Cherubism and its charlatans

Aggressive behaviour of cherubism in a teenager: 4-years of clinical follow-up associated with radiographic and histological features

Cherubism is a rare hereditary fibro-osseous childhood disease characterized by bone degradation and fibrous tissue replacement at the angles of the mandible and at the tuberosity areas of the maxilla that leads to prominence of the lower face and an appearance reminiscent of the cherub's portrayal in Renaissance art. This disease has an autosomal dominant hereditary characteristic. The purpose of this report is to analyse laboratory tests, clinicopathological and radiographic features of cherubism and its intraoral manifestations in a patient during 4-years of follow-up, correlating the features observed in this case with those of the literature. Also discussed is the atypical and aggressive behaviour of this case during puberty.

Clinicopathologic study of 24 cases of cherubism

The authors reviewed 24 cases of familial or nonfamilial cherubism. The age at onset was between 6 and 10 years. It was characterized by bilateral painless swelling of jaws and eyes-to-heaven appearance was visible when the maxillae were affected as well. Radiographs showed well-defined multilocular radiolucencies and with age, thick sclerotic borders were visible. A malocclusive and abnormal dentition, worse in the mandible can be seen. Histopathologically, numerous randomly distributed multinucleated giant cells and vascular spaces within a fibrous connective tissue stroma with or without eosinophilic collagen perivascular cuffing were apparent. Multinucleated giant cells were positive for osteoclastic specific markers, tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase and human alphaV beta3 integrin, 23C6. Results after follow-up were available for 14 cases. Of these, no treatment was carried out in five cases, cherubism resolved (three cases) or grew slowly (two cases); curettage or surgical contouring was performed in seven cases, during the rapid growth of the lesions. This not only gave good immediate results, but also arrested active growth of remnant cherubic lesions and even stimulated bone regeneration. Segmental mandibulectomy followed by reconstruction was performed in two cases with extensive lesion and the risk of pathologic fracture of the mandible, and excellent results were obtained.

Clinical and radiological features of central giant-cell lesions of the jaw

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the clinical and radiological features of central giant-cell lesions that were diagnosed in The Netherlands between January 1, 1990, and January 1, 1995.

STUDY DESIGN

A population-based retrospective study was carried out, examining all patients with a central giant-cell lesion from this period.

RESULTS

In 83 patients there was a central giant-cell granuloma (89 lesions). Aggressive signs and symptoms (pain, paresthesia, or root resorption) were found in 16 (19.3%) patients. Multiple lesions occurred in 3 (3.6%) patients. The overall recurrence rate was 26.3%, and there was a higher recurrence rate in patients who exhibited aggressive signs and symptoms than in patients without these features (RR 1.6). In 5 patients a clinical diagnosis of cherubism or concomitant neurofibromatosis type 1 was made (14 lesions).

CONCLUSION

In a general population, large and aggressive lesions are less common than suggested by the literature. Multiple lesions, however, occur more frequently than previously assumed. In patients with aggressive signs and symptoms, surgical curettage is not an effective therapy.

Cherubism: Review of four affected members in a Kuwaiti family

Cherubism is a rare autosomal dominant fibro-osseous disorder of childhood, mostly limited to the maxilla and mandible. Extra-cranial skeletal involvement is rare. Post-pubertal involution of the process and jaw remodeling occurs in adulthood. The aim of this case report is to present four cherubs, a father and his three daughters, in whom the diagnosis was made based on history, physical examination, laboratory tests and typical radiological features. The imaging characteristics are discussed and the published literature is reviewed.

Querubismo: relato de caso e revisão da literatura com aspectos imaginológicos

Querubismo é uma doença óssea hereditária não neoplásica caracterizada, clinicamente, por aumento indolor bilateral da mandíbula e maxilar em crianças, produzindo uma aparência querubínica. Pode ocorrer em casos isolados ou em membros de uma mesma família. Relatamos o caso de querubismo em uma menina sem história familiar, com lesões osteolíticas expansivas na mandíbula e maxila demonstradas em exames radiológicos.

A missense mutation in the SH3BP2 gene on chromosome 4p16.3 found in a case of nonfamilial cherubism

OBJECTIVE

Cherubism is a rare hereditary multilocular cystic disease of the jaws, characterized by its typical appearance. Although nonfamilial cases have been reported, it is difficult to distinguish nonfamilial cherubism from central giant cell granuloma. Recent studies have revealed the point mutations in the SH3BP2 gene on chromosome 4p16.3 in cherubism families. In this article, the SH3BP2 gene in nonfamilial cherubism was examined.

PATIENT

A 21-year-old Japanese woman with nonfamilial cherubism.

INTERVENTIONS

Genomic DNA was purified from a blood sample obtained from the patient and used for direct sequencing. In addition, a sample of the lesion, resected during surgery, was used for histologic and immunohistochemical purposes.

RESULTS

Genomic DNA sequencing found a Pro418Arg mutation in the SH3BP2 gene of the patient. In a histochemical analysis, the multinucleated giant cells proved to be strongly positive for PGM-1, KP-1, and tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase and faintly positive for osteopontin.

CONCLUSIONS

The missense mutation Pro418Arg was identified in the SH3BP2 gene from a nonfamilial case of cherubism. DNA diagnosis may play a significant role in the identification of cherubism.

Clinical and radiological evaluation of cherubism: a sporadic case report and review of the literature

Many cases have been published on cherubism since Jones described it first time in three children of the same family [Am. J. Cancer 17 (1933) 946]. Cherubism is an autosomal-dominant disorder in which the normal bone is replaced by cellular fibrous tissue and immature bone. Extracranial skeletal involvement is rarely seen in hereditary and non-hereditary forms of the disorder. The mandible is the most severely affected craniofacial component, in which uncontrolled growth of the malady deteriorates the aesthetic balance of the face. Bilateral swelling of the cheeks, mandibular enlargement and maxillary spongious hypertrophy cause orbital manifestations and tendency of eyes looking up to the sky. Thus, the pathognomic clinical feature resembles the appearance of "raised to heaven" Renaissance cherubs. The sporadic case concerns a child affected by cherubism. Radiographic and clinical data of the patient are presented and brief review of the literature is included.

Calcitonin therapy for central giant cell granuloma

PURPOSE

A number of alternative nonsurgical therapies have been advocated in recent years for the management of the central giant cell granuloma (CGCG). These include calcitonin injections, intralesional steroid injections and subcutaneous alpha-interferon injections. This report provides the results of calcitonin therapy.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Ten patients received calcitonin therapy, 9 via subcutaneous injection and 1 via nasal spray, for the management of a CGCG. Patients were reviewed retrospectively

RESULTS

In 8 cases, the lesions resolved completely after 19 to 21 months of subcutaneous calcitonin treatment. In the ninth case, the lesion resolved on calcitonin treatment only to reappear 26 months later. The recurrence was treated with both repeated calcitonin and local enucleation. The tenth case with calcitonin (intranasal) treatment was abandoned due to poor patient compliance, and the patient ultimately underwent surgical treatment.

CONCLUSION

Calcitonin treatment appears to be a viable option for the treatment of CGCGs but, because of the length of treatment time, should probably be reserved for multiple lesions, recurrent lesions, or particularly aggressive lesions. The exact mechanism of action of both calcitonin and other treatment modalities remains to be fully elucidated. The reported success of all such treatments raises questions about the natural history of this lesion.