Molecular targets of TBBPA in zebrafish analysed through integration of genomic and proteomic approaches

Systems biology: leading the revolution in ecotoxicology

The rapid development of new technologies such as transcriptomics, proteomics, and metabolomics (Omics) are changing the way ecotoxicology is practiced. The data deluge has begun with genomes of over 65 different aquatic species that are currently being sequenced, and many times that number with at least some level of transcriptome sequencing. Integrating these top-down methodologies is an essential task in the field of systems biology. Systems biology is a biology-based interdisciplinary field that focuses on complex interactions in biological systems, with the intent to model and discover emergent properties of the system. Recent studies demonstrate that Omics technologies provide valuable insight into ecotoxicity, both in laboratory exposures with model organisms and with animals exposed in the field. However, these approaches require a context of the whole animal and population to be relevant. Powerful approaches using reverse engineering to determine interacting networks of genes, proteins, or biochemical reactions are uncovering unique responses to toxicants. Modeling efforts in aquatic animals are evolving to interrelate the interacting networks of a system and the flow of information linking these elements. Just as is happening in medicine, systems biology approaches that allow the integration of many different scales of interaction and information are already driving a revolution in understanding the impacts of pollutants on aquatic systems.

The obesogen hypothesis: a shift of focus from the periphery to the hypothalamus

The obesogen concept proposes that environmental contaminants may be contributing to the epidemic of obesity and its related pathology, metabolic disorder. The first references to such a notion appeared at the beginning of the current decade, with the hypothesis that the correlation between increasing incidence of obesity and enhanced industrial chemical production was not simply coincidental, but potentially causally related. The next event was the introduction of the term "obesogen" as representing an environmental pollutant that adversely affects various aspects of adipose tissue functions. More recently, the concept was extended to include substances that may modify metabolic balance at the central, hypothalamic level. The actions of two prime candidate obesogens, tributyltin (TBT) and tetrabromobisphenol A (TBBPA), acting at the central level are the main focus of this review. Having discussed the evidence for contaminant accumulation in the environment and in human tissues and the potential mechanisms of action, data are provided showing that these two widespread pollutants modify hypothalamic gene regulations. Our studies are based on maternal exposure and measurement of effects in the progeny, mainly based on in vivo gene reporter assays. Such models are obviously pertinent to testing current hypotheses that propose that early exposure might exert effects on later development and physiological functions. The potential molecular mechanisms involved are discussed, as are the broader physiological consequences of these hypothalamic dysregulations.

Proteins in ecotoxicology - how, why and why not?

The growing interest in the application of proteomic technologies to solve toxicology issues and its relevance in ecotoxicology research has resulted in the emergence of "ecotoxicoproteomics". There is a general consensus that ecotoxicoproteomics is a powerful tool to spot early molecular events involved in toxicant responses, which are responsible for the adverse effects observed at higher levels of biological organization, thus contributing to elucidate the mode of action of stressors and to identify specific biomarkers. Ultimately, early-warning indicators can then be developed and deployed in "in situ" bioassays and in environmental risk assessment. The number of field experiments or laboratory trials using ecologically relevant test-species and involving proteomics has been, until recently, insufficient to allow a critical analysis of the real benefits of the application of this approach to ecotoxicology. This article intends to present an overview on the applications of proteomics in the context of ecotoxicology, focusing mainly on the prospective research to be done in invertebrates. Although these represent around 95% of all animal species and in spite of the key structural and functional roles they play in ecosystems, proteomic research in invertebrates is still in an incipient stage. We will review applications of ecotoxicoproteomics by evaluating the technical methods employed, the organisms and the contexts studied, the advances achieved until now and lastly the limitations yet to overcome will be discussed.

Incorporating zebrafish omics into chemical biology and toxicology

In this communication, we describe the general aspects of omics approaches for analyses of transcriptome, proteome, and metabolome, and how they can be strategically incorporated into chemical screening and perturbation studies using the zebrafish system. Pharmacological efficacy and selectivity of chemicals can be evaluated based on chemical-induced phenotypic effects; however, phenotypic observation has limitations in identifying mechanistic action of chemicals. We suggest adapting gene-expression-based high-throughput screening as a complementary strategy to zebrafish-phenotype-based screening for mechanistic insights about the mode of action and toxicity of a chemical, large-scale predictive applications and comparative analysis of chemical-induced omics signatures, which are useful to identify conserved biological responses, signaling pathways, and biomarkers. The potential mechanistic, predictive, and comparative applications of omics approaches can be implemented in the zebrafish system. Examples of these using the omics approaches in zebrafish, including data of ours and others, are presented and discussed. Omics also facilitates the translatability of zebrafish studies across species through comparison of conserved chemical-induced responses. This review is intended to update interested readers with the current omics approaches that have been applied in chemical studies on zebrafish and their potential in enhancing discovery in chemical biology.

Long-term warm or cold acclimation elicits a specific transcriptional response and affects energy metabolism in zebrafish

Organisms are often forced to acclimate to changing environmental temperature. Temperature compensation mechanisms have been reported, which enable organisms to minimize some of the temperature related effects. To investigate this process, zebrafish (Danio rerio) were acclimated to a control (26 degrees C), an increased (34 degrees C) or a decreased (18 degrees C) temperature for 4, 14 and 28 days. In general, warm acclimation depleted energy stores and decreased the condition factor, while cold acclimation increased both. The energy parameters as well as the transcriptional responses (investigated using printed 15k microarrays and real time PCR) indicated that warm acclimation was particularly stressful. However, after 28 days of warm acclimation, energy stores had recovered from the initial depletion. This could have been facilitated by the observed downregulation of transcripts involved in catabolic processes. Transcriptional regulation seemed to be an important means of coordinating the temperature compensation process. We could distinguish an early response which was independent of the direction of the temperature change and a direction specific long-term response. The early response was characterized by the upregulation of defence mechanisms, tissue regeneration and hemopoiesis. In the long-term response there was a strong emphasis on compensating for the altered metabolic rate as well as cell structure and replacement.

An integrated transcriptomic and proteomic approach characterizing estrogenic and metabolic effects of 17 alpha-ethinylestradiol in zebrafish (Danio rerio)

Nowadays there is much concern about the presence of endocrine disrupting compounds (EDCs) in the environment due to their ability to interfere with the endocrine system. In the presented study, adult zebrafish (Danio rerio) were exposed to 30 ng L(-1) 17alpha-ethinylestradiol (EE2) for 4 and 28 days. The underlying molecular mechanisms of EE2 were studied in the zebrafish liver by applying a combined transcriptomics and proteomics approach. In addition, we assessed the added value of such an integrated-omics approach. Oligo microarrays, spotted with 3479 zebrafish-specific oligos, were employed to generate differential gene expression levels. The proteomic responses were evaluated by means of differential in-gel electrophoresis (DiGE), combined with MALDI-tandem mass spectrometry. Assessment of the major biological functions of the differentially expressed transcripts and proteins illustrated that both individual platforms could profile a clear estrogenic interference, next to numerous metabolism-related effects and stress responses. Cross-comparison of both transcriptomics and proteomics datasets displayed limited concordance, though, thorough revision of the results illustrated that transcriptional effects were projected on protein level as downstream effects of affected signalling pathways. Overall, this study demonstrated that a proteomics approach can lift the biological interpretation of microarrays to a higher level, and moreover, opens a window for identification of possible new biomarkers.

Novel methodologies in marine fish larval nutrition

Major gaps in knowledge on fish larval nutritional requirements still remain. Small larval size, and difficulties in acceptance of inert microdiets, makes progress slow and cumbersome. This lack of knowledge in fish larval nutritional requirements is one of the causes of high mortalities and quality problems commonly observed in marine larviculture. In recent years, several novel methodologies have contributed to significant progress in fish larval nutrition. Others are emerging and are likely to bring further insight into larval nutritional physiology and requirements. This paper reviews a range of new tools and some examples of their present use, as well as potential future applications in the study of fish larvae nutrition. Tube-feeding and incorporation into Artemia of (14)C-amino acids and lipids allowed studying Artemia intake, digestion and absorption and utilisation of these nutrients. Diet selection by fish larvae has been studied with diets containing different natural stable isotope signatures or diets where different rare metal oxides were added. Mechanistic modelling has been used as a tool to integrate existing knowledge and reveal gaps, and also to better understand results obtained in tracer studies. Population genomics may assist in assessing genotype effects on nutritional requirements, by using progeny testing in fish reared in the same tanks, and also in identifying QTLs for larval stages. Functional genomics and proteomics enable the study of gene and protein expression under various dietary conditions, and thereby identify the metabolic pathways which are affected by a given nutrient. Promising results were obtained using the metabolic programming concept in early life to facilitate utilisation of certain nutrients at later stages. All together, these methodologies have made decisive contributions, and are expected to do even more in the near future, to build a knowledge basis for development of optimised diets and feeding regimes for different species of larval fish.

Histopathological and proteomic analysis of hepatic tissue from adult male zebrafish exposed to 17β-estradiol

17β-Estradiol (E2) is known to contribute significantly a large extent to the estrogenicity in aquatic system. In the present study, two-dimensional gel electrophoresis (2-DE) and mass spectrometry (MALDI-TOF-TOF MS), combined with histopathological analysis, was used to screen hepatic responses in adult male zebrafish. Eight proteins were found to be up-regulated more than 2-fold, whereas five protein spots were down-regulated more than 2-fold after 1nM E2 treatment for 14 days, which had caused histological effects in zebrafish livers. These differentially expressed proteins accounted for a variety of cellular biological processes, such as response to oxidative stress, cell surface receptor-linked signal transduction, oxidation-reduction and cellular calcium ion homeostasis. The results demonstrated that E2 comprehensively influenced a variety of cellular and biological processes in zebrafish. Moreover, the proteomic responses elicited in zebrafish allow us to better understand the underlying mechanisms of endocrine-disrupting chemicals (EDCs)-induced toxicity fully.

Towards functional genomics in fish using quantitative proteomics

Microarray and gene expression analysis have been key in our understanding of molecular pathways underlying physiological responses. Arguably, a large number of microarray based studies in fish have examined steroid nuclear receptor signaling (e.g., estrogens, androgens) in the context of both physiology and toxicology. Following close behind the advances in gene expression analysis, novel proteomic tools are available that have been under utilized in fish endocrinology studies. Quantitative proteomic approaches include both gel based (e.g., 2D gel electrophoresis, 2-D Fluorescence Difference Gel Electrophoresis; DIGE) and non-gel based methods that can be separated further into labeling approaches such as stable isotope labeling (SILAC), isotope coded affinity tags (ICAT), and isobaric tagging (iTRAQ) and label-free approaches (e.g., spectral counting and absolute quantitation). This review summarizes quantitative proteomic approaches and describes a successful application of iTRAQ) to study changes in the liver proteome in fathead minnows in response to the androgen, 17beta-trenbolone. The challenge remains to integrate molecular datasets in such a manner as to be able to consider temporal effects and complex regulation at the level of the genome and proteome.

Proteomic studies in zebrafish liver cells exposed to the brominated flame retardants HBCD and TBBPA

Proteomic effect screening in zebrafish liver cells was performed to generate hypotheses regarding single and mixed exposure to the BFRs HBCD and TBBPA. Responses at sublethal exposure were analysed by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis followed by MALDI-TOF and FT-ICR protein identification. Mixing of HBCD and TBBPA at sublethal doses of individual substances seemed to increase toxicity. Proteomic analyses revealed distinct exposure-specific and overlapping responses suggesting novel mechanisms with regard to HBCD and TBBPA exposure. While distinct HBCD responses were related to decreased protein metabolism, TBBPA revealed effects related to protein folding and NADPH production. Overlapping responses suggest increased gluconeogenesis (GAPDH and aldolase) while distinct mixture effects suggest a pronounced NADPH production and changes in proteins related to cell cycle control (prohibitin and crk-like oncogene). We conclude that mixtures containing HBCD and TBBPA may result in unexpected effects highlighting proteomics as a sensitive tool for detecting and hypothesis generation of mixture effects.