Suppression of beta-1,3-glucanase transgene expression in homozygous plants

Plum pox potyvirus resistance associated to transgene silencing that can be stabilized after different number of plant generations

Nicotiana benthamiana plants were transformed with a fragment of the plum pox potyvirus (PPV) genome that encodes the nuclear inclusion a (NIa) and b (NIb) proteins and the N-terminus of the capsid protein (NIa-NIb-CP). Lines transformed with this PPV genomic fragment harboring mutations in the GDD replicase-motif were also obtained. Plants of NIaDeltaV lines that carry a GDD to VDD mutation in the PPV transgene, were immune to PPV infection. The resistance was highly specific, since it was only partially overcome by a PPV strain different to that from which the transgene was derived, and no resistance was observed after inoculation with a second potyvirus. PPV was not able to replicate in protoplasts isolated from NIaDeltaV transgenic plants, indicating that the resistance was functional at the single cell level. Only a fraction of plants from lines transformed with the NIa-NIb-CP fragment harboring a GDD to ADD mutation (NIaDeltaA lines), were resistant to PPV infection. This same phenotype was observed in plants expressing the wild-type construction (NIaDelta), although the progeny of some non-infected plants seemed to be completely resistant to PPV, independently of the allelic status of the parental plant. In all cases, the resistance phenotype correlated positively with low levels of transgene mRNA accumulation, suggesting that it was mainly due to a gene silencing mechanism. Our results show that, although the transgene was not silenced in all R1 plants from some individual lines, a stable silenced status could be reached in the following generations.

Epigenetic instability and trans-silencing interactions associated with an SPT::Ac T-DNA locus in tobacco

Progeny of tobacco line 2853.6, which carries a streptomycin phosphotransferase (SPT) gene interrupted by the maize element Activator (Ac), were selected for streptomycin resistance (Spr) because of germinal Ac excision. Some events gave rise to Spr alleles that were unstable and exhibited a mottled phenotype on streptomycin-containing medium due to somatic loss of SPT function. This instability was most pronounced in one particular line, Spr12F. Other Spr alleles rarely exhibited silencing of SPT. Streptomycin-sensitive, homozygous Spr12F plants were recovered, and crosses were performed with other, more stable Spr lines. A high proportion of the resulting heterozygous progeny were silenced for SPT expression. The silenced state was heritable even after the Spr12F allele segregated away. No correlation could be made between silencing and methylation of the SPTgene. Structural analysis of allele Spr12F showed that the SPT gene from which Ac had excised was flanked by direct repeats of Ac. A search was carried out among 110 additional Spr alleles for new independent unstable alleles, and four were identified. All of these alleles also carried an SPT gene flanked by direct repeats of Ac. Thus, there is a strong correlation between this structure and instability of SPT expression.

Control of papaya ringspot virus in papaya: a case study

The papaya crop is severely affected by papaya ringspot virus (PSRV) worldwide. This review focuses on efforts to control the destructiveness of the disease caused by PSRV in Hawaii, starting from the use of cross protection to parasite-derived resistance with transgenic papaya expressing the PSRV coat protein gene. A chronology of the research effort is given and related to the development of technologies and the pressing need to control PSRV in Hawaii. The development of commercial virus-resistant transgenic papaya provides a tangible approach to control PSRV in Hawaii. Moreover, the development of transgenic papaya by other laboratories and employment of a mechanism of effective technology transfer to different countries hold promise for control of PSRV worldwide.

Repeat-induced gene silencing in mammals

In both plants and Drosophila melanogaster, expression from a transgenic locus may be silenced when repeated transgene copies are arranged as a concatameric array. This repeat-induced gene silencing is frequently manifested as a decrease in the proportion of cells that express the transgene, resulting in a variegated pattern of expression. There is also some indication that, in transgenic mammals, the number of transgene copies within an array can exert a repressive influence on expression, with several mouse studies reporting a decrease in the level of expression per copy as copy number increases. However, because these studies compare different sites of transgene integration as well as arrays with different numbers of copies, the expression levels observed may be subject to varying position effects as well as the influence of the multicopy array. Here we describe use of the lox/Cre system of site-specific recombination to generate transgenic mouse lines in which different numbers of a transgene are present at the same chromosomal location, thereby eliminating the contribution of position effects and allowing analysis of the effect of copy number alone on transgene silencing. Reduction in copy number results in a marked increase in expression of the transgene and is accompanied by decreased chromatin compaction and decreased methylation at the transgene locus. These findings establish that the presence of multiple homologous copies of a transgene within a concatameric array can have a repressive effect upon gene expression in mammalian systems.

Heat treatment results in a loss of transgene-encoded activities in several tobacco lines

Heat treatment (37 degrees C) of transgenic tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum) plants led to a reversible reduction or complete loss of transgene-encoded activities in about 40% of 10 independent transformants carrying the luciferase-coding region fused to the 355 cauliflower mosaic virus or the soybean small subunit promoter and the nopaline synthase promoter driving the neomycin phosphotransferase gene, whereas the other lines had temperature-tolerant activities. Temperature sensitivity or tolerance of transgene-encoded activities was heritable. In some of the lines, temperature sensitivity of the transgene-encoded activities depended on the stage of development, occurring in either seedlings (40% luciferase and 50% neomycin phosphotransferase) or adult plants (both 40%). The phenomenon did not correlate with copy numbers or the homo- or hemizygous state of the transgenes. In lines harboring a temperature-sensitive luciferase activity, reduction of bioluminescence was observed after 2 to 3 h at 37 degrees C. Activity was regained after 2 h of subsequent cultivation at 25 degrees C. Irrespective of the reaction to the heat treatment, the level of luciferase RNA was slightly increased at 37 degrees C. Only in lines showing temperature sensitivity of transgene-encoded activities was the amount of luciferase and neomycin phosphotransferase strongly reduced. In sterile culture, heat treatment for 15 d did not cause visible damage or changes in plant morphology. In all plants tested a slight induction of the heat-shock response was observed at 37 degrees C.

DNA methylation inhibits elongation but not initiation of transcription in Neurospora crassa

In plants, animals, and fungi, DNA methylation is frequently associated with gene silencing, yet little is known about the role of the methylation in silencing. In Neurospora crassa, repeated sequences are silenced by repeat-induced point mutation (RIP) and genes that have suffered numerous GC --> AT mutations by RIP are typically methylated at remaining cytosines. We investigated possible effects on transcription from methylation associated with RIP by taking advantage of 5-azacytidine, which prevents most methylation in Neurospora and a dim-2 mutation that abolishes all detectable methylation. Northern analyses revealed that methylation prevents the accumulation of transcripts from genes mutated by RIP. Measurements of transcription rates in vivo showed that methylation inhibits transcription severely but does not influence mRNA stability. Results of nuclear run-on experiments demonstrated that transcription initiation was not significantly inhibited by the dense methylation in the promoter sequences. In contrast, methylation blocked transcription elongation in vivo.

Nontarget DNA sequences reduce the transgene length necessary for RNA-mediated tospovirus resistance in transgenic plants

RNA-mediated virus resistance has recently been shown to be the result of post-transcriptional transgene silencing in transgenic plants. This study was undertaken to characterize the effect of transgene length and nontarget DNA sequences on RNA-mediated tospovirus resistance in transgenic plants. Transgenic Nicotiana benthamiana plants were generated to express different regions of the nucleocapsid (N) protein of tomato spotted wilt (TSWV) tospovirus. Transgenic plants expressing half-gene segments (387-453 bp) of the N gene displayed resistance through post-transcriptional gene silencing. Although smaller N gene segments (92-235 bp) were ineffective in conferring resistance when expressed alone in transgenic plants, these segments conferred resistance when fused to the nontarget green fluorescent protein gene DNA. These results demonstrate that (i) a critical length of N transgene (236-387 bp) is required for a high level of transgene expression and consequent gene silencing, and (ii) the post-transcriptional gene silencing mechanism can trans-inactivate the incoming tospovirus genome with homologous transgene segments that are as short as 110 bp. Therefore, the activation of post-transcriptional transgene silencing requires a significantly larger transgene than is required for the trans-inactivation of the incoming viral genome. These results raise the possibility of developing a simple new strategy for engineering multiple virus resistance in transgenic plants.

Post-transcriptional gene silencing in plants

Overexpression of chimeric transgenes in plants can trigger post-transcriptional gene silencing that is dependent on epigenetic information and physiological conditions. The current view is that unproductive RNA serves as a crucial signal for gene silencing, although direct evidence is lacking for this theory. A signalling cascade then leads to strongly enhanced turnover of all RNAs that share a critical degree of sequence similarity. The molecular details of the mechanism are, however, insufficiently understood to explain the phenomenon completely and to comprehend its biological significance.

Silencing of a beta-1,3-glucanase transgene is overcome during seed formation

Expression of a beta-1,3-glucanase transgene (gn1) driven by the CaMV 35S promoter is silenced in the T17 homozygous tobacco transgenic line. This silencing process is post-transcriptionally regulated and subject to developmental control. We have examined this phenomenon to investigate the developmental pathways involved in suppression and reactivation of gn1 expression as well as to identify the plant tissues where these processes occur. Analysis of beta-1,3-glucanase activity and gene expression have allowed us to determine that suppression of gn1 is a very efficient process reducing the steady-state gn1 mRNA level, simultaneously, in all leaves of the plant. Gene silencing occurs a few weeks after seed germination, and is maintained throughout vegetative growth and floral development. Expression of gn1 is restored in the maturing fruit some time after fertilization. In situ hybridization analyses show that expression of gn1 is restored within the developing seeds in tissues derived from meiotically divided cells. In contrast to the high level of expression found in seedlings obtained from germinated T17 homozygous seeds, the expression of gn1 is not reactivated in plantlets regenerated in vitro from leaf explants of suppressed T17 homozygous plants that is, in plant tissues obtained by mitotic division. Thus, reactivation of gn1 expression specifically occurs along the developmental programme controlling sexual reproduction and likely throughout epigenetic modifications affecting the state of gene expression during meiosis.

Overexpression of L-Phenylalanine Ammonia-Lyase in Transgenic Tobacco Plants Reveals Control Points for Flux into Phenylpropanoid Biosynthesis

Transgenic tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L.) plants overexpressing the enzyme L-phenylalanine ammonia-lyase (PAL; EC 4.3.1.5) were grown from seeds of a primary transformant containing the bean PAL2 gene, which had shown homology-dependent silencing of the endogenous tobacco PAL genes. Analysis of endogenous and transgene-encoded PAL transcripts and protein in the primary transformant (T0) and first-generation (T1) overexpressor plants indicated that the transgene-encoded PAL is the cause of the greater than wild-type levels of PAL activity (up to 5- and 2-fold greater in leaf and stem tissue, respectively) in the T1 plants. Leaves of PAL-overexpressing plants contained increased levels of the hydroxycinnamic acid ester chlorogenic acid but not of the flavonoid rutin, indicating that PAL is the key control point for flux into chlorogenic acid. In addition, levels of the glucoside of 4-coumaric acid increased in the overexpressing plants, suggesting that the 4-coumarate:coenzyme A ligase or coumarate hydroxylase reactions might have become limiting. These results help to define the regulatory architecture of the phenylpropanoid pathway and indicate the possibility of engineering-selective changes in this complex metabolic pathway by overexpression of a single early pathway gene.

Frequencies, Timing, and Spatial Patterns of Co-Suppression of Nitrate Reductase and Nitrite Reductase in Transgenic Tobacco Plants

Frequencies, timing, and spatial patterns of co-suppression of the nitrate (Nia) and nitrite (Nii) genes were analyzed in transgenic tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum) plants carrying either Nia or Nii cDNAs under the control of the 35S promoter, or a Nii gene with its own regulatory signals (promoter, introns, and terminator) cloned downstream of two copies of the enhancer of the 35S promoter. We show that (a) the frequencies of transgenic lines affected by co- suppression are similar for the three constructs, ranging from 19 to 25%; (b) Nia and Nii co-suppression are triggered stochastically during a phenocritical period of 2 weeks between germination and flowering; (c) the timing of co-suppression (i.e. the percentage of isogenic plants affected by co-suppression reported as a function of the number of days of culture) differs from one transgenic line to another; (d) the percentage of isogenic plants affected by co-suppression is increased by growing the plants in vitro prior to their transfer to the greenhouse and to the field; and (e) at the end of the culture period, plants are either unaffected, completely co-suppressed, or variegated. Suppressed and nonsuppressed parts of these variegated plants are separated by a vertical plane through the stem in Nia co-suppression, and separated by a horizontal plane in Nii co-suppression.

Exogenous phytohormone-independent growth and regeneration of tobacco plants transgenic for the 6b gene of Agrobacterium tumefaciens AKE10

The 6b gene of Agrobacterium tumefaciens AKE10 (AK-6b) induces crown gall tumors on certain plants but so far there have been no reports of the gene being able to induce tumors on culture medium. We cloned T-DNA segments containing the 6b gene but lacking the auxin and cytokinin biosynthesis genes from A. tumefaciens AKE10. Tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum) leaf discs infected with A. tumefaciens LBA4404 carrying the clones produced shooty calli on hormone-free Murashige-Skoog medium. The relevant T-DNA segment was integrated into plant DNA as determined by Southern hybridization. Some of these immature shoots spontaneously developed into mature shoots, of which several leaves displayed morphological abnormalities. When leaf discs of these mature plants were placed onto the same medium numerous shoots developed from the wounding sites, indicating that the transgenic plants possessed a high regenerative potential. Northern blot and reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction analyses showed a large accumulation of the AK-6b transcripts in the shooty calli, but only a limited degree in mature plants, demonstrating that AK-6b expression is regulated in plants and essential for the early stages of regeneration. Cytokinin levels in the shooty calli were comparable to those in normal shoots, suggesting that shoot regeneration is not mediated by the modulation of cytokinin content.

RNA as a target and an initiator of post-transcriptional gene silencing in transgenic plants

Post-transcriptional gene silencing in transgenic plants is the manifestation of a mechanism that suppresses RNA accumulation in a sequence-specific manner. The target RNA species may be the products of transgenes, endogenous plant genes or viral RNAs. For an RNA to be a target it is necessary only that it has sequence homology to the sense RNA product of the transgene. There are three current hypotheses to account for the mechanism of post transcriptional gene silencing. These models all require production of an antisense RNA of the RNA targets to account for the specificity of the mechanism. There could be either direct transcription of the antisense RNA from the transgene, antisense RNA produced in response to over expression of the transgene or antisense RNA produced in response to the production of an aberrant sense RNA product of the transgene. To determine which of these models is correct it will be necessary to find out whether transgene methylation, which is frequently associated with the potential of transgenes to confer post-transcriptional gene silencing, is a cause or a consequence of the process.

RNA as a target and an initiator of post-transcriptional gene silencing in transgenic plants

Post-transcriptional gene silencing in transgenic plants is the manifestation of a mechanism that suppresses RNA accumulation in a sequence-specific manner. The target RNA species may be the products of transgenes, endogenous plant genes or viral RNAs. For an RNA to be a target it is necessary only that it has sequence homology to the sense RNA product of the transgene. There are three current hypotheses to account for the mechanism of post transcriptional gene silencing. These models all require production of an antisense RNA of the RNA targets to account for the specificity of the mechanism. There could be either direct transcription of the antisense RNA from the transgene, antisense RNA produced in response to over expression of the transgene or antisense RNA produced in response to the production of an aberrant sense RNA product of the transgene. To determine which of these models is correct it will be necessary to find out whether transgene methylation, which is frequently associated with the potential of transgenes to confer post-transcriptional gene silencing, is a cause or a consequence of the process.

Chalcone synthase cosuppression phenotypes in petunia flowers: comparison of sense vs. antisense constructs and single-copy vs. complex T-DNA sequences

Flower pigmentation patterns were scored in 185 sense Chalcone synthase (Chs) transgenotes and 85 antisense Chs transgenotes; upon first flowering, 139 (75%) of sense transgenotes were found to be phenotypically altered, as were 70 (82%) of the antisense transgenotes. The observed patterns document the range of phenotypic variations that occur, as well as confirm and extend the finding that sense Chs constructs produce several types of morphology-based flower pigmentation patterns that antisense Chs constructs do not. Long-term monitoring for epigenetic variations in one population of 44 sense Chs transgenotes showed that 43 (98%) were capable of producing a cosuppression phenotype. The primary determinant of sense-specific patterns of cosuppression of Chs was found to be the repetitiveness and organization pattern of the transgene, not 'position effects' by, or 'readthrough' from, flanking plant DNA sequences. The degree of cosuppression observed in progeny of transgenotes carrying multiple, dispersed copies as compared to that observed with a single copy of the transgene suggests that sense cosuppression of Chs is subject to a transgene dosage effect.

Transgene silencing of the al-1 gene in vegetative cells of Neurospora is mediated by a cytoplasmic effector and does not depend on DNA-DNA interactions or DNA methylation

The molecular mechanisms involved in transgene-induced gene silencing ('quelling') in Neurospora crassa were investigated using the carotenoid biosynthetic gene albino-1 (al-1) as a visual marker. Deletion derivatives of the al-1 gene showed that a transgene must contain at least approximately 132 bp of sequences homologous to the transcribed region of the native gene in order to induce quelling. Transgenes containing only al-1 promoter sequences do not cause quelling. Specific sequences are not required for gene silencing, as different regions of the al-1 gene produced quelling. A mutant defective in cytosine methylation (dim-2) exhibited normal frequencies and degrees of silencing, indicating that cytosine methylation is not responsible for quelling, despite the fact that methylation of transgene sequences frequently is correlated with silencing. Silencing was shown to be a dominant trait, operative in heterokaryotic strains containing a mixture of transgenic and non-transgenic nuclei. This result indicates that a diffusable, trans-acting molecule is involved in quelling. A transgene-derived, sense RNA was detected in quelled strains and was found to be absent in their revertants. These data are consistent with a model in which an RNA-DNA or RNA-RNA interaction is involved in transgene-induced gene silencing in Neurospora.

HOMOLOGY-DEPENDENT GENE SILENCING IN PLANTS

Homology-dependent gene silencing phenomena in plants have received considerable attention, especially when it was discovered that the presence of homologous sequences not only affected the stability of transgene expression, but that the activity of endogenous genes could be altered after insertion of homologous transgenes into the genome. Homology-mediated inactivation most likely comprises at least two different molecular mechanisms that induce gene silencing at the transcriptional or posttranscriptional level, respectively. In this review we discuss different mechanistic models for plant-specific inactivation mechanisms and their relationship with repeat-specific silencing phenomena in other species.

A ribozyme gene and an antisense gene are equally effective in conferring resistance to tobacco mosaic virus on transgenic tobacco

Ribozymes of the hammerhead class can be designed to cleave a target RNA in a sequence-specific manner and can potentially be used to specifically modulate gene activity. We have targeted the tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) genome with a ribozyme containing three catalytic hammerhead domains embedded within a 1 kb antisense RNA. The ribozyme was able to cleave TMV RNA at all three target sites in vitro at 25 degrees C. Transgenic tobacco plants were generated which expressed the ribozyme or the corresponding antisense constructs directed at the TMV genome. Six of 38 independent transgenic plant lines expressing the ribozyme and 6 of 39 plant lines expressing the antisense gene showed some level of protection against TMV infection. Homozygous progeny of some lines were highly resistant to TMV; at least 50% of the plants remained asymptomatic even when challenged with high levels of TMV. These plants also displayed resistance to infection with TMV RNA or the related tomato mosaic virus (ToMV). In contrast, hemizygous plants of the same lines displayed only very weak resistance when inoculated with low amounts of TMV and no resistance against high inoculation levels. Resistance in homozygous plants was not overcome by a TMV strain which was altered at the three target sites to abolish ribozyme-mediated cleavage, suggesting that the ribozyme conferred resistance primarily by an antisense mechanism.

Genetic and biochemical dissection of transgenic RNA-mediated virus resistance

RNA-mediated virus resistance has been observed in transgenic plants at varying frequencies, suggesting that a nuclear requirement or other pre-condition must be met. This study was undertaken to characterize genetically transgenes that confer a highly resistant state to infection by tobacco etch virus (TEV). Transgenic tobacco line 2RC-6.13, expressing an untranslatable mRNA containing the TEV coat protein open reading frame, had three distinct transgene integration events that segregated as two linkage groups. A genetic series of plants that contained zero, one, two, or all three transgene inserts in both homozygous and heterozygous conditions was produced and examined. Genetic and biochemical data suggested that RNA-mediated virus resistance is a multigenic trait in line 2RC-6.13; three or more transgenes were necessary to establish the highly resistant state. One or two transgene copies resulted in an inducible form of resistance (i.e., recovery). Transcription rates and steady state RNA levels of the transgene-derived transcript present in different members of the genetic series supported a post-transcriptional RNA degradation process as the underlying mechanism for transgene transcript reduction and virus resistance. This degradation process appeared to initiate via cleavage of specific sites within the target RNA sequence, as determined by RNA get blot and primer extension analyses of transgene-derived mRNA from various transgenic plant lines.

Gene silencing in transgenic tobacco hybrids: frequency of the event and visualization of somatic inactivation pattern

We have investigated the stability of the expression of different T-DNA-borne genes in hybrid tobacco lines. These lines were constructed to rescue rolC-induced male sterility in kanamycin-resistant P35s-rolC transgenic tobacco plants by expression of rolC antisense genes. Using five different tester lines, a total of 158 hybrids was obtained. We observed inactivation of transgene expression in 20% of the F1 progeny and in 35% of the backcrossed F2 progeny, as indicated by the loss of kanamycin resistance. In 3% of all crosses complete loss of antibiotic resistance was noted, while in most affected hybrid progeny only part of the population became kanamycin sensitive. Single genes could be selectively inactivated on T-DNAs harboring several genes. Gene inactivation was not restricted to one of the two T-DNAs examined. Somatic silencing, visualized by a cell-specific 35SGUSINT marker gene, occurred in a random fashion or exhibited an inherited specific pattern. The type of somatic silencing pattern observed indicated developmental control of the process. Two phenotypic classes could be distinguished with respect to frequency and timing of the inactivation process. Rapid gene inactivation, occurring within a few weeks after germination of hybrid seedlings, was characterized by complete methylation of restriction sites in the promoter of the silenced gene, resetting of gene expression during meiosis, heredity of the developmentally controlled program of gene silencing in subsequent generations, and rapid reactivation of gene expression after genetic separation of the different T-DNAs. In contrast, a slow type of gene inactivation was of a more stochastic nature and was recognized only in hybrids of the backcrossed F2 generation. In this case the degree of promoter methylation, which could extend beyond the T-DNA borders, was not correlated with the reduction in steady-state poly(A)+ mRNA levels, the silenced state was transmitted through meiosis and reactivation lasted several generations. The implications of the observations for our understanding of the gene inactivation process are discussed.

Field trial analysis of nitrate reductase co-suppression: a comparative study of 38 combinations of transgene loci

Co-suppression of host genes and 35S transgenes encoding nitrate reductase was previously reported in transgenic tobacco plants (Nicotiana tabacum cv. Paraguay or Burley) using either a full-length cDNA or fragments devoid of the 3' and/or 5' UTR. Co-suppression was previously shown to affect a limited fraction of the progeny of one transgenic tobacco line homozygous for a single transgene locus, and the phenomenon occurred at each generation. In this work, 38 combinations of transgene loci derived from 13 independent transgenic lines homozygous for a single transgene locus were field-tested under two different conditions in an attempt to determine the corresponding frequencies of co-suppression, i.e. the percentage of plants showing co-suppression. Each of the 13 homozygous lines exhibited a different frequency of co-suppression, ranging from 0% to 57%. High frequencies were found to be associated with transgene loc carrying a high number of copy of the transgene, suggesting a transgene dose effect. Combinations carrying 2 non-allelic transgene loci in a hemizygous state exhibited frequencies of co-suppression between those of each of the 2 transgene loci in a homozygous state, while combinations carrying 2 non-allelic transgene loci in a homozygous state exhibited frequencies of co-suppression higher than the sum of those of the 2 transgene loci alone in a homozygous state, clearly confirming a transgene dose effect. Co-suppression frequencies were increased when the plants were grown initially in vitro, suggesting some environmental effect. The roles of transgene copy number, number of transgene loci and environmental factors are discussed in the light of a threshold hypothesis.

Molecular and genetic analysis of nitrite reductase co-suppression in transgenic tobacco plants

Silencing of Nia host genes and transgenes (encoding nitrate reductase) was previously achieved by introducing into tobacco plants the tobacco Nia2 cDNA cloned downstream of the cauliflower mosaic virus (CaMV) 35S promoter. To check whether Nii host genes and transgenes (encoding nitrite reductase, the second enzyme of the nitrate assimilation pathway) were also susceptible to silencing, a transgene consisting of the tobacco Nii1 gene with two copies of the enhancer of the 35S promoter cloned 1 kb upstream of the Nii promoter region was introduced into tobacco plants. Among nine independent transformants analysed, two showed silencing of Nii host genes and transgenes in some descendants after selfing, but never after back-crossing with wild-type plants, suggesting that silencing depends on the number of transgene loci and/or on certain allelic or ectopic combinations of transgene loci. In one transformant carrying a single transgene locus in a homozygous state, silencing was triggered in all progeny plants of each generation, 20 to 50 days after germination. Field trial analysis confirmed that silencing was not triggered when the transgene locus of this latter line was present in a hemizygous state. In addition, it was revealed that silencing can be triggered, albeit at low frequency and later during the development, when this transgene locus is brought into the presence of a non-allelic transgene locus by crossing, suggesting that a homozygous state is not absolutely required.

Transgenes and gene suppression: telling us something new?

Transgenes provide unique opportunities to assess the relationship between genotype and phenotype in an organism. In most cases, introduction and subsequent expression of a transgene will increase (with a sense RNA) or decrease (with an antisense RNA) the steady-state level of a specific gene product. However, a number of surprising observations have been made in the course of many transgenic studies. We develop a hypothesis that suggests that many examples of endogenous gene suppression by either antisense or sense transcripts are mediated by the same cellular mechanism.

Somatic intrachromosomal homologous recombination events in populations of plant siblings

Intrachromosomal homologous recombination in whole tobacco plants was analyzed using beta-glucuronidase as non-selectable marker. We found that recombination frequencies were additive for transgenes in allelic positions and could be enhanced by treatment of plants with DNA-damaging agents. We compared the patterns of distribution of recombination events of different transgenic lines of tobacco and Arabidopsis with the respective Poisson distributions. Some lines showed Poisson-like distributions, indicating that recombination at the transgene locus was occurring in a random fashion in the plant population. In other cases, however, the distributions deviated significantly from Poisson distributions indicating that for specific transgene loci and/or configurations recombination events are not randomly distributed in the population. This was due to overrepresentation of plants with especially many as well as especially few recombination events. Analysis of one tobacco line indicated furthermore that the distribution of recombination events could be influenced by treating the seedlings with external factors. Our results suggest that different plant individuals, or parts of them, might exhibit different transient 'states' of recombination competence. A possible model relating 'recombination silencing' and transcription silencing to heterochromatization of the transgene locus is discussed.

Post-transcriptional cosuppression of beta-1,3-glucanase genes does not affect accumulation of transgene nuclear mRNA

Silencing of a Nicotiana plumbaginifolia beta-1,3-glucanase (gn1) transgene in tobacco line T17 occurs in homozygous and in haploid plants with one transgene locus dosage per chromosome set. We have previously shown that the silent state is manifested by a reduced gn1 steady state mRNA level and results from a post-transcriptional process that is under developmental control in homozygous T17 plants. In this study, we show that specific endogenous beta-1,3-glucanase genes are cosuppressed with gn1 in homozygous T17 plants. We also demonstrate that the developmental timing of cosuppression depends on environmental conditions and that once silencing is established it is stably maintained during plant development. Analyses of additional transgenic tobacco lines revealed that gn1 silencing is not restricted to the T17 line and showed that silencing can also take place in R0 plants containing independent loci in hemizygous states. Furthermore, silencing can also be obtained in progeny plants in which expressing loci have been combined. Importantly, cosuppression occurs via a post-transcriptional mechanism that does not interfere with the accumulation of transgene nuclear mRNA. These results strongly suggest that the silencing mechanism operates at RNA transport and/or RNA stability levels.

Post-transcriptional cosuppression of beta-1,3-glucanase genes does not affect accumulation of transgene nuclear mRNA

Silencing of a Nicotiana plumbaginifolia beta-1,3-glucanase (gn1) transgene in tobacco line T17 occurs in homozygous and in haploid plants with one transgene locus dosage per chromosome set. We have previously shown that the silent state is manifested by a reduced gn1 steady state mRNA level and results from a post-transcriptional process that is under developmental control in homozygous T17 plants. In this study, we show that specific endogenous beta-1,3-glucanase genes are cosuppressed with gn1 in homozygous T17 plants. We also demonstrate that the developmental timing of cosuppression depends on environmental conditions and that once silencing is established it is stably maintained during plant development. Analyses of additional transgenic tobacco lines revealed that gn1 silencing is not restricted to the T17 line and showed that silencing can also take place in R0 plants containing independent loci in hemizygous states. Furthermore, silencing can also be obtained in progeny plants in which expressing loci have been combined. Importantly, cosuppression occurs via a post-transcriptional mechanism that does not interfere with the accumulation of transgene nuclear mRNA. These results strongly suggest that the silencing mechanism operates at RNA transport and/or RNA stability levels.

Isolation of new promoter-mediated co-suppressed lines in Arabidopsis thaliana

Four new independent lines that exhibit co-suppression of an introduced cab140::tms2 gene and the native cab140 gene have been isolated in Arabidopsis thaliana. These lines are of particular interest because the homology shared between the introduced and native genes is 1.3 kb of promoter DNA that only contains 14 bp of transcribed region. Most other reported examples of co-suppression involve homologies between transcribed portions of genes. A similar line, lct, had been isolated previously from EMS-mutagenized seeds, and we concluded that this example of co-suppression was probably due to a mutation that mapped at or near the introduced cab140::tms2 gene [Brusslan JA, Karlin-Neumann GA, Huang L, Tobin EM: Plant Cell 5: 667-677 (1993)]. Our observations with these four new lines, however, suggest that an epigenetic event(s) rather than a mutation might be the cause of co-suppression in these and the lct line.

Inheritance of gusA and neo genes in transgenic rice

Inheritance of foreign genes neo and gusA in rice (Oryza sativa L. cv. IR54 and Radon) has been investigated in three different primary (T0) transformants and their progeny plants. T0 plants were obtained by co-transforming protoplasts from two different rice suspension cultures with the neomycin phosphotransferase II gene [neo or aph (3') II] and the beta-glucuronidase gene (uidA or gusA) residing on separate chimeric plasmid constructs. The suspension cultures were derived from callus of immature embryos of indica variety IR54 and japonica variety Radon. One transgenic line of Radon (AR2) contained neo driven by the CaMV 35S promoter and gusA driven by the rice actin promoter. A second Radon line (R3) contained neo driven by the CaMV 35S promoter and gusA driven by a promoter of the rice tungro bacilliform virus. The third transgenic line, IR54-1, contained neo driven by the CaMV 35S promoter and gusA driven by the CaMV 35S. Inheritance of the transgenes in progeny of the transgenic rice was investigated by Southern blot analysis and enzyme assays. Southern blot analysis of genomic DNA showed that, regardless of copy numbers of the transgenes in the plant genome and the fact that the two transgenes resided on two different plasmids before transformation, the introduced gusA and neo genes were stably transmitted from one generation to another and co-inherited together in transgenic rice progeny plants derived from self-pollination. Analysis of GUS and NPT II activities in T1 to T2 plants provided evidence that inheritance of the gusA and neo genes was in a Mendelian fashion in one plant line (AR2), and in an irregular fashion in the two other plant lines (R3 and IR54-1). Homozygous progeny plants expressing the gusA and neo genes were obtained in the T2 generation of AR2, but the homozygous state was not found in the other two lines of transgenic rice.

Distinct phenotypes generated by overexpression and suppression of S-adenosyl-L-methionine synthetase reveal developmental patterns of gene silencing in tobacco

S-Adenosyl-L-methionine synthetase (SAM-S) catalyzes the conversion of L-methionine and ATP into S-adenosyl-L-methionine. Tobacco plants that were transformed with a construct allowing high transcription levels of an Arabidopsis sam-s gene could be grouped into two main classes based on their morphology. One class developed yellow-green leaves and had high SAM-S activity and transgene mRNA levels, whereas the other class was stunted and had leather-like leaves, very low SAM-S activity, and suppressed mRNA level of the transgene. Because both overexpression and silencing of transgene expression led to distinct, abnormal phenotypes, the developmental pattern of transgene silencing was visualized. In the lower leaves, the suppressed phenotype was associated with the veins. In successive leaves, the area of the suppressed tissue increased until all newly developed leaves displayed the suppressed phenotype. In this study, a hypothesis is presented for this developmental gene silencing. Furthermore, transgenic plants with suppressed SAM-S activity had a characteristic smell, a consequence of the accumulation of L-methionine that is converted into the volatile methanethiol.

Distinct phenotypes generated by overexpression and suppression of S-adenosyl-L-methionine synthetase reveal developmental patterns of gene silencing in tobacco

S-Adenosyl-L-methionine synthetase (SAM-S) catalyzes the conversion of L-methionine and ATP into S-adenosyl-L-methionine. Tobacco plants that were transformed with a construct allowing high transcription levels of an Arabidopsis sam-s gene could be grouped into two main classes based on their morphology. One class developed yellow-green leaves and had high SAM-S activity and transgene mRNA levels, whereas the other class was stunted and had leather-like leaves, very low SAM-S activity, and suppressed mRNA level of the transgene. Because both overexpression and silencing of transgene expression led to distinct, abnormal phenotypes, the developmental pattern of transgene silencing was visualized. In the lower leaves, the suppressed phenotype was associated with the veins. In successive leaves, the area of the suppressed tissue increased until all newly developed leaves displayed the suppressed phenotype. In this study, a hypothesis is presented for this developmental gene silencing. Furthermore, transgenic plants with suppressed SAM-S activity had a characteristic smell, a consequence of the accumulation of L-methionine that is converted into the volatile methanethiol.

Transgenic plant virus resistance mediated by untranslatable sense RNAs: expression, regulation, and fate of nonessential RNAs

Haploid leaf tissue of tobacco cultivars K326 and K149 was transformed with several transgenes containing cDNA of the potato virus Y (PVY) coat protein (CP) open reading frame (ORF). The various transgenes containing the PVY CP ORF sequence produced (1) the expected mRNA and CP product, (2) an mRNA rendered untranslatable by introduction of a stop codon immediately after the initiation codon, or (3) an antisense RNA that was untranslatable as a result of the incorrect orientation of the PVY CP ORF behind the transcriptional promoter. Homozygous doubled haploid (DH) (diploid) plants were generated, and selfed progeny from these plants were examined. Resistance was virus specific, functioning only against PVY. An inverse correlation between transgene-derived PVY transcript steady state levels and resistance was generally noted with lines expressing the untranslatable sense version of the PVY CP ORF. A collection of DH lines, derived from a single transformation event of a common haploid plant and isogenic for the PVY transgenes expressing untranslatable sense RNA, displayed different levels of PVY resistance. Lines with actively transcribed, methylated transgene sequences had low steady state levels of transgene transcript and a virus-resistant phenotype. These results are discussed within the context of sense suppression in plants.

Homology-dependent gene silencing in transgenic plants: epistatic silencing loci contain multiple copies of methylated transgenes

Previous work has shown that two homologous, unlinked transgene loci can interact in plant nuclei, leading to non-reciprocal trans-inactivation and methylation of genes at one locus. Here, we report the structure and methylation of different transgene loci that contain the same construct but are variably able to inactivate and methylate a partially homologous, unlinked target locus. Silencing loci comprised multiple, methylated copies of the transgene construct, whereas a non-silencing locus contained a single, unmethylated copy. The correspondence between strength of silencing activity and copy number/degree of methylation was further demonstrated by producing novel alleles of a strong silencing locus: reducing the transgene copy number and methylation within this silencing locus decreased its ability to inactivate the target locus. The strong silencing locus, which was located close to a telomere, trans-inactivated various structural variants of the original target construct, regardless of their location in the genome. This suggests that the silencing locus can scan the entire genome for homologous regions, a process possibly aided by its telomeric location. Our data support the idea that epistatic trans-inactivation of unlinked, homologous transgenes in plants results from a pre-existing epigenetic difference between transgene loci, which is subsequently equalized by "epigene conversion" involving DNA-DNA pairing.

Susceptibility of transgene loci to homology-dependent gene silencing

Previous work has shown that two unlinked, partially homologous transgene loci can interact in plant nuclei, leading to reversible methylation and inactivation of one transgene locus in the presence of the second. To study whether the chromosomal location of a transgene influences its susceptibility to trans-inactivation, we retransformed four transgenic lines, which contained the same construct (H) integrated in different chromosomal locations, with a second, partially homologous construct (K). At least 50 double transformants (DTs) were regenerated from each single transformants (ST) and screened for inactivation of markers [chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (CAT); hygromycin resistance (HYGR)] at the resident H locus. For two STs, H locus markers were inactivated in less than 1% of the DTs, suggesting that, at these integration sites, H was relatively resistant to trans-inactivation. In contrast, the other two STs appeared to be more sensitive to trans-inactivation: 4-10% of the DTs were CAT- and/or Hygs. Inactivation of H locus markers could be attributed to two distinct phenomena: 1. Regeneration from cells containing different epigenetic states of H, in which either both, one or none of the H alleles was active. This instability in the expression of the H locus, which was independent of K, was more pronounced in the homozygous state, and was associated with cellular mosaicism of expression and methylation. 2. The presence of an unlinked K locus could weaken the HygR phenotype by transcriptional inactivation and increased methylation of the hph gene at the H locus. These results indicated that a susceptible transgene locus is inherently unstable and partially methylated, and that these characteristics are exacerbated when the locus is homozygous for the transgene and/or when an unlinked homologous transgene is present.

Co-suppression of nitrate reductase host genes and transgenes in transgenic tobacco plants

Constructs carrying the entire or part of the tobacco nitrate reductase cDNA (NIA) cloned between the promoter and terminator sequences of the 35S RNA of the cauliflower mosaic virus were introduced into tobacco, in an attempt to improve nitrate assimilation. Several transgenic plants that had elevated NIA mRNA and nitrate reductase (NR) activity were obtained. In addition, a few plants that exhibited a chlorotic phenotype characteristic of NR-deficient mutants were also obtained. One of these plants contained no NIA mRNA, no NR activity and accumulated nitrate. This phenotype was therefore assumed to result from co-suppression of 35S-NIA transgenes and host NIA genes. NR-deficient plants were also found among the progeny of transformants overexpressing NIA mRNA. Genetic analyses indicated that these NR-deficient plants were homozygous for the 35S-NIA transgene, although not all homozygous plants were deficient for NR. The ratio of normal to NR-deficient plants in the progeny of homozygous plants remained constant at each generation, irrespective of the state of expression of the NIA genes (active or inactive) in the previous generation. This ratio also remained unchanged when field trials were performed in two areas of France: Versailles and Bergerac. The analysis of homozygous plants revealed that co-suppression was reversible at some stage of sexual reproduction. Indeed, host genes and transgenes reactivated at each generation, and co-suppression always appeared after a lag period of normal growth, suggesting that the phenomenon is developmentally regulated.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)