Variable clinical expression of mutations in the P/Q-type calcium channel gene in familial hemiplegic migraine. Dutch Migraine Genetics Research Group

A G301R Na+/K+ -ATPase mutation causes familial hemiplegic migraine type 2 with cerebellar signs

Familial hemiplegic migraine (FHM) is an autosomal dominant subtype of migraine with hemiparesis during the aura. In over 50% of cases the causative gene is CACNA1A (FHM1), which in some cases produces a phenotype with cerebellar signs, including ataxia and nystagmus. Recently, mutations in ATP1A2 on chromosome 1q23 encoding a Na+/K+ -ATPase subunit were identified in four families (FHM2). We now describe an FHM2 pedigree with a fifth ATP1A2 mutation coding for a G301R substitution. The phenotype was particularly severe and included hemiplegic migraine, seizure, prolonged coma, elevated temperature, sensory deficit, and transient or permanent cerebellar signs, such as ataxia, nystagmus, and dysarthria. A mild crossed cerebellar diaschisis during an attack further supported the clinical evidence of a cerebellar deficit. This is the first report suggesting cerebellar involvement in FHM2. A possible role for CACNA1A in producing the phenotype in this family was excluded by linkage studies to the FHM1 locus. The study of this family suggests that the absence of cerebellar signs may not be a reliable indicator to clinically differentiate FHM2 from FHM1.

Drug targets in the voltage-gated calcium channel family: why some are and some are not

The L-type calcium channel antagonists have been, and continue to be, a very successful group of therapeutic agents targeted at cardiovascular disorders, notably angina and hypertension. The discovery that the voltage-gated calcium channels are a large and widely distributed family with important roles in both the peripheral and central nervous systems has initiated a major search for drugs active at other calcium channel types directed at disorders of the central nervous system, including pain, epilepsy, and stroke. These efforts have not been therapeutically successful thus far, and small molecule equivalents of the L-type blockers nifedipine, diltiazem, and verapamil directed at non-L-type channels have not been found. The underlying reasons for this are discussed together with suggestions for new directions, including fertility control, oxygen-sensitive channels, and calcium channel activators.

Toward a molecular genetic classification of familial hemiplegic migraine

The genetics of migraine is a fascinating and rapidly moving research area. Familial hemiplegic migraine, a rare subtype of migraine with a Mendelian pattern of inheritance, is caused by mutations in the chromosome 19 CACNA1A gene or in the chromosome 1 ATP1A2 gene. Familial migraine variants are classified on the basis of clinical, descriptive criteria, but this is insufficient. In the future, a diagnostic classification based on mutation-analysis is needed.

The genetics of migraine: implication for treatment approaches

Migraine is a paroxysmal neurological disorder affecting up to 12% of males and 24% of females in the general population, demonstrated to have a strong, but complex, genetic component. Genetic investigation of migraine bears great promise in providing new targets for drug development and optimization of individual specific therapy. Better, preferably prophylactic, treatment of migraine patients is desired because the presently used drugs are not effective in all patients, allow recurrence of the headache in a high percentage of patients and sometimes have severe adverse side effects. With the recent identification of the brain-specific P/Q-type calcium channel gene CACNA1A in the pathogenesis of migraine, the first step has been taken to identify primary biochemical pathways leading to migraine. Here, we summarize the current knowledge about the genetics of migraine and focus on the implication for treatment approaches.

Migraine genetics

The genetics of migraine is a fascinating and moving research area. Familial hemiplegic migraine, a rare subtype of migraine with a Mendelian pattern of inheritance, is caused by mutations in the chromosome 19 CACNA1A gene in approximately 75% of the families. The finding of mutations in an ionchannel subunit defines migraine as a channelopathy (eg, epilepsy). The genetics of the more frequent variants, migraine with and without aura, is more complex. Several loci have been studied in families and case-control studies, but need to be confirmed.

Pathophysiology, epidemiology, and impact of migraine

Despite a decade of progress, migraine headache remains prevalent, disabling, underdiagnosed, and undertreated in the United States. Migraine affects approximately 12% of the population, and the economic burden in terms of annual cost of labor lost to migraine disability is between $5.6 and $17.2 billion. The threshold for migraine may be genetically determined, although recent genetic and neurophysiologic studies point to migraine as possibly a channelopathy. Cerebral cortical and brain stem changes occur in migraine. Head pain and associated symptoms of migraine can be explained by activation of the trigeminal vascular system. Evidence has also been accumulated that suggests the release of nitric oxide is an important trigger mechanism. Introduction of the triptans has dramatically advanced acute migraine pharmacotherapy, and preventive therapy has greatly improved; however, public health initiatives may be needed to further advance diagnosis and treatment of this common and disabling disorder.

Acetazolamide acts on neuromuscular transmission abnormalities found in some migraineurs

Mild subclinical impairment of neuromuscular transmission can be detected with single-fibre electromyography (SFEMG) in subgroups of patients suffering from migraine and could be due to dysfunctioning Ca2+-channels on motor axons controlling stimulation-induced acetylcholine release. Acetazolamide, which is thought to ameliorate ion channel function, was shown effective in familial hemiplegic migraine and episodic ataxia type 2, both of which are associated with mutations of the neuronal Ca2+-channel gene CACNA1A, as well as in aura status. We treated therefore in an open pilot study five non-hemiplegic migraineurs showing mild SFEMG abnormalities with acetazolamide for several weeks. This was followed by a normalization of SFEMG recordings in all patients and by clinical improvement in four. These results support the assumption that the subclinical impairment of neuromuscular transmission found in certain migraineurs might be due to dysfunctioning Ca2+-channels.

The genetics of migraine

The search for genes involved in the pathophysiology of migraine poses major difficulties. First, there is no objective diagnostic method to assess the status of the individuals studied. Second, migraine is a polygenic multifactorial disorder. Familial hemiplegic migraine (FHM) is the only known autosomal dominant subtype of migraine. In half the families with FHM who have been studied, there are mutations in the calcium-channel gene CACNA1A, located on chromosome 19. In other families, a locus has been mapped on chromosome 1. The role of these loci in typical migraine is still unknown. A susceptibility locus for migraine with aura has been located on chromosome 19 (but is distinct from CACNA1A) and a genome-wide linkage analysis has mapped a susceptibility locus on chromosome 4. Another locus for migraine may be on the X chromosome. Finally, many positive association studies have been published, but few have been replicated.

Calcium channel mutations and migraine

An increasing number of mutations in the CACNA1A gene have been identified, which are associated with a broad clinical spectrum, including familial hemiplegic migraine. Transfection studies and mouse model analyses are currently being undertaken to study the correlation between CACNA1A mutations and disease.

A population-based study of familial hemiplegic migraine suggests revised diagnostic criteria

Familial hemiplegic migraine (FHM) is a rare autosomal dominantly inherited subtype of migraine with aura. The clinical characteristics of FHM have been described previously in selected materials or case studies, but population-based studies are important in order to analyse the full spectrum of the disorder. The aim of the present study was to perform a systematic search for familial cases of migraine with an aura that included motor weakness in order to generate non-selected material of as many FHM cases as possible in the Danish population of 5.2 million inhabitants, and to compare this material with already available population-based clinical descriptions of migraine with typical aura (MA). Due to the rarity of FHM, traditional population-based methods were not feasible. Therefore, the search strategy employed a computer search of the National Patient Register, screening >27 000 case records from headache clinics and private neurologists, and advertisements. A total of 147 affected FHM patients from 44 families were identified. FHM patients most often had all four 'typical' aura symptoms (visual, sensory, aphasic and motor symptoms) and all had at least two of these aura symptoms during FHM attacks. The motor, sensory and visual aura symptoms were all similar in type to the motor, sensory and visual aura symptoms in MA, but FHM had a statistically significantly longer duration of the visual and sensory aura symptoms, and these and other aura symptoms often fulfilled the criteria of the International Headache Society for prolonged aura. In addition, 69% had basilar migraine (BM) symptoms during FHM attacks. The order of the aura symptoms was usually visual, followed by sensory, aphasic, motor and, lastly, basilar-type migraine symptoms. Headache was present in 99% of FHM patients during FHM attacks, whereas the aura symptoms more often occurred without headache in MA. Headache duration was significantly longer in FHM compared with MA. Based on these data, we suggest more precise diagnostic criteria for FHM and a more clear clinical distinction between FHM and BM. Our results have significant implications for case finding in genetic studies and for clinical migraine differential diagnosis.

An epidemiological survey of hemiplegic migraine

The objective of the present study was to use systematic nation-wide case-finding methods to establish the prevalence and sex ratio of hemiplegic migraine (HM) in the entire Danish population of 5.2 million inhabitants. Affected patients were identified from three different recruitment sources: the National Patient Register, case records from private practising neurologists and advertisements. Based on the observed number of affected patients from each case-finding method, it was attempted to estimate the total number of affected patients by means of the statistical method known as capture-recapture. Two hundred and ninety-one affected patients were identified; 147 were familial HM from 44 different families, 105 were sporadic HM and 39 were unclassifiable HM. The HM sex ratio (M:F) was 1:3. Based on the identified number of affected patients the prevalence of HM at the end of 1999 was estimated to be 0.01% in Denmark, where the familial and sporadic form were equally frequent.

Investigation of the CACNA1A gene as a candidate for typical migraine susceptibility

Typical migraine is a complex neurological disorder comprised of two main subtypes: migraine with (MA) and without aura (MO). The disease etiology is still unclear, but family studies provide strong evidence that defective genes play an important role. Familial hemiplegic migraine (FHM) is a very rare and severe subtype of MA. It has been proposed that FHM and MA may have a similar genetic etiology. Therefore, genetic studies on FHM provide a useful model for investigating the more prevalent types of typical migraine. FHM in some families has been shown to be caused by mutations in a brain-specific P/Q-type calcium channel alpha1 subunit gene (CACNA1A) on chromosome 19p13. There has also been a report of a CACNA1A mutation being associated with MA in a patient from a family with predominant FHM. We have previously demonstrated suggestive linkage of typical migraine in a large Australian family to the FHM region on chromosome 19p13. These findings suggest that CACNA1A may also be implicated in the etiology of typical migraine in this pedigree. To investigate this possibility, we sequenced two patients carrying the critical susceptibility haplotype surrounding CACNA1A. No disease-causing mutations or polymorphisms were revealed in any of the 47 exons screened. To determine whether the CACNA1A gene was implicated in typical migraine susceptibility in the general Caucasian population, we also analyzed 82 independent pedigrees and a large case control group. We did not detect any linkage or association in these groups and conclude that if CACNA1A plays a role in typical migraine, it does not confer a major effect on the disease.

CACNA1A gene polymorphisms in cluster headache

Cluster headache (CH) is a primary headache disorder where the aetiological and pathophysiological mechanisms still are largely unknown. An increased risk of CH in first- and second-degree relatives suggests the importance of genetic factors. Mutations of the P/Q type calcium channel alpha 1 subunit (CACNA1A) gene on chromosome 19p13 have been shown to cause several neurological disorders with a wide clinical spectrum, mainly episodic diseases. Missense mutations of the gene cause familial hemiplegic migraine (FHM) and it is also likely to be involved in the more common forms of migraine. The CACNA1A gene is thus a promising candidate gene for CH. In this study we performed an association analysis of an intragenic polymorphic (CA)n-repeat with marker D19S1150 and a (CAG)n-repeat in the 3'UTR region, in 75 patients with CH according to IHS criteria and 108 matched controls. Genotypes and allele frequencies were similarly distributed in patients and controls. Linkage disequilibrium between the two markers was similar in patients and controls. We conclude that an importance of the CACNA1A gene in sporadic CH is unlikely.

Familial hemiplegic migraine: a ion channel disorder

At present, little information is available on the genetics of common migraines, most likely to be considered a multifactorial disease. Recently, the CACNA1A gene encoding the brain-specific P/Q type calcium channel alpha(1) subunit, has been cloned and mutations in this gene, located on chromosome 19p13, have been shown to be involved in familial hemiplegic migraine (FHM), a rare autosomal dominantly inherited subtype of migraine with aura. Being part of the migraine spectrum, FHM represents a good model to study the genetics of more common forms of migraine. Different classes of mutations within the CACNA1A gene have been associated with different diseases, thus identifying a new member among 'channelopathies'. Variable clinical expression and genetic heterogeneity of FHM will be discussed.

The clinical spectrum of familial hemiplegic migraine associated with mutations in a neuronal calcium channel

BACKGROUND

Familial hemiplegic migraine, an autosomal dominant disorder characterized by attacks of transient hemiparesis followed by a migraine headache, is classically divided into pure familial hemiplegic migraine (affecting 80 percent of families) and familial hemiplegic migraine with permanent cerebellar signs (affecting 20 percent of families). Mutations in CACNA1A, which encodes a neuronal calcium channel, are present in 50 percent of families with hemiplegic migraine, including all those with cerebellar signs. We studied the various clinical manifestations associated with mutations in CACNA1A in families with hemiplegic migraine with and without cerebellar signs.

METHODS

CACNA1A was analyzed and nine mutations were detected in 15 of 16 probands of families affected by hemiplegic migraine and cerebellar signs, in 2 of 3 subjects with sporadic hemiplegic migraine and cerebellar signs, and in 4 of 12 probands of families affected by pure hemiplegic migraine. Genotyping of probands and relatives identified a total of 117 subjects with mutations whose clinical manifestations were assessed in detail.

RESULTS

Eighty-nine percent of the subjects with mutations had attacks of hemiplegic migraine. One third had severe attacks with coma, prolonged hemiplegia, or both, with full recovery. All nine mutations, including five newly identified ones, were missense mutations. Six mutations were associated with hemiplegic migraine and cerebellar signs, and 83 percent of the subjects with these six mutations had nystagmus, ataxia, or both. Three mutations were associated with pure hemiplegic migraine.

CONCLUSIONS

Hemiplegic migraine in subjects with mutations in CACNA1A has a broad clinical spectrum. This clinical variability is partially associated with the various types of mutations.

Delayed cerebral edema and fatal coma after minor head trauma: role of the CACNA1A calcium channel subunit gene and relationship with familial hemiplegic migraine

Trivial head trauma may be complicated by severe, sometimes even fatal, cerebral edema and coma occurring after a lucid interval ("delayed cerebral edema"). Attacks of familial hemiplegic migraine (FHM) can be triggered by minor head trauma and are sometimes accompanied by coma. Mutations in the CACNA1A calcium channel subunit gene on chromosome 19 are associated with a wide spectrum of mutation-specific episodic and chronic neurological disorders, including FHM with or without coma. We investigated the role of the CACNA1A gene in three subjects with delayed cerebral edema. Two subjects originated from a family with extreme FHM, and one subject was the previously asymptomatic daughter of a sporadic patient with hemiplegic migraine attacks. In all three subjects with delayed severe edema, we found a C-to-T substitution resulting in the substitution of serine for lysine at codon 218 (S218L) in the CACNA1A gene. The mutation was absent in nonaffected family members and 152 control individuals. Haplotype analysis excluded a common founder for both families. Neuropathological examination in one subject showed Purkinje cell loss with relative preservation of granule cells and sparing of the dentate and inferior olivary nuclei. We conclude that the novel S218L mutation in the CACNA1A calcium channel subunit gene is involved in FHM and delayed fatal cerebral edema and coma after minor head trauma. This finding may have important implications for the understanding and treatment of this dramatic syndrome.

Three new familial hemiplegic migraine mutants affect P/Q-type Ca(2+) channel kinetics

Missense mutations in the pore-forming human alpha(1A) subunit of neuronal P/Q-type Ca(2+) channels are associated with familial hemiplegic migraine. We studied the functional consequences on P/Q-type Ca(2+) channel function of three recently identified mutations, R583Q, D715E, and V1457L after introduction into rabbit alpha(1A) and expression in Xenopus laevis oocytes. The potential for half-maximal channel activation of Ba(2+) inward currents was shifted by > 9 mV to more negative potentials in all three mutants. The potential for half-maximal channel inactivation was shifted by > 7 mV in the same direction in R583Q and D715E. Biexponential current inactivation during 3-s test pulses was significantly faster in D715E and slower in V1457L than in wild type. Mutations R583Q and V1457L delayed the time course of recovery from channel inactivation. The decrease of peak current through R583Q (30.2%) and D715E (30. 1%) but not V1457L (18.7%) was more pronounced during 1-Hz trains of 15 100-ms pulses than in wild type (18.2%). Our data demonstrate that the mutations R583Q, D715E, and V1457L, like the previously reported mutations T666M, V714A, and I1819L, affect P/Q-type Ca(2+) channel gating. We therefore propose that altered channel gating represents a common pathophysiological mechanism in familial hemiplegic migraine.

Molecular genetics of migraine headaches: a review

Following the recent discovery of neural calcium channel mutations in familial hemiplegic migraine, genetic linkage and association studies have been performed world-wide in an effort to unveil the genetic basis of the more common types of migraine too. Mutations in neural calcium channels, mitochondrial DNA, serotonin receptors and transporter, dopamine receptors and genetic prothrombotic risk factors have been especially investigated and are discussed here. No unambiguous conclusions have, however, been reached. FHM remains an isolated success story in the quest for the genetic basis of migraine.

Neurological channelopathies: diagnosis and therapy in the new millennium

Rapid progress in the complementary fields of molecular genetics and cellular electrophysiology has led to a better understanding of many disorders which are caused by ion channel dysfunction. These channelopathies may manifest in a multitude of ways depending on the tissue specificity of the channel that is affected. Several important general medical conditions are now known to be channelopathies but the neurological members of this family are amongst the best characterized. Over recent years, ion channel dysfunction in skeletal muscle in particular has emerged as a paradigm for understanding neurological ion channel disorders. This review concentrates mainly on the diseases caused by dysfunction of the voltage-gated ion channels. We initially focus on the skeletal muscle channelopathies (the periodic paralyses, malignant hyperthermia, paramyotonia congenita and myotonia congenita). The central nervous system channelopathies are then explored, with particular reference to the advances which have implications for understanding the mechanisms of common neurological disorders such as epilepsy and migraine. Looking towards the new millennium, DNA-based diagnosis will become a realistic proposition for most neurological channelopathies. Furthermore, it seems likely that new therapies will be designed based on genotype and mode of ion channel dysfunction.

The genetic basis of migraine: how much do we know?

Migraine with and without aura is thought to be genetically complex with aggregation in families due to a combination of environmental and genetic tendencies. Twin studies are most important in establishing the multifactorial nature of migraine with heritability approaching 50%. Familial hemiplegic migraine (FHM) on the other hand is an autosomal dominant, highly penetrant, though rare form of migraine with strong genetic tendency. Fifty percent of families with FHM are linked to chromosome 19p13 and mutations demonstrated for some in a brain expressed calcium channel alpha 1A subunit, CACNL1A4. Other FHM loci have been identified on chromosome 1q and further genetic heterogeneity is likely. The exact role of the mutated calcium channel in the pathway leading to hemiplegic migraine is yet to be established. Changes in the electrophysiologic properties of the mutated forms of the CACNL1A4 calcium channel expressed in heterologous systems help establish the functional significance of the mutations and suggest that chromosome 19p-linked FHM, an episodic disorder, represents a CNS channelopathy. Additional candidate genes causative for migraine might include other calcium channel subunits and related proteins important for neuronal membrane stability. Delineating the cascade of biochemical events leading to hemiplegic migraine will serve as a model for understanding the pathophysiology of more common forms of migraine. The evidence suggesting that some families of migraine with and without aura might also be related to the chromosome 19p locus, chromosome Xq28 locus, or DRD2 receptor polymorphisms is reviewed.

Personality and response to repeated visual stimulation in migraine and tension-type headaches

Migraine sufferers potentiate their visual evoked potentials (VEPs) from a short period of 2 min to a longer period of 15 min. As a lack of habituation is linked to higher level arousal, we thus hypothesized that short-term VEP potentiation might be correlated with an arousal-related personality trait. We therefore carried out short-term VEPs, Plutchik-van Praag's Depression Inventory, Zuckerman's Sensation-Seeking Scales (Form V), and Zuckerman-Kuhlman's Personality Questionnaire in 26 healthy subjects, 22 patients suffering from migraine without aura between attacks, 13 episodic and 20 chronic tension-type headaches. The chronic tension-type headache sufferers showed increased depression compared with other groups, which might be a consequence of the headache itself. Migraines, however, showed steeper habituation slopes of N1-P1 and P1-N2, decreased thrill and adventure-seeking, and general sensation-seeking than healthy controls; in addition, the habituation slope of P1-N2 was positively correlated with experience-seeking in migraine. The short-term VEP potentiation and the decreased thrill and adventure-seeking and general sensation-seeking in migraine might be related to a high level of cortical arousal and a low 5HT neurotransmission. In compliance with the long-term VEP study, the positive correlation between the P1-N2 habituation slope and experience-seeking in migraine suggests a continuous metabolic overload for the brain interictally, which can trigger the activation of a migraine attack.

Functional consequences of mutations in the human alpha1A calcium channel subunit linked to familial hemiplegic migraine

Mutations in alpha1A, the pore-forming subunit of P/Q-type calcium channels, are linked to several human diseases, including familial hemiplegic migraine (FHM). We introduced the four missense mutations linked to FHM into human alpha1A-2 subunits and investigated their functional consequences after expression in human embryonic kidney 293 cells. By combining single-channel and whole-cell patch-clamp recordings, we show that all four mutations affect both the biophysical properties and the density of functional channels. Mutation R192Q in the S4 segment of domain I increased the density of functional P/Q-type channels and their open probability. Mutation T666M in the pore loop of domain II decreased both the density of functional channels and their unitary conductance (from 20 to 11 pS). Mutations V714A and I1815L in the S6 segments of domains II and IV shifted the voltage range of activation toward more negative voltages, increased both the open probability and the rate of recovery from inactivation, and decreased the density of functional channels. Mutation V714A decreased the single-channel conductance to 16 pS. Strikingly, the reduction in single-channel conductance induced by mutations T666M and V714A was not observed in some patches or periods of activity, suggesting that the abnormal channel may switch on and off, perhaps depending on some unknown factor. Our data show that the FHM mutations can lead to both gain- and loss-of-function of human P/Q-type calcium channels.

Recurrence of the T666M calcium channel CACNA1A gene mutation in familial hemiplegic migraine with progressive cerebellar ataxia

Familial hemiplegic migraine (HM) is an autosomal dominant migraine with aura. In 20% of HM families, HM is associated with a mild permanent cerebellar ataxia (PCA). The CACNA1A gene encoding the alpha1A subunit of P/Q-type voltage-gated calcium channels is involved in 50% of unselected HM families and in all families with HM/PCA. Four CACNA1A missense mutations have been identified in HM: two in pure HM and two in HM/PCA. Different CACNA1A mutations have been identified in other autosomal dominant conditions: mutations leading to a truncated protein in episodic ataxia type 2 (EA2), small expansions of a CAG trinucleotide in spinocerebellar ataxia type 6 and also in three families with EA2 features, and, finally, a missense mutation in a single family suffering from episodic ataxia and severe progressive PCA. We screened 16 families and 3 nonfamilial case patients affected by HM/PCA for specific CACNA1A mutations and found nine families and one nonfamilial case with the same T666M mutation, one new mutation (D715E) in one family, and no CAG repeat expansion. Both T666M and D715E substitutions were absent in 12 probands belonging to pure HM families whose disease appears to be linked to CACNA1A. Finally, haplotyping with neighboring markers suggested that T666M arose through recurrent mutational events. These data could indicate that the PCA observed in 20% of HM families results from specific pathophysiologic mechanisms.