Ubiquitylation in plants: a post-genomic look at a post-translational modification

Inhibition of proteasome by MG-132 treatment causes extra phragmoplast formation and cortical microtubule disorganization during M/G1 transition in synchronized tobacco cells

The 26S proteasome plays essential roles in cell cycle progression in various types of cell. We previously reported that the inhibition of 26S proteasome activities by a proteasome inhibitor, MG-132, exclusively caused cell cycle arrest in synchronized tobacco BY-2 cells. Here we report a further observation of 26S proteasome involvement during M/G1 transition utilizing a transgenetic BY-2 cell line that stably expresses a GFP-alpha-tubulin fusion protein (BY-GT16). Interestingly, MG-132 treatment caused the arrest of cell cycle progression prior to entering the G1 phase. Indeed, phragmoplast-like structures were formed and cortical microtubules were not organized after the collapse of the original phragmoplasts. Additionally, actin microfilaments showed irregular rearrangements when further incubated with MG-132 and as the phragmoplast-like structures developed. Since these phragmoplast-like structures had a similar configuration and ability to form cell plates to that of the original phragmoplasts, we designated these phragmoplast-like structures as extra phragmoplasts. Furthermore, we showed that a tobacco kinesin-related polypeptide of 125 kDa (TKRP125) localized in the extra phragmoplasts and that its protein level remained unchanged during MG-132 treatment. We propose that TKRP125 might be one of the possible targets of the ubiquitin-proteasome degradation pathway during M/G1 transition.

Molecular events in senescing Arabidopsis leaves

Senescence is the final stage of leaf development. Although it means the loss of vitality of leaf tissue, leaf senescence is tightly controlled by the development to increase the fitness of the whole plant. The molecular mechanisms regulating the induction and progression of leaf senescence are complex. We used a cDNA microarray, containing 11 500 Arabidopsis DNA elements, and the whole-genome Arabidopsis ATH1 Genome Array to examine global gene expression in dark-induced leaf senescence. By monitoring the gene expression patterns at carefully chosen time points, with three biological replicates each time, we identified thousands of up- or down-regulated genes involved in dark-induced senescence. These genes were clustered and categorized according to their expression patterns and responsiveness to dark treatment. Genes with different expression kinetics were classified according to different biological processes. Genes showing significant alteration of expression patterns in all available biochemical pathways were plotted to envision the molecular events occurring in the processes examined. With the expression data, we postulated an innovative biochemical pathway involving pyruvate orthophosphate dikinase in generating asparagine for nitrogen remobilization in dark-treated leaves. We also surveyed the alteration in expression of Arabidopsis transcription factor genes and established an apparent association of GRAS, bZIP, WRKY, NAC, and C2H2 transcription factor families with leaf senescence.

Transcriptional profiling by cDNA-AFLP and microarray analysis reveals novel insights into the early response to ethylene in Arabidopsis

A comprehensive transcriptome analysis by means of cDNA-amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) and cDNA-microarray technology was performed in order to gain further understanding of the molecular mechanisms of immediate transcriptional response to ethylene. Col-0 plants were treated with exogenous ethylene and sampled at six different time-points ranging from 10 min until 6 h. In order to isolate truly ethylene-responsive genes, both the ethylene-insensitive mutant ein2-1 and the constitutive mutant (ctr1-1) were analysed in parallel by cDNA-AFLP while ein2-1 was included for the microarray experiment. Out of the cDNA-transcript profiling covering about 5% of the Arabidopsis transcriptome, 46 ethylene-responsive genes were isolated, falling in different classes of expression pattern and including a number of novel genes. Out of the 6008 genes present on the chip, 214 genes were significantly (alpha = 0.001) differentially expressed between Col-0 and ein2-1 over time. Cluster analysis and functional grouping of co-regulated genes allowed to determine the major ethylene-regulated classes of genes. In particular, a large number of genes involved in cell rescue, disease and defence mechanisms were identified as early ethylene-regulated genes. Furthermore, the data provide insight into the role of protein degradation in ethylene signalling and ethylene-regulated transcription and protein fate. Novel interactions between ethylene response and responses to several other signals have been identified by this study. Of particular interest is the overlap between ethylene response and responses to abscisic acid, sugar and auxin. In conclusion, the data provide unique insight into early regulatory steps of ethylene response.

Catalase deficiency drastically affects gene expression induced by high light in Arabidopsis thaliana

In plants, hydrogen peroxide (H(2)O(2)) plays a major signaling role in triggering both a defense response and cell death. Increased cellular H(2)O(2) levels and subsequent redox imbalances are managed at the production and scavenging levels. Because catalases are the major H(2)O(2) scavengers that remove the bulk of cellular H(2)O(2), altering their levels allows in planta modulation of H(2)O(2) concentrations. Reduced peroxisomal catalase activity increased sensitivity toward both ozone and photorespiratory H(2)O(2)-induced cell death in transgenic catalase-deficient Arabidopsis thaliana. These plants were used as a model system to build a comprehensive inventory of transcriptomic variations, which were triggered by photorespiratory H(2)O(2) induced by high-light (HL) irradiance. In addition to an H(2)O(2)-dependent and -independent type of transcriptional response during light stress, microarray analysis on both control and transgenic catalase-deficient plants, exposed to 0, 3, 8, and 23 h of HL, revealed several specific regulatory patterns of gene expression. Thus, photorespiratory H(2)O(2) has a direct impact on transcriptional programs in plants.

The diverse roles of ubiquitin and the 26S proteasome in the life of plants

A tightly regulated and highly specific system for the degradation of individual proteins is essential for the survival of all organisms. In eukaryotes, this is achieved by the tagging of proteins with ubiquitin and their subsequent recognition and degradation by the 26S proteasome. In plants, genetic analysis has identified many genes that regulate developmental pathways. Subsequent analysis of these genes has implicated ubiquitin and the 26S proteasome in the control of diverse developmental processes, and indicates that proteolysis is a crucial regulatory step throughout the life cycle of plants.

The ubiquitin 26S proteasome proteolytic pathway

Much of plant physiology, growth, and development is controlled by the selective removal of short-lived regulatory proteins. One important proteolytic pathway involves the small protein ubiquitin (Ub) and the 26S proteasome, a 2-MDa protease complex. In this pathway, Ub is attached to proteins destined for degradation; the resulting Ub-protein conjugates are then recognized and catabolized by the 26S proteasome. This review describes our current understanding of the pathway in plants at the biochemical, genomic, and genetic levels, using Arabidopsis thaliana as the model. Collectively, these analyses show that the Ub/26S proteasome pathway is one of the most elaborate regulatory mechanisms in plants. The genome of Arabidopsis encodes more than 1400 (or >5% of the proteome) pathway components that can be connected to almost all aspects of its biology. Most pathway components participate in the Ub-ligation reactions that choose with exquisite specificity which proteins should be ubiquitinated. What remains to be determined is the identity of the targets, which may number in the thousands in plants.

Identification and characterization of three novel cold acclimation-responsive genes from the extremophile hair grass Deschampsia antarctica Desv

Deschampsia antarctica Desv. is the only monocot that thrives in the harsh conditions of the Antarctic Peninsula and represents an invaluable resource for the identification of genes associated with freezing tolerance. In order to identify genes regulated by low temperature, we have initiated a detailed analysis of its gene expression. Preliminary 2-D gels of in vivo-labeled leaf proteins showed qualitative and quantitative differences between cold-acclimated and non-acclimated plants, suggesting differential gene expression. Similarly, cold-acclimation-related transcripts were screened by a differential display method. Of the 38 cDNAs initially identified, three cDNA clones were characterized for their protein encoding, expression pattern, response to several stresses, and for their tissue-specific expression. Northern blot analysis of DaGrx, DaRub1, and DaPyk1 encoding a glutaredoxin, a related-to-ubiquitin protein, and a pyruvate kinase-like protein, respectively, showed a distinct regulation pattern during the cold-acclimation process, and in some cases, their cold response seemed to be tissue specific. All three transcripts seem to be responsive to water stress as their levels were up-regulated with polyethyleneglycol treatment. DaRUB1 and DaPyk1 expression was up-regulated in leaf and crown, but down-regulated in roots from cold-acclimated plants. The significance of these results during the cold-acclimation process will be discussed.

PRT1 of Arabidopsis is a ubiquitin protein ligase of the plant N-end rule pathway with specificity for aromatic amino-terminal residues

The gene PRT1 of Arabidopsis, encoding a 45-kD protein with two RING finger domains, is essential for the degradation of F-dihydrofolate reductase, a model substrate of the N-end rule pathway of protein degradation. We have determined the function of PRT1 by expression in yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae). PRT1 can act as a ubiquitin protein ligase in the heterologous host. The identified substrates of PRT1 have an aromatic residue at their amino-terminus, indicating that PRT1 mediates degradation of N-end rule substrates with aromatic termini but not of those with aliphatic or basic amino-termini. Expression of model substrates in mutant and wild-type plants confirmed this substrate specificity. A ligase activity exclusively devoted to aromatic amino-termini of the N-end rule pathway is apparently unique to plants. The results presented also imply that other known substrates of the plant N-end rule pathway are ubiquitylated by one or more different ubiquitin protein ligases.

Modulation of sensitivity and selectivity in plant signaling by proteasomal destabilization

The ubiquitin (Ub) system of intracellular protein degradation regulates the abundance of numerous proteins that control plant growth and development. Recent advances have begun to illustrate how environmental and endogenous signals affect plant responses through Ub-related proteolysis, the importance of combinatorial control in regulated protein destruction and how multiprotein complexes confer sensitivity and selectivity to ubiquitination. Further insight into the cell biology of Ub-chain assembly and proteasomal degradation, as well as into the relationship between proteolysis and other regulatory modifications, will be essential for understanding the mechanistic basis of the integration of diverse plant signals.

Misfolded plant virus proteins: elicitors and targets of ubiquitylation

Mutant tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) coat proteins (CPs) with known amino acid replacements provide well defined examples of destabilized tertiary structures. Here we show that misfolded TMV CPs, but not functional wild-type CPs, induce massive ubiquitylation in tobacco cells and that denatured, insoluble CP subunits are the main substrates of ubiquitin conjugation. As TMV CPs can be easily manipulated they are unique tools to study the molecular basis of the plant cell's response to aberrant protein structures and the associated intracellular stress reactions.

Isolation of tobacco ubiquitin-conjugating enzyme cDNA in a yeast two-hybrid system with tobacco ERF3 as bait and its characterization of specific interaction

Tobacco ETHYLENE-RESPONSIVE FACTOR3 (ERF3) is a member of the ERF-domain transcription factors and has a transcriptional repressor activity, whereas other ERF proteins show activation activity. To understand the regulation of ERF3-repressor activity, protein(s) were screened which interact with ERF3 in a yeast two-hybrid system. A partial sequence (B8) of NtUBC2, a tobacco ubiquitin-conjugating enzyme was isolated. This B8 specifically interacted with ERF3 in the yeast two-hybrid system. Further analyses revealed that the region unique to ERF3 interacted with B8. The physiological functions of NtUBC2 and the stability of ERF3 are discussed in relation to the regulation of the repression activity of ERF3.

Metabolome diversity: too few genes, too many metabolites?

The multitude of metabolites found in living organisms and the calculated, unexpected small number of genes identified during genome sequencing projects discomfit biologists. Several processes on the transcription and translation level lead to the formation of isoenzymes and can therefore explain at least parts of this surprising result. However, poor enzyme specificity may also contribute to metabolome diversity. In former studies, when enzymes were isolated from natural sources, impure protein preparations were hold responsible for broad enzyme specificity. Nowadays, highly purified enzymes are available by molecular biological methods such as heterologous expression in host organisms and they can be thoroughly analyzed. During biochemical analysis of heterologously expressed enzymes poor specificity was observed for enzymes involved in fruit ripening, e.g. in flavour and color formation. Surprisingly broad specificity was shown for the reactants in the case of alcohol acyl-CoA transferase, O-methyltransferase, glucosyltransferase, P450 monooxygenases as well as polyketide synthases and for the product in the case of monoterpene synthases. Literature data confirm the assumption of limited specificity for enzymes involved in metabolism and bioformation of secondary metabolites. It is concluded that metabolome diversity is caused by low enzyme specificity but availability of suitable substrates due to compartmentation has also taken into account.

Chlamydomonas reinhardtii genome project. A guide to the generation and use of the cDNA information

The National Science Foundation-funded Chlamydomonas reinhardtii genome project involves (a) construction and sequencing of cDNAs isolated from cells exposed to various environmental conditions, (b) construction of a high-density cDNA microarray, (c) generation of genomic contigs that are nucleated around specific physical and genetic markers, (d) generation of a complete chloroplast genome sequence and analyses of chloroplast gene expression, and (e) the creation of a Web-based resource that allows for easy access of the information in a format that can be readily queried. Phases of the project performed by the groups at the Carnegie Institution and Duke University involve the generation of normalized cDNA libraries, sequencing of cDNAs, analysis and assembly of these sequences to generate contigs and a set of predicted unique genes, and the use of this information to construct a high-density DNA microarray. In this paper, we discuss techniques involved in obtaining cDNA end-sequence information and the ways in which this information is assembled and analyzed. Descriptions of protocols for preparing cDNA libraries, assembling cDNA sequences and annotating the sequence information are provided (the reader is directed to Web sites for more detailed descriptions of these methods). We also discuss preliminary results in which the different cDNA libraries are used to identify genes that are potentially differentially expressed.

The COP9 signalosome: regulating plant development through the control of proteolysis

The COP9 signalosome (CSN) is a multiprotein complex that was initially identified in plants as a repressor of photomorphogenesis. It is now known to play major roles in several other developmental pathways, from auxin response to flower development. Furthermore, the COP9 signalosome shares homologies with the lid sibcomplex of the proteasome and is evolutionarily conserved from fission yeast to humans. It is important for the proper development of virtually all higher eukaryotes. In recent years, significant progress has been made in unraveling the molecular, cellular, and physiological mode of action of the COP9 signalosome. This review discusses our current understanding of the COP9 signalosome function with particular emphasis on its recently defined role in modulating a wide variety of cellular processes by regulating specific protein degradation events.

Identification and characterization of the ARIADNE gene family in Arabidopsis. A group of putative E3 ligases

ARIADNE (ARI) proteins were recently identified in fruitfly (Drosophila melanogaster), mouse, and man because of their specific interaction with the ubiquitin-conjugating (E2) enzymes UbcD10, UbcM4, UbcH7, and UbcH8. They are characterized by specific motifs and protein structures that they share with PARKIN, and there is increasing evidence that ARI/PARKIN proteins function as E2-dependent ubiquitin-protein ligases. On the basis of homology and motif searches, 16 AtARI genes were identified in Arabidopsis. Analysis of the position of exons/introns and their chromosomal localization indicates that the AtARI gene family expanded via larger and smaller genome duplications. We present evidence that retroposition of processed mRNA may have also contributed to enlarging this gene family. Phylogenetic analyses divides the AtARI proteins into three subgroups. Two groups are absent in yeast, invertebrates, and vertebrates and may therefore represent new plant-specific subfamilies. Examination of the predicted protein sequences revealed that the ARI proteins share an additional leucine-rich region at the N terminus that is highly conserved in all phyla analyzed. Furthermore, conserved consensus signals for casein kinase II-dependent phosphorylation and for nuclear localization were identified. The in silico-based analyses were complemented with experimental data to quantify expression levels. Using real-time polymerase chain reaction, we show that the ARI genes are differentially transcribed. AtARI1 is highly expressed in all organs, whereas no transcripts could be detected for AtARI11, AtARI13, and AtARI14. AtARI12 and AtARI16 are expressed in an organ-specific manner in the roots and siliques, respectively.

The AtRbx1 protein is part of plant SCF complexes, and its down-regulation causes severe growth and developmental defects

Recently in yeast and animal cells, one particular class of ubiquitin ligase (E3), called the SCF, was demonstrated to regulate diverse processes including cell cycle and development. In plants SCF-dependent proteolysis is also involved in different developmental and hormonal regulations. To further investigate the function of SCF, we characterized at the molecular level the Arabidopsis RING-H2 finger protein AtRbx1. We demonstrated that the plant gene is able to functionally complement a yeast knockout mutant strain and showed that AtRbx1 protein interacts physically with at least two members of the Arabidopsis cullin family (AtCul1 and AtCul4). AtRbx1 also associates with AtCul1 and the Arabidopsis SKP1-related proteins in planta, indicating that it is part of plant SCF complexes. AtRbx1 mRNAs accumulate in various tissues of the plant, but at higher levels in tissues containing actively dividing cells. Finally to study the function of the gene in planta, we either overexpressed AtRbx1 or reduced its expression by a dsRNA strategy. Down-regulation of AtRbx1 impaired seedling growth and development, indicating that the gene is essential in plants. Furthermore, the AtRbx1-silenced plants showed a reduced level of AtCul1 protein, but accumulated higher level of cyclin D3.

Stability in vitro of the 69K movement protein of Turnip yellow mosaic virus is regulated by the ubiquitin-mediated proteasome pathway

Plant viruses move to adjacent cells with the use of virus-encoded cell-to-cell movement proteins. Using proteins produced by in vitro translation, we present evidence that the '69K' movement protein of Turnip yellow mosaic virus (TYMV) is recognized as a substrate for the attachment of polyubiquitin chains and for subsequent rapid and selective proteolysis by the proteasome, the ATP-dependent proteolytic system present in reticulocyte lysate. Truncation of the 69K protein suggests the existence of two degradation signals within its sequence. We propose that selective degradation of virus movement proteins may contribute to the previously reported transient nature of their accumulation during infection.

COI1 links jasmonate signalling and fertility to the SCF ubiquitin-ligase complex in Arabidopsis

Jasmonates (JAs) regulate Arabidopsis thaliana wound and defence responses, pollen development, and stress-related growth inhibition. Significantly, each of these responses requires COI1, an F-box protein. Other F-box proteins interact with SKP1 and cullin proteins to form SCF complexes that selectively recruit regulatory proteins targeted for ubiquitination. To determine whether COI1 also functions in an SCF complex, we have characterized Arabidopsis proteins that bind to COI1. An Arabidopsis cDNA expression library was screened in yeast for clones that produce proteins which can bind to COI1. We recovered two SKP1 homologues and a histone deacetylase. The Arabidopsis F-box protein TIR1 interacted with SKP1 proteins, but not with the histone deacetylase. Mutant COI1 proteins revealed that the F-box is required for interaction with SKP1s, but that sequences in leucine-rich repeat domains are required for interaction with the histone deacetylase. Epitope-tagged COI1 was introduced into Arabidopsis plants and cell cultures. Co-immunoprecipitation experiments confirmed the interaction in planta of COI1 with SKP1-like proteins and histone deacetylase, and also indicated that COI1 interacted with cullin. These results suggest that COI1 forms an SCFCOI1 complex in vivo. COI1 is therefore expected to form a functional E3-type ubiquitin ligase in plants and to regulate expression of jasmonate responsive genes, possibly by targeted ubiquitination of a histone deacetylase.

Molecular characterization of plant ubiquitin-conjugating enzymes belonging to the UbcP4/E2-C/UBCx/UbcH10 gene family

The anaphase promoting complex or cyclosome is the ubiquitin-ligase that targets destruction box-containing proteins for proteolysis during the cell cycle. Anaphase promoting complex or cyclosome and its activator (the fizzy and fizzy-related) proteins work together with ubiquitin-conjugating enzymes (UBCs) (E2s). One class of E2s (called E2-C) seems specifically involved in cyclin B1 degradation. Although it has recently been shown that mammalian E2-C is regulated at the protein level during the cell cycle, not much is known concerning the expression of these genes. Arabidopsis encodes two genes belonging to the E2-C gene family (called UBC19 and UBC20). We found that UBC19 is able to complement fission yeast (Schizosaccharomyces pombe) UbcP4-140 mutant, indicating that the plant protein can functionally replace its yeast ortholog for protein degradation during mitosis. In situ hybridization experiments were performed to study the expression of the E2-C genes in various tissues of plants. Their transcripts were always, but not exclusively, found in tissues active for cell division. Thus, the UBC19/20 E2s may have a key function during cell cycle, but may also be involved in ubiquitylation reactions occurring during differentiation and/or in differentiated cells. Finally, we showed that a translational fusion protein between UBC19 and green fluorescent protein localized both in the cytosol and the nucleus in stable transformed tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum cv Bright Yellow 2) cells.

Ubiquitin-mediated proteolysis in plant hormone signal transduction

Being sessile organisms, plants usually have little control over their immediate growth environment. Responses to environmental and developmental factors need to be rapid and finely coordinated to trigger the necessary morphological and metabolic changes that ensure plant survival and growth. Many of these adaptive responses are mediated by plant hormones. Recent work has shown that ubiquitin-mediated proteolysis plays an important regulatory role in hormone signaling.

EL5, a rice N-acetylchitooligosaccharide elicitor-responsive RING-H2 finger protein, is a ubiquitin ligase which functions in vitro in co-operation with an elicitor-responsive ubiquitin-conjugating enzyme, OsUBC5b

EL5, a rice gene responsive to N-acetylchitooligosaccharide elicitor, encodes a RING-H2 finger protein with structural features common to the plant-specific ATL family. We show that the fusion protein of EL5 with maltose binding protein (MBP) was polyubiquitinated by incubation with ubiquitin, ubiquitin-activating enzyme (E1), and the Ubc4/5 subfamily of the ubiquitin-conjugating enzyme (E2). EL5 possesses the activity to catalyse the transfer of ubiquitin to the MBP moiety, and the RING-H2 finger motif of EL5 is necessary for this activity. Thus, we concluded that EL5 represents a ubiquitin ligase (E3). We also show that two rice E2s (OsUBC5a, OsUBC5b) of the Ubc4/5 subfamily function as E2 which catalyses EL5-mediated ubiquitination, and OsUBC5b was induced by elicitor, as well as EL5. These results strongly suggest that EL5 and OsUBC5b have roles in plant defense response through the turnover of protein(s) via the ubiquitin/proteasome system.

Distribution of DNA repair-related ESTs in sugarcane

DNA repair pathways are necessary to maintain the proper genomic stability and ensure the survival of the organism, protecting it against the damaging effects of endogenous and exogenous agents. In this work, we made an analysis of the expression patterns of DNA repair-related genes in sugarcane, by determining the EST (expressed sequence tags) distribution in the different cDNA libraries of the SUCEST transcriptome project. Three different pathways - photoreactivation, base excision repair and nucleotide excision repair - were investigated by employing known DNA repair proteins as probes to identify homologous ESTs in sugarcane, by means of computer similarity search. The results showed that DNA repair genes may have differential expressions in tissues, depending on the pathway studied. These in silico data provide important clues on the potential variation of gene expression, to be confirmed by direct biochemical analysis.