a chlorophyll (Chl)-binding protein of Photosystem II (PSII), the water-splitting and oxygen-evolving enzyme of photosynthesis. CP47, encoded by psbB, a Chl-binding protein of PSII, is closely related to CP43. The Chl-binding six transmembrane helical unit typified by CP43, is also structurally related to the N-terminal domains of the PsaA and PsaB proteins of Photosystem I (PSI) as well as to the family of light-harvesting proteins encoded by cyanobacterial isiA genes and prochlorophyte pcb genes. Here we use recent structural information derived for PSII and PSI to review similarities and differences between the various members of the CP43-like class of light-harvesting proteins, exploring both functional and evolutionary implications.

A protein dynamics study of photosystem II: the effects of protein conformation on reaction center function

Molecular dynamics simulations have been performed to study photosystem II structure and function. Structural information obtained from simulations was combined with ab initio computations of chromophore excited states. In contrast to calculations based on the x-ray structure, the molecular-dynamics-based calculations accurately predicted the experimental absorbance spectrum. In addition, our calculations correctly assigned the energy levels of reaction-center (RC) chromophores, as well as the lowest-energy antenna chlorophyll. The primary and secondary quinone electron acceptors, Q(A) and Q(B), exhibited independent changes in position over the duration of the simulation. Q(B) fluctuated between two binding sites similar to the proximal and distal sites previously observed in light- and dark-adapted RC from purple bacteria. Kinetic models were used to characterize the relative influence of chromophore geometry, site energies, and electron transport rates on RC efficiency. The fluctuating energy levels of antenna chromophores had a larger impact on quantum yield than did their relative positions. Variations in electron transport rates had the most significant effect and were sufficient to explain the experimentally observed multi-component decay of excitation in photosystem II. The implications of our results are discussed in the context of competing evolutionary selection pressures for RC structure and function.

Structure and function of photosystems I and II

Oxygenic photosynthesis, the principal converter of sunlight into chemical energy on earth, is catalyzed by four multi-subunit membrane-protein complexes: photosystem I (PSI), photosystem II (PSII), the cytochrome b(6)f complex, and F-ATPase. PSI generates the most negative redox potential in nature and largely determines the global amount of enthalpy in living systems. PSII generates an oxidant whose redox potential is high enough to enable it to oxidize H(2)O, a substrate so abundant that it assures a practically unlimited electron source for life on earth. During the last century, the sophisticated techniques of spectroscopy, molecular genetics, and biochemistry were used to reveal the structure and function of the two photosystems. The new structures of PSI and PSII from cyanobacteria, algae, and plants has shed light not only on the architecture and mechanism of action of these intricate membrane complexes, but also on the evolutionary forces that shaped oxygenic photosynthesis.

Light Harvesting in Photosystem I Supercomplexes,

In photosynthetic membranes of cyanobacteria, algae, and higher plants, photosystem I (PSI) mediates light-driven transmembrane electron transfer from plastocyanin or cytochrome c6 to the ferredoxin-NADP complex. The oxidoreductase function of PSI is sensitized by a reversible photooxidation of primary electron donor P700, which launches a multistep electron transfer via a series of redox cofactors of the reaction center (RC). The excitation energy for the functioning of the primary electron donor in the RC is delivered via the chlorophyll core antenna in the complex with peripheral light-harvesting antennas. Supermolecular complexes of the PSI acquire remarkably different structural forms of the peripheral light-harvesting antenna complexes, including distinct pigment types and organizational principles. The PSI core antenna, being the main functional unit of the supercomplexes, provides an increased functional connectivity in the chlorophyll antenna network due to dense pigment packing resulting in a fast spread of the excitation among the neighbors. Functional connectivity within the network as well as the spectral overlap of antenna pigments allows equilibration of the excitation energy in the depth of the whole membrane within picoseconds and loss-free delivery of the excitation to primary donor P700 within 20-40 ps. Low-light-adapted cyanobacteria under iron-deficiency conditions extend this capacity via assembly of efficiently energy coupled rings of CP43-like complexes around the PSI trimers. In green algae and higher plants, less efficient energy coupling in the eukaryotic PSI-LHCI supercomplexes is probably a result of the structural adaptation of the Chl a/b binding LHCI peripheral antenna that not only extends the absorption cross section of the PSI core but participates in regulation of excitation flows between the two photosystems as well as in photoprotection.

The structure of photosystem I and evolution of photosynthesis

Oxygenic photosynthesis is the principal producer of both oxygen and organic matter on earth. The primary step in this process--the conversion of sunlight into chemical energy--is driven by four multi-subunit membrane protein complexes named photosystem I, photosystem II, cytochrome b(6)f complex and F-ATPase. Photosystem I generates the most negative redox potential in nature and thus largely determines the global amount of enthalpy in living systems. The recent structural determination of PSI complexes from cyanobacteria and plants sheds light on the evolutionary forces that shaped oxygenic photosynthesis. The fortuitous formation of our solar system in a space plentiful of elements, our distance from the sun and the long time of uninterrupted evolution enabled the perfection of photosynthesis and the evolution of advanced organisms. The available structural information complements the knowledge gained from genomic and proteomic data to illustrate a more precise scenario for the evolution of life systems on earth.

The antenna system of photosystem II from Thermosynechococcus elongatus at 3.2 A resolution

The content and type of cofactors harboured in the Photosystem II core complex (PS IIcc) of the cyanobacterium Thermosynechococcus elongatus has been determined by biochemical and spectroscopic methods. 17 +/- 1 chlorophyll a per pheophytin a and 0.25 beta-carotene per chlorophyll a have been found in re-dissolved crystals of dimeric PS IIcc. The X-ray crystal structure of PS IIcc from Thermosynechococcus elongatus at 3.2 A resolution clearly shows chlorophyll a molecules arranged in two layers close to the cytoplasmic and lumenal sides of the thylakoid membrane. Each of the cytoplasmic layers contains 9 chlorophyll a, whose positions and orientations are related by a local twofold rotation pseudo-C2 axis passing through the non-haem Fe2+. These chlorophyll a are arranged comparably to those in the antenna domains of PsaA and PsaB of cyanobacterial Photosystem I affirming an evolutionary relation. The chlorophyll a in the lumenal layer are less well conserved between Photosystems I and II and even between CP43 and CP47 with 4 chlorophyll a in the former and 7 in the latter.

Lipids in and around photosynthetic reaction centres

Reaction centres are membrane-embedded pigment–protein complexes that transduce the energy of sunlight into a biologically useful form. The most heavily studied reaction centres are the PS-I (Photosystem I) and PS-II complexes from oxygenic phototrophs, and the reaction centre from purple photosynthetic bacteria. A great deal is known about the compositions and structures of these reaction centres, and the mechanism of light-activated transmembrane electron transfer, but less is known about how they interact with other components of the photosynthetic membrane, including the membrane lipids. X-ray crystallography has provided high-resolution structures for PS-I and the purple bacterial reaction centre, and revealed binding sites for a number of lipids, either embedded in the protein interior or attached to the protein surface. These lipids play a variety of roles, including the binding of cofactors and the provision of structural support. The challenges of modelling surface-associated electron density features such as lipids, detergents, small amphiphiles and ions are discussed.

Protein Interactions Limit the Rate of Evolution of Photosynthetic Genes in Cyanobacteria

Using a bioinformatic approach, we analyzed the correspondence in genetic distance matrices between all possible pairwise combinations of 82 photosynthetic genes in 10 species of cyanobacteria. Our analysis reveals significant correlations between proteins linked in a conserved gene order and between structurally identified interacting protein scaffolds that coordinate the binding of cofactors involved in photosynthetic electron transport. Analyses of amino acid substitution rates suggest that the tempo of evolution of genes encoding core metabolic processes in the photosynthetic apparatus is highly constrained by protein-protein, protein-lipid, and protein-cofactor interactions (collectively called "protein interactions"). These interactions are critical for energy transduction, primary charge separation, and electron transport and effectively act as an internal selection pressure governing the conservation of clusters of photosynthetic genes in oxygenic prokaryotic photoautotrophs. Consequently, although several proteins within the photosynthetic apparatus are biophysically and physiologically inefficient, selection has not significantly altered the genes encoding these essential proteins over billions of years of evolution. In effect, these core proteins have become "frozen metabolic accidents."

Phylogenetic analyses of the core antenna domain: investigating the origin of photosystem I

Phototrophy, the conversion of light to biochemical energy, occurs throughout the Bacteria and plants, however, debate continues over how different phototrophic mechanisms and the bacteria that contain them are related. There are two types of phototrophic mechanisms in the Bacteria: reaction center type 1 (RC1) has core and core antenna domains that are parts of a single polypeptide, whereas reaction center type 2 (RC2) is composed of short core proteins without antenna domains. In cyanobacteria, RC2 is associated with separate core antenna proteins that are homologous to the core antenna domains of RC1. We reconstructed evolutionary relationships among phototrophic mechanisms based on a phylogeny of core antenna domains/proteins. Core antenna domains of 46 polypeptides were aligned, including the RC1 core proteins of heliobacteria, green sulfur bacteria, and photosystem I (PSI) of cyanobacteria and plastids, plus core antenna proteins of photosystem II (PSII) from cyanobacteria and plastids. Maximum likelihood, parsimony, and neighbor joining methods all supported a single phylogeny in which PSII core antenna proteins (PsbC, PsbB) arose within the cyanobacteria from duplications of the RC1-associated core antenna domains and accessory antenna proteins (IsiA, PcbA, PcbC) arose from duplications of PsbB. The data indicate an evolutionary history of RC1 in which an initially homodimeric reaction center was vertically transmitted to green sulfur bacteria, heliobacteria, and an ancestor of cyanobacteria. A heterodimeric RC1 (=PSI) then arose within the cyanobacterial lineage. In this scenario, the current diversity of core antenna domains/proteins is explained without a need to invoke horizontal transfer.

Energy problems in life evolution

Evolutionary aspects of bioenergetics are considered. These include the origin of the first organisms, UV-protection and the beginnings of anoxygenic photosynthesis, the electron donor problem of life and the appearance of oxygenic photosynthesis, oxygen danger and strategies of defense, and the role of oxygen in programmed cell death.

A redox switch hypothesis for the origin of two light reactions in photosynthesis

Photosynthesis provides energy in the Earth's biosphere and oxygen in its atmosphere. For oxygen to be produced, two different light reactions must operate simultaneously and in series. Known anaerobic, photosynthetic bacteria contain one or other of these photosystems, but never both. Here, I propose that the two photosystems diverged, in structure and function, from a common ancestor, within a single, continuous, anaerobic lineage. In such cells, living examples of which are predicted, the two photosystems are isoenzymes encoded by orthologous genes under co-ordinated, redox regulatory control. A redox switch responds to defined environmental conditions and selects which set of genes is expressed. In these cells, the two photosystems are thus synthesised at different times. It is further proposed that the origin of oxygen-evolving photosynthesis was a simple mutation that disabled the redox switch, permitting simultaneous expression of the two sets of genes. The two, newly co-existing photosystems became connected by shared electron carriers, allowing generation of electrochemical potential high enough to oxidise water; an inexhaustible supply of reductant; and the selective advantages and pressures of an aerobic world.

The complex architecture of oxygenic photosynthesis

Oxygenic photosynthesis is the principal producer of both oxygen and organic matter on earth. The primary step in this process - the conversion of sunlight into chemical energy - is driven by four, multisubunit, membrane-protein complexes that are known as photosystem I, photosystem II, cytochrome b(6)f and F-ATPase. Structural insights into these complexes are now providing a framework for the exploration not only of energy and electron transfer, but also of the evolutionary forces that shaped the photosynthetic apparatus.

Structure of cyanobacterial photosystem I

Photosystem I is one of the most fascinating membrane protein complexes for which a structure has been determined. It functions as a bio-solar energy converter, catalyzing one of the first steps of oxygenic photosynthesis. It captures the light of the sun by means of a large antenna system, consisting of chlorophylls and carotenoids, and transfers the energy to the center of the complex, driving the transmembrane electron transfer from plastoquinone to ferredoxin. Cyanobacterial Photosystem I is a trimer consisting of 36 proteins to which 381 cofactors are non-covalently attached. This review discusses the complex function of Photosystem I based on the structure of the complex at 2.5 A resolution as well as spectroscopic and biochemical data.

The evolutionary development of the protein complement of photosystem 2

During the transition from anoxygenic to oxygenic photosynthesis, the Type 2 reaction center underwent many changes, none so dramatic as the remarkable increase in complexity at the protein level, from only three or four subunits in the anoxygenic reaction center to possibly more than 25 in Photosystem 2 (PS2). The evolutionary source of most of these proteins is enigmatic, as they have no apparent homology to any other proteins in existing databases. However, some of the proteins in PS2 have apparent homologies to each other, suggesting ancient gene duplications have played an important role in the development of the complex. These homologies include the well-known examples of the D1 and D2 reaction center core proteins and the CP43 and CP47 core antenna proteins. In addition, PsbE and PsbF, the two subunits comprising cytochrome b-559, show homology to each other, suggesting that a homodimeric cytochrome preceded the heterodimeric one. Other potential homologies that appear to be statistically significant include PsbV with the N-terminal part of D1 and PsbT with PsbI. Most of the proteins that make up the photosynthetic apparatus bear no relation to any other proteins from any source. This suggests that a period of remarkable evolutionary innovation took place when the ability to make oxygen was invented. This was probably a response to the production of highly toxic oxygen and these new proteins served to protect and repair the photosynthetic apparatus from the harmful effects of oxygen.

Lateral gene transfer and the origins of prokaryotic groups

Lateral gene transfer (LGT) is now known to be a major force in the evolution of prokaryotic genomes. To date, most analyses have focused on either (a) verifying phylogenies of individual genes thought to have been transferred, or (b) estimating the fraction of individual genomes likely to have been introduced by transfer. Neither approach does justice to the ability of LGT to effect massive and complex transformations in basic biology. In some cases, such transformation will be manifested as the patchy distribution of a seemingly fundamental property (such as aerobiosis or nitrogen fixation) among the members of a group classically defined by the sharing of other properties (metabolic, morphological, or molecular, such as small subunit ribosomal RNA sequence). In other cases, the lineage of recipients so transformed may be seen to comprise a new group of high taxonomic rank ("class" or even "phylum"). Here we review evidence for an important role of LGT in the evolution of photosynthesis, aerobic respiration, nitrogen fixation, sulfate reduction, methylotrophy, isoprenoid biosynthesis, quorum sensing, flotation (gas vesicles), thermophily, and halophily. Sometimes transfer of complex gene clusters may have been involved, whereas other times separate exchanges of many genes must be invoked.

Architecture of the photosynthetic oxygen-evolving center

Photosynthesis uses light energy to drive the oxidation of water at an oxygen-evolving catalytic site within photosystem II (PSII). We report the structure of PSII of the cyanobacterium Thermosynechococcus elongatus at 3.5 angstrom resolution. We have assigned most of the amino acid residues of this 650-kilodalton dimeric multisubunit complex and refined the structure to reveal its molecular architecture. Consequently, we are able to describe details of the binding sites for cofactors and propose a structure of the oxygen-evolving center (OEC). The data strongly suggest that the OEC contains a cubane-like Mn3CaO4 cluster linked to a fourth Mn by a mono-micro-oxo bridge. The details of the surrounding coordination sphere of the metal cluster and the implications for a possible oxygen-evolving mechanism are discussed.

Acquisition of photosynthetic capacity by a reaction centre that lacks the QA ubiquinone; possible insights into the evolution of reaction centres?

A photosynthetically impaired strain of Rhodobacter sphaeroides containing reaction centres with an alanine to tryptophan mutation at residue 260 of the M-polypeptide (AM260W) was incubated under photosynthetic growth conditions. This incubation produced photosynthetically competent strains containing suppressor mutations that changed residue M260 to glycine or cysteine. Spectroscopic analysis demonstrated that the loss of the Q(A) ubiquinone seen in the original AM260W mutant was reversed in the suppressor mutants. In the mutant where Trp M260 was replaced by Cys, the rate of reduction of the Q(A) ubiquinone by the adjacent (H(A)) bacteriopheophytin was reduced by three-fold. The findings of the experiment are discussed in light of the X-ray crystal structures of the wild-type and AM260W reaction centres, and the possible implications for the evolution of reaction centres as bioenergetic complexes are considered.

Electron transfer in cyanobacterial photosystem I: I. Physiological and spectroscopic characterization of site-directed mutants in a putative electron transfer pathway from A0 through A1 to FX

The Photosystem I (PS I) reaction center contains two branches of nearly symmetric cofactors bound to the PsaA and PsaB heterodimer. From the x-ray crystal structure it is known that Trp697PsaA and Trp677PsaB are pi-stacked with the head group of the phylloquinones and are H-bonded to Ser692PsaA and Ser672PsaB, whereas Arg694PsaA and Arg674PsaB are involved in a H-bonded network of side groups that connects the binding environments of the phylloquinones and FX. The mutants W697FPsaA, W677FPsaB, S692CPsaA, S672CPsaB, R694APsaA, and R674APsaB were constructed and characterized. All mutants grew photoautotrophically, yet all showed diminished growth rates compared with the wild-type, especially at higher light intensities. EPR and electron nuclear double resonance (ENDOR) studies at both room temperature and in frozen solution showed that the PsaB mutants were virtually identical to the wild-type, whereas significant effects were observed in the PsaA mutants. Spin polarized transient EPR spectra of the P700+A1- radical pair show that none of the mutations causes a significant change in the orientation of the measured phylloquinone. Pulsed ENDOR spectra reveal that the W697FPsaA mutation leads to about a 5% increase in the hyperfine coupling of the methyl group on the phylloquinone ring, whereas the S692CPsaA mutation causes a similar decrease in this coupling. The changes in the methyl hyperfine coupling are also reflected in the transient EPR spectra of P700+A1- and the CW EPR spectra of photoaccumulated A1-. We conclude that: (i) the transient EPR spectra at room temperature are predominantly from radical pairs in the PsaA branch of cofactors; (ii) at low temperature the electron cycle involving P700 and A1 similarly occurs along the PsaA branch of cofactors; and (iii) mutation of amino acids in close contact with the PsaA side quinone leads to changes in the spin density distribution of the reduced quinone observed by EPR.

Origin and evolution of transmembrane Chl-binding proteins: hydrophobic cluster analysis suggests a common one-helix ancestor for prokaryotic (Pcb) and eukaryotic (LHC) antenna protein superfamilies

All chlorophyll (Chl)-binding proteins constituting the photosynthetic apparatus of both prokaryotes and eukaryotes possess hydrophobic domains, corresponding to membrane-spanning alpha-helices (MSHs). Hydrophobic cluster analysis of representative members of the different Chl protein superfamilies revealed that all Chl proteins except the five-helix reaction center II proteins and the small subunits of photosystem I possess related domains. As a major conclusion, we found that the eukaryotic antennae likely share a common precursor with the prokaryotic Chl a/b antennae from Chl-b-containing oxyphotobacteria. From these data, we propose a global scheme for the evolution of these proteins from a one-MSH ancestor.

Functional role of C(alpha)-H...O hydrogen bonds between transmembrane alpha-helices in photosystem I

The crystal structure at 2.5A resolution of the membrane-intrinsic, homotrimeric photosystem I (PSI) isolated from the thermophilic cyanobacterium Synechococcus elongatus shows that each monomer is composed of 12 protein subunits of which nine are embedded in the membrane and feature a total of 34 transmembrane alpha-helices (TMH). Hence, PSI provides an ideal case to study "conventional" and C(alpha)-H...O hydrogen bonds between TMH engaged in intra- and intersubunit interactions. Of the total of 75 C(alpha)-H...O hydrogen bonds between TMHs, 72 are intrasubunit and only three are intersubunit. The two largest subunits PsaA and PsaB are each folded into 11 TMHs showing 29 and 24 intrasubunit C(alpha)-H...O hydrogen bonds, respectively, that are not distributed randomly but many of them flank chlorophyll a (Chl a) co-ordinating amino acids, suggesting stabilisation of these structural segments. As major constituent of the trimerisation domain, subunit PsaL is located next to the 3-fold axis relating the three monomers of PSI. PsaL features a unique number of 19 intrasubunit C(alpha)-H...O hydrogen bonds that connect two of its three TMHs but there are no intersubunit C(alpha)-H...O hydrogen bonds between the three PsaL. Of the three intersubunit C(alpha)-H...O hydrogen bonds, two are formed between PsaA and PsaB and one between PsaB and PsaM. The large number of 75 C(alpha)-H...O hydrogen bonds contrasts the 49 conventional hydrogen bonds, indicating that the former and van der Waals contacts determine association and orientation of TMHs in PSI.

Type I photosynthetic reaction centres: structure and function

We review recent advances in the study of the photosystem I reaction centre, following the determination of a spectacular 2.5 A resolution crystal structure for this complex of Synechococcus elongatus. Photosystem I is proving different to type II reaction centres in structure and organization, and the mechanism of transmembrane electron transfer, and is providing insights into the control of function in reaction centres that operate at very low redox potentials. The photosystem I complex of oxygenic organisms has a counterpart in non-oxygenic bacteria, the strictly anaerobic phototrophic green sulphur bacteria and heliobacteria. The most distinctive feature of these type I reaction centres is that they contain two copies of a large core polypeptide (i.e. a homodimer), rather than a heterodimeric arrangement of two related, but different, polypeptides as in the photosystem I complex. To compare the structural organization of the two forms of type I reaction centre, we have modelled the structure of the central region of the reaction centre from green sulphur bacteria, using sequence alignments and the structural coordinates of the S. elongatus Photosystem I complex. The outcome of these modelling studies is described, concentrating on regions of the type I reaction centre where important structure-function relationships have been demonstrated or inferred.

Photosystem II: evolutionary perspectives

Based on the current model of its structure and function, photosystem II (PSII) seems to have evolved from an ancestor that was homodimeric in terms of its protein core and contained a special pair of chlorophylls as the photo-oxidizable cofactor. It is proposed that the key event in the evolution of PSII was a mutation that resulted in the separation of the two pigments that made up the special chlorophyll pair, making them into two chlorophylls that were neither special nor paired. These ordinary chlorophylls, along with the two adjacent monomeric chlorophylls, were very oxidizing: a property proposed to be intrinsic to monomeric chlorophylls in the environment provided by reaction centre (RC) proteins. It seems likely that other (mainly electrostatic) changes in the environments of the pigments probably tuned their redox potentials further but these changes would have been minor compared with the redox jump imposed by splitting of the special pair. This sudden increase in redox potential allowed the development of oxygen evolution. The highly oxidizing homodimeric RC would probably have been not only inefficient in terms of photochemistry and charge storage but also wasteful in terms of protein or pigments undergoing damage due to the oxidative chemistry. These problems would have constituted selective pressures in favour of the lop-sided, heterodimeric system that exists as PSII today, in which the highly oxidized species are limited to only one side of the heterodimer: the sacrificial, rapidly turned-over D1 protein. It is also suggested that one reason for maintaining an oxidizable tyrosine, TyrD, on the D2 side of the RC, is that the proton associated with its tyrosyl radical, has an electrostatic role in confining P(+) to the expendable D1 side.

Photosystem II and photosynthetic oxidation of water: an overview

Conceptually, photosystem II, the oxygen-evolving enzyme, can be divided into two parts: the photochemical part and the catalytic part. The photochemical part contains the ultra-fast and ultra-efficient light-induced charge separation and stabilization steps that occur when light is absorbed by chlorophyll. The catalytic part, where water is oxidized, involves a cluster of Mn ions close to a redox-active tyrosine residue. Our current understanding of the catalytic mechanism is mainly based on spectroscopic studies. Here, we present an overview of the current state of knowledge of photosystem II, attempting to delineate the open questions and the directions of current research.

Functional implications on the mechanism of the function of photosystem II including water oxidation based on the structure of photosystem II

The structure of photosystem I at 3.8 A resolution illustrated the main structural elements of the water-oxidizing photosystem II complex, including the constituents of the electron transport chain. The location of the Mn cluster within the complex has been identified for the first time to our knowledge. At this resolution, no individual atoms are visible, however, the electron density of the Mn cluster can be used to discuss both the present models of the Mn cluster as revealed from various spectroscopic methods and the implications for the mechanisms of water oxidation. Twenty-six chlorophylls from the antenna system of photosystem II have been identified. They are arranged in two layers, one close to the stromal side and one close to the lumenal side. Comparing the structure of the antenna system of photosystem II with the chlorophyll arrangement in photosystem I, which was recently determined at 2.5 A resolution shows that photosystem II lacks the central domain of the photosystem I antenna, which is discussed in respect of the repair cycle of photosystem II due to photoinhibition.

Insights into the evolution of the antenna domains of Type-I and Type-II photosynthetic reaction centres through homology modelling

The (bacterio)chlorophylls of photosynthetic antenna and reaction centre complexes are bound to the protein via a fifth, axial ligand to the central magnesium atom. A number of the amino acids identified as providing such ligands are conserved between the large antenna of the cyanobacterial Type-I reaction centre and smaller antennas of the Type-I reaction centres of green sulphur bacteria and heliobacteria, and these numbers match closely the estimated number of antenna bacteriochlorophylls in the latter. The possible organisation of the antenna in the latter reaction centres is discussed, as is the mechanism by which the more pigment-rich antenna of the cyanobacterial reaction centre evolved. The homology modelling approach is also extended to the six-helix antenna proteins CP47 and CP43 associated with the Photosystem II reaction centre.

A cytochrome b origin of photosynthetic reaction centers: an evolutionary link between respiration and photosynthesis

The evolutionary origin of photosynthetic reaction centers has long remained elusive. Here, we use sequence and structural analysis to demonstrate an evolutionary link between the cytochrome b subunit of the cytochrome bc(1) complex and the core polypeptides of the photosynthetic bacterial reaction center. In particular, we have identified an area of significant sequence similarity between a three contiguous membrane-spanning domain of cytochrome b, which contains binding sites for two hemes, and a three contiguous membrane-spanning domain in the photosynthetic reaction center core subunits, which contains binding sites for cofactors such as (bacterio)chlorophylls, (bacterio)pheophytin and a non-heme iron. Three of the four heme ligands in cytochrome b are found to be conserved with the cofactor ligands in the reaction center polypeptides. Since cytochrome b and reaction center polypeptides both bind tetrapyrroles and quinones for electron transfer, the observed sequence, functional and structural similarities can best be explained with the assumption of a common evolutionary origin. Statistical analysis further supports a distant but significant homologous relationship. On the basis of previous evolutionary analyses that established a scenario that respiration evolved prior to photosynthesis, we consider it likely that cytochrome b is the evolutionary precursor for type II reaction center apoproteins. With a structural analysis confirming a common evolutionary origin of both type I and type II reaction centers, we further propose a novel "reaction center apoprotein early" hypothesis to account for the development of photosynthetic reaction center holoproteins.

Photosystem II: a multisubunit membrane protein that oxidises water

A structure of photosystem II recently determined by X-ray crystallography at 3.8 A resolution complements structural studies using high-resolution electron microscopy and represents a major step towards understanding how photosynthetic organisms use light energy to oxidise water.

Light- and redox-dependent thermal stability of the reaction center of the photosynthetic Bacterium rhodobacter sphaeroides

Irreversible loss of the photochemical activity and damage of the pigments (bacteriochlorophyll [Bchl] monomer, Bchl dimer [P] and bacteriopheophytin) by combined treatment with intense and continuous visible light and elevated temperature have been studied in a deoxygenated solution of reaction center (RC) protein from the nonsulfur purple photosynthetic bacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Both the fraction of RC in the charge-separated redox state (P+Q-, where Q is a quinone electron acceptor) and the degradation of the pigments showed saturation as a function of increasing light intensity up to 400 mW cm(-2) (488/515 nm) or 1100 microE m(-2) s(-1) (white light). The thermal denaturation curves of the RC in the P+Q- redox state demonstrated broadening and 10-20 degrees C shift to lower temperature (after 30-90 min heat treatment) compared with those in the PQ redox state. Similar but less striking behavior was seen for RC of other redox states (P+Q and PQ-) generated either by light or by electrochemical treatment in the dark. These experiments suggest that it is not the intense light per se but the changes in the redox state of the protein that are responsible for the increased sensitivity to photo- and heat damage. The RC with a charge pair (P+Q-) is more vulnerable to elevated temperature than the RC with (P+Q or PQ-) or without (PQ) a single charge. To reveal both the thermodynamic and kinetic aspects of the denaturation, a simple three-state model of coupled reversible thermal and irreversible kinetic transitions is presented. These effects may have relevance to the heat stability of other redox proteins in bioenergetics.

Reaction centres: the structure and evolution of biological solar power

Reaction centres are complexes of pigment and protein that convert the electromagnetic energy of sunlight into chemical potential energy. They are found in plants, algae and a variety of bacterial species, and vary greatly in their composition and complexity. New structural information has highlighted features that are common to the different types of reaction centre and has provided insights into some of the key differences between reaction centres from different sources. New ideas have also emerged on how contemporary reaction centres might have evolved and on the possible origin of the first chlorophyll-protein complexes to harness the power of sunlight.

Insertional inactivation of the menG gene, encoding 2-phytyl-1,4-naphthoquinone methyltransferase of Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803, results in the incorporation of 2-phytyl-1,4-naphthoquinone into the A(1) site and alteration of the equilibrium constant between A(1) and F(X) in photosystem I

A gene encoding a methyltransferase (menG) was identified in Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803 as responsible for transferring the methyl group to 2-phytyl-1,4-naphthoquinone in the biosynthetic pathway of phylloquinone, the secondary electron acceptor in photosystem I (PS I). Mass spectrometric measurements showed that targeted inactivation of the menG gene prevented the methylation step in the synthesis of phylloquinone and led to the accumulation of 2-phytyl-1,4-naphthoquinone in PS I. Growth rates of the wild-type and the menG mutant strains under photoautotrophic and photomixotrophic conditions were virtually identical. The chlorophyll a content of the menG mutant strain was similar to that of wild type when the cells were grown at a light intensity of 50 microE m(-2) s(-1) but was slightly lower when grown at 300 microE m(-2) s(-1). Chlorophyll fluorescence emission measurements at 77 K showed a larger increase in the ratio of PS II to PS I in the menG mutant strain relative to the wild type as the light intensity was elevated from 50 to 300 microE m(-2) s(-1). CW EPR studies at 34 GHz and transient EPR studies at multiple frequencies showed that the quinone radical in the menG mutant has a similar overall line width as that for the wild type, but consistent with the presence of an aromatic proton at ring position 2, the pattern of hyperfine splittings showed two lines in the low-field region. The spin polarization pattern indicated that 2-phytyl-1,4-naphthoquinone is in the same orientation as phylloquinone, and out-of-phase, spin-echo modulation spectroscopy shows the same P700(+) to Q(-) center-to-center distance as in wild-type PS I. Transient EPR studies indicated that the lifetime for forward electron transfer from Q(-) to F(X) is slowed from 290 ns in the wild type to 600 ns in the menG mutant. The redox potential of 2-phytyl-1,4-naphthoquinone is estimated to be 50 to 60 mV more oxidizing than phylloquinone in the A(1) site, which translates to a lowering of the equilibrium constant between Q(-)/Q and F(X)(-)/F(X) by a factor of ca. 10. The lifetime of the P700(+) [F(A)/F(B)](-) backreaction decreased from 80 ms in the wild type to 20 ms in the menG mutant strain and is evidence for a thermally activated, uphill electron transfer through the quinone rather than a direct charge recombination between [F(A)/F(B)](-) and P700(+).

Complex evolution of photosynthesis

The origin of photosynthesis is a fundamental biological question that has eluded researchers for decades. The complexity of the origin and evolution of photosynthesis is a result of multiple photosynthetic components having independent evolutionary pathways. Indeed, evolutionary scenarios have been established for only a few photosynthetic components. Phylogenetic analysis of Mg-tetrapyrrole biosynthesis genes indicates that most anoxygenic photosynthetic organisms are ancestral to oxygen-evolving cyanobacteria and that the purple bacterial lineage may contain the most ancestral form of this pigment biosynthesis pathway. The evolutionary path of type I and type II reaction center apoproteins is still unresolved owing to the fact that a unified evolutionary tree cannot be generated for these divergent reaction center subunits. However, evidence for a cytochrome b origin for the type II reaction center apoproteins is emerging. Based on the combined information for both photopigments and reaction centers, a unified theory for the evolution of reaction center holoproteins is provided. Further insight into the evolution of photosynthesis will have to rely on additional broader sampling of photosynthesis genes from divergent photosynthetic bacteria.

Blue light drives B-side electron transfer in bacterial photosynthetic reaction centers

The core of the photosynthetic reaction center from the purple non-sulfur bacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides is a quasi-symmetric heterodimer, providing two potential pathways for transmembrane electron transfer. Past measurements have demonstrated that only one of the two pathways (the A-side) is used to any significant extent upon excitation with red or near-infrared light. Here, it is shown that excitation with blue light into the Soret band of the reaction center gives rise to electron transfer along the alternate or B-side pathway, resulting in a charge-separated state involving the anion of the B-side bacteriopheophytin. This electron transfer is much faster than normal A-side transfer, apparently occurring within a few hundred femtoseconds. At low temperatures, the B-side charge-separated state is stable for at least 1 ns, but at room temperature, the B-side bacteriopheophytin anion is short-lived, decaying within approximately 15 ps. One possible physiological role for B-side electron transfer is photoprotection, rapidly quenching higher excited states of the reaction center.

P700: the primary electron donor of photosystem I

The primary electron donor of photosystem I, P700, is a chlorophyll species that in its excited state has a potential of approximately -1.2 V. The precise chemical composition and electronic structure of P700 is still unknown. Recent evidence indicates that P700 is a dimer of one chlorophyll (Chl) a and one Chl a'. The Chl a' and Chl a are axially coordinated by His residues provided by protein subunits PsaA and PsaB, respectively. The Chl a', but not the Chl a, is also H-bonded to the protein. The H-bonding is likely responsible for selective insertion of Chl a' into the reaction center. EPR studies of P700(+*) in frozen solution and single crystals indicate a large asymmetry in the electron spin and charge distribution towards one Chl of the dimer. Molecular orbital calculations indicate that H-bonding will specifically stabilize the Chl a'-side of the dimer, suggesting that the unpaired electron would predominantly reside on the Chl a. This is supported by results of specific mutagenesis of the PsaA and PsaB axial His residues, which show that only mutations of the PsaB subunit significantly alter the hyperfine coupling constants associated with a single Chl molecule. The PsaB mutants also alter the microwave induced triplet-minus-singlet spectrum indicating that the triplet state is localized on the same Chl. Excitonic coupling between the two Chl a of P700 is weak due to the distance and overlap of the porphyrin planes. Evidence of excitonic coupling is found in PsaB mutants which show a new bleaching band at 665 nm that likely represents an increased intensity of the upper exciton band of P700. Additional properties of P700 that may give rise to its unusually low potential are discussed.

The reaction center of green sulfur bacteria(1)

The composition of the P840-reaction center complex (RC), energy and electron transfer within the RC, as well as its topographical organization and interaction with other components in the membrane of green sulfur bacteria are presented, and compared to the FeS-type reaction centers of Photosystem I and of Heliobacteria. The core of the RC is homodimeric, since pscA is the only gene found in the genome of Chlorobium tepidum which resembles the genes psaA and -B for the heterodimeric core of Photosystem I. Functionally intact RC can be isolated from several species of green sulfur bacteria. It is generally composed of five subunits, PscA-D plus the BChl a-protein FMO. Functional cores, with PscA and PscB only, can be isolated from Prostecochloris aestuarii. The PscA-dimer binds P840, a special pair of BChl a-molecules, the primary electron acceptor A(0), which is a Chl a-derivative and FeS-center F(X). An equivalent to the electron acceptor A(1) in Photosystem I, which is tightly bound phylloquinone acting between A(0) and F(X), is not required for forward electron transfer in the RC of green sulfur bacteria. This difference is reflected by different rates of electron transfer between A(0) and F(X) in the two systems. The subunit PscB contains the two FeS-centers F(A) and F(B). STEM particle analysis suggests that the core of the RC with PscA and PscB resembles the PsaAB/PsaC-core of the P700-reaction center in Photosystem I. PscB may form a protrusion into the cytoplasmic space where reduction of ferredoxin occurs, with FMO trimers bound on both sides of this protrusion. Thus the subunit composition of the RC in vivo should be 2(FMO)(3)(PscA)(2)PscB(PscC)(2)PscD. Only 16 BChl a-, four Chl a-molecules and two carotenoids are bound to the RC-core, which is substantially less than its counterpart of Photosystem I, with 85 Chl a-molecules and 22 carotenoids. A total of 58 BChl a/RC are present in the membranes of green sulfur bacteria outside the chlorosomes, corresponding to two trimers of FMO (42 Bchl a) per RC (16 BChl a). The question whether the homodimeric RC is totally symmetric is still open. Furthermore, it is still unclear which cytochrome c is the physiological electron donor to P840(+). Also the way of NAD(+)-reduction is unknown, since a gene equivalent to ferredoxin-NADP(+) reductase is not present in the genome.

Modification of photosystem I reaction center by the extraction and exchange of chlorophylls and quinones

The photosystem (PS) I photosynthetic reaction center was modified thorough the selective extraction and exchange of chlorophylls and quinones. Extraction of lyophilized photosystem I complex with diethyl ether depleted more than 90% chlorophyll (Chl) molecules bound to the complex, preserving the photochemical electron transfer activity from the primary electron donor P700 to the acceptor chlorophyll A(0). The treatment extracted all the carotenoids and the secondary acceptor phylloquinone (A(1)), and produced a PS I reaction center that contains nine molecules of Chls including P700 and A(0), and three Fe-S clusters (F(X), F(A) and F(B)). The ether-extracted PS I complex showed fast electron transfer from P700 to A(0) as it is, and to FeS clusters if phylloquinone or an appropriate artificial quinone was reconstituted as A(1). The ether-extracted PS I enabled accurate detection of the primary photoreactions with little disturbance from the absorbance changes of the bulk pigments. The quinone reconstitution created the new reactions between the artificial cofactors and the intrinsic components with altered energy gaps. We review the studies done in the ether-extracted PS I complex including chlorophyll forms of the core moiety of PS I, fluorescence of P700, reaction rate between A(0) and reconstituted A(1), and the fast electron transfer from P700 to A(0). Natural exchange of chlorophyll a to 710-740 nm absorbing chlorophyll d in PS I of the newly found cyanobacteria-like organism Acaryochloris marina was also reviewed. Based on the results of exchange studies in different systems, designs of photosynthetic reaction centers are discussed.