A classical enzyme active center motif lacks catalytic competence until modulated electrostatically

Electrostatic properties in the catalytic site of papain: A possible regulatory mechanism for the reactivity of the ion pair

We present an analysis of the electrostatic properties in the catalytic site of papain (EC 3.4.22.2), an archetype enzyme of the C1 cysteine proteinase family, and we investigate their possible role in the formation, stabilization and regulation of the Cys25((-))...His159((+)) catalytic ion pair. The electrostatic properties were computed using a reassociation method based in multicentered multipolar expansions obtained from ab initio quantum calculations of overlapping protein fragments. Solvent effects were introduced by coupling the use of multicentered multipolar expansions to two continuum boundary element methods to solve the Poisson and the linearized Poisson-Boltzmann equations. The electrostatic profile found in the proton transfer region of papain showed that this enzyme has a well-defined electrostatic environment to favor the formation and stabilization of the catalytic ion pair. The papain catalytic site electrostatic profile can be considered as an electrostatic fingerprint of the papain family with the following characteristics: (i) the presence of a net electric field highly aligned in the (Cys25)-SG-->(His159)-ND1 direction; (ii) the electrostatic profile has a saddle-point character; (iii) it is basically a local environmental effect. Furthermore, our analysis describes a possible regulatory mechanism (the E(SG-->ND1) attenuation effect) controlling the ion pair reactivity and permits to infer the Asp57 acidic residue as the most probable candidate to act as the electrostatic modulator.

Variation in the pH-dependent pre-steady-state and steady-state kinetic characteristics of cysteine-proteinase mechanism: evidence for electrostatic modulation of catalytic-site function by the neighbouring carboxylate anion

The acylation and deacylation stages of the hydrolysis of N -acetyl-Phe-Gly methyl thionoester catalysed by papain and actinidin were investigated by stopped-flow spectral analysis. Differences in the forms of pH-dependence of the steady-state and pre-steady-state kinetic parameters support the hypothesis that, whereas for papain, in accord with the traditional view, the rate-determining step is the base-catalysed reaction of the acyl-enzyme intermediate with water, for actinidin it is a post-acylation conformational change required to permit release of the alcohol product and its replacement in the catalytic site by the key water molecule. Possible assignments of the kinetically influential p K (a) values, guided by the results of modelling, including electrostatic-potential calculations, and of the mechanistic roles of the ionizing groups, are discussed. It is concluded that Asp(161) is the source of a key electrostatic modulator (p K (a) 5.0+/-0.1) in actinidin, analogous to Asp(158) in papain, whose influence is not detected kinetically; it is always in the 'on' state because of its low p K (a) value (2.8+/-0.06).

Crystallographic structure at 1.6-A resolution of the human adenovirus proteinase in a covalent complex with its 11-amino-acid peptide cofactor: insights on a new fold

The crystal structure of the human adenovirus proteinase (AVP), a cysteine proteinase covalently bound to its 11-amino-acid peptide cofactor pVIc, has been solved to 1.6-A resolution with a crystallographic R-factor of 0.136, R(free)=0.179. The fold of AVP-pVIc is new and the structural basis for it is described in detail. The polypeptide chain of AVP folds into two domains. One domain contains a five-strand beta-sheet with two peripheral alpha-helices; this region represents the hydrophobic core of the protein. A second domain contains the N terminus, several C-terminal alpha-helices, and a small peripheral anti-parallel beta-sheet. The domains interact through an extended polar interface. pVIc spans the two domains like a strap, its C-terminal portion forming a sixth strand on the beta-sheet. The active site is in a long, deep groove located between the two domains. Portions are structurally similar to the active site of the prototypical cysteine proteinase papain, especially some of the Calpha backbone atoms (r.m.s. deviation of 0.354 A for 12 Calpha atoms). The active-site nucleophile of AVP, the conserved Cys(122), was shown to have a pK(a) of 4.5, close to the pK(a) of 3.0 for the nucleophile of papain, suggesting that a similar ion pair arrangement with His(54) may be present in AVP-pVIc. The interactions between AVP and pVIc include 24 non-beta-strand hydrogen bonds, six beta-strand hydrogen bonds and one covalent bond. Of the 204 amino acid residues in AVP, 33 are conserved among the many serotypes of adenovirus, and these aid in forming the active site groove, are involved in substrate specificity or interact between secondary structure elements.

The only active mutant of thymidylate synthase D169, a residue far from the site of methyl transfer, demonstrates the exquisite nature of enzyme specificity

Cysteine is the only variant of D169, a cofactor-binding residue in thymidylate synthase, that shows in vivo activity. The 2.4 A crystal structure of Escherichia coli thymidylate synthase D169C in a complex with dUMP and the antifolate CB3717 shows it to be an asymmetric dimer, with only one active site covalently bonded to dUMP. At the active site with covalently bound substrate, C169 S gamma adopts the roles of both carboxyl oxygens of D169, making a 3.6 A S...H[bond]N hydrogen bond to 3-NH of CB3717 and a 3.4 A water-mediated hydrogen bond to H212. Analogous hydrogen bonds formed during the enzyme reaction are important for cofactor binding and are postulated to contribute to catalysis. The C169 side chain is likely to be ionized, making it a better hydrogen bond acceptor than a neutral sulfhydryl group. At the second active site, C169 S gamma makes a shorter (3 A) hydrogen bond to the 3-NH of CB3717, CB3717 is approximately 1.5 A out of its binding site and there is no covalent bond between dUMP and the catalytic cysteine. Changes to partitioning among productive and non-productive conformations of reaction intermediates may contribute as much, if not more, to the diminished activity of this mutant than reduced stabilization of transition states.

Foot-and-mouth disease virus leader proteinase: a papain-like enzyme requiring an acidic environment in the active site

Foot-and-mouth disease virus leader proteinase (L(pro)), a papain-like cysteine proteinase, has six acidic amino acids between 4 A and 11 A of the catalytic dyad of Cys51 and His148. In contrast, in papain and related enzymes, only one acidic residue lies within this distance. We have examined by site-directed mutagenesis the importance of each of these residues for L(pro) self-processing and cleavage of its cellular substrate, eukaryotic initiation factor 4GI. Only substitution of the electrostatic charge of aspartate 164 affected enzyme activity. Thus, in contrast to the prototype papain, L(pro) activity requires a negative charge 4.5 A from the catalytic dyad.

Modulation of the electrostatic charge at the active site of foot-and-mouth-disease-virus leader proteinase, an unusual papain-like enzyme

The leader proteinase (L(pro)) of foot-and-mouth-disease virus is an unusual papain-like cysteine proteinase. Synthesized without an N-terminal pro precursor region, it frees itself from the growing polypeptide chain by cleavage at its own C-terminus. It also possesses a unique electrostatic environment around the active site, essentially due to Asp(163), which orients the catalytic histidine residue, and Asp(164); the equivalent residues in papain are Asn(175) and Ser(176). The importance of these residues for L(pro) activity was examined by site-directed mutagenesis. Replacement of Asp(163) with asparagine reduced activity by five-fold towards a hexapeptide substrate and slightly delayed self-processing when expressed in rabbit reticulocyte lysates. However, no effect on the cleavage of the only known cellular substrate of L(pro), eukaryotic initiation factor 4GI (eIF4GI), was observed. In contrast, replacement of Asp(164) by either alanine, asparagine or lysine abrogated activity towards the hexapeptide. Furthermore, in all cases, the onset of both self-processing and eIF4GI cleavage were significantly delayed; the reaction rates were also diminished compared with those of the wild-type enzyme. The alanine-substituted enzyme was least affected, followed by those substituted with asparagine and lysine. The double mutant protein in which both aspartate residues were replaced by asparagine was most severely affected; it failed to complete either self-processing or eIF4GI cleavage within 3 h, compared with the 8 min required by the wild-type enzyme. Hence, we propose that the electrostatic charge of Asp(164), and to a lesser extent that of Asp(163), is extremely important for L(pro) to attain full activity upon synthesis.

Variation in aspects of cysteine proteinase catalytic mechanism deduced by spectroscopic observation of dithioester intermediates, kinetic analysis and molecular dynamics simulations

The possibility of a slow post-acylation conformational change during catalysis by cysteine proteinases was investigated by using a new chromogenic substrate, N-acetyl-Phe-Gly methyl thionoester, four natural variants (papain, caricain, actinidin and ficin), and stopped-flow spectral analysis to monitor the pre-steady state formation of the dithioacylenzyme intermediates and their steady state hydrolysis. The predicted reversibility of acylation was demonstrated kinetically for actinidin and ficin, but not for papain or caricain. This difference between actinidin and papain was investigated by modelling using QUANTA and CHARMM. The weaker binding of hydrophobic substrates, including the new thionoester, by actinidin than by papain may not be due to the well-known difference in their S2-subsites, whereby that of actinidin in the free enzyme is shorter due to the presence of Met211. Molecular dynamics simulation suggests that during substrate binding the sidechain of Met211 moves to allow full access of a Phe sidechain to the S2-subsite. The highly anionic surface of actinidin may contribute to the specificity difference between papain and actinidin. During subsequent molecular dynamics simulations the P1 product, methanol, diffuses rapidly (over<8 ps) out of papain and caricain but 'lingers' around the active centre of actinidin. Uniquely in actinidin, an Asp142-Lys145 salt bridge allows formation of a cavity which appears to constrain diffusion of the methanol away from the catalytic site. The cavity then undergoes large scale movements (over 4.8 A) in a highly correlated manner, thus controlling the motions of the methanol molecule. The changes in this cavity that release the methanol might be those deduced kinetically.

Biochemical and X-ray crystallographic studies on shikimate kinase: the important structural role of the P-loop lysine

Shikimate kinase, despite low sequence identity, has been shown to be structurally a member of the nucleoside monophosphate (NMP) kinase family, which includes adenylate kinase. In this paper we have explored the roles of residues in the P-loop of shikimate kinase, which forms the binding site for nucleotides and is one of the most conserved structural features in proteins. In common with many members of the P-loop family, shikimate kinase contains a cysteine residue 2 amino acids upstream of the essential lysine residue; the side chains of these residues are shown to form an ion pair. The C13S mutant of shikimate kinase was found to be enzymatically active, whereas the K15M mutant was inactive. However, the latter mutant had both increased thermostability and affinity for ATP when compared to the wild-type enzyme. The structure of the K15M mutant protein has been determined at 1.8 A, and shows that the organization of the P-loop and flanking regions is heavily disturbed. This indicates that, besides its role in catalysis, the P-loop lysine also has an important structural role. The structure of the K15M mutant also reveals that the formation of an additional arginine/aspartate ion pair is the most likely reason for its increased thermostability. From studies of ligand binding it appears that, like adenylate kinase, shikimate kinase binds substrates randomly and in a synergistic fashion, indicating that the two enzymes have similar catalytic mechanisms.

Kinetic and titration methods for determination of active site contents of enzyme and catalytic antibody preparations

Kinetic characterization of enzymes and analogous catalysts such as catalytic antibodies requires knowledge of the molarity of functional sites. Various stoichiometric titration methods are available for the determination of active-site concentrations of some enzymes and these are exemplified in the second part of this article. Most of these are not general in that they require the existence of certain types of either intermediate or active-site residues that are susceptible to specific covalent modification. Thus they are not readily applicable to many enzymes and they are rarely available currently for titration of catalytic antibody active sites. In the first part of the article we discuss a general kinetic method for the investigation of active-site availability in preparations of macromolecular catalysts. The method involves steady-state kinetics to provide Vmax and Km and single-turnover first-order kinetics using excess of catalyst over substrate to provide the analogous parameters k(obs)lim and K(m)app. The active-site contents of preparations that contain only active catalyst (Ea) and inert material (Ei) may be calculated as [Ea](T) = Vmax)/k(obs)lim. This is true even if nonproductive binding to E(a) occurs. For polyclonal catalytic antibody preparations, which may contain binding but noncatalytic material (Eb) in addition to Ea and Ei, the significance of Vmax/k(obs)lim is more complex but provides an upper limit to E(a). This can be refined by consideration of the relative values of Km and the equilibrium dissociation constant of EbS. Analysis of the Ea, Eb, Ei system requires the separate determination of Ei. For catalytic antibodies this may be achieved by analytical affinity chromatography using an immobilized hapten or hapten analog and an ELISA procedure to ensure the clean separation of Ei from the Ea + Eb mixture.

The theory and application of transition state pK(a) values: the reaction of papain with a series of trimethylene disulphide reactivity probes

For many years methods to describe the structure of the transition state for a reaction have been sought. Most commonly these structures have been inferred from kinetic isotope effects. We report here for the first time the application of transition state pK(a) values to describe the relationship between molecular recognition and the transition state for the catalytic mechanism of papain. The background to the theory is presented and applied to the reactions of papain with a series of trimethylene disulphide reactivity probes. The common feature of these reactions is a loss in reactivity on ionization of the imidazolium cation for those probes containing molecular recognition features and an increase in reactivity on ionization of the electrostatic switch residue. The use of transition state pK(a) values enhances this information by providing details regarding the protonic distribution within the transition state. This has led to the reconsideration of the effect of the electrostatic switch ionization and the role of the hydrogen bond formed between the catalytic-site imidazolium cation and the leaving group of the reaction in the catalytic mechanism of papain.

The two sides of enzyme-substrate specificity: lessons from the aspartic proteinases

Like most proteolytic enzymes, the aspartic proteinases bind substrates and most inhibitors within an extended active site cleft. Bound ligands typically adopt a beta-strand conformation. Interactions with groups on both sides of the cleft determine the primary as well as secondary specificity of the enzymes. We have pursued the discovery of the sometimes subtle distinctions between members of the aspartic proteinase family by two routes. In the first case, we have constructed sets of oligopeptide substrates with systematic variation in each position to assess interactions at one position at a time. In the second type of experiment, we have altered residues of the enzymes in order to test theories of selectivity. The combination of the two approaches has provided a better understanding of the forces involved in determining specificity of enzyme action.

Lysosomal cysteine proteases: more than scavengers

Lysosomal cysteine proteases were believed to be mainly involved in intracellular protein degradation. Under special conditions they have been found outside lysosomes resulting in pathological conditions. With the discovery of a series of new cathepsins with restricted tissue distributions, it has become evident that these enzymes must be involved in a range of specific cellular tasks much broader than as simple housekeeping enzymes. It is therefore timely to review and discuss the various physiological roles of mammalian lysosomal papain-like cysteine proteases as well as their mechanisms of action and the regulation of their activity.

The lysosomal cysteine proteases

A significant number of exciting papain-like cysteine protease structures have been determined by crystallographic methods over the last several years. This trove of data allows for an analysis of the structural features that empower these molecules as they efficiently carry out their specialized tasks. Although the structure of the paradigm for the family, papain, has been known for twenty years, recent efforts have reaped several structures of specialized mammalian enzymes. This review first covers the commonalities of architecture and purpose of the papain-like cysteine proteases. From that broad platform, each of the lysosomal enzymes for which there is an X-ray structure (or structures) is then examined to gain an understanding of what structural features are used to customize specificity and activity. Structure-based design of inhibitors to control pathological cysteine protease activity will also be addressed.

The enhancing of a cysteine proteinase activity at acidic pH by protein engineering, the role of glutamic 50 in the enzyme mechanism of caricain

Carica papaya produces four cysteine proteinases. Calculations show that the Cys25, His159 essential ion pair is fully ionised at pH 2.99, where activity cannot be detected, but apparently an additional ionisation with a pKa of 4 is essential for activity (an electrostatic switch). Caricain (EC 3.4.22.30) wt and D158E genetic backgrounds were used to study the contribution of E50A to activity. E50 or E135 are candidates for the switch, E50A would be expected to reduce activity. However, activity increased at pH 5.0 in both backgrounds and at the pH optimum in D158E E50A but decreased slightly in the wt background. This challenges the hypothesis of an electrostatic switch.

Substrate inhibition of cruzipain is not affected by the C-terminal domain

Endogenous and recombinant cruzipain, the major cysteine proteinase from the protozoan parasite Trypanosoma cruzi, exhibit differences in the protein and circular dichroism spectra probably attributed to the absence of the C-terminal domain in the recombinant enzyme. Substrate hydrolysis of both molecules at 25 degrees C and neutral pH obeyed Michaelis-Menten kinetics whereas significant substrate inhibition was observed above neutral pH. The results suggest that substrate inhibition of cruzipain is pH-dependent, and that the C-terminal domain does not play an essential role in this process.

Crystal structure of porcine cathepsin H determined at 2.1 A resolution: location of the mini-chain C-terminal carboxyl group defines cathepsin H aminopeptidase function

BACKGROUND

Cathepsin H is a lysosomal cysteine protease, involved in intracellular protein degradation. It is the only known mono-aminopeptidase in the papain-like family and is reported to be involved in tumor metastasis. The cathepsin H structure was determined in order to investigate the structural basis for its aminopeptidase activity and thus to provide the basis for structure-based design of synthetic inhibitors.

RESULTS

The crystal structure of native porcine cathepsin H was determined at 2.1 A resolution. The structure has the typical papain-family fold. The so-called mini-chain, the octapeptide EPQNCSAT, is attached via a disulfide bond to the body of the enzyme and bound in a narrowed active-site cleft, in the substrate-binding direction. The mini-chain fills the region that in related enzymes comprises the non-primed substrate-binding sites from S2 backwards.

CONCLUSIONS

The crystal structure of cathepsin H reveals that the mini-chain has a definitive role in substrate recognition and that carbohydrate residues attached to the body of the enzyme are involved in positioning the mini-chain in the active-site cleft. Modeling of a substrate into the active-site cleft suggests that the negatively charged carboxyl group of the C terminus of the mini-chain acts as an anchor for the positively charged N-terminal amino group of a substrate. The observed displacements of the residues within the active-site cleft from their equivalent positions in the papain-like endopeptidases suggest that they form the structural basis for the positioning of both the mini-chain and the substrate, resulting in exopeptidase activity.