Does programmed cell death (apoptosis) play a role in the development of multiple organ dysfunction in critically ill patients? a review and a theoretical framework

Correlating functional staging to effective treatment of acute surgical illness

BACKGROUND

Proinflammatory and anti-inflammatory events may eventually trigger host response, which acting via a broad spectrum of complex biological processes and molecular interactions may either enhance or resolve the symptoms of acute surgical illness (ASI). Staging the sequence of biological events that take place at the cellular level during the development of ASI may provide leads to effective stage-specific treatments. In line with the hypothesis that proper timing of therapeutic intervention may be crucial to the management of the disease, we have attempted in this review to correlate functional staging to effective treatment of ASI.

DATA SOURCE

The present report proposes a conceptual synthesis on the biogenesis and treatment of ASI that is based on known molecular and cellular aspects of human inflammatory sequence and patient data from clinical trials. It also introduces proper timing of therapeutic intervention as a potentially important determinant for the successful outcome of the disease process.

CONCLUSIONS

Progress in understanding the biogenesis of ASI did not result in successful therapeutic developments as yet. The challenge ahead should be a better understanding of the dynamics of the various processes and regulators in appropriate animal and clinical models of ASI, in order to properly intervene and direct effective therapies for the benefit of critically ill patients.

Anaphylatoxins and infectious and non-infectious inflammatory diseases

In recent years a plethora of data has accumulated directing toward an important role of polypeptides C3a and C5a and its degradation product C5adesArg, summarized as anaphylatoxins (ATs), in microbial host defense and immune regulation. The ATs exert their various biologic functions by interacting with specific C3a- and C5a-receptors present on cells of myeloid origin, epithelial cells, smooth muscle cells as well as on activated B- and T-cells. Activation of AT receptors mediates signal transduction pathways triggering a variety of proinflammatory events. However, by interacting with the cytokine- and chemokine network C3a and C5a exhibit also anti-inflammatory properties. In this review the focus is on the pathogenetic role of the ATs in sepsis, immune complex disease, delayed type hypersensitivity and asthma. Discussed are data from animal models in which the ATs are blocked by specific C3a or C5a inhibitors or from mice with genetic deletions of the specific receptors of either C3a or C5a/C5adesArg.

Recombinant human activated protein C: a system modulator of vascular function for treatment of severe sepsis

OBJECTIVE

To review the mechanisms of action and rationale for the use of recombinant human activated protein C in the treatment of severe sepsis. Specifically, we focus on the mechanisms of action in the protein C pathway that converge to modulate the pathophysiology of severe inflammatory disease and sepsis. This analysis includes a discussion of the role of activated protein C in directly modulating cell system biology, independent of antithrombotic activity.

DATA SOURCES/STUDY SELECTION

Published research and review articles relating to the protein C pathway, recombinant human protein C, and the role of protein C in sepsis. Data were also derived from broad gene profiling in model systems of endothelial dysfunction.

DATA EXTRACTION AND SYNTHESIS

Relevant studies were included to support discussion of the unique mechanistic aspect of protein C and its role in the pathogenesis of severe sepsis. We discuss the potential of activated protein C as a unique system modulator for the treatment of severe sepsis and other systemic inflammatory responses that result in microvascular coagulopathy, endothelial dysfunction, and vascular bed failure.

CONCLUSIONS

The protein C pathway plays a unique role in modulating vascular function. As an antithrombotic/profibrinolytic agent, it plays a clear role in maintaining vascular patency. Moreover, it has anti-inflammatory properties and appears to play a unique role as an antiapoptotic and endothelial cell survival factor. In states of systemic inflammatory activation, loss of protein C due to consumptive processes results in a compromised ability to modulate coagulation as well as inflammatory and cell survival functions. This compromise leads to vascular dysfunction, end-organ failure, and death. Replacement with recombinant human activated protein C offers a system-modulating approach to improved outcome.

Pediatric sepsis and multiple organ dysfunction syndrome

Systemic inflammatory response syndrome may be viewed as the systemic expression of cytokine signals that normally function on an autocrine or paracrine level. Sepsis is defined as systemic inflammatory response syndrome caused by an infection. Multiple organ dysfunction syndrome may represent the end stage of severe systemic inflammatory response syndrome or sepsis. Many cells are involved, including endothelial cells and leukocytes and multiple proinflammatory and antiinflammatory mediators (cytokines, oxygen free radicals, coagulation factors, and so forth). Various pathophysiologic mechanisms have been postulated. The most popular theory is that the inflammatory process loses its autoregulatory capacity; however, microcirculatory dysregulation and apoptosis may also be important, and a new paradigm posits a complex nonlinear system. Many new treatments have been studied recently. The usefulness of immune modulating diets remains to be evaluated. Molecular immunomodulation is still of unclear value. The therapy of sepsis and multiple organ dysfunction syndrome remains mainly supportive.

Multiple organ dysfunction syndrome: a narrative review

PURPOSE

To review multiple organ dysfunction syndrome with respect to: 1) clinical measurement systems; 2) molecular mechanisms; and 3) therapeutic directions based upon molecular mechanisms.

METHODS

The Medline, Cochrane, and Best Evidence databases (1996 to 2000), conference proceedings, bibliographies of review articles were searched for relevant articles. Key index words were multiple organ failure, multiple system organ dysfunction, sepsis, septic shock, shock, systemic inflammatory response syndrome. Outcomes prospectively defined were death and physiological reversal of end organ failure.

RESULTS

Multiple organ dysfunction/failure (MODS) is the most common cause for death in intensive care units. The recognition of this syndrome in the last 30 yr may be due to advances in early resuscitation unmasking these delayed sequelae in those that would have died previously. Multiple organ dysfunction occurs after shock of varied etiologies and may be the result of unbridled systemic inflammation. As yet, therapy directed to prevent or improve MODS has not dramatically altered outcomes.

CONCLUSION

Multiple organ dysfunction may serve as useful measure of disease severity for risk adjustment and outcome marker for quality of care and therapy provided. Anesthesiologists treating shock patients will note the subsequent development of MODS in the critical care unit and may be required to provide anesthetic support to these patients.

Gene expression profile of antithrombotic protein c defines new mechanisms modulating inflammation and apoptosis

Human protein C is a natural anticoagulant factor, and a recombinant activated form of the molecule (rhAPC) is completing clinical evaluation for treatment of severe sepsis. Because of the pathophysiologic role of endothelial dysfunction in severe inflammatory disease and sepsis, we explored the possibility that rhAPC might directly modulate endothelial function, independent of its anticoagulant activity. Using broad transcriptional profiling, we show that rhAPC directly modulates patterns of endothelial cell gene expression clustering into anti-inflammatory and cell survival pathways. rhAPC directly suppressed expression of p50 and p52 NFkappaB subunits, resulting in a functional decrease in NFkappaB binding at target sites. Further, rhAPC blocked expression of downstream NFkappaB regulated genes following tumor necrosis factor alpha induction, including dose-dependent suppression of cell adhesion expression and functional binding of intracellular adhesion molecule 1, vascular cell adhesion molecule 1, and E-selectin. Further, rhAPC modulated several genes in the endothelial apoptosis pathway, including the Bcl-2 homologue protein and inhibitor of apoptosis protein. These pathway changes resulted in the ability of rhAPC to inhibit the induction of apoptosis by the potent inducer, staurosporine. This new mechanistic understanding of endothelial regulation and the modulation of tumor necrosis factor-induced endothelial dysfunction creates a novel link between coagulation, inflammation, and cell death and provides insight into the molecular basis for the efficacy of APC in systemic inflammation and sepsis.

Expression of Fas (CD95) and Fas ligand on peripheral blood mononuclear cells in critical illness and association with multiorgan dysfunction severity and survival

OBJECTIVE

This was an exploratory study with three goals: a) to quantify the expression of the apoptotic receptor Fas and its ligand (FasL) on peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) in patients with, or at risk for, multiple organ dysfunction syndrome (MODS); b) to compare this expression with the respective expression in matched controls; and c) to explore the association with MODS severity and survival.

DESIGN

Repeated-measures correlational and cross-sectional design.

SETTING

The surgical, medical, and the trauma/burn intensive care unit of an academic institution.

PATIENTS

Thirty-five adult, critically ill patients meeting the diagnostic criteria for systemic inflammatory response syndrome (SIRS) with MODS, or at risk for MODS, were followed for 14 days. Thirty-five non-SIRS controls matched with patients for age, gender, and race comprised the control group.

INTERVENTIONS

Peripheral blood sampling every 48 hrs.

MEASUREMENTS/MAIN RESULTS

T cells were considerably depleted in SIRS/MODS patients (p <.001), and Fas and FasL expression on PBMCs (flow cytometric analysis) was elevated significantly compared with controls (p <.001). In contrast to controls, non-T cells were the major sources of Fas and FasL in SIRS/MODS patients (p <.01). Expression of Fas and FasL exhibited a bimodal correlation with severity (p <.03). High severity patients demonstrated increasing Fas and FasL expression with increasing severity in contrast to declining expression in moderately severe patients. Fas and FasL measurements were significantly and positively associated with the likelihood of survival (p <.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Dysregulation in the expression of apoptotic receptors Fas and FasL, at least in PBMCs, may be involved in the pathophysiology of SIRS, the related lymphocytopenia, and the onset of MODS and the related morbidity and mortality rates.

Protective effects of anti-C5a in sepsis-induced thymocyte apoptosis

Multiorgan apoptosis occurs during sepsis. Following cecal ligation and puncture (CLP) in rats, thymocytes underwent apoptosis in a time-dependent manner. C5a blockade dramatically reduced thymocyte apoptosis as measured by thymic weight, binding of annexin V to thymocytes, and laddering of thymocyte DNA. When C5a was generated in vivo by infusion of purified cobra venom factor (CVF), thymocyte apoptosis was significantly increased. Similar results were found when CVF was injected in vivo during the early stages of CLP. In animals 12 hours after induction of CLP, there was an increase in the activities of caspase-3, -6, and -9, but not caspase-1 and -8. Cytosolic cytochrome c levels increased by twofold, whereas mitochondrial levels showed a 50% decrease. Western blot analysis revealed that the content of Bcl-X(L) (but not of Bcl-2, BAX, Bad, and Bim) significantly decreased in thymocytes after CLP. C5a blockade in the sepsis model almost completely inhibited caspase-3, -6, and -9 activation, significantly preserved cytochrome c in the mitochondrial fraction, and restored Bcl-X(L) expression. These data suggest that systemic activation of complement induces C5a-dependent apoptosis of thymocytes and that the blockade of C5a during sepsis rescues thymocytes from apoptosis.

Nutritional support in sepsis: still skeptical?

The immediate metabolic response to a septic challenge is probably adaptive, meaning that nutritional interference, mainly via the parenteral route, during this early phase of instability can do more harm than good. During the later phases, a gradual increase in enteral nutrition, at the expense of parenteral nutrition, combined with the administration of nutraceuticals such as glutamine and omega-3 fatty acids, can counteract wasting and modulate the complex inflammatory response and immunosuppression associated with sepsis. In these times of scarce resources, there is an urgent need to clearly document the efficacy of immuno/pharmaconutrients, individually and in combination, enterally or parenterally, before proposing them for routine management of septic patients in the intensive care unit.