Proton-Coupled Electron Transfer

Water oxidation chemistry of a synthetic dinuclear ruthenium complex containing redox-active quinone ligands

We investigated theoretically the catalytic mechanism of electrochemical water oxidation in aqueous solution by a dinuclear ruthenium complex containing redox-active quinone ligands, [Ru2(X)(Y)(3,6-tBu2Q)2(btpyan)](m+) [X, Y = H2O, OH, O, O2; 3,6-tBu2Q = 3,6-di-tert-butyl-1,2-benzoquinone; btpyan =1,8-bis(2,2':6',2″-terpyrid-4'-yl)anthracene] (m = 2, 3, 4) (1). The reaction involves a series of electron and proton transfers to achieve redox leveling, with intervening chemical transformations in a mesh scheme, and the entire molecular structure and motion of the catalyst 1 work together to drive the catalytic cycle for water oxidation. Two substrate water molecules can bind to 1 with simultaneous loss of one or two proton(s), which allows pH-dependent variability in the proportion of substrate-bound structures and following pathways for oxidative activation of the aqua/hydroxo ligands at low thermodynamic and kinetic costs. The resulting bis-oxo intermediates then undergo endothermic O-O radical coupling between two Ru(III)-O(•) units in an anti-coplanar conformation leading to bridged μ-peroxo or μ-superoxo intermediates. The μ-superoxo species can liberate oxygen with the necessity for the preceding binding of a water molecule, which is possible only after four-electron oxidation is completed. The magnitude of catalytic current would be limited by the inherent sluggishness of the hinge-like bending motion of the bridged μ-superoxo complex that opens up the compact, hydrophobic active site of the catalyst and thereby allows water entry under dynamic conditions. On the basis of a newly proposed mechanism, we rationalize the experimentally observed behavior of electrode kinetics with respect to potential and discuss what causes a high overpotential for water oxidation by 1.

Ion-gated synthetic photosystems

Herein, molecular strings of ions built along charge-transporting channels are shown to dramatically increase photocurrents and enable charge transport over long distances, thus confirming the existence and significance of ion-gated photosystems. For their synthesis, ordered and oriented stacks of naphthalenediimides were grown on indium tin oxide by ring-opening disulfide-exchange polymerization. To these charge-transporting channels, coaxial strings of anions or cations-fixed, mobile, complete, partial, pure, or mixed-were added by orthogonal hydrazone exchange. The presence of partially protonated carboxylates was found to most significantly increase activity, implying that they both attract holes and repel electrons, that is, facilitate photoinduced charge separation and hinder charge recombination at the same time. As a result of this quite remarkable situation, photocurrents increased rather than decreased with increasing charge stabilization on their "stepping stones." The presence of mobile anions facilitated long-distance charge transport through thick films. Turned off by inhibited anion mobility, that is, proton hopping, hole/proton antiport is identified to account for long-distance charge transport in ion-gated photosystems.

Artificial photosynthesis: from nanosecond electron transfer to catalytic water oxidation

Human society faces a fundamental challenge as energy consumption is projected to increase due to population and economic growth as fossil fuel resources decrease. Therefore the transition to alternative and sustainable energy sources is of the utmost importance. The conversion of solar energy into chemical energy, by splitting H2O to generate molecular O2 and H2, could contribute to solving the global energy problem. Developing such a system will require the combination of several complicated processes, such as light-harvesting, charge separation, electron transfer, H2O oxidation, and reduction of the generated protons. The primary processes of charge separation and catalysis, which occur in the natural photosynthetic machinery, provide us with an excellent blueprint for the design of such systems. This Account describes our efforts to construct supramolecular assemblies capable of carrying out photoinduced electron transfer and to develop artificial water oxidation catalysts (WOCs). Early work in our group focused on linking a ruthenium chromophore to a manganese-based oxidation catalyst. When we incorporated a tyrosine unit into these supramolecular assemblies, we could observe fast intramolecular electron transfer from the manganese centers, via the tyrosine moiety, to the photooxidized ruthenium center, which clearly resembles the processes occurring in the natural system. Although we demonstrated multi-electron transfer in our artificial systems, the bottleneck proved to be the stability of the WOCs. Researchers have developed a number of WOCs, but the majority can only catalyze H2O oxidation in the presence of strong oxidants such as Ce(IV), which is difficult to generate photochemically. By contrast, illumination of ruthenium(II) photosensitizers in the presence of a sacrificial acceptor generates [Ru(bpy)3](3+)-type oxidants. Their oxidation potentials are significantly lower than that of Ce(IV), but our group recently showed that incorporating negatively charged groups into the ligand backbone could decrease the oxidation potential of the catalysts and, at the same time, decrease the potential for H2O oxidation. This permitted us to develop both ruthenium- and manganese-based WOCs that can operate under neutral conditions, driven by the mild oxidant [Ru(bpy)3](3+). Many hurdles to the development of viable systems for the production of solar fuels remain. However, the combination of important features from the natural photosynthetic machinery and novel artificial components adds insights into the complicated catalytic processes that are involved in splitting H2O.

Unusual kinetic isotope effects of deuterium reinforced polyunsaturated fatty acids in tocopherol-mediated free radical chain oxidations

Substitution of -CD2- at the reactive centers of linoleic and linolenic acids reduces the rate of abstraction of D by a tocopheryl radical by as much as 36-fold, compared to the abstraction of H from a corresponding -CH2- center. This H atom transfer reaction is the rate-determining step in the tocopherol-mediated peroxidation of lipids in human low-density lipoproteins, a process that has been linked to coronary artery disease. The unanticipated large kinetic isotope effects reported here for the tocopherol-mediated oxidation of linoleic and linolenic acids and esters suggests that tunneling makes this process favorable.

The photophysics of fac-[Re(CO)3(NN)(bpa)]+ complexes: a theoretical/experimental study

The influence of the polypyridyl ligand on the photophysics of Re(i) tricarbonyl complexes was investigated by steady-state and time resolved spectroscopy as well as by theoretical calculations.

Creating electrochemical gradients by light: from bio-inspired concepts to photoelectric conversion

Artificial light harvesting systems can be used to convert light into electrochemical gradients and photocurrents.

Switching magnetic interactions in the NiFe Prussian Blue Analogue: an ab initio inspection

Wave function embedded cluster calculations are performed to stress a cation-coupled electron transfer process in the NiFe Prussian Blue Analogue.

Meridional vs. facial coordination geometries of a dipodal ligand framework featuring a secondary coordination sphere

Ligation of bipyridine invokes a conformational change in iron and copper complexes.

Production of hydrogen by electrocatalysis: making the H–H bond by combining protons and hydrides

Electrocatalytic production of hydrogen by nickel complexes is reviewed, with an emphasis on heterocoupling of protons and hydrides.

Do Spin State and Spin Density Affect Hydrogen Atom Transfer Reactivity?

The prevalence of hydrogen atom transfer (HAT) reactions in chemical and biological systems has prompted much interest in establishing and understanding the underlying factors that enable this reactivity. Arguments have been advanced that the electronic spin state of the abstractor and/or the spin-density at the abstracting atom are critical for HAT reactivity. This is consistent with the intuition derived from introductory organic chemistry courses. Herein we present an alternative view on the role of spin state and spin-density in HAT reactions. After a brief introduction, the second section introduces a new and simple fundamental kinetic analysis, which shows that unpaired spin cannot be the dominant effect. The third section examines published computational studies of HAT reactions, which indicates that the spin state affects these reactions indirectly, primarily via changes in driving force. The essay concludes with a broader view of HAT reactivity, including indirect effects of spin and other properties on reactivity. It is suggested that some of the controversy in this area may arise from the diversity of HAT reactions and their overlap with proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) reactions.

Intermolecular proton shuttling in excited state proton transfer reactions: insights from theory

The mechanism of intermolecular proton shuttling involved in a prototypical excited state proton transfer reaction is disclosed using DFT and TD-DFT.

Towards an improved prediction of the free radical scavenging potency of flavonoids: the significance of double PCET mechanisms

The 1H(+)/1e(-) and 2H(+)/2e(-) proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) processes of free radical scavenging by flavonoids were theoretically studied for aqueous and lipid environments using the PM6 and PM7 methods. The results reported here indicate that the significant contribution of the second PCET mechanism, resulting in the formation of a quinone/quinone methide, effectively discriminates the active from inactive flavonoids. The predictive potency of descriptors related to the energetics of second PCET mechanisms (the second O-H bond dissociation enthalpy (BDE2) related to hydrogen atom transfer (HAT) mechanism, and the second electron transfer enthalpy (ETE2) related to sequential proton loss electron transfer (SPLET) mechanism) are superior to the currently used indices, which are related to the first 1H(+)/1e(-) processes, and could serve as primary descriptors in development of the QSAR (quantitative structure-activity relationships) of flavonoids.

Electrochemical evidence for intermolecular proton-coupled electron transfer through a hydrogen bond complex in a p-phenylenediamine-based urea. Introduction of the "wedge scheme" as a useful means to describe reactions of this type

The electrochemistry of several p-phenylenediamine derivatives, in which one of the amino groups is part of an urea functional group, has been investigated in methylene chloride and acetonitrile. The ureas are abbreviated U(R)R', where R' indicates the substituent on the N that is part of the phenylenediamine redox couple and R indicates the substituent on the other urea N. Cyclic voltammetry and UV-vis spectroelectrochemical studies indicate that U(Me)H and U(H)H undergo an apparent 1e(-) oxidation that actually corresponds to 2e(-) oxidation of half the ureas to a quinoidal-diimine cation, U(R)(+). This is accompanied by proton transfer to the other half of the ureas to make the electroinactive cation HU(R)H(+). This explains the observed irreversibility of the oxidation of U(Me)H in both solvents and U(H)H in acetonitrile. However, the oxidation of U(H)H in methylene chloride is reversible at higher concentrations and slower scan rates. Several lines of evidence suggest that the most likely reason for this is the accessibility of a H-bond complex between U(H)(+) and HU(H)H(+) in methylene chloride. Reduction of the H-bond complex occurs at a less negative potential than that of U(H)(+), leading to reversible behavior. This conclusion is strongly supported by the appearance of a more negative reduction peak at lower concentrations and faster scan rates, conditions in which the H-bond complex is less favored. The overall reaction mechanism is conveniently described by a "wedge scheme", which is a more general version of the square scheme typically used to describe redox processes in which proton transfer accompanies electron transfer.

Nitranilic acid hexahydrate, a novel benchmark system of the Zundel cation in an intrinsically asymmetric environment: spectroscopic features and hydrogen bond dynamics characterised by experimental and theoretical methods

Nitranilic acid (2,5-dihydroxy-3,6-dinitro-2,5-cyclohexadiene-1,4-dione) as a strong dibasic acid in acidic aqueous media creates the Zundel cation, H5O2(+). The structural unit in a crystal comprises (H5O2)2(+) (2,5-dihydroxy-3,6-dinitro-1,4-benzoquinonate)(2-) dihydrate where the Zundel cation reveals no symmetry, being an ideal case for studying proton dynamics and its stability. The Zundel cation and proton transfer dynamics are studied by variable-temperature X-ray diffraction, IR and solid-state NMR spectroscopy, and various quantum chemical methods, including periodic DFT calculations, ab initio molecular dynamics simulation, and quantization of nuclear motion along three fully coupled internal coordinates. The Zundel cation features a short H-bond with the O···O distance of 2.433(2) Å with an asymmetric placement of hydrogen. The proton potential is of a single well type and, due to the non-symmetric surroundings, of asymmetric shape. The formation of the Zundel cation is facilitated by the electronegative NO2 groups. The employed spectroscopic techniques supported by calculations confirm the presence of a short H-bond with a complex proton dynamics.

Dichotomous hydrogen atom transfer vs proton-coupled electron transfer during activation of X-H bonds (X = C, N, O) by nonheme iron-oxo complexes of variable basicity

We describe herein the hydrogen-atom transfer (HAT)/proton-coupled electron-transfer (PCET) reactivity for Fe(IV)-oxo and Fe(III)-oxo complexes (1-4) that activate C-H, N-H, and O-H bonds in 9,10-dihydroanthracene (S1), dimethylformamide (S2), 1,2-diphenylhydrazine (S3), p-methoxyphenol (S4), and 1,4-cyclohexadiene (S5). In 1-3, the iron is pentacoordinated by tris[N'-tert-butylureaylato)-N-ethylene]aminato ([H3buea](3-)) or its derivatives. These complexes are basic, in the order 3 ≫ 1 > 2. Oxidant 4, [Fe(IV)N4Py(O)](2+) (N4Py: N,N-bis(2-pyridylmethyl)bis(2-pyridyl)methylamine), is the least basic oxidant. The DFT results match experimental trends and exhibit a mechanistic spectrum ranging from concerted HAT and PCET reactions to concerted-asynchronous proton transfer (PT)/electron transfer (ET) mechanisms, all the way to PT. The singly occupied orbital along the O···H···X (X = C, N, O) moiety in the TS shows clearly that in the PCET cases, the electron is transferred separately from the proton. The Bell-Evans-Polanyi principle does not account for the observed reactivity pattern, as evidenced by the scatter in the plot of calculated barrier vs reactions driving forces. However, a plot of the deformation energy in the TS vs the respective barrier provides a clear signature of the HAT/PCET dichotomy. Thus, in all C-H bond activations, the barrier derives from the deformation energy required to create the TS, whereas in N-H/O-H bond activations, the deformation energy is much larger than the corresponding barrier, indicating the presence of a stabilizing interaction between the TS fragments. A valence bond model is used to link the observed results with the basicity/acidity of the reactants.

Efficient water oxidation catalyzed by homogeneous cationic cobalt porphyrins with critical roles for the buffer base

A series of cationic cobalt porphyrins was found to catalyze electrochemical water oxidation to O2 efficiently at room temperature in neutral aqueous solution. Co-5,10,15,20-tetrakis-(1,3-dimethylimidazolium-2-yl)porphyrin, with a highly electron-deficient meso-dimethylimidazolium porphyrin, was the most effective catalyst. The O2 formation rate was 170 nmol · cm(-2) · min(-1) (k(obs) = 1.4 × 10(3) s(-1)) with a Faradaic efficiency near 90%. Mechanistic investigations indicate the generation of a Co(IV)-O porphyrin cation radical as the reactive oxidant, which has accumulated two oxidizing equivalents above the Co(III) resting state of the catalyst. The buffer base in solution was shown to play several critical roles during the catalysis by facilitating both redox-coupled proton transfer processes leading to the reactive oxidant and subsequent O-O bond formation. More basic buffer anions led to lower catalytic onset potentials, extending below 1 V. This homogeneous cobalt-porphyrin system was shown to be robust under active catalytic conditions, showing negligible decomposition over hours of operation. Added EDTA or ion exchange resin caused no catalyst poisoning, indicating that cobalt ions were not released from the porphyrin macrocycle during catalysis. Likewise, surface analysis by energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy of the working electrodes showed no deposition of heterogeneous cobalt films. Taken together, the results indicate that Co-5,10,15,20-tetrakis-(1,3-dimethylimidazolium-2-yl)porphyrin is an efficient, homogeneous, single-site water oxidation catalyst.

Proton-coupled electron transfer and Lewis acid recognition at self-assembled monolayers of an oxo-bridged diruthenium(III) complex functionalized with two disulfide anchors

A new μ-oxo-bis(μ-acetato)diruthenium(III) complex bearing two pyridyl disulfide ligands {[Ru2(μ-O)(μ-OAc)2(bpy)2(L(py-SS))2](PF6)2 (OAc = CH3CO2(-), bpy = 2,2'-bipyridine, L(py-SS) = (C5H4N)CH2NHC(O)(CH2)4CH(CH2)2SS) (1)} has been synthesized to prepare self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) on the Au(111) electrode surface. The SAMs have been characterized by contact-angle measurements, reflection-absorption surface infrared spectroscopy, cyclic voltammetry, and reductive desorption experiments. The SAMs exhibited proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) reactions when the electrochemistry was studied in aqueous electrolyte solution (0.1 M NaClO4 with Britton-Robinson buffer to adjust the solution pH). The potential-pH plot (Pourbaix diagram) in the pH range from 1 to 12 has established that the dinuclear ruthenium moiety was involved in the interfacial PCET processes with four distinct redox states: Ru(III)Ru(III)(μ-O), Ru(II)Ru(III)(μ-OH), Ru(II)Ru(II)(μ-OH), and Ru(II)Ru(II)(μ-OH2). We also demonstrated that the interfacial redox processes were modulated by the addition of Lewis acids such as BF3 or Al(3+) to the electrolyte media, in which the externally added Lewis acids interacted with μ-O of the dinuclear moiety within the SAMs.

Proton-coupled electron transfer with photoexcited metal complexes

Proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) plays a crucial role in many enzymatic reactions and is relevant for a variety of processes including water oxidation, nitrogen fixation, and carbon dioxide reduction. Much of the research on PCET has focused on transfers between molecules in their electronic ground states, but increasingly researchers are investigating PCET between photoexcited reactants. This Account describes recent studies of excited-state PCET with d(6) metal complexes emphasizing work performed in my laboratory. Upon photoexcitation, some complexes release an electron and a proton to benzoquinone reaction partners. Others act as combined electron-proton acceptors in the presence of phenols. As a result, we can investigate photoinduced PCET involving electron and proton transfer in a given direction, a process that resembles hydrogen-atom transfer (HAT). In other studies, the photoexcited metal complexes merely serve as electron donors or electron acceptors because the proton donating and accepting sites are located on other parts of the molecular PCET ensemble. We and others have used this multisite design to explore so-called bidirectional PCET which occurs in many enzymes. A central question in all of these studies is whether concerted proton-electron transfer (CPET) can compete kinetically with sequential electron and proton transfer steps. Short laser pulses can trigger excited-state PCET, making it possible to investigate rapid reactions. Luminescence spectroscopy is a convenient tool for monitoring PCET, but unambiguous identification of reaction products can require a combination of luminescence spectroscopy and transient absorption spectroscopy. Nevertheless, in some cases, distinguishing between PCET photoproducts and reaction products formed by simple photoinduced electron transfer (ET) (reactions that don't include proton transfer) is tricky. Some of the studies presented here deal directly with this important problem. In one case study we employed a cyclometalated iridium(III) complex. Our other studies with ruthenium(II) complexes and phenols focused on systematic variations of the reaction free energies for the CPET, ET, and proton transfer (PT) steps to explore their influence on the overall PCET reaction. Still other work with rhenium(I) complexes concentrated on the question of how the electronic structure of the metal-to-ligand charge transfer (MLCT) excited states affects PCET. We used covalent rhenium(I)-phenol dyads to explore the influence of the electron donor-electron acceptor distance on bidirectional PCET. In covalent triarylamine-Ru(bpy)₃²⁺/Os(bpy)₃²⁺-anthraquinone triads (bpy = 2,2'-bipyridine), hydrogen-bond donating solvents significantly lengthened the lifetimes of photogenerated electron/hole pairs because of hydrogen-bonding to the quinone radical anion. Until now, comparatively few researchers have investigated this variation of PCET: the strengthening of H-bonds upon photoreduction.