The appearance of new structures and functions in proteins during evolution

Evolution of catalytic proteins or on the origin of enzyme species by means of natural selection

It is believed that all present-day organisms descended from a common cellular ancestor. Such a cell must have evolved from more primitive and simpler precursors, but neither their organization nor the route such evolution took are accessible to the molecular techniques available today. We propose a mechanism, based on functional properties of enzymes and the kinetics of growth, which allows us to reconstruct the general course of early enzyme evolution. A precursor cell containing very few multifunctional enzymes with low catalytic activities is shown to lead inevitably to descendants with a large number of differentiated monofunctional enzymes with high turnover numbers. Mutation and natural selection for faster growth are shown to be the only conditions necessary for such a change to have occurred.

Origin of evolutionary novelty in proteins: how a high-cysteine chorion protein has evolved

The structure of unusual high-cysteine (Hc) proteins (ca. 30 mol %), which are characteristic of the chorion of the silkmoth Bombyx mori, has been determined by determining the sequence of a corresponding cDNA clone. The Hc protein sequence has evolved from a family of more ordinary chorion genes, in large part through fixation of mutations leading to enhanced cysteine content. Mutations of different types are differentially distributed in different parts of the sequence. In two conservative parts, those encoding the amino-terminal signal peptide and the highly structured central region of the protein, only base substitutions have been accepted. By contrast, in two alternating parts, which encode variable arms flanking the central region, deletions and duplications of tandemly repetitive sequences are prominent. Both base substitutions and expansions or deletions of tandemly repetitive elements are important in the evolution of this type of protein; functional constraints of the various protein domains dictate which class of mutations can be accepted.

Similar amino acid sequences: chance or common ancestry?

The systemic comparison of every newly determined amino acid sequence with all other known sequences may allow a complete reconstruction of the evolutionary events leading to contemporary proteins. But sometimes the surviving similarities are so vague that even computer-based sequence comparisons procedures are unable to validate relationships. In other cases similar sequences may appear in totally alien proteins as a result of mere chance or, occasionally, by the convergent evolution of sequences with special properties.

The coupling ATPase complex: an evolutionary view

Phospholipid micelles and vesicles, present in the primordial soup, formed both primitive (surface) catalyst and primitive replicative life forms. With the adoption of a common energy source, ATP, integrated biochemical systems within these vesicles became possible - cells. Fermentation within these primitive cells was favoured by the evolution, first of ion channels allowing protons to leak out, and then of an active ATP-driven pump. In the prokaryotic/mitochondria/chloroplast line, the proton channel was such as to be blocked by dicyclohexylcarbodiimide and the adenosine 5' triphosphate phosphohydrolase (ATPase) by 4-chloro 7-nitrobenzofurazan (Nbf-C1). The ATPase was initially simple (4 subunits) but later, possibly concomitant with its evolution to an ATP synthetase, became more complex (8 subunits). One of the steps in evolution probably involved gene duplication and divergence of 2 subunits (alpha and beta) from the largest of the ATPase subunits. From this stage, the general form of the ATPase was fixed, although sensitivity to, for example, oligomycin involved later, after divergence of the mitochondrial and chloroplast lines. A regulatory protein, the ATPase inhibitor, is found associated with a wide spectrum of coupling ATPases.

Possible role of RNA-dependent DNA-polymerase in early stages of evolution

The tDNA cistrons have permuted sequences of triplets corresponding to anti-codons in tRNA at specific regions in their sequences. We invoke reverse transcription for the generation of such sequences in the genome during early stages of evolution. Making the assumption that a single tDNA cistron, in a genome might have come into existence by an 'accident', after transcription, tRNA is expected to fold into a three-dimensional shape analogous to the contemporary tRNA, where the anti-codon triplet bases are sticking out well-exposed for chemical mutagens. The mutated tRNAs would have been reverse-transcribed into the genome by crude analogs of now-known reverse-transcriptases. The back and forth process of transcription and reverse transcription would give rise to all the tDNA cistrons with the required anti-codons. This process may act as an important feedback mechanism for the efficient progress of evolution.

Some evidence for the universality of structural periodicity in proteins

A new simple and sensitive method for detecting small periodicity (repetition of a small segment along the chain) in proteins is developed, based on the repetition of identical residues. 38 proteins from organisms representing different levels of evolutionary development have been tested for small periodicity. The same is done with the nodal ancestors of 25 of them. The results are presented graphically (the periodicity curves). The statistical significance of the observed periodicity is confirmed by a modified version of the chi-square test. All the results obtained support the conception that the small periodicity of the contemporary proteins is a reflection of their evolutionary history and that the most ancient proteins have arisen through a polycondensation of short peptides or through transcription and translation of satellite-type repeat sequence DNA.

The evolution of the protein synthesis system, II. From chemical evolution to biological evolution

The sequence of events previously proposed for modern protein synthesis is reviewed. It begins with an abiological synthesis of a template, and evolves through two model autocatalytic systems to a primitive cell that has a rudimentary biological protein synthesis system. A possible scheme for the origin of tRNA's is described so as to fill the gap between the model and the modern system. Fragments of genes that existed in and around the primitive system are proposed to be precursors of tRNA's. Since these fragments must have been undesirable components for the system, the origin and evolution of tRNA's may be regarded as an excellent answer by the primitive system to adverse circumstances.

Evolutionary diversification of structure and function in the family of intracellular calcium-binding proteins

The maximum parsimony method was used to reconstruct the genealogical history of the family of intracellular calcium-binding proteins represented by six major present-day lineages, three of which--calcium dependent modulator protein, heart and skeletal muscle troponin Cs, and alkali light chains of myosin--were found to share a closer kinship with one another than with the other lineages. Similarly, parvalbumins and regulatory light chains of myosin were depicted as more closely related, whereas the branch of intestinal calcium-binding protein proved to have the most distant separation. The computer-generated amino acid sequence for the common ancestor of these six lineages described a four domain protein in which each domain of approximately 40 amino acid residues had a mid-region. 12 residue segment that bound calcium and had properties most resembling those of the calcium dependent modulator protein. It could then be deduced that parvalbumins evolved by deletion of domain I, inactivation of calcium-binding properties in domain II, and acquisition of increased affinity for Ca++ and Mg++ in domains III and IV. Regulatory light chains of myosin lost the cation binding property from three domains, retaining it in I, whereas alkali light chains of myosin lost this ability from each of the four domains. In skeletal muscle troponin C all domains retained their calcium-binding activity; however, like parvalbumins, domains III and IV acquired high affinity properties. Cardiac troponin C lost its binding activity from domain I but otherwise resembled the skeletal muscle form. Finally, intestinal calcium-binding protein evolved by deletion of domains III and IV. Positive selection could be implicated in these evolutionary changes in that the rate of fixation of mutations substantially increased in the mid portions of those domains which were loosing calcium-binding activity. Likewise, when the cation binding sites were changing from low to high affinity, an accelerated rate of fixed mutations was observed. Once this new functional parameter was selected these regions showed a remarkable conservatism, as did those binding sites which were maintaining the lower affinity. Moreover even in sequence regions not directly involved in cation binding, the lineage of troponin C because very conservative over the past 300 million years, perhaps becuase of the necessity for maintaining specific interfaces in order for the molecule to interact with troponin I and T in a functional thin myofilament. A similar phenomenon was observed in domain II of the regulatory light chains of the myosin lineage suggesting a possible binding site with the heavy chain of myosin.

Evolutionary conservation of large chromosomal segments reflected in mammalian gene maps

Conservation of genetic linkage over long periods of time is exemplifted. Comparisons are made between chromosomal regions in different species as well as within two species, man and the house mouse. Homologous regions are defined and the phenomenon of differential silencing of genes is described. The importance of conservation of particular sequences of genes is discussed in relation to medical genetics, animal breeding, evolutionary theory and genetic regulation.

Two types of amino acid substitutions in protein evolution

The frequency of amino acid substitutions, relative to the frequency expected by chance, decreases linearly with the increase in physico-chemical differences between amino acid pairs involved in a substitution. This correlation does not apply to abnormal human hemoglobins. Since abnormal hemoglobins mostly reflect the process of mutation rather than selection, the correlation manifest during protein evolution between substitution frequency and physico-chemical difference in amino acids can be attributed to natural selection. Outside of 'abnormal' proteins, the correlation also does not apply to certain regions of proteins characterized by rapid rates of substitution. In these cases again, except for the largest physico-chemical differences between amino acid pairs, the substitution frequencies seem to be independent of the physico-chemical parameters. The limination of the substituents involving the largest physico-chemical differences can once more be attributed to natural selection. For smaller physico-chemical differences, natural selection, if it is operating in the polypeptide regions, must be based on parameters other than those examined.

Evolution of homologous physiological mechanisms based on protein sequence data

1. Genetic duplications can give rise to homologous physiological mechanisms that include structurally related protein components. There are many such examples of related proteins within the human body. 2. Evolutionary histories showing the origins and subsequent divergences of these distantly related proteins can be derived from the protein sequences and correlated with the functional characteristics of these proteins. 3. The hormones related to glucagon provide an example of homology of physiological mechanisms and emergence of new functions subsequent to gene duplications. 4. The proteins related to troponin C illustrate the participation of distantly related proteins in the same mechanism (muscle contraction), the relationship of proteins characteristic of a specialized tissue to proteins found in all eukaryote cells, and the correlation of genetic duplications with the evolutionary appearance of different types of muscle.

Homology of functionally diverse proteins

Disulphide-rich proteins of widely differing functions were aligned with the aid of their half-cystinyl residues. This led to the grouping of ribonuclease, phospholipase A, lysozyme, snake venom toxins, bee and scorpion venom peptides, and the plant proteins potatoe carboxypeptidase inhibitor, ragweed pollen allergen, mistletoe toxins and pineapple sulfhydryl protease inhibitor into one super-family of proteins. Very few deletions/insertions were needed to effect alignment and probabilities were calculated for random occurrence of the matches that were found.

Compartmentalization in proteinoid microspheres

Proteinoid microspheres with stable internal compartments and internal structure are made from acidic proteinoid and basic proteinoid with calcium. The populations of microspheres are characterized by a wide diversity of structure. A model of primitive intracellular communication is suggested by the observed movement of internal particles between compartments of a multicompartmentalized unit. Differential response to pH change and to temperature change has been demonstrated within one population and suggests one mode of adaptive selection among primordial cell populations.

Gene control in eukaryotes and the c-value paradox "excess" DNA as an impediment to transcription of coding sequences

Ways in which control of gene activity may lead to the observed high DNA content per haploid eukaryote genome are examined. It is proposed that deoxyribonucleoprotein (DNP) acts as a barrier to transcription at two distinct structural levels. At the lower level, melting of the nucleosome supercoil (quaternary structure) and of the nucleosomes (tertiary structure) might be brought about by the process of transcription itself. After unwinding the barrier section, the polymerase would eventually reach the structural gene. The transcripts of noncoding sequences, at least as far as their "unique" sequence components are concerned, may thus have filled their main function through the very process of transcription. The possibility of an inverse relationship between the length of the DNP barrier and the rates of transcription of the coding sequences is to some extent supported by available data. Different modes of coordination between the transcription of mRNA and of hnRNA from a single functional unit of gene action (funga) are considered. An analysis of gene control at high structural levels of DNP is made on the basis of other data, in relation to the concepts of eurygenic and stenogenic control. The concept of a euryon is introduced, namely of a set of linked fugas under common eurygenic control. Structure of order higher than quaternary can be inferred to exist in larger chromomeres of polytene chromosomes and in corresponding sections of ordinary chromosomes. Only moderate amounts of highest order interphase euchromatic structure are likely to be able to be accomodated in average chromomeres and none in very thin chromomeres. Puffs are interpreted as the melting of highest order interphase structure, and the absence of puffs during transcription as the absence of this highest order structure in the resting state of the chromomeres. Genes that are constantly active in all tissues may dispense with highest order interphase structure and with the corresponding control mechanism, and the fugas involved thus may not puff. Puffs, large chromomeres and highest order interphase euchromatic DNP structure seem to be correlated with genes that need to be transcribed only under certain developmental conditions. It is proposed that the function of high order structure is to sequester genetic material, namely mainly controller sequences. Since such high order structure, in most cases, would be built up to house the controller dependencies of just one structural gene, the amount of DNA per structural gene needed for gene control would be considerable, and the concept, if correct, would go a long way towards explaining the c-value paradox ("excess" DNA in eukaryotes). In eurygenic determination, the high order structure is thought to be conditioned for melting or to actually melt to an intermediate level of structure. From there, stenogenic control, leading to transcription, is considered to carry the melting process further to yet lower structural levels...

Evolutionary processes and evolutionary noise at the molecular level. II. A selectionist model for random fixations in proteins

On account, notably, of a competition between different component functions for individual sites in polypeptide chains, each protein molecule represents a functional compromise, with some functions optimized, but the overall state of the molecule "suboptimal". The proposal is made that the selection coefficient relating to a protein molecule under given conditions can in principle be broken down into partial selection coefficients relevant to the different functions that the molecule carries out. At general-function sites, each fixation improves some function, while others deteriorate, at first nonsignificantly, and the overall adaptive state of the molecule fluctuates around its maximum. A selective mechanism is described whereby kaleidoscopic changes in primary structure at variable sites are indefinitely promoted, independently of any environmental changes and with the molecule remaining close to a state of maximal overall adaptation. The paradoxical aspect of this proposal is analyzed. The implication of specific functions in substitutions at general-function sites is noted. Further, it is shown that a certain category of changes in the internal environment of the organism can be integrated into the constant-environmental model for selection. Genetic sufficiency is considered a notion more adequate than genetic optimality for describing biological fitness and for providing a basis for the present model. On this basis selection occurs without genetic load. Multipolymorphism is one of the consequences. Several lines of evidence, in particular observations on polymorphism in deep sea organisms, seem to support the model. It is pointed out that it provides a theoretical foundation for a molecular evolutionary clock. The theoretical constancy of the clock depends on the constancy of functional density. The question of the evolution of functional density is examined. Comparisons of observed substitution frequencies with values expected on a random basis are rejected as a measure of the contribution to evolution of nondetermination. They are considered to reflect a hierarchy in the resistance of the molecules to different amino acid residues as substituents. A limited component of "true" randomness, again accompanied by selection, is on the other hand provided by the model. Most amino acid substitutions are considered evolutionary noise, even though noise compatible with selection. It is proposed that evolutionary significant substitutions may be identified by monitoring changes in functional density and weighted functional density.

Evolutionary processes and evolutionary noise at the molecular level. I. Functional density in proteins

The distinction between molecular sites that mainly carry out general functions and sites committed to specific functions is analyzed, notably in terms of different evolutionary variabilities. Functional density is defined as the proportion of sites involved in specific functions. Weighted functional density, by representing the relative variability at specific-function sites is to some extent a measure of the specificity of molecular interactions. The relationship between general- and specific-function sites on the one hand the covarions of Fitch on the other is discussed. The functional "degeneracy" of amino acids is described as increasing the interdependence of general functions. It is predicted that proteins tht do not possess general-function sites besides their specific-function sites tend to "freeze" their primary structure, according to an evolutionary process that is an autocatalytic function of the decrease in site variability. This limits the use of weighted functional density as an indicator of the overall degree of interaction specificity of a protein to values that are not close to unity.