In vitro selection of RNAs that undergo autolytic cleavage with Pb2+

Isolation of a ribozyme with 5'-5' ligase activity

BACKGROUND

Many new ribozymes, including sequence-specific nucleases, ligases and kinases, have been isolated by in vitro selection from large pools of random-sequence RNAs. We are attempting to use in vitro selection to isolate new ribozymes that have, or can be evolved to have, RNA polymerase-like activities. As phosphorimidazolide-activated nucleosides are extensively used to study non-enzymatic RNA replication, we wished to select for a ribozyme that would accelerate the template-directed ligation of 5'-phosphorimidazolide-activated oligonucleotides.

RESULTS

Ribozymes selected to perform the desired template-directed ligation reaction instead ligated themselves to the activated substrate oligonucleotide via their 5'-triphosphate, generating a 5'-5' P1,P4-tetraphosphate linkage. Deletion analysis of one of the selected sequences revealed that a 54-nucleotide RNA retained activity; this small ribozyme folds into a pseudoknot secondary structure with an internal binding site for the substrate oligonucleotide. The ribozyme can also synthesize 5'-5' triphosphate and 5'-5' pyrophosphate linkages.

CONCLUSIONS

The emergence of ribozymes that accelerate an unexpected 5'-5' ligation reaction from a selection designed to yield template-dependent 3'-5' ligases suggests that it may be much easier for RNA to catalyze the synthesis of 5'-5' linkages than 3'-5' linkages. 5'-5' linkages are found in a variety of contexts in present-day biology. The ribozyme-catalyzed synthesis of such linkages raises the possibility that these 5'-5' linkages originated in the biochemistry of the RNA world.

Highly specific and efficient cleavage of squid tRNA(Lys) catalyzed by magnesium ions

Two lysine isoacceptor tRNAs corresponding to the codons AAA and AAG, respectively, were isolated from squid (Loligo bleekeri), and their nucleotide sequences were determined. During this analysis, we discovered that the tRNA with the anticodon CUU was efficiently cleaved at a specific site in the presence of magnesium ions, whereas the tRNA with the anticodon UUU was not. Cleavage occurred almost exclusively at the phosphodiester linkage between G15 and D16 (p16). The most remarkable feature of this cleavage reaction is that the end product was not a 2',3'-cyclic phosphate but was mainly a 3'-phosphate. Thus, this reaction was distinct from the well characterized cleavage of yeast tRNA(Phe) by lead and from reactions catalyzed by various other metalloribozymes. The presence of a cytidine residue at position 60 was required for efficient cleavage but was not crucial for the reaction, and the entire tRNA molecule had to be intact for this specific and efficient cleavage reaction. The present study provides evidence that there exists a new catalytic mechanism for cleavage of tRNA that exploits biologically ubiquitous ions rather than toxic, nonessential ions such as lead.

Combinatorial drug discovery: which methods will produce the greatest value?

Combinatorial strategies are important new approaches to drug discovery, and it seems quite likely that they will result in the discovery of interesting potential pharmaceuticals. However, it is less clear whether combinatorial approaches will result in quantum advances in therapeutics. Nor is there general agreement about the factors most important in defining how combinatorial strategies will provide value to the discovery of lead and therapeutic compounds. In this review, we propose criteria that define the value of combinatorial strategies and categorize the various approaches by: (a) the type of chemical space to be searched, (b) the tactics employed to synthesize and screen libraries, and (c) the structures of individual molecules in libraries. We evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of the various strategies and suggest milestones that can help to track their success.

Ribozymes, recognition and evolution

Precision in the recognition and orientation of substrate is important in the selectivity of catalysis by natural enzymes. Several new ribozyme species have been evolved using in vitro selection/mutagenesis which make use of precise substrate recognition to catalyze a variety of reactions.

Understanding cellular responses to toxic agents: a model for mechanism-choice in bacterial metal resistance

Bacterial resistances to metals are heterogeneous in both their genetic and biochemical bases. Metal resistance may be chromosomally-, plasmid- or transposon-encoded, and one or more genes may be involved: at the biochemical level at least six different mechanisms are responsible for resistance. Various types of resistance mechanisms can occur singly or in combination and for a particular metal different mechanisms of resistance can occur in the same species. To understand better the diverse responses of bacteria to metal ion challenge we have constructed a qualitative model for the selection of metal resistance in bacteria. How a bacterium becomes resistant to a particular metal depends on the number and location of cellular components sensitive to the specific metal ion. Other important selective factors include the nature of the uptake systems for the metal, the role and interactions of the metal in the normal metabolism of the cell and the availability of plasmid (or transposon) encoded resistance mechanisms. The selection model presented is based on the interaction of these factors and allows predictions to be made about the evolution of metal resistance in bacterial populations. It also allows prediction of the genetic basis and of mechanisms of resistance which are in substantial agreement with those in well-documented populations. The interaction of, and selection for resistance to, toxic substances in addition to metals, such as antibiotics and toxic analogues, involve similar principles to those concerning metals. Potentially, models for selection of resistance to any substance can be derived using this approach.

Enrichment for RNA molecules that bind a Diels-Alder transition state analog

RNA molecules that bind a transition state analog for a Diels-Alder reaction (Kd = 0.35 +/- 0.05 mM) were isolated from a starting pool of approximately 10(14) sequences by affinity chromatography. After the initial rise and plateau of the amount of RNA that eluted with soluble analog, a step gradient elution was used to further enrich the pool for sequences with higher affinities for the target. To our knowledge, the isolation of RNA molecules that bind either a nonplanar or a hydrophobic ligand has not been reported previously. A conserved nucleotide sequence and secondary structure present in many of the RNA molecules are necessary but not sufficient for binding the analog. No catalysts of the targeted Diels-Alder reaction were found among the binders. The absence of catalysis contrasts with previous successful experiments with antibodies and suggests that other strategies may be needed to identify oligonucleotides with diverse catalytic activities.

Modified RNA sequence pools for in vitro selection

We report the use of modified RNA, in which the 2'-OH group of pyrimidines is replaced by a 2'-amino (2'-NH2) group to identify high affinity ligands specific for human neutrophil elastase (HNE) by in vitro selection. Compared to unmodified RNA the 2'-NH2-modified RNA ligands show enhanced stability in human serum and urine. Use of RNase T1 cleavage data in the presence of K+ and Li+ ions suggests that the modified RNA ligands selected for HNE form an intermolecular G-quartet structure.

A DNA enzyme that cleaves RNA

BACKGROUND

Several types of RNA enzymes (ribozymes) have been identified in biological systems and generated in the laboratory. Considering the variety of known RNA enzymes and the similarity of DNA and RNA, it is reasonable to imagine that DNA might be able to function as an enzyme as well. No such DNA enzyme has been found in nature, however. We set out to identify a metal-dependent DNA enzyme using in vitro selection methodology.

RESULTS

Beginning with a population of 10(14) DNAs containing 50 random nucleotides, we carried out five successive rounds of selective amplification, enriching for individuals that best promote the Pb(2+)-dependent cleavage of a target ribonucleoside 3'-O-P bond embedded within an otherwise all-DNA sequence. By the fifth round, the population as a whole carried out this reaction at a rate of 0.2 min-1. Based on the sequence of 20 individuals isolated from this population, we designed a simplified version of the catalytic domain that operates in an intermolecular context with a turnover rate of 1 min-1. This rate is about 10(5)-fold increased compared to the uncatalyzed reaction.

CONCLUSIONS

Using in vitro selection techniques, we obtained a DNA enzyme that catalyzes the Pb(2+)-dependent cleavage of an RNA phosphoester in a reaction that proceeds with rapid turnover. The catalytic rate compares favorably to that of known RNA enzymes. We expect that other examples of DNA enzymes will soon be forthcoming.

In vitro evolution of new ribozymes with polynucleotide kinase activity

We have isolated a large number of polynucleotide kinase ribozymes from a pool of RNA molecules consisting of an ATP-binding domain flanked by regions of random sequence. Different classes of kinases catalyse the transfer of the gamma-thiophosphate of ATP-gamma S to the 5'-hydroxyl or to internal 2'-hydroxyls. An engineered version of one class is able to catalyse the transfer of thiophosphate from ATP-gamma S to the 5'-hydroxyl of an exogenous oligoribonucleotide substrate with multiple turnover, thus acting as a true enzyme.

Inventing and improving ribozyme function: rational design versus iterative selection methods

Two major strategies for generating novel biological catalysts exist. One relies on our knowledge of biopolymer structure and function to aid in the 'rational design' of new enzymes. The other, often called 'irrational design', aims to generate new catalysts, in the absence of detailed physicochemical knowledge, by using selection methods to search a library of molecules for functional variants. Both strategies have been applied, with considerable success, to the remodeling of existing ribozymes and the development of ribozymes with novel catalytic function. The two strategies are by no means mutually exclusive, and are best applied in a complementary fashion to obtain ribozymes with the desired catalytic properties.

Evolutionary optimization of the catalytic properties of a DNA-cleaving ribozyme

In a previous study [Beaudry, A. A., & Joyce, G. F. (1992) Science 257, 635-641], an in vitro evolution procedure was used to obtain variants of the Tetrahymena ribozyme with 100-fold improved ability to cleave a target single-stranded DNA under physiologic conditions. Here we report continuation of the in vitro evolution process to achieve 10(5)-fold overall improvement in DNA-cleavage activity. In addition, we demonstrate that, by appropriate manipulation of the selection constraints, one can optimize specific catalytic properties of the evolved ribozymes. We first reduced the concentration of the DNA substrate 50-fold to favor ribozymes with improved substrate binding affinity. We then reduced the reaction time 12-fold to favor ribozymes with improved catalytic rate. In both cases, the evolving population responded as expected, first improving substrate binding 25-fold, and then improving catalytic rate about 50-fold. The population of ribozymes has undergone 27 successive generations of in vitro evolution, resulting in, on average, 17 mutations relative to the wild type that are responsible for the improved DNA-cleavage activity.

Structural elements that contribute to an unusual tertiary interaction in a transfer RNA

Transfer RNAs (tRNAs) contain a set of defined tertiary hydrogen-bonding interactions that are established between conserved and semiconserved nucleotides. Although the crystal structures of tRNAs describe each of the tertiary interactions in detailed molecular terms, little is known about the underlying structural parameters that stabilize the tertiary interactions. Escherichia coli (E. coli) tRNA(Cys) has an unusual tertiary interaction between G15 in the dihydrouridine (D) loop and G48 in the variable loop that is critical for cysteine aminoacylation. All other tRNAs have a purine 15 and a complementary pyrimidine 48 that establish a tertiary interaction known as the Levitt base pair [Levitt, M. (1969) Nature 224, 759-763; Klug et al. (1974) J. Mol. Biol. 89, 511-516]. In this study, the G15.G48 tertiary interaction in E. coli tRNA(Cys) was used to investigate the structural elements that contribute to its variation from the Levitt base pair. Analysis with chemical probes showed that substitution of U21 with A21 in the D loop and formation of a Watson-Crick base pair between nucleotides 13 and 22 in the D stem switch the hydrogen-pairing of G15.G48 to a Levitt-like G15.G48 base pair. This switch was accompanied by a decrease of the catalytic efficiency of aminoacylation by 2 orders of magnitude. In contrast, insertion of additional nucleotides in the D or variable loops had little effect.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Cloning and characterization of the RNase P RNA genes from two porcine mycoplasmas

We report the cloning of the RNase P RNA genes from the primary aetiological agent of porcine pneumonia, Mycoplasma hyopneumoniae, and the closely related commensal, Mycoplasma flocculare. The monocistronic genes each have promoters with AT-rich -35 regions and Rho-independent-like transcription terminators which are retained in the RNase P RNA. Both of these RNase P RNA variants are shown to be catalytically active in vitro in spite of a low overall GC content (30%). Our results suggest a new example of a stable mini-helix in the conserved core of the mycoplasmal RNase P RNAs. Deletion of the corresponding structural element in Escherichia coli RNase P RNA (M1 RNA) generated an RNase P RNA with an impaired substrate interaction. Displacement of this structural element with the mycoplasmal mini-helix resulted in an enzyme with a phenotype similar to that of wild-type M1 RNA. In addition, this structural element is important for lead ion-induced cleavage at specific sites in M1 RNA.

Lead-ion-induced cleavage of RNase P RNA

Pb(2+)-induced hydrolysis of RNase P RNAs from Escherichia coli and the thermophilic eubacterium Thermus thermophilus HB8 revealed one prominent site-specific cleavage in the two RNAs and several minor cleavage sites in structurally corresponding regions of both RNAs. Data presented here and in a previous study [Kazakov, S. & Altman, S. (1991) Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 88, 9193-9197] provide evidence for several ubiquitous metal-ion-binding sites in eubacterial RNase P RNA subunits. With the T. thermophilus RNase P RNA, susceptibility to Pb(2+)-induced strand scission at the most prominent site was hypersensitive at the temperature of highest enzyme activity (55 degrees C). Pb2+ hydrolysis at this site was strongly reduced at a temperature of 37 degrees C, where processing is also inefficient. For E. coli RNase P RNA, specific changes in the lead hydrolysis pattern were observed due to the presence of excess tRNA. Thus, Pb(2+)-induced hydrolysis seems suitable to sense different conformations of RNase P RNAs. The T. thermophilus RNase P RNA, in particular, displayed significant processing activity after severe fragmentation by Pb2+, and therefore appears to be suited for reconstituting an active enzyme from RNA subfragments.

All you wanted to know about SELEX

In vitro selection, or SELEX, is a technique that allows the simultaneous screening of highly diverse pools of different RNA or DNA (dsDNA or ssDNA) molecules for a particular feature. Different examples from a great variety of applications of in vitro selection experiments are described and a detailed overview of the method and its variations will be given. Some especially conclusive in vitro selection experiments are discussed in detail to illustrate the potential power and diversity of this method. Potential restrictions of the methods and possible ways to overcome them are pointed out.

Recombinant photoreactive tRNA molecules as probes for cross-linking studies

Photoreactive tRNA derivatives have been used extensively for investigating the interaction of tRNA molecules with their ligands and substrates. Recombinant RNA technology facilitates the construction of such tRNA probes through site-specific incorporation of photoreactive nucleosides. The general strategy involves preparation of suitable tRNA fragments and their ligation either to a photoreactive nucleotide or to each other. tRNA fragments can be prepared by site-specific cleavage of native tRNAs, or synthesized by enzymatic and chemical means. A number of photoreactive nucleosides suitable for incorporation into tRNA are presently available. Joining of tRNA fragments is accomplished either by RNA ligase or by DNA ligase in the presence of a DNA splint. The application of this methodology to the study of tRNA binding sites on the ribosome is discussed, and a model of the tRNA-ribosome complex is presented.

Specific ammonium ion requirement for functional ribosomal RNA tertiary structure

In compactly folded RNAs, coordination or hydrogen bonding of cations in specific sites is a potentially important aspect of the tertiary structure. NH4+ specifically stabilizes the tertiary structure of a conserved, 58-nt fragment of the large subunit ribosomal RNA, as judged in two ways: a melting transition associated with tertiary interactions is sharpened and stabilized more effectively by NH4+ than by any alkali metal cation, and the affinity of the RNA fragment for ribosomal protein L11 or the antibiotic thiostrepton is approximately 10-fold stronger when measured in NH4+ than in Na+. The dependence of the melting temperature on NH4+ concentration shows that a single bound ion is responsible for these effects. The requirement of different ribosome functions for NH4+ suggests that other such sites exist in ribosomal RNAs.

Identification of important bases in a single-stranded region (SSrC) of the hepatitis delta (delta) virus ribozyme

Models for the secondary structure of genomic and antigenomic self-cleaving RNAs of human hepatitis delta (delta) virus (HDV) have been proposed by several groups. Our recent results support a pseudoknot structure and have allowed us to identify functionally important nucleotides in single-stranded regions [nucleotides 726-731 (SSrA) and nucleotides 762-766 (SSrB)]. For the identification of the important residues in the remaining single-stranded region, nucleotides 708-715 (SSrC), of the genomic HDV ribozyme, we made derivatives with a single-base substitution in the SSrC region. To screen inactive mutants rapidly, we use a simplified in-vitro selection method. Among the various base substitutions in mutants in the SSrC, U708A, C709(A/G/U) and G713C variants had less than 10% of the cleavage activity of the wild-type SSrC (HDV86). By analyzing the self-cleavage activities of various mutants, we determined the base requirements for SSrC as 5'-(U/C/G)-C-N-N-(C/A/G)-(G/A/U)-N-N-3'.

Ribozymes: a distinct class of metalloenzymes

Ribozymes are an important new class of metalloenzymes that have an unlikely feature: they are made entirely of ribonucleic acid (RNA). Metal ions are essential for efficient chemical catalysis by ribozymes and are often required for the stabilization of ribozyme structure. Most ribozymes catalyze reactions at phosphorus centers through one of two major mechanistic pathways, and reaction has been observed at carbon centers. Creative experiments have revealed the position of metal ions in the active site of two ribozymes. The exploitation of variable metal geometry and reactivity has expanded ribozyme chemistry and has facilitated the application of in vitro selection for the creation of novel ribozymes.

Metal coordination sites that contribute to structure and catalysis in the group I intron from Tetrahymena

We have used nucleoside phosphorothioates (NTP alpha S) and a substitution-interference method to identify phosphate oxygens that appear to be important to guanosine cofactor addition in the self-splicing group I intron from Tetrahymena thermophila. For the majority of these phosphate oxygens, however, the effect of NTP alpha S substitution is significantly reduced in reactions containing the added presence of manganese ion (Mn2+) relative to magnesium ion (Mg2+) alone. The observed "rescue" of the NTP alpha S effect at these positions is thought to be due to the larger affinity of Mn2+ for sulfur. These data suggest the direct coordination of divalent metal ions within the highly conserved catalytic core of the Tetrahymena intron. Because many of these metal binding sites appear to be in positions of close backbone-backbone approach, and adjacent to the guanosine binding site the splice junction, we suggest roles for the corresponding ions in stabilizing tertiary structure and substrate recognition and as participants in catalysis.

In vitro selection of optimal DNA substrates for T4 RNA ligase

We have used in vitro selection techniques to characterize DNA sequences that are ligated efficiently by T4 RNA ligase. We find that the ensemble of selected sequences ligated about 10 times as efficiently as the random mixture of sequences used as the input for selection. Surprisingly, the majority of the selected sequences approximated a well-defined consensus sequence.

Replacement of RNA hairpins by in vitro selected tetranucleotides

An in vitro selection method based on the autolytic cleavage of yeast tRNA(Phe) by Pb2+ was applied to obtain tRNA derivatives with the anticodon hairpin replaced by four single-stranded nucleotides. Based on the rates of the site-specific cleavage by Pb2+ and the presence of a specific UV-induced crosslink, certain tetranucleotide sequences allow proper folding of the rest of the tRNA molecule, whereas others do not. One such successful tetramer sequence was also used to replace the acceptor stem of yeast tRNA(Phe) and the anticodon hairpin of E.coli tRNA(Phe) without disrupting folding. These experiments suggest that certain tetramers may be able to replace structurally nonessential hairpins in any RNA.

Lead cleavage sites in the core structure of group I intron-RNA

Self-splicing of group I introns requires divalent metal ions to promote catalysis as well as for the correct folding of the RNA. Lead cleavage has been used to probe the intron RNA for divalent metal ion binding sites. In the conserved core of the intron, only two sites of Pb2+ cleavage have been detected, which are located close to the substrate binding sites in the junction J8/7 and at the bulged nucleotide in the P7 stem. Both lead cleavages can be inhibited by high concentrations of Mg2+ and Mn2+ ions, suggesting that they displace Pb2+ ions from the binding sites. The RNA is protected from lead cleavage by 2'-deoxyGTP, a competitive inhibitor of splicing. The two major lead induced cleavages are both located in the conserved core of the intron and at phosphates, which had independently been demonstrated to interact with magnesium ions and to be essential for splicing. Thus, we suggest that the conditions required for lead cleavage occur mainly at those sites, where divalent ions bind that are functionally involved in catalysis. We propose lead cleavage analysis of functional RNA to be a useful tool for mapping functional magnesium ion binding sites.

The TYMV tRNA-like structure

The genomic RNA from turnip yellow mosaic virus presents a 3'-end functionally and structurally related to tRNAs. This report summarizes our knowledge about the peculiar structure of the tRNA-like domain and its interaction with tRNA specific proteins, like RNAse P, tRNA nucleotidyl-transferase, aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases, and elongation factors. It discusses also the biological role of this structure in the viral life cycle. A brief survey of our knowledge of other tRNA mimicries in biological systems, as well as their relevance for understanding canonical tRNA, will also be presented.

A small metalloribozyme with a two-step mechanism

An RNA molecule consisting of an asymmetric internal loop of six nucleotides can be rapidly and specifically cleaved by Pb2+ in the presence of Mg2+. The 5' cleavage product terminates with a 3' phosphomonoester generated from a 2',3'-cyclic phosphodiester reaction intermediate. This two-step reaction mechanism resembles that of many protein ribonucleases but has not previously been observed for reactions catalysed by RNA.

An ultraviolet light-induced crosslink in yeast tRNA(Phe)

The irradiation of native or unmodified yeast tRNA(Phe) by short wavelength UV light (260 nM) results in an intramolecular crosslink that has been mapped to occur between C48 in the variable loop and U59 in the T loop. Photo-reversibility of the crosslink and the absence of fluorescent photo adducts suggest that the crosslink product is a cytidine-uridine cyclobutane dimer. This is consistent with the relative geometries of C48 and U59 in the crystal structure of yeast tRNA(Phe). Evaluation of the crosslinking efficiency of the mutants of tRNA(Phe) indicates that the reaction depends on the correct tertiary structure of the RNA.