Automated selection of aptamers against protein targets translated in vitro: from gene to aptamer

Application of aptamers in therapeutics and for small-molecule detection

Nucleic acids that can bind with high affinity and specificity to target molecules are called "apta mers". Aptamers recognise a large variety of different molecule classes. The main focus of this chapter is small molecules as targets. Aptamers are applied complementarily to antibody technologies and can substitute antibodies or small molecules wherever their different properties, such as biochemical nature or highly discriminating capacities, are advantageous. Examples of promising applications of these versatile molecules are discussed in the field of therapeutics and biotechnology with a special view to small-molecule detection.

Arginine-rich motifs present multiple interfaces for specific binding by RNA

A number of proteins containing arginine-rich motifs (ARMs) are known to bind RNA and are involved in regulating RNA processing in viruses and cells. Using automated selection methods we have generated a number of aptamers against ARM peptides from various natural proteins. Aptamers bind tightly to their cognate ARMs, with K(d) values in the nanomolar range, and frequently show no propensity to bind to other ARMs or even to single amino acid variants of the cognate ARM. However, at least some anti-ARM aptamers can cross-recognize a limited set of other ARMs, just as natural RNA-binding sites have been shown to exhibit so-called "chameleonism." We expand upon the number of examples of cross-recognition and, using mutational and circular dichroism (CD) analyses, demonstrate that there are multiple mechanisms by which RNA ligands can cross-recognize ARMs. These studies support a model in which individual arginine residues govern binding to an RNA ligand, and the inherent flexibility of the peptide backbone may make it possible for "semi-specific" recognition of a discrete set of RNAs by a discrete set of ARM peptides and proteins.

Aptamers as tools for target validation

Synthetic nucleic acid ligands, called aptamers, bind to protein targets with high specificity and affinity. They are very potent inhibitors of protein function and their application can greatly enhance the process of target validation and drug development. An important benefit of this technology is the recent development of rapidly identifying these sophisticated ligands for almost any target molecule in multi-parallel, automated workstations. The aptamer technology is thus well-suited to addressing the growing demand for high-throughput analysis and functional validation of potential drug targets. Numerous examples have shown the potency of aptamers in inhibiting the function of proteins in cell culture and in vivo models. The technology is complementary to genetic knockout or siRNA approaches as it provides highly valuable information at the proteomic level. In addition, the aptamer technology has recently been extended to developing aptamer drugs and identifying functionally equivalent small molecule leads.

Selection of RNA aptamers against human influenza virus hemagglutinin using surface plasmon resonance

Aptamers are functional nucleic acids possessing high affinity and specificity to their cognate ligands and are isolated from a library of nucleic acids by iterative rounds of selection and amplification. In the current study, we used surface plasmon resonance (Biacore) as an efficient methodology for selecting aptamers that bind to hemagglutinin (HA) of human influenza virus. This procedure allowed us to monitor and select the target-bound aptamers specifically and simultaneously. These studies not only yielded an aptamer that binds to the HA of influenza virus with high affinity but also revealed the consensus sequence, 5'-GUCGNCNU(N)(2-3)GUA-3, for HA recognition.

Nucleic acid aptamers for target validation and therapeutic applications

In the simplest view, aptamers can be thought of as nucleic acid analogs to antibodies. They are able to bind specifically to proteins, and, in many cases, that binding leads to a modulation of protein activity. New aptamers are rapidly generated through the SELEX (Systematic Evolution of Ligands by Exponential enrichment) process and have a very high target affinity and specificity (picomoles to nanomoles). Furthermore, aptamers composed of modified nucleotides have a long in vivo half-life (hours to days), are nontoxic and nonimmunogenic, and are easily produced using standard nucleic acid synthesis methods. These properties make aptamers ideal for target validation and as a new class of therapeutics. As a target validation tool, aptamers provide important information that complements that provided by other methods. For example, siRNA is widely used to demonstrate that protein knock-out in a cellular assay can lead to a biological effect. Aptamers extend that information by showing that the dose-dependent modulation of protein activity can be used to derive a therapeutic benefit. That is, aptamers can be used to demonstrate that the protein is a good target for drug development. As a new class of therapeutics, aptamers bridge the gap between small molecules and biologics. Like biologics, biologically active aptamers are rapidly discovered, have no class-specific toxicity, and are adept at disrupting protein-protein interaction. Like small molecules, aptamers can be rationally engineered and optimized, are nonimmunogenic, and are produced by scalable chemical procedures at moderate cost. As such, aptamers are emerging as an important source of new therapeutic molecules.

Micromechanical detection of proteins using aptamer-based receptor molecules

We report label-free protein detection using a microfabricated cantilever-based sensor that is functionalized with DNA aptamers to act as receptor molecules. The sensor utilizes two adjacent cantilevers that constitute a sensor/reference pair and allows direct detection of the differential bending between the two cantilevers. One cantilever is functionalized with aptamers selected for Taq DNA polymerase while the other is blocked with single-stranded DNA. We have found that the polymerase-aptamer binding induces a change in surface stress, which causes a differential cantilever bending that ranges from 3 to 32 nm depending on the ligand concentration. Protein recognition on the sensor surface is specific and has a concentration dependence that is similar to that in solution.

Development of an automated in vitro selection protocol to obtain RNA-based aptamers: identification of a biostable substance P antagonist

We have developed an automated SELEX (Systematic Evolution of Ligands by EXponential Enrichment) process that allows the execution of in vitro selection cycles without any direct manual intervention steps. The automated selection protocol is designed to provide for high flexibility and versatility in terms of choice of buffers and reagents as well as stringency of selection conditions. Employing the automated SELEX process, we have identified RNA aptamers to the mirror-image configuration (d-peptide) of substance P. The peptide substance P belongs to the tachykinin family and exerts various biologically important functions, such as peripheral vasodilation, smooth muscle contraction and pain transmission. The aptamer that was identified most frequently was truncated to the 44mer SUP-A-004. The mirror-image configuration of SUP-A-004, the so-called Spiegelmer, has been shown to bind to naturally occurring l-substance P displaying a K_d of 40 nM and to inhibit (IC₅₀ of 45 nM) l-substance P-mediated Ca²⁺ release in a cell culture assay.

Programmable ligand-controlled riboregulators of eukaryotic gene expression

Recent studies have demonstrated the importance of noncoding RNA elements in regulating gene expression networks. We describe the design of a class of small trans-acting RNAs that directly regulate gene expression in a ligand-dependent manner. These allosteric riboregulators, which we call antiswitches, are made fully tunable and modular by rational design. They offer flexible control strategies by adopting active or inactive forms in response to ligand binding, depending on their design. They can be tailor-made to regulate the expression of target transcripts in response to different cellular effectors. Coupled with in vitro selection technologies for generating nucleic acid ligand-binding species, antiswitches present a platform for programming cellular behavior and genetic networks with respect to cellular state and environmental stimuli.

High-throughput antibody production

Proteome-wide sets of antibodies would be an invaluable research resource for use in highly parallel assays such as microarrays. Such assays could provide deeper insights into biology and a wealth of information for clinical diagnostics. However, the rate of discovery of new proteins far exceeds the antibody supply currently produced from traditional animal-based systems. To address this problem, a variety of improvements in antibody production have been developed, including improved animal-based technologies, new antibody structures with superior performances, faster and more discriminating screening techniques, and rapid validation methods. Many of these technologies are amenable to automation, allowing antibody production throughput to significantly increase.

SELEX: just another separation?

The potential for quickly isolating high affinity, highly selective ligands generated much excitement when SELEX was first described. Fifteen years later, SELEX has still not achieved widespread acceptance due to limitations in aptamer affinity, stability and throughput. Recent research is beginning to address these limitations though and SELEX is quickly regaining its standing as a hot topic in areas as diverse as drug discovery, chemical analysis, and even genomics and proteomics.

Analytical applications of aptamers

So far, several bio-analytical methods have used nucleic acid probes to detect specific sequences in RNA or DNA targets through hybridisation. More recently, specific nucleic acids, aptamers, selected from random sequence pools, have been shown to bind non-nucleic acid targets, such as small molecules or proteins. The development of in vitro selection and amplification techniques has allowed the identification of specific aptamers, which bind to the target molecules with high affinity. Many small organic molecules with molecular weights from 100 to 10,000 Da have been shown to be good targets for selection. Moreover, aptamers can be selected against difficult target haptens, such as toxins or prions. The selected aptamers can bind to their targets with high affinity and even discriminate between closely related targets. Aptamers can thus be considered as a valid alternative to antibodies or other bio-mimetic receptors, for the development of biosensors and other analytical methods. The production of aptamers is commonly performed by the SELEX (systematic evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment) process, which, starting from large libraries of oligonucleotides, allows the isolation of large amounts of functional nucleic acids by an iterative process of in vitro selection and subsequent amplification through polymerase chain reaction. Aptamers are suitable for applications based on molecular recognition as analytical, diagnostic and therapeutic tools. In this review, the main analytical methods, which have been developed using aptamers, will be discussed together with an overview on the aptamer selection process.

Natural and engineered nucleic acids as tools to explore biology

RNA and DNA molecules can form complex, three-dimensional folded structures that have surprisingly sophisticated functions, including catalysing chemical reactions and controlling gene expression. Although natural nucleic acids make occasional use of these advanced functions, the true potential for sophisticated function by these biological polymers is far greater. An important challenge for biochemists is to take RNA and DNA beyond their proven use as polymers that form double-helical structures. Molecular engineers are beginning to harness the power of nucleic acids that form more complex three-dimensional structures, and apply them as tools for exploring biological systems and as therapeutics.

Nucleic acid aptamers as tools and drugs: recent developments

Nucleic acid aptamers are molecules that bind to their ligands with high affinity and specificity. Unlike other functional nucleic acids such as antisense oligonucleotides, ribozymes, or siRNAs, aptamers almost never exert their effects on the genetic level. They manipulate their target molecules such as gene products or epitopes directly and site specifically, leaving nontargeted protein functions intact. In a similar way to antibodies, aptamers bind to many different kinds of target molecules with high specificity and can be made to order, but as a result of their different biochemical nature and size they can also be used complementary to antibodies. In some cases, aptamers might be more suitable or more specific than antibody approaches or small molecules, both as scientific and biotechnological tools and as therapeutic agents. Recent examples of characterization of aptamers as tools for scientific research to study regulatory circuits, as tools in diagnostic or biosensor development, and as therapeutic agents are discussed.

Construction, stability, and activity of multivalent circular anticoagulant aptamers

Here we describe the design and construction of multivalent circular DNA aptamers. Four aptameric binding motifs directed at blood-borne targets are used as a model set from which larger, multidomain aptamers are constructed in a straightforward manner. Intra- or intermolecular ligation of precursor oligonucleotides provides a stabilizing mechanism against degradation by the predominant exonuclease activity of blood products without the need for post-selection chemical modification. In many cases, circular DNA aptamer half-lives are extended beyond 10 h in serum and plasma, making such constructs viable for therapeutic and diagnostic applications. Duplexes and three-way junctions are used as scaffold architectures around which two, three, or four aptameric motifs can be arranged in a structurally defined manner, giving rise to improved binding characteristics through stability and avidity gains. Circular aptamers targeted against thrombin display improved anticoagulant potency with EC50 values 2-3-fold better than those of the canonical GS-522 thrombin DNA aptamer. Intrinsic duplex regions provide an opportunity to incorporate additional transcription factor binding motifs, whereas ancillary loops can be used to provide further functionality. These anticoagulant aptamers provide a starting point for merging the principles of DNA nanotechnology with aptameric functions.

SELEX-derived aptamers of the duck hepatitis B virus RNA encapsidation signal distinguish critical and non-critical residues for productive initiation of reverse transcription

Protein-primed replication of hepatitis B viruses (HBVs) is initiated by the chaperone dependent binding of the reverse transcriptase (P protein) to the bulged epsilon stem-loop on the pregenomic RNA, and the epsilon-templated synthesis of the 5' terminal nucleotides of the first DNA strand. How P protein recognizes the initiation site is poorly understood. In mammalian HBVs and in duck HBV (DHBV) the entire stem-loop is extensively base paired; in other avian HBVs the upper stem regions have a low base pairing potential. Initiation can be reconstituted with in vitro translated DHBV, but not HBV, P protein and DHBV epsilon (Depsilon) RNA. Employing the SELEX method on a constrained library of Depsilon upper stem variants, we obtained a series of well-binding aptamers. Most contained C-rich consensus motifs with very low base pairing potential; some supported initiation, others did not. Consensus-based secondary mutants allowed to pin down this functional difference to the residues flanking the conserved loop, and an unpaired U. In vitro active consensus sequences also supported virus replication. Hence, most of the upper stem acts as a spacer, which, if not base paired, warrants accessibility of relevant anchor residues. This suggests that the base paired Depsilon represents an exceptional rather than a prototypic avian HBV epsilon signal, and it offers an explanation as to why attempts to in vitro reconstitute initiation with human HBV have thus far failed.

Electrochromatographic retention studies on a flavin-binding RNA aptamer sorbent

Aptamers are oligonucleotides that are isolated and amplified on the basis of their recognition of a target molecule. In this study, an RNA aptamer isolated and amplified on the basis of its affinity for flavin mononucleotide (FMN) was covalently bound to the inner walls of fused-silica capillaries. This aptamer recognizes the flavin moiety of both FMN and flavin adenine dinucleotide (FAD). When an attempt was made to evaluate these capillaries according to existing theory, the theory proved to be insufficient. We describe a new method to evaluate capillaries for use in open-tubular capillary electrochromatography (OTCEC) of charged analytes, which combines OTCEC and flow-counterbalanced capillary electrophoresis. This method enabled us to extract k' and evaluate k(CEC) values for these capillaries, and the dependence of these values on Mg(2+) concentration was explored. The k' values for these capillaries ranged from 0.0951 to 0.2530 and from 0.0255 to 0.1118 for FMN and FAD, respectively.

Monitoring protein modification with allosteric ribozymes

An allosteric ribozyme is an RNA-based enzyme (ribozyme) whose catalytic activity is modulated by molecular recognition of a protein. The direct coupling of a detectable catalytic event to molecular recognition by an allosteric ribozyme enables simple assays for quantitative protein detection. Most significantly, the mode of development and molecular recognition characteristics of allosteric ribozymes are fundamentally different from antibodies, providing them with functional characteristics that complement those of antibodies. Allosteric ribozymes can be developed using native proteins and, therefore, are often sensitive to protein conformation. In contrast, antibodies tend to recognize a series of adjacent amino acids as a consequence of antigen presentation and typically are not sensitive to protein conformation. Unlike antibody development, the development of allosteric ribozymes is a completely in vitro process that allows the specificity of an allosteric ribozyme to be tightly controlled. These significant differences from antibodies allow the pre-programmed development of conformation-state-specific protein detection reagents that can be used to investigate the activation-state of signal transduction components.

In vitro selection of molecular beacons

While molecular beacons are primarily known as biosensors for the detection of nucleic acids, it has proven possible to adapt other nucleic acid binding species (aptamers) to function in a manner similar to molecular beacons, yielding fluorescent signals only in the presence of a cognate ligand. Unfortunately, engineering aptamer beacons requires a detailed knowledge of aptamer sequence and structure. In order to develop a general method for the direct selection of aptamer beacons we have first developed a selection method for molecular beacons. A pool of random sequence DNA molecules were immobilized via a capture oligonucleotide on an affinity column, and those variants that could be released from the column by a target oligonucleotide were amplified. After nine rounds of selection and amplification the elution characteristics of the population were greatly improved. A fluorescent reporter in the selected beacons was located adjacent to a DABCYL moiety in the capture oligonucleotide; addition of the target oligonucleotide led to release of the capture oligonucleotide and up to a 17-fold increase in fluorescence. Signaling was specific for the target oligonucleotide, and occurred via a novel mechanism, relative to designed molecular beacons. When the target oligonucleotide is bound it can form a stacked helical junction with an intramolecular hairpin in the selected beacon; formation of the intramolecular hairpin in turn leads to release of the capture oligonucleotide. The ability to select molecular beacons may prove useful for identifying available sites on complex targets, such as mRNAs, while the method for selection can be easily generalized to other, non-nucleic acid target classes.