An RNA polymerase mutant with reduced accuracy of chain elongation

Transcriptional infidelity promotes heritable phenotypic change in a bistable gene network

Bistable epigenetic switches are fundamental for cell fate determination in unicellular and multicellular organisms. Regulatory proteins associated with bistable switches are often present in low numbers and subject to molecular noise. It is becoming clear that noise in gene expression can influence cell fate. Although the origins and consequences of noise have been studied, the stochastic and transient nature of RNA errors during transcription has not been considered in the origin or modeling of noise nor has the capacity for such transient errors in information transfer to generate heritable phenotypic change been discussed. We used a classic bistable memory module to monitor and capture transient RNA errors: the lac operon of Escherichia coli comprises an autocatalytic positive feedback loop producing a heritable all-or-none epigenetic switch that is sensitive to molecular noise. Using single-cell analysis, we show that the frequency of epigenetic switching from one expression state to the other is increased when the fidelity of RNA transcription is decreased due to error-prone RNA polymerases or to the absence of auxiliary RNA fidelity factors GreA and GreB (functional analogues of eukaryotic TFIIS). Therefore, transcription infidelity contributes to molecular noise and can effect heritable phenotypic change in genetically identical cells in the same environment. Whereas DNA errors allow genetic space to be explored, RNA errors may allow epigenetic or expression space to be sampled. Thus, RNA infidelity should also be considered in the heritable origin of altered or aberrant cell behaviour.

Potential role of phenotypic mutations in the evolution of protein expression and stability

Phenotypic mutations (errors occurring during protein synthesis) are orders of magnitude more frequent than genetic mutations. Consequently, the sequences of individual protein molecules transcribed and translated from the same gene can differ. To test the effects of such mutations, we established a bacterial system in which an antibiotic resistance gene (TEM-1 beta-lactamase) was transcribed by either a high-fidelity RNA polymerase or its error-prone mutant. This setup enabled the analysis of individual mRNA transcripts that were synthesized under normal or error-prone conditions. We found that an increase of approximately 20-fold in the frequency of transcription errors promoted the evolution of higher TEM-1 expression levels and of more stable enzyme variants. The stabilized variants exhibited a distinct advantage under error-prone transcription, although under normal transcription they conferred resistance similar to wild-type TEM-1. They did so, primarily, by increasing TEM-1's tolerance to destabilizing deleterious mutations that arise from transcriptional errors. The stabilized TEM-1 variants also showed increased tolerance to genetic mutations. Thus, although phenotypic mutations are not individually subjected to inheritance and natural selection, as are genetic mutations, they collectively exert a direct and immediate effect on protein fitness. They may therefore play a role in shaping protein traits such as expression levels, stability, and tolerance to genetic mutations.

Transient reversal of RNA polymerase II active site closing controls fidelity of transcription elongation

To study fidelity of RNA polymerase II (Pol II), we analyzed properties of the 6-azauracil-sensitive and TFIIS-dependent E1103G mutant of rbp1 (rpo21), the gene encoding the catalytic subunit of Pol II in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Using an in vivo retrotransposition-based transcription fidelity assay, we observed that rpb1-E1103G causes a 3-fold increase in transcription errors. This mutant showed a 10-fold decrease in fidelity of transcription elongation in vitro. The mutation does not appear to significantly affect translocation state equilibrium of Pol II in a stalled elongation complex. Primarily, it promotes NTP sequestration in the polymerase active center. Furthermore, pre-steady-state analyses revealed that the E1103G mutation shifted the equilibrium between the closed and the open active center conformations toward the closed form. Thus, open conformation of the active center emerges as an intermediate essential for preincorporation fidelity control. Similar mechanisms may control fidelity of DNA-dependent DNA polymerases and RNA-dependent RNA polymerases.

Phenotypic mutation rates and the abundance of abnormal proteins in yeast

Phenotypic mutations are errors that occur during protein synthesis. These errors lead to amino acid substitutions that give rise to abnormal proteins. Experiments suggest that such errors are quite common. We present a model to study the effect of phenotypic mutation rates on the amount of abnormal proteins in a cell. In our model, genes are regulated to synthesize a certain number of functional proteins. During this process, depending on the phenotypic mutation rate, abnormal proteins are generated. We use data on protein length and abundance in Saccharomyces cerevisiae to parametrize our model. We calculate that for small phenotypic mutation rates most abnormal proteins originate from highly expressed genes that are on average nearly twice as large as the average yeast protein. For phenotypic mutation rates much above 5 × 10⁻⁴, the error-free synthesis of large proteins is nearly impossible and lowly expressed, very large proteins contribute more and more to the amount of abnormal proteins in a cell. This fact leads to a steep increase of the amount of abnormal proteins for phenotypic mutation rates above 5 × 10⁻⁴. Simulations show that this property leads to an upper limit for the phenotypic mutation rate of approximately 2 × 10⁻³ even if the costs for abnormal proteins are extremely low. We also consider the adaptation of individual proteins. Individual genes/proteins can decrease their phenotypic mutation rate by using preferred codons or by increasing their robustness against amino acid substitutions. We discuss the similarities and differences between the two mechanisms and show that they can only slow down but not prevent the rapid increase of the amount of abnormal proteins. Our work allows us to estimate the phenotypic mutation rate based on data on the fraction of abnormal proteins. For S. cerevisiae, we predict that the value for the phenotypic mutation rate is between 2 × 10⁻⁴ and 6 × 10⁻⁴.

A functional protein machinery, built from genetic information, is central to every living organism. Surprisingly, the decoding of genes into amino acid sequences is fairly inaccurate. Errors in this process (phenotypic mutations) are several orders of magnitude more frequent than errors during DNA replication (genotypic mutations). Many researchers have explored the evolution of genotypic mutation rates, but there are as yet few investigations into the evolutionary dynamics of phenotypic mutation rates. Here we present a mathematical model that describes the effect of phenotypic mutation on the amount of abnormal proteins in cells. We parameterize our model using data from yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae). We show that for phenotypic mutation rates above 5 × 10⁻⁴ per amino acid, the error-free synthesis of large proteins becomes nearly impossible. We estimate the phenotypic mutation rate of S. cerevisiae to be between 2 × 10⁻⁴ and 6 × 10⁻⁴ per amino acid.

Fluctuations, pauses, and backtracking in DNA transcription

Transcription is a vital stage in the process of gene expression and a major contributor to fluctuations in gene expression levels for which it is typically modeled as a single-step process with Poisson statistics. However, recent single molecule experiments raise questions about the validity of such a simple single-step picture. We present a molecular multistep model of transcription elongation that demonstrates that transcription times are in general non-Poisson-distributed. In particular, we model transcriptional pauses due to backtracking of the RNA polymerase as a first passage process. By including such pauses, we obtain a broad, heavy-tailed distribution of transcription elongation times, which can be significantly longer than would be otherwise. When transcriptional pauses result in long transcription times, we demonstrate that this naturally leads to bursts of mRNA production and non-Poisson statistics of mRNA levels. These results suggest that transcriptional pauses may be a significant contributor to the variability in transcription rates with direct implications for noise in cellular processes as well as variability between cells.

Selectivity and proofreading both contribute significantly to the fidelity of RNA polymerase III transcription

We examine here the mechanisms ensuring the fidelity of RNA synthesis by RNA polymerase III (Pol III). Misincorporation could only be observed by using variants of Pol III deficient in the intrinsic RNA cleavage activity. Determination of relative rates of the reactions producing correct and erroneous transcripts at a specific position on a tRNA gene, combined with computational methods, demonstrated that Pol III has a highly efficient proofreading activity increasing its transcriptional fidelity by a factor of 10(3) over the error rate determined solely by selectivity (1.8 x 10(-4)). We show that Pol III slows down synthesis past a misincorporation to achieve efficient proofreading. We discuss our findings in the context of transcriptional fidelity studies performed on RNA Pols, proposing that the fidelity of transcription is more crucial for Pol III than Pol II.

Template Misalignment in Multisubunit RNA Polymerases and Transcription Fidelity

Recent work showed that the single-subunit T7 RNA polymerase (RNAP) can generate misincorporation errors by a mechanism that involves misalignment of the DNA template strand. Here, we show that the same mechanism can produce errors during transcription by the multisubunit yeast RNAP II and bacterial RNAPs. Fluorescence spectroscopy reveals a reorganization of the template strand during this process, and molecular modeling suggests an open space above the polymerase active site that could accommodate a misaligned base. Substrate competition assays indicate that template misalignment, not misincorporation, is the preferred mechanism for substitution errors by cellular RNAPs. Misalignment could account for data previously taken as evidence for additional NTP binding sites downstream of the active site. Analysis of the effects of different template topologies on misincorporation indicates that the duplex DNA immediately downstream of the active site plays an important role in transcription fidelity.

Kinetic investigation of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase mutants that influence nucleotide discrimination and transcription fidelity

Recent RNA polymerase (RNAP) structures led to a proposed three-step model of nucleoside triphosphate (NTP) binding, discrimination, and incorporation. NTPs are thought to enter through the secondary channel, bind to an E site, rotate into a pre-insertion (PS) site, and ultimately align in the catalytic (A) site. We characterized the kinetics of correct and incorrect incorporation for several Escherichia coli RNAPs with substitutions in the proposed NTP entry pore (secondary channel). Substitutions of the semi-conserved residue betaAsp(675), which is >10A away from these sites, significantly reduce fidelity; however, substitutions of the totally conserved residues betaArg(678) and betaAsp(814) do not significantly alter the correct or incorrect incorporation kinetics, even though the corresponding residues in RNAPII crystal structures appear to be interacting with the NTP phosphate groups and coordinating the second magnesium ion in the active site, respectively. Structural analysis suggests that the lower fidelity of the betaAsp(675) mutants most likely results from reduction of the negative potential of a small pore between the E and PS sites and elimination of several structural interactions around the pore. We suggest a mechanism of nucleotide discrimination that is governed both by rotation of the NTP through this pore and subsequent rearrangement or closure of RNAP to align the NTP in the A site.

RNA polymerase II subunit Rpb9 is important for transcriptional fidelity in vivo

The fidelity of yeast RNA polymerase II (Pol II) was assessed in vivo with an assay in which errors in transcription of can1-100, a nonsense allele of CAN1, result in enhanced sensitivity to the toxic arginine analog canavanine. The Pol II accessory factor TFIIS has been proposed to play a role in transcript editing by stimulating the intrinsic nuclease activity of the RNA polymerase. However, deletion of DST1, the gene encoding the yeast homolog of TFIIS, had only a small effect on transcriptional fidelity, as determined by this assay. In contrast, strains containing a deletion of RPB9, which encodes a small core subunit of Pol II, were found to engage in error-prone transcription. rpb9Delta strains also had increased steady-state levels of can1-100 mRNA, consistent with transcriptional errors that decrease the normal sensitivity of the can1-100 transcript to nonsense-mediated decay, a pathway that degrades mRNAs with premature stop codons. Sequences of cDNAs from rpb9Delta strains confirmed a significantly increased occurrence of transcriptional substitutions and insertions. These results suggest that Rpb9 plays an important role in maintaining transcriptional fidelity, whereas TFIIS may serve a different primary purpose.

Model-based inference of gene expression dynamics from sequence information

A dynamic model of prokaryotic gene expression is developed that makes considerable use of gene sequence information. The main contribution arises from the fact that the combined gene expression model allows us to access the impact of altering a nucleotide sequence on the dynamics of gene expression rates mechanistically. The high level of detail of the mathematical model is considered as an important step towards bringing together the tremendous amount of biological in-depth knowledge that has been accumulated at the molecular level, using a systems level analysis (in the sense of a bottom-up, inductive approach). This enables to the model to provide highly detailed insights into the various steps of the protein expression process and it allows us to access possible targets for model-based design. Taken as a whole, the mathematical gene expression model presented in this study provides a comprehensive framework for a thorough analysis of sequence-related effects on the stages of mRNA synthesis, mRNA degradation and ribosomal translation, as well as their nonlinear interconnectedness. Therefore, it may be useful in the rational design of recombinant bacterial protein synthesis systems, the modulation of enzyme activities in pathway design, in vitro protein biosynthesis, and RNA-based vaccination.

Lethal mutagenesis of HIV

HIV-1 and other retroviruses exhibit mutation rates that are 1,000,000-fold greater than their host organisms. Error-prone viral replication may place retroviruses and other RNA viruses near the threshold of "error catastrophe" or extinction due to an intolerable load of deleterious mutations. Strategies designed to drive viruses to error catastrophe have been applied to HIV-1 and a number of RNA viruses. Here, we review the concept of extinguishing HIV infection by "lethal mutagenesis" and consider the utility of this new approach in combination with conventional antiretroviral strategies.

Host RNA polymerase II makes minimal contributions to retroviral frame-shift mutations

The rate of mutation during retrovirus replication is high. Mutations can occur during transcription of the viral genomic RNA from the integrated provirus or during reverse transcription from viral RNA to form viral DNA or during replication of the proviral DNA as the host cell is dividing. Therefore, three polymerases may all contribute to retroviral evolution: host RNA polymerase II, viral reverse transcriptases and host DNA polymerases, respectively. Since the rate of mutation for host DNA polymerase is very low, mutations are more likely to be caused by the host RNA polymerase II and/or the viral reverse transcriptase. A system was established to detect the frequency of frame-shift mutations caused by cellular RNA polymerase II, as well as the rate of retroviral mutation during a single cycle of replication in vivo. In this study, it was determined that RNA polymerase II contributes less than 3 % to frame-shift mutations that occur during retrovirus replication. Therefore, the majority of frame-shift mutations detected within the viral genome are the result of errors during reverse transcription.

Transcription elongation factor S-II maintains transcriptional fidelity and confers oxidative stress resistance

BACKGROUND

During transcription elongation, RNA polymerase II is arrested on the template when incorrect ribonucleotides are incorporated into the nascent transcripts. Transcription factor S-II enhances the excision of these mis-incorporated nucleotides by RNA polymerase II and stimulates transcription elongation in vitro. This mechanism is considered to be transcriptional proof-reading, but its physiological relevance remains unknown.

RESULTS

We report that S-II contributes to the maintenance of transcriptional fidelity in vivo. We employed a genetic reporter assay utilizing a mutated lacZ gene from which active beta-galactosidase protein is expressed when mRNA proof-reading is compromised. In S-II-disrupted mutant yeasts, beta-galactosidase activity was ninefold higher than that in wild-type. The S-II mutant exhibited sensitivity to oxidants, which was suppressed by introduction of the S-II gene. The mutant S-II proteins, which are unable to stimulate transcription by RNA polymerase II in vitro, did not suppress the sensitivity of the mutants to oxidative stress or maintain transcriptional fidelity.

CONCLUSION

These results suggest that S-II confers oxidative stress resistance by providing an mRNA proof-reading mechanism during transcription elongation.

Cell-selfish modes of evolution and mutations directed after transcriptional bypass

During transcription, prokaryotic and eukaryotic RNA polymerases bypass and misread (transcriptional mutagenesis) several classes of DNA lesions. For example, misreading of 8-OH-dG generates mRNAs containing G to T transversions. After translation, if the mutant protein briefly allowed the cell a growth-DNA replication advantage, then precocious DNA replication would bypass that unrepaired 8-OH-dG and misinsert dA opposite the directing DNA lesion with a higher probability than would be experienced for 8-OH-G lesions at other positions in otherwise identical neighboring cells. Such retromutations would have been tested for their imparted growth advantage as mRNA before they became heritable DNA mutations. The logical properties of a mode of evolution that utilizes directed-retromutagenesis were compared one by one with those of the standard neo-Darwinian mode. The retromutagenesis mode, while minimizing mutational load, is cell-selfish; fitness is for an immediate growth advantage rather than future reproductive potential. In prokaryotes, an evolutionary mode that involves standard Darwinian fitness testing of novel alleles in the genetic background of origin followed by clonal expansion also favors cell-selfish allele combinations when linkage disequilibrium is practiced. For metazoa and plants to have evolved organized tissues, cell-selfish modes of evolution represent systems-poisons that must be totally suppressed. The feedback loops that allow evolution to be cell-serving in prokaryotes are actively blocked in eukaryotes by traits that restrict fitness to future reproductive potential. These traits include (i) delay of fitness testing until after the mutation is made permanently heritable, (ii) diploidy to further delay fitness testing, (iii) segregation of somatic lines from germ lines, (iv) testing of novel alleles against randomized allele combinations constructed by obligate sex, and (v) obligate genetic death to insure that that the most basic systems unit of selfish allele combinatorial uniqueness is the species instead of the cell. The analyses indicate that modes of evolution in addition to our neo-Darwinian one could have existed utilizing known molecular mechanisms. The evolution of multicellularity was as much the discarding of old cell-selfish habits as the acquisition of new altruistic ones.

Use of an in vivo reporter assay to test for transcriptional and translational fidelity in yeast

Eukaryotic RNA polymerase II and Escherichia coli RNA polymerase possess an intrinsic ribonuclease activity that is stimulated by the polymerase-binding proteins SII and GreB, respectively. This factor-activated hydrolysis of nascent RNA has been postulated to be involved in transcription elongation as well as removal of incorrect bases misincorporated into RNA. Little is known about the frequency of misincorporation by RNA polymerases in vivo or about the mechanisms involved in improving RNA polymerase accuracy. Here we have developed a luciferase reporter system in an effort to assay for base misincorporation in living Saccharomyces cerevisiae. The assay employs a luciferase open reading frame that contains a premature stop codon. The inactive truncated enzyme would become active if misincorporation by RNA polymerase II took place at the stop triplet. Yeast lacking SII did not display a significant change in reporter activity when compared with wild-type cells. We estimate that under our assay conditions, mRNAs with a misincorporation at the test site could not exceed 1 transcript per 500 cells. The reporter assay was very effective in detecting the previously described process of nonsense suppression (translational read-through) by ribosomes, making it difficult to determine an absolute level of basal (SII-independent) misincorporation by RNA polymerase II. Although these data cannot exclude the possibility that SII is involved in proofreading, they make it unlikely that such a contribution is physiologically significant, especially relative to the high frequency of translational errors.

Missense translation errors in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

We describe the development of a novel plasmid-based assay for measuring the in vivo frequency of misincorporation of amino acids into polypeptide chains in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. The assay is based upon the measurement of the catalytic activity of an active site mutant of type III chloramphenicol acetyl transferase (CATIII) expressed in S. cerevisiae. A His195(CAC)-->Tyr195(UAC) mutant of CATIII is completely inactive, but catalytic activity can be restored by misincorporation of histidine at the mutant UAC codon. The average error frequency of misincorporation of histidine at this tyrosine UAC codon in wild-type yeast strains was measured as 0. 5x10(-5) and this frequency was increased some 50-fold by growth in the presence of paromomycin, a known translational-error-inducing antibiotic. A detectable frequency of misincorporation of histidine at a mutant Ala195 GCU codon was also measured as 2x10(-5), but in contrast to the Tyr195-->His195 misincorporation event, the frequency of histidine misincorporation at Ala195 GCU was not increased by paromomycin, inferring that this error did not result from miscognate codon-anticodon interaction. The His195 to Tyr195 missense error assay was used to demonstrate increased frequencies of missense error at codon 195 in SUP44 and SUP46 mutants. These two mutants have previously been shown to exhibit a translation termination error phenotype and the sup44+ and sup46+ genes encode the yeast ribosomal proteins S4 and S9, respectively. These data represent the first accurate in vivo measurement of a specific mistranslation event in a eukaryotic cell and directly confirm that the eukaryotic ribosome plays an important role in controlling missense errors arising from non-cognate codon-anticodon interactions.

Counteraction by MutT protein of transcriptional errors caused by oxidative damage

Oxidized guanine (8-oxo-7,8-dihydroguanine; 8-oxo-G) is a potent mutagen because of its ambiguous pairing with cytosine and adenine. The Escherichia coli MutT protein specifically hydrolyzes both 8-oxo-deoxyguanosine triphosphate (8-oxo-dGTP) and 8-oxo-guanosine triphosphate (8-oxo-rGTP), which are otherwise incorporated in DNA and RNA opposite template A. In vivo, this cleaning of the nucleotide pools decreases both DNA replication and transcription errors. The effect of mutT mutation on transcription fidelity was shown to depend on oxidative metabolism. Such control of transcriptional fidelity by the ubiquitous MutT function has implications for evolution of RNA-based life, phenotypic expression, adaptive mutagenesis, and functional maintenance of nondividing cells.

In vivo versus in vitro screening or selection for catalytic activity in enzymes and abzymes

The recent development of catalytic antibodies and the introduction of new techniques to generate huge libraries of random mutants of existing enzymes have created the need for powerful tools for finding in large populations of cells those producing the catalytically most active proteins. Several approaches have been developed and used to reach this goal. The screening techniques aim at easily detecting the clones producing active enzymes or abzymes; the selection techniques are designed to extract these clones from mixtures. These techniques have been applied both in vivo and in vitro. This review describes the advantages and limitations of the various methods in terms of ease of use, sensitivity, and convenience for handling large libraries. Examples are analyzed and tentative rules proposed. These techniques prove to be quite powerful to study the relationship between structure and function and to alter the properties of enzymes.

Differences in mutagenesis during minus strand, plus strand and strand transfer (recombination) synthesis of the HIV-1 gene in vitro

We have developed an HIV nef-Escherichia coli lacZ fusion system in vitro that allows the detection of low frequency mutations, including frameshifts, deletions and insertions. A portion of the nef gene that encompasses a hypervariable region was fused in-frame with a downstream lacZalpha peptide coding region. The resulting lacZalpha peptide fusion protein remained functional. Any frameshift mutations in the nef insert would put the downstream lacZ alpha peptide gene out of frame, eliminating alpha complementation. With this system we compared the error rates of frameshift mutations that arise during DNA-directed and RNA-directed DNA synthesis. Results showed that DNA-directed and RNA-directed DNA synthesis did not contribute equally to the generation of mutations. DNA-directed DNA synthesis generated frameshift mutations at a frequency approximately 10-fold higher than those arising from RNA-directed DNA synthesis. RNA-directed DNA synthesis in the presence of acceptor templates showed an increase in mutation rate and differences in the mutation spectrum. The enhancement of mutation rate was caused by the appearance of mutations at three new locations that correlated with likely recombination sites. Results indicate that recombination is another source of mutations during viral replication.

Mechanisms of retroviral mutation

Retroviruses, like other RNA viruses, mutate at very high rates (0.05-1 mutations per genome per replication cycle) and exist as complex genetically heterogeneous populations ('quasispecies') that are ever changing. De novo mutations are generated by inherently error-prone steps in the retroviral life cycle that introduce base substitutions, frame shifts, genetic rearrangements and hypermutations.

Short-patch reverse transcription in Escherichia coli

Chimeras of RNA and DNA have distinctive physical and biological properties. Chimeric oligonucleotides that contained one, two or three ribonucleotides whose phosphodiester backbone was covalently continuous with DNA were synthesized. Site-directed mutagenesis was used to assess genetic information transfer from the ribonucleotide positions. Transfer was scored by the formation or reversion of an ochre site that also corresponded to a restriction cleavage site. This allowed physical as well as genetic assay of mutational events. Bases attached to the ribonucleotides were able to accurately direct the synthesis of progeny DNA. The results suggest that in vivo DNA polymerases utilize a "running start" on a DNA backbone to continue across a covalent backbone junction into a region of ribonucleotides and then back again onto a normal DNA backbone. The phenomenon is designated short-patch reverse transcription (SPRT) by analogy to short-patch mismatch correction and reverse transcription as the term is generally used. The possibility is considered that SPRT contributes to an unrecognized pathway of mutagenesis.

A structural model for fidelity in transcription

Distances between the metal ions bound to the product terminus i site and the substrate i + 1 site of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase range from 5.0 to 5.6 A when the substrate is complementary to a template base and from 6.5 to 7.0 A for a noncomplementary relationship. The metal bound to the substrate at the i + 1 site exhibits a constant distance to the three phosphates on the substrate regardless of complementarity, but the distance to base and ribose protons changes. The differences in these geometric parameters are explained by the ability of the enzyme to assume two conformations, one to place correct nucleotide substrates in optimal position for bond formation and the other to prevent incorrect nucleotides from assuming such a position. In this scheme a metal-triphosphate complex can move toward or away from the terminal 3' OH group of the growing RNA chain, to assure fidelity of transcription.

Phosphorolytic error correction during transcription

Escherichia coli DNA-directed RNA polymerase is shown to contain a novel phosphorolytic error correction activity which removes erroneous nucleotides, as rNDPs, from the 3'-end of the growing transcript. The activity we describe is biochemically similar to polynucleotide phosphorylase (PNP), yet in contrast to PNP is activated by Mn2+. We demonstrate that the activity, which is mediated by Pi, is dependent on the presence of an incorrectly incorporated nucleotide at the leading 3'-end of the transcript. The correction activity we describe exhibits a 4 x 10(4)-fold preference for the excision of incorrect nucleotides from the transcript. These findings suggest the possibility that RNA phosphorolysis may play a critical role in the process of transcriptional proofreading.

Genetics of eukaryotic RNA polymerases I, II, and III

The transcription of nucleus-encoded genes in eukaryotes is performed by three distinct RNA polymerases termed I, II, and III, each of which is a complex enzyme composed of more than 10 subunits. The isolation of genes encoding subunits of eukaryotic RNA polymerases from a wide spectrum of organisms has confirmed previous biochemical and immunological data indicating that all three enzymes are closely related in structures that have been conserved in evolution. Each RNA polymerase is an enzyme complex composed of two large subunits that are homologous to the two largest subunits of prokaryotic RNA polymerases and are associated with smaller polypeptides, some of which are common to two or to all three eukaryotic enzymes. This remarkable conservation of structure most probably underlies a conservation of function and emphasizes the likelihood that information gained from the study of RNA polymerases from one organism will be applicable to others. The recent isolation of many mutations affecting the structure and/or function of eukaryotic and prokaryotic RNA polymerases now makes it feasible to begin integrating genetic and biochemical information from various species in order to develop a picture of these enzymes. The picture of eukaryotic RNA polymerases depicted in this article emphasizes the role(s) of different polypeptide regions in interaction with other subunits, cofactors, substrates, inhibitors, or accessory transcription factors, as well as the requirement for these interactions in transcription initiation, elongation, pausing, termination, and/or enzyme assembly. Most mutations described here have been isolated in eukaryotic organisms that have well-developed experimental genetic systems as well as amenable biochemistry, such as Saccharomyces cerevisiae, Drosophila melanogaster, and Caenorhabditis elegans. When relevant, mutations affecting regions of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase that are conserved among eukaryotes and prokaryotes are also presented. In addition to providing information about the structure and function of eukaryotic RNA polymerases, the study of mutations and of the pleiotropic phenotypes they imposed has underscored the central role played by these enzymes in many fundamental processes such as development and cellular differentiation.

Solution of the ribosome riddle: how the ribosome selects the correct aminoacyl-tRNA out of 41 similar contestants

Three tRNA binding sites, the A, P and E sites, have been demonstrated on ribosomes of bacterial, archaebacterial and eukaryotic origin. In all these cases the first and the third site, the A and the E site, are allosterically coupled in the sense of a negative co-operativity. Therefore, the allosteric three-site model seems to be a generally valid description of the ribosomal elongation phase, where in a cycle of reactions the nascent peptide chain is prolonged by one amino acid. The molecular concept of the allosteric three-site model explains the astonishing ability of the ribosome to select the correct substrate out of a large number of very similar substrates, and it provides a framework within which the mechanisms of the elongation factors could be understood.

Accuracy of wheat-germ RNA polymerase II. General enzymatic properties and effect of template conformational transition from right-handed B-DNA to left-handed Z-DNA

We investigated the accuracy of the insertion process in RNA chain elongation catalyzed by wheat germ RNA polymerase II. Error frequencies varied from 1 misinserted nucleotide per 250 polymerized correct substrates to less than 1 in 2 x 10(5), depending on template sequence and nature of the divalent metal cofactor. Higher error ratios were observed in the presence of Mn2+ compared to Mg2+, and with alternating poly[d(G-C)].poly[d(G-C)] compared to poly[d(A-T)].poly[d(A-T)]. In this latter case the eukaryotic RNA polymerase was as accurate as Escherichia coli RNA polymerase holo-enzyme. The fidelity of wheat germ RNA polymerase II was also examined in transcription of polynucleotide templates in the poly[d(G-C)] family adopting either the right-handed B or left-handed Z conformations. Error ratios for noncomplementary ATP increased markedly under experimental conditions favoring the B-to-Z conformational transition of the alternating copolymers. In accordance with the results of previous studies, the rate of productive elongation, i.e. the synthesis of poly[r(G-C)], was depressed, suggesting that the decreased accuracy of the enzyme derived from an altered competence of the enzyme to form elongation complexes on the left-handed DNA. As judged by the large difference in apparent Km values of the enzyme for complementary and noncomplementary nucleoside triphosphates, part of the discrimination between substrates seemed to take place at the initial binding step. Furthermore, the results indicate that wheat germ RNA polymerase II was able to elongate a primer with a 3'-terminal mismatch, and thus to incorporate the mismatched nucleotide stably in the nascent RAN. However, the probability of productive RNA chain elongation was much lower with noncognate than with the complementary substrates.

RNA virus populations as quasispecies

RNA virus mutation frequencies generally approach maximum tolerable levels, and create complex indeterminate quasispecies populations in infected hosts. This usually favors extreme rates of evolution, although periods of relative stasis or equilibrium, punctuated by rapid change may also occur (as for other life forms). Because complex quasispecies populations of RNA viruses arise probabilistically and differentially in every host, their compositions and exact roles in disease pathogenesis are indeterminate and their directions of evolution, and the nature and timing of "new" virus outbreaks are unpredictable.

Connections between translation, transcription and replication error-rates

The analysis of published data from E coli suggests that in all three processes of translation, transcription, and replication, a minority of errors are produced by sub-classes of error-prone components. These add to the basal level of errors a noise of about 10 to 30%. Each one of the three processes contributes to the noisiness of the two others in a loose manner: a large increase in one error-rate produces a moderate increase in another error-rate. The strongest influence is that of transcription on translation errors. There it is possible that a majority of the misacylation errors are produced during the encounter of a correct amino acyl-tRNA ligase with a mistranscribed tRNA. Extreme mutator mutants are expected to produce a moderate increase in translation errors.

The role of RNA polymerase in transcriptional fidelity

The overall transcription of DNA has previously been demonstrated to proceed at extremely high levels of accuracy. We review the evidence that the process of transcription is subject to proof-reading in the Hopfield sense. In addition, we speculate that the proof-reading activity associated with transcription is subject to cyclical phase transitions. That is, during periods of low processivity associated with initiation, RNA synthesis is relatively imprecise. The transition to the elongation phase of RNA synthesis, characterized by a shift to high processivity, is accompanied by enhanced proof-reading. A model for the damping of transcriptional errors, based on a PPi-mediated processive pyrophosphorolysis reaction, is discussed in terms of pausing during transcription.

Transcriptional slippage occurs during elongation at runs of adenine or thymine in Escherichia coli

A run of 11 adenine or thymine residues at the 5' end of an out-of-frame lacZ gene causes a high level of beta-galactosidase expression in E. coli. This effect was not observed for a run of guanine residues. Reverse transcription of mRNA isolated from E. coli containing the run of 11 A's reveals heterogeneity of transcript length while reverse transcription of mRNA isolated from S. cerevisiae containing the same gene shows no heterogeneity. Protein sequencing of the beta-galactosidase molecules derived from the out-of-frame construct containing a run of adenines reveals the addition of a lysine at the run. A new method was developed where messages small enough to allow resolution of single nucleotide differences on an acrylamide gel are electrophoresed, electroblotted onto nylon and probed. This confirmed the reverse transcription results and showed that additional residues can be added to transcripts derived from DNA containing 10 or 11 thymine residues. A mechanism for slippage is discussed where the A-U rich RNA-DNA hybrid can denature during elongation and rehybridize in an offset position, causing the addition of extra residues to the transcript.

Reversibility of nucleotide incorporation by Escherichia coli RNA polymerase, and its effect on fidelity

During transcription, Escherichia coli RNA polymerase is capable of removing the nucleotide that it has just added to a growing RNA chain, and this removal depends on the presence of small concentrations of pyrophosphate. Chemically, the removal reaction is simply the reversal of the incorporation reaction, and we have observed the generation of free triphosphate as a result. After the removal the enzyme can continue synthesis. To test whether this reaction can provide an error correction mechanism, misincorporation rates were measured at a single position in an RNA transcript by withholding the correct nucleotide for that position, measuring the amount of readthrough transcript, and analyzing the readthrough transcripts with nearest-neighbor analysis and enzymatic RNA sequencing. The removal of pyrophosphate increases the rate of misincorporation. We present a theory that explains how reversible incorporation can increase the available discrimination free energy between correct and incorrect nucleotides and therefore may increase the fidelity of transcription. The formation of a covalent phosphodiester bond allows discrimination on the basis of helical structure as well as base-pairing. We propose that the important discrimination step is the translocation of the enzyme from one site on the DNA template to the next, and that reversible incorporation is necessary in order to take full advantage of the maximum discrimination free energy.