Differential gene expression governed by chromosomal spatial asymmetry

Characterization of a novel inhibitory feedback of the anti-anti-sigma SpoIIAA on Spo0A activation during development in Bacillus subtilis

Compartmentalized gene expression during sporulation is initiated after asymmetric division by cell-specific activation of the transcription factors sigmaF and sigmaE. Synthesis of these sigma factors, and their regulatory proteins, requires the activation (phosphorylation) of Spo0A by the phosphorelay signalling system. We report here a novel regulatory function of the anti-anti-sigmaF SpoIIAA as inhibitor of Spo0A activation. This effect did not require sigmaF activity, and it was abolished by expression of the phosphorelay-independent form Spo0A-Sad67 indicating that SpoIIAA directly interfered with Spo0A approximately P generation. IPTG-directed synthesis of the SpoIIE phosphatase in a strain carrying a multicopy plasmid coding for SpoIIAA and its specific inhibitory kinase SpoIIAB blocked Spo0A activation suggesting that the active form of the inhibitor was SpoIIAA and not SpoIIAA-P. Furthermore, expression of the non-phosphorylatable mutant SpoIIAAS58A (SpoIIAA-like), but not SpoIIAAS58D (SpoIIAA-P-like), completely blocked Spo0A-dependent gene expression. Importantly, SpoIIAA expressed from the chromosome under the control of its normal spoIIA promoter showed the same negative effect regulated not only by SpoIIAB and SpoIIE but also by septum morphogenesis. These findings are discussed in relation to the potential contribution of this novel inhibitory feedback with the proper activation of sigmaF and sigmaE during development.

Transient genetic asymmetry and cell fate in a bacterium

Certain species of Gram-positive bacteria can initiate a developmental program that results in the formation of two daughter cells with different fates. One cell develops into a spore and the other cell undergoes programmed lysis, with each process being mediated by a cascade of cell-type-specific transcription factors. An early and critical step in this developmental pathway is the formation of a division septum near one pole, creating two compartments of different sizes. But how is this morphological asymmetry translated into the transcriptional asymmetry of the two compartments? Recent results suggest that the chromosomal position of the genes encoding several key components of the transcriptional regulatory network has an important role in this process.

Generating and exploiting polarity in bacteria

Bacteria are often highly polarized, exhibiting specialized structures at or near the ends of the cell. Among such structures are actin-organizing centers, which mediate the movement of certain pathogenic bacteria within the cytoplasm of an animal host cell; organized arrays of membrane receptors, which govern chemosensory behavior in swimming bacteria; and asymmetrically positioned septa, which generate specialized progeny in differentiating bacteria. This polarization is orchestrated by complex and dynamic changes in the subcellular localization of signal transduction and cytoskeleton proteins as well as of specific regions of the chromosome. Recent work has provided information on how dynamic subcellular localization occurs and how it is exploited by the bacterial cell. The main task of a bacterial cell is to survive and duplicate itself. The bacterium must replicate its genetic material and divide at the correct site in the cell and at the correct time in the cell cycle with high precision. Each kind of bacterium also executes its own strategy to find nutrients in its habitat and to cope with conditions of stress from its environment. This involves moving toward food, adapting to environmental extremes, and, in many cases, entering and exploiting a eukaryotic host. These activities often involve processes that take place at or near the poles of the cell. Here we explore some of the schemes bacteria use to orchestrate dynamic changes at their poles and how these polar events execute cellular functions. In spite of their small size, bacteria have a remarkably complex internal organization and external architecture. Bacterial cells are inherently asymmetric, some more obviously so than others. The most easily recognized asymmetries involve surface structures, e.g., flagella, pili, and stalks that are preferentially assembled at one pole by many bacteria. "New" poles generated at the cell division plane differ from old poles from the previous round of cell division. Even in Escherichia coli, which is generally thought to be symmetrical, old poles are more static than new poles with respect to cell wall assembly (1), and they differ in the deposition of phospholipid domains (2). There are many instances of differential polar functions; among these is the preferential use of old poles when attaching to host cells as in the interaction of Bradyrhizobium with plant root hairs (3) or the polar pili-mediated attachment of the Pseudomonas aeruginosa pathogen to tracheal epithelia (4). An unusual polar organelle that mediates directed motility on solid surfaces is found in the nonpathogenic bacterium Myxococcus xanthus. The gliding motility of this bacterium is propelled by a nozzle-like structure that squirts a polysaccharide-containing slime from the pole of the cell (5). Interestingly, M. xanthus, which has nozzles at both poles, can reverse direction by closing one nozzle and opening the other in response to end-to-end interactions between cells.

MinCD-dependent regulation of the polarity of SpoIIIE assembly and DNA transfer

During Bacillus subtilis sporulation, the SpoIIIE DNA translocase moves a trapped chromosome across the sporulation septum into the forespore. The direction of DNA translocation is controlled by the specific assembly of SpoIIIE in the mother cell and subsequent export of DNA into the forespore. We present evidence that the MinCD heterodimer, which spatially regulates cell division during vegetative growth, serves as a forespore-specific inhibitor of SpoIIIE assembly. The deletion of minCD increases the ability of forespore-expressed SpoIIIE to assemble and translocate DNA, and causes otherwise wild-type cells to reverse the direction of DNA transfer, producing anucleate forespores. We propose that two distinct mechanisms ensure the specific assembly of SpoIIIE in the mother cell, the partitioning of more SpoIIIE molecules into the larger mother cell by asymmetric cell division and the MinCD-dependent repression of SpoIIIE assembly in the forespore. Our results suggest that the ability of MinCD to sense positional information is utilized during sporulation to regulate protein assembly differentially on the two faces of the sporulation septum.

AAA+ proteins and substrate recognition, it all depends on their partner in crime

Members of the AAA+ superfamily have been identified in all organisms studied to date. They are involved in a wide range of cellular events. In bacteria, representatives of this superfamily are involved in functions as diverse as transcription and protein degradation and play an important role in the protein quality control network. Often they employ a common mechanism to mediate an ATP-dependent unfolding/disassembly of protein-protein or DNA-protein complexes. In an increasing number of examples it appears that the activities of these AAA+ proteins may be modulated by a group of otherwise unrelated proteins, called adaptor proteins. These usually small proteins specifically modify the substrate recognition of their AAA+ partner protein. The occurrence of such adaptor proteins are widespread; representatives have been identified not only in Escherichia coli but also in Bacillus subtilis, not to mention yeast and other eukaryotic organisms. Interestingly, from the currently known examples, it appears that the N domain of AAA+ proteins (the most divergent region of the protein within the family) provides a common platform for the recognition of these diverse adaptor proteins. Finally, the use of adaptor proteins to modulate AAA+ activity is, in some cases, an elegant way to redirect the activity of an AAA+ protein towards a particular substrate without necessarily affecting other activities of that AAA+ protein while, in other cases, the adaptor protein triggers a complete switch in AAA+ activity.

The cell differentiation protein SpoIIE contains a regulatory site that controls its phosphatase activity in response to asymmetric septation

Starvation induces Bacillus subtilis to initiate a -simple, two-cell developmental process that begins with an asymmetric cell division. Activation of the first compartment-specific transcription factor, sigmaF, is coupled to this morphological event. SpoIIE, a bifunctional protein, is essential for the compartment-specific activation of sigmaF and also has a morphogenic activity required for asymmetric cell division. SpoIIE consists of three domains: a hydrophobic N-terminal domain, which targets the protein to the membrane; a central domain, involved in oligomerization of SpoIIE and interaction with the cell division protein FtsZ; and a C-terminal domain comprising a PP2C protein phosphatase. Here, we report the isolation of mutations at the very beginning of the central domain of spoIIE, which are capable of activating sigmaF inde-pendently of septum formation. Purified mutant proteins showed the same phosphatase activity as the wild-type protein in vitro. The mutant proteins were fully functional in respect of their localization to sites of asymmetric septation and support of asymmetric division. The data provide strong evidence that the phosphatase domain of SpoIIE is tightly regulated in a way that makes it respond to the formation of the asymmetric septum.

A sporulation membrane protein tethers the pro-sigmaK processing enzyme to its inhibitor and dictates its subcellular localization

The developmental transcription factor sigmaK is derived from the inactive precursor protein pro-sigmaK by regulated proteolysis during the process of sporulation in the bacterium Bacillus subtilis. The putative pro-sigmaK processing enzyme SpoIVFB is a member of a family of membrane-embedded metalloproteases and is held inactive by two other integral membrane proteins, SpoIVFA and BofA. Herein we show that the processing enzyme and its two regulators exist in a multimeric complex that localizes to the membrane surrounding the developing spore (the forespore). We further show that one of the regulators, SpoIVFA, plays a central role in both the formation of this complex and its subcellular localization. Evidence is presented in support of a model in which SpoIVFA acts as a platform for bringing BofA and SpoIVFB together, whereby BofA inhibits pro-sigmaK processing until a signal has been received from the forespore.

Developmental biology: regulation by selective gene localization

Recent studies have shown that, early during sporulation in Bacillus subtilis, the temporary exclusion of 70% of the chromosome from the forespore compartment is critical to the regulated activation of two major transcription factors, sigma(F) and sigma(E).

Morphological coupling in development: lessons from prokaryotes

At certain junctures in development, gene transcription is coupled to the completion of landmark morphological events. We refer to this dependence on morphogenesis for gene expression as "morphological coupling." Three examples of morphological coupling in prokaryotes are reviewed in which the activation of a transcription factor is tied to the assembly of a critically important structure in development.