Structure/function studies of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 reverse transcriptase. Alanine scanning mutagenesis of an alpha-helix in the thumb subdomain

Complex patterns predicted in an in vitro experimental model system for the evolution of molecular cooperation

An isothermal biochemical in vitro amplification system with two trans-cooperatively coupled amplifying DNA molecules was investigated homogeneously using a hierarchy of kinetic models and as a simplified reaction-diffusion system. In our model of this recently developed experimental system, no reaction mechanism higher than second order occurs, yet numerical simulations show a variety of complex spatiotemporal patterns which arise in response to finite amplitude perturbations in a flow reactor. In a certain domain of the kinetic parameters the system shows self-replicating spots. These spots can stabilize the cooperative amplification in such evolving systems against emerging parasites. The results are of high relevance for experimental studies on these functional in vitro ecosystems in spatially resolved microstructured reactors.

Compression of the DNA minor groove is responsible for termination of DNA synthesis by HIV-1 reverse transcriptase

HIV-1 reverse transcriptase (RT) generally terminates plus strand DNA synthesis at the centre of the viral genome. The central termination sequence (CTS) contains two termination sites which are located at the 3' end of AnTm motifs. These motifs generate a global curvature of the DNA helix which correlates with termination of DNA synthesis. Here, we have characterized HIV-1 RT termination sites on different DNA sequences. Again, they are located at the 3' end of A-tracts. Using hydroxyl radicals as a probe of the width of the DNA helix, we have shown that RT termination sites are always located a few base-pairs downstream of a compressed minor groove. Mutations which relieve these compressions also abolish the termination events. The replacement of the adenine tracts by 2,6-diaminopurine tracts has a similar effect. Moreover, no termination site is observed on DNA sequences containing phased GC-tracts which curve the DNA helix but compress the major groove. The compression of the DNA minor groove and not necessarily the curved trajectory of the DNA is, therefore, responsible for termination of DNA synthesis at the CTS by HIV-1 RT. This conclusion is consistent with interpretation of other biochemical data on the processivity of HIV-1 RT, based on the structure of a DNA-enzyme complex.

Structure and functional implications of the polymerase active site region in a complex of HIV-1 RT with a double-stranded DNA template-primer and an antibody Fab fragment at 2.8 A resolution

The structure of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) reverse transcriptase (RT) complexed with a 19-mer/18-mer double-stranded DNA template-primer (dsDNA) and the Fab fragment of monoclonal antibody 28 (Fab28) has been refined at 2.8 A resolution. The structures of the polymerase active site and neighboring regions are described in detail and a number of novel insights into mechanisms of polymerase catalysis and drug inhibition are presented. The three catalytically essential amino acid residues (Asp110, Asp185, and Asp186) are located close to the 3' terminus of the primer strand. Observation of a hydrogen bond between the 3'-OH of the primer terminus and the side-chain of Asp185 suggests that the carboxylate of Asp185 could act as a general base in initiating the nucleophilic attack during polymerization. Nearly all of the close protein-DNA interactions involve atoms of the sugar-phosphate backbone of the nucleic acid. However, the phenoxyl side-chain of Tyr183, which is part of the conserved YMDD motif, has hydrogen-bonding interactions with nucleotide bases of the second duplex base-pair and is predicted to have at least one hydrogen bond with all Watson-Crick base-pairs at this position. Comparison of the structure of the active site region in the HIV-1 RT/dsDNA complex with all other HIV-1 RT structures suggests that template-primer binding is accompanied by significant conformational changes of the YMDD motif that may be relevant for mechanisms of both polymerization and inhibition by non-nucleoside inhibitors. Interactions of the "primer grip" (the beta12-beta13 hairpin) with the 3' terminus of the primer strand primarily involve the main-chain atoms of Met230 and Gly231 and the primer terminal phosphate. Alternative positions of the primer grip observed in different HIV-1 RT structures may be related to conformational changes that normally occur during DNA polymerization and translocation. In the vicinity of the polymerase active site, there are a number of aromatic residues that are involved in energetically favorable pi-pi interactions and may be involved in the transitions between different stages of the catalytic process. The protein structural elements primarily responsible for precise positioning of the template-primer (including the primer grip, template grip, and helices alphaH and alphaI of the p66 thumb) can be thought of functioning as a "translocation track" that guides the relative movement of nucleic acid and protein during polymerization.

Studies on the effects of truncating alpha-helix E' of p66 human immunodeficiency virus type 1 reverse transcriptase on template-primer binding and fidelity of DNA synthesis

The role of alpha-helix E' of the RNase H domain of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 reverse transcriptase (HIV-1 RT) in template-primer binding and fidelity of DNA synthesis was investigated by using a series of mutant enzymes with deletions of 4, 8, 12, 16, and 20 amino acids at the C-terminal end of the 66 kDa subunit. The dissociation equilibrium constants (Kd) of wild-type HIV-1 RT and 38/16mer and 47/25mer DNA/DNA template-primer complexes were 2.2 +/- 0.7 and 0.69 +/- 0.35 nM, respectively. Deletions involving partial or total removal of alpha-helix E' rendered enzymes with a 2-5-fold decrease in binding affinity. Misinsertion and mispair extension fidelity of DNA synthesis of the wild-type enzyme and truncated mutants were determined by using both DNA/DNA template-primers and a 47/25mer RNA/DNA complex. In all cases, incorporation assays were done in the same sequence context, which was taken from the viral gag gene. The removal of alpha-helix E' had little effect on fidelity as determined with the three template-primers. Misinsertion fidelity assays showed that the specificity of mismatch formation was A:C approximately A:G > A:A for the DNA template and A:C > A:G approximately A:A for the RNA template, in 47/25mers. The specificity of extending mispaired 3'-termini was similar with both 47/25mers: A:C > A:A approximately A:G. However, the efficiency of transversion mispair extension was higher with RNA templates. The results reported in this paper suggest that alpha-helix E' may stabilize the RT/template-primer interaction, but does not have a strong influence in the correct positioning of the template-primer at the polymerase active site.

Vertical-scanning mutagenesis of a critical tryptophan in the minor groove binding track of HIV-1 reverse transcriptase. Molecular nature of polymerase-nucleic acid interactions

While sequence-specific DNA-binding proteins interact predominantly in the DNA major groove, DNA polymerases bind DNA through interactions in the minor groove that are sequence nonspecific. Through functional analyses of alanine-substituted mutant enzymes that were guided by molecular dynamics modeling of the human immunodeficiency virus type 1-reverse transcriptase and DNA complex, we previously identified a structural element in reverse transcriptase, the minor groove binding track (MGBT). The MGBT is comprised of five residues (Ile94, Gln258, Gly262, Trp266, and Gln269) which interact 2-6 base pairs upstream from the polymerase active site in the DNA minor groove and are important in DNA binding, processivity, and frameshift fidelity. These residues do not contribute equally; functional analysis of alanine mutants suggests that Trp266 contributes the most to binding. To define the molecular interactions between Trp266 and the DNA minor groove, we have analyzed the properties of eight mutants, each with an alternate side chain at this position. A refined molecular dynamics model was used to calculate relative binding free energies based on apolar surface area buried upon complex formation. In general, there was a strong correlation between the relative calculated binding free energies for the alternate residue 266 side chains and the magnitude of the change in the properties which reflect template-primer interactions (template-primer dissociation rate constant, Ki,AZTTP, processivity, and frameshift fidelity). This correlation suggests that hydrophobic interactions make a major contribution to the stability of the polymerase-DNA complex. Additionally, tyrosine and arginine substitutions resulted in mutant enzymes with DNA binding properties better than predicted by buried surface area alone, suggesting that hydrogen bonding could also play a role in DNA binding at this position.

Phenotypic mechanism of HIV-1 resistance to 3'-azido-3'-deoxythymidine (AZT): increased polymerization processivity and enhanced sensitivity to pyrophosphate of the mutant viral reverse transcriptase

The multiple mutations associated with high-level AZT resistance (D67N, K70R, T215F, K219Q) arise in two separate subdomains of the viral reverse transcriptase (RT), suggesting that these mutations may contribute differently to overall resistance. We compared wild-type RT with the D67N/K70R/T215F/K219Q, D67N/K70R, and T215F/K219Q mutant enzymes. The D67N/K70R/T215F/K219Q mutant showed increased DNA polymerase processivity; this resulted from decreased template/primer dissociation from RT, and was due to the T215F/K219Q mutations. The D67N/K70R/T215F/K219Q mutant was less sensitive to AZTTP (IC50 approximately 300 nM) than wt RT (IC50 approximately 100 nM) in the presence of 0.5 mM pyrophosphate. This change in pyrophosphate-mediated sensitivity of the mutant enzyme was selective for AZTTP, since similar Km values for TTP and inhibition by ddCTP and ddGTP were noted with wt and mutant RT in the absence or in the presence of pyrophosphate. The D67N/K70R/T215F/K219Q mutant showed an increased rate of pyrophosphorolysis (the reverse reaction of DNA synthesis) of chain-terminated DNA; this enhanced pyrophosphorolysis was due to the D67N/K70R mutations. However, the processivity of pyrophosphorolysis was similar for the wild-type and mutant enzymes. We propose that HIV-1 resistance to AZT results from the selectively decreased binding of AZTTP and the increased pyrophosphorolytic cleavage of chain-terminated viral DNA by the mutant RT at physiological pyrophosphate levels, resulting in a net decrease in chain termination. The increased processivity of viral DNA synthesis may be important to enable facile HIV replication in the presence of AZT, by compensating for the increased reverse reaction rate.

Contacts between reverse transcriptase and the primer strand govern the transition from initiation to elongation of HIV-1 reverse transcription

HIV-1 reverse transcriptase (RT) utilizes RNA oligomers to prime DNA synthesis. The initiation of reverse transcription requires specific interactions between HIV-1 RNA, primer tRNA3Lys, and RT. We have previously shown that extension of an oligodeoxyribonucleotide, a situation that mimicks elongation, is unspecific and differs from initiation by the polymerization rate and dissociation rate of RT from the primer-template complex. Here, we used replication intermediates to analyze the transition from the initiation to the elongation phases. We found that the 2'-hydroxyl group at the 3' end of tRNA had limited effects on the polymerization and dissociation rate constants. Instead, the polymerization rate increased 3400-fold between addition of the sixth and seventh nucleotide to tRNA3Lys. The same increase in the polymerization rate was observed when an oligoribonucleotide, but not an oligodeoxyribonucleotide, was used as a primer. In parallel, the dissociation rate of RT from the primer-template complex decreased 30-fold between addition of the 17th and 19th nucleotide to tRNA3Lys. The polymerization and dissociation rates are most likely governed by interactions of the primer strand with helix alphaH in the p66 thumb subdomain and the RNase H domain of RT, respectively.

Construction and characterization of a temperature-sensitive human immunodeficiency virus type 1 reverse transcriptase mutant

A temperature-sensitive (ts) human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) reverse transcriptase (RT) mutant was generated by charged-cluster-to-alanine mutagenesis. The mutant virus, containing three charged residues within the RT finger domain changed to alanine (K64A, K66A, and D67A), replicated normally at 34.5 but not 39.5 degrees C. Quantitating virus particle production by p24 antigen capture or virion-associated RT activity and virus infectivity by the MAGI cell assay, we found that (i) mutant virions produced at the permissive temperature were indistinguishable from wild-type virus in assays performed at the nonpermissive temperature, suggesting that the ts mutation did not impair early steps in the virus replication cycle and that the mutant RT enzyme was not ts; and (ii) virus particle production in cells transfected with the ts mutant at the nonpermissive temperature was comparable to that of wild-type virus. However, the particle-associated RT activity and infectivity of mutant virions produced at the nonpermissive temperature were greatly reduced when assays were conducted at the permissive temperature. These results are consistent with an irreversible ts event affecting RT that occurs during virus particle production. Radioimmunoprecipitation analyses revealed that both p66 and p51 RT subunits were absent from mutant virions generated at 39.5 degrees C. The presence of normal levels of HIV-1 integrase in mutant particles produced at the nonpermissive temperature was inconsistent with defective Gag-Pol synthesis or Gag-Pol incorporation into progeny virions. Furthermore, wild-type levels of the mutant Pr160(gag-pol) were detected in virions produced at the nonpermissive temperature when the HIV-1 protease was inactivated by site-specific mutagenesis. Taken together, these results are most consistent with a ts defect affecting the degradation or aberrant processing of the mutated RT during its processing/maturation within nascent particles.

Interaction of retroviral reverse transcriptase with template-primer duplexes during replication

Conversion of the single-stranded RNA of an invading retrovirus into double-stranded proviral DNA is catalyzed in a multi-step process by a single virus-coded enzyme, reverse transcriptase (RT). Achieving this requires a combination of DNA polymerase abd ribonuclease H (RNase H) activities, which are located at the amino and carboxy terminus of the enzyme, respectively. Moreover, proviral DNA synthesis requires that three structurally-distinct nucleic acid duplexes are accommodated by this enzyme, namely (a) A-form RNA (initiation of minus strand synthesis), non-A, non-B RNA/DNA hybrid (minus strand synthesis and initiation of plus strand synthesis) and B-form duplex DNA (plus strand synthesis). This review summarizes our current understanding of the manner in which retroviral RT interacts with this diverse array of nucleic acid duplexes, exploiting in many cases mutants unable to catalyze a specific event. These studies illustrate that seemingly 'simple' events such as tRNA-primed initiation of minus strand synthesis are considerably more complex, involving intermolecular tRNA-viral RNA interactions outside the primer binding site. Moreover, RNase H activity, generally thought to catalyze non-specific degradation of the RNA-DNA replicative intermediate, is required for highly specialized events including DNA strand transfer and polypurine selection. Finally, a unique structure near the center of HIV proviral DNA, the central termination sequence, serves to halt the replication machinery in a manner analogous to termination of transcription. As these highly specialized events are better understood at the molecular level, they may open new avenues of therapeutic intervention in the continuing effort to stem the progression of HIV infection and AIDS.

The fidelity of 3' misinsertion and mispair extension during DNA synthesis exhibited by two drug-resistant mutants of the reverse transcriptase of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 with Leu74-->Val and Glu89-->Gly

The relatively low fidelity of DNA synthesis characteristic to the reverse transcriptases (RTs) of the AIDS-causing viruses, human immunodeficiency viruses types 1 and 2 (HIV-1 and HIV-2, respectively) was implicated as a dominant factor that contributes to the genetic hypervariability of these viruses. The formation of 3'-mispaired DNA and the subsequent extension of this DNA were shown to be key determinants that lead to the error proneness of these RTs. As part of our goal to study the structure/function relationship in HIV-1 RT, we have conducted mutational studies aimed at identifying amino-acid residues involved in affecting the fidelity of DNA synthesis by the enzyme. We have recently found that two mutants of HIV-1 RT, which show resistance to nucleoside analog inhibitors ([Leu184]RT and [Phe183]RT), exhibit in vitro error proneness of DNA synthesis lower than that of wild-type enzyme [Bakhanshvili, M., Avidan, O. & Hizi, A. (1996) Mutational studies of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 reverse transcriptase: the involvement of residues 183 and 184 in the fidelity of DNA synthesis, FEBS Lett. 391, 257-262]. Using both criteria, the current comparative study suggests that these two mutant RTs display a substantially enhanced fidelity of DNA synthesis relative to the wild-type RT counterpart. In the current study we have analyzed two additional drug-resistant mutants of HIV-1 RT, [Val74]RT and [Gly89]RT, for their in vitro fidelity of DNA synthesis using two parameters of DNA synthesis: 3' mispair formation and elongation of 3'-mismatched DNA. The current comparative study suggests that these two mutant RTs display a substantially enhanced fidelity of DNA synthesis relative to the wild-type RT counterpart, using both criteria. Analysis of the relative frequencies of misinsertion and mispair extension indicates that the overall error proneness of DNA synthesis in HIV-1 RT is wild-type > [Val74]RT > [Gly89]RT mutant. The results further support the possible linkage between the capacity of an enzyme to incorporate a nucleoside analog instead of the correct dNTP (leading to drug sensitivity) and the ability to incorporate and extend a wrong nucleotide (resulting in mutagenesis). Our results may bear on the potential use of selecting and maintaining HIV virions with high fidelity and drug-resistant RTs to suppress the subsequent appearance of virions resistant to other drugs.

Mutating a conserved motif of the HIV-1 reverse transcriptase palm subdomain alters primer utilization

In order to investigate how primer grip residues of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 reverse transcriptase (HIV-1 RT) contribute toward the architecture of its palm subdomain and neighboring structural elements, the DNA polymerase and ribonuclease H (RNase H) activities of enzymes bearing aromatic substitutions at Trp229 and Tyr232 of the catalytically-competent p66 subunit were evaluated. Although all mutants retained RNase H function, the manner in which different RNA-DNA hybrids were hydrolyzed was affected. Depending on the nature of the substitution, DNA-dependent DNA synthesis was (i) unaffected, (ii) interrupted shortly after initiation, or (iii) stalled when the replication machinery encountered an intramolecular duplex on the single-stranded template. Evaluating (-) strand strong-stop DNA synthesis on an RNA template derived from the viral genome raises the additional possibility that DNA and RNA primers might be differentially recognized by the retroviral polymerase. In support of this, all mutants were unable to extend the HIV-1 polypurine tract (PPT) RNA primer into (+) strand DNA, despite supporting the equivalent event from an oligodeoxynucleotide primer. Collectively, our data illustrate that subtle alterations to primer grip architecture may manifest themselves in discrimination between oligoribo- and oligodeoxyribonucleic acid primers.

Mutations within the primer grip region of HIV-1 reverse transcriptase result in loss of RNase H function

Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) DNA synthesis is accompanied by degradation of genomic RNA by the RNase H of reverse transcriptase (RT). Two different modes of RNase H activity appear necessary for complete RNA removal. In one, occurring during minus strand synthesis, positioning of the RNase H is determined by binding of the polymerase active site to the DNA 3'-end. In the other, used for removal of remaining RNA fragments, positioning of RT for RNase H-directed cleavage is determined by the RNA 5'-ends. We attempted to identify RT amino acids responsible for these modes of positioning. Twelve RT mutants, each with one alanine replacement in residues 224 to 235, known as the primer grip region, were examined for catalytic abilities. Six of the examined primer grip mutants, although distant from the RNase H active site were altered in their ability to cleave RNA. The mutants P226A, F227A, G231A, Y232A, E233A, and H235A failed to perform RNA 5'-end-directed RNase H cleavage in heparin-challenged reactions. The last four mutants also lacked DNA synthesis and DNA 3'-end-directed RNase H cleavage activities in challenged reactions. Since mutants P226A and F227A carried out these latter reactions normally, these two residues specifically influence 5'-RNA-directed RNase H catalysis.

Probing structure/function relationships of HIV-1 reverse transcriptase with styrene oxide N2-guanine adducts

Details of the interactions between the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV-1) reverse transcriptase and substrate DNA were probed both by introducing site-specific and stereospecific modifications into DNA and by altering the structure of potential critical residues in the polymerase. Unadducted 11-mer DNAs and 11-mer DNAs containing R and S enantiomers of styrene oxide at N2-guanine were ligated with two additional oligonucleotides to create 63-mers that served as templates for HIV-1 reverse transcriptase replication. Oligonucleotides that primed synthesis 5 bases 3' to the adducts could be extended up to 1 base 3' and opposite the lesion. However, when the positions of the 3'-OH of the priming oligonucleotides were placed 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, and 6 bases downstream of the styrene oxide guanine adducts, replication was initiated, only to be blocked after incorporating 4, 5, 6, and 7 bases beyond the lesion. The sites of this adduct-induced termination corresponded to the position of the DNA where alpha-helix H makes contact with the DNA minor groove, 3-5 bases upstream of the growing 3' end. In addition, mutants of the polymerase in alpha-helix H (W266A and G262A) alter the termination probabilities caused by these DNA adducts, suggesting that alpha-helix H is a sensitive monitor of modifications in the minor groove of newly synthesized template-primer DNA several bases distal to the 3'-OH.

Base miscoding and strand misalignment errors by mutator Klenow polymerases with amino acid substitutions at tyrosine 766 in the O helix of the fingers subdomain

A mutant derivative of Klenow fragment DNA polymerase containing serine substituted for tyrosine at residue 766 has been shown by kinetic analysis to have an increased misinsertion rate relative to wild-type Klenow fragment, but a decreased rate of extension from the resulting mispairs (Carroll, S. S., Cowart, M., and Benkovic, S. J. (1991) Biochemistry 30, 804-813). In the present study we use an M13mp2-based fidelity assay to study the error specificity of this mutator polymerase. Despite its compromised ability to extend mispairs, the Y766S polymerase and a Y766A mutant both have elevated base substitution error rates. The magnitude of the mutator effect is mispair-specific, from no effect for some mispairs to rates elevated by 60-fold for misincorporation of TMP opposite template G. The results with the Y766S mutant are remarkably consistent with the earlier kinetic analysis of misinsertion, demonstrating that either approach can be used to identify and characterize mutator polymerases. Both the Y766S and Y766A mutant polymerases are also frameshift mutators, having elevated rates for two-base deletions and a 276-base deletion between a direct repeat sequence. However, neither mutant polymerase has an increased error rate for single-base frameshifts in repetitive sequences. This error specificity suggests that the deletions generated by the mutator polymerases are initiated by misinsertion rather than by strand slippage. When considered with recent structure-function studies of other polymerases, the data indicate that the nucleotide misinsertion and strand-slippage mechanisms for polymerization infidelity are differentially affected by changes in distinct structural elements of DNA polymerases that share similar subdomain structures.

DNA curvature controls termination of plus strand DNA synthesis at the centre of HIV-1 genome

In vivo and in vitro, reverse transcriptase (RT) from human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) terminates plus strand synthesis at the centre of the viral genome. The central termination sequence (CTS) contains curved DNA fragments located upstream of each terminator site. Two different models, relying either on the A-tract or general sequence roll assumptions, were used to predict the extent and the direction of this curvature as well as to design mutants, which abolished it. Straightening of each curved element abolished termination at the site located immediately downstream from the curvature. When synthesis was performed on the other strand and in the opposite direction, the two curved elements C1 and C2 associated with the two termination sites Ter1 and Ter2, led again to termination of DNA synthesis. Therefore, termination occurred as a nascent bent duplex was synthesized within the template primer binding cleft of RT, even when putative strand-specific motifs have been removed by the inversion. Computation of DNA paths upstream of other known arrest sites suggested that this feature was of general relevance for termination. At the CTS, termination occurred more precisely at the 3' end of an AnTm motif (n + m = 7). The possible structures, adopted by this motif, are discussed and confronted with the present crystallographic and biochemical data obtained on HIV-1 RT-DNA interactions and on HIV-1 RT processivity.

Differential tolerance to DNA polymerization by HIV-1 reverse transcriptase on N6 adenine C10R and C10S benzo[a]pyrene-7,8-dihydrodiol 9,10-epoxide-adducted templates

To determine the effect of various stereoisomers of benzo[a]pyrene-7,8-dihydrodiol 9,10-epoxide (BPDE) on translesion bypass by human immunodeficiency virus-1 reverse transcriptase and its alpha-helix H mutants, six 33-mer templates were constructed bearing site- and stereospecific adducts. This in vitro model system was chosen to understand the structure-function relationships between the polymerase and damaged DNA during replication. Comparison of the replication pattern between wild type human immunodeficiency virus-1 reverse transcriptase and its mutants, using primers which were 3' to the lesion, revealed essentially similar patterns. While these primers terminated with all three of the C10R and two of the C10S BPDE-adducted templates 1 base 5' and 1 base 3' to the damaged site respectively, (+)-anti-trans-(C10S) BPDE-adducted DNA alone permitted the formation of full-length products. Utilization of a primer with its 3'-hydroxyl 1 base beyond the lesion resulted in full-length products with all the C10S BPDE-adducted templates and the (-)-syn-trans-(C10R)-BPDE-adducted template, following replication with either the wild type or mutant enzymes. However, the other two C10R BPDE-adducted templates failed to allow any primer extension, even with the wild type enzyme. Although T.P depletion studies further confirmed the differential primer extension abilities using the C10R and C10S adducted templates, their binding affinities were similar, yet distinct from the unadducted template.

Strained template under the thumbs. How reverse transcriptase of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 moves along its template

In retroviruses, such as human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1), the reverse transcriptase (RT) copies single-stranded viral RNA into complementary DNA, which is then used as a template for synthesis of the second DNA strand. The resulting double-stranded DNA is integrated into the host genome. How RT translocates on the different templates is the subject of this study. We have developed a theoretical model for RT translocation during processive DNA synthesis. The model is based on the assumption that there are two template-binding sites, namely the helix clamps, located in the thumb subdomains of RT subunits p66 and p51. Flexibility of the p66 thumb provides undisrupted template-binding during polymerase translocation. Coordinated association and dissociation of the template at the thumbs, triggered by nucleotide incorporation, is assumed, which ensures template contact with at least one subdomain throughout translocation. We suggest that coordination between the sites is effected by stress in the template region located between the thumbs. Translocation of HIV-1 RT proceeds continuously but with different processivities on RNA and DNA templates. These findings are explained in detail by the proposed model.

A thumb subdomain mutant of the large fragment of Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I with reduced DNA binding affinity, processivity, and frameshift fidelity

In Klenow fragment DNA polymerase, a flexible 50-amino acid subdomain at the tip of the thumb which includes two alpha helices has been suggested to interact with the duplex template-primer (Beese, L.S., Derbyshire, V. and Steitz, T.A. (1993) Science 260, 352-355). The present study investigates the properties of Klenow polymerase containing a 24-amino acid deletion (residues 590-613) that removes a portion of the tip of the thumb. The mutant polymerase has relatively normal dNTP binding and catalytic rate. However, its DNA binding affinity is reduced by more than 100-fold relative to the intact polymerase and its ability to conduct processive synthesis is also reduced. Although the mutant polymerase has relatively normal base substitution fidelity, it has strongly reduced frameshift fidelity, being especially error-prone for single nucleotide addition errors in homopolymeric runs. The addition error rate increases as the length of the reiterated sequence increases, indicative of errors initiated by template-primer strand slippage. These observations suggest a role for the tip of the thumb of Klenow polymerase in determining DNA binding, processivity and frameshift fidelity, perhaps by tracking the minor groove of the duplex DNA. The results are discussed in light of remarkably similar observations with T7 DNA polymerase in the presence or absence of thioredoxin, an accessory subunit that affects these same properties.

Alterations to the primer grip of p66 HIV-1 reverse transcriptase and their consequences for template-primer utilization

Alanine scanning mutagenesis was undertaken to evaluate the structural significance of Met230-His235 of the 66 kDa subunit of p66/p51 human immunodeficiency virus reverse transcriptase (HIV-1 RT). Together with Glu224-Trp229, these residues provide the framework of the p66 "primer grip", whose proposed role is maintaining the primer terminus in an orientation appropriate for nucleophilic attack on an incoming dNTP. Of these residues, altering Leu234 results in a p66 subunit incapable of associating into heterodimer. The remaining selectively mutated enzymes were successfully reconstituted and purified to homogeneity for evaluation of RT-associated activities. We show here that alterations to any residue within the p66-Trp229-Met230-Gly231-Tyr232-quartet alter functions associated with both the DNA polymerase and ribonuclease H (RNase H) domains. Detailed analysis of mutant p66Y232A/p51 with an intact or a model "precleaved" RNA-DNA hybrid suggests an altered RNase H phenotype could result from relocation of template-primer in the nucleic acid binding cleft. As a consequence, template nucleotide-8 is positioned in the immediate vicinity of the RNase H catalytic center rather than nucleotide-17.

Increased polymerase fidelity of E89G, a nucleoside analog-resistant variant of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 reverse transcriptase

Nucleoside analog resistance in human immunodeficiency virus type 1 results from mutations in reverse transcriptase (RT) that allow the enzyme to discriminate against such analogs. To evaluate the possible impact of such mutations on the ability of human immunodeficiency virus RT to selectively incorporate Watson-Crick base-paired deoxynucleotide triphosphates (dNTPs) over incorrectly paired dNTPs, we have measured the fidelity of dNTP insertion by the E89G variant of RT in in vitro reaction mixtures containing synthetic template primers. The E89G RT was previously shown to be resistant to several ddNTPs and to phosphonoformic acid. Our results show that the mutant enzyme displays a lower level of efficiency of misinsertion than did the wild-type RT for every mispair tested (ranging from 2- to 17-fold.

Role of the "helix clamp" in HIV-1 reverse transcriptase catalytic cycling as revealed by alanine-scanning mutagenesis

Residues 259-284 of HIV-1 reverse transcriptase exhibit sequence homology with other nucleic acid polymerases and have been termed the "helix clamp" (Hermann, T., Meier, T., Gotte, M., and Heumann, H. (1994) Nucleic Acids Res. 22, 4625-4633), since crystallographic evidence indicates these residues are part of two alpha-helices (alpha H and alpha I) that interact with DNA. Alanine-scanning mutagenesis has previously demonstrated that several residues in alpha H make important interactions with nucleic acid and influence frameshift fidelity. To define the role of alpha I (residues 278-286) during catalytic cycling, we performed systematic site-directed mutagenesis from position 277 through position 287 by changing each residue, one by one, to alanine. Each mutant protein was expressed and, except for L283A and T286A, was soluble. The soluble mutant enzymes were purified and characterized. In contrast to alanine mutants of alpha H, alanine substitution in alpha I did not have a significant effect on template.primer (T.P) binding as revealed by a lack of an effect on Km, T.P, Ki for 3'-azido-2',3'-dideoxythymidine 5'-triphosphate, koff, T.P and processivity. Consistent with these observations, the fidelity of the mutant enzymes was not influenced. However, alanine mutagenesis of alpha I lowered the apparent activity of every mutant relative to wild-type enzyme. Titration of two mutants exhibiting the lowest activity with T.P (L282A and R284A) demonstrated that these mutant enzymes could bind T.P stoichiometrically and tightly. In contrast, active site concentrations determined from "burst" experiments suggest that the lower activity is due to a smaller populations of enzyme bound productively to T.P. The putative electrostatic interactions between the basic side chains of the helix clamp and the DNA backbone are either very weak or kinetically silent. In contrast, interactions between several residues of alpha H and the DNA minor groove, 3-5 nucleotides from the 3'-primer terminus, are suggested to be critical for DNA binding and fidelity.

Role of methionine 184 of human immunodeficiency virus type-1 reverse transcriptase in the polymerase function and fidelity of DNA synthesis

Methionine 184 of HIV-1 RT is a constituent of the catalytically crucial and highly conserved YXDD motif in the reverse transcriptase class of enzymes. We investigated the role of this residue by substituting it with Ala and Val by site-directed mutagenesis followed by extensive characterization of the two mutant enzymes. The kinetic parameters governing DNA synthesis directed by RNA and DNA templates indicated that both M184A and M184V mutants are catalytically as efficient as the wild type enzyme. Photoaffinity labeling of both the mutant and the wild type enzyme exhibited an identical affinity for RNA-DNA and DNA-DNA template primers. We further demonstrate that M-->V substitution at 184 position significantly increases the fidelity of DNA synthesis while M-->A substitution results in a highly error-prone enzyme without having compromised its efficiency of DNA synthesis. The M184V mutant exhibited a 25-45-fold increase in mismatch selectivity (ratio of k(cat)/K(m) of correct versus incorrect nucleotides) as compared to the WT enzyme. This pattern of error-prone synthesis is also confirmed by examining the abilities of the enzyme-(template-primer) covalent complexes to incorporate correct versus incorrect nucleotide onto the immobilized template-primer. The nature of error-prone synthesis by the M184A mutant shows an increase in both the mismatch synthesis and extension of the mismatched primer termini. Using a three-dimensional molecular model of the ternary complex of HIV-1 RT, template-primer, and dNTP, we observe that the strategic location of M184 may allow it to interact with the sugar moiety of either the primer nucleotide or the dNTP substrate.

Site-directed mutagenesis of arginine 72 of HIV-1 reverse transcriptase. Catalytic role and inhibitor sensitivity

In order to determine the catalytic role of Arg72 of HIV-1 reverse transcriptase (RT), we carried out site-directed mutagenesis at codon 72. Two mutant proteins (R72A and R72K) were purified and characterized. With Arg to Ala substitution the kcat of the polymerase reaction was reduced by nearly 100-fold with poly(rA) template, but only about 5-15-fold with poly(rC) and poly(dC) templates. The Arg to Lys substitution exhibited a qualitatively similar pattern, although the overall reduction in kcat was less severe. Most interestingly, we noted a large difference in the rate constant of the first and second nucleotide incorporation by R72A, suggesting that Arg72 participates in the reaction after the formation of the first phosphodiester bond. We propose this step to be the pyrophosphate binding and removal step following the nucleotidyltransferase reaction. Support for this proposal is obtained from the observation that the R72A mutant (i) exhibited a pronounced translocation defect in the processivity analysis, (ii) lacked the ability to catalyze pyrophosphorolysis, and (iii) showed complete resistance to phosphonoformate, an analog of PPi.Arg72 is the first residue of HIV-1 RT proposed to be involved in the pyrophosphate binding/removal function of RT.

Reduced frameshift fidelity and processivity of HIV-1 reverse transcriptase mutants containing alanine substitutions in helix H of the thumb subdomain

We have analyzed two human immunodeficiency virus (HIV-1) reverse transcriptase mutants of helix H in the thumb subdomain suggested by x-ray crystallography to interact with the primer strand of the template-primer. These enzymes, G262A and W266A, were previously shown to have greatly elevated dissociation rate constants for template-primer and to be much less sensitive to inhibition by 3'-azidodeoxythymidine 5'-triphosphate. Here we describe their processivity and error specificity. The results reveal that: (i) both enzymes have reduced processivity and lower fidelity for template-primer slippage errors, (ii) they differ from each other in sequence-dependent termination of processive synthesis and in error specificity, and (iii) the magnitude of the mutator effect relative to wild-type enzyme for deletions in homopolymeric sequences decreases as the length of the run increases. Thus amino acid substitutions in a subdomain thought to interact with the duplex template-primer confer a strand slippage mutator phenotype to a replicative DNA polymerase. This suggests that interactions between specific amino acids and the primer stem at positions well removed from the active site are critical determinants of processivity and fidelity. These effects, obtained in aqueous solution during catalytic cycling, are consistent with and support the existing crystallographic structural model.