Clinical results of wavefront-guided laser in situ keratomileusis 3 months after surgery

A control-matched comparison of laser epithelial keratomileusis and laser in situ keratomileusis for low to moderate myopia

PURPOSE

To compare the visual and refractive outcomes of laser epithelial keratomileusis (LASEK) and laser in situ keratomileusis (LASIK) for the treatment of low to moderate myopia.

DESIGN

Retrospective, nonrandomized, control-matched study.

METHODS

The charts of 2257 eyes that underwent LASEK or LASIK treatment were reviewed. Patients who were 21 years of age or older having between -0.75 and -6.00 diopters (D) of myopia with up to -2.25 D of astigmatism were included. One hundred twenty-two LASEK-treated eyes were matched with 122 LASIK-treated eyes having preoperative spheres, cylinders, and spherical equivalent (SE) within +/-0.50 D. Both groups had similar preoperative best spectacle-corrected visual acuity (BSCVA), laser platform, and follow-up durations. Outcome measures were visual and refractive results.

RESULTS

Preoperatively, the mean SE was -3.50 +/- 1.40 D for LASEK and -3.50 +/- 1.42 D for LASIK (P = .59). Postoperatively, the mean logarithm of minimum angle of resolution (logMAR) uncorrected visual acuity (UCVA) was 0.01 +/- 0.08 (20/21) for LASEK and 0.06 +/- 0.12 (20/23) for LASIK; the mean SE was -0.15 +/- 0.40 D for LASEK and -0.37 +/- 0.45 D for LASIK; and the mean logMAR of BSCVA was -0.03 +/- 0.06 (20/19) for LASEK and -0.02 +/- 0.05 (20/19) for LASIK. No eye lost 2 or more lines of BSCVA in both groups.

CONCLUSIONS

Slight differences in the visual and refractive results between LASEK and LASIK were observed, despite the use of the same nomogram. Both procedures were safe, effective, and predictable. Nomogram adjustment may be necessary for LASIK surgeons adopting surface ablation.

Customized LASIK Treatment for Myopia: Relationship Between Preoperative Higher Order Aberrations and Refractive Outcome

PURPOSE

To analyze the effect of preoperative higher order aberrations on postoperative sphere and cylinder outcome.

METHODS

Three hundred thirty myopic eyes (mean: -3.32 +/- 1.54 diopters [D], range: -1.0 to -7.0 D) treated with customized ablation using the Technolas 217z laser (Bausch & Lomb) were followed through 6 months after LASIK. Pre- and postoperative visual acuity, higher order root mean square (RMS), third order RMS, and spherical aberration were compared to study the safety and efficacy of the treatment. The relationship between preoperative higher order aberrations and manifest refraction after LASIK was analyzed.

RESULTS

Following LASIK, 91.5% of eyes obtained an uncorrected visual acuity of > or = 20/20 and 70.3% of eyes obtained 20/16 without retreatment; 99% had a best spectacle-corrected visual acuity of > or = 20/20 (75.9% of eyes were within +/- 0.50 D). Mean value of significant increase in postoperative higher order aberrations was 0.12 +/- 0.18 microm (P<.0001). Increased spherical aberration was associated with increased myopia treatment (P<.0001). Greater positive spherical aberration after LASIK was significantly correlated to postoperative hyperopia (overcorrection). Change in third order RMS was significantly correlated to change in spherical equivalent refraction among eyes with postoperative astigmatism (P<.0001).

CONCLUSIONS

With the Bausch & Lomb Technolas 217z Zyoptix software, treatment of higher order aberrations, especially third order (coma and trefoil) and spherical aberration, significantly improved postoperative refractive status.

Bilateral Comparison of Conventional Versus Topographic-guided Customized Ablation for Myopic LASIK With the NIDEK EC-5000

PURPOSE

To compare visual acuity and higher order aberrations before and after myopic LASIK using conventional versus customized ablation.

METHODS

This prospective, randomized study included 54 myopic eyes in 27 patients who underwent bilateral LASIK using the NIDEK EC-5000 excimer laser system (NIDEK Technologies, Gamagori, Japan). Customized aspheric treatment zone (CATz) treatment was used in one eye (CATz group) and conventional ablation (conventional group) was used in the fellow eye. Uncorrected visual acuity (UCVA) and higher order aberrations (root-mean-square [RMS] in 4-mm and 6-mm zones) of both groups were observed with the NIDEK OPD-Scan aberrometer before and 3 months after LASIK. Preoperative mean refractive error was similar for both eyes of each patient (P>.05).

RESULTS

No statistically significant differences were noted in preoperative higher order aberrations (RMS in 4-mm and 6-mm zones) between groups (P>.05). No statistically significant difference was noted between pre- and postoperative higher order aberrations in the CATz group (P>.05). However, a highly statistically significant increase in higher order aberrations was observed after conventional ablation (P<.001). There was a statistically significant higher increase of higher order aberrations after LASIK in the conventional group than the CATz group (P<.05). Postoperative UCVA with both conventional and customized ablation was not significantly different (P>.05).

CONCLUSIONS

LASIK with conventional ablation and CATz ablation resulted in the same UCVA. The increase in higher order aberrations after CATz ablation was less than after conventional ablation.

Efficacy of Measuring Visual Performance of LASIK Patients under Photopic and Mesopic Conditions

Introduction: The aim of the study was to compare the visual performance of LASIK eyes measured using high-contrast logMAR letter charts under bright (photopic) and dim (mesopic) conditions. Materials and Methods: A total of 46 subjects (35 ± 8 years of age) undergoing LASIK procedures were recruited for the study. The best spectacle-corrected visual acuity (BSCVA) of each subject was measured using the high-contrast ETDRS logMAR chart under photopic and mesopic conditions at 3 visits: preoperative (Pre), 1 month postoperative (Post1) and 3 months postoperative (Post3). The differences in logMAR scores for the right eyes only were analysed for the Pre-Post1 (n = 46), Pre-Post3 (n = 18) and Post1-Post3 (n = 16) comparisons. Results: The logMAR scores of subjects were worse at the 1-month postoperative visit than preoperatively, and improvement in visual performance was seen at the 3-month postoperative visit. These changes in visual performance became more evident under mesopic conditions. The means and standard errors of the differences in logMAR scores for the Pre-Post3 (0.097 ± 0.020) were slightly larger than those of the Pre-Post1 (-0.067 ± 0.019) and Post1-Post3 (0.031 ± 0.012) comparisons. Under mesopic conditions, the visual performance of the subjects was statistically significant for the 3 comparisons, but not under photopic conditions. Conclusion: High-contrast logMAR chart performed under mesopic conditions has the potential to replace visual acuity measured under photopic conditions in providing more reliable representation of postoperative visual outcomes of LASIK eyes. Eye doctors should consider performing this vision test routinely to gauge the success of LASIK surgery. Key words: Contrast sensitivity, logMAR chart, Visual acuity

Size of corneal topographic effective optical zone: comparison of standard and customized myopic laser in situ keratomileusis

PURPOSE

To investigate the corneal topographic effective optical zone (EOZ) in eyes after wavefront-guided myopic laser in situ keratomileusis (LASIK) and to compare them with the EOZ after standard LASIK.

DESIGN

Retrospective, case-control study.

METHODS

We evaluated the corneal topographic maps of 41 eyes of 25 consecutive patients who had CustomVue LASIK (CV LASIK) and 41 eyes of 23 patients who had standard LASIK with correction up to -7 diopters using the VISX Star S4 laser (VISX Inc, Santa Clara, California, USA). On the refractive map of the Humphrey Topography System, we defined the EOZ as the area outlined by a change of corneal power of 0.5 diopters from the power at the center of the pupil. We analyzed the differences in EOZs of the two ablation patterns and the correlation between EOZ and magnitude of refractive correction.

RESULTS

The mean postoperative EOZs were 17.9 +/- 3.7 mm(2) and 11.4 +/- 3.4 mm(2) after CV and standard LASIK, representing 60% and 40% of the laser-programmed optical zones, respectively (both P < .0001). There was no correlation between the postoperative EOZs and the magnitude of refractive correction for both ablations (all P > .05). In eyes with spherical correction (cylinder < or =0.25 diopters), CV LASIK increased the preoperative EOZ by 3.8 +/- 5.6 mm(2) (P = .018), whereas standard LASIK decreased EOZ by 4.5 +/- 5.2 mm(2) (P = .005).

CONCLUSION

CV LASIK created larger corneal topographic EOZs than standard ablation. In eyes with spherical correction, the preoperative EOZ was expanded by CV LASIK and reduced by standard LASIK.

Corneal Asphericity and Visual Function After Wavefront-Guided LASIK

PURPOSE

In recent years, a theory has been advanced that corneal asphericity in and of itself determines visual function; that the natural, optimal shape of the cornea is prolate; and that changing the cornea from prolate to oblate negatively impacts visual results. This article presents an analysis of the impact of corneal asphericity on wavefront-guided LASIK.

METHOD

A retrospective analysis was conducted of 160 myopic eyes that had undergone wavefront-guided LASIK. Surgical procedures and data collection were conducted at six clinical sites. Corneal topography, visual acuity, and contrast sensitivity data were collected before and 6 months after surgery. The topographically measured corneal surface of each eye was fitted to a conic, and a Q-value was computed for a 5.5-mm pupil. Multivariate regression analysis was performed to evaluate the correlation between Q-value and visual function. The relationship of changes in the corneal surfaces to visual performance was also investigated.

RESULTS

Preoperative corneas exhibited negative (prolate) conic shape constants. Postoperative corneas were about equally divided between positive (oblate) and negative conics. There was no statistically significant correlation between corneal shape and visual acuity or contrast sensitivity function. Changes in corneal asphericity after surgery had no significant correlation with changes in visual acuity or contrast sensitivity.

CONCLUSION

Visual acuity and contrast sensitivity after wavefront-guided LASIK are not dependent on corneal asphericity. Neither preserving nor inducing asphericity ensures better visual outcome. Better visual outcomes are more likely to result from the application of a customized shape than a standard conic shape.

Zyoptix wavefront-guided versus standard photorefractive keratectomy (PRK) in low and moderate myopia: randomized controlled 6-month study

PURPOSE

To evaluate the refractive and aberrometric outcome of wavefront-guided photorefractive keratectomy (PRK) compared to standard PRK in myopic patients.

METHODS

Fifty-six eyes of 56 patients were included in the study and were randomly divided into two groups. The study group consisted of 28 eyes with a mean spherical equivalent (SE) of -2.25+/-0.76 diopters (D) (range: -1.5 to -3.5 D) treated with wavefront-guided PRK using the Zywave ablation profile and the Bausch & Lomb Technolas 217z excimer laser (Zyoptix system) and the control group included 28 eyes with a SE of -2.35+/-1.01 D (range: -1.5 to -3.5 D) treated with standard PRK (PlanoScan ablation) using the same laser. A Zywave aberrometer was used to analyze and calculate the root-mean-square (RMS) of total high order aberrations (HOA) and Zernike coefficients of third and fourth order before and after (over a 6-month follow-up period) surgery in both groups. Preoperative and postoperative SE, un-corrected visual acuity (UCVA), and best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA) were evaluated in all cases.

RESULTS

There was a high correlation between achieved and intended correction. The differences between the two treatment groups were not statistically significant for UCVA, BCVA, or SE cycloplegic refraction . Postoperatively the RMS value of high order aberrations was raised in both groups. At 6-month control, on average it increased by a factor of 1.17 in the Zyoptix PRK group and 1.54 in the PlanoScan PRK group (p=0.22). In the Zyoptix group there was a decrease of coma aberration, while in the PlanoScan group this third order aberration increased. The difference between postoperative and preoperative values between the two groups was statistically significant for coma aberration (p=0.013). No statistically significant difference was observed for spherical-like aberration between the two groups. In the study group eyes with a low amount of preoperative aberrations (HOA RMS lower than the median value; <0.28 microm) showed an increase of HOA RMS while eyes with RMS higher than 0.28 microm showed a decrease (p<0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Zyoptix wavefront-guided PRK is as safe and efficacious for the correction of myopia and myopic astigmatism as PlanoScan PRK. Moreover this technique induces a smaller increase of third order coma aberration compared to standard PRK. The use of Zyoptix wavefront-guided PRK is particularly indicated in eyes with higher preoperative RMS values.

Factors affecting the change in lower-order and higher-order aberrations after wavefront-guided laser in situ keratomileusis for myopia with the Zyoptix 3.1 system

PURPOSE

To identify factors that affect the change in lower- and higher-order wavefront aberrations after myopic wavefront-guided laser in situ keratomileusis (wg-LASIK).

SETTING

Department of Ophthalmology, Johann Wolfgang Goethe-University, Frankfurt am Main, Germany.

METHODS

Sixty myopic eyes of 32 patients were treated with wg-LASIK (Zyoptix version 3.1, Bausch & Lomb) and had an uneventful follow-up of 12 months. Wavefront errors were measured preoperatively and 12 months after LASIK and were computed for pupil diameters (PDs) of 3.5 mm and 6.0 mm. Multiple stepwise regression analysis was performed to assess the influence of patient age, spherical equivalent (SE), sphere, cylinder, optical zone (OZ) diameter, and the preoperative individual Zernike coefficients on lower- and higher-order aberration (HOA) change.

RESULTS

The mean preoperative SE was -5.59 diopters (D) +/- 2.20 (SD) (range -1.00 to -9.50 D); the mean OZ diameter was 6.70 +/- 0.68 mm (range 5.6 to 8.1 mm). Reduction in almost all Zernike coefficients was influenced significantly by the preoperative amount of the individual coefficient. The effect varied among the coefficients and was lower with the 6.0 mm PD. With the 3.5 mm PD, age, SE, sphere, cylinder, and OZ diameter did not have a significant effect on individual Zernike coefficients. With the 6.0 mm PD, SE and OZ diameter had a significant effect on the induction of Z4(0); the OZ diameter also had an effect on the induction of coma root mean square.

CONCLUSIONS

Three groups of factors influenced the change in HOAs: The negative correlation with the magnitude of preoperative HOA values reflected the effect of the wavefront-guided algorithm. The SE and OZ diameter affected the inadvertent induction of spherical aberrations. Randomly acting effects such as decentration or flap creation, which were not included in the model, affected the induction of HOAs, particularly coma-like terms.

System performance evaluation of refractive surgical lasers: a mathematical approach

A study was conducted for the purpose of improving the designs of the next generation of refractive surgical laser systems. Two common refractive laser systems, variable-spot scanning (type A) and small-spot scanning (type B), are discussed by identifying sources of error that could adversely affect the capability of these lasers to accurately produce complex, customized wavefront guided ablations. A mathematical model was used to construct a laser simulator that models the two common laser systems in terms of the root-mean-square error. Error sources from ablation profile fitting, ablation registration, eye tracking, and the laser delivery system are compared, and the relative contribution of each to the overall system error is analyzed. This system-level analysis can be helpful to the improvement of both laser systems.

Aberrations induced in wavefront-guided laser refractive surgery due to shifts between natural and dilated pupil center locations

PURPOSE

To determine the aberrations induced in wavefront-guided laser refractive surgery due to shifts in pupil center location from when aberrations are measured preoperatively (over a dilated pupil) to when they are corrected surgically (over a natural pupil).

SETTING

Center for Visual Science and Department of Ophthalmology, University of Rochester, Rochester, New York, USA.

METHODS

Shifts in pupil center were measured between dilated phenylephrine hydrochloride (Neo-Synephrine [2.5%]) and nonpharmacological mesopic conditions in 65 myopic eyes treated with wavefront-guided laser in situ keratomileusis (Technolas 217z, Bausch & Lomb). Each patient's preoperative and 6-month postoperative wave aberrations were measured over the dilated pupil. Aberrations theoretically induced by decentration of a wavefront-guided ablation were calculated and compared with those measured 6 months postoperatively (6.0 mm pupil).

RESULTS

The mean magnitude of pupil center shift was 0.29 mm +/- 0.141 (SD) and usually occurred in the inferonasal direction as the pupil dilated. Depending on the magnitude of shift, the fraction of the higher-order postoperative root-mean-square wavefront error that could be due theoretically to pupil center decentrations was highly variable (mean 0.26 +/- 0.20 mm). There was little correlation between the calculated and 6-month postoperative wavefronts, most likely because pupil center decentrations are only 1 of several potential sources of postoperative aberrations.

CONCLUSIONS

Measuring aberrations over a Neo-Synephrine-dilated pupil and treating them over an undilated pupil typically resulted in a shift of the wavefront-guided ablation in the superotemporal direction and an induction of higher-order aberrations. Methods referencing the aberration measurement and treatment with respect to a fixed feature on the eye will reduce the potential for inducing aberrations due to shifts in pupil center.

Influence of pupil and optical zone diameter on higher-order aberrations after wavefront-guided myopic LASIK

PURPOSE

To investigate the influence of pupil and optical zone (OZ) diameter on higher-order aberrations (HOAs) after myopic wavefront-guided laser in situ keratomileusis (LASIK).

METHODS

Twenty-seven myopic eyes of 19 patients were included. The mean preoperative spherical equivalent was -6.86 diopters (D) +/- 1.24 (SD) (range -4.25 to -9.5 D); the mean planned OZ diameter was 6.26 +/- 0.45 mm (range 5.7 to 7.1 mm). All patients had uneventful wavefront-guided LASIK (Zyoptix version 3.1, Bausch & Lomb) and an uncomplicated follow-up of 12 months. Wavefront measurements were performed with a Hartmann-Shack sensor in maximum mydriasis preoperatively and 12 months after LASIK. Wavefront errors were computed for pupil diameters (PDs) of 3.0, 3.5, 4.0, 5.0, 6.0, and 7.0 mm for the individual OZ diameter and for the individual mydriatic PD (7.93 +/- 0.46 mm). The impact of the relationship between pupil diameter and OZ diameter (fractional clearance [FC]) on HOA was described and quantified using curvilinear regression with a 4th-order polynomial fit.

RESULTS

There was a reproducible relationship between FC and the amount of induced HOA. The change in HOA root mean square and primary spherical aberration (Z(4)0) was significantly correlated with FC. If the OZ was 16.5% larger than the pupil (FC = 1.17), only half the amount of HOA was expected to be induced than if the OZ equaled the pupil. In contrast, an OZ that was 9% smaller than the pupil (FC = 0.91) resulted in an HOA induction 50% higher than at FC = 1.

CONCLUSION

The OZ zone to pupil ratio (fractional clearance) had a significant impact on HOA induction after wavefront-guided LASIK.

Surgeon offsets and dynamic eye movements in laser refractive surgery

PURPOSE

To determine the amount of static and dynamic pupil decentrations that occur during laser refractive surgery.

SETTING

The Center of Visual Science and the Department of Ophthalmology, University of Rochester, Rochester, New York, USA.

METHODS

The surgeon's accuracy in aligning the pupil center with the laser center axis was measured when engaging the eye-tracker in 17 eyes receiving conventional laser in situ keratomileusis (LASIK) procedures (Technolas 217z; Bausch & Lomb). Eye movements were measured subsequently during the treatment in 10 eyes using a pupil camera operating at 50 Hz. Temporal power spectra were calculated from the eye movement measurements.

RESULTS

The mean pupil misalignment by the surgeon at the beginning of the procedure was 206.1 microm +/- 80.99 (SD) (with respect to the laser center). The laser center was typically misaligned below (inferiorly) and to the left (nasally and temporally in left and right eyes, respectively) of the pupil [corrected] center. Small amounts of cyclotorsion were observed during the ablation (<2 degrees). The mean magnitude of dynamic pupil decentration from the laser center during treatment was 227.0 +/- 44.07 microm. The mean standard deviation of eye movements was 65.7 +/- 25.64 microm. Temporal power spectra calculated from the horizontal and vertical changes in eye position during the ablation were similar. Ninety-five percent of the total power of the eye movements was contained in temporal frequencies up to 1 Hz, on average, in both directions.

CONCLUSIONS

Most eye movements during LASIK are slow drifts in fixation. An eye-tracker with a 1.4 Hz closed-loop bandwidth could compensate for most eye movements in conventional or customized ablations.

Influence of laser in situ keratomileusis and laser epithelial keratectomy on patients' reading performance

PURPOSE

To evaluate the influence of laser in situ keratomileusis (LASIK) and laser-assisted subepithelial keratectomy (LASEK) on reading performance regarding reading acuity, reading speed based on print size, maximum reading speed, and critical print size.

SETTING

Department of Ophthalmology, University of Vienna, Vienna, and Auge-und-Laser, Medicent Baden, Austria.

METHODS

Fifty-two eyes of 34 patients (26 eyes per group) were studied. Best corrected LogMAR visual acuity (Early Treatment Diabetic Retinopathy Study charts), reading acuity, and reading speed were tested monocularly before LASIK or LASEK and 3 weeks after surgery. Reading acuity (LogRAD) and reading speed were determined with the standardized Radner reading charts.

RESULTS

Preoperatively, the distance visual acuity and reading acuity were comparable between the LASIK and LASEK patients. Reading speed measurements also showed no statistical difference. Three weeks after refractive surgery, no statistically significant differences in the preoperative measures and between the 2 surgical procedures could be found in any tested parameters. The mean distance visual acuity was LogMAR -0.02 +/- 0.06 (SD) (LASIK) and LogMAR -0.05 +/- 0.07 (LASEK). The mean reading acuity was LogRAD 0.00 +/- 0.12 (97.7% of LogMAR) (LASIK) and LogRAD 0.04 +/- 0.16 (93.7% of LogMAR) (LASEK). The mean maximum reading speed was 235 +/- 35 words per minute (LASIK) and 240 +/- 37 words per minute (LASEK), and the mean critical print size was at LogRAD 0.48 +/- 0.19 (LASIK) and 0.49 +/- 0.17 (LASEK).

CONCLUSIONS

In a standardized reading test setting, no significant effects of LASIK and LASEK on individual reading performance could be evaluated. This indicates that patients can expect to retain their normal visual function after refractive surgery with these 2 procedures under full light conditions.

Comparison of Corneal Higher-Order Aberrations Induced by Myopic and Hyperopic LASIK

OBJECTIVE

To compare the change in anterior corneal higher-order (third- to fifth-order) aberrations (HOAs) induced by myopic and hyperopic LASIK.

DESIGN

Retrospective comparative case series.

PARTICIPANTS

One hundred eyes (50 myopes and 50 hyperopes) of 59 patients were included. The mean preoperative spherical equivalent (SE) was -4.22+/-1.78 diopters (D; range, -1.25 to -8.00 D) in the myopic group (group A) and +2.72+/-1.25 D (range, +0.25 to +5.00 D) in the hyperopic group (group B).

INTERVENTION

LASIK was performed using a conventional spherocylindrical laser algorithm (Planoscan V2.9992, Bausch & Lomb/Technolas, Munich, Germany). Optical zone diameter was 6.70+/-0.32 mm (range, 6-7 mm) in group A and 6.59+/-0.19 mm (range, 6.5 to 7 mm) in group B. Third to fifth corneal HOA were computed for a pupil diameter of 6 mm from corneal topographic examinations before and 1 month after surgery.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Change in corneal HOAs, derived from corneal topography.

RESULTS

Total HOA root mean square (RMS) changed in group A by 0.167+/-0.180 microm (factor 1.53) and in group B by 0.341+/-0.341 microm (factor 1.89). The mean induction of coma RMS was significantly different in both groups (myopes, 0.092+/-0.195 microm; hyperopes, 0.252+/-0.305 microm; P<0.05). For spherical aberration (Z 4,0), the myopic group showed a significant increase (0.130+/-0.120 microm; factor 1.6; P<0.001), whereas the hyperopic group showed a significant decrease (-0.317+/-0.158 microm; factor 0.76; P<0.001). Fifth-order aberrations showed an increase in both groups, which was higher in group B (0.069+/-0.120 microm; factor 2.46) than in group A (0.005+/-0.065 microm; factor 1.49).

CONCLUSIONS

Myopic and hyperopic LASIK had different patterns of HOA induction. Myopic LASIK induced positive spherical aberrations and positive secondary astigmatism, whereas hyperopic LASIK induced negative spherical aberrations and negative secondary astigmatism. Hyperopic LASIK induced more third- and fifth-order comalike aberrations than myopic LASIK.

Wavefront-guided LASIK With the NIDEK NAVEX Platform for the Correction of Myopia and Myopic Astigmatism With 6-month Follow-up

PURPOSE

To assess safety, efficacy, predictability, stability, and change in higher order aberrations after wavefront-guided LASIK for myopia and myopic astigmatism using the NIDEK NAVEX platform.

METHODS

Wavefront-guided LASIK was performed in 93 eyes in a 6-month trial with a goal of emmetropia. Treated eyes had a mean subjective manifest spherical equivalent refraction of -4.08+/-1.99 D diopters (D), with a range of -9.50 to -0.38 D of myopia and -4.50 to 0.00 D of astigmatism. An early nomogram with the OPDCAT software program provided by the manufacturer was used in all procedures. Safety, efficacy, predictability, stability, and change in higher order aberrations were evaluated at 6 months.

RESULTS

At 6 months, 100% eyes were within +/-1.0 D of emmetropia and 95% eyes were within +/-0.5 D. Uncorrected visual acuity (UCVA) of > or = 1.0 was achieved in 89% of eyes, and 38% of eyes achieved UVCA of > or = 1.2. No eyes lost > or = 2 lines of best spectacle-corrected visual acuity (BSCVA), 25% of eyes gained 1 line, 3% gained 2 lines, and 1% gained > or = 2 lines of BSCVA. Higher order root-mean-square (RMS) values increased by 19% on average between pre- and postoperative measurements. Eyes treated with higher order aberrations of < 0.3 RMS showed on average an increase of 40% on preoperative values, whereas eyes with significant aberrations showed a decrease in aberrations following wavefront treatment.

CONCLUSIONS

Wavefront-guided ablation using the NIDEK NAVEX platform is safe, effective, and predictable. However, patients with low amounts of aberrations showed an increase in aberrations following wavefront treatment, therefore, wavefront treatment may not be indicated or beneficial to every patient.

Comparison of NIDEK CATz Wavefront-guided LASIK to Traditional LASIK With the NIDEK CXII Excimer Laser in Myopia

PURPOSE

To compare the visual and refractive outcomes in myopic LASIK between wavefront-guided and traditional treatment.

METHODS

The study included 162 eyes of 81 myopic patients undergoing LASIK by one surgeon. The right eye of each patient underwent customized LASIK with the NIDEK NAVEX laser system (NIDEK, Gamagori, Japan) (study group); the left eye of each patient underwent traditional LASIK with the NIDEK CXII excimer laser system (control group).

RESULTS

No significant differences were noted in refractive error, uncorrected visual acuity, and best spectacle-corrected visual acuity after surgery between the two groups (t test, P>.05). Postoperatively, 3.7% of patients in the study group reported glare, which was significantly lower than 12.4% in the control group (chi-square test, .01<P<.05). Higher order aberrations increased after surgery in both groups, but less increase was noted in patients in the study group. A statistically significant reduction was noted in the postoperative increase of Zernike coefficients C7, C8, and C12 in the study group compared to the control group (t test, P<.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Customized LASIK significantly reduces the rate of postoperative glare and induction of higher order aberrations compared to traditional LASIK.

Wavefront-guided correction of ocular aberrations: are phase plate and refractive surgery solutions equal?

Wavefront-guided laser eye surgery has been recently introduced and holds the promise of correcting not only defocus and astigmatism in patients but also higher-order aberrations. Research is just beginning on the implementation of wavefront-guided methods in optical solutions, such as phase-plate-based spectacles, as alternatives to surgery. We investigate the theoretical differences between the implementation of wavefront-guided surgical and phase plate corrections. The residual aberrations of 43 model eyes are calculated after simulated refractive surgery and also after a phase plate is placed in front of the untreated eye. In each case, the current wavefront-guided paradigm that applies a direct map of the ocular aberrations to the correction zone is used. The simulation results demonstrate that an ablation map that is a Zernike fit of a direct transform of the ocular wavefront phase error is not as efficient in correcting refractive errors of sphere, cylinder, spherical aberration, and coma as when the same Zernike coefficients are applied to a phase plate, with statistically significant improvements from 2% to 6%.

Simulation of Eye-tracker Latency, Spot Size, and Ablation Pulse Depth on the Correction of Higher Order Wavefront Aberrations With Scanning Spot Laser Systems

PURPOSE

The aim of this theoretical work was to investigate the robustness of scanning spot laser treatments with different laser spot diameters and peak ablation depths in case of incomplete compensation of eye movements due to eye-tracker latency.

METHODS

Scanning spot corrections of 3rd to 5th Zernike order wavefront errors were numerically simulated. Measured eye-movement data were used to calculate the positioning error of each laser shot assuming eye-tracker latencies of 0, 5, 30, and 100 ms, and for the case of no eye tracking. The single spot ablation depth ranged from 0.25 to 1.0 microm and the spot diameter from 250 to 1000 microm. The quality of the ablation was rated by the postoperative surface variance and the Strehl intensity ratio, which was calculated after a low-pass filter was applied to simulate epithelial surface smoothing.

RESULTS

Treatments performed with nearly ideal eye tracking (latency approximately 0) provide the best results with a small laser spot (0.25 mm) and a small ablation depth (250 microm). However, combinations of a large spot diameter (1000 microm) and a small ablation depth per pulse (0.25 microm) yield the better results for latencies above a certain threshold to be determined specifically. Treatments performed with tracker latencies in the order of 100 ms yield similar results as treatments done completely without eye-movement compensation. CONCWSIONS: Reduction of spot diameter was shown to make the correction more susceptible to eye movement induced error. A smaller spot size is only beneficial when eye movement is neutralized with a tracking system with a latency <5 ms.

Wavefront-guided LASIK with the Zyoptix 3.1 system for the correction of myopia and compound myopic astigmatism with 1-year follow-up

OBJECTIVE

To assess safety, efficacy, predictability, stability, and change in aberrations after wavefront-guided LASIK for myopia and myopic astigmatism.

DESIGN

Prospective, nonrandomized, self-controlled trial.

PARTICIPANTS

Wavefront-guided LASIK was performed in 97 eyes in a 1-year trial. Treated eyes had a mean subjective manifest spherical equivalent (SE) of -5.22+/-2.07 diopters (D), with a range of -0.25 to -9.00 D of myopia and 0 to -3.25 D of astigmatism.

INTERVENTION

After a microkeratome cut, a wavefront-based excimer ablation (Zyoptix 3.1) was performed. The full treatment to achieve emmetropia of an early nomogram provided by the system manufacturer was used in all procedures.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Safety, efficacy, predictability, and stability were evaluated at 1, 3, and 12 months postoperatively. Wavefront changes of higher order aberrations (HOAs) at 1 year were determined for pupil sizes of 3.5 and 6 mm.

RESULTS

At 1 year postoperatively, uncorrected visual acuity (VA) was 20/20 or better in 83% of the eyes, and 20/40 or better in 98%. The mean subjective manifest SE at 1 year was -0.25+/-0.43 D; it was within 0.50 D in 77% and within 1.0 D in 95%. No eye lost > or =2 lines of best spectacle-corrected VA (BSCVA) at 1 year postoperatively; 40 eyes gained 1 line of BSCVA, and 5 eyes gained 2 lines. The total HOA root mean square (RMS) increased on average by a factor of 1.23+/-0.57 with a 3.5-mm pupil; for the 6 mm pupil, the increase factor was 1.52+/-0.36. No change or reduction in the total HOA RMS was observed in 45.5% of the eyes for a 3.5-mm pupil and in 20.6% for a 6-mm pupil. There was a significant increase of primary spherical aberration (Z 4,0) by a factor of 4.11+/-10.17 for 3.5-mm pupils and 4.31+/-6.76 for 6-mm pupils.

CONCLUSIONS

Wavefront-guided LASIK using Zyoptix 3.1 is an effective and safe procedure for the treatment of myopia and myopic astigmatism. Although in close to half of the eyes HOAs could be reduced, there was still undercorrection and induction of HOAs with the algorithm employed.

Pupil size and night vision disturbances after LASIK for myopia

PURPOSE

To examine whether standardized, preoperative evaluation of pupil sizes can predict the risk of night vision visual disturbances after bilateral laser in situ keratomileusis (LASIK) for myopia.

METHODS

A prospective study was carried out involving 46 patients who underwent bilateral LASIK for myopia. Pupil sizes were measured before surgery using an infrared pupillometer under standardized settings. Pre- and postoperative refraction and best spectacle-corrected visual acuity (BSCVA) were registered. At the 3-month follow-up visit, the patients completed a questionnaire regarding night vision pre- and postoperatively.

RESULTS

The mean bilateral, spherical equivalent refraction (SE) was - 8.76 D (range 6.32 to - 12.0 D) preoperatively, and - 1.69 D (range 0 to - 4.38 D) postoperatively. The mean bilateral BSCVA was not changed by the operations. We found a significant correlation between large scotopic pupil sizes and the impression of worsened night vision (p < 0.01). A significant correlation between gender (males) and subjectively reduced night vision postoperatively was also found (p < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

Large pupil size measured preoperatively is correlated with an increased frequency of subjectively experienced post-LASIK visual disturbances during scotopic conditions. We recommend preoperative evaluation of pupil size in all patients prior to LASIK surgery.

[Current state of wavefront guided corneal surgery to correct refraction disorders]

The present review describes the current status of wavefront-guided corneal surgery and up-to-date results. Wavefront-guided LASIK procedures performed to date achieved uncorrected vision of i.o or better in a larger number of patients than with conventional LASIK surgery, but the "eagle eye" has remained the exception. In part of the patients reductions of higher order aberrations could be obtained, but in the majority of ca-ses an increase was observed. This increase was however less than with conventional LASIK surgery. Correction of higher order aberrations has not yet been perfected since the predictability of corrections appears to be deserving of improvement on the one hand and aberrations are still induced by the technique on the other hand.

Patient Motivation for Laser in situ Keratomileusis in the State of Bihar

PURPOSE

To evaluate the main reasons for seeking laser in situ keratomileusis (LASIK) and patient satisfaction after surgery in the socioeconomically underdeveloped eastern state of Bihar, India.

METHODS

This retrospective study evaluated results of the first 100 consecutive patients (169 eyes) who had LASIK at our center from July 2002 to September 2003.

RESULTS

Of the 100 patients, 65% were male and 35% were female. Ninety percent of male patients were between 18 and 24 years old; they sought LASIK to achieve an uncorrected visual acuity of 6/6 to 6/9-the basic qualifying criterion for jobs in the railway and defense services. Eighty-six percent of female patients were of marrying age. At 1 month after LASIK, 93% of patients achieved an UCVA of 6/6, 4% had UCVA between 6/9 to 6/12, and only 1% had <6/60.

CONCLUSION

In the socioeconomically poor state of Bihar, the main reason for males in our study to seek LASIK was to enhance their job prospects. In females, the main reason was to improve facial appearance in order to enhance marriage prospects.

Alignment in Customized Laser in situ Keratomileusis

PURPOSE

To identify fundamentals of beam alignment in customized laser in situ keratomileusis (LASIK) with a special focus on the Nidek NAVEX system.

METHODS

Analysis of Nidek specifications and recommendations for beam alignment with regard to a critical case example are presented. The potential impact of misalignment (tilt and defocus) is calculated. Cyclotorsional error evaluation in a normal LASIK population was performed by video image comparison. Potential problems of infrared-based eyetracking systems are discussed.

RESULTS

The laser beam should be aligned with reference to the line of sight (LOS) when customized segmental laser ablation is applied. Only in cases with significant offset between the LOS and the visual axis it is recommended not to use segmental ablation and to manually align the beam toward the visual axis. Eye drift (tilt) as well as defocus should be avoided since undercorrection and irregular astigmatism can result. Almost 30% of eyes in a normal LASIK population showed a torsional error of 5 degrees to 10 degrees (9% more than 10 degrees) on video-based image comparison. Eye-trackers not only are defined by take-up speed and latency, but also by their sensibility (picking the real center of the pupil) and robustness (keeping it tracked during surgery). Errors due to parallax and reflex effects can systematically influence the performance of an eyetracker.

CONCLUSION

Correct alignment is difficult to achieve but is of fundamental importance in customized LASIK. Strict standardization and further improvement in the alignment strategy is necessary to achieve more consistent results in customized LASIK.

The effect of corneal flap on optical aberrations

PURPOSE

To evaluate the changes in ocular aberrations induced by corneal flap creation.

DESIGN

Prospective interventional nonrandomized clinical trial.

METHODS

This study included 15 patients who were scheduled for laser in situ keratomileusis. A nasal hinge flap was created, using the Nidek MK-2000 microkeratome and then replaced without performing laser ablation. The ocular aberrations were measured before and after flap creation using the Nidek Optical Path Difference Scanning System ARK-10000.

RESULTS

The root mean square wavefront errors of the higher-order optical aberrations (third-, fourth-, fifth-, and sixth-order aberrations) were not significantly altered at 1 week postsurgery compared with the preoperative values (P >.35).

CONCLUSIONS

Creating a corneal flap with the Nidek MK-2000 microkeratome did not induce changes in higher-order optical aberrations as measured with the Nidek Optical Path Difference Scanning System ARK-10000 during the early postoperative period.

Quality of vision and patient satisfaction after LASIK

PURPOSE

The purpose of this article is to review the literature and find characteristics that lead to improved patient satisfaction and better quality of vision.

RECENT FINDINGS

Flatter preoperative corneal curvature is a risk factor for starbursts after laser-assisted in situ keratomileusis (LASIK). Pupil size has not been found to be correlated with night vision symptoms. Wavefront-guided ablations reduce higher-order aberrations in comparison with traditional LASIK. Night vision symptoms are correlated with younger age, greater correction/increased ablation depth, enhancement, and decreased ablation diameter. Contrast sensitivity has been found to initially decrease after LASIK, returning to baseline 6 to 12 months postoperatively.

SUMMARY

LASIK has quickly become the refractive procedure of choice around the world. Quality of vision and patient satisfaction after LASIK can be difficult to assess because of the many variables that must be considered to accurately measure these endpoints. Preoperative characteristics such as: increased patient age, decreased corneal toricity, or increased pupil size reduce patient satisfaction. Intraoperative factors like decentration, ablation-zone size, active eye tracking, and wavefront guided ablations affect quality of vision. Finally, postoperative factors such as night vision symptoms, reduced contrast sensitivity, and re-treatment can lead to a decline in patient satisfaction. Eliminating or limiting these variables may lead to increased patient satisfaction and higher quality of vision after LASIK.

Glare sensitivity and optical side effects 1 year after photorefractive keratectomy and laser in situ keratomileusis

PURPOSE

To compare the outcome of low-contrast visual acuity and glare sensitivity after photorefractive keratectomy (PRK) and laser in situ keratomileusis (LASIK).

SETTING

Department of Ophthalmology, Cantonal Hospital of Lucerne, Lucerne, Switzerland.

METHODS

In this prospective study, patients selected PRK or LASIK after the advantages and disadvantages of both had been described. Snellen visual acuity and disability glare were measured with the Berkeley glare test preoperatively and 1 year postoperatively. At the 1-year follow-up, haze was graded and patients had to assess their quality of vision subjectively.

RESULTS

One-year follow-up of 58 patients in the PRK group and 64 patients in the LASIK group was achieved. In both groups, the mean uncorrected visual acuity was 20/32 (P =.63) and the mean best corrected visual acuity, 20/20 with no statistically significant difference (P =.20). There were no preoperative or postoperative differences between the 2 groups in low-contrast visual acuity under 4 glare conditions. At 1 year, LASIK eyes had significantly lower postoperative haze scores than PRK eyes (P =.0013). The number of eyes with visually moderate and disturbing halos or disturbances in night vision did not differ considerably between the groups (P =.88).

CONCLUSIONS

Efficacy outcomes were generally similar in the PRK and LASIK groups. Both achieved good objective and subjective results after treatment with a second-generation excimer laser.

Laser in situ keratomileusis for myopia and the contrast sensitivity function

PURPOSE

To characterize the clinical effects of laser in situ keratomileusis (LASIK) on the cornea and visual performance by the contrast sensitivity function (CSF).

SETTING

Clinique d'Ophtalmologie IRIS, Laval, Quebec, Canada.

METHODS

Thirty-four patients aged 18 to 50 years volunteered for this prospective study. All patients had bilateral LASIK to correct myopia between -1.00 and -6.75 diopters (D) and refractive astigmatism less than 2.50 D. The mean spherical equivalent (SE) refractive error in the 68 eyes was -3.93 D +/- 1.67 (SD). A Hansatome microkeratome (Bausch & Lomb) and a Technolas 217C excimer laser (Bausch & Lomb) driven by the PlanoScan program were used. The monocular CSF for spatial frequencies of 3, 6, 12, and 18 cycles per degree (cpd) for both day and night vision simulations were made with a CSV-1000E system (Vector Vision) before and 1 month and up to 9 months after LASIK. All patients wore their best spectacle correction for the baseline CSF.

RESULTS

The group (n = 68) averaged preoperative and postoperative CSFs did not differ at 1 month (analysis of variance [ANOVA], P>.05). In a subgroup of 11 eyes that had corneal microstriae, however, there was a significant reduction in the photopic and mesopic CSF at 6, 12, and 18 cpd (ANOVA, P<.05) despite normal Snellen visual acuities. The CSF normalized in 6 to 9 months as the microstriae became less visible.

CONCLUSIONS

Subtle central corneal microstriae after LASIK can reduce the baseline CSF at medium to high spatial frequencies even with 20/20 visual acuity. The CSF normalizes as the microstriae fade over time.

Wavefront Aberrations Following Laser in situ Keratomileusis and Refractive Lens Exchange for Hypermetropia

PURPOSE

To compare the magnitude of aberrations in eyes after elective hypermetropic laser in situ keratomileusis (LASIK) and refractive lens exchange (clear lens replacement).

METHODS

Forty-nine patients (92 eyes) had hypermetropic LASIK and 28 (48 eyes) had refractive lens exchange; 23 hypermetropic subjects (41 eyes) were the control group. LASIK was performed with the Nidek EC-5000 excimer laser; ablation zones 5.5 to 6.0-mm in diameter with transition zones 7.5 to 8-mm in diameter. For refractive lens exchange, all but four IOLs were made of foldable acrylic. Aberrations and corneal topography were measured with the Nidek OPD-Scan model ARK-10000 more than 12 months after surgery. The higher-order root-mean-square (HORMS) wave aberrations for combined third to sixth Zernike aberration orders and the Zernike spherical aberration coefficient C(0)(4) at both 4.2-mm and 6.0-mm pupil sizes were calculated.

RESULTS

For the LASIK group, surgical refractive change correlated significantly with total, corneal, and internal HORMS and spherical aberrations (except with internal spherical aberration for a 4.2-mm diameter pupil). For the refractive lens exchange group, there were no significant correlations of surgical refractive change with any of these factors. Similarly, there were no significant correlations of refraction with any of these factors for the control group. For a 3-diopter change in refraction with 6-mm pupils, LASIK doubled the total HORMS aberrations. LASIK changed the sign of spherical aberration from positive to negative by increasing the negative asphericity of the anterior cornea. Taking age differences between groups into account, refractive lens exchange increased the total HORMS aberrations by 40% compared with that of the control group, but this was not statistically significant. However, refractive lens exchange significantly increased total spherical aberration.

CONCLUSION

Refractive lens exchange was a better refractive procedure than LASIK for minimizing total higher order optical aberrations that accompany hypermetropic refractive surgery.

Age-related changes in corneal and ocular higher-order wavefront aberrations

PURPOSE

To investigate age-related changes in ocular and corneal higher-order wavefront aberrations and elucidate relative contributions of the cornea and the lens in the age-related changes.

DESIGN

Observational case series.

METHODS

Corneal and ocular higher-order wavefront aberrations in the central 6 mm diameter were measured with videokeratography and the Hartmann-Shack wavefront aberrometer in 75 normal eyes of 75 patients with a mean age of 43.5 +/- 11.7 years (range, 18-69 years). Higher-order wavefront aberrations were calculated with Zernike polynomials up to sixth order. From the Zernike coefficients, we calculated root mean square (RMS) of coma and spherical aberration. To examine age-related changes of the polarity of spherical aberration, the changes of the Zernike coefficient Z(4)(0) was also investigated.

RESULTS

Both corneal (r =.307, P =.007) and ocular (r =.334, P =.0033) coma RMS showed positive correlations with age. There was a positive correlation between corneal and ocular coma RMS (r =.468, P <.0001). The RMS of corneal spherical aberration did not change with aging (r =.153, P =.1895), whereas the RMS of ocular spherical aberration had a positive correlation with aging (r =.308, P =.0068).

CONCLUSIONS

These results suggest that the ocular coma increases with age, mainly because of the increase in the corneal coma, and the ocular spherical aberration increases with age, mainly because of the increase in the spherical aberration in the internal optics.

The usefulness of Vistech and FACT contrast sensitivity charts for cataract and refractive surgery outcomes research

AIM

To investigate the repeatability and sensitivity of two commonly used sine wave patch charts for contrast sensitivity (CS) measurement in cataract and refractive surgery outcomes.

METHODS

The Vistech CS chart and its descendant, the Functional Acuity Contrast Test (FACT), were administered in three experiments: (1) Post-LASIK and age matched normal subjects; (2) Preoperative cataract surgery and age matched normal subjects; (3) Test-retest repeatability data in normal subjects.

RESULTS

Contrast sensitivity was similar between post-LASIK and control groups and between the Vistech and FACT charts. The percentage of subjects one month post-LASIK achieving the maximum score across spatial frequencies (1.5, 3, 6, 12, 18 cycles per degree) were (50, 33, 13, 13, 0 respectively) for FACT, but only (0, 0, 13, 4, 0 respectively) for Vistech. A small number of cataract patients also registered the maximum score on the FACT, but up to 60% did not achieve the minimum score. Test-retest intraclass correlation coefficients varied from 0.28 to 0.64 for Vistech and 0.18 to 0.45 for FACT. Bland-Altman limits of agreement across spatial frequencies were between +/-0.30 and +/-0.85 logCS for Vistech, and +/-0.30 to +/-0.75 logCS for FACT.

DISCUSSION

The Vistech was confirmed as providing poorly repeatable data. The FACT chart, likely because of a smaller step size, showed slightly better retest agreement. However, the reduced range of scores on the chart due to the smaller step size led to ceiling (post-LASIK) and floor (cataract) effects. These problems could mask subtle differences between groups of patients with near normal visual function as found post-refractive or cataract surgery. The Vistech and FACT CS charts are ill suited for refractive or cataract surgery outcomes research.

Wavefront-guided Laser in situ Keratomileusis With the Bausch & Lomb Zyoptix System

PURPOSE

To evaluate the clinical results of wavefront-guided laser in situ keratomileusis (LASIK) with the Zyoptix system.

METHODS

Twelve patients (24 eyes) underwent wavefront-guided LASIK with the Bausch & Lomb Zyoptix system. Uncorrected and best spectacle-corrected visual acuity and manifest refraction were measured at postoperative day 1, week 1, and months 1 and 3. A subjective vision quality questionnaire evaluated light sensitivity, dryness, tearing, glare, halos, ghost images, and difficulties in night driving, preoperatively and 3 months postoperatively.

RESULTS

Preoperatively, mean sphere was -3.70 +/- 2.33 D (range -0.50 to -8.00 D), mean cylinder was -0.90 +/- 0.98 D (range 0 to -3.00 D), and mean spherical equivalent refraction was -4.15 +/- 2.16 D (range -1.38 to -8.25 D). Three-month postoperative spherical equivalent refraction was within +/- 0.50 D of emmetropia in 17 eyes (70.8%) and within +/- 1.00 D in 22 eyes (91.7%). At 3 months postoperatively, no eyes lost any lines of BSCVA and eight eyes (33.3%) gained 2 lines. The ratio of postoperative BSCVA to preoperative BSCVA (safety) was 1.05 +/- 0.09 (range 1.00 to 1.20) at 1 month and 1.07 +/- 0.10 (range 1.00 to 1.29) at 3 months. The ratio of postoperative UCVA to preoperative BSCVA (efficacy) was 0.96 +/- 0.12 (range 0.80 to 1.20) at 1 month and 0.95 +/- 0.12 (range 0.8 to 1.2) at 3 months. The subjective vision quality questionnaire revealed less tearing, fewer halos, and less difficulty in night driving after wavefront-guided LASIK. Comparison of higher order optical aberrations before and after surgery was not done.

CONCLUSIONS

Wavefront-guided LASIK with the Bausch & Lomb Zyoptix system was safe and effective in correcting low to moderate myopic refractive error.

Maximum permissible torsional misalignment in aberration-sensing and wavefront-guided corneal ablation

PURPOSE

To determine the maximum permissible torsional misalignment in wavefront-guided refractive surgery.

SETTING

University of Zurich, Department of Ophthalmology, Zurich, Switzerland.

METHODS

The effect of torsionally misaligned ablations on the optical outcome was simulated using measured wavefront aberration patterns (2nd to 6th orders) in 130 normally aberrated eyes. The calculations were done for 3.0 mm, 5.0 mm, and 7.0 mm pupils. The optical quality of the simulated correction was rated by the root-mean-square residual wavefront error.

RESULTS

The required accuracy of torsional alignment is higher for the correction of higher-order aberrations than for cylindrical treatments only. To improve the optical performance to the level of the best 10% of a normal, untreated population, ablation would have to occur within a tolerance range of 4.0 degrees for 7.0 mm pupils.

CONCLUSIONS

The tolerance range for torisional alignment in wavefront-guided higher-order corrections depends on the amount of original optical error in each eye. Rough centration based on the surgeon's judgment may not be accurate enough to achieve significantly improved optical quality in a high percentage of treated eyes.

In vivo and in vitro repeatability of Hartmann-Shack aberrometry

PURPOSE

To assess the in vivo and in vitro repeatability of objective refraction and higher-order aberrations (HOAs) measured by a commercially available Hartmann-Shack wavefront sensor.

SETTING

Department of Ophthalmology, Johann-Wolfgang-Goethe University, Frankfurt am Main, Germany.

METHODS

After pupil dilation of 40 myopic or myopic, astigmatic eyes of 20 patients, wavefront measurements were performed 6 times in each eye and in a test object provided by the manufacturer by 2 experienced examiners using a Hartmann-Shack wavefront sensor (Zywave, software version 3.21, Bausch & Lomb). The mean standard deviation (SD) and the coefficient of variation (CV) for sphere, cylinder, and each Zernike polynomial were computed for a 7.0 mm pupil diameter. Vector analysis was performed for the astigmatism. After the data were subdivided into 2 groups with 3 measurements in each, one measurement that best matched the subjective manifest refraction was chosen in each group and the difference between them was calculated.

RESULTS

The mean SD (CV) was 0.15 diopter (D) (7%) for the sphere value of the predicted phoropter refraction and 0.16 D (22%) for astigmatism. Thirty-two eyes had an axis deviation of at least 10 degrees. Vector analysis revealed a mean SD of 0.24@109.8. Other results for mean SD and mean CV were as follows: total in vivo higher-order RMS, 0.097 microm, 13.4%; sphere in myopic test device, 0.034 D, 0.65%; sphere in hyperopic test object, 0.035 D, 0.72%. The difference between the 2 best-matched refractions was significantly different from zero (0.11 D, P<.001). The CV was significantly higher for HOAs than for the 2nd-order aberrations (defocus and astigmatism).

CONCLUSIONS

Repeatability of Hartmann-Shack aberrometry by the Zywave wavefront sensor was not satisfactory, particularly for small amounts of HOAs. Under these conditions, aberrometry measurements should be repeated several times and outliers should be excluded in calculating the means.

Effect of methods of myopia correction on visual acuity, contrast sensitivity, and depth of focus

PURPOSE

To psychophysically measure spherical and irregular aberrations in patients with various types of myopia correction.

SETTING

Laboratory of Experimental Ophthalmology, University of Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands.

METHODS

Three groups of patients with low myopia correction (spectacles, soft contact lens, and Intacs) and 4 groups with high myopia correction (spectacles, rigid contact lens, Artisan claw lens, and laser in situ keratomileusis [LASIK]) had through-focus contrast sensitivity measurements to establish the myopic shift and depth of focus. From these 2 parameters, spherical and irregular aberrations were determined using theoretical eye models and geometric optics. Visual acuity, stray light, and predictability were also studied.

RESULTS

There were no differences in best corrected visual acuity (BCVA) or best corrected contrast sensitivity between the low myopia groups. The Intacs group had a significantly larger depth of focus (P<.05). The results in the soft contact lens group were comparable to those in a human eye model with an average amount of spherical and irregular aberrations. The LASIK group had worse uncorrected visual acuity (UCVA) and best corrected contrast sensitivity than the spectacles, rigid contact lens, and Artisan claw lens groups (P<.05) due to the amount of spherical and irregular aberrations present after LASIK. The low and high myopia spectacles groups had average amounts of spherical and irregular aberrations.

CONCLUSIONS

Neither surgical techniques nor contact lenses resulted in BCVA or best corrected contrast sensitivity that surpassed the values measured in the best corrected spectacles groups. The Artisan claw lens performed better than LASIK in UCVA, predictability, and best corrected contrast sensitivity.

Estimating Visual Quality from Wavefront Aberration Measurements

PURPOSE

Root mean square (RMS) wavefront error may not be the best metric for predicting a patient's visual function; other metrics should be considered. We describe the most important metrics of optical quality, which are being investigated to predict vision quality and visual performance.

METHODS

Optical quality can be described in two different ways. Pupil plane metrics describe variability of the wavefront error at the pupillary plane (eg, RMS wavefront error). Image plane metrics describe the retinal image and do so for either a point source of light (eg, point-spread function [PSF]) or sinusoidal gratings (optical transfer function [OTF]). Visual quality metrics, however, must also consider neural processing and subjective perception.

RESULTS

Since vision is more sensitive to rays coming from the center of the pupil, "pupil fraction" appears to be a better predictor of visual acuity (r2 = 0.50) than RMS error (r2 = 0.13). However, image plane metrics, such as the visual Strehl ratio (r2 = 0.62) and the volume between the optical transfer function and neural contrast sensitivity function (r2 = 0.80) appear to be even better.

CONCLUSION

Visual perception is highly subjective and involves many aspects of image quality. A single metric to describe all aspects of image quality may be unrealistic. Nevertheless, improved visual quality metrics need further investigation and will likely involve preferential weighing of light passing through the central area of the pupil and/or incorporating neural factors into image quality computation.

Clinical outcomes of wavefront-guided laser in situ keratomileusis: 6-month follow-up

PURPOSE

To evaluate the clinical outcomes 6 months after wavefront-guided laser in situ keratomileusis (LASIK) for myopia in Japan.

SETTING

Department of Ophthalmology, Sanno Hospital, Tokyo, Japan.

METHODS

This prospective study comprised 22 eyes of 12 patients treated with wavefront-guided LASIK who were available for evaluation at 6 months. The mean patient age was 31.2 years +/- 8.4 (SD) (range 23 to 50 years), and the mean preoperative spherical equivalent refraction was -7.30 +/- 2.72 diopters (D) (range -2.75 to -11.88 D). In all cases, preoperative wavefront analysis was performed with a Hartmann-Shack aberrometer and the Technolas 217z flying-spot excimer laser system (Bausch & Lomb) was used with 1.0 mm and 2.0 mm spot sizes and an active eye tracker with a 120 Hz tracking rate. The clinical outcomes of wavefront-guided LASIK were evaluated in terms of safety, efficacy, predictability, stability, complications, and preoperative and postoperative aberrations.

RESULTS

At 6 months, 10 eyes had no change in best spectacle-correct visual acuity and 10 gained 1 or more lines. The safety index was 1.11 and the efficacy index, 0.82. Slight undercorrections were observed in highly myopic eyes. In all eyes, the postoperative refraction tended slightly toward myopia for 3 months and stabilized after that. No complication such as epithelial ingrowth, diffuse lamellar keratitis, or infection was observed. Comparison of the preoperative and postoperative aberrations showed that 2nd-order aberrations decreased and higher-order aberrations increased. In the 3rd order, aberrations increased in the high-myopia group (-6.0 D or worse) and decreased in the low to moderate-myopia group (better than -6.0 D).

CONCLUSION

Wavefront-guided LASIK was a good option for refractive surgery, although a longer follow-up in a larger study is required.

Interaction between aberrations to improve or reduce visual performance

PURPOSE

To investigate how pairs of Zernike modes interact to increase or decrease visual acuity.

SETTING

Visual Optics Institute, College of Optometry, University of Houston, Houston, Texas, USA.

METHODS

Subjects read aberrated and unaberrated visual acuity charts 3 times. Each aberrated chart was produced by convolving an aberrated point-spread function with an unaberrated acuity chart. Point-spread functions were defined by 4 pairs of Zernike modes. For each pair, 9 combinations were used, ranging from all aberration being loaded into the first mode to all aberration being loaded into the second mode. The root mean square (RMS) wavefront error always totaled 0.25 microm (6.0 mm pupil), a level similar to the aberration induced by traditional flying small-spot laser refractive surgeries.

RESULTS

For all conditions (except the unaberrated charts), visual acuity decreased. Acuity varied significantly depending on which modes were mixed and the relative contribution of each mode. Modes 2 radial orders apart and having the same sign and angular frequency tended to combine to increase visual acuity. Modes within the same radial order tended to combine to decrease acuity.

CONCLUSIONS

For low levels of aberration, the RMS wavefront error is not a good predictor of visual acuity. Clinically, it is important to define how aberrations interact to optimize visual performance. New metrics of optical/neural performance that correlate better with clinical measures of visual performance need to be adopted or developed, as well as new clinically viable measures of visual performance that are sensitive to subtle changes in optical performance.

Separate effects of the microkeratome incision and laser ablation on the eye's wave aberration

PURPOSE

To study the optical changes induced by the microkeratome cut, the subsequent laser ablation, and the biomechanical healing response of the cornea in normal laser in situ keratomileusis (LASIK) eyes.

DESIGN

Prospective randomized clinical trial.

METHODS

A Hansatome microkeratome was used to cut a corneal flap in one eye (study eye) of 17 normal myopic patients and a subsequent laser ablation was performed 2 months after this initial microkeratome incision. Control eyes received conventional LASIK treatments at the latter time point. The wave aberration of both the study and contralateral control eyes were measured over a 6-mm pupil with a Shack-Hartmann wavefront sensor for all preoperative, postflap cut, and postablation visits.

RESULTS

The eye's higher order aberrations had a small, but significant increase (P =.03) of approximately 30% 2 months after cutting a flap. No systematic changes were observed in nearly all Zernike coefficients from their preoperative levels at 2 months postflap cut. A significant difference between the study and control eyes was observed for one trefoil mode, Z(3)(3) (P =.04).

CONCLUSIONS

There was a wide variation in the response of individual Zernike modes across patients after cutting a flap. The majority of spherical aberration induced by the LASIK procedure seems to be due to the laser ablation and not the microkeratome cut. In addition, the total and higher order root mean square of wavefront errors were nearly identical for both the study and control eyes 3-months after the laser ablation, indicating that a procedure in which the incision and the ablation are separated in time to better control aberrations does not compromise the outcome of a conventional LASIK treatment.

Wavefront-supported Photorefractive Keratectomy: 12-month Follow-up

PURPOSE

To evaluate safety, efficacy, predictability, and stability of wavefront-supported photorefractive keratectomy (PRK) for correction of myopia and myopic astigmatism, with 12-month follow-up.

METHODS

Thirty eyes of 23 patients with myopia less than -8.00 D (mean -3.76 +/- 1.90 D) and cylinder less than -3.50 D (mean -0.81 +/- 0.71 D) were selected. Aberrometry measurements were taken with the Asclepion aberrometer in order to perform customized wavefront-supported PRK. Eyes were treated with the Asclepion MEL 70 excimer laser and were followed for 12 months.

RESULTS

UCVA of 20/16 or better was achieved by 47% (14 eyes) at 1 month, 67% (20 eyes) at 3 months, 77% (23 eyes) at 6 months, 90% (27 eyes) at 9 months, and 83% (25 eyes) after 1 year. No eye lost more than 1 line of BSCVA at 3, 6, 9, or 12 months. Two eyes (7%) gained more than 2 lines 1 month postoperatively, and 13% (4 eyes) gained more than 2 lines at 6, 9, and 12 months postoperatively. BSCVA of 20/10 or better was achieved in nine eyes (30%) at 1 and 12 months. Visual acuity under low contrast at 3 and 12 months after PRK was unchanged in 87% (26 eyes). Visual acuity under glare remained unchanged at 3 months after PRK in 86% (26 eyes) and at 12 months in 83% (25 eyes).

CONCLUSION

Excimer laser wavefront-supported PRK with the Asclepion MEL 70 laser was safe and effective for the treatment of myopia and myopic astigmatism. Daylight visual acuity and mesopic visual acuity outcomes remained stable over 1 year.

Higher Order Ocular Aberrations After Cycloplegic and Non-cycloplegic Pupil Dilation

PURPOSE

Clinical aberrometry is commonly undertaken with the use of mydriatic agents, however there is no literature available on whether aberrometry results obtained under cycloplegia differ from those obtained without cycloplegia.

METHODS

Higher order aberrations were measured over a 6-mm pupil with a Bausch and Lomb Technolas Zywave Aberrometer on the right eyes of 31 young subjects (average age 19.7 +/- 1.7 years; 5 females, 16 males). Two measurement conditions were used for each subject: 1) topical installation of 3 drops 1% cyclopentolate hydrochloride; and 2) topical installation of 1 drop 2.5% phenylephrine hydrochloride, prior to aberrometry measurements.

RESULTS

For higher order aberrations (3rd to 5th order), average root mean square (RMS) after phenylephrine measurement (0.3852 microm) was significantly lower than after cyclopentolate (0.4259 microm). A small but statistically significant difference was found between the two conditions for average vertical and horizontal coma and, to a lesser extent, horizontal 5th order aberrations. Repeatability RMS, a measure of test-retest measurement repeatability, was similar for the two conditions at 0.15 microm, and significantly lower than the average RMS for the difference between the two conditions (residual RMS) of 0.22 microm.

CONCLUSIONS

The difference between cycloplegic and non-cycloplegic aberration measurements has implications for surgical correction of higher order aberrations.

Changes of Higher Order Aberration With Various Pupil Sizes in the Myopic Eye

PURPOSE

To investigate the effect of pupil diameter on higher order aberration in myopic eyes.

METHODS

One hundred and two eyes of 51 normal subjects were evaluated with the Nidek OPD-Scan.

RESULTS

All types of aberration increased significantly with increasing pupil size (P<.001). However, optical aberrations had a less pronounced increase in C3(-1) and C3(+1) , more pronounced increase in C4(0) with pupil area increased (P<.05), 2nd coma (C5(-1) and C6(+1)) and high order astigmatism (C4(-2), C4(+2) C6(-2), C6(+2) with larger pupil diameter. Compared with the aberrations of each high order aberration at 4 mm, the average increase root mean square values were 1.54, 1.59, 1.71, and 1.87 on S3, S4, S5, and S6 respectively, with a 5-mm pupil, whereas increased root mean square values were 1.46, 1.88, 1.51, and 1.60 for a 6-mm-diameter pupil.

CONCLUSION

For an equal increase of pupil size, not all Zernike polynomial coefficients induced equivalent increase of values. Coma-like aberrations increased less with pupil dilation. Spherical-like aberration showed only a small increase from 4 mm to 5 mm pupil size, but a larger increase from 5 mm to 6 mm pupil size. Other higher order aberrations (S5 and S6) increased slightly with pupil dilation. Coma-like aberration was larger than spherical aberration, and larger than other higher order aberrations for all pupil sizes.

Simplified mathematics for customized refractive surgery

PURPOSE

To describe a simple mathematical approach to customized corneal refractive surgery or customized intraocular lens (IOL) design that allows "hypervision" and to investigate the accuracy limits.

SETTING

University eye hospital, Mainz, Germany.

METHODS

Corneal shape and at least 1 IOL surface are approximated by the well-known Cartesian conic section curves (ellipsoid, paraboloid, or hyperboloid). They are characterized by only 2 parameters, the vertex radius and the numerical eccentricity. Residual refraction errors for this approximation are calculated by numerical ray tracing. These errors can be displayed as a 2-dimensional refraction map across the pupil or by blurring the image of a Landolt ring superimposed on the retinal receptor grid, giving an overall impression of the visual outcome.

RESULTS

If the eye is made emmetropic for paraxial rays and if the numerical eccentricities of the cornea and lens are appropriately fitted to each other, the residual refractive errors are small enough to allow hypervision. Visual acuity of at least 2.0 (20/10) appears to be possible, particularly for mesopic pupil diameters. However, customized optics may have limited application due to their sensitivity to misalignment errors such as decentrations or rotations.

CONCLUSIONS

The mathematical approach described by Descartes 350 years ago is adequate to calculate hypervision optics for the human eye. The availability of suitable mathematical tools should, however, not be viewed with too much optimism as long as the accuracy of the implementation in surgical procedures is limited.

Corneal model

PURPOSE

To describe the optical region of the cornea with as few parameters as possible and to compare this approach to commonly used mathematical models for the cornea.

SETTING

University eye hospital, Mainz, Germany.

METHODS

Corneal surface is approximated by a simple model (SM) that is defined by 2 perpendicular vertex radii, their angle to the horizontal, and a unique numerical eccentricity. These parameters, together with a parameter quantifying the decentration of the recording, are obtained in a consistent fit of corneal topographic data. The SM is compared to Zernike polynomial approximations of the 4th (Z4 model) and 8th (Z8 model) radial orders. Residual refraction errors for these approximations are calculated by numerical ray tracing, allowing a comparison of the different approaches. The statistical evaluation was carried out in 100 healthy eyes.

RESULTS

The model approximation accuracy for the SM was at least as high as the reproducibility of the topographic measurements. For small optical zones up to 4.0 mm in diameter, the SM was on average more accurate than the Z4 model.

CONCLUSIONS

The parameters of the SM, which are closely related to conventional parameters of the cornea, provided a highly accurate basis for following refractive interventions (customized corneal or cataract surgery). Zernike polynomials tend to improve peripheral optical quality at the expense of the central quality. Except in cases of technical optics, this is an unwanted effect in the human eye.

Correlation Between Corneal and Total Wavefront Aberrations in Myopic Eyes

PURPOSE

Corneal topography data expressed as corneal aberrations are frequently used to report corneal laser surgery results. However, the optical image quality depends on all optical elements of the eye, including the human lens. We investigated correlations between corneal and total wavefront aberrations and the relevance of corneal aberrations for representing the optical quality of the total eye.

METHODS

Thirty-three eyes of 22 myopic patients were measured using a corneal topography system and a Tscherning-type wavefront analyzer. Pupils were dilated to at least 6 mm in diameter. All measurements were centered with respect to the line of sight. Corneal and total wavefront aberrations were calculated up to the 6th Zernike order in the same reference plane.

RESULTS

Statistically significant correlations (P<.05) between corneal and total wavefront aberrations were found for astigmatism (C3,C5) and all 3rd Zernike order coefficients such as coma (C7,C8). No statistically significant correlations were found for 4th, 5th, or 6th order Zernike coefficients. On average, all Zernike coefficients for corneal aberrations were larger than the Zernike coefficients for total wavefront aberrations.

CONCLUSIONS

Due to the lack of correlation between corneal and total wavefront aberrations in most of the higher order aberrations, measurement of corneal aberrations are of limited use for representation of the optical quality of the human eye, especially after corneal laser surgery. Corneal aberrations and optical elements within the eye are optically balanced. As a consequence, ideal customized ablations must take both corneal and total wavefront aberrations into consideration.

Mathematical model of corneal surface smoothing after laser refractive surgery

PURPOSE

To construct a quantitative model of corneal surface smoothing after laser ablation for refractive correction.

DESIGN

Experimental study, interventional case series, and meta-analysis of literature.

METHODS

A theory of epithelial smoothing in response to corneal contour change is derived from differential equations that describe epithelial migration, growth, and loss. Computer simulations calculate the effects on postoperative epithelial thickness, topography, refraction, and spherical aberration. Model parameter is matched with laser in situ keratomileusis (LASIK) outcome in literature and in a retrospective study of primary spherical myopic (77 eyes) and hyperopic (19 eyes) corrections. Surgically induced refractive change was the main outcome measure.

RESULTS

Simulated epithelial remodeling after myopic ablation produces central epithelial thickening, reduction in achieved correction, and induction of oblate spherical aberration. Simulation of hyperopic ablation shows peripheral epithelial thickening, a larger reduction in correction, and induction of prolate spherical aberration. Simulation using a minus cylinder laser ablation pattern shows decreased astigmatism correction and increased hyperopic shift. In the LASIK series, linear regression of achieved correction vs ablation setting in hyperopic and minus cylinder corrections shows slopes of 0.97, 0.71, and 0.74, respectively. These clinical results match model predictions when the smoothing constant is set at 0.32, 0.63, and 0.55 mm, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Epithelial thickness modulations after ablation can be modeled mathematically to explain clinically observed regression and induction of aberration. The cornea appears to smooth over ablated features smaller than approximately 0.5 mm. The model provides an approach for designing ablation patterns that precompensate for the smoothing to improve final outcome.

Repeatability of ocular wavefront measurement

PURPOSE

To assess the repeatability of measurements of ocular aberrations using wavefront sensing in a small group of observers and to assess the potential effect of measurement error on custom corneal correction due to this variability.

METHOD

A Shack-Hartmann wavefront sensor was used to measure the ocular wavefront in nine eyes. Head position was stabilized using a dental bite bar, and the pupil was centred using a cathode ray tube monitor and circular grating. Twenty Shack-Hartmann images were collected for each measurement. Each observer had three sets of measurements taken; the first and the second after careful alignment and the final after regrasping the bite bar in the same position as for the second measurement, but without pupil realignment. The modulation transfer functions for each set were calculated, and the effect of best-aligned custom treatments on the modulation transfer function was estimated.

RESULTS

There were highly statistically significant differences in a large number of Zernike modes between the three sets of measurements. The modulation transfer functions calculated for the residual wavefronts after aligned custom treatment were below the diffraction limit. The root mean square wavefront errors were consistently better for the residual wavefronts obtained using the realigned data than using data taken without pupil realignment.

CONCLUSIONS

Sequential measurement of ocular aberrations shows statistically significant differences in a large number of Zernike modes. If aberrations determined by a single measurement are to be used in a custom correction, the resulting modulation transfer function is likely to remain below the diffraction limit. Pupil realignment is critical in reduction of the residual root mean square wavefront values to a minimum.

Maximum permissible lateral decentration in aberration-sensing and wavefront-guided corneal ablation

PURPOSE

To investigate the lateral alignment accuracy needed in wavefront-guided refractive surgery to improve the ocular optics to a desired level in a percentage of normally aberrated eyes.

SETTING

Department of Ophthalmology, University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland.

METHODS

The effect of laterally misaligned ablations on the optical outcome was simulated using measured wavefront aberration patterns from 130 normal eyes. The calculations were done for 3.0 mm, 5.0 mm, and 7.0 mm pupils. The optical quality of the simulated correction was rated by means of the root-mean-square residual wavefront error.

RESULTS

To achieve the diffraction limit in 95% of the normal eyes with a 7.0 mm pupil, a lateral alignment accuracy of 0.07 mm or better was required. An accuracy of 0.2 mm was sufficient to reach the same goal with a 3.0 mm pupil.

CONCLUSION

Procedures must be developed to ensure that the ablation is within a tolerance range based on each eye's original optical error. Rough centration based on the surgeon's judgment might not be accurate enough to achieve significantly improved optical quality in a high percentage of treated eyes.