Selected configuration interaction dressed by perturbation

Further Development of iCIPT2 for Strongly Correlated Electrons

The efficiency of the recently proposed iCIPT2 [iterative configuration interaction (iCI) with selection and second-order perturbation theory (PT2); J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2020, 16, 2296] for strongly correlated electrons is further enhanced (by up to 20×) by using (1) a new ranking criterion for configuration selection, (2) a new particle-hole algorithm for Hamiltonian construction over randomly selected configuration state functions (CSF), and (3) a new data structure for the quick sorting of the variational and first-order interaction spaces. Meanwhile, the memory requirement is also significantly reduced. As a result, this improved implementation of iCIPT2 can handle 1 order of magnitude more CSFs than the previous version, as revealed by taking the chromium dimer and an iron-sulfur cluster, [Fe₂S₂(SCH₃)]₄^2-, as examples.

Multicomponent CASSCF Revisited: Large Active Spaces Are Needed for Qualitatively Accurate Protonic Densities

Multicomponent methods seek to treat select nuclei, typically protons, fully quantum mechanically and equivalent to the electrons of a chemical system. In such methods, it is well-known that due to the neglect of electron-proton correlation, a Hartree-Fock (HF) description of the electron-proton interaction catastrophically fails leading to qualitatively incorrect protonic properties. In single-component quantum chemistry, the qualitative failure of HF is normally indicative of the need for multireference methods such as complete active space self-consistent field (CASSCF). While a multicomponent CASSCF method was implemented nearly 20 years ago, it is only able to perform calculations with very small active spaces (∼10⁵ multicomponent configurations). Therefore, in order to extend the realm of applicability of the multicomponent CASSCF method, this study derives and implements a new two-step multicomponent CASSCF method that uses multicomponent heat-bath configuration interaction for the configuration interaction step, enabling calculations with very large active spaces (up to 16 electrons in 48 orbitals). We find that large electronic active spaces are needed to obtain qualitatively accurate protonic densities for the HCN and FHF^- molecules. Additionally, the multicomponent CASSCF method implemented here should have further applications for double-well protonic potentials and systems that are inherently electronically multireference.

The Shape of Full Configuration Interaction to Come

We present a Perspective on what the future holds for full configuration interaction (FCI) theory, with an emphasis on conceptual rather than technical details. Upon revisiting the early history of FCI, a number of its key contemporary approximations are compared on as equal a footing as possible, using a recent blind challenge on the benzene molecule as a testbed [Eriksen et al., J. Phys. Chem. Lett., 2020 11, 8922]. In the process, we review the scope of applications for which FCI continues to prove indispensable, and the required traits in terms of robustness, efficacy, and reliability its modern approximations must satisfy are discussed. We close by conveying a number of general observations on the merits offered by the state-of-the-art alongside some of the challenges still faced to this day. While the field has altogether seen immense progress over the years-the past decade, in particular-it remains clear that our community as a whole has a substantial way to go in enhancing the overall applicability of near-exact electronic structure theory for systems of general composition and increasing size.

A hybrid approach to excited-state-specific variational Monte Carlo and doubly excited states

We extend our hybrid linear-method/accelerated-descent variational Monte Carlo optimization approach to excited states and investigate its efficacy in double excitations. In addition to showing a superior statistical efficiency when compared to the linear method, our tests on small molecules show good energetic agreement with benchmark methods. We also demonstrate the ability to treat double excitations in systems that are too large for a full treatment by using selected configuration interaction methods via an application to 4-aminobenzonitrile. Finally, we investigate the stability of state-specific variance optimization against collapse to other states' variance minima and find that symmetry, Ansatz quality, and sample size all have roles to play in achieving stability.

Dynamical kernels for optical excitations

We discuss the physical properties and accuracy of three distinct dynamical (i.e., frequency-dependent) kernels for the computation of optical excitations within linear response theory: (i) an a priori built kernel inspired by the dressed time-dependent density-functional theory kernel proposed by Maitra et al. [J. Chem. Phys. 120, 5932 (2004)], (ii) the dynamical kernel stemming from the Bethe-Salpeter equation (BSE) formalism derived originally by Strinati [Riv. Nuovo Cimento 11, 1-86 (1988)], and (iii) the second-order BSE kernel derived by Zhang et al. [J. Chem. Phys. 139, 154109 (2013)]. The principal take-home message of the present paper is that dynamical kernels can provide, thanks to their frequency-dependent nature, additional excitations that can be associated with higher-order excitations (such as the infamous double excitations), an unappreciated feature of dynamical quantities. We also analyze, for each kernel, the appearance of spurious excitations originating from the approximate nature of the kernels, as first evidenced by Romaniello et al. [J. Chem. Phys. 130, 044108 (2009)]. Using a simple two-level model, prototypical examples of valence, charge-transfer, and Rydberg excited states are considered.

The Ground State Electronic Energy of Benzene

We report on the findings of a blind challenge devoted to determining the frozen-core, full configuration interaction (FCI) ground-state energy of the benzene molecule in a standard correlation-consistent basis set of double-ζ quality. As a broad international endeavor, our suite of wave function-based correlation methods collectively represents a diverse view of the high-accuracy repertoire offered by modern electronic structure theory. In our assessment, the evaluated high-level methods are all found to qualitatively agree on a final correlation energy, with most methods yielding an estimate of the FCI value around -863 mE_H. However, we find the root-mean-square deviation of the energies from the studied methods to be considerable (1.3 mE_H), which in light of the acclaimed performance of each of the methods for smaller molecular systems clearly displays the challenges faced in extending reliable, near-exact correlation methods to larger systems. While the discrepancies exposed by our study thus emphasize the fact that the current state-of-the-art approaches leave room for improvement, we still expect the present assessment to provide a valuable community resource for benchmark and calibration purposes going forward.

Variational Principles in Quantum Monte Carlo: The Troubled Story of Variance Minimization

We investigate the use of different variational principles in quantum Monte Carlo, namely, energy and variance minimization, prompted by the interest in the robust and accurate estimation of electronic excited states. For two prototypical, challenging molecules, we readily reach the accuracy of the best available reference excitation energies using energy minimization in a state-specific or state-average fashion for states of different or equal symmetry, respectively. On the other hand, in variance minimization, where the use of suitable functionals is expected to target specific states regardless of the symmetry, we encounter severe problems for a variety of wave functions: as the variance converges, the energy drifts away from that of the selected state. This unexpected behavior is sometimes observed even when the target is the ground state and generally prevents the robust estimation of total and excitation energies. We analyze this problem using a very simple wave function and infer that the optimization finds little or no barrier to escape from a local minimum or local plateau, eventually converging to a lower-variance state instead of the target state. For the increasingly complex systems becoming in reach of quantum Monte Carlo simulations, variance minimization with current functionals appears to be an impractical route.

The Quest for Highly Accurate Excitation Energies: A Computational Perspective

We provide an overview of the successive steps that made it possible to obtain increasingly accurate excitation energies with computational chemistry tools, eventually leading to chemically accurate vertical transition energies for small- and medium-size molecules. First, we describe the evolution of ab initio methods employed to define benchmark values, with the original Roos CASPT2 method, then the CC3 method as in the renowned Thiel set, and more recently the resurgence of selected configuration interaction methods. The latter method has been able to deliver consistently, for both single and double excitations, highly accurate excitation energies for small molecules, as well as medium-size molecules with compact basis sets. Second, we describe how these high-level methods and the creation of representative benchmark sets of excitation energies have allowed the fair and accurate assessment of the performance of computationally lighter methods. We conclude by discussing possible future theoretical and technological developments in the field.

Extended Dynamically Weighted CASPT2: The Best of Two Worlds

We introduce a new variant of the complete active space second-order perturbation theory (CASPT2) method that performs similarly to multistate CASPT2 (MS-CASPT2) in regions of the potential energy surface where the electronic states are energetically well separated and is akin to extended MS-CASPT2 (XMS-CASPT2) in case the underlying zeroth-order references are near-degenerate. Our approach follows a recipe analogous to that of XMS-CASPT2 to ensure approximate invariance under unitary transformations of the model states and a dynamic weighting scheme to smoothly interpolate the Fock operator between state-specific and state-average regimes. The resulting extended dynamically weighted CASPT2 (XDW-CASPT2) methodology possesses the most desirable features of both MS-CASPT2 and XMS-CASPT2, that is, the ability to provide accurate transition energies and correctly describe avoided crossings and conical intersections. The reliability of XDW-CASPT2 is assessed on a number of molecular systems. First, we consider the dissociation of lithium fluoride, highlighting the distinctive characteristics of the new approach. Second, the invariance of the theory is investigated by studying the conical intersection of the distorted allene molecule. Finally, the relative accuracy in the calculation of vertical excitation energies is benchmarked on a set of 26 organic compounds. We found that XDW-CASPT2, albeit being only approximately invariant, produces smooth potential energy surfaces around conical intersections and avoided crossings, performing equally well to the strictly invariant XMS-CASPT2 method. The accuracy of vertical transition energies is almost identical to MS-CASPT2, with a mean absolute deviation of 0.01–0.02 eV, in contrast to 0.12 eV for XMS-CASPT2.

Generalized Many-Body Expanded Full Configuration Interaction Theory

Facilitated by a rigorous partitioning of a molecular system's orbital basis into two fundamental subspaces-a reference and an expansion space, both with orbitals of unspecified occupancy-we generalize our recently introduced many-body expanded full configuration interaction (MBE-FCI) method to allow for electron-rich model and molecular systems dominated by both weak and strong correlation to be addressed. By employing minimal or even empty reference spaces, we show through calculations on the one-dimensional Hubbard model with up to 46 lattice sites, the chromium dimer, and the benzene molecule how near-exact results may be obtained in an entirely unbiased manner for chemical and physical problems of not only academic but also applied chemical interest. Given the massive parallelism and overall accuracy of the resulting method, we argue that generalized MBE-FCI theory possesses an immense potential to yield near-exact correlation energies for molecular systems of unprecedented size, composition, and complexity in the years to come.

Stochastic perturbation theory in a limited configuration space

A general-order stochastic perturbation algorithm is obtained from the order-by-order expansion of the imaginary-time evolution of a configuration interaction wave function. A truncation of configuration space that is required for the practical treatment of the perturbative corrections, however, does not preserve size-consistency as is the case for a truncated configuration interaction. To circumvent this problem, we formulate a linked variant of stochastic perturbation theory based on the coupled-cluster ansatz. The implementation based on the linearized coupled-cluster is compared with several full configuration interaction results. We also compare the results with those obtained from deterministic coupled-cluster and many-body perturbation theories.

Complementary first and second derivative methods for ansatz optimization in variational Monte Carlo

This Perspective contrasts first and second derivative methods in variational Monte Carlo and presents a hybrid optimization approach that combines their advantages.