Aminoacyl esterase activity of the Tetrahymena ribozyme

Applicability of PM3 to transphosphorylation reaction path: toward designing a minimal ribozyme

A growing body of evidence shows that RNA can catalyze many of the reactions necessary both for replication of genetic material and the possible transition into the modern protein-based world. However, contemporary ribozymes are too large to have self-assembled from a prebiotic oligonucleotide pool. Still, it is likely that the major features of the earliest ribozymes have been preserved as molecular fossils in the catalytic RNA of today. Therefore, the search for a minimal ribozyme has been aimed at finding the necessary structural features of a modern ribozyme (Beaudry and Joyce, 1990). Both a three-dimensional model and quantum chemical calculations are required to quantitatively determine the effects of structural features of the ribozyme on the reaction it catalyzes. Using this model, quantum chemical calculations must be performed to determine quantitatively the effects of structural features on catalysis. Previous studies of the reaction path have been conducted at the ab initio level, but these methods are limited to small models due to enormous computational requirements. Semiempirical methods have been applied to large systems in the past; however, the accuracy of these methods depends largely on the system under investigation. In the present study we assess the validity of the MNDO/PM3 method on a simple model of the ribozyme-catalyzed reaction, or hydrolysis of phosphoric acid. We find that the results are qualitatively similar to ab initio results using large basis sets. Therefore, PM3 is suitable for studying the reaction path of the ribozyme-catalyzed reaction.

The RNA-world and co-evolution hypotheses and the origin of life: implications, research strategies and perspectives

The applicability of the RNA-world and co-evolution hypotheses to the study of the very first stages of the origin of life is discussed. The discussion focuses on the basic differences between the two hypotheses and their implications, with regard to the reconstruction methodology, ribosome emergence, balance between ribozymes and protein enzymes, and their major difficulties. Additional complexities of the two hypotheses, such as membranes and the energy source of the first reactions, are not treated in the present work. A central element in the proposed experimental strategies is the study of the catalytic activities of very small peptides and RNA-like oligomers, according to existing, as well as to yet-to-be-invented scenarios of the two hypotheses under consideration. It is suggested that the novel directed molecular evolution technology, and molecular computational modelling, can be applied to this research. This strategy is assumed to be essential for the suggested goal of future studies of the origin of life, namely, the establishment of a 'Primordial Darwinian entity'.

On concerted origin of transfer RNAs with complementary anticodons

Pairs of antiparallely oriented consensus tRNAs with complementary anticodons show surprisingly small numbers of mispairings within the 17-bp- long anticodon stem and loop region. Even smaller such complementary distances are shown by illegitimately complementary anticodons, i.e. those with allowed pairing between G and U bases. Accordingly, we suppose that transfer RNAs have emerged concertedly as complementary strands of primordial double helix-like RNA molecules. Replication of such molecules with illegitimately complementary anticodons might generate new synonymous codons for the same pair of amino acids. Logically, the idea of tRNA concerted origin dictates very ancient establishment of direct links between anticodons and the type of amino acids with which pre-tRNAs were to be charged. More specifically, anticodons (first of all, the 2nd base) could selectively target 'their' amino acids, reaction of acylating itself being performed by another non-specific site of pre-tRNA or even by another ribozyme. In all, the above findings and speculations are consistent to the hypercyclic concept (Eigen and Schuster, 1979), and throw new light on the genetic code origin and associated problems. Also favoring this idea are data on complementary codon usage patterns in different genomes.

Utilization of cofactors expands metabolism in a new RNA world

RNA has been hypothesized to have preceded proteins as the major catalysts of the biosphere, yet there are only a very limited number of chemical reactions that are known to be catalyzed by modern RNA. Cofactors are used by the majority of protein enzymes to supply additional functional groups to the active site. RNA should also be able to utilize some of these same cofactors to extend its own catalytic potential. We describe here how it could be possible to use selection--amplification from a population of random RNA to obtain a coenzyme A mediated RNA transacylase. Exploitation of some of the sulphur chemistry mediated by coenzyme A could have significantly expanded a prebiotic RNA directed metabolism.

Importance of independence in ribozyme reactions: kinetic behavior of trimmed and of simply connected multiple ribozymes with potential activity against human immunodeficiency virus

The kinetic behavior of ribozymes derived from two types of multiple-ribozyme expression vector were examined. In some cases, multiple ribozymes were expressed as a single RNA molecule and all the ribozymes were simply connected in tandem (connected type). In other cases, multiple ribozymes were flanked by cis-acting ribozymes at both their 5' and 3' ends so that, upon transcription, multiple ribozymes were trimmed at both their 5' and 3' ends, with resultant liberation of multiple independent ribozymes (shotgun type). When levels of ribozyme expression were examined for the shotgun-type vector, the level of the ribozyme transcript was found to be proportional to the number of units (n) connected in tandem. Accordingly, the activities of the shotgun-type ribozymes, in terms of the cleavage of HIV-1 RNA in vitro, were also found to be proportional to the number of units connected in tandem (n). By contrast, the activities of the connected-type ribozymes reached plateau values at around n = 3. These results indicate that, when the shotgun-type expression system is used, it is theoretically possible to generate various independent ribozymes, each specific for a different target site, without sacrificing the activity of any individual ribozyme.

RNA based evolutionary optimization

The notion of an RNA world has been introduced for a prebiotic scenario that is dominated by RNA molecules and their properties, in particular their capabilities to act as templates for reproduction and as catalysts for several cleavage and ligation reactions of polynucleotides and polypeptides. This notion is used here also for simple experimental assays which are well suited to study evolution in the test tube. In molecular evolution experiments fitness is determined in essence by the molecular structures of RNA molecules. Evidence is presented for adaptation to environment in cell-free media. RNA based molecular evolution experiments have led to interesting spin-offs in biotechnology, commonly called 'applied molecular evolution', which make use of Darwinian trial-and-error strategies in order to synthesize new pharmacological compounds and other advanced materials on a biological basis. Error-propagation in RNA replication leads to formation of mutant spectra called 'quasispecies'. An increase in the error rate broadens the mutant spectrum. There exists a sharply defined threshold beyond which heredity breaks down and evolutionary adaptation becomes impossible. Almost all RNA viruses studied so far operate at conditions close to this error threshold. Quasispecies and error thresholds are important for an understanding of RNA virus evolution, and they may help to develop novel antiviral strategies. Evolution of RNA molecules can be studied and interpreted by considering secondary structures. The notion of sequence space introduces a distance between pairs of RNA sequences which is tantamount to counting the minimal number of point mutations required to convert the sequences into each other. The mean sensitivity of RNA secondary structures to mutation depends strongly on the base pairing alphabet: structures from sequences which contain only one base pair (GC or AU are much less stable against mutation than those derived from the natural (AUGC) sequences. Evolutionary optimization of two-letter sequences in thus more difficult than optimization in the world of natural RNA sequences with four bases. This fact might explain the usage of four bases in the genetic language of nature. Finally we study the mapping from RNA sequences into secondary structures and explore the topology of RNA shape space. We find that 'neutral paths' connecting neighbouring sequences with identical structures go very frequently through entire sequence space. Sequences folding into common structures are found everywhere in sequence space.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

The evolutionary change of the genetic code as restricted by the anticodon and identity of transfer RNA

The discovery of non-universal genetic codes in several mitochondria and nuclear systems during the part ten years has necessitated a reconsideration of the concept that the genetic code is universal and frozen, as was once believed. Here, the flexibility of the relationship between codons and amino acids is discussed on the basis of the distribution of non-universal genetic codes in various organisms insofar as has been observed to date. Judging from the result of recent investigations into tRNA identity, it would appear that the non-participation of the anticodon in recognition by aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase has significantly influenced the variability of codons.

Coding coenzyme handles: a hypothesis for the origin of the genetic code

The coding coenzyme handle hypothesis suggests that useful coding preceded translation. Early adapters, the ancestors of present-day anticodons, were charged with amino acids acting as coenzymes of ribozymes in a metabolically complex RNA world. The ancestral aminoacyl-adapter synthetases could have been similar to present-day self-splicing tRNA introns. A codon-anticodon-discriminator base complex embedded in these synthetases could have played an important role in amino acid recognition. Extension of the genetic code proceeded through the take-over of nonsense codons by novel amino acids, related to already coded ones either through precursor-product relationship or physicochemical similarity. The hypothesis is open for experimental tests.

The ribosome as a source of genome hypervariability?

In this report it is suggested that at early stages of evolution ribosomes were responsible for synthesizing short oligonucleotide cDNA packets which formed the protogenic tandem repetitive sequences. Ribosomal RNA (rRNA) could have been the most probable template for such a synthesis. rRNA has homology with the monomers of tandem hypervariable repetitive elements of the genome. A model for the proposed participation of rRNA in the genesis of genomic fragments is provided by analysis of the active center of GTP-binding proteins. The role of oligonucleotides, synthesized by the ribosome, in the context of mechanisms of genome regulation, genes responsible for disease and human longterm memory formation are also discussed.

Cleavage of full-length beta APP mRNA by hammerhead ribozymes

The sequences surrounding the first 5'GUC3' in the mRNA encoding the Alzheimer amyloid peptide precursor (beta APP) were used to construct a pair of transacting hammerhead ribozymes. Each ribozyme contained the conserved core bases of the hammerhead motif found in the positive strand of satellite RNA of tobacco ringspot virus [(+)sTRSV] and two stems, 7 and 8 bases long, complementary to the target, beta APP mRNA. However, one of the ribozyme cleaving strands was lengthened at its 3' end to include the early splicing and polyadenylation signal sequences of SV40 viral RNA. This RNA, therefore, more closely mimics transcripts produced by RNA polymerase II from eucaryotic expression vectors in vivo. RNA, prepared by run-off transcription of cDNA oligonucleotide or plasmid constructs containing a T7 RNA polymerase promoter was used to characterize several properties of the cleavage reaction. In the presence of both ribozyme cleaving strands magnesium-ion dependent cleavage of a model 26 base beta APP substrate RNA or full-length beta APP-751 mRNA was observed at the hammerhead consensus cleavage site. Neither ribozyme was active against non-message homologs of beta APP mRNA, nor was cleavage detected when point mutations were made in the conserved core sequences. However, the kcat/Km at 37 degrees C in 10 mM Mg+2 of the longer ribozyme was reduced twenty-fold when model and full-length substrates were compared. The use of short deoxyoligonucleotides (13-17 mers) that bind upstream of the ribozyme was found to enhance the rate of cleavage of the full-length but not beta APP model substrate RNAs. The rate of enhancement depended on both the length of the deoxyoligonucleotide used as well as its site of binding with respect to the ribozyme. These data demonstrate the utility of ribozymes to cleave target RNAs in a catalytic, site-specific fashion in vitro. Direct comparison of the efficiency of different ribozyme constructs and different modulating activities provide an experimental strategy for designing more effective ribozymes for therapeutic purposes.

Ribozymes: a distinct class of metalloenzymes

Ribozymes are an important new class of metalloenzymes that have an unlikely feature: they are made entirely of ribonucleic acid (RNA). Metal ions are essential for efficient chemical catalysis by ribozymes and are often required for the stabilization of ribozyme structure. Most ribozymes catalyze reactions at phosphorus centers through one of two major mechanistic pathways, and reaction has been observed at carbon centers. Creative experiments have revealed the position of metal ions in the active site of two ribozymes. The exploitation of variable metal geometry and reactivity has expanded ribozyme chemistry and has facilitated the application of in vitro selection for the creation of novel ribozymes.

From RNA to DNA, why so many ribonucleotide reductases?

It is generally accepted that DNA appeared after RNA during the chemical evolution of life. To synthesize DNA, deoxyribonucleotides are required as building blocks. At present, these are formed from the corresponding ribonucleotides through the enzymatic action of ribonucleotide reductases. Three classes of enzymes are present in various organisms. There is little sequence similarity among the three classes of reductases. However, enzymic mechanisms and the allosteric behavior of the enzymes from various organisms are strongly conserved, suggesting that the enzymes might have evolved from a common ancestor, with the class III anaerobic Escherichia coli reductase as its closest relative.

Modeling study on the cleavage step of the self-splicing reaction in group I introns

A three-dimensional model of the Tetrahymena thermophila group I intron is used to further explore the catalytic mechanism of the transphosphorylation reaction of the cleavage step. Based on the coordinates of the catalytic core model proposed by Michel and Westhof (Michel, F., Westhof, E. J. Mol. Biol. 216, 585-610 (1990)), we first converted their ligation step model into a model of the cleavage step by the substitution of several bases and the removal of helix P9. Next, an attempt to place a trigonal bipyramidal transition state model in the active site revealed that this modified model for the cleavage step could not accommodate the transition state due to insufficient space. A lowering of P1 helix relative to surrounding helices provided the additional space required. Simultaneously, it provided a better starting geometry to model the molecular contacts proposed by Pyle et al. (Pyle, A. M., Murphy, F. L., Cech, T. R. Nature 358, 123-128. (1992)), based on mutational studies involving the J8/7 segment. Two hydrated Mg2+ complexes were placed in the active site of the ribozyme model, using the crystal structure of the functionally similar Klenow fragment (Beese, L.S., Steitz, T.A. EMBO J. 10, 25-33 (1991)) as a guide. The presence of two metal ions in the active site of the intron differs from previous models, which incorporate one metal ion in the catalytic site to fulfill the postulated roles of Mg2+ in catalysis. The reaction profile is simulated based on a trigonal bipyramidal transition state, and the role of the hydrated Mg2+ complexes in catalysis is further explored using molecular orbital calculations.

RNA as a catalyst: natural and designed ribozymes

RNA can catalyse chemical reactions through its ability to fold into complex three-dimensional structures and to specifically bind small molecules and divalent metal ions. The 2'-hydroxyl groups of the ribose moieties contribute to this exceptional reactivity of RNA, compared to DNA. RNA is not only able to catalyse phosphate ester transfer reactions in ribonucleic acids, but can also show amino-acyl esterase activity, and is probably able to promote peptide bond formation. Bearing its potential for functioning both as a genome and as a gene product, RNA is suitable for in vitro evolution experiments enabling the selection of molecules with new properties. The growing repertoire of RNA catalysed reactions will establish RNA as a primordial molecule in the evolution of life.

Movement of the guide sequence during RNA catalysis by a group I ribozyme

Ribozymes derived from the self-splicing pre-ribosomal RNA of Tetrahymena act as sequence-specific endonucleases. The reaction involves binding an RNA or DNA substrate by base pairing to the internal guide sequence (IGS) to form helix P1. Site-specific photo-crosslinking localized the 5' end of the IGS in helix P1 to the vicinity of conserved bases between helices P4 and P5, supporting a major feature of the Michel-Westhof three-dimensional structure model. The crosslinked ribozyme retained catalytic activity. When not base-paired, the IGS was still specifically crosslinked, but the major site was 37 A distant from the reactive site in the experimentally supported three-dimensional model. The data indicate that a substantial induced-fit conformational change accompanies P1 formation, and they provide a physical basis for understanding the transport of oligonucleotides to the catalytic core of the ribozyme. The ability of RNA to orchestrate large-scale conformational changes may help explain why the ribosome and the spliceosome are RNA-based machines.

RNA multi-structure landscapes. A study based on temperature dependent partition functions

Statistical properties of RNA folding landscapes obtained by the partition function algorithm (McCaskill 1990) are investigated in detail. The pair correlation of free energies as a function of the Hamming distance is used as a measure for the ruggedness of the landscape. The calculation of the partition function contains information about the entire ensemble of secondary structures as a function of temperature and opens the door to all quantities of thermodynamic interest, in contrast with the conventional minimal free energy approach. A metric distance of structure ensembles is introduced and pair correlations at the level of the structures themselves are computed. Just as with landscapes based on most stable secondary structure prediction, the landscapes defined on the full biophysical GCAU alphabet are much smoother than the landscapes restricted to pure GC sequences and the correlation lengths are almost constant fractions of the chain lengths. Correlation functions for multi-structure landscape exhibit an increased correlation length, especially near the melting temperature. However, the main effect on evolution is rather an effective increase in sampling for finite populations where each sequence explores multiple structures.

Receptor-based assays

Recombinant DNA technology has expanded the potential of the targeted screening approach in drug discovery. The use of cloned and expressed receptors as targets for the evaluation of novel compounds can significantly simplify the structure affinity/activity process. However, the patenting of cloned receptors, as well as species differences in receptor pharmacology, especially with respect to human tissues, may limit their use in drug screening. Improved technologies to measure the functional aspects of the receptor-ligand interaction offer the potential to further enhance the targeted screening approach. A greater strategic focus is required to access chemically and biologically diverse ligand sources.

A tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase binds specifically to the group I intron catalytic core

The Neurospora CYT-18 protein, the mitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase, functions in splicing group I introns in mitochondria. Here, we show that CYT-18 binds strongly to diverse group I introns that have minimal sequence homology and recognizes highly conserved structural features of the catalytic core of these introns. Inhibition experiments indicate that the intron RNA and tRNA(Tyr) compete for the same or overlapping binding sites in the CYT-18 protein. Considered together with functional analysis, our results indicate that the CYT-18 protein promotes splicing by binding to the intron core and stabilizing it in a conformation required for catalytic activity. Furthermore, the specific binding of the synthetase suggests that the group I intron catalytic core has structural similarities to tRNAs, which could reflect either convergent evolution or an evolutionary relationship between group I introns and tRNAs.