Unravelling an HLA-DR Association in Childhood Acute Lymphoblastic Leukemia

Effect of human leukocyte antigen heterozygosity on infectious disease outcome: the need for allele-specific measures

BACKGROUND

Doherty and Zinkernagel, who discovered that antigen presentation is restricted by the major histocompatibility complex (MHC, called HLA in humans), hypothesized that individuals heterozygous at particular MHC loci might be more resistant to particular infectious diseases than the corresponding homozygotes because heterozygotes could present a wider repertoire of antigens. The superiority of heterozygotes over either corresponding homozygote, which we term allele-specific overdominance, is of direct biological interest for understanding the mechanisms of immune response; it is also a leading explanation for the observation that MHC loci are extremely polymorphic and that these polymorphisms have been maintained through extremely long evolutionary periods. Recent studies have shown that in particular viral infections, heterozygosity at HLA loci was associated with a favorable disease outcome, and such findings have been interpreted as supporting the allele-specific overdominance hypothesis in humans.

METHODS

An algebraic model is used to define the expected population-wide findings of an epidemiologic study of HLA heterozygosity and disease outcome as a function of allele-specific effects and population genetic parameters of the study population.

RESULTS

We show that overrepresentation of HLA heterozygotes among individuals with favorable disease outcomes (which we term population heterozygote advantage) need not indicate allele-specific overdominance. On the contrary, partly due to a form of confounding by allele frequencies, population heterozygote advantage can occur under a very wide range of assumptions about the relationship between homozygote risk and heterozygote risk. In certain extreme cases, population heterozygote advantage can occur even when every heterozygote is at greater risk of being a case than either corresponding homozygote.

CONCLUSION

To demonstrate allele-specific overdominance for specific infections in human populations, improved analytic tools and/or larger studies (or studies in populations with limited HLA diversity) are necessary.

High occurence of DRB1 11 in chronic lymphocytic leukaemia families

Recently, linkage analysis of a series of familial chronic lymphocytic leukaemia (CLL) showed that affected sibling pairs did not share common major histocompatibilty complex haplotypes. We analysed Class I and II antigens in 11 Italian families with familial CLL. Although there was no association of disease status with any particular human leucocyte antigen, there was an overrepresentation of DRB1 11 alleles in these families (P = 0.009). A similar trend was also observed in a second series of nine French families (P = 0.002). Larger studies are needed to determine whether non-inherited paternal or maternal DRB1 antigens play a role in familial CLL development.

Human leukocyte antigens class II and tumor necrosis factor genetic polymorphisms are independent predictors of non-Hodgkin lymphoma outcome

Tumor necrosis factor (TNF) production and non-Hodgkin lymphoma (NHL) outcome was found to be related to the TNF(-308) polymorphism. To explore whether this could be linked to neighboring polymorphisms, we genotyped the TNF(-376,-308,-238,-163), lymphotoxin alpha (LTalpha)(+252), and HLA DRB1 alleles in 204 patients with NHL and 120 controls. TNF(-308A) was the only allele associated with higher TNF and its p55 and p75 receptors' levels (P =.009, P =.03, and P =.007) and lower complete remission rates (P =.006). Freedom from progression (FFP) and overall survival (OS) were shorter in patients with TNF(-308A) (P =.009 and P =.02), null HLA DRB1*02 allele (P =.007 and P =.14), or both genetic markers (P =.004 and P =.005). Multivariate analysis incorporating International Prognostic Index (IPI) identified TNF(-308A) (P <.0001, relative risk [RR] = 1.63; P <.0001, RR = 1.51) and null HLA DRB1*02 alleles (P =.015, RR = 1.18; P <.0001, RR = 1.25) as independent factors for FFP and OS. These results indicate the existence of at least 2 inherited factors involved in NHL outcome.

Increased heterozygosity for MHC class II lineages in newborn males

In plants, fungi and marine invertebrates, there are genetic compatibility systems to ensure diversity in the offspring. The importance of genetic compatibility in gametic union and selective abortion in vertebrate animals has also been appreciated recently. There have been suggestions that the major histocompatibility complex (HLA in humans) may be a compatibility system in vertebrates. HLA class II haplotypes often contain a second expressed DRB locus which can be either DRB3, DRB4 or DRB5. These encode the supertypical specificities and mark the ancestral lineages. The members of each lineage have related DNA sequences at the main class II locus HLA-DRB1. We analysed 415 newborns at all expressed DRB loci by PCR analysis to seek evidence for sex-specific prenatal selection events. While there was no significant change in heterozygosity rates between males and females at DRB1, the proportion of males carrying two DRB1 specificities from different ancestral lineages was significantly increased (53.7% in males vs 39.3% in females, P = 0.003). The genotypes consisting of phylogenetically most distinct ones, namely the DRB3 and DRB4 haplotypes, showed the most striking difference between sexes (P = 0.007). These results suggested a more favourable outcome for male concepti heterozygous for supertypical haplotypes. Heterozygosity for most divergent haplotypical families ensures the highest degree of functional heterozygosity at the main HLA class II locus DRB1 while increasing the likelihood of heterozygosity also at other MHC loci. Our observations agree with the previously reported heterozygote excess in male newborn rats and mice. Correlations between MHC class II heterozygosity and advertised male quality in deer and pheasant as well as increased reproductive success in MHC class II heterozygous male macaques are examples of postnatal benefits of heterozygosity in males that may be behind the development of prenatal selection mechanisms. The MHC-mediated prenatal selection of males may also be one of the selective events suggested by the very high primary (male-to-female) sex ratio at fertilization reaching close to unity at birth in humans. These results provide an appealing working hypothesis for further studies in humans and other vertebrates.

A male-specific increase in the HLA-DRB4 (DR53) frequency in high-risk and relapsed childhood ALL

Previous studies reported significant HLA-DR associations with various leukemias one of which is with HLA-DRB4 (DR53) family in male patients with childhood ALL. We have HLA-DR-typed 212 high-risk or relapsed patients with childhood (n=114) and adult (n=98) ALL and a total of 250 healthy controls (118 children, 132 adult) by PCR-SSP analysis. The members of the HLA-DRB3 (DR52) family were underrepresented in patients most significantly for HLA-DRB1*12 (P=0.0007) and HLA-DRB1*13 (P=0.0001). In childhood ALL, the protective effect of DRB3 was evident in homozygous form (P=0.001). The DRB4 marker frequency was increased in males with childhood ALL (67.4%) compared to age- and sex-matched controls (42.1%, P=0.003) and female patients (35.7%, P=0.004). Besides being a general marker for increased susceptibility to childhood ALL in males, HLA-DRB4 is over-represented in high-risk patients. These results further suggest that the HLA system is one of the components of genetic susceptibility to leukemia but mainly in childhood and in boys only.

Hemochromatosis gene in leukemia and lymphoma

The gene causing hereditary hemochromatosis (HH), HFE is an HLA class I-like gene with no known immunological function but indirectly related to the immune functions because of its role in iron transport. It is located 6.5 Mb telomeric to HLA-A. The most common mutation of HFE, C282Y, has a Celtic origin and most patients with HH are homozygous for it in Northern European populations. While there is an enormously increased risk for hepatocellular cancer in hemochromatosis that is attributed to the toxic effects of iron, the risk for extra-hepatic cancers is also increased slightly. Recent studies have found genetic associations between several cancers and C282Y but only in the presence of a particular allele of the transferrin receptor gene. This suggests that the increased cancer risk is more likely due to the effects of iron. In childhood acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL), however, there is a strong association of C282Y with a gender effect in two different Celtic populations. This association does not require homozygosity for C282Y or an interaction with the transferrin receptor gene, and is male-specific. The other HFE mutation H63D does not confer increased risk to childhood ALL. Acute myeloblastic leukemia and Hodgkin's disease in adults do not have an association with HFE. Its male-specificity, occurrence in childhood and the lack of a gene-dosage effect suggest that the C282Y association in childhood ALL may reflect the involvement of another HLA-linked gene in leukemia susceptibility.

Risk of haematological malignancies in HLA-B27 carriers

Human leucocyte antigen (HLA)-B27 carriers are predisposed to inflammatory and autoimmune diseases. Among 1137 patients with haematological diseases, 59 HLA-B27 carriers were identified. Compared with 18 774 volunteers, the incidence of HLA-B27 was increased in patients with acute leukaemia (relative risk RR = 1.67, P = 0.002), for both acute myeloid leukaemia (AML) (RR) = 1.67, P = 0.007) and acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL) (RR = 1.68, P = 0.094). Of all the HLA-B27 carriers, four patients had ankylosing spondylitis (AS), all with lymphoid malignancies (three ALL, one Hodgkin's disease), whereas no HLA-B27 carriers with myeloid leukaemia had AS symptoms (P = 0.006). This suggests that HLA-B27 carriers may have an increased risk of acute leukaemia and those with concomitant AS may be predisposed to lymphoid malignancies.

An overview of the Welsh bone marrow donor registry: 10 years of bone marrow donor provision

The Welsh Bone Marrow Donor Registry (WBMDR) is in its 11th year of operation and its 4th year as an International 'Hub' participating in Bone Marrow Donors Worldwide. It is operated by the Welsh Regional Tissue Typing Laboratory which is accredited by Clinical Pathology Accreditation (UK) Ltd, and the European Federation for Immunogenetics and, together with the Welsh Blood Service, its donor centre, is ISO 9001 Registered. The active donor panel of over 21 000 regular blood donors are all HLA-A, B, DR, DQ typed (over 95% to the split specificity level or higher). All HLA-DR, DQ and over 50% of HLA-A, B typing has been performed by DNA-based methods. CMV antibody status, now tested on all donors, is known on over 70% of subjects. The WBMDR has over 80% success at obtaining Confirmatory Typing samples and operates a rapid Expanded Typing service on stored donor material. It has provided 174 bone marrow donations (140 for UK and 34 for overseas patients), and 11 lymphocyte donations, since its inception in 1989.