DNA ligase IV-deficient cells are more resistant to ionizing radiation in the absence of Ku70: Implications for DNA double-strand break repair

An overview of three new disorders associated with genetic instability: LIG4 syndrome, RS-SCID and ATR-Seckel syndrome

Around 15-20 hereditary disorders associated with impaired DNA damage response mechanisms have been previously described. The range of clinical features associated with these disorders attests to the significant role that these pathways play during development. Recently, three new such disorders have been reported extending the importance of the damage response pathways to human health. LIG4 syndrome is conferred by hypomorphic mutations in DNA ligase IV, an essential component of DNA non-homologous end-joining (NHEJ), and is associated with pancytopaenia, developmental and growth delay and dysmorphic facial features. Radiosensitive severe combined immunodeficiency (RS-SCID) is caused by mutations in Artemis, a protein that plays a subsidiary role in non-homologous end-joining although it is not an essential component. RS-SCID is characterised by severe combined immunodeficiency but patients have no overt developmental abnormalities. ATR-Seckel syndrome is caused by mutations in ataxia telangiectasia and Rad3 related protein (ATR), a component of a DNA damage signalling pathway. ATR-Seckel syndrome patients have dramatic microcephaly and marked growth and developmental delay. The clinical features of these patients are considered in the light of the function of the defective protein.

Genetic evidence for involvement of two distinct nonhomologous end-joining pathways in repair of topoisomerase II-mediated DNA damage

In vertebrate cells, DNA double-strand breaks are efficiently repaired by homologous recombination or nonhomologous end-joining (NHEJ). The latter pathway relies on Ku (the Ku70/Ku86 heterodimer), DNA-PKcs, Artemis, Xrcc4, and DNA ligase IV (Lig4). Here, we show that a human pre-B cell line nullizygous for Lig4 exhibits hypersensitivity to topoisomerase II (Top2) inhibitors, demonstrating a crucial role for the NHEJ pathway in repair of Top2-induced DNA damage in vertebrates. We also show that in the chicken DT40 cell line, all NHEJ mutants (i.e., Ku70-, Lig4-, and DNA-PKcs-null cells) are equally hypersensitive to the Top2 inhibitor ICRF-193, indicating that the drug-induced damage is repaired by NHEJ involving DNA-PKcs. Intriguingly, however, DNA-PKcs-null cells display considerably less severe phenotype than other NHEJ mutants in terms of hypersensitivity to VP-16, a Top2 poison that stabilizes cleavable complexes. The results indicate that two distinct NHEJ pathways, involving or not involving DNA-PKcs, are important for the repair of VP-16-induced DNA damage, providing additional evidence for the biological relevance of DNA-PKcs-independent NHEJ. Our results provide significant insights into the mechanisms of repair of Top2-mediated DNA damage, with implications for chemotherapy involving Top2 inhibitors.

Loss of nonhomologous end joining confers camptothecin resistance in DT40 cells. Implications for the repair of topoisomerase I-mediated DNA damage

DNA topoisomerase I (Top1) generates transient DNA single-strand breaks via the formation of cleavage complexes in which the enzyme is linked to the 3'-phosphate of the cleavage strand. The anticancer drug camptothecin (CPT) poisons Top1 by trapping cleavage complexes, thereby inducing Top1-linked single-strand breaks. Such DNA lesions are converted into DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) upon collision with replication forks, implying that DSB repair pathways could be involved in the processing/repair of Top1-mediated DNA damage. Here we report that Top1-mediated DNA damage is repaired primarily by homologous recombination, a major pathway of DSB repair. Unexpectedly, however, we found that nonhomologous end joining (NHEJ), another DSB repair pathway, has no positive role in the relevant repair; notably, DT40 cell mutants lacking either of the NHEJ factors (namely, Ku70, DNA-dependent protein kinase catalytic subunit, and DNA ligase IV) were resistant to killing by CPT. In addition, we showed that the absence of NHEJ alleviates the requirement of homologous recombination in the repair of CPT-induced DNA damage. Our results indicate that NHEJ can be a cytotoxic pathway in the presence of CPT, shedding new light on the molecular mechanisms for the formation and repair of Top1-mediated DNA damage in vertebrates. Thus, our data have significant implications for cancer chemotherapy involving Top1 inhibitors.

Cell cycle-dependent regulation of a human DNA helicase that localizes in DNA damage foci

Mutational studies of human DNA helicase B (HDHB) have suggested that its activity is critical for the G1/S transition of the cell cycle, but the nature of its role remains unknown. In this study, we show that during G1, ectopically expressed HDHB localizes in nuclear foci induced by DNA damaging agents and that this focal pattern requires active HDHB. During S and G2/M, HDHB localizes primarily in the cytoplasm. A carboxy-terminal domain from HDHB confers cell cycle-dependent localization, but not the focal pattern, to a reporter protein. A cluster of potential cyclin-dependent kinase phosphorylation sites in this domain was modified at the G1/S transition and maintained through G2/M of the cell cycle in vivo, coincident with nuclear export of HDHB. Serine 967 of HDHB was the major site phosphorylated in vivo and in vitro by cyclin-dependent kinases. Mutational analysis demonstrated that phosphorylation of serine 967 is crucial in regulating the subcellular localization of ectopically expressed HDHB. We propose that the helicase of HDHB operates primarily during G1 to process endogenous DNA damage before the G1/S transition, and it is largely sequestered in the cytoplasm during S/G2.

Mechanism and regulation of human non-homologous DNA end-joining

Non-homologous DNA end-joining (NHEJ)--the main pathway for repairing double-stranded DNA breaks--functions throughout the cell cycle to repair such lesions. Defects in NHEJ result in marked sensitivity to ionizing radiation and ablation of lymphocytes, which rely on NHEJ to complete the rearrangement of antigen-receptor genes. NHEJ is typically imprecise, a characteristic that is useful for immune diversification in lymphocytes, but which might also contribute to some of the genetic changes that underlie cancer and ageing.

Hypersensitivity of nonhomologous DNA end-joining mutants to VP-16 and ICRF-193: implications for the repair of topoisomerase II-mediated DNA damage

A number of clinically useful anticancer drugs, including etoposide (VP-16), target DNA topoisomerase (topo) II. These drugs, referred to as topo II poisons, stabilize cleavable complexes, thereby generating DNA double-strand breaks. Bis-2,6-dioxopiperazines such as ICRF-193 also inhibit topo II by inducing a distinct type of DNA damage, termed topo II clamps, which has been believed to be devoid of double-strand breaks. Despite the biological and clinical importance, the molecular mechanisms for the repair of topo II-mediated DNA damage remain largely unknown. Here, we perform genetic analyses using the chicken DT40 cell line to investigate how DNA lesions caused by topo II inhibitors are repaired. Notably, we show that LIG4-/- and KU70-/- cells, which are defective in nonhomologous DNA end-joining (NHEJ), are extremely sensitive to both VP-16 and ICRF-193. In contrast, RAD54-/- cells (defective in homologous recombination) are much less hypersensitive to VP-16 than the NHEJ mutants and, more importantly, are not hypersensitive to ICRF-193. Our results provide the first evidence that NHEJ is the predominant pathway for the repair of topo II-mediated DNA damage; that is, cleavable complexes and topo II clamps. The outstandingly increased cytotoxicity of topo II inhibitors in the absence of NHEJ suggests that simultaneous inhibition of topo II and NHEJ would provide a powerful protocol in cancer chemotherapy involving topo II inhibitors.

Biochemical evidence for Ku-independent backup pathways of NHEJ

Cells of higher eukaryotes process within minutes double strand breaks (DSBs) in their genome using a non-homologous end joining (NHEJ) apparatus that engages DNA-PKcs, Ku, DNA ligase IV, XRCC4 and other as of yet unidentified factors. Although chemical inhibition, or mutation, in any of these factors delays processing, cells ultimately remove the majority of DNA DSBs using an alternative pathway operating with an order of magnitude slower kinetics. This alternative pathway is active in mutants deficient in genes of the RAD52 epistasis group and frequently joins incorrect ends. We proposed, therefore, that it reflects an alternative form of NHEJ that operates as a backup (B-NHEJ) to the DNA-PK-dependent (D-NHEJ) pathway, rather than homology directed repair of DSBs. The present study investigates the role of Ku in the coordination of these pathways using as a model end joining of restriction endonuclease linearized plasmid DNA in whole cell extracts. Efficient, error-free, end joining observed in such in vitro reactions is strongly inhibited by anti-Ku antibodies. The inhibition requires DNA-PKcs, despite the fact that Ku efficiently binds DNA ends in the presence of antibodies, or in the absence of DNA-PKcs. Strong inhibition of DNA end joining is also mediated by wortmannin, an inhibitor of DNA-PKcs, in the presence but not in the absence of Ku, and this inhibition can be rescued by pre-incubating the reaction with double stranded oligonucleotides. The results are compatible with a role of Ku in directing end joining to a DNA-PK dependent pathway, mediated by efficient end binding and productive interactions with DNA-PKcs. On the other hand, efficient end joining is observed in extracts of cells lacking DNA-PKcs, as well as in Ku-depleted extracts in line with the operation of alternative pathways. Extracts depleted of Ku and DNA-PKcs rejoin blunt ends, as well as homologous ends with 3' or 5' protruding single strands with similar efficiency, but addition of Ku suppresses joining of blunt ends and homologous ends with 3' overhangs. We propose that the affinity of Ku for DNA ends, particularly when cooperating with DNA-PKcs, suppresses B-NHEJ by quickly and efficiently binding DNA ends and directing them to D-NHEJ for rapid joining. A chromatin-based model of DNA DSB rejoining accommodating biochemical and genetic results is presented and deviations between in vitro and in vivo results discussed.

Paradoxical decrease in mutant frequencies and chromosomal rearrangements in a transgenic lacZ reporter gene in Ku80 null mice deficient in DNA double strand break repair

Repair of DNA double strand breaks (DSB), either by homologous recombination (HR) or nonhomologous end-joining (NHEJ), is essential to maintain genomic stability. To examine the impact of NHEJ deficiency on genomic integrity in Ku80 null (Ku-) mice, the chromosomally integrated shuttle vector pUR288, which includes a lacZ reporter gene, was used to measure mutations in vivo. Unexpectedly, a significant decrease was found in mutant frequencies of Ku- liver (5.04x10(-5)) and brain (4.55x10(-5)) compared to tissues obtained from normal (Ku+) littermates (7.92x10(-5)and 7.30x10(-5), respectively). No significant difference was found in mutant frequencies in spleen from Ku- (7.21x10(-5)) and Ku+ mice (8.16x10(-5)). The determination of the mutant spectrum in lacZ revealed the almost complete absence of chromosomal rearrangements (R) in Ku- tissues (0.5%, 3/616), a notable distinction from Ku+ controls (16.7%, 104/621). These findings suggest that accurate repair of DSB by HR and elimination of cells with unrepaired DNA damage by apoptosis are capable of maintaining genomic stability of the lacZ reporter in Ku- mice.

The embryonic lethality in DNA ligase IV-deficient mice is rescued by deletion of Ku: implications for unifying the heterogeneous phenotypes of NHEJ mutants

There are two general pathways by which multicellular eukaryotes repair double-strand DNA breaks (DSB): homologous recombination (HR) and nonhomologous DNA end joining (NHEJ). All mammalian mutants in the NHEJ pathway demonstrate a lack of B and T lymphocytes and ionizing radiation sensitivity. Among these NHEJ mutants, the DNA-PK(cs) and Artemis mutants are the least severe, having no obvious phenotype other than the general defects described above. Ku mutants have an intermediate severity with accelerated senescence. The XRCC4 and DNA ligase IV mutants are the most severe, resulting in embryonic lethality. Here we show that the lethality of DNA ligase IV-deficiency in the mouse can be rescued when Ku86 is also absent. To explain the fact that simultaneous gene mutations in the NHEJ pathway can lead to viability when a single mutant is not viable, we propose a nuclease/ligase model. In this model, disrupted NHEJ is more severe if the Artemis:DNA-PK(cs) nuclease is present in the absence of a ligase, and Ku mutants are of intermediate severity, because the nuclease is less efficient. This model is also consistent with the order of severity in organismal phenotypes; consistent with chromosomal breakage observations reported here; and consistent with the NHEJ mutation identified in radiation sensitive human SCID patients.

Dynamic mechanism of nick recognition by DNA ligase

DNA ligases are the enzymes responsible for the repair of single-stranded and double-stranded nicks in dsDNA. DNA ligases are structurally similar, possibly sharing a common molecular mechanism of nick recognition and ligation catalysis. This mechanism remains unclear, in part because the structure of ligase in complex with dsDNA has yet to be solved. DNA ligases share common structural elements with DNA polymerases, which have been cocrystallized with dsDNA. Based on the observed DNA polymerase-dsDNA interactions, we propose a mechanism for recognition of a single-stranded nick by DNA ligase. According to this mechanism, ligase induces a B-to-A DNA helix transition of the enzyme-bound dsDNA motif, which results in DNA contraction, bending and unwinding. For non-nicked dsDNA, this transition is reversible, leading to dissociation of the enzyme. For a nicked dsDNA substrate, the contraction of the enzyme-bound DNA motif (a) triggers an opened-closed conformational change of the enzyme, and (b) forces the motif to accommodate the strained A/B-form hybrid conformation, in which the nicked strand tends to retain a B-type helix, while the non-nicked strand tends to form a shortened A-type helix. We propose that this conformation is the catalytically competent transition state, which leads to the formation of the DNA-AMP intermediate and to the subsequent sealing of the nick.

Disruption of the Arabidopsis AtKu80 gene demonstrates an essential role for AtKu80 protein in efficient repair of DNA double-strand breaks in vivo

Double-strand breaks (DSBs) in DNA may occur spontaneously in the cell or be induced experimentally by gamma-irradiation, and represent one of the most serious threats to genomic integrity. Non-homologous end joining (NHEJ) rather than homologous recombination appears to be the major pathway for DSB repair in humans and plants, and it may also be the major route whereby T-DNA integrates into the plant genome during cell transformation. In yeast and mammals, the exposed ends of damaged DNA are bound with high affinity by a dimer of Ku70 and Ku80 proteins, which protects the ends from exonucleases and juxtaposes the two ends of the DSB, independent of sequence homology. Here we report the functional characterization of Ku70 and Ku80 from Arabidopsis thaliana, and demonstrate that AtKu80 and AtKu70 form a heterodimer with DNA binding activity that is specific for DNA ends. An atku80 knockout mutant shows hypersensitivity to the DNA-damaging agents menadione and bleomycin, consistent with a role for AtKu80 in the repair of DSBs in vivo in Arabidopsis.

DNA damage response pathway in radioadaptive response

Radioadaptive response is a biological defense mechanism in which low-dose ionizing irradiation elicits cellular resistance to the genotoxic effects of subsequent irradiation. However, its molecular mechanism remains largely unknown. We previously demonstrated that the dose recognition and adaptive response could be mediated by a feedback signaling pathway involving protein kinase C (PKC), p38 mitogen activated protein kinase (p38MAPK) and phospholipase C (PLC). Further, to elucidate the downstream effector pathway, we studied the X-ray-induced adaptive response in cultured mouse and human cells with different genetic background relevant to the DNA damage response pathway, such as deficiencies in TP53, DNA-PKcs, ATM and FANCA genes. The results showed that p53 protein played a key role in the adaptive response while DNA-PKcs, ATM and FANCA were not responsible. Wortmannin, a specific inhibitor of phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase (PI3K), mimicked the priming irradiation in that the inhibitor alone rendered the cells resistant against the induction of chromosome aberrations and apoptosis by the subsequent X-ray irradiation. The adaptive response, whether it was afforded by low-dose X-rays or wortmannin, occurred in parallel with the reduction of apoptotic cell death by challenging doses. The inhibitor of p38MAPK which blocks the adaptive response did not suppress apoptosis. These observations indicate that the adaptive response and apoptotic cell death constitute a complementary defense system via life-or-death decisions. The p53 has a pivotal role in channeling the radiation-induced DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) into an adaptive legitimate repair pathway, where the signals are integrated into p53 by a circuitous PKC-p38MAPK-PLC damage sensing pathway, and hence turning off the signals to an alternative pathway to illegitimate repair and apoptosis. A possible molecular mechanism of adaptive response to low-dose ionizing irradiation has been discussed in relation to the repair of DSBs and implicated to the current controversial observations on the expression of adaptive response.

Vertebrate cells lacking FEN-1 endonuclease are viable but hypersensitive to methylating agents and H2O2

The structure-specific FEN-1 endonuclease has been implicated in various cellular processes, including DNA replication, repair and recombination. In vertebrate cells, however, no in vivo evidence has been provided so far. Here, we knocked out the FEN-1 gene (FEN1) in the chicken DT40 cell line. Surprisingly, homozygous mutant (FEN1-/-) cells were viable, indicating that FEN-1 is not essential for cell proliferation and thus for Okazaki fragment processing during DNA replication. However, compared with wild-type cells, FEN1-/- cells exhibited a slow growth phenotype, probably due to a high rate of cell death. The mutant cells were hypersensitive to methylmethane sulfonate, N-methyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine and H2O2, but not to UV light, X-rays and etoposide, suggesting that FEN-1 functions in base excision repair in vertebrate cells.

DNA damage: air-breaks?

Cells deficient in repairing DNA double-strand breaks have an increased level of spontaneous chromosomal aberrations. Modulating the level of molecular oxygen and its reactive metabolites demonstrates that oxygen metabolism is a major source of genomic instability.

Oxygen metabolism causes chromosome breaks and is associated with the neuronal apoptosis observed in DNA double-strand break repair mutants

Cells deficient in a major DNA double-strand break repair pathway (nonhomologous DNA end joining [NHEJ]) have increased spontaneous chromosome breaks; however, the source of these chromosome breaks has remained undefined. Here, we show that the observed spontaneous chromosome breaks are partially suppressed by reducing the cellular oxygen tension. Conversely, elevating the level of reactive oxygen species by overexpressing the antioxidant enzyme superoxide dismutase 1 (SOD1), in a transgenic mouse, increases chromosome breakage. The effect of SOD1 can also be modulated by cellular oxygen tension. The elevated chromosome breakage correlates histologically with a significant increase in the amount of neuronal cell death in Ku86(-/-) SOD1 transgenic embryos over that seen in Ku86(-/-) embryos. Therefore, oxygen metabolism is a major source of the genomic instability observed in NHEJ-deficient cells and, presumably, in all cells.

Genetic analysis of the DNA-dependent protein kinase reveals an inhibitory role of Ku in late S-G2 phase DNA double-strand break repair

Two major complementary double-strand break (DSB) repair pathways exist in vertebrates, homologous recombination (HR), which involves Rad54, and non-homologous end-joining, which requires the DNA-dependent protein kinase (DNA-PK). DNA-PK comprises a catalytic subunit (DNA-PKcs) and a DNA-binding Ku70 and Ku80 heterodimer. To define the activities of individual DNA-PK components in DSB repair, we targeted the DNA-PKcs gene in chicken DT40 cells. DNA-PKcs deficiency caused a DSB repair defect that was, unexpectedly, suppressed by KU70 disruption. We have shown previously that genetic ablation of Ku70 confers RAD54-dependent radioresistance on S-G(2) phase cells, when sister chromatids are available for HR repair. To test whether direct interference by Ku70 with HR might explain the Ku70(-/-)/DNA-PKcs(-/-/-) radioresistance, we monitored HR activities directly in Ku- and DNA-PKcs-deficient cells. The frequency of intrachromosomal HR induced by the I-SceI restriction enzyme was increased in the absence of Ku but not of DNA-PKcs. Significantly, abrogation of HR activity by targeting RAD54 in Ku70(-/-) or DNA-PKcs(-/-/-) cells caused extreme radiosensitivity, suggesting that the relative radioresistance seen with loss of Ku70 was because of HR-dependent repair pathways. Our findings suggest that Ku can interfere with HR-mediated DSB repair, perhaps competing with HR for DSB recognition.