Brain plasticity in poststroke aphasia: what is the contribution of the right hemisphere?

Late plasticity for language in a child's non-dominant hemisphere: a pre- and post-surgery fMRI study

The ability of the right hemisphere to sustain the acquisition or the recovery of language after extensive damage to the left hemisphere has been essentially related to the age at the time of injury. Better language abilities are acquired when the insult occurs in early childhood (perinatal insults) compared with later occurrence. However, while previous studies have described the neuropsychological pattern of language development in typical cases, the neural bases of such plasticity remain unexplored. Non-invasive functional MRI (fMRI) is a unique tool to assess the neural correlates of brain plasticity through repeated studies, but the technique has not been widely used in children because of methodological limitations. Plasticity of language was studied in a boy who developed intractable epilepsy related to Rasmussen's syndrome of the left hemisphere at age 5 years 6 months, after normal language acquisition. The first fMRI study at age 6 years 10 months showed left lateralization of language networks during a word fluency task. After left hemispherotomy at age 9 years, the child experienced profound aphasia and alexia, with rapid recovery of receptive language but slower and incomplete recovery of expressive language and reading. Postoperative fMRI at age 10 years 6 months showed a shift of language-related networks to the right during expressive and receptive tasks. Right activation was seen mainly in regions that could not be detected preoperatively, but mirrored those previously found in the left hemisphere (inferior frontal, temporal and parietal cortex), suggesting reorganization in a pre-existing bilateral network. In addition, neuropsychological data of this case support the hypothesis of innately more bilateral distribution of receptive than expressive language. This first serial fMRI study illustrates the great plasticity of the child's brain and the ability of the right hemisphere to take over some expressive language functions, even at a relatively late age. It also suggests a limit for removal of the dominant hemisphere beyond the age of 6 years, a classical limit for the critical period of language acquisition.

Plasticity of language networks in patients with brain tumors: a positron emission tomography activation study

We investigated plasticity of language networks exposed to slowly evolving brain damage. Single subject 0-15-water language activation positron emission tomography studies were analyzed in 61 right-handed patients with brain tumors of the left hemisphere, and 12 normal controls. In controls, activations were found in left Brodmann's Area (BA)44 and BA45, superior posterior temporal gyrus bilaterally, and right cerebellum. Patients additionally activated left BA46, BA47, anterior insula, and left cerebellum. Superior temporal activation was less frequent, and activations in areas other than posterior temporal gyrus were found bilaterally. Frontolateral activations within the nondominant hemisphere were only seen in patients (63%) with frontal or posterior temporal lesions. Laterality indices of frontolateral cortex showed reversed language dominance in 18% of patients. Laterality indices of the cerebellum were negatively correlated with language performance. Two compensatory mechanisms in patients with slowly evolving brain lesions are described: An intrahemispheric mechanism with recruitment of left frontolateral regions other than classic language areas; and an interhemispheric compensatory mechanism with frontolateral activation in the nondominant hemisphere. The latter one was only found in patients with frontal or posterior temporal lesions, thus supporting the hypothesis that right frontolateral activations are a disinhibition phenomenon.

Language representation in a patient with a dominant right hemisphere: fMRI evidence for an intrahemispheric reorganisation

Studies have suggested that congenital left hemispheric (LH) frontal arteriovenous malformations (AVMs) are associated with an early transfer of language to right hemisphere (RH) frontal regions. The question remains whether such anatomofunctional reorganisation is due to RH compensatory abilities or to a general principle of lateral shift. In this study, we used fMRI language paradigms to investigate the case of a patient presenting aphasic symptoms following an haemorrhage due to a right frontal AVM. Prior to surgery, fMRI showed that language processing was confined to the RH, suggesting that language had not shifted during childhood from this congenitally dominant RH to the LH. After surgery, the patient presented severe aphasia that recovered to presurgical level within 70 days. At this time, fMRI showed that language tasks were still not associated with activations in the LH. These results suggest that the principles of early cerebral reorganisation after congenital lesions may differ in the RH and the LH. In addition, they support the idea that efficient restoration of language is achieved if a sufficiently large neuronal network is preserved around the lesion.

The contribution of functional neuroimaging to recovery after brain damage: a review

The introduction of functional neuroimaging techniques has contributed to understanding the neural correlates of recovery of motor, sensory and cognitive functions after brain damage. In this paper, we review the literature of the past twenty years, with particular emphasis on quantitative studies of cerebral blood flow and metabolism. Studies are presented that examine recovery from hemiparesis, aphasia, spatial hemineglect and sensory disorders. The contribution of this research is critically discussed in a methodological perspective. A basic distinction is made between cerebral plasticity and recovery of functions. It is also argued that the most frequently used experimental designs do not permit directly relating changes in brain activity to functional recovery. The importance of accurate behavioural measures is underlined. Alternative experimental designs are proposed, based on correlations between behavioural performance and brain activations.

Language localization in cases of left temporal lobe arachnoid cyst: evidence against interhemispheric reorganization

We investigated whether left-hemisphere arachnoid cysts lead to reorganization of the language function using PET. A group analysis demonstrated that patients showed no more right-hemisphere activation than a matched control group. Several patients had clear language localizations in the left hemisphere during language comprehension; none of the patients showed right-hemisphere activation. We conclude that left-hemisphere tissue must suffer considerable compromise before reorganization of language into the right hemisphere becomes necessary. Language activations within the left hemisphere are clearly displaced. This is consistent with mere physical displacement in some patients rather than reorganization within the left hemisphere; in others intrahemispheric reorganization cannot be excluded.

Functional Reorganization after Training of Alertness in Two Patients with Right-Hemisphere Lesions

Funktionelle Reorganisation nach Alertness-Training bei zwei Patienten mit Läsionen der rechten Hemisphere

Zusammenfassung: Bei Patienten mit Alertness-Defiziten nach rechtshemisphärischer vaskulärer Schädigung wurde die individuelle Veränderung des funktionellen Netzwerkes für Alertness nach einem spezifischen Training in einer PET-Aktivierungsstudie untersucht. Die Patienten wurden mit dem Unterprogram Alertness aus dem computergestützten AIXTENT Aufmerksamkeitstraining behandelt. Vor und nach dem Training erfolgte jeweils eine PET- und eine neuropsychologische Untersuchung zur Erfassung von Aufmerksamkeitsstörungen und Hemineglect. In dieser Arbeit präsentieren wir zwei Patienten, von denen einer signifikante Leistungsverbesserungen nach dem Training erzielte. Bei diesem Patienten zeigte sich nach dem Training eine teilweise Restitution des rechtshemisphärischen funktionellen Netzwerks, welches sich bei Gesunden als relevant für die intrinsische Alertness-Kontrolle erwiesen hat. Bei dem zweiten Patienten, der keine Verbesserung zeigte, ergab sich nach dem Training lediglich eine deutliche linkshemisphärische Aktivierung im PET.

Magnetic resonance assessment of acute and chronic stroke

This article describes the important role of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in noninvasively assessing human focal ischemic stroke. Conventional MRI, diffusion-weighted and/or perfusion-weighted imaging have been used to facilitate both the qualitative and quantitative evaluation of heterogeneity of ischemic brain tissue. Further, by combining 2 or more magnetic resonance parameters, tissue-signature models have been developed that may be used as surrogate markers of tissue histopathology to characterize ischemic tissue as salvageable, necrotic, or tissue in transition to necrosis. Magnetic resonance tissue-signature models and results are presented. Dynamic changes in the evolution of ischemic tissue to infarction are also discussed. Recovery from acute stroke was studied with blood oxygenation level-dependent functional MRI to investigate the neural mechanisms for recovery from aphasia after stroke.

Functional MRI of the supplementary motor area: comparison of motor and sensory tasks

PURPOSE

The purpose of this work was to assess the activation of the supplementary motor area (SMA) during simple motor, complex motor, hot sensory, and touch sensory tasks.

METHOD

Functional MRI (fMRI) was performed in eight right-handed healthy volunteers. There were four tasks: simple motor, complex motor, hot sensory, and touch sensory. The number of pixels and the average percentage change of signal intensity in the activated SMA were obtained during the four tasks and then compared.

RESULTS

The SMA was consistently activated on fMRI during both motor and sensory tasks. The average number of activated pixels during the complex motor task was more than the number during the hot sensory task, but the difference was not statistically significant. The average number of activated pixels during the complex motor task was greater than during the simple motor task. The average number of activated pixels during the hot sensory task was greater than during the touch sensory task. The average percentage change of signal intensity was statistically significant between the simple motor and the complex motor task. The average percentage change of signal intensity was not statistically significant between the complex motor and the hot sensory task.

CONCLUSION

The SMA is activated in both motor and sensory tasks. The degree of activation of the SMA differs according to the type of task.

Cortical language activation in stroke patients recovering from aphasia with functional MRI

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Two mechanisms for recovery from aphasia, repair of damaged language networks and activation of compensatory areas, have been proposed. In this study, we investigated whether both mechanisms or one instead of the other take place in the brain of recovered aphasic patients.

METHODS

Using blood oxygenation level-dependent functional MRI (fMRI), we studied cortical language networks during lexical-semantic processing tasks in 7 right-handed aphasic patients at least 5 months after the onset of left-hemisphere stroke and had regained substantial language functions since then.

RESULTS

We found that in the recovered aphasic patient group, functional language activity significantly increased in the right hemisphere and nonsignificantly decreased in the left hemisphere compared with that in the normal group. Bilateral language networks resulted from partial restitution of damaged functions in the left hemisphere and activation of compensated (or recruited) areas in the right hemisphere. Failure to restore any language function in the left hemisphere led to predominantly right hemispheric networks in some individuals. However, better language recovery, at least for lexical-semantic processing, was observed in individuals who had bilateral rather than right hemisphere-predominant networks.

CONCLUSIONS

The results indicate that the restoration of left-hemisphere language networks is associated with better recovery and inversely related to activity in the compensated or recruited areas of the right hemisphere.