Aberrant methylation patterns at the two-cell stage as an indicator of early developmental failure

The case for prepatterning in the mouse

In studies from several laboratories using a variety of different techniques, features of the zygote and two-cell conceptus have been found to map nonrandomly on the blastocyst with respect to both its axis of polarity and bilateral plane. This is not what would be expected if, as is widely believed, early patterning depends entirely on positional relationships and interactions among the progeny of blastomeres that are equipotential until at least the eight-cell stage. Rather, the implication of these findings is that prepatterning is a normal facet of development in mammals, just as it is in most other metazoa. Nevertheless, there is still no general consensus regarding the extent to which such prepatterning depends on intrinsic organization of the oocyte, as opposed to events that are contingent on fertilization.

DNA methylation patterns in in vitro-fertilised goat zygotes

Recent studies have shown that zygote demethylation patterns in mammals are variable among species. However, the methylation patterns of goat zygotes have not yet been reported on. In the present study, using immunofluorescence staining with an antibody against 5-methylcytosine, the methylation patterns of in vitro-derived goat zygotes were studied. The results indicate that goat zygotes do not undergo active global demethylation during pronuclei development, which is similar to the situation in ovine, but not in murine or bovine zygotes. This is believed to be the first report regarding methylation in goat zygotes.

Genomic imprinting and assisted reproduction

Imprinted genes exhibit a parent-of-origin specific pattern of expression. Such genes have been shown to be targets of molecular defects in particular genetic syndromes such as Beckwith-Wiedemann and Angelman syndromes. Recent reports have raised concern about the possibility that assisted reproduction techniques, such as in vitro fertilization or intracytoplasmic sperm injection, might cause genomic imprinting disorders. The number of reported cases of those disorders is still too small to draw firm conclusions and the safety of these widely used assisted reproduction techniques needs to be further evaluated.

DNA methylation in the preimplantation embryo: the differing stories of the mouse and sheep

In mammals, active demethylation of cytosine methylation in the sperm genome prior to forming a functional zygotic nucleus is thought to be a function of the oocyte cytoplasm important for subsequent normal development. Furthermore, a stepwise passive loss of DNA methylation in the embryonic nucleus has been observed as DNA replicates between two-cell and morula stages, with somatic cell levels of methylation being re-established by, or after the blastocyst stage when differentiated lineages are formed. The ability of oocyte cytoplasm to also reprogram the genome of a somatic cell by nuclear transfer (SCNT) has raised the possibility of directing reprogramming of a somatic nucleus ex ovo by mimicking the epigenetic events normally induced by maternal factors from the oocyte. Whilst examining DNA methylation changes in normal sheep fertilization, we were surprised to observe no demethylation of the sheep male pronucleus at any point in the first cell cycle. Furthermore, using quantitative image analysis, we observed limited demethylation of the sheep embryonic genome only between the two- and eight-cell stages and no evidence of remethylation by the blastocyst stage. We suggest that the dramatic differences in DNA methylation between the sheep and other mammalian species examined call in to question the requirement and role of DNA methylation in early mammalian embryonic development.

Stem-cell consequences of embryo epigenetic defects

CONTEXT

The genetic code in the DNA of virtually every somatic cell can produce the entire complement of encoded proteins. Acetylation of histones and methylation of histones and DNA cytosine residues are part of the complex epigenetic regulatory process determining lineage-specific gene expression by altering the local structure of chromatin. After fertilisation, sperm DNA exchanges protamines for histones recruited from oocyte cytoplasm, reconfiguring both parental genomes into an epigenetic state conducive to activating the embryonic developmental programme. The identification of epigenetic reprogramming mechanisms is a major interest, rekindled by the ability of at least some somatic cells to acquire totipotency after somatic-cell nuclear transfer.

STARTING POINT

Recently, Woo SukHwang and colleagues (Science 2004; 303: 1669-74) derived a human embryonic stem-cell line from embryo therapeutic cloning. Chad Cowan and colleagues (N Engl JMed 2004; 350: 1353-56) produced 17 new lines from embryos supernumerary to infertility treatments. However, increasing evidence from a range of mammals shows a propensity for epigenetic errors with embryo technologies. If paralleled in human embryos, the effect on tumorigenic and differentiation properties of embryonic stem cells needs to be established. WHERE NEXT? Identifying the mechanisms in the oocyte that reprogramme a somatic cell to the embryonic state might allow somatic cells to be reprogrammed ex ovo by in-vitro manipulation of the epigenome. Because the oocyte is designed to reprogramme the sperm genome, which is in a different chromatin state from a somatic cell, perhaps many of the epigenetic errors induced by somatic-cell nuclear transfer could be avoided by a more targeted approach.

Methylation Reprogramming and Chromosomal Aneuploidy in In Vivo Fertilized and Cloned Rabbit Preimplantation Embryos1

Active demethylation of the paternal genome but not of the maternal genome occurs in fertilized mouse, rat, pig, and bovine zygotes. To study whether this early demethylation wave is important for embryonic development, we have analyzed the global methylation patterns of both in vivo-fertilized and cloned rabbit embryos. Anti-5-methylcytosine immunofluorescence of in vivo-fertilized rabbit embryos revealed that the equally high methylation levels of the paternal and maternal genomes are largely maintained from the zygote up to the 16-cell stage. The lack of detectable methylation changes in rabbit preimplantation embryos suggests that genome-wide demethylation is not an obligatory requirement for epigenetic reprogramming. The methylation patterns of embryos derived from fibroblast and cumulus cell nuclear transfer were similar to those of in vivo-fertilized rabbit embryos. Fluorescence in situ hybridization with chromosome-specific BACs demonstrated significantly increased chromosomal aneuploidy rates in cumulus cell nuclear transfer rabbit embryos and embryos derived from nuclear transfer of rabbit fibroblasts into bovine oocytes compared with in vivo-fertilized rabbit embryos. The incidence of chromosomal abnormalities was correlated with subsequent developmental failure. We propose that postzygotic mitotic errors are one important explanation of why mammalian cloning often fails.

The effect of interspecific oocytes on demethylation of sperm DNA

In contrast to mice, in sheep no genome-wide demethylation of the paternal genome occurs within the first postfertilization cell cycle. This difference could be due either to an absence of a sheep demethylase activity that is present in mouse ooplasm or to an increased protection of methylated cytosine residues in sheep sperm. Here, we use interspecies intracytoplasmic sperm injection to demonstrate that sheep sperm DNA can be demethylated in mouse oocytes. Surprisingly, mouse sperm can also be demethylated to a limited extent in sheep oocytes. Our results suggest that the murine demethylation process is facilitated either by a sperm-derived factor or by male pronuclear chromatin composition.

Effect of limited DNA methylation reprogramming in the normal sheep embryo on somatic cell nuclear transfer

Active demethylation of cytosine residues in the sperm genome before forming a functional zygotic nucleus is thought to be an important function of the oocyte cytoplasm for subsequent embryonic development in the mouse. Conversely, this event does not occur in the sheep or rabbit zygote and occurs only partially in the cow. The aim of this study was to investigate the effect of limited methylation reprogramming in the normal sheep embryo on reprogramming somatic nuclei. Sheep fibroblast somatic nuclei were partially demethylated after electrofusion with recipient sheep oocytes and undergo a stepwise passive loss of DNA methylation during early development, as determined by 5-methylcytosine immunostaining on interphase embryonic nuclei. A similar decrease takes place with in vivo-derived sheep embryos up to the eight-cell stage, although nuclear transfer embryos exhibit a consistently higher level of methylation at each stage. Between the eight-cell and blastocyst stages, DNA methylation levels in nuclear transfer embryos are comparable with those derived in vivo, but the distribution of methylated DNA is abnormal in a high proportion. By correlating DNA methylation with developmental potential at individual stages, our results suggest that somatic nuclei that do not undergo rapid reorganization of their DNA before the first mitosis fail to develop within two to three cell cycles and that the observed methylation defects in early cleavage stages more likely occur as a direct consequence of failed nuclear reorganization than in failed demethylation capacity. However, because only embryos with reorganized chromatin appear to survive the 16-cell and morula stages, failure to demethylate the trophectoderm cells of the blastocyst is likely to directly impact on developmental potential by altering programmed patterns of gene expression in extra-embryonic tissues. Thus, both remodeling of DNA and epigenetic reprogramming appear critical for development of both fertilized and nuclear transfer embryos.

Incidence of apoptosis in clone embryos and improved development by the treatment of donor somatic cells with putative apoptosis inhibitors

This study was conducted to promote in vitro-development of clone embryos by the treatment of donor somatic cells with hemoglobin (Hb) and/or beta-mercaptoethanol (ME), based on the analysis of apoptosis after somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT). Prospective, randomized study was conducted and, in vitro-matured bovine oocytes and fetal fibroblasts were provided for SCNT. In the first series of experiment, embryo apoptosis after SCNT was monitored by a terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase-mediated d-UTP nick end-labeling assay. As results, apoptosis occurred more (P < 0.05) frequently after SCNT than after in vitro-fertilization (IVF) of control treatment. Subsequently, donor somatic cells treated with Hb (1 microg/ml) and/or ME (10 microM) were provided for SCNT. Either Hb or ME greatly reduced apoptosis (0.083 +/- 0.006 vs. 0.058-0.068 +/- 0.005), while combined treatment did not. ME was more promotive than Hb; significant increases were found in morula compaction (86%), cell numbers of blastocyst (131.3 +/- 1.3 cells/blastocyst), and inner cell mass (31.9 +/- 0.8 cells/blastocyst) cell, and the ratio of inner cell mass to trophectodermal cell numbers (0.24 +/- 0.01). In conclusion, the treatment of donor somatic cells with ME or Hb could reduce apoptosis after SCNT, resulting improved preimplantation development.

Nuclear transfer: progress and quandaries

Cloning mammals by nuclear transfer is a powerful technique that is quickly advancing the development of genetically defined animal models. However, the overall efficiency of nuclear transfer is still very low and several hurdles remain before the power of this technique will be fully harnessed. Among these hurdles include an incomplete understanding of biologic processes that control epigenetic reprogramming of the donor genome following nuclear transfer. Incomplete epigenetic reprogramming is considered the major cause of the developmental failure of cloned embryos and is frequently associated with the disregulation of specific genes. At present, little is known about the developmental mechanism of reconstructed embryos. Therefore, screening strategies to design nuclear transfer protocols that will mimic the epigenetic remodeling occurring in normal embryos and identifying molecular parameters that can assess the developmental potential of pre-implantation embryos are becoming increasingly important. A crucial need at present is to understand the molecular events required for efficient reprogramming of donor genomes after nuclear transfer. This knowledge will help to identify the molecular basis of developmental defects seen in cloned embryos and provide methods for circumventing such problems associated with cloning the future application of this technology.

Epigenetic asymmetry in the mammalian zygote and early embryo: relationship to lineage commitment?

Epigenetic asymmetry between parental genomes and embryonic lineages exists at the earliest stages of mammalian development. The maternal genome in the zygote is highly methylated in both its DNA and its histones and most imprinted genes have maternal germline methylation imprints. The paternal genome is rapidly remodelled with protamine removal, addition of acetylated histones, and rapid demethylation of DNA before replication. A minority of imprinted genes have paternal germline methylation imprints. Methylation and chromatin reprogramming continues during cleavage divisions, but at the blastocyst stage lineage commitment to inner cell mass (ICM) or trophectoderm (TE) fate is accompanied by a dramatic increase in DNA and histone methylation, predominantly in the ICM. This may set up major epigenetic differences between embryonic and extraembryonic tissues, including in X-chromosome inactivation and perhaps imprinting. Maintaining epigenetic asymmetry appears important for development as asymmetry is lost in cloned embryos, most of which have developmental defects, and in particular an imbalance between extraembryonic and embryonic tissue development.

Towards a single embryo transfer

The delivery of a single, healthy child is the desired outcome of human assisted reproduction techniques. To attain this goal, there is an increasing movement toward single embryo transfer. The question is, therefore, at what stage to transfer the human embryo back to the uterus? Maximal implantation rates reported to date have come from the transfer of blastocysts (70% fetal heart rate). In any given cycle of treatment the probability of conceiving a child will be further increased by the ability to cryopreserve those embryos not transferred. It is therefore proposed that the transfer of a single blastocyst is the best treatment for most patients, given the high implantation rates of fresh transfers, and that it is now possible to cryopreserve supernumerary blastocysts effectively. The next decision is how to culture the human embryo to the blastocyst stage. The use of sequential culture media, designed not only to allow for changes in nutrient requirements and metabolism as development proceeds, but also to minimize intracellular trauma, can facilitate the development of highly viable blastocysts. Sequential culture media have been evaluated against a single-step culture system. It has been shown that sequential media (G1/G2) produce more viable blastocysts than those embryos cultured in a single medium formulation (simplex optimized medium with elevated potassium and with amino acids, KSOM(AA)) throughout the preimplantation period. Furthermore, even if KSOM(AA) is used for embryo culture, it is essential that the medium be renewed after 48 h to alleviate the toxicity associated with ammonium build-up. Of great significance, embryos cultured in sequential media G1 and G2 have the same rate of development as embryos developed in vivo.

Epigenetic reprogramming in mammalian nuclear transfer

With the exception of lymphocytes, the various cell types in a higher multicellular organism have basically an identical genotype but are functionally and morphologically different. This is due to tissue-specific, temporal, and spatial gene expression patterns which are controlled by genetic and epigenetic mechanisms. Successful cloning of mammals by transfer of nuclei from differentiated tissues into enucleated oocytes demonstrates that these genetic and epigenetic programs can be largely reversed and that cellular totipotency can be restored. Although these experiments indicate an enormous plasticity of nuclei from differentiated tissues, somatic cloning is a rather inefficient and unpredictable process, and a plethora of anomalies have been described in cloned embryos, fetuses, and offspring. Accumulating evidence indicates that incomplete or inappropriate epigenetic reprogramming of donor nuclei is likely to be the primary cause of failures in nuclear transfer. In this review, we discuss the roles of various epigenetic mechanisms, including DNA methylation, chromatin remodeling, imprinting, X chromosome inactivation, telomere maintenance, and epigenetic inheritance in normal embryonic development and in the observed abnormalities in clones from different species. Nuclear transfer represents an invaluable tool to experimentally address fundamental questions related to epigenetic reprogramming. Understanding the dynamics and mechanisms underlying epigenetic control will help us solve problems inherent in nuclear transfer technology and enable many applications, including the modulation of cellular plasticity for human cell therapies.

Genomic imprinting and epigenetic reprogramming: unearthing the garden of forking paths

Genomic imprinting, an epigenetic form of gene regulation, determines the parent-dependent gene expression of marked or imprinted genes during gametogenesis and embryonic development. Imprinting involves differential allele DNA methylation in one sex cell lineage but not in the other. Egg and sperm each contributes the same DNA sequences to the zygote but epigenetic imprinting of a subset of genes determines that only one of the parent alleles are expressed relative to the parental origin. Primordial germ cells inherit biallelically imprinted genes from maternal and paternal origin and erase their imprints to start de novo monoallelic imprinting during gametogenesis. Epigenetic paternalization is an ongoing process in the mitotically-dividing spermatogonial stem cell and derived meiotically-dividing spermatocyte progeny to endow sperm with imprinted alleles. Epigenetic maternalization is restricted to the oocyte growth phase of folliculogenesis and is unrelated to DNA replication since it takes place while the oocyte remains in the diplotene stage of meiotic prophase I. Sperm and oocyte genomic methylation patterns depend on the activity of DNA methyltransferases (Dnmt). A variant of Dnmt1, designated Dnmt1o, accumulates in oocyte nuclei during the follicular growth phase. Dnmt3L, an isoform of Dnmt3a and Dnmt3b, but lacking enzymatic activity, interacts with Dnmt2a and Dnmt3b and is required for spermatogenesis. In the mouse early zygote, the male pronucleus is demethylated within 4 h of fertilization. Global demethylation takes place gradually up to the morula stage. In the blastocyst, de novo methylation is reestablished in the inner cell mass but not in the trophectoderm. Both the significance of genomic imprinting and the severe developmental defects caused by disrupted Dnmt activity, point to a need for a better understanding of the causes of low cloning efficiency by somatic nuclear transfer to enucleated ovulated oocyte.