Differences between rodent and human cell lines in the amount of integrated DNA after transfection

A promising genomic transfectant into Xeroderma pigmentosum group A with highly amplified mouse DNA and intermediate UV resistance turns revertant

Following transfection of genomic mouse DNA into an SV40 transformed fibroblast cell line from a patient with Xeroderma pigmentosum (complementation group A, XPA), a single UV resistant cell clone was isolated out of a total of 10(4) independent transfectants. The recipient XPA cell line has as yet not produced spontaneous revertants among 2.2 x 10(8) cells. The isolated cell clone contains 50-70 kb of mouse sequences which are heavily amplified (500-fold), and has acquired both intermediate resistance to UV killing and intermediate unscheduled DNA synthesis (UDS) capacity. By continued passage without selective pressure, cells were generated, which had lost both the dominant marker gene and repetitive mouse sequences. Single colonies of these cells were still intermediately resistant to UV suggesting that either undetected unique mouse DNA had segregated from the bulk of repetitive DNA, or, more likely, that the initially isolated transfectant was a spontaneous revertant. This documents that a persuasive clone isolated can still be a false positive (spontaneous revertant) and that an extremely laborious approach may lead into a dead end.

The use of integrating DNA vectors to analyse the molecular defects in ionising radiation-sensitive mutants of mammalian cells including ataxia telangiectasia

Integrating DNA vectors, encoding selectable recombinant genes, were used to assess rejoining and recombination in wild-type mammalian cells and their ionising radiation-sensitive mutants. To provide a simple model of an important radiation-induced lesion - the DNA double-strand break - the vectors were cut with restriction endonucleases at specific single sites. If these breaks were made in the coding sequence of a selectable gene, the fidelity of the rejoin/recombination process could be measured by survival of vector-transformed cells in selective medium. Rejoining was assessed using vectors without internal homologies, while recombination was measured using pairs of fragments or deletion vectors carrying homologous regions. Initial experiments were made with vectors carrying a single selectable gene but, to overcome potential artefacts, 2-gene vectors were then constructed where one gene acts as a linked marker and (unbroken) control for the other (broken) gene. Available data are reviewed to show that, compared to their respective wild-type counterparts: (1) an ataxia telangiectasia (A-T) cell line and the hamster irs1 mutant show a consistent reduction in the fidelity of rejoining double-strand breaks (while the hamster mutants irs2, irs3, xrs series, and EM9 show wild-type fidelity); (2) the hamster EM9 mutant shows a reduction in ability to recombine homologous vector fragments (while the A-T line and probably the xrs mutants show show wild-type abilities); and (3) the xrs mutants show a reduction in overall transformation frequency with vector DNA, whether broken or not, while the other mutants tested show approximately wild-type frequencies. A critical account of the techniques and data is given, together with speculations on the molecular nature of the processes which are defective in these mutants, leading to radiosensitivity.

Effect of DNA damage on stable transformation of mammalian cells with integrative and episomal plasmids

The efficiency of stable transformation of human cells by integrative (non-replicating) plasmids carrying a selectable gene has been shown to be markedly enhanced by the introduction into the plasmid DNA of bulky damage, such as cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers or psoralen photoadducts. Enhanced transformation (ET) occurs in all human cells tested, including DNA repair-deficient cells from the hereditary syndrome xeroderma pigmentosum, but significantly less, if at all, in rodent cells. ET has been observed with a variety of integrative plasmid constructs, suggesting the generality of the phenomenon; as expected, ET is due to an increase in the number of cells carrying integrated plasmid sequences. In contrast to integrative plasmids, stable transformation by episomal (autonomously replicating) plasmids derived from the Epstein-Barr virus is only depressed by the introduction of photoproducts; furthermore, pronounced inactivation of transformation mediated by episomal plasmids becomes apparent in xeroderma pigmentosum cells. Altogether, these results suggest that DNA damage increases the probability of stable insertion of heterologous non-replicating DNA into human chromosomes. Moreover, the differential sensitivity to DNA damage of human cell transformation mediated by integrative versus episomal plasmids suggests caution in using such assay to measure host cell reactivation capacity; processing of DNA damage in mammalian cells might differ significantly between intra- versus extra-chromosomal DNA. Since ET may be induced by damage outside the selectable gene carried on integrative plasmids, we propose a model that involves local disruption of chromatin structure by helix-distorting DNA lesions flanking actively transcribed sequences; alternatively, reorganization of such altered DNA structure might be favored by the presence of topoisomerase-like activities in the proximity of active genes. Because ET can also be induced by DNA damage to the recipient cells, it is speculated that similar mechanism(s) might be involved in the generation of other types of non-homologous DNA recombination in damaged human chromosomes, including oncogenic cell transformation mediated by integrative DNA viruses.

Comparative study of Epstein-Barr virus and SV40-based shuttle-expression vectors in human repair-deficient cells

Shuttle vectors and expression vectors have been used in human cells to examine various aspects of DNA repair including effects of DNA damage on mutagenesis, transcription, replication and recombination. A combined shuttle-expression system should provide further advantages for the stable expression of and perhaps selection/rescue strategies for DNA repair genes. We describe 2 such systems. The first is a simian virus 40 (SV40) shuttle system which allows a quasi-stable episomal vector/host relationship in which the shuttle vector may be recovered in extrachromosomal DNA preparations many months after transfection and selection but in which a high proportion of the plasmids rescued in bacteria are heavily mutated and rearranged. Secondly, we describe Epstein-Barr virus-based shuttle-expression vectors which exist as stable, multicopy episomes in human cells. Using a reporter gene and a metal-inducible promoter we have obtained low basal and very high induced expression from episomal vectors in a variety of human cells including xeroderma pigmentosum and ataxia telangiectasia cell lines. This should facilitate many molecular genetic experiments in human cells and may have particular application to molecular cloning, expression and analysis of DNA repair genes.

The cloned human DNA excision repair gene ERCC-1 fails to correct xeroderma pigmentosum complementation groups A through I

The human DNA excision repair gene ERCC-1 complements the ultraviolet light (UV) and mitomycin C (MMC) sensitivity of CHO mutants of complementation group 1. We have investigated whether ERCC-1 is the mutated gene in cell lines from xeroderma pigmentosum (XP) complementation groups A through I by analyzing the endogenous gene in XP cells and by introduction of the gene followed by repair assays. Our studies show that ERCC-1 is not deleted or grossly rearranged in representative cell lines of 9 XP groups. Furthermore, Northern blot analysis revealed correct transcription of ERCC-1 in all groups. The cloned human ERCC-1 gene was introduced into immortalized XP cells by DNA transfection (groups A, C, D, E and F). The presence of the integrated transfected sequences was verified on Southern blots and by selection for 2 dominant marker genes that flank the ERCC-1 gene on the transfected cos43-34 DNA. ERCC-1 failed to confer a normal UV survival and UV-induced unscheduled DNA synthesis (UDS) to transfected populations. In the case of the remaining XP complementation groups (B, G, H and I), nuclear microinjection was used to introduce an ERCC-1 cDNA construct driven by an SV40 promoter into primary fibroblasts. Coinjection of the SV40 large T gene and analysis of its expression served as a control for the injection. The ERCC-1 cDNA failed to induce increased levels of UDS in the microinjected fibroblasts. We infer from these experiments that ERCC-1 is not the mutated gene in the 9 XP complementation groups examined. From a similar type of experiments we conclude that ERCC-1 is not the defective gene in UV-sensitive Cockayne's syndrome cells.

Complementation of the DNA-repair defect in a CHO mutant by human DNA that lacks highly abundant repetitive sequences

Recently, two human DNA-repair genes have been cloned which complement the defects in complementation groups 1 and 2 of the CHO mutants which are sensitive to ultraviolet light and deficient in the incision step of excision repair. Here we report human gene transfer-mediated complementation of a group 4 CHO mutant sensitive to ultraviolet light and mitomycin C (MMC). The transfectants generated by transfecting human DNA into the repair-deficient cell line demonstrate the repair-proficient phenotype, as they have wild-type levels of resistance to UV light and MMC and are competent in performing the incision step of excision repair in response to UV irradiation. 3 of the 8 transfectants isolated display no detectable human repetitive sequences, while the other 5 contain varying amounts of human repetitive DNA. As the evidence suggests that all of the transfectants are repair-proficient as a result of the uptake of human DNA, we conclude that the human gene that complements the repair defect in group 4 CHO mutants contains no highly abundant human repetitive sequences. This imposes the necessity of developing cloning strategies involving the identification of sequences that flank the gene.

The molecular genetics of the incision step in the DNA excision repair process

This review describes the evolution of research into the genetic basis of how different organisms use the process of excision repair to recognize and remove lesions from their cellular DNA. One particular aspect of excision repair, DNA incision, and how it is controlled at the genetic level in bacteriophage, bacteria, S. cerevisae, D. melanogaster, rodent cells and humans is examined. In phage T4, DNA is incised by a DNA glycosylase-AP endonuclease that is coded for by the denV gene. In E. coli, the products of three genes, uvrA, uvrB and uvrC, are required to form the UVRABC excinuclease that cleaves DNA and releases a fragment 12-13 nucleotides long containing the site of damage. In S. cerevisiae, genes complementing five mutants of the RAD3 epistasis group, rad1, rad2, rad3, rad4 and rad10 have been cloned and analyzed. Rodent cells sensitive to a variety of mutagenic agents and deficient in excision repair are being used in molecular studies to identify and clone human repair genes (e.g. ERCC1) capable of complementing mammalian repair defects. Most studies of the human system, however, have been done with cells isolated from patients suffering from the repair defective, cancer-prone disorder, xeroderma pigmentosum, and these cells are now beginning to be characterized at the molecular level. Studies such as these that provide a greater understanding of the genetic basis of DNA repair should also offer new insights into other cellular processes, including genetic recombination, differentiation, mutagenesis, carcinogenesis and aging.

SV 40-transformed normal and DNA-repair-deficient human fibroblasts can be transfected with high frequency but retain only limited amounts of integrated DNA

The ability of simian virus 40-transformed human fibroblasts to integrate and maintain transfected genomic DNA has been investigated in two normal and six DNA-repair-deficient human cell lines. These cell lines were transfected with DNA containing two selective markers (G418 and hygromycin (Hyg) resistance) separated by random pieces of human DNA of 0-40 kb in length. The transfection frequency for the selected (G418R) marker was between 2 x 10(-4) and 2 x 10(-3) for all cell lines, comparable to many other mammalian systems. About 50% of the G418R colonies were also initially resistant to Hyg. Analysis of the DNA from individual clones expanded for a further month revealed, however, that about one to three copies of the selected marker but only about 0.1 copy per cell of the unselected marker were maintained. Our results were broadly similar for all eight cell lines. Thus the amount of integrated DNA that is stably maintained in these cells is in general very small (less than 50 kb). This may provide an explanation for the difficulties encountered in many laboratories in attempts to correct the defect in DNA-repair-deficient human cells by transfection with genomic DNA. Our results also show that none of several defects in DNA repair has any obvious effect on either the transfection frequency or the amount of stably integrated foreign DNA.

Molecular cloning and biological characterization of a human gene, ERCC2, that corrects the nucleotide excision repair defect in CHO UV5 cells

The UV-sensitive Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cell line UV5, which is defective in the incision step of nucleotide excision repair, was used to identify and clone a complementing human gene, ERCC2, and to study the repair process. Genomic DNA from a human-hamster hybrid cell line was sheared and cotransferred with pSV2gpt plasmid DNA into UV5 cells to obtain five primary transformants. Transfer of sheared DNA from one primary transformant resulted in a secondary transformant expressing both gpt and ERCC2. The human repair gene was identified with a probe for Alu-family repetitive sequences. For most primary, secondary, and cosmid transformants, survival after UV exposure showed a return to wild-type levels of resistance. The levels of UV-induced mutation at the aprt locus for secondary and cosmid transformants varied from 50 to 130% of the wild-type level. Measurements of the initial rate of UV-induced strand incision by alkaline elution indicated that, whereas the UV5 rate was 3% of the wild-type level, rates of cosmid-transformed lines were similar to that of the wild type, and the secondary transformant rate was about 165% of the wild-type rate. Analysis of overlapping cosmids determined that ERCC2 is between 15.5 and 20 kilobases and identified a closely linked gpt gene. Cosmids were obtained with functional copies of both ERCC2 and gpt. ERCC2 corrects only the first of the five CHO complementation groups of incision-defective mutants.

Ataxia telangiectasia resists gene cloning: an account of parameters determining gene transfer into human recipient cells

A subclone of an SV40-transformed fibroblast cell line from a patient with Ataxia telangiectasia (AT) with a relatively high rate of DNA uptake was isolated. However, more than 65000 independent genomic transfectants (using wild-type human DNA) did not contain the functional AT gene. This number represents the statistical distribution of an amount of DNA equivalent to more than three times the haploid human genome. The transfectants were screened by an X ray selection protocol that could rescue a single wild-type cell out of a population of 10(6) AT cells. This suggests a reversion frequency for AT of below 10(-8). The DNA uptake into human cells is compared with that into NIH3T3 cells and future possibilities for the isolation of human repair genes are discussed.

Complementation of the xeroderma pigmentosum DNA repair defect in cell-free extracts

Soluble extracts from human lymphoid cell lines that perform repair synthesis on covalently closed circular DNA containing pyrimidine dimers or psoralen adducts are described. Short patches of nucleotides are introduced by excision repair of damaged DNA in an ATP-dependent reaction. Extracts from xeroderma pigmentosum cell lines fail to act on damaged circular DNA, but are proficient in repair synthesis of ultraviolet-irradiated DNA containing incisions generated by Micrococcus luteus pyrimidine dimer-DNA glycosylase. Repair is defective in extracts from all xeroderma pigmentosum cell lines investigated, representing the genetic complementation groups A, B, C, D, H, and V. Mixing of cell extracts of group A and C origin leads to reconstitution of the DNA repair activity.

Molecular cloning and biological characterization of a human gene, ERCC2, that corrects the nucleotide excision repair defect in CHO UV5 cells

The UV-sensitive Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cell line UV5, which is defective in the incision step of nucleotide excision repair, was used to identify and clone a complementing human gene, ERCC2, and to study the repair process. Genomic DNA from a human-hamster hybrid cell line was sheared and cotransferred with pSV2gpt plasmid DNA into UV5 cells to obtain five primary transformants. Transfer of sheared DNA from one primary transformant resulted in a secondary transformant expressing both gpt and ERCC2. The human repair gene was identified with a probe for Alu-family repetitive sequences. For most primary, secondary, and cosmid transformants, survival after UV exposure showed a return to wild-type levels of resistance. The levels of UV-induced mutation at the aprt locus for secondary and cosmid transformants varied from 50 to 130% of the wild-type level. Measurements of the initial rate of UV-induced strand incision by alkaline elution indicated that, whereas the UV5 rate was 3% of the wild-type level, rates of cosmid-transformed lines were similar to that of the wild type, and the secondary transformant rate was about 165% of the wild-type rate. Analysis of overlapping cosmids determined that ERCC2 is between 15.5 and 20 kilobases and identified a closely linked gpt gene. Cosmids were obtained with functional copies of both ERCC2 and gpt. ERCC2 corrects only the first of the five CHO complementation groups of incision-defective mutants.

Transfection of the cloned human excision repair gene ERCC-1 to UV-sensitive CHO mutants only corrects the repair defect in complementation group-2 mutants

The human DNA-excision repair gene ERCC-1 is cloned by its ability to correct the excision-repair defect of the ultraviolet light- and mitomycin-C-sensitive CHO mutant cell line 43-3B. This mutant is assigned to complementation group 2 of the excision-repair-deficient CHO mutants. In order to establish whether the correction by ERCC-1 is confined to CHO mutants of one complementation group, the cloned repair gene, present on cosmid 43-34, was transfected to representative cell lines of the 6 complementation groups that have been identified to date. Following transfection, mycophenolic acid was used to select for transferants expressing the dominant marker gene Ecogpt, also present on cosmid 43-34. Cotransfer of the ERCC-1 gene was shown by Southern blot analysis of DNA from pooled (500-2000 independent colonies) transformants of each mutant. UV survival and UV-induced UDS showed that only mutants belonging to complementation group 2 and no mutants of other groups were corrected by the ERCC-1 gene. This demonstrates that ERCC-1 does not provide an aspecific bypass of excision-repair defects in CHO mutants and supports the assumption that the complementation analysis is based on mutations in different repair genes.

Correction of excision repair in xeroderma pigmentosum by hamster chromosome fragments involves both classes of pyrimidine dimers

The ultraviolet light-sensitive phenotype of xeroderma pigmentosum (XP) has been corrected by the incorporation into XP cells of small chromosome fragments from Chinese hamster ovary cells. Like normal human and hamster cells, these XP-hamster hybrids are able to excise both of the photoproducts produced by ultraviolet light: cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers and the minor photoproduct, (6-4) pyrimidine-pyrimidone dimers. This excision capacity contrasts with that of an XP revertant, of the same cell line used in this study, which is able to excise only the (6-4) photoproducts. The excision defect of XP has been fully corrected in the hybrids; therefore, the small hamster chromosome fragments they contain should carry the gene for complementation group A of XP.