Ragweed immunotherapy in adult asthma

[Specific immunotherapy]

Increase of the prevalence of allergy these last 20 years is in part secondary to the modification of the allergenic charge of our environment. The specific immunotherapy (SIT) is the only etiologic treatment of the allergic disease and numbers of authors believe that, for the future, this treatment could change the natural history of the respiratory allergy, provided that it is realised early in the first years of life. Several experimental studies show that the process of the SIT could be the restoration of the Th1 cell/Th2 cell balance which is reversed in allergies. However, indications of SIT have to be carefully selected. The ideal indication is the single sensitized asthma, and treatment has to be started in the first years of life, at the onset of the asthmatic disease, before a definitive remodelling of the respiratory airways induced by inflammation. Subcutaneous SIT is for the moment the only effective route confirmed by several controlled trials, in particular for grass pollens, possibly for house dust, pet danders and mite allergens. Risk of syndromic effects, present all the time of the SIT protocol, can be prevented by rigorous use of the SIT according to the European consensus. The advent of recombinant allergens, in particular by complementary DNA (cDNA) modified by site-directed mutagenesis, could tip the immune response to a Th-1 like response instead of a Th-2 like response (IgE mediated) and result in a better tolerated and more efficacy immunomodulation.

Effectiveness of specific immunotherapy in the treatment of asthma: a meta-analysis of prospective, randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled studies

BACKGROUND

Despite decades of positive experience with specific immunotherapy (SIT) in the treatment of asthma, outcomes associated with SIT have not been evaluated.

OBJECTIVE

This meta-analysis was conducted to compare the effects of SIT plus medical treatment with those of SIT without medical treatment in patients with asthma.

METHODS

All studies of SIT in patients with asthma published in English between the years 1966 and 1998 were identified through a MEDLINE search. All prospective, randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled studies of SIT identified by the search were included in the meta-analysis. One author (R.N.R.) extracted data from these studies. Odds ratios (ORs) and 95% confidence intervals (CIs) were calculated using a random-effects model.

RESULTS

Data were extracted from 24 identified studies of the clinical effectiveness of SIT in the treatment of asthma, involving 962 asthmatic patients with documented allergy. Immunotherapy was judged effective in 17 (71%) of the 24 studies, ineffective in 4 (17%), and equivocal in 3 (12%) (chi2 = 15.25, df = 2, P = 0.0005). Symptoms of asthma were more likely to improve in patients who received SIT than in patients who received placebo (OR 2.76, 95% CI 2.22 to 3.42). Results also favored the immunotherapy group for improvement in pulmonary function (OR 2.87, 95% CI 1.82 to 4.52), protection against bronchial challenge (OR 1.81, 95% CI 1.32 to 2.49), and reduced need for medications (OR 2.00, 95% CI 1.46 to 2.72).

CONCLUSION

The findings of this meta-analysis support the conclusion that SIT is effective in a population of patients with allergen-triggered asthma.

The consideration of immunotherapy in the treatment of allergic asthma

Immunotherapy has undergone rigorous trials to assess its therapeutic benefit in the treatment of allergic respiratory disease. The tools of molecular biology have provided a framework with which to begin to understand the mechanistic effects of immunotherapy on the underlying inflammatory component of allergic respiratory disease. The clinical relevance of these observations belies our understanding of allergic inflammation as the subsoil for the development of abnormal airway physiology, heightened bronchial reactivity, and the development of chronic asthmatic symptoms. Immunotherapy provides the potential to downregulate this inflammatory cascade, reduce IgE antibody production, and attenuate symptoms. Conceptually, early intervention of allergic disease holds the most promise as a therapeutic intervention capable of arresting the progression of the disease, altering the severity of the disease, and/or preventing the development of the respiratory disease process.

Economic evaluation of specific immunotherapy versus symptomatic treatment of allergic rhinitis in Germany

OBJECTIVE

To use published data to compare the economic consequences of specific immunotherapy (SIT) lasting 3 years with those of continuous symptomatic treatment in patients with either pollen or mite allergy.

DESIGN AND SETTING

The evaluation was conducted from the following 3 perspectives in Germany: (i) society; (ii) healthcare system; and (iii) statutory health insurance (SHI) provider. A modelling approach was used which was based on secondary analysis of existing data. The follow-up period was 10 years. The break-even point of cumulated costs, their difference per patient and the additional cost per additional patient free from asthma symptoms [incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER)] were used as target variables, each from the viewpoint of SIT. The types of costs were direct and indirect (society), direct (healthcare system) and those incurred by SHI (i.e. expenses). In the base-case analysis, the average values of the clinical parameters and average case-related costs/expenses were applied.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES AND RESULTS

The break-even point was reached between year 6 and year 8 after the start of therapy, resulting in net savings of between 650 and 1190 deutschmarks (DM) per patient after 10 years. The ICERs of SIT were between -DM3640 and -DM7410, depending on study perspective and nature of the allergy (1990 values for symptomatic treatment and treatment of asthma, 1995 values for SIT; DM1 approximately $US0.58). The sensitivity analysis demonstrated the robustness of the model and its results. First, all the independent variables of the model were varied. Secondly, the influence of the model variables was quantified using a deterministic model. SIT was more likely to result in net savings than in additional costs. An economic parameter (cost for symptomatic treatment) had the highest influence on the results.

CONCLUSIONS

This evaluation showed that SIT for 3 years is economically advantageous in patients who are allergic to pollen or mites and whose symptoms are inadequately controlled by continuous symptomatic treatment. After 10 years, the administration of SIT leads to net savings from the perspectives of society, the healthcare system and SHI (third-party payer) in Germany.

Recent advances in alternative therapies

Complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) is becoming more popular, and CAM remedies are used instead of, or integrated with, orthodox allopathic therapies by many patients with asthma. Although most CAM remedies may have no discernible effects when analyzed by conventional medical techniques, some double-blind controlled studies do suggest that a meaningful benefit can be obtained with acupunture and homeopathic management in asthma. Herbal medicine is more popular, despite little evidence that the vast majority of herbs for asthma have any useful effects other than a nonspecific expectorant action. Dietary adjustment may benefit a small percentage of patients with asthma, but extreme measures are very rarely indicated. Formal pyschologic approaches can help some patients by reducing anxiety. Although most CAM approaches are harmless, the lack of benefit of many remedies and the potential harm from some of them must be recognized.

The safety and efficacy of ALLERVAX CAT in cat allergic patients

Conventional immunotherapy for cat allergy is effective in reducing cat allergy symptoms in many patients, but this type of immunotherapy can cause severe reactions, including anaphylaxis, and often requires years of injections for successful desensitization. To improve the efficacy of immunotherapy for cat allergic patients, synthetic cat allergen peptides (ALLERVAX CAT) were generated, based on analysis of the immunodominant T cell epitopes of cat allergen. These peptides lack the tertiary structure of native Fel d1 and possess a significantly reduced capacity to bind to Fel d1-specific IgE. Using these peptides, we performed a multicenter, randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study of 133 cat allergic patients chronically exposed to cats or who had failed previous conventional cat immunotherapy. We evaluated the safety of ALLERVAX CAT treatment and determined whether ALLERVAX CAT treatment improved tolerance to cat allergen, as measured by symptom analysis and pulmonary function testing. Three of the ALLERVAX CAT-treated patients required systemic epinephrine for adverse reactions, but the frequency of all adverse reactions in both groups was not statistically different from that of the placebo group. The majority of adverse events were "late" events, most commonly associated with respiratory symptoms, and these events declined with successive injections. ALLERVAX CAT given at a dose of 750 microg/dose improved pulmonary function in patients with reduced baseline FEV1, and global evaluation of the subjects' ability to tolerate cats improved significantly in the actively treated groups relative to placebo. Thus, although therapy with ALLERVAX CAT is associated with some adverse events in patients with severe cat sensitivity, such therapy is an effective approach for the management of cat allergy, since it improves tolerance to cats and improves pulmonary function in cat allergic patients with reduced FEV1.

Long-term clinical efficacy of grass-pollen immunotherapy

BACKGROUND

Pollen immunotherapy is effective in selected patients with IgE-mediated seasonal allergic rhinitis, although it is questionable whether there is long-term benefit after the discontinuation of treatment.

METHODS

We conducted a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial of the discontinuation of immunotherapy for grass-pollen allergy in patients in whom three to four years of this treatment had previously been shown to be effective. During the three years of this trial, primary outcome measures were scores for seasonal symptoms and the use of rescue medication. Objective measures included the immediate conjunctival response and the immediate and late skin responses to allergen challenge. Cutaneous-biopsy specimens obtained 24 hours after intradermal allergen challenge were examined for T-cell infiltration and the presence of cytokine-producing T helper cells (TH2 cells) (as evidenced by the presence of interleukin-4 messenger RNA). A matched group of patients with hay fever who had not received immunotherapy was followed as a control for the natural course of the disease.

RESULTS

Scores for seasonal symptoms and the use of rescue antiallergic medication, which included short courses of prednisolone, remained low after the discontinuation of immunotherapy, and there was no significant difference between patients who continued immunotherapy and those who discontinued it. Symptom scores in both treatment groups (median areas under the curve in 1995, 921 for continuation of immunotherapy and 504 for discontinuation of immunotherapy; P=0.60) were markedly lower than those in the group that had not received immunotherapy (median value in 1995, 2863). Although there was a tendency for immediate sensitivity to allergen to return late after discontinuation, there was a sustained reduction in the late skin response and associated CD3+ T-cell infiltration and interleukin-4 messenger RNA expression.

CONCLUSIONS

Immunotherapy for grass-pollen allergy for three to four years induces prolonged clinical remission accompanied by a persistent alteration in immunologic reactivity.

National guidelines needed to manage rhinitis and prevent complications

OBJECTIVES

Rhinitis is an extremely common disease worldwide and nasal allergies are one of the major causes of the condition. Allergic rhinitis not only produces a range of nasal and non-nasal symptoms, but it has been closely associated with other chronic airways diseases, such as asthma and sinusitis. This review was undertaken to evaluate the relationship of allergic rhinitis to these diseases and to provide support for proposing national guidelines for managing rhinitis.

DATA SOURCES

Relevant studies in English were searched for using MEDLINE, bibliographies from obtained articles, and consultation with experts.

STUDY SELECTION

All major studies related to the epidemiology and effects of allergic rhinitis and the relationship between allergic rhinitis and asthma, sinusitis, and other airways diseases were reviewed.

DATA SYNTHESIS

There is substantial scientific and clinical evidence that allergic rhinitis frequently coexists with asthma, and sinusitis and may be a predisposing factor for both. In addition, a number of studies have demonstrated that nasal inflammation and obstruction directly affect pulmonary function and clinical symptoms of asthma. Finally, it has been clearly demonstrated that treating allergic rhinitis with antihistamines, nasal corticosteroids, immunotherapy, and allergen avoidance have a significant, positive effect on lung function and asthma symptomology.

CONCLUSIONS

The prevalence of allergic rhinitis, asthma, and sinusitis are increasing. Asthma and sinusitis can be debilitating conditions. Asthma alone can be life threatening and costly to treat. The timely and optimal treatment of allergic rhinitis may help prevent these conditions or, at least, prevent them from worsening. Consequently, there is an immediate need to establish national, evidence-based, practice guidelines to assist primary care physicians in diagnosing and managing rhinitis and in evaluating and managing rhinitis and in evaluating and managing allergic rhinitis coexisting with other airways diseases.

DNA-Based immunization for asthma

BACKGROUND

Immunostimulatory DNA sequences (ISS) containing a CpG motif are able to inhibit Th2-mediated airway eosinophilia and bronchial hyperresponsiveness in a mouse model of asthma.

METHODS

To determine the optimal frequency and timing of intervention with ISS in inhibiting Th2 cytokine production and airway eosinophilia, we used ISS administration protocols which differed in the frequency (one vs. two doses), route (systemic vs. mucosal) and timing of ISS administration (before or together with antigen) in a mouse model of ovalbumin-induced eosinophilic airway inflammation.

RESULTS

ISS induced Th1 cytokine production (IFN-gamma) and effectively inhibited Th2 cytokine production (IL-5) as well as eosinophilic inflammation when ISS was administered before or coadministered with inhaled allergen challenge. Although ISS was effective when coadministered with inhaled allergen, it was most effective when administered once 6 days prior to allergen challenge. Mucosal (intranasal and intratracheal) delivery of ISS was as effective as systemic (intraperitoneal) ISS delivery in inhibiting airway eosinophilia and switching cytokine responses from a Th2 to a Th1 response.

CONCLUSIONS

ISS is most effective in inhibiting airway eosinophilia when administered as a single dose 6 days prior to antigen inhalation. However, ISS can also significantly inhibit eosinophilic inflammation, when coadministered with antigen inhalation. Thus, ISS administered prior or together with allergen should be considered as a novel method of allergen-based immunotherapy.

Immunostimulatory DNA Sequences Inhibit IL-5, Eosinophilic Inflammation, and Airway Hyperresponsiveness in Mice

We have used a mouse model of allergen-induced airway hyperresponsiveness to demonstrate that immunostimulatory DNA sequences (ISS) containing a CpG DNA motif significantly inhibit airway eosinophilia and reduce responsiveness to inhaled methacholine. ISS not only inhibited eosinophilia of the airway (by 93%) and lung parenchyma (91%), but also significantly inhibited blood eosinophilia (86%), suggesting that ISS was exerting a significant effect on the bone marrow production of eosinophils. The inhibition of the bone marrow production of eosinophils by 58% was associated with a significant inhibition of T cell-derived cytokine generation (IL-5, granulocyte-macrophage CSF, and IL-3). ISS exerted this inhibitory effect on T cell cytokine production indirectly by stimulating monocytes/macrophages and NK cells to generate IL-12 and IFNs. The onset of the ISS effect on reducing the number of tissue eosinophils was both immediate (within 1 day of administration) and sustained (lasted 6 days), and was not due to ISS directly inducing eosinophil apoptosis. ISS was effective in inhibiting eosinophilic airway inflammation when administered either systemically (i.p.), or mucosally (i.e., intranasally or intratracheally). Interestingly, a single dose of ISS inhibited airway eosinophilia as effectively as daily injections of corticosteroids for 7 days. Moreover, while both ISS and corticosteroids inhibited IL-5 generation, only ISS was able to induce allergen-specific IFN-γ production and redirect the immune system toward a Th1 response. Thus, systemic or mucosal administration of ISS before allergen exposure could provide a novel form of active immunotherapy in allergic diseases.

Allergen immunotherapy inhibits airway eosinophilia and hyperresponsiveness associated with decreased IL-4 production by lymphocytes in a murine model of allergic asthma

In the present study, we investigated whether allergen immunotherapy is effective in a murine model with immunologic and pathophysiologic features reminiscent of allergic asthma. Ovalbumin-sensitized mice received increasing (1 microgram to 1 mg) subcutaneous doses of ovalbumin twice a week for 8 wk according to a semirush immunotherapy protocol as used in allergic patients. During immunotherapy, an initial rise in serum levels of ovalbumin-specific antibodies (immunoglobulin [Ig]G1, IgE, IgG2a) occurred, after which IgE levels decreased sharply concomitant with an increase in IgG2a levels. The increase in IgG2a levels, with the decline in IgE levels, suggests that during immunotherapy interferon-gamma production is increased or interleukin (IL)-4 production is decreased. After immunotherapy, inhalation challenge of the mice with ovalbumin revealed almost complete inhibition (98%, P < 0.01) of eosinophil infiltration into bronchoalveolar lavage and airway hyperresponsiveness (100% at 320 microgram/kg methacholine, P < 0.05) compared with sham-treated animals. In addition, IL-4 production of thoracic lymph node cells stimulated with ovalbumin in vitro was largely reduced (60%, P < 0.05) after immunotherapy. Thus, effective immunotherapy in this animal model appears to be due to modulation of antigen-specific T cells. Similar effects on airway symptoms and IL-4 production can be obtained within 1 wk by three injections of the highest dose of ovalbumin (1 mg). This animal model will be used as a preclinical model to improve allergen immunotherapy and to gain more insight into the mechanisms involved.

Future directions for allergen immunotherapy

Over the last 30 years several approaches to modify immunotherapy have been tested, including allergoids, alum precipitation, and most recently peptides. However, none of these have replaced the traditional regimens. Over the same period our scientific understanding of allergic disease has been transformed. Today it is possible to identify and monitor changes occurring during treatment and to target many different aspects of the immune system. Recombinant technology provides a powerful technique both for sequencing proteins and producing allergens in commercial quantities. The recombinant proteins can be modified by site-directed mutagenesis so as to decrease their reactivity with IgE antibodies while maintaining reactivity with T cells. Knowledge of the tertiary structure of allergens will make it simpler to identify and change surface epitopes. A completely different approach is to use plasmids to introduce the genes for an allergen. The strength of this technique is that the plasmid can be designed to control expression and also to influence the cytokine profile of the response or the isotype of antibodies produced. Finally, different adjuvants can be used with proteins to alter the response. These include IL-12, immunostimulatory sequences of DNA, and bacterial proteins such as those used in HibVax. It is now possible to identify the cells that control the immune response to allergens and to design treatments that will either downregulate or change the response of T cells. The challenge is to transform this information into an effective treatment for allergic disease.

IgE responses to Dermatophagoides pteronyssinus native major allergens Der p 1 and Der p 2 during long-term specific immunotherapy

We investigated by ELISA the IgE response to whole extract of the house-dust mite Dermatophagoides pteronyssinus (Dp) and to the native major allergens, Der p 1 and Der p 2, in sera from 18 adult patients (group A) with Dp-allergic asthma before (t0) and 1, 2, 3, and 4 (t1-t4) years after subcutaneous specific immunotherapy (SIT). A qualitative reduction (P = 0.05) of the IgE responses to Dp and Der p 2 was observed from t1 to t4, but a highly statistical significant decrease appeared at t3 (P < 0.01). With regard to Der p 1 IgE values, the immunotherapy induced a significant decrease (P < 0.01) at t3, but not before. In group A, the IgE responses to Der p 1 and Der p 2 were not correlated at t0 (rs = 0.31; P = 0.21) but were correlated at t3 (rs = 0.78; P = 0.001). We also examined sera from 14 adult patients (group B, same SIT schedule as group A) who were without respiratory symptoms at the end of the third year (t3) of Dp SIT. At this time (t3), there were no significant differences in Der p 1 and Der p 2 IgE levels between group A and group B.

Wasp venom immunotherapy changes IgG antibody specificity

BACKGROUND

The evolution of the IgG response during venom immunotherapy (VIT) has been previously investigated in terms of antibody titres and subclasses.

OBJECTIVES

The present work studied the evolution of IgG antibody fine specificity in wasp allergic patients treated with rush VIT.

METHODS

Antibody specificity was evaluated in 51 wasp allergic patients in competitive ELISA using streptavidin biotin technology. Patients were tested before and during specific rush immunotherapy (at 15 days, 6 months, 12 months) and compared with 44 patients treated by venom injections for at least 2 years.

RESULTS

The capacity of sera to prevent the antigen binding of pooled IgG from allergic patients changed rapidly with mean percentage inhibitions (+/-SD) falling from 70+/-11-51+/-18% after 15 days of treatment (P<0.001 by one way ANOVA). Similarly, the antigen binding capacity of pooled IgG from VIT patients was differently prevented by sera with mean percentage inhibitions increasing from 37+/-12-65+/-8 after 15 days of treatment (P< 0.0001 by one-way ANOVA).

CONCLUSIONS

The immunodominance pattern of IgG epitopes recognized on wasp venom antigens by sera from wasp allergic patients changes soon after initiating rush VIT. Further studies will indicate whether, instead of measuring IgG titres, this marked change could be used as the basis of a new test for monitoring the outcome of VIT.

A controlled trial of immunotherapy for asthma in allergic children

BACKGROUND

Injections of allergens are widely prescribed for patients with asthma, but little is known about the effectiveness of immunotherapy.

METHODS

We conducted a double-blind, placebo-controlled trial of multiple-allergen immunotherapy in 121 allergic children with moderate-to-severe, perennial asthma. The children, who required daily medication for their asthma, were randomly assigned to receive subcutaneous injections of either a mixture of up to seven aeroallergen extracts or a placebo. Maintenance injections were continued for 18 months or longer. Medications were adjusted every two to three weeks on the basis of peak flow rates and symptoms. The principal outcome was the daily medication score. Bronchial sensitivity to methacholine (the concentration provoking a 20 percent decrease in the forced expiratory volume in one second [PC20]) was measured twice yearly.

RESULTS

The median medication score declined from 5.4 to 4.9 in the immunotherapy group (P<0.001) and from 5.2 to 5.0 in the placebo group (P<0.001), but there was no significant difference between the groups (P>0.6). The number of days on which oral corticosteroids were used was similar in the two groups. Partial or complete remission of asthma occurred in 31 percent of the immunotherapy group and in 28 percent of the placebo group (P>0.5). There was no difference between the groups in the use of medical care, symptoms, or peak flow rates. The median PC20 increased significantly in both groups, but again with no difference between the two groups.

CONCLUSIONS

Immunotherapy with injections of allergens for over two years was of no discernible benefit in allergic children with perennial asthma who were receiving appropriate medical treatment.

Development of immune functions related to allergic mechanisms in young children

The newborn immune system differs quantitatively and functionally from that of adults. Development of the immune system has important implications for childhood diseases. The immaturity of the immune system in the first years of life may contribute to failure of tolerance induction and in the development of allergic disease. T cell function is diminished, especially the capacity to produce cytokines; production of interferon (IFN)-gamma, and IL-4 is strongly reduced. IFN-gamma has been found to be even lower in cord blood of newborns with a family history of atopy. Differences in other cell types (natural killer cells, antigen-presenting cells, and B cells) could also play a role in the development of allergic disease. Current data suggest that irregularities in IgE synthesis, helper T cell subsets (Th1, Th2, CD45RA, and CD45RO), cytokines (IL-4, IFN-gamma), and possibly other cell types may play a role in the development of allergy in childhood. Moreover, the role of cell surface molecules, like co-stimulatory molecules (CD28, CD40L), activation markers (CD25), and adhesion molecules (LFA-1/ICAM-1, VLA-4/ VCAM-1) is also discussed. These variables are modulated by genetic (relevant loci are identified on chromosome 5q, 11q, and 14) and environmental forces (allergen exposure, viral infections, and smoke). The low sensitivity of current predictive factors for the development of allergic diseases, such as cord blood IgE levels, improves in combination with family history and by measurement of in vitro responses of lymphocytes and skin reactivity to allergens. New therapeutic approaches are being considered on the basis of our current understanding of the immunopathology of allergic disease, for instance cytokine therapy and vaccination with tolerizing doses of allergen or peptides.