Natural inspirations for metal–ligand cooperative catalysis

A computational approach to understand the role of metals and axial ligands in artificial heme enzyme catalyzed C-H insertion

Engineered heme enzymes such as myoglobin and cytochrome P450s metalloproteins are gaining widespread importance due to their efficiency in catalyzing non-natural reactions. In a recent strategy, the naturally occurring Fe metal in the heme unit was replaced with non-native metals such as Ir, Rh, Co, Cu, etc., and axial ligands to generate artificial metalloenzymes. Determining the best metal-ligand for a chemical transformation is not a trivial task. Here we demonstrate how computational approaches can be used in deciding the best metal-ligand combination which would be highly beneficial in designing new enzymes as well as small molecule catalysts. We have used Density Functional Theory (DFT) to shed light on the enhanced reactivity of an Ir system with varying axial ligands. We look at the insertion of a carbene group generated from diazo precursors via N2 extrusion into a C-H bond. For both Ir(Me) and Fe systems, the first step, i.e., N2 extrusion is the rate determining step. Strikingly, neither the better ligand overlap with 5d orbitals on Ir nor the electrophilicity on the carbene centre play a significant role. A comparison of Fe and Ir systems reveals that a lower distortion in the Ir(Me)-porphyrin on moving from the reactant to the transition state renders it catalytically more active. We notice that for both metal porphyrins, the free energy barriers are affected by axial ligand substitution. Further, for Fe porphyrin, the axial ligand also changes the preferred spin state. We show that for the carbene insertion into the C-H bond, Fe porphyrin systems undergo a stepwise HAT (hydrogen atom transfer) instead of a concerted hydride transfer process. Importantly, we find that the substitution of the axial Me ligand on Ir to imidazole or chloride, or without an axial substitution changes the rate determining step of the reaction. Therefore, an optimum ligand that can balance the barriers for both steps of the catalytic cycle is essential. We subsequently used the QM cluster approach to delineate the protein environment's role and mutations in improving the catalytic activity of the Ir(Me) system.

Selective Implantation of Diamines for Cooperative Catalysis in Isoreticular Heterometallic Titanium-Organic Frameworks

We introduce the first example of isoreticular titanium-organic frameworks, MUV-10 and MUV-12, to show how the different affinity of hard Ti(IV) and soft Ca(II) metal sites can be used to direct selective grafting of amines. This enables the combination of Lewis acid titanium centers and available -NH₂ sites in two sizeable pores for cooperative cycloaddition of CO₂ to epoxides at room temperature and atmospheric pressure. The selective grafting of molecules to heterometallic clusters adds up to the pool of methodologies available for controlling the positioning and distribution of chemical functions in precise positions of the framework required for definitive control of pore chemistry.

A bio-inspired mononuclear manganese catalyst for high-rate electrochemical hydrogen production

[FeFe]-hydrogenase (H₂ase) catalyzes hydrogen evolution reactions (HERs), with an excellent performance that rivals that of platinum, the active site of which is built with crucial structural features required for efficient H-H bond formation. Herein, we report a mononuclear manganese complex (1) that contains a square pyramid coordination sphere and an intramolecular aniline as the proton relay, consistent with the crucial features of the active site in H₂ase. Benefitting from these features, complex 1 electrocatalyzes the HER with a turnover frequency (TOF) exceeding 10 000 s^-1 at -1.45 V (versus the ferrocenium/ferrocene couple) using anilinium tetrafluoroborate as a proton source. This work provides the first Mn-based functional model of H₂ase, serving as a new paradigm for a high performance, low cost, environmentally benign hydrogen production electrocatalyst.

Aromaticity in catalysis: metal ligand cooperation via ligand dearomatization and rearomatization

Unlike the conventional model of transition metal catalysis, ligands in metal-ligand cooperative (or bifunctional) catalysis are involved in the substrate activations. Such processes have offered unique mechanistic understandings and led to new concepts for the catalyst design. In particular, unprecedented activities were discovered when the ligand could undergo dearomatization-rearomatization reactions during the catalytic cycle. Aromatization can provide an extra driving force to thermodynamics; consequently, it brings a new perspective to ligand platform design for catalysis. While numerous applications were demonstrated, the influences of changing ligand aromatic properties were often overlooked. In this article, representative ligand systems will be highlighted and a comparison between the Milstein and the Huang pincer systems will be discussed to provide theoretical and conceptual insights.

Applications of Discrete Synthetic Macromolecules in Life and Materials Science: Recent and Future Trends

In the last decade, the field of sequence-defined polymers and related ultraprecise, monodisperse synthetic macromolecules has grown exponentially. In the early stage, mainly articles or reviews dedicated to the development of synthetic routes toward their preparation have been published. Nowadays, those synthetic methodologies, combined with the elucidation of the structure-property relationships, allow envisioning many promising applications. Consequently, in the past 3 years, application-oriented papers based on discrete synthetic macromolecules emerged. Hence, material science applications such as macromolecular data storage and encryption, self-assembly of discrete structures and foldamers have been the object of many fascinating studies. Moreover, in the area of life sciences, such structures have also been the focus of numerous research studies. Here, it is aimed to highlight these recent applications and to give the reader a critical overview of the future trends in this area of research.

The cooperative role of innocent ligand in N-heterocyclic carbene manganese catalyzed carbon dioxide hydrogenation

The concept of Lewis acidic π* cooperation was proposed for innocent CO ligand in NHC–Mn catalyzed CO2 hydrogenation by systematic DFT studies.

Ambiphilic boryl groups in a neutral Ni(ii) complex: a new activation mode of H2

The concept of metal-ligand cooperation opens new avenues for the design of catalytic systems that may offer alternative reactivity patterns to the existing ones. Investigations of this concept with ligands bearing a boron center in their skeleton established mechanistic pathways for the activation of small molecules in which the boron atom usually performs as an electrophile. Here, we show how this electrophilic behavior can be modified by the ligand trans to the boron center, evincing its ambiphilic nature. Treatment of diphosphinoboryl (PBP) nickel-methyl complex 1 with bis(catecholato)diboron (B2Cat2) allows for the synthesis of nickel(ii) bis-boryl complex 3 that promotes the clean and reversible heterolytic cleavage of dihydrogen leading to the formation of dihydroborate nickel complex 4. Density functional theory analysis of this reaction revealed that the heterolytic activation of H2 is facilitated by the cooperation of both boryl moieties and the metal atom in a concerted mechanism that involves a Ni(ii)/Ni(0)/Ni(ii) process. Contrary to 1, the boron atom from the PBP ligand in 3 behaves as a nucleophile, accepting a formally protic hydrogen, whereas the catecholboryl moiety acts as an electrophile, receiving the attack from the hydride-like fragment. This manifests the dramatic change in the electronic properties of a ligand by tuning the substituent trans to it and constitutes an unprecedented cooperative mechanism that involves two boryl ligands in the same molecule operating differently, one as a Lewis acid and the other one as a Lewis base, in cooperation with the metal. In addition, reactivity towards different nucleophiles such as amines or ammonia confirmed the electrophilic nature of the Bcat moiety, allowing the formation of aminoboranes.

Few-Atomic-Layers Iron for Hydrogen Evolution from Water by Photoelectrocatalysis

The carbon-free production of hydrogen from water splitting holds grand promise for the critical energy and environmental challenges. Herein, few-atomic-layers iron (Fe_FAL) anchored on GaN nanowire arrays (NWs) is demonstrated as a highly active hydrogen evolution reaction catalyst, attributing to the spatial confinement and the nitrogen-terminated surface of GaN NWs. Based on density functional theory calculations, the hydrogen adsorption on Fe_FAL:GaN NWs is found to exhibit a significantly low free energy of −0.13 eV, indicative of high activity. Meanwhile, its outstanding optoelectronic properties are realized by the strong electronic coupling between atomic iron layers and GaN(10ī0) together with the nearly defect-free GaN NWs. As a result, Fe_FAL:GaN NWs/n⁺-p Si exhibits a prominent current density of ∼ −30 mA cm⁻² at an overpotential of ∼0.2 V versus reversible hydrogen electrode with a decent onset potential of +0.35 V and 98% Faradaic efficiency in 0.5 mol/L KHCO₃ aqueous solution under standard one-sun illumination.

•

Few-atomic-layers iron was anchored on GaN nanowires as an efficient HER catalyst

•

The spatial-confinement and N-rich GaN is essential for forming atomic iron layers

•

Low hydrogen absorption free energy is theoretically revealed over Fe_3L:GaN

•

The device exhibits a prominent performance for PEC water splitting to H₂

Triple the fun: tris(ferrocenyl)arene-based gold(i) complexes for redox-switchable catalysis

The modular syntheses of C₃-symmetric tris(ferrocenyl)arene-based tris-phosphanes and their homotrinuclear gold(i) complexes are reported. Choosing the arene core allows fine-tuning of the exact oxidation potentials and thus tailoring of the electrochemical response. The tris[chloridogold(i)] complexes were investigated in the catalytic ring-closing isomerisation of N-(2-propyn-1-yl)benzamide, showing cooperative behaviour vs. a mononuclear chloridogold(i) complex. Adding one, two, or three equivalents of 1,1′-diacetylferrocenium[tetrakis(perfluoro-tert-butoxy)aluminate] as an oxidant during the catalytic reaction (in situ) resulted in a distinct, stepwise influence on the resulting catalytic rates. Isolation of the oxidised species is possible, and using them as (pre-)catalysts (ex situ oxidation) confirmed the activity trend. Proving the intactness of the P–Au–Cl motif during oxidation, the tri-oxidised benzene-based complex has been structurally characterised.

Trinuclear gold(i) complexes of C₃-symmetric tris(ferrocenyl)arene-based tris-phosphanes with four accessible oxidation states catalyse the ring-closing isomerisation of N-(2-propyn-1-yl)benzamide with different rates depending on their redox state.

Metal-ligand cooperativity in the soluble hydrogenase-1 from Pyrococcus furiosus

Metal–ligand cooperativity is an essential feature of bioinorganic catalysis. The design principles of such cooperativity in metalloenzymes are underexplored, but are critical to understand for developing efficient catalysts designed with earth abundant metals for small molecule activation. The simple substrate requirements of reversible proton reduction by the [NiFe]-hydrogenases make them a model bioinorganic system. A highly conserved arginine residue (R355) directly above the exogenous ligand binding position of the [NiFe]-catalytic core is known to be essential for optimal function because mutation to a lysine results in lower catalytic rates. To expand on our studies of soluble hydrogenase-1 from Pyrococcus furiosus (Pf SH1), we investigated the role of R355 by site-directed-mutagenesis to a lysine (R355K) using infrared and electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopic probes sensitive to active site redox and protonation events. It was found the mutation resulted in an altered ligand binding environment at the [NiFe] centre. A key observation was destabilization of the Ni_a³⁺–C state, which contains a bridging hydride. Instead, the tautomeric Ni_a⁺–L states were observed. Overall, the results provided insight into complex metal–ligand cooperativity between the active site and protein scaffold that modulates the bridging hydride stability and the proton inventory, which should prove valuable to design principles for efficient bioinspired catalysts.

Metal–ligand cooperativity is an essential feature of bioinorganic catalysis.

Aluminum porphyrins with quaternary ammonium halides as catalysts for copolymerization of cyclohexene oxide and CO2: metal-ligand cooperative catalysis

Bifunctional Al porphyrins worked as excellent catalysts for the copolymerization of cyclohexene oxide (CHO) and CO₂.

Bifunctional Al^III porphyrins with quaternary ammonium halides, 2-Cl and 2-Br, worked as excellent catalysts for the copolymerization of cyclohexene oxide (CHO) and CO₂ at 120 °C. Turnover frequency (TOF) and turnover number (TON) reached 10 000 h^–1 and 55 000, respectively, and poly(cyclohexene carbonate) (PCHC) with molecular weight of up to 281 000 was obtained with a catalyst loading of 0.001 mol%. In contrast, bifunctional Mg^II and Zn^II counterparts, 3-Cl and 4-Cl, as well as a binary catalyst system, 1-Cl with bis(triphenylphosphine)iminium chloride (PPNCl), showed poor catalytic performances. Kinetic studies revealed that the reaction rate was first-order in [CHO] and [2-Br] and zero-order in [CO₂], and the activation parameters were determined: ΔH^‡ = 12.4 kcal mol^–1, ΔS^‡ = –26.1 cal mol^–1 K^–1, and ΔG^‡ = 21.6 kcal mol^–1 at 80 °C. Comparative DFT calculations on two model catalysts, Al^III complex 2′ and Mg^II complex 3′, allowed us to extract key factors in the catalytic behavior of the bifunctional Al^III catalyst. The high polymerization activity and carbonate-linkage selectivity originate from the cooperative actions of the metal center and the quaternary ammonium cation, both of which facilitate the epoxide-ring opening by the carbonate anion to form the carbonate linkage in the key transition state such as TS3b (ΔH^‡ = 13.3 kcal mol^–1, ΔS^‡ = –3.1 cal mol^–1 K^–1, and ΔG^‡ = 14.4 kcal mol^–1 at 80 °C).

Mechanistic insight into the azo radical-promoted dehydrogenation of heteroarene towards N-heterocycles

A mechanistic analysis reflecting the desaturation of heteroarene towards the efficient synthesis of pyrimidine and triazine under mild conditions.

Recent advances in the mechanisms of the hydrogen evolution reaction by non-innocent sulfur-coordinating metal complexes

This review comments on the homogeneous HER mechanisms for catalysts carrying S-non-innocent ligands in the light of experimental and computational data.

The monoiron anionfac-[Fe(CO)3I3]−and its organic aminium salts: their preparation, CO-release, and cytotoxicity

The anionfac-[Fe(CO)₃I₃]⁻undergoes rapid decomposition to release CO and involve iodine radical. The CO-release can be tuned by its cations. The radical causes severe cytotoxicity which may endow the anion a great potential as an anticancer drug.

Metal-ligand cooperative C-O bond cleavage of propargylic alcohol with protic pyrazole complexes of ruthenium

The C-O bond cleavage of a propargylic alcohol, 1,1-dimethyl-3-phenylprop-2-yn-1-ol (3), by metal-ligand cooperation was investigated. The reactions of a naphthalene complex [CpRu(η6-C10H8)]PF6 (Cp = η5-C5H5) with 5-R-3-(pyrid-2-yl)pyrazoles (R-LH; R = Ph, CF3) in acetonitrile afforded the starting metal-ligand bifunctional ruthenium complexes [CpRu(R-LH)(MeCN)]PF6 (1a, R = Ph; 1b, R = CF3) featuring an N-N chelate protic pyrazole. The treatment of the CF3-substituted pyrazole complex 1b with 3 in 1,2-dichloroethane at 50 °C resulted in the formation of the η3-butadienyl complex 5. Meanwhile, the corresponding reaction of the phenylpyrazole complex 1a in 1,4-dioxane at 90 °C gave the N-allenylmethylpyrazole complex 6. The C-O and C-H bond cleavage of 3 in these reactions can be ascribed to the metal-ligand cooperation: initial formation of an η3-propargyl complex assisted by NHO hydrogen bonding and following C-H deprotonation by the neighboring pyrazolato ligand. On the other hand, in boiling methanol, the protic pyrazole complex 1a catalyzed the C-O bond cleavage of 3, which resulted in catalytic isomerization of 3 to an α,β-unsaturated enone, 3-methyl-1-phenylbut-2-en-1-one (8). The control experiments using non-protic and isocyanide ruthenium complexes indicated that both a labile nitrile ligand on the metal and the protic cooperating ligand are crucial for the catalysis.

Cooperative H2 Activation on Dicopper(I) Facilitated by Reversible Dearomatization of an "Expanded PNNP Pincer" Ligand

A naphthyridine-derived expanded pincer ligand is described that can host two copper(I) centers. The proton-responsive ligand can undergo reversible partial and full dearomatization of the naphthyridine core, which enables cooperative activation of H2 giving an unusual butterfly-shaped Cu4 H2 complex.

Reversible and cooperative photoactivation of single-atom Cu/TiO2 photocatalysts

The reversible and cooperative activation process, which includes electron transfer from surrounding redox mediators, the reversible valence change of cofactors and macroscopic functional/structural change, is one of the most important characteristics of biological enzymes, and has frequently been used in the design of homogeneous catalysts. However, there are virtually no reports on industrially important heterogeneous catalysts with these enzyme-like characteristics. Here, we report on the design and synthesis of highly active TiO₂ photocatalysts incorporating site-specific single copper atoms (Cu/TiO₂) that exhibit a reversible and cooperative photoactivation process. Our atomic-level design and synthetic strategy provide a platform that facilitates valence control of co-catalyst copper atoms, reversible modulation of the macroscopic optoelectronic properties of TiO₂ and enhancement of photocatalytic hydrogen generation activity, extending the boundaries of conventional heterogeneous catalysts.

A catalytically active [Mn]-hydrogenase incorporating a non-native metal cofactor

Nature carefully selects specific metal ions for incorporation into the enzymes that catalyze the chemical reactions necessary for life. Hydrogenases, enzymes that activate molecular H₂, exclusively utilize Ni and Fe in [NiFe]-, [FeFe]-, and [Fe]-hydrogeanses. However, other transition metals are known to activate or catalyze the production of hydrogen in synthetic systems. Here, we report the development of a biomimetic model complex of [Fe]-hydrogenase that incorporates a Mn, as opposed to a Fe, metal center. This Mn complex is able to heterolytically cleave H₂ as well as catalyze hydrogenation reactions. Incorporation of the model into an apoenzyme of [Fe]-hydrogenase results in a [Mn]-hydrogenase with enhanced occupancy-normalized activity over an analogous semi-synthetic [Fe]-hydrogenase. These findings represent the first instance of a non-native metal hydrogenase showing catalytic functionality and demonstrate that hydrogenases based on a manganese active site are viable.

Computational Approach to Molecular Catalysis by 3d Transition Metals: Challenges and Opportunities

Computational chemistry provides a versatile toolbox for studying mechanistic details of catalytic reactions and holds promise to deliver practical strategies to enable the rational in silico catalyst design. The versatile reactivity and nontrivial electronic structure effects, common for systems based on 3d transition metals, introduce additional complexity that may represent a particular challenge to the standard computational strategies. In this review, we discuss the challenges and capabilities of modern electronic structure methods for studying the reaction mechanisms promoted by 3d transition metal molecular catalysts. Particular focus will be placed on the ways of addressing the multiconfigurational problem in electronic structure calculations and the role of expert bias in the practical utilization of the available methods. The development of density functionals designed to address transition metals is also discussed. Special emphasis is placed on the methods that account for solvation effects and the multicomponent nature of practical catalytic systems. This is followed by an overview of recent computational studies addressing the mechanistic complexity of catalytic processes by molecular catalysts based on 3d metals. Cases that involve noninnocent ligands, multicomponent reaction systems, metal-ligand and metal-metal cooperativity, as well as modeling complex catalytic systems such as metal-organic frameworks are presented. Conventionally, computational studies on catalytic mechanisms are heavily dependent on the chemical intuition and expert input of the researcher. Recent developments in advanced automated methods for reaction path analysis hold promise for eliminating such human-bias from computational catalysis studies. A brief overview of these approaches is presented in the final section of the review. The paper is closed with general concluding remarks.

Cooperative ruthenium complex catalyzed multicomponent synthesis of pyrimidines

The ruthenium-catalyzed multicomponent synthesis of pyrimidines from amidines and alcohols is reported for the first time.

Photocatalytic hydrogen evolution on Si photocathodes modified with bis(thiosemicarbazonato)nickel(ii)/Nafion

Molecular NiATSM on p-Si durably photocatalyzed hydrogen evolution from water at practical conditions in acid with greater activity than Ni metal.

Metallo-supramolecular assembly of protic pincer-type complexes: encapsulation of dinitrogen and carbon disulfide into a multiproton-responsive diruthenium cage

A protic pincer complex and rigid diphosphine linker formed a cage, which incorporated N₂ and CS₂ into the multiproton-responsive cavity.

Bottom-Up Assembly of a Highly Efficient Metal-Organic Framework for Cooperative Catalysis

In this study, we demonstrate a bottom-up assembly of a monomeric copper complex and a two-dimensional (2-D) heterometallic metal-organic framework (MOF) from a carboxylate-functionalized tridentate Schiff base ligand and metal ions. The obtained 2-D MOF features a unique bimetallic copper center which is different from its monometallic precursor and acts as an efficient heterogeneous catalyst for the Friedel-Crafts reaction and Henry reaction. The MOF catalyst shows a remarkably superior activity compared to its homogeneous counterparts in a wide range of substrates. It is presumably ascribed to the dual activation of the substrates by the active bimetallic copper center confined in the MOF network, which is supported by the significant changes in catalytic activity at low catalyst/substrates ratios when using the 2-D MOF and its precursor as catalysts, respectively. Moreover, the MOF catalyst also shows an excellent stability and recyclability. Our work, therefore, provides a stepwise strategy to design a heterogeneous cooperative catalyst, by taking advantage of the modulated structure of MOF and tunable functionality of the tridentate Schiff base, with high performance in a variety of organic synthesis.

On the alcoholysis of alkyl-aluminum(iii) alkoxy-NHC derivatives: reactivity of the Al-carbene Lewis pair versus Al-alkyl

Alkyl-aluminum(iii) derivatives supported by a bifunctional alkoxy-NHC ligand display unusual reactivity at the carbene, yielding imidazolium-aluminate zwitterions.