ATP synthase: a tentative structural model

Inter-subunit rotation and elastic power transmission in F0F1-ATPase

ATP synthase (F-ATPase) produces ATP at the expense of ion-motive force or vice versa. It is composed from two motor/generators, the ATPase (F1) and the ion translocator (F0), which both are rotary steppers. They are mechanically coupled by 360 degrees rotary motion of subunits against each other. The rotor, subunits gamma(epsilon)C10-14, moves against the stator, (alphabeta)3delta(ab2). The enzyme copes with symmetry mismatch (C3 versus C10-14) between its two motors, and it operates robustly in chimeric constructs or with drastically modified subunits. We scrutinized whether an elastic power transmission accounts for these properties. We used the curvature of fluorescent actin filaments, attached to the rotating c ring, as a spring balance (flexural rigidity of 8.10(-26) N x m2) to gauge the angular profile of the output torque at F0 during ATP hydrolysis by F1. The large average output torque (56 pN nm) proved the absence of any slip. Angular variations of the torque were small, so that the output free energy of the loaded enzyme decayed almost linearly over the angular reaction coordinate. Considering the three-fold stepping and high activation barrier (>40 kJ/mol) of the driving motor (F1) itself, the rather constant output torque seen by F0 implied a soft elastic power transmission between F1 and F0. It is considered as essential, not only for the robust operation of this ubiquitous enzyme under symmetry mismatch, but also for a high turnover rate under load of the two counteracting and stepping motors/generators.

Structure of Ala(20) --> Pro/Pro(64) --> Ala substituted subunit c of Escherichia coli ATP synthase in which the essential proline is switched between transmembrane helices

The structure of the A20P/P64A mutated subunit c of Escherichia coli ATP synthase, in which the essential proline has been switched from residue 64 of the second transmembrane helix (TMH) to residue 20 of the first TMH, has been solved by (15)N,(1)H NMR in a monophasic chloroform/methanol/water (4:4:1) solvent mixture. The cA20P/P64A mutant grows as well as wild type, and the F(0)F(1) complex is fully functional in ATPase-coupled H(+) pumping. Residues 20 and 64 lie directly opposite to each other in the hairpin-like structure of wild type subunit c, and the prolinyl 64 residue is thought to induce a slight bend in TMH-2 such that it wraps around a more straightened TMH-1. In solution, the A20P/P64A substituted subunit c also forms a hairpin of two alpha-helices, with residues 41-45 forming a connecting loop as in the case of the wild type protein, but, in this case, Pro(20) induces a bend in TMH-1, which then packs against a more straightened TMH-2. The essential prolinyl residue, whether at position 64 or 20, lies close to the aspartyl 61 H(+) binding site. The prolinyl residue may introduce structural flexibility in this region of the protein, which may be necessary for the proposed movement of the alpha-helical segments during the course of the H(+) pumping catalytic cycle.

The rotor in the membrane of the ATP synthase and relatives

In recent years, structural information on the F(1) sector of the ATP synthase has provided an insight into the molecular mechanism of ATP catalysis. The structure strongly supports the proposal that the ATP synthase works as a rotary molecular motor. Insights into the membrane domain have just started to emerge but more detailed structural information is needed if the molecular mechanism of proton translocation coupled to ATP synthesis is to be understood. This review will focus mainly on the ion translocating rotor in the membrane domain of the F-type ATPase, and the related vacuolar and archaeal relatives.

Diabetes and nutrition: the mitochondrial part

Diabetes mellitus is the most common genetic disease in the Western world today. It is the phenotype for >150 genotypes. Each of these genotypes is characterized by impaired glucose tolerance and impaired control of intermediary metabolism. There are many strains of mice and rats that can be used to study diabetes in its various forms. One of these is the BHE/Cdb rat, which mimics the human phenotype with a mutation in the mitochondrial (mt) DNA. The result of such mutation is a loss in metabolic control with respect to the role of the mitochondria in this control. This review addresses those aspects of control that are exerted by mt oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS). Diet can have both genomic and nongenomic effects on OXPHOS. The type of dietary fat influences the fluidity of the mt membranes and hence, mt function. The dietary fat effect depends on the genetic background of the consumer. Diabetes-prone BHE/Cdb rats with base substitutions in the mt ATPase 6 gene are more likely to be influenced by the diet effect on mt membrane fluidity than are normal rats. Vitamin A also affects mt function through an effect on mt gene expression. BHE/Cdb rats have a greater need for vitamin A than normal rats and supplemental vitamin A appears to influence OXPHOS.

Insights into the rotary catalytic mechanism of F0F1 ATP synthase from the cross-linking of subunits b and c in the Escherichia coli enzyme

The transmembrane sector of the F(0)F(1) rotary ATP synthase is proposed to organize with an oligomeric ring of c subunits, which function as a rotor, interacting with two b subunits at the periphery of the ring, the b subunits functioning as a stator. In this study, cysteines were introduced into the C-terminal region of subunit c and the N-terminal region of subunit b. Cys of N2C subunit b was cross-linked with Cys at positions 74, 75, and 78 of subunit c. In each case, a maximum of 50% of the b subunit could be cross-linked to subunit c, which suggests that either only one of the two b subunits lie adjacent to the c-ring or that both b subunits interact with a single subunit c. The results support a topological arrangement of these subunits, in which the respective N- and C-terminal ends of subunits b and c extend to the periplasmic surface of the membrane and cAsp-61 lies at the center of the membrane. The cross-linking of Cys between bN2C and cV78C was shown to inhibit ATP-driven proton pumping, as would be predicted from a rotary model for ATP synthase function, but unexpectedly, cross-linking did not lead to inhibition of ATPase activity. ATP hydrolysis and proton pumping are therefore uncoupled in the cross-linked enzyme. The c subunit lying adjacent to subunit b was shown to be mobile and to exchange with c subunits that initially occupied non-neighboring positions. The movement or exchange of subunits at the position adjacent to subunit b was blocked by dicyclohexylcarbodiimide. These experiments provide a biochemical verification that the oligomeric c-ring can move with respect to the b-stator and provide further support for a rotary catalytic mechanism in the ATP synthase.

Artificial Molecular Machines

The miniaturization of components used in the construction of working devices is being pursued currently by the large-downward (top-down) fabrication. This approach, however, which obliges solid-state physicists and electronic engineers to manipulate progressively smaller and smaller pieces of matter, has its intrinsic limitations. An alternative approach is a small-upward (bottom-up) one, starting from the smallest compositions of matter that have distinct shapes and unique properties-namely molecules. In the context of this particular challenge, chemists have been extending the concept of a macroscopic machine to the molecular level. A molecular-level machine can be defined as an assembly of a distinct number of molecular components that are designed to perform machinelike movements (output) as a result of an appropriate external stimulation (input). In common with their macroscopic counterparts, a molecular machine is characterized by 1) the kind of energy input supplied to make it work, 2) the nature of the movements of its component parts, 3) the way in which its operation can be monitored and controlled, 4) the ability to make it repeat its operation in a cyclic fashion, 5) the timescale needed to complete a full cycle of movements, and 6) the purpose of its operation. Undoubtedly, the best energy inputs to make molecular machines work are photons or electrons. Indeed, with appropriately chosen photochemically and electrochemically driven reactions, it is possible to design and synthesize molecular machines that do work. Moreover, the dramatic increase in our fundamental understanding of self-assembly and self-organizational processes in chemical synthesis has aided and abetted the construction of artificial molecular machines through the development of new methods of noncovalent synthesis and the emergence of supramolecular assistance to covalent synthesis as a uniquely powerful synthetic tool. The aim of this review is to present a unified view of the field of molecular machines by focusing on past achievements, present limitations, and future perspectives. After analyzing a few important examples of natural molecular machines, the most significant developments in the field of artificial molecular machines are highlighted. The systems reviewed include 1) chemical rotors, 2) photochemically and electrochemically induced molecular (conformational) rearrangements, and 3) chemically, photochemically, and electrochemically controllable (co-conformational) motions in interlocked molecules (catenanes and rotaxanes), as well as in coordination and supramolecular complexes, including pseudorotaxanes. Artificial molecular machines based on biomolecules and interfacing artificial molecular machines with surfaces and solid supports are amongst some of the cutting-edge topics featured in this review. The extension of the concept of a machine to the molecular level is of interest not only for the sake of basic research, but also for the growth of nanoscience and the subsequent development of nanotechnology.

A re-examination of the structural and functional consequences of mutation of alanine-128 of the b subunit of Escherichia coli ATP synthase to aspartic acid

The effects of mutation of residue Ala-128 of the b subunit of Escherichia coli ATP synthase to aspartate on the structure of the subunit and its interaction with the F(1) sector were analyzed. Determination of solution molecular weights by sedimentation equilibrium ultracentrifugation revealed that the A128D mutation had little effect on dimerization in the soluble b construct, b(34-156). However, the mutation caused a structural perturbation detected through both a 12% reduction in the sedimentation coefficient and also a reduced tendency to form intersubunit disulfide bonds between cysteine residues inserted at position 132. Unlike the wild-type sequence, the A128D mutant was unable to interact with F(1)-ATPase. These results indicate that the A128D mutation caused a structural change in the C-terminal region of the protein, preventing the binding to F(1) but having little or no effect on the dimeric nature of b.

The structural and functional connection between the catalytic and proton translocating sectors of the mitochondrial F1F0-ATP synthase

The structural and functional connection between the peripheral catalytic F1 sector and the proton-translocating membrane sector F0 of the mitochondrial ATP synthase is reviewed. The observations examined show that the N-terminus of subunit gamma, the carboxy-terminal and central region of F0I-PVP(b), OSCP, and part of subunit d constitute a continuous structure, the lateral stalk, which connects the peripheries of F1 to F0 and surrounds the central element of the stalk, constituted by subunits gamma and delta. The ATPase inhibitor protein (IF1) binds at one side of the F1F0 connection. The carboxy-terminal segment of IF1 apparently binds to OSCP. The 42L-58K segment of IF1, which is per se the most active domain of the protein, binds at the surface of one of the three alpha/beta pairs of F1, thus preventing the cyclic interconversion of the catalytic sites required for ATP hydrolysis.

F1 and F0 connections in the bovine mitochondrial ATP synthase: the role of the of alpha subunit N-terminus, oligomycin-sensitivity conferring protein (OCSP) and subunit d

We have studied the functional effect of limited proteolysis by trypsin of the constituent subunits in the native and reconstituted F1F0 complex and isolated F1 of the bovine heart mitochondrial ATP synthase (EC 3.6.1.34). Chemical cross-linking of oligomycin-sensitivity conferring protein (OSCP) with other subunits of the ATP synthase and the consequent functional effects were also investigated. The results obtained show that the alpha subunit N-terminus is essential for the correct, functional connection of F1 to F0. The alpha-subunit N-terminus contacts OSCP which, in turn, contacts the F0I-PVP(b) and the F0-d subunits. The N-terminus of subunit alpha, OSCP, a segment of subunit d and the C-terminal and central region of F0I-PVP(b) subunits are peripherally located with respect to subunits gamma and delta which are completely shielded in the F1F0 complex against trypsin digestion. This qualifies the N-terminus of subunit alpha, OSCP, subunit d and F0I-PVP(b) as components of the lateral element of the stalk. These subunits, rather than being confined at one side of the complex which would leave most of the central part of the gamma subunit uncovered, surround the gamma and the delta subunits located in the central stalk.

The mechanochemistry of V-ATPase proton pumps

The vacuolar H(+)-ATPases (V-ATPases) are a universal class of proton pumps that are structurally similar to the F-ATPases. Both protein families are characterized by a membrane-bound segment (V(o), F(o)) responsible for the translocation of protons, and a soluble portion, (V(1), F(1)), which supplies the energy for translocation by hydrolyzing ATP. Here we present a mechanochemical model for the functioning of the V(o) ion pump that is consistent with the known structural features and biochemistry. The model reproduces a variety of experimental measurements of performance and provides a unified view of the many mechanisms of intracellular pH regulation.

A model for the structure of subunit a of the Escherichia coli ATP synthase and its role in proton translocation

Most of what is known about the structure and function of subunit a, of the ATP synthase, has come from the construction and isolation of mutations, and their analysis in the context of the ATP synthase complex. Three classes of mutants will be considered in this review. (1) Cys substitutions have been used for structural analysis of subunit a, and its interactions with subunit c. (2) Functional residues have been identified by extensive mutagenesis. These studies have included the identification of second-site suppressors within subunit a. (3) Disruptive mutations include deletions at both termini, internal deletions, and single amino acid insertions. The results of these studies, in conjunction with information about subunits b and c, can be incorporated into a model for the mechanism of proton translocation in the Escherichia coli ATP synthase.

The ATP synthase of Escherichia coli: structure and function of F(0) subunits

In this review we discuss recent work from our laboratory concerning the structure and/or function of the F(0) subunits of the proton-translocating ATP synthase of Escherichia coli. For the topology of subunit a a brief discussion gives (i) a detailed picture of the C-terminal two-thirds of the protein with four transmembrane helices and the C terminus exposed to the cytoplasm and (ii) an evaluation of the controversial results obtained for the localization of the N-terminal region of subunit a including its consequences on the number of transmembrane helices. The structure of membrane-bound subunit b has been determined by circular dichroism spectroscopy to be at least 75% alpha-helical. For this purpose a method was developed, which allows the determination of the structure composition of membrane proteins in proteoliposomes. Subunit b was purified to homogeneity by preparative SDS gel electrophoresis, precipitated with acetone, and redissolved in cholate-containing buffer, thereby retaining its native conformation as shown by functional coreconstitution with an ac subcomplex. Monoclonal antibodies, which have their epitopes located within the hydrophilic loop region of subunit c, and the F(1) part are bound simultaneously to the F(0) complex without an effect on the function of F(0), indicating that not all c subunits are involved in F(1) interaction. Consequences on the coupling mechanism between ATP synthesis/hydrolysis and proton translocation are discussed.

The epsilon subunit of bacterial and chloroplast F(1)F(0) ATPases. Structure, arrangement, and role of the epsilon subunit in energy coupling within the complex

Recent studies show that the epsilon subunit of bacterial and chloroplast F(1)F(0) ATPases is a component of the central stalk that links the F(1) and F(0) parts. This subunit interacts with alpha, beta and gamma subunits of F(1) and the c subunit ring of F(0). Along with the gamma subunit, epsilon is a part of the rotor that couples events at the three catalytic sites sequentially with proton translocation through the F(0) part. Structural data on the epsilon subunit when separated from the complex and in situ are reviewed, and the functioning of this polypeptide in coupling within the ATP synthase is considered.

Insights into ATP synthase assembly and function through the molecular genetic manipulation of subunits of the yeast mitochondrial enzyme complex

Development of an increasingly detailed understanding of the eucaryotic mitochondrial ATP synthase requires a detailed knowledge of the stoichiometry, structure and function of F(0) sector subunits in the contexts of the proton channel and the stator stalk. Still to be resolved are the precise locations and roles of other supernumerary subunits present in mitochondrial ATP synthase complexes, but not found in the bacterial or chloroplast enzymes. The highly developed system of molecular genetic manipulation available in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, a unicellular eucaryote, permits testing for gene function based on the effects of gene disruption or deletion. In addition, the genes encoding ATP synthase subunits can be manipulated to introduce specific amino acids at desired positions within a subunit, or to add epitope or affinity tags at the C-terminus, enabling questions of stoichiometry, structure and function to be addressed. Newly emerging technologies, such as fusions of subunits with GFP are being applied to probe the dynamic interactions within mitochondrial ATP synthase, between ATP synthase complexes, and between ATP synthase and other mitochondrial enzyme complexes.

Structural interpretations of F(0) rotary function in the Escherichia coli F(1)F(0) ATP synthase

F(1)F(0) ATP synthases are known to synthesize ATP by rotary catalysis in the F(1) sector of the enzyme. Proton translocation through the F(0) membrane sector is now proposed to drive rotation of an oligomer of c subunits, which in turn drives rotation of subunit gamma in F(1). The primary emphasis of this review will be on recent work from our laboratory on the structural organization of F(0), which proves to be consistent with the concept of a c(12) oligomeric rotor. From the NMR structure of subunit c and cross-linking studies, we can now suggest a detailed model for the organization of the c(12) oligomer in F(0) and some of the transmembrane interactions with subunits a and b. The structural model indicates that the H(+)-carrying carboxyl of subunit c is located between subunits of the c(12) oligomer and that two c subunits pack in a front-to-back manner to form the proton (cation) binding site. The proton carrying Asp61 side chain is occluded between subunits and access to it, for protonation and deprotonation via alternate entrance and exit half-channels, requires a swiveled opening of the packed c subunits and stepwise association with different transmembrane helices of subunit a. We suggest how some of the structural information can be incorporated into models of rotary movement of the c(12) oligomer during coupled synthesis of ATP in the F(1) portion of the molecule.

The structure of the H(+)-ATP synthase from chloroplasts and its subcomplexes as revealed by electron microscopy

The electron microscopic data available on CF(0)F(1) and its subcomplexes, CF(0), CF(1), subunit III complex are collected and the CF(1) data are compared with the high resolution structure of MF(1). The data are based on electron microscopic investigation of negatively stained isolated CF(1), CF(0)F(1) and subunit III complex. In addition, two-dimensional crystals of CF(0)F(1) and CF(0)F(1) reconstituted liposomes were investigated by cryo-electron microscopy. Progress in the interpretation of electron microscopic data from biological samples has been made with the introduction of image analysis. Multi-reference alignment and classification of images have led to the differentiation between different conformational states and to the detection of a second stalk. Recently, the calculation of three-dimensional maps from the class averages led to the understanding of the spatial organisation of the enzyme. Such three-dimensional maps give evidence of the existence of a third connection between the F(0) part and F(1) part.

Mechanism of activation of the chloroplast ATP synthase. A kinetic study of the thiol modulation of isolated ATPase and membrane-bound ATP synthase from spinach by Eschericia coli thioredoxin

The mechanism of thiol modulation of the chloroplast ATP synthase by Escherichia coli thioredoxin was investigated in the isolated ATPase subcomplex and in the ATP synthase complex reconstituted in bacteriorhodopsin proteoliposomes. Thiol modulation was resolved kinetically by continuously monitoring ATP hydrolysis by the isolated subcomplex and ATP synthesis by proteoliposomes. The binding rate constant of reduced thioredoxin to the oxidized ATPase subcomplex devoid of its epsilon subunit could be determined. It did not depend on the catalytic turnover. Reciprocically, the catalytic turnover did not seem to depend on thioredoxin binding. Thiol modulation by Trx of the epsilon-bearing ATPase subcomplex was slow and favored the release of epsilon. The rate constant of thioredoxin binding to the membrane-bound ATP synthase increased with the protonmotive force. It was lower in the presence of ADP than in its absence, revealing a specific effect of the ATP synthase turnover on thioredoxin-gamma subunit interaction. These findings, and more especially the comparisons between the isolated ATPase subcomplex and the ATP synthase complex, can be interpreted in the frame of the rotational catalysis hypothesis. Finally, thiol modulation changed the catalytic properties of the ATP synthase, the kinetics of which became non-Michaelian. This questions the common view about the nature of changes induced by ATP synthase thiol modulation.

Theories of rotary motors

The bacterial flagellar motor and the ATP-hydrolysing F1 portion of the F1Fo-ATPase are known to be rotary motors, and it seems highly probable that the H+-translocating Fo portion rotates too. The energy source in the case of Fo and the flagellar motor is the flow of ions, either H+ (protons) or Na+, down an electrochemical gradient across a membrane. The fact that ions flow in a particular direction through a well-defined structure in these motors invites the possibility of a type of mechanism based on geometric constraints between the rotor position and the paths of ions flowing through the motor. The two best-studied examples of such a mechanism are the 'turnstile' model of Khan and Berg and the 'proton turbine' model of Läuger or Berry. Models such as these are typically represented by a small number of kinetic states and certain allowed transitions between them. This allows the calculation of predictions of motor behaviour and establishes a dialogue between models and experimental results. In the near future structural data and observations of single-molecule events should help to determine the nature of the mechanism of rotary motors, while motor models must be developed that can adequately explain the measured relationships between torque and speed in the flagellar motor.

F-ATPase: specific observation of the rotating c subunit oligomer of EF(o)EF(1)

The rotary motion in response to ATP hydrolysis of the ring of c subunits of the membrane portion, F(o), of ATP synthase, F(o)F(1), is still under contention. It was studied with EF(o)EF(1) (Escherichia coli) using microvideography with a fluorescent actin filament. To overcome the limited specificity of actin attachment through a Cys-maleimide couple which might have hampered the interpretation of previous work, we engineered a 'strep-tag' sequence into the C-terminal end of subunit c. It served (a) to purify the holoenzyme and (b) to monospecifically attach a fluorescent actin filament to subunit c. EF(o)EF(1) was immobilized on a Ni-NTA-coated glass slide by the engineered His-tag at the N-terminus of subunit beta. In the presence of MgATP we observed up to five counterclockwise rotating actin filaments per picture frame of 2000 microm(2) size, in some cases yielding a proportion of 5% rotating over total filaments. The rotation was unequivocally attributable to the ring of subunit c. The new, doubly engineered construct serves as a firmer basis for ongoing studies on torque and angular elastic distortions between F(1) and F(o).

Structure, functioning, and assembly of the ATP synthase in cells from patients with the T8993G mitochondrial DNA mutation. Comparison with the enzyme in Rho(0) cells completely lacking mtdna

The structure and functioning of the ATP synthase of human fibroblast cell lines with 91 and 100%, respectively, of the T8993G mutation have been studied, with MRC5 human fibroblasts and Rho(0) cells derived from this cell line as controls. ATP hydrolysis was normal but ATP synthesis was reduced by 60% in the 100% mutants. Both activities were highly oligomycin-sensitive. The levels of F(1)F(0) were close to normal, and the enzyme was stable. It is concluded that the loss of ATP synthesis is because of disruption of the proton translocation step within the F(0) part. This is supported by membrane potential measurements using the dye JC-1. Cells with a 91% mutation load grew well and showed only a 25% loss in ATP synthesis. This much reduced effect for only a 9% difference in mutation load mirrors the reduced pathogenicity in patients. F(1)F(0) has been purified for the first time from human cell lines. A partial complex was obtained from Rho(0) cells containing the F(1) subunits associated with several stalk, as well as F(0) subunits, including oligomycin sensitivity conferring protein, b, and c subunits. This partial complex no longer binds inhibitor protein.

Mutations in single hairpin units of genetically fused subunit c provide support for a rotary catalytic mechanism in F(0)F(1) ATP synthase

Previously, we generated genetically fused dimers and trimers of subunit c of the Escherichia coli ATP synthase based upon the precedent of naturally occurring dimers in V-type H(+)-transporting ATPases. The c(2) and c(3) oligomers have proven useful in testing hypothesis regarding the mechanism of energy coupling. In the first part of this paper, the uncoupling Q42E substitution has been introduced into the second loop of the c(2) dimer or the third loop of the c(3) trimer. Both mutant proteins proved to be as functional as the wild type c(2) dimer or wild type c(3) trimer. The results argue against an obligatory movement of the epsilon subunit between loops of monomeric subunit c in the c(12) oligomer during rotary catalysis. Rather, the results support the hypothesis that the c-epsilon connection remains fixed as the c-oligomer rotates. In the second section of this paper, we report on the effect of substitution of the proton translocating Asp(61) in every second helical hairpin of the c(2) dimer, or in every third hairpin of the c(3) trimer. Based upon the precedent of V-type ATPases, where the c(2) dimer occurs naturally with a single proton translocating carboxyl in every second hairpin, these modified versions of the E. coli c(2) and c(3) fused proteins were predicted to have a functional H(+)-transporting ATPase activity, with a reduced H(+)/ATP stoichiometry, but to be inactive as ATP synthases. A variety of Asp(61)-substituted proteins proved to lack either activity indicating that the switch in function in V-type ATPases is a consequence of more than a single substitution.

Direct visualisation of conformational changes in EF(0)F(1) by electron microscopy

The isolated H(+)-ATPase from Escherichia coli (EF(0)F(1)) was investigated by electron microscopy of samples of negatively stained monodisperse molecules, followed by single-particle image processing. The resulting three-dimensional maps showed that the F(1)-part is connected by a prominent stalk to a more peripheral part of F(0). The F(1)-part showed stain-accessible cavities inside. In three-dimensional maps from selected particles, a second stalk could be detected which was thinner than the main stalk and is thought to correspond to the stator.Three-dimensional maps of the enzyme in the absence and in the presence of the substrate analogue adenyl-beta, gamma-imidodiphosphate (AMP-PNP) were calculated. Upon binding of AMP-PNP the three-dimensional maps showed no significant changes in the F(0)-part of EF(0)F(1), whereas a major conformational change in the F(1)-part was observed. (1) The diameter of the F(1)-part decreased upon binding of AMP-PNP mainly in the upper half of F(1). (2) Enzyme particles prepared in the presence of AMP-PNP had a pointed cap at the top of the F(1)-part which was missing in its absence. (3) The stain-accessible cavity inside the F(1)-part altered its pattern significantly.

Disulfide cross-linking of subunits F(1)-gamma and F(0)I-PVP(b) results in asymmetric effects on proton translocation in the mitochondrial ATP synthase

A study is presented on the effect of diamide-induced disulfide cross-linking of F(1)-gamma and F(0)I-PVP(b) subunits on proton translocation in the mitochondrial ATP synthase. The results show that, upon cross-linking of these subunits, whilst proton translocation from the A side to the B F(1) side is markedly accelerated with decoupling of oxidative phosphorylation, proton translocation in the reverse direction, driven by either ATP hydrolysis or a diffusion potential, is unaffected. These observations reveal further peculiarities of the mechanism of energy transfer in the ATP synthase of coupling membranes.

Molecular architecture of the rotary motor in ATP synthase

Adenosine triphosphate (ATP) synthase contains a rotary motor involved in biological energy conversion. Its membrane-embedded F0 sector has a rotation generator fueled by the proton-motive force, which provides the energy required for the synthesis of ATP by the F1 domain. An electron density map obtained from crystals of a subcomplex of yeast mitochondrial ATP synthase shows a ring of 10 c subunits. Each c subunit forms an alpha-helical hairpin. The interhelical loops of six to seven of the c subunits are in close contact with the gamma and delta subunits of the central stalk. The extensive contact between the c ring and the stalk suggests that they may rotate as an ensemble during catalysis.

The dimerization domain of the b subunit of the Escherichia coli F(1)F(0)-ATPase

In this study a series of N- and/or C-terminal truncations of the cytoplasmic domain of the b subunit of the Escherichia coli F(1)F(0) ATP synthase were tested for their ability to form dimers using sedimentation equilibrium ultracentrifugation. The deletion of residues between positions 53 and 122 resulted in a strongly decreased tendency to form dimers, whereas all the polypeptides that included that sequence exhibited high levels of dimer formation. b dimers existed in a reversible monomer-dimer equilibrium and when mixed with other b truncations formed heterodimers efficiently, provided both constructs included the 53-122 sequence. Sedimentation velocity and (15)N NMR relaxation measurements indicated that the dimerization region is highly extended in solution, consistent with an elongated second stalk structure. A cysteine introduced at position 105 was found to readily form intersubunit disulfides, whereas other single cysteines at positions 103-110 failed to form disulfides either with the identical mutant or when mixed with the other 103-110 cysteine mutants. These studies establish that the b subunit dimer depends on interactions that occur between residues in the 53-122 sequence and that the two subunits are oriented in a highly specific manner at the dimer interface.

On the stator of rotary ATP synthase: the binding strength of subunit delta to (alpha beta)3 as determined by fluorescence correlation spectroscopy

ATP synthase is conceived as a rotary enzyme. Proton flow drives the rotor (namely, subunits c12 epsilon gamma) relative to the stator (namely, subunits ab2 delta(alpha beta)3) and extrudes spontaneously formed ATP from three symmetrically arranged binding sites on (alpha beta)3 into the solution. We asked whether the binding of subunit delta to (alpha beta)3 is of sufficient strength to hold against the elastic strain, which is generated during the operation of this enzyme. According to current estimates, the elastically stored energy is about 50 kJ/mol. Subunit delta was specifically labeled without impairing its function. Its association with solubilized (alpha beta)3 gamma in detergent-free buffer was studied by fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS). A very strong tendency of delta to dimerize in detergent-free buffer was apparent (K(d) </= 0.2 nM). Taking the upper limit of this figure into account, the dissociation constant between monomeric delta and (alpha beta)3 gamma was 0.8 nM if not smaller. It is equivalent to a free energy of binding of at least 52 kJ/mol and therewith is sufficient for the assumed hold-function of delta in the stator. Our data were compatible with a single binding site for delta on the hexagon of (alpha beta)3.

F0 complex of the Escherichia coli ATP synthase. Not all monomers of the subunit c oligomer are involved in F1 interaction

The antigenic determinants of mAbs against subunit c of the Escherichia coli ATP synthase were mapped by ELISA using overlapping synthetic heptapeptides. All epitopes recognized are located in the hydrophilic loop region and are as follows: 31-LGGKFLE-37, 35-FLEGAAR-41, 36-LEGAAR-41 and 36-LEGAARQ-42. Binding studies with membrane vesicles of different orientation revealed that all mAbs bind to everted membrane vesicles independent of the presence or absence of the F1 part. Although the hydrophilic region of subunit c and particularly the highly conserved residues A40, R41, Q42 and P43 are known to interact with subunits gamma and epsilon of the F1 part, the mAb molecules have no effect on the function of F0. Furthermore, it could be demonstrated that the F1 part and the mAb molecule(s) are bound simultaneously to the F0 complex suggesting that not all c subunits are involved in F1 interaction. From the results obtained, it can be concluded that this interaction is fixed, which means that subunits gamma and epsilon do not switch between the c subunits during catalysis and furthermore, a complete rotation of the subunit c oligomer modified with mAb(s) along the stator of the F1F0 complex, proposed to be composed of at least subunits b and delta, seems to be unlikely.

Structure of the subunit c oligomer in the F1Fo ATP synthase: model derived from solution structure of the monomer and cross-linking in the native enzyme

The structure of the subunit c oligomer of the H+-transporting ATP synthase of Escherichia coli has been modeled by molecular dynamics and energy minimization calculations from the solution structure of monomeric subunit c and 21 intersubunit distance constraints derived from cross-linking of subunits. Subunit c folds in a hairpin-like structure with two transmembrane helices. In the c12 oligomer model, the subunits pack to form a compact hollow cylinder with an outer diameter of 55-60 A and an inner space with a minimal diameter of 11-12 A. Phospholipids are presumed to pack in the inner space in the native membrane. The transmembrane helices pack in two concentric rings with helix 1 inside and helix 2 outside. The calculations strongly favor this structure versus a model with helix 2 inside and helix 1 outside. Asp-61, the H+-transporting residue, packs toward the center of the four transmembrane helices of two interacting subunits. From this position at the front face of one subunit, the Asp-61 carboxylate lies proximal to side chains of Ala-24, Ile-28, and Ala-62, projecting from the back face of a second subunit. These interactions were predicted from previous mutational analyses. The packing supports the suggestion that a c-c dimer is the functional unit. The positioning of the Asp-61 carboxyl in the center of the interacting transmembrane helices, rather than at the periphery of the cylinder, has important implications regarding possible mechanisms of H+-transport-driven rotation of the c oligomer during ATP synthesis.

Kinetic modeling of rotary CF0F1-ATP synthase: storage of elastic energy during energy transduction

F0F1-ATP synthase uses proton-motive force to produce ATP from ADP and Pi. With regard to its rotary mechanics, this energy transducing molecular machine assumes a unique position among all enzymes. In the work presented here we put forward a detailed functional model which is based on experimental results obtained with ATP synthase from spinach chloroplasts. We focus on the role of the elastic element, realized by the stalk-like subunit gamma, whose function is energy transduction between F0 and F1 taking into account the H+/ATP coupling ratio of four. Fitting parameters are the rate constants and the torsional rigidity of gamma, which have been adjusted according to the experimental results where the influence of transmembrane DeltapH on the rates of ATP synthesis/hydrolysis is put to the test. We show that the input and output of torsional energy are regulated by purely statistical principles, giving rise to the amount of transiently stored energy to be sliding, depending on DeltapH. During conditions of maximal turnover gamma turns out to be wound up towards 102 degrees which corresponds to a torque of 5.3. 10-20 N.m.

Defining the domain of binding of F1 subunit epsilon with the polar loop of F0 subunit c in the Escherichia coli ATP synthase

We have previously shown that the E31C-substituted epsilon subunit of F1 can be cross-linked by disulfide bond formation to the Q42C-substituted c subunit of F0 in the Escherichia coli F1F0-ATP synthase complex (Zhang, Y., and Fillingame, R. H. (1995) J. Biol. Chem. 270, 24609-24614). The interactions of subunits epsilon and c are thought to be central to the coupling of H+ transport through F0 to ATP synthesis in F1. To further define the domains of interaction, we have introduced additional Cys into subunit epsilon and subunit c and tested for cross-link formation following sulfhydryl oxidation. The results show that Cys, in a continuous stretch of residues 26-33 in subunit epsilon, can be cross-linked to Cys at positions 40, 42, and 44 in the polar loop region of subunit c. The results are interpreted, and the subunit interaction is modeled using the NMR and x-ray diffraction structures of the monomeric subunits together with information on the packing arrangement of subunit c in a ring of 12 subunits. In the model, residues 26-33 form a turn of antiparallel beta-sheet which packs between the polar loop regions of adjacent subunit c at the cytoplasmic surface of the c12 oligomer.

Structure of the membrane domain of subunit b of the Escherichia coli F0F1 ATP synthase

The structure of the N-terminal transmembrane domain (residues 1-34) of subunit b of the Escherichia coli F0F1-ATP synthase has been solved by two-dimensional 1H NMR in a membrane mimetic solvent mixture of chloroform/methanol/H2O (4:4:1). Residues 4-22 form an alpha-helix, which is likely to span the hydrophobic domain of the lipid bilayer to anchor the largely hydrophilic subunit b in the membrane. The helical structure is interrupted by a rigid bend in the region of residues 23-26 with alpha-helical structure resuming at Pro-27 at an angle offset by 20 degrees from the transmembrane helix. In native subunit b, the hinge region and C-terminal alpha-helical segment would connect the transmembrane helix to the cytoplasmic domain. The transmembrane domains of the two subunit b in F0 were shown to be close to each other by cross-linking experiments in which single Cys were substituted for residues 2-21 of the native subunit and b-b dimer formation tested after oxidation with Cu(II)(phenanthroline)2. Cys residues that formed disulfide cross-links were found with a periodicity indicative of one face of an alpha-helix, over the span of residues 2-18, where Cys at positions 2, 6, and 10 formed dimers in highest yield. A model for the dimer is presented based upon the NMR structure and distance constraints from the cross-linking data. The transmembrane alpha-helices are positioned at a 23 degrees angle to each other with the side chains of Thr-6, Gln-10, Phe-14, and Phe-17 at the interface between subunits. The change in direction of helical packing at the hinge region may be important in the functional interaction of the cytoplasmic domains.

Transient accumulation of elastic energy in proton translocating ATP synthase

ATP synthase is conceived as a rotatory engine with two reversible drives, the proton-transporting membrane portion, F0, and the catalytic peripheral portion, F1. They are mounted on a central shaft (subunit gamma) and held together by an eccentric bearing. It is established that the hydrolysis of three molecules of ATP in F1 drives the shaft over a full circle in three steps of 120 degrees each. Proton flow through F0 probably generates a 12-stepped rotation of the shaft so that four proton-translocating steps of 30 degrees each drive the synthesis of one molecule of ATP. We addressed the elasticity of the transmission between F0 and F1 in a model where the four smaller steps in F0 load a torsional spring which is only released under liberation of ATP from F1. The kinetic model of an elastic ATP synthase described a wealth of published data on the synthesis/hydrolysis of ATP by F0F1 and on proton conduction by F0 as function of the pH and the protonmotive force. The pK values of the proton-carrying group interacting with the acidic and basic sides of the membrane were estimated as 5.3-6.4 and 8.0-8.3, respectively.

ATP synthase: two motors, two fuels

FoF1 ATPase is the universal protein responsible for ATP synthesis. The enzyme comprises two reversible rotary motors: Fo is either an ion 'turbine' or an ion pump, and F1 is either a hydrolysis motor or an ATP synthesizer. Recent biophysical and biochemical studies have helped to elucidate the operating principles for both motors.

ATP-synthase of Rhodobacter capsulatus: coupling of proton flow through F0 to reactions in F1 under the ATP synthesis and slip conditions

A stepwise increasing membrane potential was generated in chromatophores of the phototrophic bacterium Rhodobacter capsulatus by illumination with short flashes of light. Proton transfer through ATP-synthase (measured by electrochromic carotenoid bandshift and by pH-indicators) and ATP release (measured by luminescence of luciferin-luciferase) were monitored. The ratio between the amount of protons translocated by F0F1 and the ATP yield decreased with the flash number from an apparent value of 13 after the first flash to about 5 when averaged over three flashes. In the absence of ADP, protons slipped through F0F1. The proton transfer through F0F1 after the first flash contained two kinetic components, of about 6 ms and 20 ms both under the ATP synthesis conditions and under slip. The slower component of proton transfer was substantially suppressed in the absence of ADP. We attribute our observations to the mechanism of energy storage in the ATP-synthase needed to couple the transfer of four protons with the synthesis of one molecule of ATP. Most probably, the transfer of initial protons of each tetrad creates a strain in the enzyme that slows the translocation of the following protons.

Amino acid substitutions in the a subunit affect the epsilon subunit of F1F0 ATP synthase from Escherichia coli

Amino acid substitutions at many positions in the a subunit of F1F0 ATP synthase result in impaired proton translocation and altered catalytic activity. In this work, we demonstrate that amino acid substitutions in the a subunit affect the epsilon subunit. In mutant F1F0 ATP synthases, the epsilon subunit was studied by determining its sensitivity to proteolysis and by chemical crosslinking under conditions of active turnover and in quiescent enzyme. Like native F1F0 ATP synthase, the epsilon subunit in enzymes carrying either the aarg-210-->ile or agly-218-->asp substitutions proved resistant to trypsin digestion during ATP hydrolysis. In each case, the epsilon subunit was rapidly digested in the presence of a nonhydrolyzable ligand, but this did not result in the activation of hydrolytic activity typically seen in wild-type enzyme. In enzyme carrying the aala-217-->arg substitution, the trypsin digestion of the epsilon subunit occurred regardless of ligand and was accompanied by a limited hydrolytic activation. Relative to the native F1F0 ATP synthase, the aala-217-->arg substitution resulted in reduced efficiency of crosslinking between the epsilon and beta subunits using 1-ethyl-3-[3-(dimethylamino)propyl]carbodiimide. These observations indicate that the structural changes resulting from amino acid substitutions in the a subunit are propagated to the epsilon subunit and are specific to the individual substitutions.

Kinetic analysis of tentoxin binding to chloroplast F1-ATPase. A model for the overactivation process

The mechanism of action of tentoxin on the soluble part (chloroplast F1 H+-ATPase; CF1) of chloroplast ATP synthase was analyzed in the light of new kinetic and equilibrium experiments. Investigations were done regarding the functional state of the enzyme (activation, bound nucleotide, catalytic turnover). Dialysis and binding data, obtained with 14C-tentoxin, fully confirmed the existence of two tentoxin binding sites of distinct dissociation constants consistent with the observed Kinhibition and Koveractivation. This strongly supports a two-site model of tentoxin action on CF1. Kinetic and thermodynamic parameters of tentoxin binding to the first site (Ki = 10 nM; kon = 4.7 x 10(4) s-1.M-1) were determined from time-resolved activity assays. Tentoxin binding to the high affinity site was found independent on the catalytic state of the enzyme. The analysis of the kinetics of tentoxin binding on the low affinity site of the enzyme showed strong evidence for an interaction between this site and the nucleotide binding sites and revealed a complex relationship between the catalytic state and the reactivation process. New catalytic states of CF1 devoid of epsilon-subunit were detected: a transient overstimulated state, and a dead end complex unable to bind a second tentoxin molecule. Our experiments led to a kinetic model for the reactivation phenomenon for which rate constants were determined. The implications of this model are discussed in relation to the previous mechanistic hypotheses on the effect of tentoxin.

Contraction transitions of F1-F0 ATPase during catalytic turnover

Strong acoustic pressure was applied to submitochondrial particles (SMP) from bovine heart in order to drive ATP synthesis by F1-F0 complex for the account of sound waves. We observed a net ATP production at two narrow frequency ranges, about 170 Hz and about 340 Hz, that corresponds to the resonance oscillations of experimental cuvette when the acoustic pressure had a magnitude of 100 kPa. The results can be explained quantitatively by contractive conformational changes of F1-F0 complex during catalytic turnover. Negative staining electron microscopy of SMP preparations was used to visualize the ADP(Mg2+)-induced conformational changes of F1-F0 complex. In the particles with high ATPase activity in the presence of phosphate the factors F1 and F0 formed a congregated domain plunged into the membrane without any observable stalk in between. The presence of ADP(Mg2+) caused a structural rearrangement of F1-F0 to the essentially different conformation: the domains F1 and F0 were dislodged distinctly from each other and connected by a long thin stalk. The latter conformation resembled well the usual bipartite profile of ATPase. The data indicate that besides rotation, the catalytic turnover of ATP synthase is also accompanied by stretch transitions of F1-F0 complex.

Relevance of divalent cations to ATP-driven proton pumping in beef heart mitochondrial F0F1-ATPase

The ATP hydrolysis rate and the ATP hydrolysis-linked proton translocation by the F0F1-ATPase of beef heart submitochondrial particles were examined in the presence of several divalent metal cations. All Me-ATP complexes tested sustained ATP hydrolysis, although to a different extent. However, only Mg- and Mn-ATP-dependent hydrolysis could sustain a high level of proton pumping activity, as determined by acridine fluorescence quenching. Moreover, the Km of the Me-ATP hydrolysis-induced proton pumping activity was very similar to the Km value of Me-ATP hydrolysis. Both oligomycin and DCCD caused the full recovery of the fluorescence, providing clear evidence for the association of Mg-ATP hydrolysis with proton translocation through the F0F1-ATPase complex. In contrast, with other Me-ATP complexes, including Ca-ATP as substrate, the proton pumping activity was undetectable, implicating an uncoupling nature for these substrates. Attempts to demonstrate the involvement of the epsilon subunit of the enzyme in the coupling mechanism failed, suggesting that the participation of at least the N-terminal segment of the subunit in the coupling mechanism of the mitochondrial enzyme is unlikely.

Genetic fusions of subunit c in the F0 sector of H+-transporting ATP synthase. Functional dimers and trimers and determination of stoichiometry by cross-linking analysis

The multicopy c subunit of the H+-transporting ATP synthase of Escherichia coli folds through the transmembrane F0 sector as a hairpin of two hydrophobic alpha-helices with the proton-translocating aspartyl-61 side chain centered in the second transmembrane helix. The number of subunits c in the F0 complex, which is thought to determine the H+-pumping/ATP stoichiometry, was previously not determined with exactness but thought to range from 9-12. The studies described here indicate that the exact number is 12. Based upon the precedent of the subunit c in vacuolar-type ATPases, which are composed of four transmembrane helices and seem to have evolved by gene duplication of an F0-type progenitor gene, we constructed genetically fused dimers and trimers of E. coli subunit c. Both the dimeric and trimeric forms proved to be functional. These results indicate that the total number of subunit c in F0 should be a multiple of 2 and 3. Based upon a previous study in which the oligomeric organization of c subunits in F0 was determined by cross-linking of Cys-substituted subunits (Jones, P. C. , Jiang, W., and Fillingame, R. H. (1998) J. Biol. Chem. 273, 17178-17185), we introduced Cys into the first and last transmembrane helices of subunit c monomers, dimers, and trimers and attempted to generate cross-linked products by oxidation with Cu(II)-(1,10-phenanthroline)2. Double Cys substitutions at two sets of positions gave rise to extensive cross-linked multimers. Multimers of the monomer that extended up to the position of c12 were correlated and calibrated with distinct cross-linked species of the appropriate doubly Cys-substituted dimers (i.e. c2, c4, . c12) and doubly Cys-substituted trimers (i.e. c3, c6, c9, c12). The results show that there are 12 copies of subunit c per F0 in E. coli, the exact number having both mechanistic and structural significance.

A model of the quaternary structure of the Escherichia coli F1 ATPase from X-ray solution scattering and evidence for structural changes in the delta subunit during ATP hydrolysis

The shape and subunit arrangement of the Escherichia coli F1 ATPase (ECF1 ATPase) was investigated by synchrotron radiation x-ray solution scattering. The radius of gyration and the maximum dimension of the enzyme complex are 4.61 +/- 0.03 nm and 15.5 +/- 0.05 nm, respectively. The shape of the complex was determined ab initio from the scattering data at a resolution of 3 nm, which allowed unequivocal identification of the volume occupied by the alpha3beta3 subassembly and further positioning of the atomic models of the smaller subunits. The delta subunit was positioned near the bottom of the alpha3beta3 hexamer in a location consistent with a beta-delta disulfide formation in the mutant ECF1 ATPase, betaY331W:betaY381C:epsilonS108C, when MgADP is bound to the enzyme. The position and orientation of the epsilon subunit were found by interactively fitting the solution scattering data to maintain connection of the two-helix hairpin with the alpha3beta3 complex and binding of the beta-sandwich domain to the gamma subunit. Nucleotide-dependent changes of the delta subunit were investigated by stopped-flow fluorescence technique at 12 degrees C using N-[4-[7-(dimethylamino)-4-methyl]coumarin-3-yl]maleimide (CM) as a label. Fluorescence quenching monitored after addition of MgATP was rapid [k = 6.6 s-1] and then remained constant. Binding of MgADP and the noncleavable nucleotide analog AMP . PNP caused an initial fluorescent quenching followed by a slower decay back to the original level. This suggests that the delta subunit undergoes conformational changes and/or rearrangements in the ECF1 ATPase during ATP hydrolysis.

Solution structure of the epsilon subunit of the F1-ATPase from Escherichia coli and interactions of this subunit with beta subunits in the complex

The solution structure of the epsilon subunit of the Escherichia coli F1-ATPase has been determined by NMR spectroscopy. This subunit has a two-domain structure with an N-terminal 10-stranded beta sandwich and a C-terminal antiparallel two alpha-helix hairpin, as described previously (Wilkens, S., Dahlquist, F. W., McIntosh, L. P., Donaldson, L. W., and Capaldi, R. A. (1995) Nat. Struct. Biol. 2, 961-967). New data show that the two domains interact in solution in an interface formed by beta strand 7 and the very C-terminal alpha-helix. This interface involves only hydrophobic interactions. The dynamics of the epsilon subunit in solution were examined. The two domains are relatively tightly associated with little or no flexibility relative to one another. The epsilon subunit can exist in two states in the ECF1F0 complex depending on whether ATP or ADP occupies catalytic sites. Proteolysis of the epsilon subunit in solution and when bound to the core F1 complex indicates that the conformation of the polypeptide in solution closely resembles the conformation of epsilon when bound to the F1 in the ADP state. Chemical and photo-cross-linking show that the epsilon subunit spans and interacts with two beta subunits in the ADP state. These interactions are disrupted on binding of ATP + Mg2+, as is the interaction between the N- and C-terminal domains of the epsilon subunit.

Direct indication for the existence of a double stalk in CF0F1

The H+-ATPase from chloroplasts (CF0F1) was investigated by electron microscopy of negatively stained single molecules followed by image processing. The analysis of about 4700 particles from 72 micrographs gave clear evidence that the membrane-integrated F0 part is connected by at least two stalks to the F1 part. One of the two stalks is more prominent and connects a central part of F1 with a slightly peripheral part of F0. The other stalk connects a peripheral part of F1 to a peripheral part of F0.