The clinical heterogeneity of preeclampsia is related to both placental gene expression and placental histopathology

Association of preeclampsia with infant APOL1 genotype in African Americans

Background

Black women in the United States and Africa are at an increased risk for preeclampsia. Allelic variants in the gene for apolipoprotein LI, APOL1, are found only in populations of African ancestry, and have been shown to contribute significant risk for kidney disease. Recent studies suggest these APOL1 variants also may contribute risk for preeclampsia.

Methods

The association of preeclampsia with carriage of APOL1 risk alleles was evaluated in a case-control study of deliveries from black women at a single center in Cleveland, Ohio that included gross and histopathologic evaluations of placental tissues (395 cases and 282 controls). Using logistic regression models, associations between fetal APOL1 genotype and preeclampsia were evaluated using several case definitions based on prematurity and severity of preeclampsia, with uncomplicated term pregnancies as controls. Associations between APOL1 genotype and pathological features were also examined.

Results

The infant APOL1 genotype was significantly associated with preeclampsia in a dominant inheritance pattern with odds ratio of 1.41 (P=0.029, 95% CI 1.037, 1.926). Stratifying preeclampsia cases by preterm birth, significant associations were detected for both recessive (O.R.=1.70, P=0.038) and additive (O.R.=1.33, P=0.028) inheritance patterns. APOL1 genotype, however, was not significantly associated with pathological changes or other perinatal observations.

Conclusions

Preeclampsia appears to be another disease associated with APOL1 variants, however, further studies are needed to increase confidence in the mode of inheritance. By understanding the association of APOL1 variants with preeclampsia, genetic screening tests for APOL1 may be useful to predict at-risk pregnancies and targeted interventions may be developed to improve pregnancy outcomes.

Does low-dose aspirin initiated before 11 weeks' gestation reduce the rate of preeclampsia?

OBJECTIVE DATA

Preconception or early administration of low-dose aspirin might improve endometrial growth, placental vascularization, and organogenesis. Most studies have evaluated the potential benefit of preconception or early administration of low-dose aspirin in women with a history of recurrent pregnancy loss, women who have undergone in vitro fertilization, or women with thrombophilia or antiphospholipid syndrome. These women are at an increased risk of placenta-associated complications of pregnancy, including preeclampsia, preterm delivery, and fetal growth restriction.

STUDY OUTCOMES

We performed a systematic review and meta-analysis to evaluate the effect of low-dose aspirin initiated at <11 weeks' gestation on the risk of preeclampsia, gestational hypertension, or any hypertensive disorder of pregnancy. Secondary outcomes included preterm delivery at <37 weeks' gestation and fetal growth restriction.

STUDY APPRAISAL AND SYNTHESIS METHODS

We searched in MEDLINE via PubMed, EMBASE, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL), ClinicalTrials.gov, and the World Health Organization International Clinical Trials Registry Platform from 1985 to November 2018. Entry criteria were randomized controlled trials evaluating the effect of aspirin administered at <11 weeks' gestation in preventing preeclampsia and/or hypertensive disorders in pregnancy or improving pregnancy outcomes in women with recurrent miscarriage as compared with placebo or no treatment and outcome data available or provided by authors for >85% of the study population. Relative risks with 95% confidence intervals were calculated for each study and pooled for global analysis as the effect measure. We assessed statistical heterogeneity in each meta-analysis using the χ² statistics, I², and Tau². Heterogeneity was considered substantial if an I² was greater than 50% and either the Tau² was greater than zero or there was a low P value (<0.10) in the χ² test for heterogeneity. Random-effects meta-analysis, weighted by the size of the studies, was performed to produce an overall summary on aspirin effect for each outcome. Sensitivity analysis by sequential omission of each individual study and by fixed-effects model was performed. Publication bias was not assessed because of the small number of included studies. Statistical analysis was performed using Stata release 14.0 (StataCorp).

RESULTS

The entry criteria were fulfilled by 8 randomized controlled trials on a combined total of 1426 participants. Low-dose aspirin initiated at <11 weeks' gestation was associated with a nonsignificant reduction in the risk of preeclampsia (relative risk, 0.52; 95% confidence interval, 0.23-1.17, P = .115), gestational hypertension (relative risk, 0.49; 95% confidence interval, 0.20-1.21; P = .121), and any hypertensive disorder of pregnancy (relative risk, 0.59; 95% confidence interval, 0.33-1.04, P = .067). Early administration of low-dose aspirin reduced the risk of preterm delivery (relative risk, 0.52; 95% confidence interval, 0.27-0.97, P = .040) but had no impact on the risk of fetal growth restriction (relative risk, 1.10; 95% confidence interval, 0.58-2.07, P = .775). Except for preterm delivery and any hypertensive disorder of pregnancy, sensitivity analysis demonstrated similar observations, therefore confirming the robustness of the analysis.

CONCLUSION

The administration of low-dose aspirin at <11 weeks' gestation in women at high risk does not decrease the risk of preeclampsia, gestational hypertension, any hypertensive disorder of pregnancy, and fetal growth restriction. However, it might reduce the risk of preterm delivery. Larger randomized controlled trials will be required to substantiate the findings.

From animal models to patients: the role of placental microRNAs, miR-210, miR-126, and miR-148a/152 in preeclampsia

Placental microRNAs (miRNAs) regulate the placental transcriptome and play a pathological role in preeclampsia (PE), a hypertensive disorder of pregnancy. Three PE rodent model studies explored the role of placental miRNAs, miR-210, miR-126, and miR-148/152 respectively, by examining expression of the miRNAs, their inducers, and potential gene targets. This review evaluates the role of miR-210, miR-126, and miR-148/152 in PE by comparing findings from the three rodent model studies with in vitro studies, other animal models, and preeclamptic patients to provide comprehensive insight into genetic components and pathological processes in the placenta contributing to PE. The majority of studies demonstrate miR-210 is upregulated in PE in part driven by HIF-1α and NF-κBp50, stimulated by hypoxia and/or immune-mediated processes. Elevated miR-210 may contribute to PE via inhibiting anti-inflammatory Th2-cytokines. Studies report an up- and downregulation of miR-126, arguably reflecting differences in expression between cell types and its multifunctional capacity. MiR-126 may play a pro-angiogenic role by mediating the PI3K-Akt pathway. Most studies report miR-148/152 family members are upregulated in PE. Evidence suggests they may inhibit DNA methylation of genes involved in metabolic and inflammatory pathways. Given the genetic heterogeneity of PE, it is unlikely that a single placental miRNA is a suitable therapeutic target for all patients. Investigating miRNAs in PE subtypes in patients and animal models may represent a more appropriate approach going forward. Developing methods for targeting placental miRNAs and specific placental cell types remains crucial for research seeking to target placental miRNAs as a novel treatment for PE.

Effect of current guidelines on prevention of pre-eclampsia with low-dose aspirin in primary settings: A population-based case-control study

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the effect of low-dose aspirin, which was administered at or before the 16th week of pregnancy due to maternal characteristics and history of a pre-existing medical condition, on prevention of pre-eclampsia, and on the birth of a small-for-gestational-age (SGA) neonate without pre-eclampsia in nulliparas in primary settings.

METHODS

We performed a case-control study using population-based data on 47 271 nulliparas with a singleton pregnancy who delivered in Slovenia from 2013 to 2017. The treated group received low-dose aspirin. For the untreated group, propensity score matching was used to perform a 1:1 matching. In the matched sample, we calculated the odds ratios (OR) with a 95% confidence interval (95% CI) with a two-way test for pre-eclampsia, as well as SGA neonates.

RESULTS

In the treated group (n=584), the odds for an SGA neonate were significantly increased by 42.7% (OR 1.427, 95% CI 1.001-2.034). However, we found no significant effect on the odds for pre-eclampsia (OR 1.308, 95% CI 0.847-2.022).

CONCLUSIONS

In anticipation of more substantial population-based data studies, in the Slovenian population, preventive treatment with low-dose aspirin due to maternal characteristics and history of a pre-existing medical condition is not beneficial for the prevention of pre-eclampsia and can harm fetal growth.

The Use of Sex-Specific Factors in the Assessment of Women's Cardiovascular Risk

Cardiovascular disease (CVD) is the leading cause of death among women in the United States. As compared with men, women are less likely to be diagnosed appropriately, receive preventive care, or be treated aggressively for CVD. Sex differences between men and women have allowed for the identification of CVD risk factors and risk markers that are unique to women. The 2018 American Heart Association/American College of Cardiology Multi-Society cholesterol guideline and 2019 American College of Cardiology/American Heart Association guideline on the primary prevention of CVD introduced the concept of risk-enhancing factors that are specific to women and are associated with an increased risk of incident atherosclerotic CVD in women. These factors, if present, would favor more intensified lifestyle interventions and consideration of initiation or intensification of statin therapy for primary prevention to mitigate the increased risk. In this primer, we highlight sex-specific CVD risk factors in women, stress the importance of eliciting a thorough obstetrical and gynecological history during cardiovascular risk assessment, and provide a framework for how to initiate appropriate preventive measures when sex-specific risk factors are present.

Trophoblast lineage-specific differentiation and associated alterations in preeclampsia and fetal growth restriction

The human placenta is a poorly-understood organ, but one that is critical for proper development and growth of the fetus in-utero. The epithelial cell type that contributes to primary placental functions is called "trophoblast," including two main subtypes, villous and extravillous trophoblast. Cytotrophoblast and syncytiotrophoblast comprise the villous compartment and contribute to gas and nutrient exchange, while extravillous trophoblast invade and remodel the uterine wall and vessels, in order to supply maternal blood to the growing fetus. Abnormal differentiation of trophoblast contributes to placental dysfunction and is associated with complications of pregnancy, including preeclampsia (PE) and fetal growth restriction (FGR). This review describes what is known about the cellular organization of the placenta during both normal development and in the setting of PE/FGR. It also explains known trophoblast lineage-specific markers and pathways regulating their differentiation, and how these are altered in the setting of PE/FGR, focusing on studies which have used human placental tissues. Finally, it also highlights remaining questions and needed resources to advance this field.

Expression profiles of candidate microRNAs in the peripheral blood leukocytes of patients with early- and late-onset preeclampsia versus normal pregnancies

OBJECTIVES

Maternal leucocytes play an important role in the pathogenesis of preeclampsia (PE). Circulating microRNAs (miRNAs) are small, noncoding RNA molecules. The purpose of this study was to investigate miR-518b, miR-155-5p, and miR-21-3p in the peripheral blood leukocytes of patients with PE, compared to controls.

STUDY DESIGN

Using real-time quantitative PCR method, the selected miRNAs which have been associated with PE were examined from early- onset PE (EOPE) (<34 weeks) (n = 48), late- onset PE (LOPE) (≥34 weeks) (n = 48), total cases of PE (n = 96), and healthy controls (n = 52).

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

The relative expression of the target miR in patient samples was compared to the calibrator and the results were expressed as relative quantification values.

RESULTS

Gestational age (GA) was significantly different between PE and controls. Univariate logistic regression analysis adjusted for GA at blood draw were fit to compare miR-518b, miR-155-5p, and miR-21-3p between PE and controls. The expression of miR-518b, miR-155-5p, and miR-21-3p were not significantly different in PE, compared to controls. The expression of miR-518b was upregulated in the EOPE and LOPE group, compared to controls, and the area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC) of miR-518b was 0.65 and 0.62, respectively. miR-518b was positively correlated with WBC count, platelet count, serum levels of AST, ALT, LDH in EOPE. miR-21-3p expression level was negatively correlated with body mass index at blood draw and systolic blood pressure in the LOPE group.

CONCLUSIONS

Increased miR-518b expression levels were found to be associated with EOPE and LOPE.

Recurrent Placental Transcriptional Profile With a Different Histological and Clinical Presentation: A Case Report

Statistically, patients with severe pregnancy complications are at risk of recurrent complications, but it is less understood if patients present with similar or different placental pathologies in subsequent pregnancies. In this case report, we describe 2 consecutive adverse pregnancies in the same woman 4 years apart. The first pregnancy was diagnosed as early-onset preeclampsia and hemolysis, elevated liver enzymes, and low platelets (HELLP) syndrome, with placental maternal vascular malperfusion features, such as syncytial knots and accelerated villous maturity. In contrast, the second pregnancy was associated with normotensive fetal growth restriction and placental "immunological" lesions, such as massive perivillous fibrin deposition and chronic intervillositis. However, based on the expression of FLT1, LIMCH1, and TAP1 by quantitative polymerase chain reaction, the placentas from both pregnancies were found to exhibit an "immunological" transcriptional signature. This suggests that this small panel of gene expression markers may be able to predict the future reoccurrence of an immunological placental pathology despite no histological evidence within the first pregnancy. These results call for more studies looking at paired pregnancies of individuals with recurrent obstetric complications and confirm the importance of assessing matched transcriptional and histopathological placental information.

The significance of the placental genome and methylome in fetal and maternal health

The placenta is a crucial organ for supporting a healthy pregnancy, and defective development or function of the placenta is implicated in a number of complications of pregnancy that affect both maternal and fetal health, including maternal preeclampsia, fetal growth restriction, and spontaneous preterm birth. In this review, we highlight the role of the placental genome in mediating fetal and maternal health by discussing the impact of a variety of genetic alterations, from large whole-chromosome aneuploidies to single-nucleotide variants, on placental development and function. We also discuss the placental methylome in relation to its potential applications for refining diagnosis, predicting pathology, and identifying genetic variants with potential functional significance. We conclude that understanding the influence of the placental genome on common placental-mediated pathologies is critical to improving perinatal health outcomes.

Considerations when processing and interpreting genomics data of the placenta

The application of genomic approaches to placental research has opened exciting new avenues to help us understand basic biological properties of the placenta, improve prenatal screening/diagnosis, and measure effects of in utero exposures on child health outcomes. In the last decade, such large-scale genomic data (including epigenomics and transcriptomics) have become more easily accessible to researchers from many disciplines due to the increasing ease of obtaining such data and the rapidly evolving computational tools available for analysis. While the potential of large-scale studies has been widely promoted, less attention has been given to some of the challenges associated with processing and interpreting such data. We hereby share some of our experiences in assessing data quality, reproducibility, and interpretation in the context of genome-wide studies of the placenta, with the aim to improve future studies. There is rarely a single "best" approach, as that can depend on the study question and sample cohort. However, being consistent, thoroughly assessing potential confounders in the data, and communicating key variables in the methods section of the manuscript are critically important to help researchers to collaborate and build on each other's work.

Learning from experience: cellular and molecular bases for improved outcome in subsequent pregnancies

The frequencies of preeclampsia, fetal growth restriction, fetal demise, and low birthweight are lower in subsequent pregnancies. Enhanced maternal cardiovascular adaptation, shorter first and second stages of labor, and more robust lactation also have been observed in subsequent as compared with first pregnancies. We sought to investigate the cellular and molecular bases for better outcomes in subsequent pregnancies. Based on the knowledge that specialized immune cells at the maternal-fetal interface, decidual natural killer cells, promote development of the placental bed and conversion of the spiral arteries by secreting a myriad of angiogenic and growth factors, we asked whether decidual natural killer cells differ in subsequent as compared with first pregnancies. This idea stemmed from recent studies suggesting that natural killer cells, although part of the innate immune system, possess some features of adaptive immunity, including a certain type of immune cell memory, termed trained immunity. We found that decidual natural killer cells from parous women "remember pregnancy" and differ from decidual natural killer cells of primigravidae. Compared with the decidual natural killer cells of first pregnancy, these cells, that we termed pregnancy-trained decidual natural killer cells, express greater levels of the natural killer receptors NKG2C and leukocyte immunoglobulin-like receptor B1, which interact with ligands expressed on invasive trophoblasts. Furthermore, they secrete greater levels of several growth factors, including vascular endothelial growth factor α as well as interferon-γ, augmenting remodeling of the placental bed. We propose that this pregnancy-trained memory dwells in the epigenome, where memory of stimuli is known to persist even when the stimulus is no longer present. This epigenetic memory apparently resides in endometrial natural killer cells between pregnancies. We suggest that this trained memory, which we coined pregnancy-trained decidual natural killer cells, may be the missing link in the immune basis for enhanced subsequent pregnancy. Epigenetic memory (chromatin modification) also may afford a global explanation for additional findings of enhanced maternal cardiovascular adaptation, shorter first and second stages of labor, and more robust lactation. Understanding the molecular and cellular bases of improved outcomes of subsequent pregnancy may lead to the development of treatment modalities designed for women at high risk for pregnancy disorders originating at the maternal-fetal interface.

Placental transcriptional and histologic subtypes of normotensive fetal growth restriction are comparable to preeclampsia

BACKGROUND

Infants born small for gestational age because of pathologic placenta-mediated fetal growth restriction can be difficult to distinguish from those who are constitutionally small. Additionally, even among fetal growth-restricted pregnancies with evident placental disease, considerable heterogeneity in clinical outcomes and long-term consequences has been observed. Gene expression studies of fetal growth-restricted placentas also have limited consistency in their findings, which is likely due to the presence of different molecular subtypes of disease. In our previous study on preeclampsia, another heterogeneous placenta-centric disorder of pregnancy, we found that, by clustering placentas based only on their gene expression profiles, multiple subtypes of preeclampsia, including several with co-occurring suspected fetal growth restriction, could be identified.

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to discover placental subtypes of normotensive small-for-gestational-age pregnancies with suspected fetal growth restriction through the use of unsupervised clustering of placental gene expression data and to investigate their relationships with hypertensive suspected fetal growth-restricted placental subtypes.

STUDY DESIGN

A new dataset of 20 placentas from normotensive small-for-gestational-age pregnancies (birthweight <10th percentile for gestational age and sex) with suspected fetal growth restriction (ultrasound features of placental insufficiency) underwent genome-wide messenger RNA expression assessment and blinded detailed histopathologic evaluation. These samples were then combined with a subset of samples from our previously published preeclampsia cohort (n=77) to form an aggregate fetal growth-focused cohort (n=97) of placentas from normotensive small-for-gestational-age, hypertensive (preeclampsia and chronic hypertensive) small-for-gestational-age, and normotensive average-for-gestational-age pregnancies. Gene expression data were subjected to unsupervised clustering, and clinical and histopathologic features were correlated to the identified sample clusters.

RESULTS

Clustering of the aggregate dataset revealed 3 transcriptional subtypes of placentas from normotensive small-for-gestational-age/suspected fetal growth-restricted pregnancies, with differential enrichment of clinical and histopathologic findings. The first subtype exhibited either no placental disease or mild maternal vascular malperfusion lesions, and, co-clustered with the healthy average-for-gestational-age control subjects; the second subtype showed more severe evidence of hypoxic damage and lesions of maternal vascular malperfusion, and the third subtype demonstrated an immune/inflammatory response and histologic features of a maternal-fetal interface disturbance. Furthermore, all 3 of these normotensive small-for-gestational-age subtypes co-clustered with a group of placentas from hypertensive small-for-gestational-age pregnancies with more severe clinical outcomes, but very comparable transcriptional and histologic placental profiles.

CONCLUSION

Overall, this study provides evidence for at least 2 pathologic placental causes of normotensive small-for-gestational-age, likely representing true fetal growth restriction. These subtypes also show considerable similarity in gene expression and histopathology to our previously identified "canonical" and "immunologic" preeclampsia placental subtypes. Furthermore, we discovered a subtype of normotensive small-for-gestational-age (with suspected fetal growth restriction) with minimal placental disease that may represent both constitutionally small infants and mild fetal growth restriction, although these cannot be distinguished with the currently available data. Future work that focuses on the identification of etiology-driven biomarkers and therapeutic interventions for each subtype of fetal growth restriction is warranted.