A quantitative model of human DNA base excision repair. I. Mechanistic insights

Oxidative DNA damage background estimated by a system model of base excision repair

Human DNA can be damaged by natural metabolism through free radical production. It has been suggested that the equilibrium between innate damage and cellular DNA repair results in an oxidative DNA damage background that potentially contributes to disease and aging. Efforts to quantitatively characterize the human oxidative DNA damage background level, based on measuring 8-oxoguanine lesions as a biomarker, have led to estimates that vary over three to four orders of magnitude, depending on the method of measurement. We applied a previously developed and validated quantitative pathway model of human DNA base excision repair, integrating experimentally determined endogenous damage rates and model parameters from multiple sources. Our estimates of at most 100 8-oxoguanine lesions per cell are consistent with the low end of data from biochemical and cell biology experiments, a result robust to model limitations and parameter variation. Our findings show the power of quantitative system modeling to interpret composite experimental data and make biologically and physiologically relevant predictions for complex human DNA repair pathway mechanisms and capacity.

DNA base excision repair activities and pathway function in mitochondrial and cellular lysates from cells lacking mitochondrial DNA

Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) contains higher steady-state levels of oxidative damage and mutates at rates significantly greater than nuclear DNA. Oxidative lesions in mtDNA are removed by a base excision repair (BER) pathway. All mtDNA repair proteins are nuclear encoded and imported. Most mtDNA repair proteins so far discovered are either identical to nuclear DNA repair proteins or isoforms of nuclear proteins arising from differential splicing. Regulation of mitochondrial BER is therefore not expected to be independent of nuclear BER, though the extent to which mitochondrial BER is regulated with respect to mtDNA amount or damage is largely unknown. Here we have measured DNA BER activities in lysates of mitochondria isolated from human 143B TK(-) osteosarcoma cells that had been depleted of mtDNA (rho(0)) or not (wt). Despite the total absence of mtDNA in the rho(0) cells, a complete mitochondrial BER pathway was present, as demonstrated using an in vitro assay with synthetic oligonucleotides. Measurement of individual BER protein activities in mitochondrial lysates indicated that some BER activities are insensitive to the lack of mtDNA. Uracil and 8-oxoguanine DNA glycosylase activities were relatively insensitive to the absence of mtDNA, only about 25% reduced in rho(0) relative to wt cells. Apurinic/apyrimidinic (AP) endonuclease and polymerase gamma activities were more affected, 65 and 45% lower, respectively, in rho(0) mitochondria. Overall BER activity in lysates was also about 65% reduced in rho(0) mitochondria. To identify the limiting deficiencies in BER of rho(0) mitochondria we supplemented the BER assay of mitochondrial lysates with pure uracil DNA glycosylase, AP endonuclease and/or the catalytic subunit of polymerase gamma. BER activity was stimulated by addition of uracil DNA glycosylase and polymerase gamma. However, no addition or combination of additions stimulated BER activity to wt levels. This suggests that an unknown activity, factor or interaction important in BER is deficient in rho(0) mitochondria. While nuclear BER protein levels and activities were generally not altered in rho(0) cells, AP endonuclease activity was substantially reduced in nuclear and in whole cell extracts. This appeared to be due to reduced endogenous reactive oxygen species (ROS) production in rho(0) cells, and not a general dysfunction of rho(0) cells, as exposure of cells to ROS rapidly stimulated increases in AP endonuclease activities and APE1 protein levels.

Expression of base excision DNA repair genes is a sensitive biomarker for in vivo detection of chemical-induced chronic oxidative stress: identification of the molecular source of radicals responsible for DNA damage by peroxisome proliferators

Oxidative stress to DNA is recognized as one of the mechanisms for the carcinogenic effects of some environmental agents. Numerous studies have been conducted in an attempt to document the fact that chemical carcinogens that are thought to induce production of oxidants also cause the formation of oxidative DNA lesions. Although many DNA adducts continue to be useful biomarkers of dose/effect, changes in gene expression have been proposed to be a practical novel tool for studying the role of chemically induced oxidative DNA damage. Here, we hypothesized that expression of base excision DNA repair genes is a sensitive biomarker for in vivo detection of chemically induced chronic oxidative stress. To test this hypothesis, mice were treated with a known rodent carcinogen and peroxisome proliferator, WY-14,643 (500 ppm, 1 month). A number of end points that are commonly used to assess oxidative DNA damage were considered. Our data demonstrate that no difference in 8-oxoguanine, the number of abasic sites, or single strand breaks can be detected in genomic DNA from livers of control or WY-treated animals. However, a concordant marked induction of genes specific for the long-patch base excision DNA repair, a predominant pathway that removes oxidized DNA lesions in vivo, was observed in livers of WY-treated mice. Kupffer cell NADPH oxidase, and peroxisomes in parenchymal cells have been proposed as the potential sources of peroxisome proliferator-induced oxidants. The analysis of expression of base excision DNA repair genes was used to assess whether this biomarker of oxidative stress can be used to determine the source of oxidants. The data suggest that DNA-damaging oxidants are generated by enzymes that are induced after activation of peroxisome proliferator activator receptor alpha, such as those involved in lipid metabolism in peroxisomes, and are not the result of activation of NADPH oxidase in Kupffer cells. We conclude that expression of base excision DNA repair genes is a sensitive in vivo biomarker for chemically induced oxidative stress to DNA that can be successfully used for the identification of the molecular source of radicals responsible for DNA damage in vivo.

Apurinic/Apyrimidinic Endonuclease (APE/REF-1) Haploinsufficient Mice Display Tissue-specific Differences in DNA Polymerase β-Dependent Base Excision Repair

Apurinic/apyrimidinic (AP) endonuclease (APE) is a multifunctional protein possessing both DNA repair and redox regulatory activities. In base excision repair (BER), APE is responsible for processing spontaneous, chemical, or monofunctional DNA glycosylase-initiated AP sites via its 5'-endonuclease activity and 3'-"end-trimming" activity when processing residues produced as a consequence of bifunctional DNA glycosylases. In this study, we have fully characterized a mammalian model of APE haploinsufficiency by using a mouse containing a heterozygous gene-targeted deletion of the APE gene (Apex(+/-)). Our data indicate that Apex(+/-) mice are indeed APE-haploinsufficient, as exhibited by a 40-50% reduction (p < 0.05) in APE mRNA, protein, and 5'-endonuclease activity in all tissues studied. Based on gene dosage, we expected to see a concomitant reduction in BER activity; however, by using an in vitro G:U mismatch BER assay, we observed tissue-specific alterations in monofunctional glycosylase-initiated BER activity, e.g. liver (35% decrease, p < 0.05), testes (55% increase, p < 0.05), and brain (no significant difference). The observed changes in BER activity correlated tightly with changes in DNA polymerase beta and AP site DNA binding levels. We propose a mechanism of BER that may be influenced by the redox regulatory activity of APE, and we suggest that reduced APE may render a cell/tissue more susceptible to dysregulation of the polymerase beta-dependent BER response to cellular stress.

Mitochondrial and nuclear DNA base excision repair are affected differently by caloric restriction

Aging is strongly correlated with the accumulation of oxidative damage in DNA, particularly in mitochondria. Oxidative damage to both mitochondrial and nuclear DNA is repaired by the base excision repair (BER) pathway. The "mitochondrial theory of aging" suggests that aging results from declining mitochondrial function, due to high loads of damage and mutation in mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA). Restriction of caloric intake is the only intervention so far proven to slow the aging rate. However, the molecular mechanisms underlying such effects are still unclear. We used caloric-restricted (CR) mice to investigate whether lifespan extension is associated with changes in mitochondrial BER activities. Mice were divided into two groups, receiving 100% (PF) or 60% (CR) of normal caloric intake, a regime that extends mean lifespan by approximately 40% in CR mice. Mitochondria isolated from CR mice had slightly higher uracil (UDG) and oxoguanine DNA glycosylase (OGG1) activities but marginally lower abasic endonuclease and polymerase gamma gap-filling activities, although these differences were tissue-specific. Uracil-initiated BER synthesis incorporation activities were significantly lower in brain and kidney from CR mice but marginally enhanced in liver. However, nuclear repair synthesis activities were increased by CR, indicating differential regulation of BER in the two compartments. The results indicate that a general up-regulation of mitochondrial BER does not occur in CR.

Properties of and substrate determinants for the exonuclease activity of human apurinic endonuclease Ape1

Ape1 is the major human abasic endonuclease, initiating repair of this common DNA lesion by incising the phosphodiester backbone 5' to the damage site. This enzyme also functions in specific contexts to excise 3'-blocking termini, e.g. phosphate and phosphoglycolate residues, from DNA. Recently, the comparatively "minor" 3' to 5' exonuclease activity of Ape1 was found to contribute to the excision of certain 3'-mismatched nucleotides. In this study, I characterize more thoroughly the 3'-nuclease properties of Ape1 and define the effects of specific DNA determinants on this function. Data within shows that Ape1 is a non- or poorly processive exonuclease, which degrades one nucleotide gap, 3'-recessed, and nicked DNAs, but exhibits no detectable activity on blunt end or single-stranded DNA. A 5'-phosphate, compared to a 5'-hydroxyl group, reduced Ape1 degradation activity roughly tenfold, suggesting that the biological impact of certain DNA single strand breaks may be influenced by the terminal chemistry. In the context of a base excision repair-like DNA intermediate, a 5'-abasic residue exerted an about tenfold attenuation on the 3' to 5' exonuclease efficiency of Ape1. A 3'-phosphate group had little impact on Ape1 exonuclease activity, and oligonucleotides harboring these blocking termini were activated by Ape1 for DNA polymerase beta extension. Ape1 was also found to remove 3'-tyrosyl residues from 3'-recessed and nicked DNAs, suggesting a potential role in processing covalent topoisomerase I-DNA intermediates formed during chromosome relaxation. While exhibiting preferential excision of thymine in a T:G mismatch context, Ape1 was unable to degrade a triple 3'-thymine mispair. However, Ape1 was able to excise double nucleotide mispairs, apparently through a novel 3'-flap-type endonuclease activity, again activating these substrates for polymerase beta extension.

Selective interactions of human kin17 and RPA proteins with chromatin and the nuclear matrix in a DNA damage- and cell cycle-regulated manner

Several proteins involved in DNA synthesis are part of the so-called 'replication factories' that are anchored on non-chromatin nuclear structures. We report here that human kin17, a nuclear stress-activated protein, associates with both chromatin and non-chromatin nuclear structures in a cell cycle- and DNA damage-dependent manner. After L-mimosine block and withdrawal we observed that kin17 protein was recruited in the nucleus during re-entry and progression through S phase. These results are consistent with a role of kin17 protein in DNA replication. About 50% of the total amount of kin17 protein was detected on nuclear structures and could not be released by detergents. Furthermore, the amount of kin17 protein greatly increased in both G(1)/S and S phase-arrested cells in fractions containing proteins anchored to nuclear structures. The detection of kin17 protein showed for the first time its preferential assembly within non-chromatin nuclear structures in G(1)/S and S phase-arrested cells, while the association with these structures was found to be less stable in the G(2)/M phase, as judged by fractionation of human cells and immunostaining. In asynchronous growing cells, kin17 protein interacted with both chromatin DNA and non-chromatin nuclear structures, while in S phase-arrested cells it interacted mostly with non-chromatin nuclear structures, as judged by DNase I treatment and in vivo UV cross-linking. In the presence of DNA damage in S phase cells, the distribution of kin17 protein became mainly associated with chromosomal DNA, as judged by limited formaldehyde cross-linking of living cells. The physical interaction of kin17 protein with components of the nuclear matrix was confirmed and visualized by indirect immunofluorescence and immunoelectron microscopy. Our results indicate that, during S phase, a fraction of the human kin17 protein preferentially associates with the nuclear matrix, a fundamentally non-chromatin higher order nuclear structure, and to chromatin DNA in the presence of DNA damage.

Oxidative DNA damage: mechanisms, mutation, and disease

Oxidative DNA damage is an inevitable consequence of cellular metabolism, with a propensity for increased levels following toxic insult. Although more than 20 base lesions have been identified, only a fraction of these have received appreciable study, most notably 8-oxo-2'deoxyguanosine. This lesion has been the focus of intense research interest and been ascribed much importance, largely to the detriment of other lesions. The present work reviews the basis for the biological significance of oxidative DNA damage, drawing attention to the multiplicity of proteins with repair activities along with a number of poorly considered effects of damage. Given the plethora of (often contradictory) reports describing pathological conditions in which levels of oxidative DNA damage have been measured, this review critically addresses the extent to which the in vitro significance of such damage has relevance for the pathogenesis of disease. It is suggested that some shortcomings associated with biomarkers, along with gaps in our knowledge, may be responsible for the failure to produce consistent and definitive results when applied to understanding the role of DNA damage in disease, highlighting the need for further studies.

The exonuclease activity of human apurinic/apyrimidinic endonuclease (APE1). Biochemical properties and inhibition by the natural dinucleotide Gp4G

Human DNA apurinic/apyrimidinic endonuclease (APE1) plays a key role in the DNA base excision repair process. In this study, we further characterized the exonuclease activity of APE1. The magnesium requirement and pH dependence of the exonuclease and endonuclease activities of APE1 are significantly different. APE1 showed a similar K(m) value for matched, 3' mispaired, or nucleoside analog beta-l-dioxolane-cytidine terminated nicked DNA as well as for DNA containing a tetrahydrofuran, an abasic site analog. The k(cat) for exonuclease activity on matched, 3' mispaired, and beta-l-dioxolane-cytidine nicked DNA are 2.3, 61.2, and 98.8 min(-1), respectively, and 787.5 min(-1) for APE1 endonuclease. Site-directed APE1 mutant proteins (E96A, E96Q, D210E, D210N, and H309N), which target amino acid residues in the endonuclease active site, also showed significant decrease in exonuclease activity. Gp(4)G was the only potent inhibitor to compete against the substrates of endonuclease and exonuclease activities among all tested naturally occurring ribo-, deoxyribo-nucleoside/nucleotides, NAD(+), NADP(+), and Ap(4)A. The K(i) values of Gp(4)G for the endonuclease and exonuclease activities of APE1 are 10 +/- 0.6 and 1 +/- 0.2 microm, respectively. Given the relative concentrations of Gp(4)G, 3' mispaired, and abasic DNA, Gp(4)G may play an important role in regulating APE1 activity in cells. The data presented here suggest that the APE1 exonuclease and AP endonuclease are two distinct activities. APE1 may exist in two different conformations, and each conformation has a preference for a substrate. The different conformations can be affected by MgCl(2) or salt concentrations.

Long-patch DNA repair synthesis during base excision repair in mammalian cells

The base excision repair (BER) process removes base damage such as oxidation, alkylation or abasic sites. Two BER sub-pathways have been characterized using in vitro methods, and have been classified according to the length of the repair patch as either 'short-patch' BER (one nucleotide) or 'long-patch' BER (LP-BER; more than one nucleotide). To investigate the occurrence of LP-BER in vivo, we developed an assay using a plasmid containing a single modified base in the transcribed strand of the enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP) gene and a stop codon, based on a single-nucleotide mismatch, at varying distances on the 3' side of the lesion. The reversion of the stop codon occurs after DNA repair synthesis and restores EGFP expression after transfection of mismatch-repair-deficient cells. Repair patches longer than one nucleotide were observed for 55-80% or 80-100% of the plasmids with a mean length of 2-6 or 6-12 nucleotides for 8-oxo-7,8-dihydroguanine or a synthetic abasic site, respectively. These data show the existence of LP-BER in vivo, and emphasize the effect of the type of BER substrate lesion on both the yield and the extent of the LP-BER sub-pathway.

AP endonuclease 1 has no biologically significant 3(')-->5(')-exonuclease activity

The 3(')-->5(')-exonucleolytic activity of human apurinic/apyrimidinic endonuclease 1 (APE1) on mispaired DNA at the 3(')-termini of recessed, nicked or gapped DNA molecules was analyzed and compared with the primary endonucleolytic activity. We found that under reaction conditions optimal for AP endonuclease activity the 3(')-->5(')-exonuclease activity of APE1 manifests only at enzyme concentration elevated by 6-7 orders of magnitude. This activity does not show a preference to mismatched compared to matched DNA structures as well as to nicked or gapped DNA substrates in comparison to recessed ones. Therefore, the 3(')-->5(')-exonuclease activity associated with APE1 can hardly be considered as key mechanism that improves fidelity of DNA repair.