A multicenter double-blind placebo-controlled trial of pergolide as an adjunct to Sinemet in Parkinson's disease

Pergolide for levodopa-induced complications in Parkinson's disease

OBJECTIVES

To compare the efficacy and safety of adjunct pergolide therapy versus placebo in patients with Parkinson's disease suffering from the complications of levodopa therapy.

SEARCH STRATEGY

Electronic searches of MEDLINE, EMBASE and the Cochrane Controlled Trials Register. Handsearching of the neurology literature as part of the Cochrane Movement Disorders Group's strategy. Examination of the reference lists of identified studies and other reviews. Contact with Eli Lilly and Company Limited.

SELECTION CRITERIA

Randomised controlled trials of pergolide versus placebo in patients with a clinical diagnosis of idiopathic Parkinson's disease and long-term complications of levodopa therapy.

DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS

Data was abstracted independently by each author and differences settled by discussion. The outcome measures used included Parkinson's disease rating scales, levodopa dosage, 'off' time measurements and the frequency of drop outs and adverse events.

MAIN RESULTS

A large number of small RCTs were identified, but these were part of a large multicentre trial which was eventually published in full. The final publication was used as the only subject for this review. The time patients spent 'off' was reduced by 1.8 hours with pergolide compared with 0.2 hours with placebo (p < 0.001). Dyskinesia developed or deteriorated in 62% of pergolide-treated compared with 25% placebo-treated patients (p < 0. 05). The excess in dyskinesia prevalence and severity resolved by the end of the study with levodopa reduction. Levodopa dose was reduced more in those receiving pergolide (235 mg v 51 mg; p < 0. 001). Pergolide produced significant improvement in Hoehn and Yahr stage (p < 0.05) and both the motor and activities of daily living parts of a modified Columbia rating scale (both p < 0.001). Significantly more patients suffered nausea (24% v 13%; p < 0.001) and hallucinations (14% v 3%; p < 0.01) on pergolide. No difference was found in the numbers remaining on treatment at the end of the study (pergolide 84% v placebo 82%) but withdrawals due to adverse events were greater in those taking pergolide (10% v 4%).

REVIEWER'S CONCLUSIONS

Based on this single large multicentre study, pergolide reduces 'off' time and improves impairment and disability due to Parkinson's disease whilst allowing a reduction in levodopa dose. This is at the expense of dopaminergic adverse events. Further trials are required to compare pergolide with the newer dopamine agonists.

Medical treatment of later-stage motor problems of Parkinson disease

Parkinson disease progression is associated with the development of levodopa short-duration responses and dyskinesias, as well as gait freezing. Levodopa dose adjustment and adjunctive treatment with dopamine agonists form the major therapeutic strategies. Catechol O-methyltransferase inhibitors are also appropriate considerations, whereas other drugs, including selegiline, amantadine, anticholinergic agents, and propranolol, have a more minor role.

Rationale for use of dopamine agonists in Parkinson's disease: review of ergot derivatives

While dopamine agonists are still traditionally used as adjunct medications to improve performance and smooth out motor response complications in advanced levodopa-treated Parkinson's disease, they are increasingly used in monotherapy or early in combination with levodopa particularly in patients under 65 years of age. Long-term studies using bromocriptine showed efficacy in lowering the cumulative levodopa dose and reducing the early incidence of levodopa-related motor response complications. New dopamine agonists have recently shown efficacy as adjunct medications in short-term trials. While we now have more options to fit our individual patients' needs and tolerance, it is important to view the new agonists in the light of the results obtained with ergot derivatives. In this article, the rationale for use and efficacy profile of the ergolines are briefly reviewed.

Parkinson's Disease: Motor Fluctuations

Motor fluctuations represent important late complications of Parkinson's disease treated with levodopa. Although treatment of these problems has improved with the emergence of numerous pharmacologic and surgical therapies, the various options can make it confusing. Pharmacologic treatment is the first step. Polytherapy is often the rule in this case with a variety of agents available as adjunctive therapy with levodopa. These adjuncts include dopamine agonists (bromocriptine, pergolide, pramipexole, ropinirole), catechol-O-methyltransferase (COMT) inhibitors (tolcapone), controlled-release formulations of levodopa, monoamine oxidase (MAO) B inhibitors (selegiline), and amantadine. The treatment can consist of any of a number of combinations of these agents. No single algorithm can be used in all patients; therapy should be individualized. Physicians treating these patients need to be well versed in late complication patterns as well as the medications chosen. In addition, optimal doses vary, and often patients are considered treatment failures and taken off medications before reaching that level. In the more complicated cases, patients should be evaluated by specialists in movement disorders. With this in mind, some guidelines are offered for the pharmacologic approach to patients with fluctuating responses to medications. For simple wearing off, controlled-release levodopa (Sinemet CR, Dupont Pharmaceuticals, Wilmington, DE), COMT inhibitors, MAO inhibitors, and dopamine agonists are reasonable options. For more complicated fluctuations, dopamine agonists with limits on levodopa are the first choice, especially when dyskinesia is present; when dyskinesia is not a factor, COMT inhibitors may be used. For dyskinesia specifically, dopamine agonists or addition of amantadine can be helpful. Surgery should be a treatment of last resort for patients in whom medical therapy fails. Patients who are candidates for medial pallidotomy should be fluctuators with severe dyskinesia and "off" periods that have not improved with pharmacologic therapy. Thalamic deep brain stimulation (DBS) should be used only in patients with tremor-predominant disease and severe intractable tremor that is unresponsive to medication and occurs not only at rest but with posture and action as well. Surgical therapy should be performed only in centers with surgeons experienced in stereotactic techniques and movement disorder specialists to ensure that the appropriate patients come to surgery and that complications are kept to a minimum. Dietary adjustment has a limited role in treating advanced Parkinson's disease.

Neuroprotective therapies

Though effective symptomatic therapies for Parkinson's disease exist, currently no treatment is proven to slow the progression of the underlying disease. Our growing understanding of the mechanisms of neuronal models, however, offers hope that neuroprotective strategies will soon be a standard part of the treatment of PD. Current approaches to the development of neuroprotective strategies are based on the hypothesized roles of oxidative stress and excitotoxicity in the degenerative process. In this article, we review evidence in support of these hypotheses as well as attempts to achieve neuroprotection in PD based on these and other mechanisms.

Management of early Parkinson's disease

The two major questions in the treatment of early PD are (1) Does selegiline slow neuronal loss and delay the progression of clinical disability? and (2) Should dopamine agonists be used as initial symptomatic therapy in early disease rather than levodopa/PDI to reduce long-term disability and delay the onset of motor fluctuations and dyskinesia? Selegiline affords neuroprotection for dopamine neurons in cell culture systems and the results of several clinical trials are consistent with the hypothesis that it is neuroprotective in Parkinson's disease. Several clinical trials have found that initial symptomatic therapy with dopamine agonist to which levodopa/carbidopa is later added when needed leads to a lower incidence of long-term motor complications. These strategies are now being tested in prospective, randomized, blinded trials, many of which include PET or SPECT scans to assess the rate of dopamine neuron loss. These trials will provide more definitive answers to guide the early medial management of Parkinson's disease in the future.

Dopamine agonists

Dopamine agonists have been used in the treatment of Parkinson's disease (PD) since the mid 1970s. With the approval of two new agents in 1997, the number available in the United States is up to four; bromocriptine, pergolide, pramipexole, ropinirole. These agents differ in dopamine receptor affinities and chemical structure, which, in turn, may possibly result in differences in efficacy tolerability and safety. Dopamine have historically been used in combination with levodopa in patients with advanced PD, but indicators are now expanding. With is expansion comes increasing controversy. This article reviews dopamine receptor pharmacology and the results of the clinical trials that have used for agonists available in the United States as well as a discussion of three minor agonists.

Motor fluctuations in Parkinson's disease: pathophysiology and treatment

At the initial stages of Parkinson's disease (PD), levodopa (LD) is able to reduce most motor symptoms and to significantly improve the patient's quality of life. However, in the vast majority of patients with prolonged LD usage, some decline in efficacy occurs and motor complications eventually begin to appear. These complications consist not only of daily fluctuations in the voluntary motor performance often accompanied by involuntary movements, but also of fluctuations in cognitive, autonomic, and sensory functions. Several recent studies on LD complications in PD have led to a better understanding of their pathophysiology and of the possible therapeutic interventions, and a summary of these findings is presented in this review. Different observations now suggest that postsynaptic pharmacodynamic factors play a major role in determining fluctuations in PD. Two explanations are given: chronic intermittent dopaminergic therapy may lead to postsynaptic receptor downregulation in PD; or, receptor changes in the striatum may occur independently of treatment as a result of structural adaptation of the postsynaptic dopaminergic system to the progressive decline of the nigrostriatal pathway. The hypothesis of reversible postsynaptic changes as the main mechanism underlying a fluctuating response to LD lends itself to a possible pharmacological manipulation of the dopaminergic response to reverse, or even avoid, motor fluctuations (initial monotherapy with dopamine agonists and early combination LD/dopamine agonists). The role of peripheral pharmacokinetics factors is also critical and the use of controlled release LD formulations, of monoamine oxidase (MAO)-B and of catechol-O-methyltransferase (COMT) inhibitors may all, to a different degree, improve such phenomena. In the last decade, there has been a resurgence in surgical therapies in advanced PD, due to higher levels of accuracy and safety provided by the new surgical devices, and to a more precise localization of the target areas allowed by the neurophysiological mapping techniques. The surgical procedures currently used in advanced PD are stereotactic brain lesions (internal globus pallidus and subthalamic nucleus), chronic brain stimulation (of the same nuclei) and striatal grafting of dopamine-producing cells. All these procedures have already shown their efficacy in the management of severe fluctuations in PD, but their indications, and relative advantages and disadvantages, are still the subject of considerable debate and controversy.

Pergolide binds tightly to dopamine D2 short receptors and induces receptor sequestration

Pergolide is an ergotamine derivative with potent D1 and D2 receptor activity. In this study we showed that pergolide binds tightly to dopamine D2 short receptors, as indicated by the long period of occupancy of the receptors after washing. Furthermore, pergolide induces receptor internalization to a larger extent than dopamine, seeing that no recycling of the receptors to the plasma membrane was observed for either agonist. The dissociation of pergolide from dopamine receptors occurs during the endocytotic process, leaving the receptors accessible to [3H]methylspiperone. Pergolide is a lipophilic compound that can reach and compete with [3H]methylspiperone for binding to sequestered receptors. If internalized receptors are still a target for drug action, pergolide could be a suitable compound of therapeutic interest in cases where receptor sequestration could prevent dopamine efficacy, as in levodopa therapy.

Entacapone improves motor fluctuations in levodopa-treated Parkinson's disease patients. Parkinson Study Group

Motor fluctuations associated with levodopa therapy are common problems encountered in the long-term treatment of Parkinson's disease (PD). Entacapone, a peripherally acting, reversible inhibitor of catechol-O-methyltransferase, slows the elimination of levodopa in humans by reducing the formation of 3-O-methyldopa. We conducted a placebo-controlled, double-blind, parallel-group, multicenter trial of entacapone in PD patients with motor fluctuations. Two hundred five patients were randomized to receive either entacapone 200 mg or matching placebo with each dose of levodopa and were followed for 24 weeks. The primary measure of efficacy was the change in percentage of "on" time (relief of parkinsonism) while awake, as recorded by subjects at home in diaries completed at 30-minute intervals. At baseline, patients averaged approximately 10 hours of "on" time per day while awake (60.5% "on" time), and entacapone treatment increased the percent "on" time by 5.0 percentage points. The effect of entacapone was more prominent in patients with a smaller percent "on" time (<55%) at baseline, and increased as the day wore on. Entacapone is effective at increasing the duration of response to levodopa and at relieving parkinsonism in patients experiencing motor fluctuations and was well tolerated during the 24 weeks of treatment.

Parkinson's disease: prospects for improved drug therapy

L-Dopa has long been the mainstay of therapy for Parkinson's disease but its long-term shortcomings, principally uncoordinated, spasmodic or irregular movements (dyskinesias) and fluctuating control of motor symptoms (on/off fluctuations), are well documented. The postulated neuroprotective properties of L-deprenyl, often used as an adjunct to L-dopa, are under scrutiny and doubts have also been raised regarding its safety. Alternative therapeutic approaches are clearly needed. In this review, Jim Hagan, Derek Middlemiss, Paul Sharpe and George Poste outline some new approaches to treatment, with an emphasis on novel, selective dopamine receptor agonists. In addition, Parkinson's disease is commonly thought to be caused by the neurotoxic effects of an unidentified agent but recent data indicate a greater genetic component than previously recognized. Developments in the genetics of Parkinson's disease may provide the key to the next generation of therapeutics.

Neuropsychiatric adverse effects of antiparkinsonian drugs. Characteristics, evaluation and treatment

Parkinson's disease (PD) is a progressive neurological condition that causes considerable disability in the elderly. Drugs used to treat PD, such as levodopa, offer symptomatic relief but often have neuropsychiatric adverse effects, most prominently psychosis and delirium. Aged patients and those with dementia are particularly vulnerable to these adverse effects. Evaluating PD patients with drug-induced neuropsychiatric adverse effects is made difficult by their complex clinical presentations. The treatment of drug-induced psychosis and delirium begins with manipulating the antiparkinsonian drug regimen, but this frequently worsens motor function. Atypical antipsychotics such as clozapine have been successfully employed to treat the psychosis without worsening the motor disability. Patient intolerance of clozapine therapy has prompted open-label studies with newer agents such as risperidone, remoxipride, zotepine, mianserin and ondansetron.

New strategies with dopaminergic drugs: modified formulations of levodopa and novel agonists

Most new pharmacological therapies in Parkinson's disease focus on the dopaminergic system. Drugs that enhance dopaminergic function fall into three primary categories: amino acid precursors to dopamine, agonists that stimulate dopamine receptors, and enzyme antagonists that prevent the metabolism of dopamine and hence permit more or prolonged neurotransmitter activity; the first two are discussed below. Within the first category, levodopa is the amino acid precursor to dopamine, and a number of modifications in its formulation have been developed to enhance dopaminergic activity. In the area of agonists, new agents pramipexole, ropinerole, and cabergoline have recently been developed to complement the currently available bromocriptine and pergolide, and these new drugs may be released in the United States.

A "combined" levodopa test as a useful method for evaluating the efficacy of dopamine agonists: application to pergolide and bromocriptine

The efficacy of pergolide as adjunct to levodopa therapy was compared to that of bromocriptine in 12 parkinsonian patients with fluctuating motor disability and levodopa-induced dyskinesias (mean age of onset, 50.6 +/- 8 years; Hoehn and Yahr stage between II and IV; mean basal UPDRS motor score, 30.6 +/- 8.6), in a double-blind crossover study. After an 8-day habituation to each agonist, an acute challenge of a supraliminal dose of levodopa ("levodopa test") was performed in association with either 1 mg pergolide or 10 mg bromocriptine. The delay to onset and the duration of therapeutic benefit, the percentage improvement in motor disability, and the severity of onset and peak-dose dyskinesias were evaluated. Both agonists significantly increased the duration of therapeutic benefit, but pergolide more so than bromocriptine (p = 0.02). Pergolide also tended to reduce the severity of dyskinesias and was globally perceived by the patients to be more efficacious than bromocriptine on parkinsonian symptoms and fluctuations. This study illustrated the usefulness of the "levodopa test" in evaluating, objectively, the effects of dopamine agonists.

The dopamine D1D receptor. Cloning and characterization of three pharmacologically distinct D1-like receptors from Gallus domesticus

Three genomic clones encoding dopamine D1-like receptors were isolated from the avian species Gallus domesticus. Two of these genes encode proteins of 451 and 488 amino acids, which, based on deduced amino acid sequence identity and homology of exhibited pharmacological profiles, appear to be species homologs of mammalian and vertebrate D1/D1A and D5/D1B receptors, respectively. The third genomic clone, termed D1D, encodes a protein of 445 amino acids displaying a deduced amino acid sequence identity within putative transmembrane domains of 75% to mammalian D1/D1A and 77% to D5/D1B receptors with overall sequence homologies of only 49% and 46%, respectively. Membranes from COS-7 cells transfected with D1D DNA bound [3H]SCH-23390 in a saturable manner with high affinity (approximately 300 pM) and with a pharmacological profile clearly indicative of a dopamine D1-like receptor. The D1D receptor exhibited affinities for 6,7-dihydroxy-2-aminotetralin and dopamine 10-fold higher than D1/D1A receptors, characteristic of the D5/D1B receptor subfamily. In contrast, the D1D receptor bound dopaminergic agents, such as SKF-38393, apomorphine, pergolide, and lisuride, with affinities 10-fold higher than other cloned mammalian or vertebrate D1A/D1B receptor subtypes, while both clozapine and haloperidol displayed considerably lower affinity for the D1D receptor. Based on the low overall amino acid sequence identity (54%) and unique pharmacological profile, the avian dopamine D1D receptor does not appear to be a species homolog of the recently cloned vertebrate D1C receptor (Sugamori, K.S., Demchyshyn, L. L., Chung, M., and Niznik, H. B. (1994) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 91, 10536-10540). As with all cloned mammalian and vertebrate D1-like receptors, the D1D receptor stimulates adenylate cyclase activity in the presence of dopamine or SKF-82526. Northern blot analysis reveals the selective expression of both avian D1D and D1A receptor mRNAs only in brain with the D1B receptor more widely distributed and localized in tissues such as brain, kidney, and spleen. The isolation of four distinct vertebrate dopamine D1 receptor subtypes suggests the existence of additional mammalian D1 like receptor genes that may account for the observed pharmacological and biochemical multiplicity of dopamine D1-like receptor mediated events.