Ligands of steroid/thyroid receptors induce cone photoreceptors in vertebrate retina

Microenvironmental regulation of visual pigment expression in the chick retina

Visual pigment (VP) expression in the chick embryo retina was investigated in ovo, in dissociated and explant cultures, and in cDNAs from individual cells. While VP mRNA is not detectable by in situ hybridization until embryonic day (ED) 14-16 in ovo, analysis of VP expression by RT-PCR showed that VP messages are present in the retina as many as 7-10 days before they become detectable by in situ hybridization, and are also detected in other regions of the embryonic CNS. On the other hand, red opsin expression is markedly accelerated when cells are isolated from their intraocular microenvironment at ED 6, and placed in pigment epithelium-free dissociated or explant cultures. This acceleration occurs regardless of cell density, birth date, or serum presence in the medium, suggesting that many photoreceptors are already programmed to express red opsin on or before ED 6, and that microenvironmental inhibitory factors prevent implementation of this program until ED 14 in ovo. The selectivity of this phenomenon is suggested by the finding that other VPs are not observed by in situ hybridization in ED 6 cultures, although they are detectable in cultures of older retinas. Taken together, these findings suggest that red opsin expression may be constitutive for many developing photoreceptor cells in the chick.

Sources and sink of retinoic acid in the embryonic chick retina: distribution of aldehyde dehydrogenase activities, CRABP-I, and sites of retinoic acid inactivation

Previous experiments in mice and zebrafish led to the hypothesis that an asymmetric distribution of the transcriptional activator retinoic acid (RA) causes ventral-dorsal polarity in the vertebrate eye anlage. A high concentration of RA in the ventral retinal neuroepithelium has been suggested to induce developmental events that finally establish topographic order in the retinotectal projection along the vertical eye axis. In the present study we have investigated potential sources and sinks of RA during embryonic development of the chick retina. At embryonic day (E)1 to E2, when the spatial determination of the eye primordia takes place, no RA synthesis by aldehyde dehydrogenases was detectable, and neither immunoreactivity for retinaldehyde dehydrogenase RALDH-2 nor for cellular retinoic acid binding protein CRABP-I was observed. These components of RA signal transduction appeared in the eye between E3 and E5. At later stages, RA-measurements with a reporter cell line showed highest synthesis in the retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) and at the ventral and dorsal poles of the retina. RA degradation occurred mostly in a horizontal region in the middle of the retina with only small differences along the nasal-temporal axis. CRABP-I immunoreactivity appeared first in differentiating retinal ganglion cells with no indication of a spatial gradient across the ventral-dorsal eye axis. RA-production depended on three NAD+-dependent enzyme activities, which could be competitively inhibited by citral. One enzyme, located in the dorsal retina (corresponding to mouse RALDH-1), and one enzyme in the RPE (RALDH-2) were aldehyde dehydrogenases of the same molecular weight (monomers about 55 kDa) but with different isoelectric points (6.5-6.9; 4.9-5.4). The third RA-synthesizing activity (pI 6.0-6.3) was limited to the ventral retina, and likely corresponded to mouse RALDH-3. The restricted localization of retinoid-metabolizing activities along the dorsal-ventral axis of the embryonic chick retina does support the idea that RA is involved in dorsal-ventral eye patterning. However, the late time of appearance of aldehyde dehydrogenase activities and CRABP-I points to functions in cellular differentiation that are distinct from the initiation of the dorsal-ventral polarity.

Retinoic acid-mediated gene expression in transgenic reporter zebrafish

Retinoic acid-mediated gene activation is important for normal vertebrate development. The size and nature of retinoic acid make it difficult to identify the precise cellular location of this signaling molecule throughout an embryo. Additionally, retinoic acid (RA) signaling is regulated by a complex combination of receptors, coactivators, and antagonizing proteins. Thus, in order to integrate these signals and identify regions within a whole developing embryo where cells can respond transcriptionally to retinoic acid, we have used a reporter transgenic approach. We have generated several stable lines of transgenic zebrafish which use retinoic acid response elements to drive fluorescent protein expression. In these zebrafish lines, transgene expression is localized to regions of the neural tube, retina, notochord, somites, heart, pronephric ducts, branchial arches, and jaw muscles in embryos and larvae. Transgene expression can be induced in additional regions of the neural tube and retina as well as the immature notochord, hatching gland, enveloping cell layer, and fin by exposing embryos to retinoic acid. Treatment with retinoic acid synthase inhibitors, citral and diethylaminobenzaldehyde (DEAB), during neurulation, greatly reduces transgene expression. DEAB treatment of embryos at gastrulation phenocopies the embryonic effects of vitamin A deprivation or targeted disruption of the RA synthase retinaldehyde dehydrogenase-2 in other vertebrates. Together these data suggest that the reporter expression we see in zebrafish is dependent upon conserved vertebrate pathways of RA synthesis.

A thyroid hormone receptor that is required for the development of green cone photoreceptors

Color vision is facilitated by distinct populations of cone photoreceptors in the retina. In rodents, cones expressing different opsin photopigments are sensitive to middle (M, 'green') and short (S, 'blue') wavelengths, and are differentially distributed across the retina. The mechanisms that control which opsin is expressed in a particular cone are poorly understood, but previous in vitro studies implicated thyroid hormone in cone differentiation. Thyroid hormone receptor beta 2 (TR beta 2) is a ligand-activated transcription factor that is expressed in the outer nuclear layer of the embryonic retina. Here we delete Thrb (encoding Tr beta 2) in mice, causing the selective loss of M-cones and a concomitant increase in S-opsin immunoreactive cones. Moreover, the gradient of cone distribution is disturbed, with S-cones becoming widespread across the retina. The results indicate that cone photoreceptors throughout the retina have the potential to follow a default S-cone pathway and reveal an essential role for Tr beta 2 in the commitment to an M-cone identity. Our findings raise the possibility that Thrb mutations may be associated with human cone disorders.

The zebrafish young mutation acts non-cell-autonomously to uncouple differentiation from specification for all retinal cells

Embryos from mutagenized zebrafish were screened for disruptions in retinal lamination to identify factors involved in vertebrate retinal cell specification and differentiation. Two alleles of a recessive mutation, young, were isolated in which final differentiation and normal lamination of retinal cells were blocked. Early aspects of retinogenesis including the specification of cells along the inner optic cup as retinal tissue, polarity of the retinal neuroepithelium, and confinement of cell divisions to the apical pigmented epithelial boarder were normal in young mutants. BrdU incorporation experiments showed that the initiation and pattern of cell cycle withdrawal across the retina was comparable to wild-type siblings; however, this process took longer in the mutant. Analysis of early markers for cell type differentiation revealed that each of the major classes of retinal neurons, as well as non-neural Muller glial cells, are specified in young embryos. However, the retinal cells fail to elaborate morphological specializations, and analysis of late cell-type-specific markers suggests that the retinal cells were inhibited from fully differentiating. Other regions of the nervous system showed no obvious defects in young mutants. Mosaic analysis demonstrated that the young mutation acts non-cell-autonomously within the retina, as final morphological and molecular differentiation was rescued when genetically mutant cells were transplanted into wild-type hosts. Conversely, differentiation was prevented in wild-type cells when placed in young mutant retinas. Mosaic experiments also suggest that young functions at or near the cell surface and is not freely diffusible. We conclude that the young mutation disrupts the post-specification development of all retinal neurons and glia cells.

Development of the visual system of the chick. I. Cell differentiation and histogenesis

This review summarizes present knowledge on the embryonic development of the avian visual projections, based on the domestic chick as a model system. The reductionist goal to understand formation and function of complex neuroanatomical systems on a causal level requires a synthesis of classic developmental biology with recent advances on the molecular mechanisms of cell differentiation and histogenesis. It is the purpose of this article. We are discussing the processes underlying patterning of the anterior neural tube, when the retina and optic tectum are specified and their axial polarity is determined. Then the development of these structures is described from the molecular to the anatomical level. Following sections deal with the establishment of secondary visual connections, and the developmental interactions between compartments of the retinotectal system. Using this latter pathway, from the retina to the optic tectum, many investigations aimed at mechanisms of axonal pathfinding and connectivity have accumulated a vast body of research, which will be covered by a following review.

Extrinsic and intrinsic factors control the genesis of amacrine and cone cells in the rat retina

The seven major classes of cells of the vertebrate neural retina are generated from a pool of multipotent progenitor cells. Recent studies suggest a model of retinal development in which both the progenitor cells and the environment change over time (Cepko, C. L., Austin, C. P., Yang, X., Alexiades, M. and Ezzeddine, D. (1996). Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 93, 589–595). We have utilized a reaggregate culture system to test this model. A labeled population of progenitors from the embryonic rat retina were cultured with an excess of postnatal retinal cells and then assayed for their cell fate choices. We found that the postnatal environment had at least two signals that affected the embryonic cells' choice of fate; one signal inhibited the production of amacrine cells and a second affected the production of cone cells. No increase in cell types generated postnatally was observed. The source of the inhibitor of the amacrine cell fate appeared to be previously generated amacrine cells, suggesting that amacrine cell number is controlled by feedback inhibition. The progenitor cell lost its ability to be inhibited for production of an amacrine cell as it entered M phase of the cell cycle. We suggest that postmitotic cells influence progenitor cell fate decisions, but that they do so in a manner restricted by the intrinsic biases of progenitor cells.

The roles of intrinsic and extrinsic cues and bHLH genes in the determination of retinal cell fates

A fundamental issue concerning development of the vertebrate retina is the relative contributions of extrinsic and intrinsic cues to the determination of cell fate. Recent findings suggest that retinal progenitors go through a series of changes in intrinsic properties that control their competence to make different cell types and that extrinsic cues influence the ratios of the cell types that they produce. Recent studies of the role of the basic helix-loop-helix genes in retinal development have indicated that they can regulate competence and/or other aspects of cell fate determination.

A role for the fibroblast growth factor receptor in cell fate decisions in the developing vertebrate retina

The mature vertebrate retina contains seven major cell types that develop from an apparently homogenous population of precursor cells. Clonal analyses have suggested that environmental influences play a major role in specifying retinal cell identity. Fibroblast growth factor-2 is present in the developing retina and regulates the survival, proliferation and differentiation of developing retinal cells in culture. Here we have tested whether fibroblast growth factor receptor signaling biases retinal cell fate decisions in vivo. Fibroblast growth factor receptors were inhibited in retinal precursors in Xenopus embryos by expressing a dominant negative form of the receptor, XFD. Dorsal animal blastomeres that give rise to the retina were injected with cDNA expression constructs for XFD and a control non-functional mutant receptor, D48, and the cell fates of transgene-expressing cells in the mature retina determined. Fibroblast growth factor receptor blockade results in almost a 50% loss of photoreceptors and amacrine cells, and a concurrent 3.5-fold increase in Muller glia, suggesting a shift towards a Muller cell fate in the absence of a fibroblast growth factor receptor signal. Inhibition of non-fibroblast-growth-factor-mediated receptor signaling with a third mutant receptor, HAVO, alters cell fate in an opposite manner. These results suggest that it is the balance of fibroblast growth factor and non-fibroblast growth factor ligand signals that influences retinal cell genesis.

Vertebrate photoreceptor cell development and disease

Photoreceptors provide an excellent model for studies of vertebrate neuronal differentiation, and many human diseases resulting in blindness primarily affect photoreceptors. There is therefore great interest in studying the cellular and molecular mechanisms of photoreceptor development. This article discusses our current understanding of this process, including the recent discovery of the homeodomain transcription factor Crx and its potential role in diseases affecting human vision.

Molecular regulators involved in vertebrate eye development

Development of the eye can be subdivided into three phases. The first phase is the formation of the major structures of the eye by the processes of induction and regional specification. The second is the maturation of these structures to form the functional eye, and the third phase is the formation of neuronal connections between retina and the optic tectum. These processes are tightly regulated by signalling cascades that direct axonal outgrowth, cellular proliferation and differentiation. Some members of these signalling cascades have been identified in recent studies. These include secreted factors which transmit signals extracellularly, and receptors and transcription factors which are members of intracellular signalling pathways that respond to extracellular signals. This review summarizes the recent research that has implicated these factors in playing a role in eye development on the basis of functional or expression criteria.

Changes in Epidermal Growth Factor Receptor Expression and Competence to Generate Glia Regulate Timing and Choice of Differentiation in the Retina

Previous studies demonstrated that the level of epidermal growth factor receptors (EGF-Rs) expressed by progenitor cells in the newborn (P0) rat retina was limiting for the generation of Muller glial cells but not for proliferation. To determine whether EGF-R signaling biases cells to generate a specific cell type or regulates more general processes during progenitor cell development, we have introduced extra copies of the EGF-R into progenitor cells at earlier stages (E15 and E18), when different cell types are produced. We show that progenitor cells in early embryonic retina (E15) normally express lower levels of EGF-Rs than progenitor cells in later retina (E18 and P0). Whereas lower levels of stimulation of endogenous and virally transduced EGF-Rs enhanced proliferation, higher levels reduced proliferation, resulting in premature differentiation. At E15, very few EGF-R-infected progenitor cells differentiated prematurely into Muller glial cells, unlike E18 and P0 cells, even when they were exposed to an older retinal environment. Higher levels of EGF-R-mediated signaling alone therefore do not specify a glial fate, indicating that competence to generate glia is temporally regulated by additional mechanisms. The differences in EGF-R expression observed among retinal progenitor cells at distinct developmental stages may instead help to define signaling thresholds which delay or accelerate their differentiation. Copyright 1998 Academic Press.

Cellular diversification in the vertebrate retina

The discovery of heterogeneous populations of retinal precursors with sequentially modified fates may help solve the conundrum of conserved histogenesis in the absence of determination either by birthdate or lineage. Combined with a wealth of new data on the exogenous and endogenous factors that influence cellular fate in the retina, models of how complexity is generated are beginning to emerge.

T3 treatment increases mitosis, then bax expression and apoptosis in the optic lobe of the chick embryo

We investigated T3 effects on cell proliferation and apoptosis in the optic lobe of the chick embryo between embryonic days (E) 6 and 11. Injection of T3 into the yolk increased [3H]thymidine incorporation between E7 and E9. This increased mitosis was followed by altered timing and degree of apoptosis during E9-11. In T3-treated embryos a marked increase in apoptosis occurred on E10, coincident with increased levels of mRNA encoding Bax, a pro-apoptotic protein. By E11, the overall morphology and total number of cells in each layer of the optic lobe were not different in control and treated embryos. Thus, although T3 transiently increases cell number, a homeostatic mechanism enters into play re-adjusting the balance between cellular proliferation and cell death.

Muller-cell-derived leukaemia inhibitory factor arrests rod photoreceptor differentiation at a postmitotic pre-rod stage of development

In the present study, we examine rod photoreceptor development in dissociated-cell cultures of neonatal mouse retina. We show that, although very few rhodopsin+ rods develop in the presence of 10% foetal calf serum (FCS), large numbers develop in the absence of serum, but only if the cell density in the cultures is high. The rods all develop from nondividing rhodopsin- cells, and new rods continue to develop from rhodopsin- cells for at least 6–8 days, indicating that there can be a long delay between when a precursor cell withdraws from the cell cycle and when it becomes a rhodopsin+ rod. We show that FCS arrests rod development in these cultures at a postmitotic, rhodopsin-, pre-rod stage. We present evidence that FCS acts indirectly by stimulating the proliferation of Muller cells, which arrest rod differentiation by releasing leukaemia inhibitory factor (LIF). These findings identify an inhibitory cell-cell interaction, which may help to explain the long delay that can occur both in vitro and in vivo between cell-cycle withdrawal and rhodopsin expression during rod development.

Induction of deep layer cortical neurons in vitro

Transplantation studies suggest that the laminar fates of cerebral cortical neurons are determined by environmental signals encountered just before mitosis. In ferret, E29 progenitor cells normally produce neurons of layers 5 and 6. When transplanted during S-phase into an older ventricular zone, E29 progenitors produce neurons that change their fates and migrate to layer 2/3; however, cells transplanted later in the cell cycle migrate to their normal deep-layer positions even in an older environment (McConnell and Kaznowski, 1991). Here we utilize three culture systems to investigate the nature of the environmental signals involved in laminar specification. E29 cells were first cultured at low density to ascertain whether cell contact and/or short-range cues are required for deep layer specification. Neurons transplanted after a short time in low-density culture failed to adopt their normal fates and migrated instead to the upper layers. When crude cell contacts were restored by pelleting E29 cells together, most transplanted neurons cells became specified to their normal deep layer fates. Finally, E29 cells were transplanted after being cultured in explants that maintained the architecture of the cerebral wall. Explants allowed normal deep layer specification to occur, as transplanted cells migrated to layers 5 and 6. These results suggest that short-range cues induce multipotent progenitors to produce deep layer neurons.

Regulation of neuronal diversity in the Xenopus retina by Delta signalling

To generate the variety of mature neurons and glia found in the developing retina, the competence of pluripotent progenitor cells to respond to extracellular signals must be controlled. Delta, a ligand of the Notch receptor, is a candidate for regulating progenitor competence on the grounds that activation of the pathway involving Notch and Delta can inhibit cellular differentiation. Here we test this possibility in the developing Xenopus retina by misexpression of Delta messenger RNA. We find that Delta-misexpressing cells with wild-type neighbours adopt earlier fates, primarily becoming ganglion cells and cone photoreceptors. Progenitors transfected with Delta later in development also produce rod photoreceptors, but not the latest-generated cell types, demonstrating the importance of timing in Delta function. We conclude that Delta signalling in the vertebrate retina is a basic regulatory mechanism that can be used to generate neuronal diversity.

Positional information and opsin identity in retinal cones

To test the hypothesis that local environmental cues regulate the expression of middle wavelength-sensitive (MWS) and short wavelength-sensitive (SWS) opsins in cone photoreceptors, we examined the development of the neonatal mouse retina in an organotypic culture system. The segregation of MWS and SWS cones into dorsal and ventral fields in the mouse retina offers an opportunity to isolate a phenotypically homogeneous population of immature cones prior to opsin expression. Retinae were harvested from mice ranging in age from birth (P0) to P18 and maintained in vitro for up to 4 weeks. Cones from newborn mice were first immunoreactive to SWS opsin-specific antibodies (OS-2 and JH455) after 5 days in vitro, which corresponds to a time course similar to that in vivo. The topographic separation of SWS cones into distinct dorsal and ventral fields was also obvious in retinal explants from newborn mice. However, the MWS opsin, identified by polyclonal antibody JH492, was expressed only in vitro when dorsal explants were harvested from P3 or older pups. Despite the absence of MWS opsin expression in newborn retinal cultures, there was no evidence of an increase in the numbers of SWS cones. To test if local diffusable cues could induce immature cones to express an aberrant opsin, dorsal and ventral retinal explants at different stages of maturation were cocultured during the incubation period. Neither the emergence of the cone fields nor the difference in the regional and temporal development of the MWS and SWS opsins was affected in these experiments. These results suggest that positional information in the retina and the opsin identity of cones is determined prior to birth and argue against the hypothesis that postnatal cones can be induced to express an aberrant opsin.