HIV-1 nucleocapsid protein activates transient melting of least stable parts of the secondary structure of TAR and its complementary sequence

Mechanistic insights into the kinetics of HIV-1 nucleocapsid protein-facilitated tRNA annealing to the primer binding site

HIV-1 reverse transcriptase uses human tRNA(Lys,3) as a primer to initiate reverse transcription. Prior to initiation, the 3' 18 nucleotides of this tRNA are annealed to a complementary sequence on the RNA genome known as the primer binding site (PBS). Here, we show that the HIV-1 nucleocapsid protein (NC) enhances this annealing by approximately five orders of magnitude in vitro, decreasing the transition state enthalpy from approximately 20 kcal mol(-1) for the uncatalyzed reaction to 13 kcal mol(-1) for the NC-catalyzed process. Moreover, the annealing follows second-order kinetics, consistent with the nucleation of the intermolecular duplex being the rate-limiting step. This nucleation is preceded by melting of a small duplex region within the original structure, and is followed by much faster zipping of the rest of the 18 base-pair (bp) duplex. A tRNA mutational analysis shows that destabilization of the tRNA acceptor stem has only a minor effect on the annealing rate. In contrast, addition of bases to the 5' end of tRNA that are complementary to its single-stranded 3' end interferes with duplex nucleation and therefore has a much larger effect on the net reaction rate. Assuming that the apparent transition free energy of the annealing reaction, Delta G(++) is a sum of the melting (Delta G(m)) and nucleation (Delta G(nuc)) free energies, we show that NC affects both Delta G(m) and Delta G(nuc). We estimate that ten to 100-fold of the overall rate enhancement is due to NC-induced destabilization of a 4 bp helix in the PBS, while the additional factor of 10(3)-10(4) rate enhancement is a result of NC-facilitated duplex nucleation. The apparently similar effectiveness of wild-type and SSHS NC, a mutant that lacks the zinc finger structures, in facilitating the tRNA annealing reaction is most likely the result of the mutual cancellation of two factors: SSHS NC is less effective than wild-type NC as a duplex destabilizer, but more effective as a duplex nucleating agent.

FinO is an RNA chaperone that facilitates sense-antisense RNA interactions

The protein FinO represses F-plasmid conjugative transfer by facilitating interactions between the mRNA of the major F-plasmid transcriptional activator, TraJ, and an antisense RNA, FinP. FinO is known to bind stem-loop structures in both FinP and traJ RNAs; however, the mechanism by which FinO facilitates sense-antisense pairing is poorly understood. Here we show that FinO acts as an RNA chaperone to promote strand exchange and duplexing between minimal RNA targets derived from FinP. This strongly suggests that FinO may function to destabilize internal secondary structures within FinP and traJ RNAs that would otherwise act as a kinetic trap to sense-antisense pairing. The energy for FinO-catalyzed base-pair destabilization does not arise from ATP hydrolysis but appears to be supplied directly from FinO RNA binding free energy. An analysis of the activities of mutants that are specifically deficient in strand exchange but not RNA-binding activity demonstrates that strand exchange is essential to the ability of FinO to mediate sense-antisense RNA recognition, and that this function also plays a role in repression of conjugation in vivo.

The annealing mechanism of HIV-1 reverse transcription primer onto the viral genome

Reverse transcription of human immunodeficiency virus-1 viral RNA uses human tRNA(3)(Lys) as a primer. The first step of viral replication is, thus, the annealing of the primer tRNA onto the primer binding site located in the 5' leader region of the viral RNA. This involves large rearrangements of both RNA structures and requires the chaperone activity of the viral nucleocapsid protein. We have developed a novel approach to analyze dynamically such RNA refolding events using heteronuclear NMR spectroscopy of mixtures of (15)N-labeled and unlabeled large RNA fragments (up to 50 kDa). We have thus been able to characterize the detailed mechanisms of both heat- and nucleocapsid-mediated annealing and to identify previously unknown key steps. The role played by the nucleocapsid is 2-fold; it facilitates strand exchange at the level of the tRNA acceptor stem, presumably via its basic N- and C-terminal extensions, and it unlocks the highly stable tertiary interactions at the level of the T Psi C loop, most likely by specific interactions involving its two zinc knuckles.

DNA condensation by the nucleocapsid protein of HIV-1: a mechanism ensuring DNA protection

The nucleocapsid (NC) protein NCp7 of the immunodeficiency virus type 1 is a small basic protein with two zinc finger motifs. NCp7 has key roles in virus replication and structure, which rely on its interactions with nucleic acids. Although most interactions involve RNAs, binding to the viral DNA is thought to be of importance to achieve protection of the DNA against cellular nucleases and its integration into the host genome. We investigated the interaction of NCp7 with plasmid DNA as a model system. The fluorescence probe YOYO-1 was used as the reporter. Binding of NCp7 to DNA caused DNA condensation, as inferred from the dramatic decrease in YOYO-1 fluorescence. Efficient condensation of DNA required the full length NCp7 with the zinc fingers. The fingerless peptide was less efficient in condensing DNA. Binding of both these NC peptides led to freezing of the segmental dynamics of DNA as revealed by anisotropy decay kinetics of YOYO-1. The truncated peptide NC(12-55) which retains the zinc fingers did not lead to DNA condensation despite its ability to bind and partially freeze the segmental motion of DNA. We propose that the histone-like property of NCp7 leading to DNA condensation contributes to viral DNA stability, in vivo.

Role of the Reverse Transcriptase, Nucleocapsid Protein, and Template Structure in the Two-step Transfer Mechanism in Retroviral Recombination

Template switching during reverse transcription promotes recombination in retroviruses. Efficient switches have been measured in vitro on hairpin-containing RNA templates by a two-step mechanism. Pausing of the reverse transcriptase (RT) at the hairpin base allowed enhanced cleavage of the initial donor RNA template, exposing regions of the cDNA and allowing the acceptor to base pair with the cDNA. This defines the first or docking step. The primer continued synthesis on the donor, transferring or locking in a second step. Here we determine the enzyme-dependent factors that influence template switching by comparing the RTs from human immunodeficiency virus, type 1 (HIV-1), and equine infectious anemia virus (EIAV). HIV-1 RT promoted transfers with higher efficiency than EIAV RT. We found that both RTs paused strongly at the base of the hairpin. While stalled, HIV-1 RT made closely spaced cuts, whereas EIAV RT made only a single cut. Docking occurred efficiently at the multiply cut but not at the singly cut site. HIV-1 nucleocapsid (NC) protein stimulated strand transfers. It improved RNase H activity of both RTs. It allowed the EIAV RT to make a distribution of cuts, greatly stimulating docking at the base of the hairpin. Most likely, it also promoted strand exchange, allowing transfers to be initiated from sites throughout the hairpin. Minor pause sites beyond the base of the hairpin correlated with the locking sites. The strand exchange properties of NC likely promote this step. We present a model that explains the roles of RNase H specificity, template structure, and properties of NC in the two-step transfer reaction.

Zinc finger-dependent HIV-1 nucleocapsid protein-TAR RNA interactions

In the minus-strand transfer step of HIV-1 reverse transcription, the nucleocapsid protein (NC) promotes annealing of the 3' 'R' (repeat) region of the RNA genome to its complementary sequence located in the newly synthesized minus-strand strong-stop DNA. The R region contains the highly stable transactivation response (TAR) RNA hairpin. To gain insights into the molecular details of TAR RNA-NC interactions, we carried out hydroxyl radical footprinting, as well as gel-shift and fluorescence anisotropy binding assays using wild-type and mutant forms of NC. Our results support the conclusion that NC variants with mutations in their zinc finger domains have dramatically altered TAR RNA binding interactions relative to wild-type NC. These data demonstrate that a specific zinc finger architecture is required for optimal TAR RNA binding, and help to explain the requirement for the zinc finger motifs of NC in its role as a nucleic acid chaperone in minus-strand transfer.

Characterizing the structural features of RNA/RNA interactions of the F-plasmid FinOP fertility inhibition system

F-like plasmid transfer is mediated by the FinOP fertility inhibition system. Expression of the F positive regulatory protein, TraJ, is controlled by the action of the antisense RNA, FinP, and the RNA-binding protein FinO. FinO binds to and protects FinP from degradation and promotes duplex formation between FinP and traJ mRNA, leading to repression of both traJ expression and conjugative F transfer. FinP antisense RNA secondary structure is composed of two stem-loops separated by a 4-base single-stranded spacer and flanked on each side by single-stranded tails. Here we show that disruption of the expected Watson-Crick base pairing between the loops of FinP stem-loop I and its cognate RNA binding partner, traJ mRNA stem-loop Ic, led to a moderate reduction in the rate of duplex formation in vitro. In vivo, alterations of the anti-ribosome binding site region in the loop of FinP stem-loop I reduced the ability of the mutant FinP to mediate fertility inhibition and to inhibit TraJ expression when expressed in trans at an elevated copy number. Alterations of intermolecular complementarity between the stems of these RNAs reduced the rate of duplex formation. Our results suggest that successful interaction between stem-loop I of FinP and stem-loop Ic of traJ mRNA requires that base pairing must proceed from an initial loop-loop interaction through the top portion of the stems for stable duplex formation to occur.

Evidence for the differential effects of nucleocapsid protein on strand transfer in various regions of the HIV genome

An in vitro strand transfer assay that mimicked recombinational events occurring during reverse transcription in HIV-1 was used to assess the role of nucleocapsid protein (NC) in strand transfer. Strand transfer in highly structured nucleic acid species from the U3 3' long terminal repeats, gag-pol frameshift region, and Rev response element were strongly enhanced by NC. In contrast, weakly structured templates from the env and pol-vif regions transferred well without NC and showed lower enhancement. The lack of strong polymerase pause sites in the latter regions demonstrated that non-pause driven mechanisms could also promote transfer. Assays conducted using NC zinc finger mutants supported a differential role for the two fingers in strand transfer with finger 1 (N-terminal) being more important on highly structured RNAs. Overall this report suggests a role for structural intricacies of RNA templates in determining the extent of influence of NC on recombination and illustrates that strand transfer may occur by several different mechanisms depending on the structural nature of the RNA.

Specific recognition of primer tRNA Lys 3 by HIV-1 nucleocapsid protein: involvement of the zinc fingers and the N-terminal basic extension

Reverse transcription of HIV-1 viral RNA uses human tRNA(Lys)(3) as a primer. We have previously characterised the structural aspects of the tRNA(Lys)(3) interaction by NMR. In HIV-1 virions, the nucleocapsid protein NCp7 contains two zinc fingers flanked by basic residues. Using NMR, the respective role of the N-terminal residues and the zinc fingers in the interaction with tRNA(Lys)(3)/NCp7 was investigated by studying the tRNA(Lys)(3) and tRNA(Lys)(3)/NCp7 complexes. The N-terminal basic residues do not change the footprint of NC on tRNA(Lys)(3)/Cys(23)NCp7 but strengthen the binding whereas the mutation of the zinc-binding histidine at position 23 that was shown to result in non-infectious particles prevents the interaction with the first bases of the acceptor stem.

Impact of the terminal bulges of HIV-1 cTAR DNA on its stability and the destabilizing activity of the nucleocapsid protein NCp7

Reverse transcription of HIV-1 genomic RNA to double-stranded DNA by reverse transcriptase (RT) is a critical step in HIV-1 replication. This process relies on two viral proteins, the RT enzyme and nucleocapsid protein NCp7 that has well documented nucleic acid chaperone properties. At the beginning of the linear DNA synthesis, the newly made minus-strand strong-stop DNA ((-)ssDNA) is transferred to the 3'end of the genomic RNA by means of an hybridization reaction between transactivation response element (TAR) RNA and cTAR DNA sequences. Since both TAR sequences exhibit stable hairpin structures, NCp7 needs to destabilize the TAR structures in order to chaperone their hybridization. To further characterize the relationships between TAR stability and NC-mediated destabilization, the role of the A(49) and G(52) bulged residues in cTAR DNA stability was investigated. The stability of cTAR and mutants where one or the two terminal bulges were replaced by base-pairs as well as the NCp7-mediated destabilization of these cTAR sequences were examined. Thermodynamic data indicate that the two bulges cooperatively destabilize cTAR by reducing the stacking interactions between the bases. This causes a free energy change of about 6.4 kcal/mol and seems to be critical for NC activity. Time-resolved fluorescence data of doubly labelled cTAR derivatives suggest that NC-mediated melting of cTAR ends propagates up to the 10C.A(44) mismatch or T(40) bulge. Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy using two-photon excitation was also used to monitor cTAR ends fraying by NC. Results show that NC causes a very significant increase of cTAR ends fraying, probably limited to the terminal base-pair in the case of cTAR mutants. Since the TAR RNA and cTAR DNA bulges or mismatches appear well conserved among all HIV-1 strains, the present data support the notion of a co-evolutionary relationship between TAR and NC activity.

Mechanism of minus strand strong stop transfer in HIV-1 reverse transcription

Retrovirus minus strand strong stop transfer (minus strand transfer) requires reverse transcriptase-associated RNase H, R sequence homology, and viral nucleocapsid protein. The minus strand transfer mechanism in human immunodeficiency virus-1 was examined in vitro with purified protein and substrates. Blocking donor RNA 5'-end cleavage inhibited transfers when template homology was 19 nucleotides (nt) or less. Cleavage of the donor 5'-end occurred prior to formation of transfer products. This suggests that when template homology is short, transfer occurs through a primer terminus switch-initiated mechanism, which requires cleavage of the donor 5' terminus. On templates with 26-nt and longer homology, transfer occurred before cleavage of the donor 5' terminus. Transfer was unaffected when donor 5'-end cleavages were blocked but was reduced when internal cleavages within the donor were restricted. Based on the overall data, we conclude that in human immunodeficiency virus-1, which contains a 97-nt R sequence, minus strand transfer occurs through an acceptor invasion-initiated mechanism. Transfer is initiated at internal regions of the homologous R sequence without requiring cleavage at the donor 5'-end. The acceptor invades at gaps created by reverse transcriptase-RNase H in the donor-cDNA hybrid. The fragmented donor is eventually strand-displaced by the acceptor, completing the transfer.

Destabilization of the HIV-1 complementary sequence of TAR by the nucleocapsid protein through activation of conformational fluctuations

The nucleocapsid protein NCp7 of HIV-1 possesses nucleic acid chaperone properties that are critical for the two obligatory strand transfer reactions required for the synthesis of a complete proviral DNA by reverse transcriptase. The first DNA strand transfer relies on the destabilization by NCp7 of double-stranded segments of the transactivation response region (TAR) sequence at the 3' end of the genomic RNA and the complementary sequence cTAR at the 3' terminus of minus strong-stop DNA, the early product of reverse transcription. In order to determine the dynamics of NCp7-mediated nucleic acid destabilization, we investigated by time-resolved fluorescence spectroscopy and two photon fluorescence correlation spectroscopy, the interaction of a doubly labeled cTAR sequence with NC(12-55) containing NCp7 CCHC zinc fingers and flanking basic amino acid residues. From the chemical rates and the activation energy associated with the conformational fluctuations observed in the absence of NC, it is concluded that such fluctuations are associated with the opening and closing of the double-stranded terminal segments of cTAR. The destabilizing activity of NC(12-55) occurs mainly through a major increase of the opening rate constant of cTAR. Moreover, NC appears to augment the number of pathways between the open and closed states of cTAR, suggesting that it initiates melting of base-pairs at different locations within the terminal segments of cTAR. This activity of NC on the dynamics of cTAR secondary structure is thought to be critical for the formation of the cTAR-TAR complex, which is essential for the specificity and extent of proviral DNA synthesis by reverse transcriptase.

Nucleic acid conformational changes essential for HIV-1 nucleocapsid protein-mediated inhibition of self-priming in minus-strand transfer

Reverse transcription of the HIV-1 genome is a complex multi-step process. HIV-1 nucleocapsid protein (NC) is a nucleic acid chaperone protein that has been shown to greatly facilitate the nucleic acid rearrangements that precede the minus-strand transfer step in reverse transcription. NC destabilizes the highly structured transactivation response region (TAR) present in the R region of the RNA genome, as well as a complementary hairpin structure ("TAR DNA") at the 3'-end of the newly synthesized minus-strand strong-stop DNA ((-) SSDNA). Melting of the latter structure inhibits a self-priming (SP) reaction that competes with the strand transfer reaction. In an in vitro minus-strand transfer system consisting of a (-) SSDNA mimic and a TAR-containing acceptor RNA molecule, we find that when both nucleic acids are present, NC facilitates formation of the transfer product and the SP reaction is greatly reduced. In contrast, in the absence of the acceptor RNA, NC has only a small inhibitory effect on the SP reaction. To further investigate NC-mediated inhibition of SP, we developed a FRET-based assay that allows us to directly monitor conformational changes in the TAR DNA structure upon NC binding. Although the majority ( approximately 71%) of the TAR DNA molecules assume a folded hairpin conformation in the absence of NC, two minor "semi-folded" and "unfolded" populations are also observed. Upon NC binding to the TAR DNA alone, we observe a modest shift in the population towards the less-folded states. In the presence of the RNA acceptor molecule, NC binding to TAR DNA results in a shift of the majority of molecules to the unfolded state. These measurements help to explain why acceptor RNA is required for significant inhibition of the SP reaction by NC, and support the hypothesis that NC-mediated annealing of nucleic acids is a concerted process wherein the unwinding step occurs in synchrony with hybridization.

Excitonic heterodimer formation in an HIV-1 oligonucleotide labeled with a donor-acceptor pair used for fluorescence resonance energy transfer

In this study, we investigated the absorbance and fluorescence properties of cTAR, the complementary DNA sequence of the transactivation response element of the HIV-1 genome, doubly end-labeled by different dyes, 5(and 6)-carboxyfluorescein (Fl) and 5(and 6)-carboxytetramethylrhodamine (TMR), frequently used in fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) studies. This oligonucleotide forms a stable stem-loop structure. The absorption spectrum of this species clearly differed from that of a doubly labeled cTAR derivative in which the terminal part of the stem is melted and from an equimolecular mixture of singly labeled species. Moreover, no significant TMR fluorescence change accompanies the dramatic Fl intensity increase when the doubly labeled native cTAR was melted by temperature or annealed with its complementary sequence. Both elements suggest the formation of an H-type ground-state heterodimer between Fl and TMR that may be described by the molecular exciton model. Moreover, time-resolved fluorescence further suggests that the nonfluorescent heterodimer is in equilibrium with a small population of partially melted species showing FRET. Based on the spectral shifts associated with heterodimer formation, an interchromophore distance of 7.7 A was calculated. Both the excitonic signal and the Fl fluorescence were used as sensitive tools to monitor the temperature-mediated and HIV nucleocapsid protein-mediated annealing of cTAR with its complementary sequence.